Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: aradru on April 29, 2012, 02:35:31 AM
-
.
-
I will leave the advice on spring tension for the experts, but would suggest that copper is a very unlikely material for springs. It will work harden and break very quickly. I would be thinking phosphor bronze, but I don't know how it compares with steel.
I don't think stretching would be the way to go, and trying to compress them, if successful, not much better so personally I would be thinking about looking for alternatives.
I believe there are those here who do make their own springs. It might help if you can describe the size and material of the springs you want to replace, and maybe identify the box.
Cheers
Malcolm
-
On melodeons where different spring strengths are needed for inner and outer rows (to get the actual button pressure the same with different leverage), this is achieved by using different thickness of (steel) spring wire. I'd suggest choosing your wire gauge for spring strength in the same way.
Copper is soft - when you bend it, it stays bent, so it's useless for springs. Maybe phosphor bronze, but steel of the right thickness should be fine.
-
If your box has coil springs then softer springing can be achieved by using springs with on or two more coils.
-
I lighten coil springs by using a screwdriver (I keep one sharpened just for this, but sharpened not necessary) that I push in the coil. Each time you push it in it opens that coil ever so slightly, lightening the tension. I have a keyboard holding jig that I use to hold the key board with the pallets as they would be on the accordion, and a cut out to get to the springs.
-
It's my standard. When I install springs, I install them where they are slightly heavy in tension, then adjust each one to where I want them. I do that because some people like lighter tension and some like heavier. I don't see any problems to come of doing it that way, other than trying to spread them too much. Since you're lightening an existing accordion, you probably won't be going very far with it. If you do it this way, just go very slow until you get the hang of it. Kind of like tuning a reed.
-
I am also interested in any information on how to make your own springs.
Here are some links to spring making. I've used a jig like this one on YouTube to make small tension springs, though I wound them by hand.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQBbGF4-t4s (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQBbGF4-t4s)
Here's a different type of spring, from the Bernard Loffet website:
http://diato.org/trucs/fabr_ressorts/image001.htm (http://diato.org/trucs/fabr_ressorts/image001.htm)
And a much longer article:
http://home.earthlink.net/~bazillion/intro.html (http://home.earthlink.net/~bazillion/intro.html)
I found a supplier of various diameters of spring steel wire, i.e. piano wire, on eBay.
-
I suppose it just softened the tension in the steel. I wouldn't think it's too good a method as once the steel loses temper then the springs might keep stretching.
I've not tried Bryan's sharpened screwdriver method but it sounds good. So far, I've always fitted longer springs if I need to lighten the action.
Emmanuel Pariselle gave me a long length of coil spring that I simply cut off the length of spring required then bend out the two end loops. This is now getting quite short. If anyone knows where to buy this kind of thing please post here.
-
The action was definitely lighter.
I'll see if Charlie sells it in longer lengths.
-
Perhaps Carini? item 30042 MOLLE A SPIRALE BAYAN 0.45 D mm 8.45 X L cm 25
-
Thanks Theo, 8.45mm diameter is too big.
I was in Carini in July and asked them but they didn't have anything suitable, although Emmanuel said that he got his from Carini.
-
I would not want to just stretch the whole spring, it's too hard to control. I've not done this myself, but if I had to I would just bend the end coil away from the body of the spring. The end coil that has been turned through a right angle to form a hook will also need some adjustment to put it back in the correct position.
-
All the earthly springs have been used to anchor the lander to the comet.
-
Thanks Theo, 8.45mm diameter is too big.
Yes I can see that piano/harp wire 8.45mm in diameter with only one turn might produce a spring that was a tad heavy for a trebuchet never mind a melodeon! ;D
-
If you know anyone who had been involved in telecoms maintenance pre electronic era (or keep an eye on ebay) you may be lucky enough to see or even acquire some of the weird and wonderful array of special tools for spring or contact (leaf spring) bending, which at simplest can be made from a bit of wire say 1/8th - 3/16th dia with a slot cut for the spring at one end with a junior hack or piercing saw and bent at 90 degrees at the other end. with a pair of these (or one and a pair of pliers) remote springs can be set or tweaked with precision.
In addition to the adjusting tools, the GPO /BT also equipped their guys with a set of spring force gauges so a prescribed value could be checked or set - these go nicely with one of those fur edged hood garments on another thread :o
-
0.45 D mm 8.45 X L cm 25
0.45 is the diameter of the wire.
8.45 is the diameter of the coil.
25 cm is the length of the coil.