Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Chris Ryall on April 21, 2012, 05:42:35 PM

Title: Chords for "she was one of the early birds" (corrected)!
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 21, 2012, 05:42:35 PM
I hear ..                                      (where Edim = Rt hand Empull, take out B, play Bbpull if you have it, and add C#pull pull)

| G(7?)| C7   | Edim | G7 |
| She was a | sweet little | dickie| bird |

There are alternatives .. but is anyone else still in G major?  The chords suggest G blues, and sure enough a natural enough  D7 enough comes by next line ..  Full House!  Still don't believe me? Well, try a Gmaj7=G+a_B_note  .. the home chord of G major ... anywhere in the song  ;)
ccidental or otherwise? >:E
Title: Re: Chords for "sweet little dickie bird"
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 21, 2012, 08:13:00 PM
I hear ..                                      (where Edim = Rt hand Empull, take out B, play Bbpull if you have it, and add C#pull pull)

| G(7?)| C7   | Edim | G7 |
| She was a | sweet little | dickie| bird |

There are alternatives .. but is anyone else still in G major?  The chords suggest G blues, and sure enough a natural enough  D7 enough comes by next line ..  Full House!  Still don't believe me? Well, try a Gmaj7=G+a_B_note  .. the home chord of G major ... anywhere in the song  ;)
ccidental or otherwise? >:E

This clearly Eurocentric and undeniably intellectual approach to harmony seems very much at odds with your avowed intent to tackle bourgeois cadence.

Even within the cosy confines of this paradigm of you own making it clear that you are nought but a revisionist.
Title: Re: Chords for "sweet little dickie bird"
Post by: Chris Brimley on April 22, 2012, 10:43:26 AM
Indeed one could say that the words of this song seem to epitomise the capitalist ethos at a personal level.  Granted the wronged lyricist seems eventually to realise the harm done by his lady friend's unashamed greed, but he does seem to make the mistake of ending up with a grudging respect for the ruthless ways of the world, instead of rejecting the whole concept of 'early birds vs worms'.  One can only hope he eventually went on to support Keir Hardie as a result of his unfortunate experiences.

;)
Title: Re: Chords for "sweet little dickie bird"
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 22, 2012, 11:12:11 AM
Actually comrades, I have to confess that these chords weren't in the Politburo 7 chord plan. I picked them by ear (looking amongst those available on "2 row + accs").

This tune was clearly written by the American running-dogs anyway. It  is well known that in the 20's the Moscow Academy went systematically through our music.  Loyal party members have struck out out flattened 9th, sharp 4th wherever they were seen.  "Blue" 7s in the minor keys have been raised to the proper major degree, now to be called a "red" 7th

I can assert that Socialist music is pure!

Title: Re: Chords for "sweet little dickie bird"
Post by: Chris Brimley on April 22, 2012, 12:43:01 PM
Apparently the vaudeville performer who made this song famous was George Beauchamp.  He later went on to play steel guitar, and took out an early patent in America for an electric guitar.  There's a moral there somewhere.
Title: Re: Chords for "sweet little dickie bird"
Post by: pikey on April 22, 2012, 06:07:59 PM
Chris, I'll give you my version in Hawes! 
Title: Re: Chords for "sweet little dickie bird"
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 23, 2012, 06:37:14 AM
Just to cross reference to the other thread on the subject (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9297.0/topicseen.html)

I'm clearly going to get nowhere on chords  ::) but am still interested in the song. Read somewhere that it was a troop song in the second war, but it seems to have had an 1895 copyright.  Anyone know more? Beauchamp was probably just too young for WW1?
Title: Re: Chords for "sweet little dickie bird"
Post by: Chris Brimley on April 23, 2012, 08:40:02 AM
Quote
I'm clearly going to get nowhere on chords

Little faith!  See:

http://www.trasksdad.com/MusicHall/Worm/page1.html

Written by T W Connor, and published in London by FD&H in 1895 - (and in plenty of time to become a WW1 trench song too.)

I think the problem is that its title was actually 'She was one of the early birds.'

As with many music hall songs, it seems that the chorus has a pretty simple accompaniment, presumably so that the audience can join in with enthusiasm, while the verse is more complicated.
Title: Re: Chords for "sweet little dickie bird"
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 23, 2012, 09:42:06 AM
Thanks Chris. I had found some dots only, but it was like yours - just the first page of four.

If you are referring to complex melody in these songs  .. they certainly were! But to my ear the chorus of this particular one has all the leading, sometimes 'blue' notes of the melody. I've lost the argument (never really stood a chance!) so I must accept that the TW Connor put them there 'accidentally'  ;)

I would really like the chorus in original form. It's available elsewhere for 99p, but I just cannot stand 'another' internet registration  :-\ Meanwhile may I respectfully point out to any melodeonistas still reading - that Chris's dots are in the "key" of F (one b on the stave). I personally think it modulates all the time between F and F lydian (lets face it, there are more B naturals than Bb's)! Never mind ...

But look - there's a Bb minor chord there!  Five flats in it's simplest form, and it still has 4, if you think of it as dorian.

Bottom line has an A7 chord  ??? - 2 #s there (it's chord V of the D scale).

You see, I'd look to playing it as  A7b9 with a Bb extension (= just pull A with the Bbpull  'accidental' mentioned above). And that's as close to the diminished we started with as makes no difference. 

1895 is too early for 'blues' in European music. But ragtime was about and they did this sort of thing all the time! I just don't think it maps to a left end structured in triads., or in my heart that those change notes are accidental to the style.  But I love 'em, and I guess that's why I had to move on to right hand chording.  :|glug
Title: Re: Chords for "sweet little dickie bird"
Post by: Chris Brimley on April 23, 2012, 10:08:13 AM
Sorry Chris, this is the link I meant to send you, which has all pages.  I hadn't realised each page had a separate link: 

http://www.trasksdad.com/MusicHall/Worm/music1.html
Title: Chords for "she was one of the early birds"
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 23, 2012, 09:46:57 PM
Yipee!  ;) .. and thanks
| F | F  | Fdim | F |
| She was a | sweet little | dickie| bird |
| F | F  | C7 | C7 |
| chip chip | chip she | went | -|

The song is mostly in the modes of C - hence the G7 chords and a Bnatural against the F chord (#4). As the F lydian base chord is still F (technical maj7)  - it doesn't change anything. 

Sometimes the line modulates briefly up to a diatonic F scale - that basically wherever there's a C7 chord about. But most of the time it scores in F, plays in F lydian

Chords drawn from the C diatonic scale

    C D E F G A B C

C    C D E F G A B C
Dm  D E  F G A B C
G7    G A B C D E F
F   F G A B C D E (in lydian mode, hence all those Bnats)

for the 'tension' bits,  G diminished scale has notes for nearly all other chords 

    G A Bb C C# D# E F# G

C7C C# D# E  F# G A Bb
BbminBb C C# D# E F# G A (Bb min6)
GminG A Bb (2 noter) or try Gm4 G[/b] A Bb C
CdimC C# D# E F# G A Bb
A7  A Bb C C# D# E F# G

The other two D7, and F0 = F Ab B D, I'm  working on. The D7 seems to be part of a bit of Anatole.  I think the F0 is there just to resolve in and out of F chord. But I could go to the Gulag for this ...
Title: Re: Chords for "she was one of the early birds" (corrected)!
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 24, 2012, 04:01:24 PM
Followers of this thread may be interested to know that in a recent episode of "Hoarding: Buried Alive". Council operatives were called to the residence of ultra-left wing activist Dave Spart (National Amalgamated Union of Sixth-Form Operatives and Allied Trades).  Whilst clearing piles of radical books, take away leftovers and discarded drinks cartons, photographs were found documenting the Spartakusbund akkordeon korps infiltration of German military forces (1938-1945).

This little known facet of anti-imperialist struggle is best understood through these lines taken from the Spartakusbund akkordeon korps manifesto (1938):

"The question today is not democracy or dictatorship. The question that history has put on the agenda reads: bourgeois democracy or socialist democracy. For the dictatorship of the proletariat does not mean bombs, putsches, riots and anarchy, as the agents of capitalist profits deliberately and falsely claim. Rather, it means using all instruments (akkordeon/handharmonika/stumpffiddle) of political power to achieve socialism, to expropriate the capitalist class, through and in accordance with the will of the revolutionary majority of the proletariat."

To see the pictures follow this link:

Spartakusbund akkordeon korps (http://mikehirst.netfirms.com/Spartakusaufstand/)

The few surviving members of the group are rumoured to be hiding in the Ukraine.

(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ed/Ukraineeurovision2007.jpg)
Title: Re: Chords for "she was one of the early birds" (corrected)!
Post by: Theo on April 24, 2012, 08:12:17 PM

To see the pictures follow this link:

Spartakusbund akkordeon korps (http://mikehirst.netfirms.com/Spartakusaufstand/)


Mike, that is an amazing set of photos!
Title: Re: Chords for "she was one of the early birds" (corrected)!
Post by: Lester on April 24, 2012, 08:41:29 PM

To see the pictures follow this link:

Spartakusbund akkordeon korps (http://mikehirst.netfirms.com/Spartakusaufstand/)


Mike, that is an amazing set of photos!

Fabulous set of photos
Title: Re: Chords for "she was one of the early birds" (corrected)!
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 24, 2012, 09:50:16 PM

To see the pictures follow this link:

Spartakusbund akkordeon korps (http://mikehirst.netfirms.com/Spartakusaufstand/)


Mike, that is an amazing set of photos!

Fabulous set of photos

I've been collecting accordion pics for some time. I've probably got a couple of thousand. At different times I've put them up on the net as a searchable resource, but never anything permanent. I should put them back on the server and post some links.

Here's another one from the wartime set that I didn't post earlier.

Title: Re: Chords for "she was one of the early birds" (corrected)!
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 24, 2012, 11:36:57 PM
There are multiple harmonic possibilities for this and indeed any other melody, of that there is no doubt. My own preference is to ignore the head and follow the heart. There is something joyful in playing the non scalar tones over a simple triad. New tones create new tensions, much as with drone instruments where the complex relationship between melody and drone create subtle rhythmic interplay.

To prevent the discussion getting dragged into the quagmire of intellectual analysis I propose that we extend the remit to include other examples of popular melodies which include non scalar tones, with practical examples where possible.

Recorded by Florrie Forde in 1912, the melody for the music hall song Joshu-ah (http://youtu.be/lN_nqw2AEJw) is characterised through the repeated use of non scalar tones. This recording is made using a Deutsche Demokratische Republik (DDR) era B/C instrument, played in the key of C (the people's key). The non scalar tones are played against the I and V7 chords (C and G7).

http://libtrad.eu/mp3/Joshua_Mixdown.mp3 (http://libtrad.eu/mp3/Joshua_Mixdown.mp3)

In this next example the same instrument is used to play the Leo Daniderff composition Le Denicheur (Valse musette). In this instance the non scalar tones are used as passing tones in the movement from I to V7 and Back again. The opening sequence is derived from the last few bars of the mid section. In the key of B, I play a descending sequence of V7 and IV inversions (F#7 and E) against the F# Bass Chord pair, building tension before moving into the main theme. The only left hand chords used are B and F#.

http://libtrad.eu/mp3/Le_Denicheur_Mixdown.mp3 (http://libtrad.eu/mp3/Le_Denicheur_Mixdown.mp3)

As with Le Denicheur this arrangement of She Was One Of The early Birds uses only two left hand chords. The non scalar tones are emphasised through the repeated use of semitone intervals.

http://libtrad.eu/mp3/She_Was_One_Of_The_Early_Birds_Mixdown.mp3 (http://libtrad.eu/mp3/She_Was_One_Of_The_Early_Birds_Mixdown.mp3)

Title: Re: Chords for "she was one of the early birds" (corrected)!
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 25, 2012, 07:12:59 AM
I've been collecting accordion pics for some time. I've probably got a couple of thousand. At different times I've put them up on the net as a searchable resource, but never anything permanent. I should put them back on the server and post some links.

I can only echo the above - not absolutely on topic, but absolutely fabulous stuff. Found a good wiki on it. All in German but google turned into something resembling English for me. An aspect of history I'd never have even suspected. Thanks

As for our tune? I sort of suspected Mike's response might have been along the lines of "bo££ocks". The two tunes he posts .. they aren't really as off-scale as  "dickie bird",. Joshua(to my ear)  is using mainly 'leading notes', but denisheur wanders a lot. 

Yes, of course the 2 chord trick works - you can basically do anything in 'altering  the dominant' and its a matter of how much tension you can take, or want. I'm personally still tempted to take dickie up as a song. I am looking more to a stable chord run, to focus on voice. So I was more interested in following the harmonic line into its underlying structure.

I still hold that in most of these tunes there are modulations going on, the 'accidentals' (remember those?) are all very precisely placed, and the number of "C" chords in dickie's F dots is .. interesting? The number of chords that are contained in the dim scale .. fascinating. There has to be underlying structure. Though its sophistry, I admit  :P

I did at one point consider 2 chording myself  (I+diminished) and had a try :-\  Er, no, so presently still on my too hard list.  Loved Mikes 'tweets' btw - wacky and witty  :|glug
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal