Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Dazbo on September 29, 2008, 04:14:08 PM
-
Thought I'd run a poll for which makes we own. Should be interesting.
Sorry if I've missed off your favourite box maker or miss-spelt the name. You can vote for any or all makes but please just vote for the ones you own on 1st October 2008.
-
For completeness:
Castagnari Tommy in D/G
Castagnari Mignon in G
Salterelle l'elfique in D/G
Streb E.2 Melodeon in any damn key you like and quite a few you may not
Hohner Erika (in the post so probably counts) in D/G
Hohner Liliput in D/G
Hohner 1 row 4 Stop in D
Hohner 1 row 4 stop in G
Hohner Club in C/F
Chinese 6 button kids melodeon in C
-
I believe "Verdi" should actually be "Verde". It's a name, but not the composer's.
http://www.verdepro.com/gverde/english/ (http://www.verdepro.com/gverde/english/)
-
Verdi is also a model of Hohner piano accordion
-
But have also owned in the past various Castagnaris, Saltarelles a couple of Weltmeisters and Paolo Soprani's!
-
Verdi is also a model of Hohner piano accordion
But who (around here) is going to own-up to one of those? ;)
-
Darren, you might have included Gaillard in the list. Not that I have one.
Yet...
Also, that blue yoke you have is a Juice-totsi, not a Gweez-totsi. :)
-
I have a Luukinen, but you have no category for that!
-
I've three Hohners but only one vote.
PS: But not one of the three is a piano accordion.
-
I've got a BCC# Casali if that is considered to be a melodeon?
-
The 'Other' in my vote being a Galotta C/F, apparently made in Klingenthal in the GDR.
Goes with the Lily D/G and the Streb that should be arriving in the post today :)
-
It is so good to have Lester posting to make the rest of us feel less guilty. I only got 1 vote but it covers an embarrassingly large number of Hohners.
-
My Hohner is currently a pile of parts in the garage, but hopes to join the land of music eventually. :)
-
Not forgetting Eric Martin
-
__. Why only one Lousiana one-row maker? There are dozens who do boxes ranging from 2-3 per lifetime to 2-3 per month.
-
Why only one Lousiana one-row maker.
Yeah, I had to put John Doucet down as "Other", even if he does make parts for "the other guy"(!), likewise my two Baldonis!!! (They get grumpy about things like that... ::))
-
In face of popular demand :-[ I have added some more options:
Baldoni
Casali
Gaillard
Galotta
Luukinen
Eric Martin
These have been added at the bottom of the list.
-
In face of popular demand :-[ I have added some more options:
Baldoni
Casali
Gaillard
Galotta
Luukinen
Eric Martin
These have been added at the bottom of the list.
How's about "Other Cajun"? Like Bruce said, there are lots of 'em!
-
Just to avoid a re-run of the War of 1812 I've added Other Cajun and Other Quebecquois (please spell check ;D)
I now think 30 options is enough!!
Can anyone vote again? I thought I'd set it up so you could vote more than once (that is more than one visit) but I can't add one of my boxes that I "forgot" about. perhaps this feature isn't available on this forum as I think it was on the old one ???
-
Just to avoid a re-run of the War of 1812 I've added Other Cajun and Other Quebecquois (please spell check ;D)
I now think 30 options is enough!!
Can anyone vote again? I thought I'd set it up so you could vote more than once (that is more than one visit) but I can't add one of my boxes that I "forgot" about. perhaps this feature isn't available on this forum as I think it was on the old one ???
I've tweaked the poll so you should be able to do this - you have to remove your vote before voting again however.
Cheers,
Clive
-
I've tweaked the poll so you should be able to do this - you have to remove your vote before voting again however.
Cheers,
Clive
Thanks Clive.
-
Thanks for the tweak Clive.
So with 83 respondants so far it appears that:
74.4% own one or more Hohners
33.73% own one or more Castagnaris
22.89% own one or more Saltarelles
16.87% own one or more Dino Baffettis
and
15.66% own one or more Paolo Sopranis
-
With "Other" being the 3rd highest category, perhaps you should now ask people who listed an "other" to say what it is. There may be makes in there polling more than the 0-1 of some other makes listed.
I'll go first - my "other" is a Notturni 2-row BC.
-
Curious to know how you results differ from the figures shown in the poll? Like, 74.4% instead of 29.9% Hohner, etc.
-
87 voters, 64 Hohners - "you do the math" as the Americans would say.
-
My 'other' is a Primo. This I believe was imported by Martyn Banks and badged as Primo, one day I'll have to give him a call to have this confirmed. It has been suggested that these were actually made by Serenellini but I don't know this as a fact, again I need to ask Martyn.
(http://www.billybragg.co.uk/forums/uploads/post-37-1207782892_thumb.jpg)
-
87 voters, 64 Hohners - "you do the math" as the Americans would say.
yeah, I can see that, but the number of voters v. number of boxes they own is not shown!
Don't mean to split hairs but we may have 64 Hohner boxes amongst 87 voters but if each Hohner voter owns 2 boxes like myself, the proportion drops by half, we would have about 32 Hohner owners (pun intended) out of 87, which is about 37%...
In any case we can see that Hohner is still a popular choice.
-
My 'other' is a Primo. This I believe was imported by Martyn Banks and badged as Primo, one day I'll have to give him a call to have this confirmed. It has been suggested that these were actually made by Serenellini but I don't know this as a fact, again I need to ask Martyn.
(http://www.billybragg.co.uk/forums/uploads/post-37-1207782892_thumb.jpg)
Interesting. Never heard of them before this post, but then one appears on eBay http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Primo-B-C-Button-Accordion_W0QQitemZ200261481758QQcmdZViewItem?hash=item200261481758&_trkparms=39%3A1%7C66%3A2%7C65%3A10%7C240%3A1318&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Primo-B-C-Button-Accordion_W0QQitemZ200261481758QQcmdZViewItem?hash=item200261481758&_trkparms=39%3A1%7C66%3A2%7C65%3A10%7C240%3A1318&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14)
-
I own five Hohners,one Klingenthal,and one ancient unbranded 2 row.I only voted once though.
Chris
-
Interesting. Never heard of them before this post, but then one appears on eBay
I played one of those quite recently, not the same quality at all I'm afraid and certainly not at all nice to play.
The Primo model I have hasn't been available for several years and cost over £1200 when new I believe, I think this is just a re-use of the name for a budget line.
Pete.
-
Would the other Beltuna owner please post or send me a P-Message? Thanks, BH NC USA
-
Interesting. Never heard of them before this post, but then one appears on eBay (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Primo-B-C-Button-Accordion_W0QQitemZ200261481758QQcmdZViewItem?hash=item200261481758&_trkparms=39%3A1%7C66%3A2%7C65%3A10%7C240%3A1318&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14)
Primo is hardly a very original name. Tallship's looks as though it might very well have been made by Serenellini, the £250 job on ebay does not!
Good point, François. I bet there are a few multi-Hohner-owners and from what I can tell from this forum it's very difficult to have just one Castagnari... ;D
-
I only own one box at the moment. A 3-row Hohner Corona in ADG. Because of this, i have now become a member of the (fictional) "Hohner Corona Owner's Club".
I have tried out many different boxes and so far I've found Hohners to be the best for playing English tunes.
My dad on the other hand owns:
2 Hohner Pokerworks in D/G
1 Hohner Pokerwork in C/F
1 Hohner Pokerwork 4-stop 1-row in C
1 Hohner Pokerwork 4-stop 1-row in D
1 (out of tune) Hohner Erica in D/G.
Hmm (thinks) this might be the reason for my love of Hohner.
MQ
-
I seem to pick one up now and then, nothing to pricey.
the one I like the most is a
red paolo soprani b/c with nine registers.
next are.
Hohner pokerwork single row c
Hohner pokerwork dbl row g/c
Hohner pokerwork dble row A/D
Hohner club 11 B [just aquired]
Hohner corona GCF.
Hohner single row G w 4 stops.
Hohner corso dbl row A/D
I would really like to get a van der Aa B/c w/ stradella base. which is in a shop I visit, but alas. to much for me to invest at the moment.
I recently saw the group beoga and talked to damien mckee, and he very much liked the Van der Aa. What a responsive box. I think the reeds are mounted on padding rather than waxed, which might contribute to the great tone. Russian cbas are also built without wax for the most part.
Clif.
-
Interesting. Never heard of them before this post, but then one appears on eBay
I played one of those quite recently, not the same quality at all I'm afraid and certainly not at all nice to play.
The Primo model I have hasn't been available for several years and cost over £1200 when new I believe, I think this is just a re-use of the name for a budget line.
Pete.
The eBay one certainly doesn't look a patch on yours. Wondering whether it is from the Delicia factory? I believe there are some fairly new models.
-
Primo is hardly a very original name.
Really? It's a model name I've never seen used on a melodeon before, which is perhaps surprising.
-
Interesting. Never heard of them before this post, but then one appears on eBay
I played one of those quite recently, not the same quality at all I'm afraid and certainly not at all nice to play.
The Primo model I have hasn't been available for several years and cost over £1200 when new I believe, I think this is just a re-use of the name for a budget line.
Pete.
The eBay one certainly doesn't look a patch on yours. Wondering whether it is from the Delicia factory? I believe there are some fairly new models.
Primo is a brand name used by The Music Room, originally on instruments built by Serenellini in Italy, but now on Chinese models - like the Primo Scholar B/C Melodeon (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249/products_id/4221?mrSid=6b6286cc9f837c60249cd92b5a8908e6) on eBay:
Fantastic starter melodeon - Made in China to a quality approaching Hohner instruments. 23 Button right hand with 8 basses AND a stop to remove the thirds in the left hand chords, a feature unheard of at this price.
For that matter, the eBay seller is based in Leeds, and everything else they're selling appears to be from The Music Room...
-
One Hohner
One Cagnonis-in-a-Hohner
and one Galanti (D/D# - a very satisfactory purchase from Rees.)
Any other Galantis out there? (Though quite a lot would be keyboard or guitar shaped melodeons!)
Tom
-
<snip>
I have tried out many different boxes and so far I've found Hohners to be the best for playing English tunes.
<snip>
Hmm (thinks) this might be the reason for my love of Hohner.
MQ
My dad too has played Hohner boxes since 1949... so my earliest memories of the accordion sound are those of his 2-rows he still owns and plays today!
When I got to play the melodeon I wanted a Hohner too... for the sound!
-
Primo is a brand name used by The Music Room, originally on instruments built by Serenellini in Italy, but now on Chinese models - like the Primo Scholar B/C Melodeon (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249/products_id/4221?mrSid=6b6286cc9f837c60249cd92b5a8908e6) on eBay:
I think that The Music Room have recently revived the brand name Primo. At the time mine was made they were marketed by 'Sounds Interesting', a mail order predecessor to the retail outlets. At the time I was doing a musical instrument building leisure course with Martyn Banks as tutor. Happy days; my hammered dulcimer still has pride of place in the living room - much admired but rarely played.
My acquisition of a Primo melodeon was entirely coincidental btw, it was some time after it was bought for me as a birthday present that I remembered Martyn proudly (and justifiably) showing off the pattern routed Primo badge many years ago. I was, as I recall, far more impressed at the time by the skill involved in creating the logo than by the box of reeds he was sticking it on. I was after all an English concertina player and far too aloof to recognise a rectangular box stuffed with cheap and vulgar harmonica reeds as a 'proper' instrument. ::)
We live and learn. ;D
-
What a responsive box. I think the reeds are mounted on padding rather than waxed, which might contribute to the great tone. Russian cbas are also built without wax for the most part.
Clif.
I have an old globe here I'm going to restore, and it's reeds are also mounted on felt and held in place with some bent metal pinching it in place...does it bear a better sound, but was discarded as the beeswax may have been easier / less expensive?
-
Tom,That D/D# Galanti that Rees had sure looked cool.in a Rat Pack,Los Vegas lounge kind of way,I loved the style and I'm intrigued to hear how it sounds and plays.
Chris
-
I think the Galanti's a fine looking old thing, though I do actually prefer the styling of the Paolos and big Club Hohners. I'm no expert but the design seems late "fifties" to me, transitioning into something more "sixties." The obvious playing comparison is with a Paolo. I've never played one of those, but I'm very happy with how this Galanti plays, big generous sound. The only similar sized box I've played much was a Hohner Club III. You definitely got the feeling with that one that it was intended for playing each phrase in one direction. The G is very happy to respond to quick bellows changes. A posting by Rees saying he'd been enjoying playing it while he had it for sale was what reminded me that I really needed to get my act together and go and see it, and I'm glad I did.
Tom
-
I play a Slovenka, Uglasitev. A great instrument. I don't see anyone who is playing one.
-
Thought I'd run a poll for which makes we own. Should be interesting.
Sorry if I've missed off your favourite box maker or miss-spelt the name. You can vote for any or all makes but please just vote for the ones you own on 1st October 2008.
is there going to be a revised poll for 2009? ;)
-
Now I just clicked on Saltarelle 'cos I's got one (Connamara II) in D/G.
Also have a broken Gremlin (That's not on the list and nor should it be)
But what about Emmanuel Pariselle ? I know there's at least 18 in England and 2 in Sweden.
-
But what about Emmanuel Pariselle ? I know there's at least 18 in England and 2 in Sweden.
Shouldn't there be a DIY category for them, and for the "kitchen sink" projects? ???
-
originally this forum probably focused mostly on DG boxes but now has a much wider focus. It would be interesting to have a poll of how many play which tuning ? C< G<D>A>F< DG< CF<GC<AD> any of foregoing with full or part row oaccidentals><ADG<GCF>DGC#<BC<CC#>C#D>DD#>BCC#.club etc etc
I havn't a clue how to set up a pole so would somebody like to have ago at it.
george
-
I havn't a clue how to set up a pole so would somebody like to have ago at it.
Poles can be set up as easily as most East Europeans, I find! ;)
That being the case I shall have a crack at setting one up along the lines you suggested...
Steve
-
I havn't a clue how to set up a pole so would somebody like to have ago at it.
Poles can be set up as easily as most East Europeans, I find! ;)
Steve,
I thought maybe George was thinking of doing some pole-dancing... :o
-
I thought of calling off the camping holiday that George and I have been planning together, since he by his own admission he'd be u.s. at setting up the tent, but that would have been too drastic.
-
... by his own admission he'd be u.s. at setting up the tent ...
Or at "flying the flag"? ???
-
I started my Melodeon experience with a single row Hohner in 'G' but unfortunately lost it by leaving it in a van after a lift. I then bought another Hohner, this time a very old one in B/C but only played in C or in B, never thought about learning to play across rows in other keys. That was used for Morris and gave me a very good grounding in playing. Hohner polka-work came next and I had many of those, mainly second hand. I was quite naive in days gone by I suppose and never considered the idea of having them tuned etc. My last Polka-work I still have and intend learning to tune it myself, "one day"!! That has had much heavy playing over the years.
I've had a Sonola 120 bass Piano Accordion for a very long time and it is at this moment in the hands of a very good tuner who is getting it back in good playing order for me. Same tuner has renovated an old Hohner Club, an old Hohner Primatona in C'C#, and an old Paolo Soprani B/C/C#. All play really well and sound good which supports the idea of keeping older instruments going provided that the reeds are sound. I also play a Castagnari student model (all I could afford at the time) which I have just had the reeds slightly adjusted to give me a less dry sound. It has taken me a very long time to realise the importance of having it tuned and adjusted on a regular basis by someone who really knows what they are doing.
-
Thought I'd run a poll for which makes we own. Should be interesting.
Sorry if I've missed off your favourite box maker or miss-spelt the name. You can vote for any or all makes but please just vote for the ones you own on 1st October 2008.
is there going to be a revised poll for 2009? ;)
Holy Necroposting, Batman! I don't remember if the orig poll counted Beltuna accordeons or Beltuna owners, but - if it's the former - it's you and me, kid! (I have two Beltuna one-rows, super little boxes).
-
Now I just clicked on Saltarelle 'cos I's got one (Connamara II) in D/G.
As this poll was supposed to be a snapshot as at October 2008 we can't really add to it, unless we keep it as an ongoing record, in which case we would all need to add or remove entries as we acquire boxes or move them on.
-
I was quite naive in days gone by I suppose and never considered the idea of having them tuned etc.
People generally used to "play 'em into the ground", and buy a new box to make a recording, but then there weren't many tuners around, in days gone by.
I have just had the reeds slightly adjusted to give me a less dry sound.
Right way to go, if you ask me. >:E