Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Mike Hirst on April 04, 2012, 12:26:35 PM

Title: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 04, 2012, 12:26:35 PM
Recently I have been going over past mel.net postings re six and eight voice D/C# combos. I've been discussing with a friend the possibilities for commissioning such an instrument (we have good connections with some of the less well known Italian makers).  I've been jotting down reed combinations mentioned in past posts. Thus far I have:

LLMMMH
LMMMHH
LLMMMM
LMMMMH

For six reed config.

and:

LLMMMMHH
LMMMMMMH

for eight reeds.

I note from previous posts that low reeds, although sometimes previously tuned apart, are more acceptable to contemporary sensibilities if tuned in unison. Similarly H reeds can be tuned apart or in unison. The big question I'm struggling with is what to do with multiple M reeds. I understand three reed musette (M- M M+), but I cant figure what do do with four and five M reed sets. Does anyone have any experience or suggestions?
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Quebecois on April 04, 2012, 03:10:53 PM
 ??? Are you going to use an auxiliary air compressor ?  ??? Or a huge bellows?
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 04, 2012, 08:19:32 PM
Hi Mike,

I'm happy to hear about your project since I love the historical Irish-American boxes with 3 - 8 sets of reeds (usually in D or D/C#).  That seems a type of box that has rarely been made in recent years.

I have seen and played a good few vintage Walters, Baldonis, etc., and I still own and play a couple. The tuning and voicing issues you mention interact * a lot * with other design factors, so I hope you will forgive a digression here.

A couple of things to consider:  

1) Do you absolutely need a full inside row of melody buttons in C# (to cover the notes not available on the outside D row) or can you manage with 3 - 7 buttons on the inside row?   The 13 key and 15 key boxes (10 + 3 as shown below, or 10 + 5) can be extremely versatile, and allow all the pallets to be in a single row on the soundboard, thus the box need only have half the number of double-sided melody reedblocks as it does voices.  A 6 voice box like this only needs 3 reedblocks, an 8 voice box needs 4 (if the pallets are in a single row).  Of course, if one or two ranks of reeds are laid flat, parallel to the soundboard, then you have different design options.

2) Do you plan to have stops (or multiple couplers) to provide many voicing options using the 6 or 8 sets of reeds, or do you plan to have just one or two choices of voices (e.g. a single lever switch, as was common in the old boxes)?

Shown in the first pic below are a 10 key Baldoni in D with 6 sets of reeds (LMMMMH) and a 13 key Baldoni with 10 keys in D plus a partial row of 3 keys in C#, that has 8 sets of reeds (LMMMMMMH).  Each has only one rear-of-keyboard coupler that selects between two voicing options.  Not every possible choice, but the sounds they do have are great!  The limited number of accidentals present on the 13 key box allow thousands of tunes outside the D scale to be played (with some creative use of octave jumps etc) but only 1 row of pallets is needed, so only 4 reedblocks for the 8 voices. The second photo shows a Saltarelle Shamrock in C#/D, 4 voices (LMMH) that has every combination of those voices available, and a Paolo in D/C#, again 4 voice (LMMH) that has only two couplers (and an unrestored Globe, LMMH with 4 stops). The Saltarelle and Paolo have as many reedblocks as they have voices, because they have more melody buttons than can be accommodated in a single row of pallets, but they make excellent use of the 4 voices they offer.  The third photo shows a Walters D 1-row with *no couplers* -- LMMM all the time and it always sounds great.

IMO many players could learn to be very happy with a box that has no or only 2 choices of voicing.  But if you want all the choices of voicing, then a 5 voice design (LMH dry as well as M+ and M-) offers lots of different sounds.  The Paolo shown below only offers a choice of LMMH or MM, and so is tuned LH dry, M +, M-. Great sound out of "only" 4 voices.  The Saltarelle with all its options is LMH dry and M+.  How wet you go with those M+ and M- reeds is up to you - I think 17 cents in each direction (around middle A) sounds good.

The old boxes with 4 or more sets of M reeds often sound good with those M reeds set at 3 or 4 different pitches. I personally prefer H reeds to be tuned dry (to the average pitch of the box), and both dry if there are two sets of piccolo.  I like the sound of two sets of bass reeds but they do tend to use a lot of air and so IMO a single set of low reeds may be a better choice for you.  But LLMM is one great traditional option for a D box - or MMHH for a G box. I've seen LLMMMM and LLMMMMHH Walters and Baldonis in D, but only rarely in boxes with more than 15 keys.

To sum up, I would think about LMMMH, LMMH, or LMMM if you want a full two rows of melody buttons -- otherwise the box may tend to become so big that it will be hard ergonomically to get the sound that I think you want.  What tunings you give the M reeds will depend on how versatile the couplers are (if any).  If you are willing to dial down the number of melody buttons to 16 or less, you can probably get a single row of pallets so half as many reedblocks as voices. In that case, you could think about LMMMMH, LMMMHH, etc, with the number and wetness of the M reeds up to your taste. Think also about minimizing the weight of the left hand side. 2 or 4 basses are traditional and were plenty for most of the old players.  That many, or maybe 6 buttons there may prove enough for you to play some good traditional accordion bass and harmony sounds, while still leaving the left end lightweight and nimble. On the other hand, I've seen some wonderful 8 bass Baldonis with very useful chords, and Joe Derrane does a great job with his very extensive bass layout!

Some of the same accordions shown below, and a good few more -- many with 6 - 8 sets of reeds -- can be seen at the following links:

http://www.tedmcgraw.com/EarlyBalWalt.html
http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Mas.Baldoni.html
http://www.nyfolklore.org/pubs/voic36-3-4/accordion.html

Paul Groff



Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 04, 2012, 08:49:39 PM
Hi again,

OK, space limited me to 2 pics above.  So here is the Gallagher Walters D box (ca. 1948) with LMMM and no switches.  By the way, the soundboard of this one is drilled for easy installation of an extra reedblock which would bring it up to 6 voices.  Most 6 voice Walters from that time would be LLMMMM.  The Gallagher box would need a new reedblock, 2 more sets of 10 reeds each, and also for the pallets to be switched to longer ones for that conversion to 6 voices.  I have also seen Walters from this period that were 6 voice with the soundboards drilled to facilitate easy expansion to 8 voice.

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 04, 2012, 08:55:00 PM
Paul,

thanks for taking the time to make such a detailed reply. The project is not much more than a pipe dream at the moment, but I' m keen to talk to people and see if it's possible to build something like the old Walters/Baldonis. I had been considering LLM-MM+H as the most logical reed set. I'm reconsidering, in the light of your comments re air flow. As to the question of stops/couplers - I hadn't given it much consideration. Your comments re restricting this to a small number of predefined combinations has set me thinking.

I know, from having one off instruments built before, that the Italian workshops like to design around pre existing components. I'm figuring that the shell of a 3 voice two row would adequately house all the reeds needed to build a 6 voice one row, maybe with only one or two accidentals. Both Dave ( my partner in the project) play single row instruments and we'd settle for a six voice 10 key box. We need to firm up our ideas on exactly what it is that we want before we approach any makers.
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 04, 2012, 09:01:44 PM
Hi again,

OK, space limited me to 2 pics above.  So here is the Gallagher Walters D box (ca. 1948) with LMMM and no switches.  By the way, the soundboard of this one is drilled for easy installation of an extra reedblock which would bring it up to 6 voices.  Most 6 voice Walters from that time would be LLMMMM.  The Gallagher box would need a new reedblock, 2 more sets of 10 reeds each, and also for the pallets to be switched to longer ones for that conversion to 6 voices.  I have also seen Walters from this period that were 6 voice with the soundboards drilled to facilitate easy expansion to 8 voice.

PG

Paul,

This is just the instrument I am imagining - 10 buttons, two bass, six voice.  Does Gallagher have any stops?
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 04, 2012, 09:08:39 PM
Hi Mike,

Please keep me posted on your progress (maybe by continuing this thread?).  That way I can learn from your work and enjoy the results vicariously!

I am sure the Italian makers could easily accommodate layouts of 10 + 2, 10 + 3, (may even 11 + 5 which would be really useful) with the pallets all in one row on the soundboard and 6 sets of reeds.  In fact, I would think a little body the size of a Castagnari Dinn 3 ought to accommodate a (10 + 2 ) X 6 voice. Since it is a 3-voice with 23-button keyboard I imagine (not having had one apart) there are 2 rows of pallets, one row of 12 and one of 11, and 3 reedblocks inside.  That soundboard ought to accommodate 12 or more long pallets in a single row.

But to really optimize the design to the layout you want, maybe you could try for the piccolo reeds flat on the soundboard and try to fit in 11 + 5 pallets in a row . . .

Have you read the melnet threads on the new 10 + 2 and 10 + 5 boxes being made in Quebec?

PG

Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 04, 2012, 09:15:13 PM

Paul,

This is just the instrument I am imagining - 10 buttons, two bass, six voice.  Does Gallagher have any stops?

Hi Mike

Sorry I was not clear.  The Gallagher Walters was made as a 4 voice, LMMM, no stops, no switches, no sliders, just two simple reedblocks on the soundboard. It sounds great.  But that aluminum soundboard is drilled with holes for 6 sets of reeds -- that is, it could easily have another reedblock fitted to it.  The extra holes are blocked off with leather inside the soundboard.  The current pallets are only long enough to cover the holes for 2 reedblocks.  So this box was designed with easy "upgrade-ability" to 6 voice by switching to longer pallets, unblocking the extra holes, and installing one  more reedblock.  And of course if I ever wanted to use the current original 2 reedblocks, but knock out the L reeds, or the M- and M+ reeds, for a gig, I could use a strip of paper under the reedblocks for the evening.

These early-post-WW2 Walters 1-row and 1.5 row boxes often were originally made and sold with an extra set of holes pre-drilled in the soundboard to allow a 4 voice box like the Gallagher to be expanded to 6 voice, or a 6 voice box to 8 voice.

Should also say that IMO the Gallagher box, though pretty lightweight as Walters go, is a good bit bigger than it really needs to be.  That extra size may help with air supply and resonance, but I personally would shrink the design before reproducing it.

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 05, 2012, 12:08:07 AM

Paul,

This is just the instrument I am imagining - 10 buttons, two bass, six voice.  Does Gallagher have any stops?

Hi Mike

Sorry I was not clear.  The Gallagher Walters was made as a 4 voice, LMMM, no stops, no switches, no sliders, just two simple reedblocks on the soundboard. It sounds great.  But that aluminum soundboard is drilled with holes for 6 sets of reeds -- that is, it could easily have another reedblock fitted to it.  The extra holes are blocked off with leather inside the soundboard.  The current pallets are only long enough to cover the holes for 2 reedblocks.  So this box was designed with easy "upgrade-ability" to 6 voice by switching to longer pallets, unblocking the extra holes, and installing one  more reedblock.  And of course if I ever wanted to use the current original 2 reedblocks, but knock out the L reeds, or the M- and M+ reeds, for a gig, I could use a strip of paper under the reedblocks for the evening.

These early-post-WW2 Walters 1-row and 1.5 row boxes often were originally made and sold with an extra set of holes pre-drilled in the soundboard to allow a 4 voice box like the Gallagher to be expanded to 6 voice, or a 6 voice box to 8 voice.

Should also say that IMO the Gallagher box, though pretty lightweight as Walters go, is a good bit bigger than it really needs to be.  That extra size may help with air supply and resonance, but I personally would shrink the design before reproducing it.

PG

You were very clear. This is very enlightening.
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 05, 2012, 12:43:29 AM
easy "upgrade-ability" to 6 voice by switching to longer pallets

Are you saying that all six and eight voice instruments are played using a single pallet for each note? this was certainly my first imagining of how it could work.

 I used to own a German accordion with four stops. The first two stops opened a MM+ pair. the back two stops opened either a third or a fifth harmony. Although the reeds were not of the  best quality, the size of the instrument is unmatched by anything I have owned since. Of particular note is the length of the treble pallets, which were particularly long, - long enough to cover six holes.

Since your last posing I have subsequently conceived a system similar to the mechanism on the bass end of my Hohner Xtreme, where a single button raises two pallets. For a six voice instrument each pallet would open three reeds. Is a single pallet the norm with six and eight reed instruments? or as a more complicated mechanism required?
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 05, 2012, 01:36:33 AM
Hi Mike,

There were a lot of different types of action tried from the 1920s to the 1960s in the Irish-American accordions.

On one of the links I cited above, there are good photos of Ma McNulty's 6 voice, 10 key Baldoni which I think is an early one, but may have been repaired or reworked since originally sold.  That box has a single long pallet for each button, covering the airholes for 3 double-sided reedblocks.  It also has a double-lever arrangement common in the pre-WW2 6 voice Baldonis and Walters, where the thick levers slide through leather washers and the thin levers keep the pallets properly oriented relative to the soundboard.*

But 4 voice Irish-American boxes (and post-WW2 6 voice boxes) seem usually to have simple pallets and single levers. The 4-voice Gallagher Walters box is built that way, and similar 6 voice Walters that come to mind.**

The pre-WW2 8-voice boxes that I've seen often have two pallets operated by each button (but some do have one long pallet spanning 4 double-sided reedblocks).  And at least one 6 voice box that was discussed here on melnet also has an interesting action with two linked pallets operated by each button:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3998.0.html

PG

* If you use the "zoom" feature to magnify the action pic for this interesting Sebastianelli accordion, recently sold on ebay, I think you can see another example of a similar action with the thick levers sliding through leather washers:

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&_trksid=p4340.l2557&hash=item20c4399a1f&item=140731062815


** edited to add 2 photos  below, of the 4-voice LMMM Gallagher Walters.  In this kind of simple action, the thick aluminum pallet levers don't slide through leather washers, and the springs are under the button levers. I've seen a few 6-voice, 15-key Walters (10 + 5) from this same early post-WW2 period, with the same general type of construction.  Those have 15 long pallets in a single row on the soundboard, each spanning 6 holes (for 3 reedblocks) and with another pair of unused, blocked holes drilled for each pallet, so that another reedblock could be added later (bringing the box to 8 voices).

Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 13, 2012, 06:38:20 PM
Hi Mike and all,

In further answer to Mikes questions about options for the pallets, here are some more action pics of 6 and 8 reed boxes.

First, a 6-voice Baldoni with a single pallet per button, the thick levers lift the pallet and slide through a leather washer, the thinner levers keep the pallets oriented, and the springs are also visible acting down on the pallets.  (Compare the Ma McNulty D Baldoni shown in the link I gave above).

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 13, 2012, 06:42:40 PM
Hi again,

Then here is a 13-key, 8 voice Baldoni.  Again there are levers that lift the pallets and slide, but this time through metal eyelets.  Again the springs act downward on the pallets.  But here there are double pallets per each button, linked with a second lever that keeps them oriented properly.  The pre-war 8 voice boxes often, but not always, have 2 pallets per button.  As I linked above in the previous melnet thread, at least one 6-voice box is known with double pallets per button, and some 8-voice boxes had single long pallets per button.

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 13, 2012, 06:56:39 PM
Hi again,

Close up of an early 10-button, 8-voice Baldoni -- each button operates a single long pallet that spans the holes for 4 reedblocks.  Here you can see how the levers work -- thick levers lift the pallets and slide through the leather washers, the thinner levers keep the pallets oriented properly.  In this case the springs are not visible; they act upward on the button levers, not downward on the pallets themselves.

Then another shot of the J. J. Dwyer 6-voice Baldoni (shown also in my previous post), showing the action from the top end of the box so the springs on that box, which act downward on the pallets, are more visible.

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 13, 2012, 07:03:58 PM
Paul,

Thanks for this. I'm just leaving for a gig. I'll post a full reply when I get back.

Best Wishes

Mike
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Owen Woods on April 13, 2012, 10:18:20 PM
Some fantastic pictures there PG!
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 18, 2012, 08:50:06 PM
Thanks ukebert,

And having gotten permission from the owner of the J. Cunningham Baldoni to post pics, I can add some better ones of that early 8 voice box with single pallet per button and springs on the button levers.  This box is historic and sounds great, though it has seen some repairs and alterations.  However, the two-pallet/button, pallet-sprung mechanism of the black 8-voice 13-key Baldoni shown above, probably made somewhat later than the Cunningham box, does seem to create an easier and faster action.  The simple action of the post-WW2 Gallagher Walters is also very light and fast (possibly aided by the much longer button levers / wide keyboard of the Gallagher box).

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 18, 2012, 09:47:32 PM
Paul,

these really are stunning photos. The close ups of pallet mechanisms answer so many questions. Every instrument just looks amazing. As a test I swapped the reed blocks around in my four voice Hohner to replicate the D/C# layout. Although the holes didn't match up I was able to get a feel for how that system would work. I'm very grateful for the time and effort you put into sharing what must be a unique insight into these important, but now largely forgotten instruments.
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 18, 2012, 10:18:40 PM
Mike,

Thank you for your interest, and for your patience as the thread went off-topic.  As I said, I believe the issues of pallet design and switching interact with the tuning question you originally posed, and some of the postwar 4-voice boxes may be relevant also.

I would appreciate hearing about your idea for a new accordion project if/when it goes forward.  I would love to see new accordions built today that take some inspiration from the Irish-American boxes of the 1920s - 1960s.  I wish I were in a position to commission some like that myself.  Some of the accordions pictured here were marvels of invention and craftsmanship, seemingly pushing the limits to make the best accordion possible for the needs of the pro players of the day.  No doubt this investment in innovation and craftsmanship was encouraged by a willingness of the players (or bandleaders, or saloon owners who may have purchased some of them) to invest substantial funds in the instruments. . . Today I guess you might sometimes have a player with a $2000 accordion playing through a $20,000 sound system, then it was the accordion itself that was expected to do both jobs and possibly priced accordingly!

The types pictured here only represent a small sample of the diversity of Irish-American boxes.  I think you mentioned that you had seen other threads here on melnet, but there is a lot of information here, so it's worth searching for more posts and photos from triskel, ray, lars, ted, hugh, hibbs, rich, ben, and others, or for the subjects "Baldoni," "Walters," "Paolo Soprani," "Superior," "Globe," etc.

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: blafleur on April 18, 2012, 11:18:24 PM
I've been more than a bit intrigued, and thanks, Paul, for posting all the pics and links.  Sure wish I was in a position to come north for some closer inspiration. 

Now, am I understanding that the 8 voice box has 8 reeds sounding for a single button?  How do you get that much air out of that size box?  Single note playing only?  I haven't finished my 5 voicer yet, but I've been told that it's hard to play with all 5 registers open because of air usage, but he was referring to double noted Cajun style. 
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Owen Woods on April 18, 2012, 11:28:16 PM
I've been more than a bit intrigued, and thanks, Paul, for posting all the pics and links.  Sure wish I was in a position to come north for some closer inspiration. 

You thinking of trying your hand at a D/C#? Go for it :P
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: blafleur on April 18, 2012, 11:30:10 PM
I actually thinking of trying a 2 row, but the ones Paul showed are one rows. (???) 
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Owen Woods on April 19, 2012, 12:35:41 AM
I actually thinking of trying a 2 row, but the ones Paul showed are one rows. (???)

Trudat. But were there not some 1.5 rows in there? D with  C# half row would be pretty awesome.

Personally I would love to get my hands on one of these boxes. And I wish that someone would start making them again.
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 19, 2012, 01:00:50 AM
I've been more than a bit intrigued, and thanks, Paul, for posting all the pics and links.  Sure wish I was in a position to come north for some closer inspiration. 

Now, am I understanding that the 8 voice box has 8 reeds sounding for a single button?  How do you get that much air out of that size box?  Single note playing only?

Hi Bryan, my source for some of the best music on the internet!

It would be great to meet you and look at accordions; I would appreciate your insights as a builder. 

Yes, the black 13-key, 4 bass Baldoni* and the J. Cunningham 10-key, 2 bass Baldoni are both true 8 voice machines, with 4 double-sided reed blocks on the melody side, and each melody button opening airways to 8 banks of reeds.

I'm not a player on the level of PJ Conlon or William Sullivan (two great players, RIP, whose music on Baldonis like these inspires me).  But as best I can, I personally use doubled melody keys very often (octaves and bits of harmony) and the basses also.  The 8 voice boxes are indeed somewhat air hungry and also a lot of the internal volume of the box when closed is taken up by those reedblocks!  So they are demanding both in terms of set-up (should not leak, should have high quality reeds and valves in good shape, etc) and also in terms of playing technique (air button control, control of bellows, playing somewhat staccato and with less than maximum pressure, and as mory mentioned recently playing from a "more open" default bellows position).  However, my own accordions are far from airtight, I tend to do the minimum with repairs and replacing parts especially when old, and I still find them a joy to play.

*That Black Baldoni 13-key is actually a D/C# and does have melody buttons in 2 rows (10 + 3) but 1 row of 13 (double) pallets on the metal soundboard. The O'Byrne DeWitt Paolo shown grille-off above is a full two-row (19 key) D/C#.  We've had some other threads here on melnet with pics of other 2 row D/C# boxes.  Stephen Chambers very usefully has described the boxes with rows of just a few buttons in terms of fractions or decimels (thus the Black Baldoni 13 key would be "1.3 row"). 


PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 19, 2012, 01:07:50 AM
I actually thinking of trying a 2 row, but the ones Paul showed are one rows. (???)

Trudat. But were there not some 1.5 rows in there? D with  C# half row would be pretty awesome.

Personally I would love to get my hands on one of these boxes. And I wish that someone would start making them again.

Hi ukebert,

Cross posted. ..  Re: your second point, the Saltarelle Tara LMMH for sale in London ought to make a decent D/C# with two very full rows!  And if you can stand a stepped keyboard, you might pick up a cheap used 3 voice (LMM) Italian organetto abruzzese with 9 + 3 melody keys, and put in D/C# reeds -- that could be a good way to try D/C#.

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: mory on April 19, 2012, 10:52:30 AM
More cross posting sorry guys. From the comments regarding the DG Tara LMMH this might all be a pointless exercise, it doesn't seem like anyone on here (generalization alert) well three people anyway, could handle the weight of an 8 voice one row if they can't handle a 4 voice 2 row AtB mory (ducks for cover)
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Lars on April 22, 2012, 12:42:54 PM
A couple of takes on the 6 voice pallets systems.

1: My 6 voice Baldoni-Bartoli in D, LMMMMH (tuned -12, 0, +12, +20 with L and H being 0 as well). Bellow frame measures 28 cm x 17.5 cm - what I would call just about the ideal size. Plenty of space for 3 reedblocks and mechanism/pallets, but small enough to play all night (when you want to be loud and obnoxious;)). The original mechanism in this box was worn out (it had the pallets mounted with central posts to make them lift 100% directly up), so a new mechanism was fitted a few years ago, as well as having the original LLMMMM setup changed to LMMMMH.
The mechanism you see was bought new in Castelfidardo (can't remember the shops name!), and it's very simple, and very effecient! This just works, no wobbling, no extra noise, just plenty of lift when you press the buttons. There's a single spring mounted under the lever, directly under the button. The buttons are 17mm, and are spaced 24 mm apart. More than most modern builders would go for, but it's actually quite nice, due to the smooth action. If the action was much harder, and more wobbly, I might find the buttons and their spacing a bit too large, luckily that's not the case.
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Lars on April 22, 2012, 12:51:31 PM
2: The BIG box - 6 voice Maugein Freres 21 button 12 bass. C#/F# (or possibly high pitch C/F) LLMMMM. This is an excellent example of why NOT to place two rows of pallets on a 6 voice box. It's just way too big to play properly, thus the reason I never did anything more than unwrap it, say "holy smokes!" and put it in the pile of 'never-to-be-completed' projects. The outside row of levers are mounted directly to the levers, and the inside row is fitted with counter-levers. Quite clever system, though the dimentions are so great that the buttons needs to be pushed in quite a bit (as it is now, anyways). The pearl buttons are 16 mm, spaced 19 mm. apart on each row. The bellow frame measures a whopping 32.5 cm x 23 cm. 6 reedblocks inside, with no couplers.
 
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 22, 2012, 04:00:04 PM
Hi all,

Lars, Thanks for adding photos of a postwar Baldoni 6 voice with even more recent action.  I knew a fellow in the 1980s that had the twin of your 1-row, and in fact since it was for sale maybe it's the same one that made its way to you. Very nice instrument!

That should be a good model for what Mike might be able to get built easily today.  In recreating a new box built to that general design, I would think *at least* 2 more pallets could be squeezed into the same row of pallets on the soundboard, for a total of 12 long pallets, with no increase in overall size of the casework of the box.  That would allow a 10 button outside row with 2 buttons on the inside row for accidentals, or an 11 button outside row with a single inside row button for accidentals. 

Here's my dream for a modern D/C# (or G/F# or C/B, or in fact any key system of "main diatonic row plus helper accidentals"):

A light, compact, great sounding and fast modern box about the size and dimensions of Lars' 6 voice 10-key box, but with very well-ventilated lightweight metal grillework (or even open pallets).  5 or 6 voices, and possibly no switches at all -- or possibly stops.  A flat, enclosed keyboard on the melody side with 16 buttons in one and a half rows (11 + 5).  Bass-side casework built to be extremely lightweight and narrow, with 6 buttons in a single vertical column, long bar/lever for the air key and a huge air-key pallet opening.  Accommodating 16 pallets in a single row on the melody soundboard, in a box the size of Lars', would necessitate some very precise design and craftsmanship, and maybe reedplates ground on the edges to be narrower as I've heard may be done by some makers today.  Here are a couple of 6-voice boxes I previously owned that come close to what I specify above, but my ideal would have one more button in the outside row on the melody side and another 2 bass buttons in the same vertical column. Both are pretty compact for what they offer in voices and helper accidentals (though both are really still "enhanced 1-row boxes), and the Walters is actually designed to accommodate an extra reedblock, with the soundboard pre-drilled with extra holes that would bring it up to an 8-voice ( if that extra reedblock were fitted; cf. the Gallagher box above).

PG

Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: mory on April 23, 2012, 10:17:12 AM
Hi Paul
What would be the layout for your DC# then  AtB mory
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 23, 2012, 12:39:31 PM
Hi mory,

Hope you don't mind if I give a more general answer here, so all readers will have the context.  I figure you are only looking for the last four paragraphs below and will not need to read the first part of this post.

The melody keyboards of some early 1-row, 10-button, Irish-American boxes had a duplicated dominant (sol) note of the scale on first button draw and second button press (as with today's 4-stop Hohners).  But most of the Irish-American 1-row boxes I've seen have the following standard layout, which is also what you would expect for the central 10 buttons of a row of buttons in a typical Irish style box such as a Paolo Soprani etc.  Notes for each button shown as  (press / draw) and viewed as if looking down on the keyboard, lower pitch notes to the left.  Since the 1-row boxes were sometimes made in C, G, or other keys as well as in D, I'll write the notes as follows to indicate the pitch relative to whatever the major scale of the box:


mi/la   sol/ti (si)   do/re   mi/fa   sol/la  do/ti (si)   mi/re   sol/fa   do/la  mi/ti (si)


Here in letter-named notes are some of the traditional layouts for D/C# boxes, with notes for each button shown as (press / draw) and viewed as if looking down on the keyboard, lower pitch notes to the left.

13 key:

                                    G#/A#   C#/C   F/D#
F#/B    A/C#    D/E    F#/G    A/B    D/C#    F#/E    A/G    D/B    F#/C#


15 key:

                           F/F#   G#/A#  C#/C   F/D#   G#/F#
F#/B    A/C#    D/E    F#/G    A/B    D/C#    F#/E     A/G    D/B    F#/C#


19 key (quite common post - WW2):

    G#/C    C#/D#  F/F#   G#/A#  C#/C   F/D#   G#/F#  C#/A#   F/C     
F#/B    A/C#    D/E    F#/G    A/B    D/C#     F#/E     A/G       D/B     F#/C#


The 13 key D/C# layout has all 12 notes of the ET chromatic scale, though some of them only in one octave, and has the middle octave C# duplicated in two bellows directions.  The 15 key layout was a nice compromise of size and features for those who wanted (or still want?) to play Irish tunes with the sound you get from 6 or more voices, since all the pallets can be in one row on the soundboard in a fairly compact box; notably it has the useful G# and F natural notes in two octaves and also a useful duplicated draw F# in two octaves.  The 19 key layout has C natural in low and high (as well as the middle) octaves.  Some interesting, early (prototype?) 19 key D/C# boxes had the pallets all in a single very long row, but usually the boxes with 19 or more melody keys were built with two rows of pallets on the soundboard, and thus rarely had 6 voices. With all these layouts, C#/D players would have little trouble finding the notes on the C# row -- but the fingerings often have to be different on the D/C# to play the same passages.

Some D/C# boxes have 17 keys, some have 21 or 23 keys.  I don't think I've ever seen one with 16 keys (11 + 5) but I think 16 pallets in one row on the soundboard should be practical in a well-proportioned, compact box, and I personally like the idea of adding an extra button (with the low notes D/G) to the 15 key layout above, to get the low G draw note for fiddle tunes and also the low D mostly used to grab an octave.

I also am interested in transposed versions of the D/C# box concept, with the rows in G/F#, C/B, etc.  Particularly for a box in the keys of G/F# I think 11 buttons rather than 10 in the main row would expand options for playing tunes in the common keys.  If these 16 key boxes could be made, it's possible that players of other kinds of music, using other key systems, who want a multi-voice sound could also find use for them, with customized reed layouts of various types.

On the bass side, six buttons in a vertical column wouldn't add to the size and weight of the casework (see how narrow and cut-away some early Baldonis, like the Cunningham box, were made!) and the reeds for 6 bass buttons needn't be too heavy.  The traditional boxes, usually with 2 or 4 bass buttons, tended to have a lot of reeds for the basses, but I would vote for the extra pair of bass buttons with fewer reeds for each of the triads.

Obviously this is just my own view, since I'm answering your question here, based on my personal interest in the tradition and sound of the older D/C# boxes with 6 or more voices and my personal interest in exploring G/F# etc.  More interesting to most of us might be to consider what Joe Derrane, or some of the brilliant Quebecois players, recommend for a modern D/C# layout!

Paul Groff







Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on April 24, 2012, 10:10:50 AM
. . . re six and eight voice D/C# combos. . .  I've been jotting down reed combinations mentioned in past posts. Thus far I have:

LLMMMH
LMMMHH
LLMMMM
LMMMMH

For six reed config.


Hi again Mike,

We can add to your list LMMMMM, and also LLMMHH which was recently found by a friend of mine in a 6 voice Baldoni.

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Owen Woods on April 24, 2012, 11:34:09 AM
Hi again Mike,

We can add to your list LLMMHH, recently found by a friend of mine in a 6 voice Baldoni.

PG

Wow!
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 24, 2012, 10:09:16 PM
Paul,

the information that is being shared through this thread is invaluable. The biggest hold up at the moment is finding the finance for the project.

I've been looking at off the shelf options from Giustozzi. I've had them build me things before and I like the way they work.

This model reminds my of some of the old Walters/Baldoni instruments:

(http://www.giustozzi.it/ws/image/cache/data/diatonici/890a-500x500.jpg)

http://www.giustozzi.it/ws/index.php?route=product/product&path=24_50&product_id=155 (http://www.giustozzi.it/ws/index.php?route=product/product&path=24_50&product_id=155)

It would make a good four voice D/C#. I'm not sure what the standard config would be, but I see no reason why it should not be set up  LMMM.

I recently came across the image attached below. In the light of our discussion re six reed pallet mechanisms the dual pallet mechanism in the pictured six stop single row is of interest.

ATB

Mike





Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on June 08, 2012, 03:31:09 PM
Hi Mike and all,

A slightly off-topic update to the parts of this thread that covered some interesting types of action found in the early Baldoni and Walters accordions.  Here's a spectacular Ranco piano accordion now listed on ebay, stamped 1927 on the reedblocks and evidently shown in an exposition in 1928, that is one example of top quality technology and craftsmanship (not to mention decoration) for that time.  The superb photographs illustrate the action very well, with 3 of the pallets being lifted by aluminum levers that slide through a leather washer (and having a second lever each to keep the pallet properly oriented to the soundboard).  Many details of the construction of this piano box (though its only a 4-voice) are very interesting to compare with the Baldonis and Walters from late 1920s through the 1930s. 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/150830685626

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on June 08, 2012, 03:38:11 PM
And since Hugh has published the photos, it would be good to link to this thread the specifications of the wonderful Baldoni-Bartoli "Radio-Tone" box.  The Radio-Tone is a 6-voice, 1-row box in D voiced LLMMHH, and has an action with a single pallet per button,  very similar to the 6 voice JJ Dwyer Baldoni-Bartoli illustrated above -- but also like the 13 key black B-B shown above in having metal eyelets instead of leather washers for the levers to slide through.  The celluloid grilles of all three boxes are fretted in a similar pattern, though the Radio-Tone has a different pattern of white paint and rhinestones applied to its grille.  The photos are here:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9598.0.html

Paul Groff
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: RPr on June 13, 2012, 05:40:46 PM
 I think we should all keep in mind that it has only been quite recently, since the advent inexpensive tuning meters, that we have had the luxury of easily tuning everyone to a standard pitch. Prior to that, a pitch pipe, tuning fork or reed instrument usually served well enough for most groups.

Though some people are quite sensitive to changes in standard pitch; the changes to standard pitch seem to be driven by instrument dynamics; rather than concerns about the voice.

For some, when they find the piece does not meet their vocal range, they simply change keys. 
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on December 31, 2012, 03:41:05 PM
Hi Mike and all,

Just to cross-reference, I thought it might be helpful to add to this thread some links to a couple of new threads where there are pics of interesting action designs posted.

Above in this thread there are already pics of a 13-key Baldoni-Bartoli that has 8 voices and two pallets per button.  Also there is a link to the thread discussing an unlabeled 6-voice box with a different kind of action that also has two pallets per button:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3998

The Likely Baldoni-Bartoli, also 6-voice, has an action similar to that unlabeled box.  Note there is a separate spring for each pallet (two springs per button):

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11144.0.html

And the Corbett Walters, an 8-voice box, also has an action with two pallets per button, but different from the above boxes:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,11281.0.html

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on December 07, 2013, 11:51:35 PM
Here's another example of six voices and 15 keys crammed into possibly the smallest case practical, without miniaturizing the reedplates.  An unlabeled box very similar to some 1940s Baldoni-Bartolis, presented here:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,13731

See photos below of the pallets and button levers.  The voicing is MMLHMM with a coupler (now working!) to take out LH, and the bellows dimensions are 6 1/2" X 11 5/8"

PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on October 07, 2017, 01:54:43 PM
Here are a couple more 8 voice boxes to compare with other examples in this topic:

"Jack" Baldoni, LMMMMMMH

Big white 15-key Walters, LLMMMMMM

More info on the big white 15-key Walters posted in the Walters history thread:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,13549.msg167376.html#msg167376


PG
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: pgroff on October 19, 2017, 02:32:05 PM

. . .

I recently came across the image attached below. In the light of our discussion re six reed pallet mechanisms the dual pallet mechanism in the pictured six stop single row is of interest.

ATB

Mike

Hi Mike,

Following up on the old photo your posted above, of one of those "giant multi-voice 1 row" boxes.  For a time, Theo had (and restored) a really cool Herfeld  6-voice 1-row box in D, that tempted many of us. Beautifully shown here:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,15795.msg194173.html#msg194173


For additional comparison, here are some large 1-row boxes made in Vienna.

First photo: on the left, an unrestored Wilhelm Lubich 4-stop box in G, voiced MHHH (relative to the typical "low" octaves of G rows, for example in a typical G/C accordion - it would be LMMM relative to the higher octaves of G used for a typical D/G box). Pitch is ca A = 435, reeds are  zinc-plate Dix. This accordion was much played over the years, and repaired by Karpek in Milwaukee WI. Nice brass-knobbed stops, similar to those on the other box in that photo. All the pallets on this accordion are above the keyboard.

First photo: on the right, an unrestored Franz Hochholzer Jun. 6-stop box in C#, with the main melody voiced in LMMH  but also with 2 extra sets of melody voices tuned to harmonize (mostly major and minor sixths above the main melody voices).*  Pitch is ca A = 443, reeds are zinc-plate with crown stamp. This accordion has extra pallets behind the keyboard for 2 of the voices.

Two additional photos: two views of an unrestored Lubich 8-voice box, currently en route to me. Described as having reeds stamped with a "star" (possibly a sun representing Sonntag reeds?). More info when it arrives!

PG

* compare earlier discussions of "quintro" tuning (maybe not quite the same as this Hochholzer?):
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,14395
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Theo on October 20, 2017, 08:33:18 PM
Here is a six-voice one row on ebay.

https://www.ebay.de/itm/Alte-Bandonika-/332413559432
Title: Re: six and eight reed combos
Post by: Winston Smith on October 20, 2017, 10:24:35 PM
What a surprise! That Bandonika has the same (or very similar) embellishments on the treble end as my black one. I had thought that they were just stuck on by the previous owner, but perhaps not. Other than the colour, it looks the same.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal