Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Lester on April 20, 2012, 08:05:02 PM
-
I think my next workshop purchase needs to be a smallish table saw. Only need to be able to cut melodeon shaped bits of wood so 20-25mm cut (see I can do foreign money ;) ) Anyone got any recommendations?
-
Yes mind your fingers! AtB mory
-
Yes mind your fingers! AtB mory
;D
-
Based on my experience in my workshop using a cheapo Chinese saw It does a decent job if I make sure the rip fence can't flex (I do this by clamping a piece of wood to the table behind it). The saw does make an awful din though. My uncle uses a decent quality small band saw and that is far more versatile (we both do model making etc). Although considerably more expensive to buy, I would recommend that route.
-
Sounds to me that a bandsaw is the way to go a lot safer if you've no tablesaw experience.
Scheppach Basato 1 Bandsaw is a pretty good make but at around £170 may be more than you're prepared to pay - cheaper makes available £110 ish but no idea what they're like.
(I'm a carpenter/ joiner)
-
The small table saws made by Proxxon and available from Axminster Tools are excellent. Very neat, quiet running and accurate. Not cheap for a small saw but I find mine very useful for melodeon sized cutting.
-
Second Theo's suggestion. The cheap chinese saws that you see in places like B&Q are like chinese boxes, need a lot of fettling to make them run right. Usually a new, finer blade plus a lot of shims round the riving knife etc which takes time and chews up a lot of wood.
For what you're describing a Proxxon or similar would be fine and not take up too much room (I cut down 5x5 sheets and need fourteen foot of clear space!)
I would not buy a bandsaw, unless you spend a fortune on really good blades you'll find that they have a tendancy to lead )one side of the blade being sharper than the other it cuts faster) and so the line goes crooked, at this point you tighten the blade and "snap" (been there).
You get what you pay for, like boxes, there's good and there's cheap, very rairly do the two meet.
Steve
-
Thanks Guys. The Proxxon looked a good saw if a bit expensive but with advice here they look to be good value for my money. The suggestion of a band saw was also interesting but it would not do the things I foresee needing to do after watching the table saw maestro Emmanuel Pariselle.
-
I`d personaly get a Bandsaw, they`re so flexible in what you can do with them, basically anything from making case parts to fine fretwork for a wooden grille . make sure the table has good guides
-
I`d personaly get a Bandsaw, they`re so flexible in what you can do with them, basically anything from making case parts to fine fretwork for a wooden grille . make sure the table has good guides
Not sure a band saw could do the sort of job I am aiming at. A good example is he work Theo did with one in this set of photos
https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.50177028166.61330.709188166&type=3 (https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.50177028166.61330.709188166&type=3)
-
I`d personaly get a Bandsaw, they`re so flexible in what you can do with them, basically anything from making case parts to fine fretwork for a wooden grille .
Fretwork on a bandsaw?? how on earth do you do that? Do you have bandsaw blades that can be split to thread through holes?
-
Thanks Guys. The Proxxon looked a good saw if a bit expensive but with advice here they look to be good value for my money. The suggestion of a band saw was also interesting but it would not do the things I foresee needing to do after watching the table saw maestro Emmanuel Pariselle.
Is is this one?
http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Bench_circular_saw_KS_230.html
-
Fretwork on a bandsaw?? how on earth do you do that? Do you have bandsaw blades that can be split to thread through holes?
Sorry, I was half asleep ;-) - I`ve done fretwork on bandsaws but not which didn`t have a path for the blade to come out. I also had an idea that Lester was about to embark on making his first box
-
Thanks Guys. The Proxxon looked a good saw if a bit expensive but with advice here they look to be good value for my money. The suggestion of a band saw was also interesting but it would not do the things I foresee needing to do after watching the table saw maestro Emmanuel Pariselle.
Is is this one?
http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Bench_circular_saw_KS_230.html
More likely this one, handles thicker stock
http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_saw_FKS_E.html (http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_saw_FKS_E.html)
-
Fretwork on a bandsaw?? how on earth do you do that? Do you have bandsaw blades that can be split to thread through holes?
Sorry, I was half asleep ;-) - I`ve done fretwork on bandsaws but not which didn`t have a path for the blade to come out. I also had an idea that Lester was about to embark on making his first box
Made two already on Emmanuel's courses where he uses a table saw for all sorts of tasks. Next on my list, after the table saw, is a router, then making a box is a possibility :o
-
More likely this one, handles thicker stock
http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_saw_FKS_E.html (http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_saw_FKS_E.html)
I have one of those, which my recommendation is based on. But this one is a newer version, same cutting capacity, but a much better fence and slightly larger table, and cheaper! http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_Saw_FET.html (http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_Saw_FET.html)
-
More likely this one, handles thicker stock
http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_saw_FKS_E.html (http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_saw_FKS_E.html)
I have one of those, which my recommendation is based on. But this one is a newer version, same cutting capacity, but a much better fence and slightly larger table, and cheaper! http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_Saw_FET.html (http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_Saw_FET.html)
I have just got one of these at work for cutting small samples of wood and composites for testing and it has proved to be very good but we have not used it enough to know how durable it will be. We also got the Dado kit see (http://www.proxxon-tools.com/tools/Proxxon-Dado-Head-Set.html) which you may find very helpfull for melodeon making. Changing the blade is quite fiddly, the dust extraction hole could do with being larger (we may modify this when it is out of warranty) and you would struggle to cut down thicker sections to make the 7 or 8mm thick boards for melodeon construction. I have also made a sled this type of thing (http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=table+saw+sled&hl=en&prmd=imvns&source=lnms&tbm=isch&ei=PYuST9B4jK3xA-ze8c0M&sa=X&oi=mode_link&ct=mode&cd=2&ved=0CBkQ_AUoAQ&biw=1146&bih=761&sei=WIuST67LEoWB8gPLsoXODA) which makes jigging and cutting of large numbers of small parts safer and more repeatable.
-
The woodwork in a melodeon is pretty varied and there is no one saw to saw it all.
A Proxxon is very good for small accurate stuff within it's capacity as Theo says - pretty ideal for cutting small strips for say wooden levers or fabricating reed blocks. I have an FKS-E.
It won't touch bigger timber though so unless your wood is already sized small enough for the Proxxon to handle you will have a problem.
Next up from that are small table top saw benches. Lots of cheap and nasty ones around though which WILL prove frustrating and inaccurate! Makita and Bosch both make decent ones. One of these would be very versatile and allow you (with care and suitable jigs) to cut mitres, slots, grooves etc as well as handle larger timber. Good quality blades (and you will need different ones for best results crosscutting and ripping) are expensive but a must for a good finish and accurate cutting. Probably the most versatile single tool to get if you can only buy one.
Bandsaw . . . a good band saw is not a cheap tool. Cheap bandsaws are in my experience immensely frustrating to set up, and with the best will in the world tend not to be accurate. Apart from cutting curves in the ends of the keyboard (which can be done by hand) I can't think of much in a melodeon which couldn't be better be done by some other means.
I'm not totally down on bandsaws - I have a Startrite which with the approriate blade will cut accurate veneers off big baulks at one end of the scale or tight curves in than materials at the other. It just wouldn't be my first choice for a saw for most bits of melodeon.
For cutting grilles and the like a used Hegner fret saw from ebay is perfect, and far preferable to a new chinese one.
Router - possibly most useful when upside down in a router table.
But, a milling machine too can be very (arguably more) useful and versatile for wood machining for a whole host of different jobs from slots, grooves, shaping, holes and so on with repeatably accurate spacing and measuring.
It's much like MAD really, one tool tends to lead to another ;D
My excuse is that I use them to earn what passes for a living.
-
I've got an older version of the cheap Proxxon - and I absolutely could not do without it. Anything from small blocks for filling too big reed chambers to to making reedblocks, it does the trick.
If I were to get a new one, I'd def. go for the one that allows the blade to be angled. The cheapo one I have will only cut with the blade up straight.
-
I have one of those, which my recommendation is based on. But this one is a newer version, same cutting capacity, but a much better fence and slightly larger table, and cheaper! http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_Saw_FET.html (http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_Saw_FET.html)
Wow, what a great little tool. I had to part with a long line of power tools :'( after my move to smaller home, tablesaw, jointer, lathe, belt sander, etc. Have not seen anything as tidy as this little saw outfit here in the US, most "small" table saws start at 10" blade. My old tools were large heavy cast iron jobs, made to endure decades of use. I did retain my drill press, though, an incredibly useful tool in any workshop situation....
-
As far as sizing wood stock, planing, thicknessing etc you may well find it cheaper to find a local joiner/cabinet maker and pay them to do it. Before I downsized my workshop I had a fairly comprensive list of machinery but when I actually sat down and did the costings all I really gained was the write-off with depreciation and could have put the cash to better use. You have to machine a lot of wood to make buying machinery cheaper than paying someone who knows what they're doing their hourly rate.
Steve
-
Jet was/is good (ish) make and this is perhaps a better spec. than the Poxon
http://www.axminster.co.uk/jet-jet-jts-10-bench-top-saw-bench-prod208698/
-
And if you buy one with tilt you can make thumb grooves in keyboards (if you take care, otherwise you might not have use for said groove)
-
Made two already on Emmanuel's courses where he uses a table saw for all sorts of tasks. Next on my list, after the table saw, is a router, then making a box is a possibility :o
As Graham W says, if you go for a router then do get a table for it as well. I have an old Elu MOF96 which doesn't have a "soft start" but a fair bit of power. Using it freehand, especially on fine work, is a non-starter, and I suspect the same applies to most new ones. All the effort is spent keeping the tool in the workpiece rather than feeding the workpiece to the tool in a controlled way. A table gives feed and, importantly, depth control; and is less terrifying.
I'm glad this discussion cropped up, as my old Burgess bandsaw has said "adios", and I was looking to replace it with a 2-wheel bandsaw. In light of what's been said here, I rather think I'll go for a decent table saw and perhaps get a cheap-ish scrollsaw for fiddly bits.
-
Comments on the proxxon here - I find this an interesting woodworking forum
http://www.ukworkshop.co.uk/forums/post619323.html#p619323
-
Another option is a radial saw. Can also be used as a mitre box!
-
Comments on the proxxon here - I find this an interesting woodworking forum
http://www.ukworkshop.co.uk/forums/post619323.html#p619323
Well I'm not surprised, cutting 20mm maple on a model making saw with a max depth of cut of 22mm. Wrong tool for the job!
-
I think table saw is the best option with a good fence (looking at the picture of the proxxcon the fence does not go the full depth of table or maybe there is a slide to the fence - but that would not lock the fence front and back that could be problem.) Adjusting the fence to the table and blade is the most important thing , not always done right at the factory and should be checked also good blade is a must I like planer blades for a cleaner cut well worth the cost if you pass the wood through with smooth motion (don't stop ) you'll get cuts without saw marks. I say any saw with good power, good fence and proper set up will give good results. I would also say when cutting small bits use blade inserts and push sticks.
table saws main use ripping , cross cutting , dados or rabbets
radial arm saws cross cuts and dado can be used for ripping but dangerous not good for small work the motor gets in the way of hands and sight.
band saw odd shapes and re sawing not very accurate usually re quires more work to get finished product
Also unless you will be using router as stand alone unit then get a small router/shaper like delta or similar table top type
unit most adjust easier and have vac. hook up and just as cheap as buying two units router and router table.
Good luck
Michael
-
Try a tool or machine auction. Second-hand yes, but you want something with a cast iron bed. Above all elaw make sure it is securely fixed, ideally to the floor.
-
"Well I'm not surprised, cutting 20mm maple on a model making saw with a max depth of cut of 22mm. Wrong tool for the job!"
It would seem so and yet they are flogging tungsten carbide blades to cut " balsa, plywood, hard and soft woods,...."?
Do you not do any hardwood repairs to boxes Theo ?
The Proxxon appears to be a well made saw but a bit limited in what it can handle - I'd be tempted to go for something with a bit more oomph to it.
-
I'd be tempted to go for something with a bit more oomph to it.
What do you use?
Yes it will cut all those materials, but maple is a very hard hardwood, and 20mm is closet to the max thickness. I just wonder how much 20mm maple was involved, I thing the poster may have been asking too much of a small tool. There is very little material that thick in a melodeon. Yes of course I repair hardwood melodeons! Here is a photo of the most extreme sawing I have done with the Proxxon:
-
"Yes of course I repair hardwood melodeons!"
Thought so - wasn't meaning to be rude.
Boxcall - I'm intrigued to know how you use planer blades on a tablesaw or am i misunderstanding something
".....good blade is a must I like planer blades for a cleaner cut"
and
radial arm saw for ripping!! "can be used for ripping but dangerous" you bet.
Can't see why folks here have a downer on bandsaws they are an essential part of a small joinery shop - lot quicker and easier to cut tenons on.
-
Can't see why folks here have a downer on bandsaws they are an essential part of a small joinery shop - lot quicker and easier to cut tenons on.
For small cuts like tenons they're fine (if well adjusted) although I use a fretsaw (:)
For bigger stuff I've found that the one I had (an INCA) just wasn't accurate enough and tended to waver on the line even when using a fence. They don't give as polished a finish on the cut edge as a table saw.
Now as you get bigger (and more expensive) they get better but even so they're low on my list of must have workshop tools.
As far as routers go, I have two, a ELU which I only use with a table and then rarely (and cost more than it's use has justified) and a Dremel Mult-tool with router attachments which is great for fiddly little jobs.
Steve
-
Well any machine should be well adjusted otherwise it's not going to perform as it should and it depends on the size of the bandsaw - big bandsaw will cut deep tenons - not used an Inca - thing with a bandsaw is to fit a good blade and ditch the one it's supplied with.
Elu's were great routers (and saws, etc.) then Dewalt took them over.
-
I can't imagine being without my bandsaw, but would never use it in place of my tablesaw. A table saw is quick and accurate with a good blade and fence. A bandsaw can cut extremely well (I can use mine to cut thin veneer), but it takes a lot of careful set up. And each time you change a blade on band saw you have to go through the set up process again.
I've never used those small Proxxons, and don't doubt they do well with smaller pieces, but I'd sure consider a bigger size table top saw, like a 10" size. Still reasonably priced and small, but can handle quite a bit bigger stock and good choice of blades available.
-
Boxcall - I'm intrigued to know how you use planer blades on a tablesaw or am i misunderstanding something
".....good blade is a must I like planer blades for a cleaner cut"
Hi Gromit
I don't use a blade from a surface planer.
I talking about a planer blade for table saws they come in different sizes 8" 1o" etc.
the blades unlike most blades have no set to the teeth which gives a smoother cut . most blades have a set to them meaning that one tooth bends slightly to one side of the blade and the next tooth bends to the other side and so on , which will leave saw marks on the wood being cut - planer blades don't or not as much usually only when you stop or shift your hands also use of feather board helps with this. try one and you won't need to run the edge though a joiner.
Michael
-
Thanks
I understand - you must be in the States those blades as far as I know are not available in the UK - we've got all sorts of safety regulations regarding saws and blades these days. Nearest I've got is a 40 tooth fine blade on my Festool that leaves a very smooth finish.
-
They have a slightly different attitude to saw benches over the water, as far as I understand;)
These 'planer' type blades are available in the UK for crosscutting, most usually in a mitre / radial saw of some sort, and give an excellent smooth and accurate glue ready finish. They are expensive and easily damaged by misuse. They are described as HiATB or 'Laminate' blades.
I've not seen one quite like that for ripping use, but one Of the industrial suppliers like Atkinson-Walker would be able to advise on what blade was best for your particular need.
A brief warning though for people who aren't familiar with circular saw blades. It's seriously important to be aware that saw blades for ripping and cross cutting have different tooth geometries, and using the wrong blade for the wrong purpose has the potential to damage the blade, the saw and yourself. A circular saw can grab and hurl or pull large pieces of wood with murderous force.
-
A circular saw can grab and hurl or pull large pieces of wood with murderous force.
I've blocked a couple of those pieces with my hip. I don't really recommend that method. :o
-
Here is the type of blade I'm talking about good for ripping and cross cutting used on my table saw.
I don't use my table saw for cross cuts unless I'm cutting wide panels and only when the piece is short enough to be handled
safely, compound mitre saw is the best for that IMO radial arm could also be used but there tends to be more play in the rail resulting in poor quality cut.
/www.google.com/products/catalog?hl=en&rlz=1G1GGLQ_ENUS326&q=oldham+planer+blades&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tbm=shop&cid=12917992164332760720&sa=X&ei=aqKWT4iEBenx6AGRwOyRDg&ved=0CIwBEPMCMAI#ps-sellers
Michael
-
A key quality in any machinery is repeatability. Its all very well having carefully plotted dimensions but if you cannot make them happen time and time again your work can become ragged. Repeatability in a saw is tied up in the fence. Any saw above the lowest price range will have adequate bearings and a strong motor, the fence is where the money needs to go. Also look at the nature of the well around the blade. Blades which cant over often have wide holes filled with inserts of dubious quality. I spent a lot of time making a better insert for my last saw from wood. If you are making a small piece of trim the last thing you want is any roughness in the table.
I went from paying other people to cut wood to cutting my own. At first it made sense letting someone else maintain the equipment, deal with the dust, and do boring saw work breaking down larger pieces of timber. After a while I realised the only way to get complete control of the process was to be able to look at wood as if it had no finite dimensions, it was whatever size I wanted. To do this I now have a bandsaw and a sander thicknesser. If I was making accordions (I make concertinas) I would buy an accurate table saw with guaranteed repeatability and a router table.
-
Here is a decent smaller table saw for someone. eBay : 160787456467
Wadkin saws are about as solid and accurate as it gets, I have a later version of this saw and have been highly delighted with it. They can be run from an Inverter or simply fit a single phase motor and starter. You will end up with a saw that will outlast and outperform light weight new saws that cost far more money.
-
Yes Graham - Wadkin or Startrite table saws, bandsaws, planers, spindle moulders, morticers etc. were pretty much standard machinery in joinery shops I used to work in the past.
-
Consider a used INCA model 259.
Jim Krenov ( self proclaimed wood guru) teacher and author ( I have the first Swedish workbench custom made for him) said if he had two stationery power tools it would be a band saw and a jointer.
Do not buy or use a radial arm saw, even as a cutoff saw.
Also it you have the funds consider products by Festool...
Also there is a very small table saw by HEGNER.. I believe now discontinued, at least for the US.
If you want a mutipurpose multi function saw and can afford it.. decent unit. EXPENSIVE.
-
I started with a radial arm saw. I thought it would be the answer - wrong! They are not good.
I now have three table saws ranging from very small to very big, plus a bandsaw - all good. (:)
-
I have a 3 hp 12" sliding table table saw.. a smaller table saw, 14" band saw, 18" band saw, Delta Scroll saw, 12 " planer, 4" IIDA planer, 22" drum sander, 24" drum sander , floor mounted drill press, bench drill press , horizontal boring machine, 6 " 3 ft jointer, 6" 6ft Jointer.... assorted other stuff...
If I were on a budget I would get a used Delta Rockwell Contractors Saw and a video by Kelly Mayer ( sp) and set it up.
I would get an older quality 6" jointer perhaps a Delta or a 50's or 60's Craftsman.
-
Consider a used INCA model 259.
I have this model - the one with the tilting table. It's a very accurate saw but can be difficult to deal with the tilting table for angled cuts. The mortising setup is very nice though making the saw dual purpose.
My first choice for any ripping process is my band saw. The kerf is thinner meaning there's less sawdust on the floor and it's much safer than the table saw for cutting thin pieces. I've used mine for almost all of the pieces in my mini-melodeon one way or the other, the table saw being used for cross cuts. Smoothness of cut on the band saw depends largely on the type of blade and the set up of the saw. Yes, there are setup issues with a band saw, but that's true of any machine tool in the shop - planer, thicknesser, table saw, router, and so forth. With the band saw you can cut veneer - something the table saw can't do.
-
Proxxon stuff does seem to be very good. A scroll saw might also be a useful thing to have.
-
I just bought a used scroll saw and have found it extremely useful for cutting air holes in treble and bass palletboards. It turned out to be fairly easy to stack a register and a reedblock shoe on top of the bass pallet board and then cut the holes all together. I hated that job until I figured out that the scroll saw could do them all together.
-
Scroll saws are great for stack cutting, fretting ends etc. They are really bad at straight lines as you cannot use a fence because of the differences between blades, even those in the same packet. The blades are basically stamped out (OK it's a bit more technical than that) and one side tends to be sharper than the other so often cutting in a straight line means cutting at a slight angle to the blade.
Steve
-
Jim Krenov ( self proclaimed wood guru) teacher and author ( I have the first Swedish workbench custom made for him) said if he had two stationery power tools it would be a band saw and a jointer.
Jeff, good advice as always -- except I think that we can give Krenov a bit more credit than "self-proclaimed" implies -- he did earn his cabinetmaking degree at a Swedish trade school, and certainly many others considered him to be a guru!
[Correction: He apparently didn't earn the degree -- but he did get hired to teach at the school ten years later! -A.]
I have occasionally amused myself with the thought of a Krenov-inspired melodeon -- built without drawn plans. Probably apple with mixed heartwood/sapwood. A little drawer on one side, for who-knows-what. Hand-whittled buttons. And a spindly-legged stand to display it -- or a "tea cabinet" to keep it in!
Nice thread -- have enjoyed reading the responses.
-Andy
-
Krenov did not earn his degree at the Malmsten Skol. He left by mutual agreement after one year. Fact.
His "job" at Mendocino was arranged for him by a Stanford professor, who was himself an author of many books including the subjects of Shaker furniture and Windsor chairs. Krenov never thanked him for the introduction or recommendation or arranging the interview for the position. Fact. Never.
Krenov was a brilliant designer and a good workman. He never made a living doing woodwork. Fact.
A Krenov designed accordeon would be interesting. He was fond of unsteamed pearwood and of course masur birch and "Swedish Pine".
-
I have one of those, which my recommendation is based on. But this one is a newer version, same cutting capacity, but a much better fence and slightly larger table, and cheaper! http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_Saw_FET.html (http://www.proxxon-direct.com/acatalog/Table_Saw_FET.html)
I am looking at getting something like this soon.
Has anyone actually used the FET? Also, anyone know if it's true that you have to buy Proxxon blades for their saws?
And finally - any other recommendations for a similar saw (UK and not second-hand)?
Ta
Malcolm
-
Has anyone actually used the FET? Also, anyone know if it's true that you have to buy Proxxon blades for their saws?
So would I be the first here to buy a FET? Or is there an Omerta condition on the order form ???
-
Sorry missed this first time round, I have a FET and am happy with it. The only thing is I think the supplied blade is a bit coarse for the stuff I do so I need to get apnea with more teeth.
-
In trying to decide whether to replace my old bandsaw with a table saw, I had a look at one of these.
It is well-built, as one might expect, and very compact, but I was rather put off by the spec. for the blades. The smaller diameter 50mm blades looked hard to find unless buying the Proxxon ones. The larger sizes up to 85mm diameter can be found from other sources, but most appear to have a bore of 15mm (the Proxxon ones are 10mm). I suppose it might be possible to use them with an arbour, but it all seemed a bit of a fiddle.
I was also looking for a tool to do a number of jobs, including cuts to materials 1 inch (25.4mm) or more thick, and the FET maximum is 22mm.
However, if blade supply and cutting depth isn't an issue, then it looks like a nice machine to have, for fairly light-duty use. In the end, I bought a midrange Metabo bandsaw, but if I had a spare £350 knocking about to spend on a small tablesaw, then this would likely be it.
-
Thanks guys.
Since I am not familiar with these beasties, why would one select (or need) a particular blade diameter? I'm sure it's not as simple as depth of cut, although it would obviously affect that?
Although my father was a carpenter and joiner, I cannot cut wood nicely to save my life. OK for garden stuff and most DIY (although not so much these days!).
-
I apologize in advance for any toes stepped on or umbrage taken - this is meant in a good-natured spirit and is not intended to be a criticism of any other posts on this thread -
there are few internet forum discussions that create more interest than the question, "which table saw?"
our man RobF recently built a beautiful boat with some basic tools including a humble $99 direct drive 8" table saw -
I think the basic cuts required in the cabinetry of a box can be done with the entry level table saw available at the usual places -
The arguments for table saws are the same as the arguments for button boxes: a beginner can make nice music on an entry level Chinese box as well as the most expensive Italian box - the question is, does a beginner need a pro line instrument to begin enjoying music, or would a entry level instrument suffice until the musician has progressed enough to benefit from a higher quality instrument?
Just as box players do not need to start out with a pro level instrument, new woodworking enthusiasts do not need to start out on a artisan level power tool to enjoy their first basic projects.
Finally, as someone said, It's a poor craftsman that blames his tools.
-
The diameter of the blade is partly determined by the form of the teeth on the blade (shape, depth etc.). These vary according to whether it is for ripping along the wood grain or crosscutting, or indeed for cutting other materials like plastic or metal.
As it would not be very handy to have to keep changing blades for the different cuts in wood, there's usually one tooth form which will serve for both cuts.
My experience, which is derived mainly from boatbuilding and repairing, is that there is not generally much need to change blades unless for different materials, or very hard timber like old seasoned oak.
As Lester says, for work on melodeons a fine blade is probably the best. I imagine that a lot of work involves cutting plywood or thin timber, and a coarse blade will lead to splintering along the cut. It may be my imagination, but I feel that, even when using a cutting "fence" to cut a straight line (which in theory should make any sort of blade cut straight), a finer blade is more accurate.
-
I apologize in advance for any toes stepped on or umbrage taken - this is meant in a good-natured spirit and is not intended to be a criticism of any other posts on this thread -
The difficulty here is striking the balance - between a tool good enough to do a decent job, and not so limited that you'd want to upgrade in 6 months, and keeping your feet on the ground.
Melodeon-wise I'm fine with Hohners (admittedly a Liliput mostly) and have no (present >:E) urge to buy a Costalotti.
Concertina-wise I bought a Rochelle to get started and upgraded later to a Marcus, selling the Rochelle for half-price. (In this case I did so knowingly - when I subsequently bought a melodeon the cause was already lost ::). No disrespect to the Rochelle - it's a beginner's box, did what I wanted and was bought by another beginner. )
So I'm looking for a saw that will do a decent job, on small pieces, that will last me a good while but not have loads of abilities that I'll never use. And while I don't mind getting good tools cheap, I'm wary of buying cheap tools.
-
Malcolm, you are welcome to call round to my workshop any time to view my machinery.
-
Thanks Rees, I may very well take you up on that. I'll be in touch.
-
I think woodworking is as absorbing of a hobby as music and melodeon playing - if you forsee yourself getting into woodworking seriously and spending the rest of your life enjoying it you should go first class -
obviously, if you only have a few specific projects in mind and the table saw will sit in your workshop unused 50 weeks of the year, then a basic bench top direct drive saw would be fine - I really like the Bosch portable saws here in the states -
I think building a box would be a fun project - it's essentially cabinetry making -
-
The diameter of the blade is partly determined by the form of the teeth on the blade (shape, depth etc.). These vary according to whether it is for ripping along the wood grain or crosscutting, or indeed for cutting other materials like plastic or metal.
Cheers - I have a few projects lined up, and some steep learning curves to climb. But then life would be boring without new stuff to learn.
-
why would one select (or need) a particular blade diameter
For depth of cut - bigger diameter cuts thicker material
The diameter of the blade is partly determined by the form of the teeth on the blade (shape, depth etc.)
You buy the correct diameter blade for your saw - so if your saw takes 10" blades that's what you buy having first decided if you want the blade for ripping or cross cutting timber or a combination blade which will safely do both.
On a 10" blade one with 24 teeth would be used for ripping one with 60 or more teeth would be for crosscutting and around 40 teeth would be a combination blade used for both - so size of blade doesn't change you just have more or less teeth. Ripping with a cross cut blade is not a good idea and can be dangerous - cross cutting with a rip saw doesn't give you a clean cut.
Unless you know what you are doing it's best to stick with the manufacturers blade or get advice - tungsten carbide tipped blades last longer - as with all tools cheap ones are generally a false economy - a poor craftsman blames his tools because he's bought cheap ones something a good craftsman wouldn't do.
-
For me the main issue with some of the cheaper table saws is the amount of play in some of the parts and the amount of fettling required to make them run true. Cutting 90 degree angles is a pain when the blade is out of true to the table and the cross cut guide is differently out of true.
Steve