Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: diatosoldo on April 13, 2012, 07:25:00 PM
-
Has anybody tried Dino Baffetti's melodeons ?
I'm particularly interested in number 82 on their catalogue (2 rows, 3 voices, 8 basses, 3.6 kg).
I'm looking for a powerful melodeon, since I sometimes play with 2 fiddles and a guitar, or with other people, and I want a grave register, more sound, and not a heavy melodeon ..
Thks to anybody who could give me some piece of advice or experience ...
-
:|||:
This post is now at it's right place, thks Theo !
-
Here's a link to the Dino Baffetti page referred to:
DB traditional diatonic accordions (http://www.baffetti-accordions.com/diatonic1.htm).
And here is a photo of the particular instrument diatosoldo is considering:
(http://www.baffetti-accordions.com/new_images/bg_art_82.jpg)
It looks like a pretty version of the DB Black Pearl III which are nice instruments and good value for money for a three voice box.
I've tried a few and found them light and responsive, but perhaps lacking in power when played hard, especially when compared with The Music Room's Dino Baffetti Oakwood Binci Special III Here (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_485/products_id/4626).
-
Steeve : thks for your advice and for the link on Dino Baffetti's wooden melodeon. I'm not sure I need such a "complete" melodeon, since I already have a good one (my Benny). And the price is a bit too high ..
What I would like is a melodeon which could be heard when my husband electrified guitar and my 2 nephews's fiddles are operating :'(
They always tell me "we cannot hear you" ... And I answer "play less loud" .. But it's no use !
So I think it's a matter of register : fiddles are sharp, my melodeon too, so a low register is needed for me, I suppose. Last week I had a melodeon friend playing with us, he has a low register on his melodeon, and everybody said "ah at least, we can hear the melodeon !" :(
Nemethmik : I'm not sure it's possible to change the reeds of my Benny ? It has only 2 voices, and I don't know any people round the corner who could do that for me ..
-
Just a thought but as they`re taking amps for the guitars, why not just Mic up the Benny as well, either with a couple of clip-on capsules or simply a Mic on a stand ?
-
I don't think the Benny is light.
I agree, it's light for a 3 row with stops.
But when you have a pokerwork and a lilly around the house, the Benny feels like a monster.
-
I'm not sure it's possible to change the reeds of my Benny ? It has only 2 voices, and I don't know any people round the corner who could do that for me ..
What I ment is complete new set of 3 treble reedblocks with LM reeds. Castagnari will do them for you about half the price as a Benny. While Castagrai is making your reedblocks you can use your Benny. Eventually you will have two sets of reedblocks 3 with MM reeds another 3 with LM reeds. Installing a new set of reedblocks is about 10 minutes for a wife.
I'm not sure I understand everything correctly : are you talking of right hand or left hand ?
I don't understand either what is MM reeds and LM reeds ... could you explain ?
-
I don't think the Benny is light.
I agree, it's light for a 3 row with stops.
But when you have a pokerwork and a lilly around the house, the Benny feels like a monster.
ah .. choosing a melodeon is really personal, and the ideal melodeon doesn't exist, all that is a matter of opinion and personal feeling, don't you think so ?
As for me, I used to play a pokerwork when I began with melodeon, I liked it much, but as soon as I had bought another one, I felt like having taken off my gloves ... it was magic !
Same with the Benny, I like it much, can play anything I want with it, but only regret it has not a grave register (by the way, is it the correct word and do you understand what I mean with "grave register" ? my english is not technically good).
-
Just a thought but as they`re taking amps for the guitars, why not just Mic up the Benny as well, either with a couple of clip-on capsules or simply a Mic on a stand ?
yes, we are considering that too ...
-
Same with the Benny, I like it much, can play anything I want with it, but only regret it has not a grave register (by the way, is it the correct word and do you understand what I mean with "grave register" ? my english is not technically good).
Your English is fine! Grave Register is perfectly understandable but not common. We generally label the registers of a box as L, M or H, the grave being L. So people might say "low reed", "low voice", "L reed" or just "third voice" to represent a LMM setup (as LMM is the most common three voice setup nowadays). LM is usually referred to as Bandoneon.
-
L = low.
M = mid.
H = high.
-
thks Rees and Ukebert for those pieces of information ;)
Now, (since I am not really ready to modify my Benny with new L reeds :-\, poor Benny), I have 2 directions to go into or to pursue :
Either amplifying my Benny, or buying a second melodeon with LM reeds ..
-
You might find it informative to have a look through this thread Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments? (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6769.msg84092.html#msg84092). The answer turns out to be "it depends", so it may be worth seeing where the other instruments you are playing with fit in the debate.
I have a Dino Baffetti Carnival II MM which I think can be played plenty loud, but am aware the DB/Oakwood Binci models are very loud and there is an LMM version as well.
-
I think many of the posters have already identified the problem (yourself included). When playing in a band, with mostly fairly high pitched melody instruments a two-voice (MM) box just blends in. A low register, either LM or LMM, does make the box stand out more in its own right. As an example of this, if I play the Bismarks CDs and go into another room, I lose the distinction between fiddle and box (Pastourelle II) and can believe I am listening to a banjo! The tracks where Ed is playing the 4-stop Hohner remain defined as two separate instruments.
So, although the Binci model may be louder per se, any three voice with low register is likely to be more distinctly heard among the other instruments.
Rob.
-
I think many of the posters have already identified the problem (yourself included). When playing in a band, with mostly fairly high pitched melody instruments a two-voice (MM) box just blends in. A low register, either LM or LMM, does make the box stand out more in its own right. As an example of this, if I play the Bismarks CDs and go into another room, I lose the distinction between fiddle and box (Pastourelle II) and can believe I am listening to a banjo! The tracks where Ed is playing the 4-stop Hohner remain defined as two separate instruments.
So, although the Binci model may be louder per se, any three voice with low register is likely to be more distinctly heard among the other instruments.
Rob.
Right, all that is really interesting, and things get clearer little by little ...
There is something else I'm wandering :
1/ With 3 reeds, I can have LMM of course, but what about LLM ???
2/ And what about the tuning (It seems that wet tuning would be louder, but I don't particularly appreciate ..)
-
I have never seen a LLM configuration, although I have seen a LL!
The difference you can expect with having the low voice will be the same whatever the tuning. My own 3-voice is dry tuned, but the low voice gives it a good rich tone. Of course, with the L voice switched out, the MM configuration doesn't benefit from any tremolo to make it heard but is still quite powerful.
Rob.
-
You might find it informative to have a look through this thread Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments? (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6769.msg84092.html#msg84092). The answer turns out to be "it depends", so it may be worth seeing where the other instruments you are playing with fit in the debate.
I have a Dino Baffetti Carnival II MM which I think can be played plenty loud, but am aware the DB/Oakwood Binci models are very loud and there is an LMM version as well.
I've read this post : plenty of information, though not easy to make up one's mind ... ? I'm just wandering ... thank u ...
-
I have never seen a LLM configuration, although I have seen a LL!
The difference you can expect with having the low voice will be the same whatever the tuning. My own 3-voice is dry tuned, but the low voice gives it a good rich tone. Of course, with the L voice switched out, the MM configuration doesn't benefit from any tremolo to make it heard but is still quite powerful.
Rob.
he he .. so I won't have to choose a wet tuning ... (must admit I'd rather not) ..
-
Right, all that is really interesting, and things get clearer little by little ...
There is something else I'm wandering :
1/ With 3 reeds, I can have LMM of course, but what about LLM ???
2/ And what about the tuning (It seems that wet tuning would be louder, but I don't particularly appreciate ..)
Theo sold a van de Aa LLM C#D a little while back. He posted a soundclip, sounded fantastic!
-
Right, all that is really interesting, and things get clearer little by little ...
There is something else I'm wandering :
1/ With 3 reeds, I can have LMM of course, but what about LLM ???
2/ And what about the tuning (It seems that wet tuning would be louder, but I don't particularly appreciate ..)
Theo sold a van de Aa LLM C#D a little while back. He posted a soundclip, sounded fantastic!
do you remember where was posted this recording ?
-
There's a secondhand Maugein Tenor G/C for sale here http://diatonie.de/shop/sonderposten.html (http://diatonie.de/shop/sonderposten.html) that might meet your requirements.
I have nothing to do with the shop but on their homepage it says that they speak french so if interested you could phone or mail them.
-
Right, all that is really interesting, and things get clearer little by little ...
There is something else I'm wandering :
1/ With 3 reeds, I can have LMM of course, but what about LLM ???
2/ And what about the tuning (It seems that wet tuning would be louder, but I don't particularly appreciate ..)
Theo sold a van de Aa LLM C#D a little while back. He posted a soundclip, sounded fantastic!
do you remember where was posted this recording ?
There you go (:)
http://soundcloud.com/theboxplace/van-der-aa-llm
-
thanks Ukebert for this link .. I like the sound, but maybe it lacks a bit of something for my taste ... I'm not sure for the moment, I'll think about that !
-
The Baffetti Binci is rather loud in the company of 1 or 2 fiddles, and the particular timbre of its tone competes (clashes?) with that of a violin too, which sound quality of course makes it very good when playing for the morris. I arrive at that opinion from experience of playing duets with my wife, which is why I will be needing another D/G box soon. . .
-
There's a secondhand Maugein Tenor G/C for sale here http://diatonie.de/shop/sonderposten.html (http://diatonie.de/shop/sonderposten.html) that might meet your requirements.
I have nothing to do with the shop but on their homepage it says that they speak french so if interested you could phone or mail them.
Thks for that link, I have been on this site. I know Maugein melodeons and really like their sound, they are really top melodeons for waltz or solos, but maybe not really responsive for fast playing ? and 4.4 kg is a bit heavy for not an athleltic player ???
-
hello everybody :-)
At the end I've bought this one :
http://youtu.be/u62e4cwaDIs
The man playing in this video is Thierry Beuze, well-known melodeon seller in Quimper (Brittany) : he sells mostly Saltarelle melodeons, but has some Baffetis too. He sold me my 85 LN baffeti !
Baffetis are not really common in France.