Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: pperrin on April 03, 2012, 11:47:47 PM
-
Having repaired my first accordion (well enough to learn to play!), and playing on the mouth organ a bit... I had an idea for making my own.
To be small, flexible, cheap, easy to maintain etc... I am thinking of using Lee Oskar harmonicas (they are designed to be 'modular') as reed blocks... I am thinking of using some commercial bellows (see what is available cheap!), I'd then fabricate the ends, and keyboard.
The mouth organs would be used with just their outer cases removed, so reed plates and comb would be inside the instrument.
I think the keyboard mechanism will be the biggest challenge, but the fixed spacing of mouth organ holes means it has to be bespoke.
I have more ideas for the detailed construction, but any thoughts/advice on the general idea?
-
It may be worth contacting Malcolm Austen of this parish who has done the very thing you are planning. His avatar shows the result
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=profile;u=154 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=profile;u=154)
-
It may be worth contacting Malcolm Austen of this parish who has done the very thing you are planning. His avatar shows the result
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=profile;u=154 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=profile;u=154)
So are you offering me a decent instrument on the cheap? Or just criticizing my efforts?
-
??? ??? ??? ??? ???
-
So are you offering me a decent instrument on the cheap? Or just criticizing my efforts?
How on earth did you come to that conclusion?
You asked for "thoughts/general advice on the idea" - Lester is suggesting that you get in touch with Malcolm because Malcolm's experience might be useful to you.
I don't see that as anything other than simply helpful, especially as I know both of them personally and Lester especially has a reputation for providing much useful information here.
-
PP--
Chill out dude. This is a friendly place. Folks are trying to help you do what you say you want to do.
What is amazing, and you will find, is that, box-wise, almost everyone has almost already done everything or at least tried.
Lee Oskar reeds are nice, also the (I think) phenolic blocks, though they are small.
Also, aren't harmonica reeds a bit too bendable for robust bellows action?
-
Also, aren't harmonica reeds a bit too bendable for robust bellows action?
Yeah, that was my first thought, little brass things ... but then again, what do I know? :D
-
As a harmonica player, I don't think that the Lee Oskar reeds (or any others) would really answer here.
Much better to get a Hohner single row (easily found on Ebay). They're relatively cheap, sound great, are great.
-
I've had this idea. I think that it is perfectly possible, but the bellows would have to be pretty tiny or the reeds would go all over the place. It would be a fun little project though.
-
Bert, you are right.
Plus, you could buy Oskar's harmonic minor reed sets and have built in coolness.