Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: HallelujahAl on September 30, 2008, 03:08:36 PM
-
Given the current credit 'squeeze' ;D would you consider a melodeon a good investment...???
-
It's a "crunch", might you not be better off (and safer) with a PA?* ;D
Chris.
*( "Welcome to Hell ... ")
-
It's a "crunch", might you not be better off (and safer) with a PA?*
Chris.
Point taken - but having just cleaned out my bank account to get a melodeon...ho hum.....
Anyway, I suppose what I'm asking is - does a melodeon hold its re-sale value better than, say a Piano Accordion? Is a melodeon a 'good' investment? I don't suppose the FSA has an opinion on this...
AL
-
In economic terms, a musical instrument is seldom a good investment. The only exceptions I've seen are older high-end instruments and buying and selling them as investments is only for experts with deep pockets.
In practical terms, many people find music to be a good escape when life turns nasty. If buying a melodeon would make you happy it would be an excellent investment.
-
Good investment..........and when everything goes pear shaped at least busking might hold out some hope.
Actually, if you want to invest in a musical instrument, try the Hurdy Gurdy......I'm told they often give better than 15% p.a. return.
Phil
-
Interesting discussion. :) Instruments are a lousy investment, but their product is priceless. All the lifelong musicians that I know are hounds for new gear. One might say that we're all either junkies, or suckers.
I make stained glass windows and about nine or ten years ago, the price of energy suddenly jumped. Almost overnight, kilns shut their doors or scaled back production (a good example is the price of the beautiful hand-rolled swirly sheets from Sunderland's Hartley Wood, which became almost impossible to find at affordable prices). For any economists wondering about the elasticity of colored art glass, well.. there you go. Even big companies like Spectrum (cheap, machine-rolled stuff, the glass equivalent of Scarlatti etc.) ceased production on their most interesting oddball varieties and scaled back production of everything else. At the time I did custom work on the side for extra money, and my prices followed suit. I know it's a credit crunch and not energy driving the issue today, but I think accordion makers have just responded by raising their prices and not cutting production.. and they raised them quite high, IMO.
At the same time I developed an interest in free reed instruments and started playing the concertina. I remember drooling over all the different makes of accordion and concertina available online. Seems that the prices have tripled since then, and for me living in America, the exchange rates have just about totaled any chance that I had of buying a new box of the snazzier makes.
This should highlight two things: 1) the importance of competition in the folk box market, notably Hohner's new diatonics which I understand are decent instruments at affordable prices, and 2) the real value of finding a quality high-end instrument on the used market. People selling such boxes on ebay often set high reserves, when the market clearly shows that people don't want to pay over 1500 Euros or so for a used Italian or French box.
I don't mean to whine about money, but is anyone else on this site curious about the high prices of new handmade diatonics? The prices are so high as to seem silly in a way. I could buy several used autos for the price of a new Castagnari Trilly. ??? Admittedly, I could drive both cars very well, but would surely crash the Trilly... :-\
-
My concertina has probably kept pace with inflation but melodeons don't. Mind you I could still get what I paid for my Tommy (ignoring inflation) as I bought it so long ago when the Lira/Pound exchange rate was very good
-
As Lester says concertinas (particularly Anglos) don't seem to lose value as quickly as melodeons do. Of course if you have a vintage Crabb (wish I did!) you are not going to be to worried as they just seem to appreciate rather than deppreciate.
-
Interesting story....and it stays on topic....trust me.
A few years ago I was asked to teach some Adult Class lessons at our local centre. My subject was, "A Beginner's guide to the Internet".....a ten week course .....two hours every Wednesday. I had all sorts of people sign up.....one lady only joined so that she could do the on-line version of the Telegraph crossword, another wanted to use Ebay.....
And then this dear old lady turned up with her Zimmer frame. She was obviously well in to her eighties.
Later in the evening, I sat beside her and said, "I hope you don't mind me asking, but what are you hoping to get out of this class."
Her answer nearly knocked me out. She said, "I want to find out more about the English Button Melodeon."
"Well," I answered, "You have indeed come to the right place. Switch that computer off."
Anyway, it transpired that her father had given her his old melodeon. Apparently he'd got it from a captured German private soldier back in World War One. She wanted to find out how much it was worth.
She brought it in the next week and my heart sank. The leather was almost dust and the woodwork was hardly better. It had a smell about it.....mustard gas?
I advised her that I really didn't think it was worth very much at all.....and she looked at me with a harrrruuuuumph.
She did stay the course though and she did learn how to price things on Ebay....and eventually I think she agreed with me as, sadly, a few weeks later I spotted the instrument in a local charity shop.
Thing is though, had it been a concertina with the name Wheatstone attached, then evenin that condition it could have been worth a bit.
Phil
-
As Lester says concertinas (particularly Anglos) don't seem to lose value as quickly as melodeons do. Of course if you have a vintage Crabb (wish I did!) you are not going to be to worried as they just seem to appreciate rather than deppreciate.
Can anyone tell me what exactly a 'vintage Crabb' is...? I mean how far back do we go before a Crabb becomes vintage............
-
With a Crabb.....you have to go awfully far back and you have to go sideways.
;)
Phil
-
Going back to the original question, I suppose the best answer is, "So long as it's loud enough to busk with".
I don't hold with musical instruments as investments. As a guitarist (first instrument for years) I see the highly inflated money charged for "vintage" Fenders and Gibsons, and the inflatd money paid for "English Ephemera" (Watkins, Burns, etc.), many of which should have been skipped years ago. In fact you generally find that the "mint and unplayed condition" items are like that because they are unplayable - and probably always were.
So, make your mind up on the basis of what another musician will pay you for how it plays and what it sounds like - and old is not necessarily better.
-
I think the credit squeeze is the result of a successful day's busking with your melodeon.
;D
-
I think the credit squeeze is the result of a successful day's busking with your melodeon.
;D
Steve very good ha ha WHY ARE YOU KNOWN AS Grumpy Old Git ???????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Lin
-
WHY ARE YOU KNOWN AS Grumpy Old Git ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????
It's to do with the inverse correlation between patience and age, expressed as a negative exponential function of the form:
-p=a2
where p is the patience factor, a is number of years greater than age 50 (the 'half-century excess).
-
yes I heard that some men take a while to p as they as grow older
-
" I am extraordinarily patient, provided I get my own way in the end."
Margaret Thatcher, in Observer April 4, 1989
-
Rees!!!!!
The M.... T.... words. How could you?? :o
You deserve to have all your fuses blow at once for that
I'll have to go and find a house-brick for my computer screen now. ;)
-
WHY ARE YOU KNOWN AS Grumpy Old Git ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????
It's to do with the inverse correlation between patience and age, expressed as a negative exponential function of the form:
-p=a2
where p is the patience factor, a is number of years greater than age 50 (the 'half-century excess).
A load of crap. According to your formula I have a negative patience factor of 441, yet all who know me are pressing for me to achieve immediate Beatification.
Alter your theory immediately or Sheffield gets the full output of the synthesiser and saxophone. If that is not enough, then it's the Erika and blues shouting.
Ancient and extremely patient Bill.
-
" I am extraordinarily patient, provided I get my own way in the end."
Margaret Thatcher, in Observer April 4, 1989
Rees,
How can anyone from Bevan's homeland quote the Ferrous Baroness? The only compensation is that she is more frightening without a gun than Sarah Palin is with lipstick, pig, Moose head and gun.
Ancient and shocked Bill.
-
A load of crap. According to your formula I have a negative patience factor of 441, yet all who know me are pressing for me to achieve immediate Beatification.
Alter your theory immediately.
Hmmm.... clearly this is unsatisfactory and an uncertain result. Perhaps there is a hitherto unknown Croydon effect*, which needs to be quantified and the equation amending accordingly.
*maybe it is due to the influence of the Coriolis force, which of course increases as one gets nearer the equator. Do you spin clockwise or anticlockwise in your bath, Bill?
-
Now see what you've started Lin..... ;)
-
A load of crap. According to your formula I have a negative patience factor of 441, yet all who know me are pressing for me to achieve immediate Beatification.
Alter your theory immediately.
Hmmm.... clearly this is unsatisfactory and an uncertain result. Perhaps there is a hitherto unknown Croydon effect*, which needs to be quantified and the equation amending accordingly.
*maybe it is due to the influence of the Coriolis force, which of course increases as one gets nearer the equator. Do you spin clockwise or anticlockwise in your bath, Bill?
You're almost certainly correct regarding the Croydon effect, Some municipal prat from Paris visited and has decided to develop the suburbs of Paris in the style of Croydon. Now there's an oxymoron.
Lay off of Lin, she can't help it as she comes from Brum and has no Welsh connections.
-
oh yes I do.. all my grandparents came from Wales and my maiden name was Price .............. so when I married I became priceless ;D
Lin
-
O my gawd!
My mother's maiden name was Price too.
Perhaps I'm your long lost Uncle Rees. ???
-
awwwwwwwwwwwwwwww............ and we met at Stowmarket and we didnt know we were related ....... :'(
-
oh yes I do.. all my grandparents came from Wales and my maiden name was Price .............. so when I married I became priceless ;D
Lin
Vote whether this is the worst joke of the day, week, month, year, decade, century, millennium, your choice. ;)
-
O my gawd!
My mother's maiden name was Price too.
Pedant's correction:-Should that read Price Two? :D
-
Can I join in because... I TOO AM WELSH (Cadwgan of St. Asaph no less!) and I feel it's become necessary to be Welsh in order to play the melodeon - obviously its an ancient Druidic instrument that was replaced in latter days by the small harp.
So then Rees, what are all these English doing playing OUR instrument???
-
.................. and marrying our sheep!
-
Do you think when Owain Glynd?r comes down from the hills he'll be playing a Costalotti? Can't really imagine Dafydd y Garreg Wen, lying dying, as the Ocker Painter has it, on anything but a harp.
Oh really, this board cannot deal with a lower case w with a circumflex. As revenge I've entered Theo in the Great North Run.
-
Do you think when Owain Glynd?r comes down from the hills he'll be playing a Costalotti?
Personally, I can't think of anything more scary...right, I'm off to practise 'Sospan Fach'!
http://www.scarlets.co.uk/default/ (http://www.scarlets.co.uk/default/)
-
Up the Scarlets!
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=W5TN26-8pTw
-
I don't hold with musical instruments as investments.
Me either, my old Wheatstone Æola is working very hard and will never be an investment or a museum piece!
As a guitarist (first instrument for years)
That's me again, my Ovation Balladeer is feeling every one of its twenty odd years of age (from a use point of view) - but carries it with much grace and still sounds beautiful. My much older (and rarer) Tama which I bought new in 1976 remains an awesome beast that took me nearly a decade to play in fully.
Instruments are for playing, not collecting or displaying.
Pete
-
I couldn't buy anything as an investment, I don't work that way - but I think that the Hohner 1-row in G that I bought new for £85.00 (inc p&p) from Hobgoblin in 1982 and still play regularly has been extremely good value for money.
Mike
PS - just spell checked this and it didn't recognise "Hohner" (suggestion: Hornier) and know from past experience that it doesn't know "melodeon" either (suggestion: Meltdown) or "Castagnari" (Geostationary - whatever that is) - is it really fit for purpose on this site ???
-
"Castagnari" (Geostationary - whatever that is)
It means that if you launch your Castagnari from the equator to an altitude of 35,786 km, it will stay there in orbit directly above your head all the time, until you fetch it down again.
For those of us afflicted with MAD and a complaining spouse ("you've not bought another melodeon have you? Just where do you think you are going to keep it?"), geostationary orbits could offer a useful storage location. If there were enough of us here wanting to do this, I suggest we approach NASA to see if they could do a discount deal for us.
If nothing else, it certainly gives the concept of 'music of the spheres' a different meaning.
-
"Just where do you think you are going to keep it?"
You've not got our house bugged, have you? :)
-
Brilliant Mr. Freereader, it's an allegory.
Owain Glynd?r is not 'up in the hills' but in geostationary orbit and will make his reappearance playing an Italian Melodeon.
Just off to the exiles, used to play in the seventeenth fifteen, to spread the good news.
Damn! Forgot about the lack of ws with circumflexes. This time revenge will consist of a London Marathon entry for Theo. :D
-
I don't hold with musical instruments as investments.
Me either, my old Wheatstone Æola is working very hard and will never be an investment or a museum piece!
As a guitarist (first instrument for years)
That's me again, my Ovation Balladeer is feeling every one of its twenty odd years of age (from a use point of view) - but carries it with much grace and still sounds beautiful. My much older (and rarer) Tama which I bought new in 1976 remains an awesome beast that took me nearly a decade to play in fully.
Instruments are for playing, not collecting or displaying.
Pete
My main acoustic is a 00028 Martin Shanendoah which is now 22 years old - my backup is a 25 year old Hullah bought from some poor soull who decided to trade up to a seriously expensive Martin (Heaven knowa why)
My aquisition problem has been several solid, workman-like electrics which have been bought (fairly cheaply) to do niche jobs and then cased thereafter and rarely used. I'd have a clear-out, but the siren voice keeps saying "As soon as you sell it you'll need it again!". Trouble is, it's usually right ;D
-
Given the current credit 'squeeze' ;D would you consider a melodeon a good investment...???
Well I'm 'investing' in one. Bet I'll get more interest aqccumilated than my savings account at the moment. ::)
and I'll play it....hopefully :P
-
I don't hold with musical instruments as investments.
Me either, my old Wheatstone Æola is working very hard and will never be an investment or a museum piece!
As a guitarist (first instrument for years)
That's me again, my Ovation Balladeer is feeling every one of its twenty odd years of age (from a use point of view) - but carries it with much grace and still sounds beautiful. My much older (and rarer) Tama which I bought new in 1976 remains an awesome beast that took me nearly a decade to play in fully.
Instruments are for playing, not collecting or displaying.
Pete
Given that you can only play one instrument at a time, I can recommend displaying them as a pretty good way of enjoying them while not in use.
Just wish the good lady agreed :)
-
Given that you can only play one instrument at a time, I can recommend displaying them as a pretty good way of enjoying them while not in use.
Just wish the good lady agreed
That is a seriously bad idea in my case - as Mrs H doesn't actually have a clue how many boxes I possess at the moment...its amazing how creative I have become in finding hiding places for them! (ah - confession is good for the soul)
-
Given that you can only play one instrument at a time, I can recommend displaying them as a pretty good way of enjoying them while not in use.
Just wish the good lady agreed
That is a seriously bad idea in my case - as Mrs H doesn't actually have a clue how many boxes I possess at the moment...its amazing how creative I have become in finding hiding places for them! (ah - confession is good for the soul)
Large blankets are very handy for hiding stuff (if I'm told to lean my room just just stuff all the mess under a blanket) or pile up creatively and call it modern art. ;)
-
Also consider the cost of the time to play the thing. On the one hand you could be out hustling for more money, on the other hand the satisfaction and mental health benefits of practicing, on the other hand (one more hand and I can play duets) I do lock up the weaponry while I am playing lest my wife do me in!
Bottom line: worth every penny.
Dan
-
I restore concertinas for a hobby - currently I have three 20 button Lachenal Anglos on the go and at various stages - fortunately Mrs H pays no attention to my hobby and therefore believes that its all one great big concertina...
...the collective noun for this must surely be: A Conspiracy of Concertinas!
...AL
-
Mrs H doesn't actually have a clue how many boxes I possess at the moment...its amazing how creative I have become in finding hiding places for them! (ah - confession is good for the soul)
Tell her you have a friend that collects antique cars, and that concertinas and melodeons are not so bad to collect after all!
-
Yes, I'm amazed at how much friends of mine will spend to have a car sit idle in a driveway/garage..still I'd like to have an antique car as well, a big-finned Cadillac from the 50's [think of how many melodeons you could store/hide in the trunk/boot!] but then I do have a couple of completely unrestorable melodeons that I just like to look at [cost of $30 or $40 for a bit of history]...until I win the lottery, I'll stick with melodeons...originally a mass-produced not too hard to learn and inexpensive way of making music, perhaps the IKEA version of musical instruments...looks good, functions well, but you know it will eventually fall apart [although the quality and lifespan of some of the mail order melodeons from 60 to 100 years ago can be amazing]...good investment, no, hours of playing pleasure and money made doing gigs/busking, yes. The high end instruments from Italy and handmade instruments from various locations are a wonderful development in the technologie [wish I could afford one...and I would think that their value would stay the same or increase over time, like Martin Guitars], but maybe the prices are getting too high, and the expectations of virtuosity in professional players are starting to borrow from the realms of classical music, which I don't think the melodeon was invented for...
-
professional players are starting to borrow from the realms of classical music, which I don't think the melodeon was invented for...
I think you're right - the melodeon was invented for simple folk like me ::)
-
I think one nice concertina (http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/emotes/aemo_squeezeyellow.gif) and one nice melodeon :|||: will be good enough for me....when it comes to collecting I have a weakness for shoes. ;)
-
....when it comes to collecting I have a weakness for shoes. ;)
I can't wait to see the emote :D
-
I think one nice concertina (http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/emotes/aemo_squeezeyellow.gif) and one nice melodeon :|||: will be good enough for me....
This is what everyone thinks and then MAD takes hold .
-
I think one nice concertina (http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/emotes/aemo_squeezeyellow.gif) and one nice melodeon :|||: will be good enough for me...
So LDT, what melodeon are you planning on getting? and how long is the wait for your Tedrow concertina? The waiting must be excruciating ;).
Wendy
-
So LDT, what melodeon are you planning on getting?
Well I suppose it will be a pokerwork or a erica...but what I really fancy is a castagnari Lilly (although its a little over my budget). I was also looking at this http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_485/products_id/4258?mrSid=c2cff6ea62193eb5b55d97096f86a2b2 but not actually being able to go try it out puts me off. :(
and how long is the wait for your Tedrow concertina? The waiting must be excruciating ;).
I have no idea how long haven't yet been told when it will be ready or started (only got told it will be started next with some others)....I can't stand all this waiting! :o
-
I have no idea how long I've already been waiting months and months and haven't yet been told when it will be ready or started (only got told it will be started next with some others)....I can't stand all this waiting!
I could make the bellows for you - I use exactly the same method as Bob to make my own sets of bellows - you could just tell Bob to get a move on with the end bits! ;D
AL