Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on April 08, 2012, 10:15:38 AM
-
Dear All,
I keep going back to a version of the History Man in Alex's wonderful book 'Diatonic Liasons'.
In the A music, it's using block chords and basses together, keeping holding down a bass G, moving from chord G to chord C, chord D and so on. To my ear it gives a wonderful effect as the melody moves along creating I think what others would call 'tension' as the melody fits some chords and is more strident with other combinations.
I find if I try and play in the way described, the bass/chords from the left hand overwhelm the melody as it meanders along.
I did wonder if it sounded better to a listener as opposed to the player's version so recorded myself on the webcam, but no, the melody gets overwhemed.
I can play it in a more usual 'bass chord umpah' style, but it then looses this movement of tension and release.
Any ideas of how to play over a left hand bass/chord to make the right hand stand out more?
cheers
Q
-
ohhh , just realised, that was my 1,000th post!
Blimey do I really talk that much?
( ok.... don't answer that ::) )
Q
-
The History Man as Alex has notated it in D.L. is very precisely done, especially in terms of LH chords/basses and bellows directions. However, the key to playing it on a D/G box is to play it one octave higher than written (it goes far too low otherwise). It was conceived as a tune for a LMM 3-voice box (a Mory, I think) so make sure the low octave voice is engaged. This will ensure a certain amount of power to the melody and it won't get overwhelmed by the LH.
Also, don't try to play it too slowly; keep it moving along. This will help with air control too, but before you start, make sure your bellows are fully extended, as the opening bars are all on the push. On an instrument with small-volume bellows, such as the Tommy, this is going to be difficult; you just don't have the air capacity. You need something a bit larger... ;) >:E
-
Thanks Steve.
I've already transposed the B music up an octave and use the low reeds. It's the A music that I seem to be struggling on. I keep having a go at the tune, putting it on a back burner then having another go.
Yes I need to think of air control. I'm sufficiently accustomed to the tune that perhaps I can up the pace a little to help, as you suggest.
' something a bit larger....? ' had you something in mind sir? ;D
I happen to be trying something a touch larger and enjoying the experience.
You never know what might happen in the future ;)
Ahhhh .... the sun's come out. Perhaps another go in the garden is in order!
cheers
Q
-
I've already transposed the B music up an octave and use the low reeds. It's the A music that I seem to be struggling on.
Play the A-music up an octave too...
-
( returns from the garden as the sun's gone in....)
Oh.... ok, will try that as well.
I have been trying with gurt big bellows full and a touch quicker, and it was starting to make a bit more sense, but i had to be quite careful. Not my normally approach!.
I'll sit down later with a pencil and transpose up.
thanks for that.
Q
-
I've been toasting my toes in front of a woodburner, quietly transposing the tune up an octave.
Toasty feet + nice little task = bliss!
Anyway, I've completed that, and just before playing, I remember i've recently downloaded Andy and Chris playing it from a while ago, but haven't had time to really take a look at it properly.
I've played the download and yes, Steve, absolutely spot on - Andy does play it an octave above the DL version.
I've given it a quick go and it does seem a bit easier up the knee end.
I shall give it a proper go....tomorrow.
Night all!
Q