Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Lester on April 24, 2012, 11:59:11 AM
-
So I have a bunch of stuff laying around my workshop including the ends of an Erica, a set of bellows that seem to fit, some reed blocks and loads of reeds. So I got to thinking of building a bandonion Erica. I have the reeds from a G/C and a D/G so the G row will be easy enough but I need a set of D reeds an octave down on normal. What is the considered opinion of lowering a set of D reeds an octave by loading the tips? Or has someone a set of D 1 row reeds laying around cheap?
-
I've never tried lowering a set of reeds by an octave, but I suspect that it would result in a complete disaster! If you have a three voice CF box with a low reed you might have more success with tuning up the low C set. Come to think of it I might have a low C# set that would be even closer.
-
Hi folks,
Another possibility is to re-tune a low F row. I have a block here from an F/Bb pokerwork. To retune low F to lower D, move the reeds over and then many of the reedplates would need only one reed retuned by a semitone, a couple would need no retuning:
F row with low diatonic notes: A/C C/E F/G A/Bb C/D F/E A/G C/Bb F/D A/E (C/G -- not used)
low D row with accidentals: (acc) A/C# D/E F#/G A/B D/C# F#/E A/G D/B F#/C# A/E
You might want to get your D/B reed for the low D row from a different source, such as a C/D reedplate which should be easy to find.
PG
-
I do happen to have a set of Hohner low octave D reeds and will gladly let you come them to good use. Pm me either here or on fb. Best regards, Olav
-
I've never tried lowering a set of reeds by an octave, but I suspect that it would result in a complete disaster!
Thanks Theo, kind of thought that would be the answer
But all has been solved thanks a very kind offer to Olav (diatonix)
All I need now is the time as I have a sudden rush of customer work (:)
-
Or buy a bandoneon?? ;D
-
interesting idea. Is this instrument going to play like a Hohner Elysium, in an Erica sized package?
-
interesting idea. Is this instrument going to play like a Hohner Elysium, in an Erica sized package?
Who knows, just got to thinking what to do with all the leftovers from various other boxes/projects in my workshop. Be assured that if/when it is successful it will appear here (:)
-
interesting idea. Is this instrument going to play like a Hohner Elysium, in an Erica sized package?
Who knows, just got to thinking what to do with all the leftovers from various other boxes/projects in my workshop. Be assured that if/when it is successful it will appear here (:)
Eagerly awaiting outcome. ;D :|glug
-
Or buy a bandoneon?? ;D
I can`t remember the last time I saw a fully working playable bandoneon (as opposed to an antique wreck) for sale in the UK.
-
I got mine (AA professional, 142 button) over the Internet from a dealer in Argentina! A few do pop up on German ebay www.ebay.de
-
There's lots of them on international sellers on ebay and I've not heard of a bad experience yet. Mine came from Germany.
However be aware that the tango/Argentnian tuning as A442.
Steve
-
I know Lester's bigger than me, but you really do need hands the size of JCB buckets to fit a bandoneon. I have an old AA Konzertina which seems to be arranged as the fore-runner of the bandoneon, luckily it is in good enough tune to enjoy playing as I wouldn't fancy learning to tune on those long reed plates! To reach the furthest buttons my hands are right through the wrist straps up to the wrists, which doesn't give much control.
None of this matters as the button layout is the most confusing and illogical thing I've ever met with.
If anyone has a smashed up HA114D donor, please donate it to Lester's project as I think it would sound awesome.
Rob.
-
I now have all the reeds, some suitablish reed blocks which will need some surgery, some Erica ends that need some TLC and a set of bellows which need retaping. All I need now is the time.
I will update the thread as I progress the build.
-
Sounds good lester ! . at least you can test the system by doing the blocks first and bunging them in the Penguin of death (or any other pokerworks or ericas you own) ,
I have a PA tuned LM Dry, it sounds very different to the usual MM swing 2 voicers have. also it`s not a register I`ve ever chosen to use on the 4 Voice box, I didn`t know what I was missing. come to that, I`ve not used MH either
-
I have a Hohner CF bandoneon tuned. Will try and post some pics of reed blocks for your inspiration.
-
I have a Hohner CF bandoneon tuned. Will try and post some pics of reed blocks for your inspiration.
Thanks Theo.
I'm using the blocks from a G/C pokerwork, the old C block which will become the G block will only need minor reshaping of some chambers. But the low reed side of the ex-G block (new D block) will need top removing to extend the chambers. Doesn't look to be that difficult (famous last words)
-
For the others here who didn't like to ask, including me, what makes it "bandoneon tuning"?
Other than cutting it square and adding shedloads of buttons?
Malcolm
-
Bandonion tuning is octave tuned, LM - although there are in fact bandonions which have more than two voices, but that is the convention (possibly taken from the naming of voices for the piano accordion).
Rob.
-
Progressing well except for a new problem. Thanks to Diatonix I have a set of low reeds out of a D 1 row but this means I am missing one reed as the 1 row is 10 button and the Erica is 11 buttons on the D row.
Unfortunately the reed I need is an odd one, an A5/E5. I cant work out how to create on as all the reeds in the 5 octave that I have are much closer in tone than A and E.
Any thoughts?
-
Hi Lester,
See my post above. Assuming you mean the very high A/E notes of a low-octave D row with 11 buttons, the A/E plates are present on the F row of a Hohner when that F row is low, as in F/Bb or F/Bb/Eb. Should be easy to find a spare one of those reed plates. As I mentioned, I have an entire NOS low F felt-bottom Hohner reedblock from an F/Bb Pokerwork set, but it would be wasteful to break that up for one plate. However, F/FB/Eb boxes are common enough that you should be able to find a good match among local box repairmen if you remind then where to look for that reedplate.
PG
-
I'll send you the missing reed.
-
I'll send you the missing reed.
I must find a way of sending beer is email. Many thanks. ;D ;D
-
I`d wait til you find how he sent the reed by E-Mail first and use the same method ;D .
-
Will you still call it an 'Erica'? It might turn out to be more of a 'Fernando'...
-
Will you still call it an 'Erica'? It might turn out to be more of a 'Fernando'...
Or possible just Banderica :D
-
Or possible just Banderica :D
;D
-
So I have modified the G Row reed block, waxed the reeds on, and rough tuned them on my tuning bench and it sounds like this which I a quite liking
http://soundcloud.com/alison-10/banderica-1 (http://soundcloud.com/alison-10/banderica-1)
Still a ways to go and the sound will improve once I have fully tuned the blocks in the correct Erica casework which will not be leaky unlike the one used for this demo.
-
So I have modified the G Row reed block, waxed the reeds on, and rough tuned them on my tuning bench and it sounds like this which I a quite liking
http://soundcloud.com/alison-10/banderica-1 (http://soundcloud.com/alison-10/banderica-1)
Still a ways to go and the sound will improve once I have fully tuned the blocks in the correct Erica casework which will not be leaky unlike the one used for this demo.
Sounds very interesting! Fill me in - what differences are the two reeds tuned to?
-
So I have modified the G Row reed block, waxed the reeds on, and rough tuned them on my tuning bench and it sounds like this which I a quite liking
http://soundcloud.com/alison-10/banderica-1 (http://soundcloud.com/alison-10/banderica-1)
Still a ways to go and the sound will improve once I have fully tuned the blocks in the correct Erica casework which will not be leaky unlike the one used for this demo.
Sounds very interesting! Fill me in - what differences are the two reeds tuned to?
They should be in unison but an octave apart, like I said needs fine tuning though.
-
Can we settle on "Lesterica"?
-
Can we settle on "Lesterica"?
;D
-
Can we settle on "Lesterica"?
;D
Of course...after all it is Histerica. Brilliant idea, Lester, can't wait to hear it all tuned up!
-
I have heard of a bulb onion, a common onion and a garden onion, but never a bandonion. Is this a new variety of allium? ???
-
I have heard of a bulb onion, a common onion and a garden onion, but never a bandonion. Is this a new variety of allium? ???
:|bl
-
IIRC correctly, Heinrich Band originally dubbed his creation the "Bandonion". To the Spanish-speaking players of Argentina and Uruguay this became "Bandoneón", losing the accent when re-imported to the English language to become "Bandoneon"...which is technically the most corrupted and least correct way to spell it...
-
It's always good to get an authoritative response from someone who clearly knows his onéons...
well someone had to do it
-
I've got a "Bandonika" in C/F that I've been in the middle of sorting out for a couple of years now ;D
It's kind of the opposite of what Lester's doing - a bandonion body tuned MH with melodeon tuning - 2 rows (C/F) on the right and 8 bass and chords on the left. The F row and basses are sounding sweet although it still needs voicing properly but the C row is still all over the place.
I really must sort it out soon.
Cheers
Squeezy
-
I've got a "Bandonika" in C/F that I've been in the middle of sorting out for a couple of years now ;D
Squeezy
Is it a pressed wood body? Dave Hunt has one, which makes an "interesting" noise...
-
I've got a "Bandonika" in C/F that I've been in the middle of sorting out for a couple of years now ;D
Squeezy
Is it a pressed wood body? Dave Hunt has one, which makes an "interesting" noise...
Yes, that's the one I borrowed for the Bath gig. Interesting, ha ha :D
-
Well it is more or less finished, just some cosmetic stuff to do and I really like the sound:
http://youtu.be/f6DCcoTO1z4 (http://youtu.be/f6DCcoTO1z4)
It is a real Frankenbox made from:
- The ends from a scrappy Erica from eBay with the perloid peeled off and stained and varnished
- The bellows from a Student 1 piano accordion again from eBay
- Treble reed blocks from a G/C pokerwork
- G reeds from the same G/C and a scrap D/G
- D reeds from the scrap D/G and a very generous donation from Diatonix of this parish (thanks Olav)
-
Sounds great Lester ..
-
Whew, that's a throaty growl! How is the response of the low reeds with Erica bellows dimensions?
-
Whew, that's a throaty growl! How is the response of the low reeds with Erica bellows dimensions?
Plays really easily, just like a normal Erica. I find that the low reeds will start far easier when in tandem with a higher octave reed.
-
Great job Lester...the box sounds quite profound. Did you have to alter the reedblocks to accept the lower reeds?
-
Great job Lester...the box sounds quite profound. Did you have to alter the reedblocks to accept the lower reeds?
By using G/C blocks I reduced the amount of woodwork needed on the blocks. the high reeds required a thin strip of wood along the bottom of the block to take up the slack, the low reeds needed a small amount of easing of the chambers for a few reeds. I will take some photos.
-
Fantastic!
-
That sounds really good Lester. I want one. I want one now.
Martin
-
Great fun in every way! Well done you.
Any chance of an ABC for the tune? Probably a bit beyond me at this stage but I'd like to put it on the 'to learn' pile :||:
-
Great fun in every way! Well done you.
Any chance of an ABC for the tune? Probably a bit beyond me at this stage but I'd like to put it on the 'to learn' pile :||:
Be warned John Spiers wrote this as a challenging piece for a Pokerwork ;)
X:213
T:Jiggery Pokerwork
M:6/8
C:John Spiers
K:Em
E2 F GFE | B2 c A3 | A2 B G2 B | BAG FGF |
E2 F GFE | B2 c A3 | A2 B G2 B | BAF E3 :||
B_B=B GEB | _B=BG EB_B | BGE cGE | dAF gdB |
B_B=B GEB | _B=BG EB_B | A3 d3 | BAF E3 :||
-
Got to play this box last night and it plays and sounds very nice and looks really good in its nude state.
Could I live with it, well not all the time but if you could just cram in a second set of reeds and a stop to take out the low reeds!
Good (bad) work again Lester, now where is that old Erica and the heat gun.