Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on April 29, 2012, 10:10:38 AM

Title: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 29, 2012, 10:10:38 AM
Dear All,
Many years back I used to have a cassette recorder ( remember them? ) and record tunes at a session to learn at a later date.
I still do this now at my local monthly session but use my mobile phone for the odd tune I need a mental trigger for when back at home. It's ok for one or two tunes, but it has a limited memory so wouldn't be suitable for anything more than the odd tune.

For the first time in years I'll be at a couple of festivals this summer and not dancing, so it's likely I'll end up sitting in a pub playing, or wondering what that lovely tune is that's just been played.
What do people use to grab tunes at sessions now - a modern equivalent of a cassette recorder?
cheers
Q
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: pbsalt on April 29, 2012, 10:32:27 AM
I now use a Zoom H2 Digital recorder. ( Theres a fairly lengthy discussion thread elsewhere on melnet if you search). Some people find them a bit slow to respond but I'm happy with it. The sound quality is excellent ( compared with the days when I recorded on a dictaphone).
A couple of 4GB memory cards, and a 2GB memory card gets me through Whitby week and  recharging the batteries every night getsthrough a days worth of recordings.   
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Mike Hirst on April 29, 2012, 10:40:43 AM
paper and pencil beermat and borrowed pen  :|glug
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Lester on April 29, 2012, 11:01:12 AM
Whilst I agree that a Zoom is a v good device, I have one and use it regularly, for sessions I use the predecessor of this

Olympus VN-8500 PC Digital Voice Recorder (http://www.tesco.com/direct/olympus-vn-8500-pc-digital-voice-recorder/211-5101.prd?skuId=211-5101&pageLevel=&sc_cmp=pcp_GSF__211-5101)

Not as good quality as the Zoom but v long battery life, v long recording, good enough quality to learn tunes from and much smaller and easier to use and only £44.96 from Tesco with Clubcard points as well  ;) .
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 29, 2012, 11:26:50 AM
Morning all!
Mike.....  ;D yes, well.... if I use my beer mat, how do I stop the dribbles from running over the table?

The Zoom sounds good, but might be a bit overkill for my use and pocket. I don't often feel the need to always record at my local sessions. Mind you, briefly flicking throught the reviews it seems to have a variety of uses including 'proper' recording of tunes. Might have more applications other than simple grabs at sessions, hadn't thought of that.

The Olympus sounds good, possibly more what I'm after. Will take a look.

Thanks, some information to browse online whilst this appalling weather down here blows over.
Might light the fire in a mintue  :-\
cheers
Q


Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Steve Somerfield on April 29, 2012, 11:59:36 AM
Something that I've used successfully for classroom music recordings is a minidisc walkman recorder. A bit old school I know but they are easy to pick up either on fleabay or at your local carboot - obviously will need a mike too, but the results are good.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 29, 2012, 12:33:46 PM
OK Steve..... another thought, though I think I like the idea of working in mp3 and directly dropping onto the pc.

Had another thought whilst laying up the fire - Mike has made a good point that went over my head when I replied.
With the plethora of good tune books now available, and on-line tune sources, in many ways a quick note of title might well be sufficient. Enabling you to check through later when back at home. Mind you, there's nothing like referring back to how it was actually played and how it sounded........
Q
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Anahata on April 29, 2012, 12:35:07 PM
Cheapest and entirely up to the job of capturing tunes in sessions is a voice recorder with option to record MP3 at higher than voice quality bit rates. 128k or more is preferable. Monophonic recording but that's no problem for this purpose.

The Zoom H1 and H2 are fine for the job, and possibly give better quality sound, also they record in stereo (of a sort: the mics are a bit close and not very directional so separation is limited, but it does sound like stereo) Olympus and others make comparable devices - they are quite similar.

I use an Edirol R-09 which I bought  because it was cheaper than the Zoom H4 and before the Zoom H2 came on the market. With a 1GB card I can get 7 hours of recording at 320K mp3, except I think the batteries would run out before I got to the end of that.

Minidisc was fine in its time; I still have a Sony MZ-R30 but never use it now.
- It needs an external mic.
- I can't copy WAV or MP3 files from it to computer.
- Limited recording time.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Chris Brimley on April 29, 2012, 12:43:49 PM
I still use my Zoom H2 all the time, and have now recorded hundreds of songs and tunes for rehearsal purposes, trimming the results with the free Goldwave software for circulating to other band members.  One could carp about a few of its design aspects, but it is just so handy, quick and easy, high quality, (and yes, cheap) for what it is.

I usually record with low cut on, rec mode mp3 192kbps, agc/comp off, and on 2-channel rather than 4.  That way, I generally end up with a file of 3-4MB size, of very good quality. This means that if you record two or three pieces during an evening's rehearsal, you can email them all off together to your chums after processing, within the 10,15, or 20MB limit on attached data transfer.  Putting low cut on and agc/comp off is useful to cut out the huge peaks you get from nearby enthusiastic clapping, which overload the recorder or make it slightly more tricky to maximise the volume in GoldWave.  You soon get to judge the right recording gain settings manually.

Also, a plug for GoldWave - their latest update v5.67 seems to have speeded it up noticeably, and I understand they've cured a data handling glitch.  This means that the time taken to load a file is a few seconds only on my PC.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: ladydetemps on April 29, 2012, 01:21:37 PM
my digital camera has record audio only option which is quite good. I also in emergency will use my phone to record sound.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Rob2Hook on April 29, 2012, 01:32:39 PM
One problem of recording in sessions is trying to avoid only getting your own stumbling attempts at picking up the tune!  I remember Ed Rennie sitting in a session with the recorder on the table in front of him, using a lapel mic (on a croc clip) clipped to the curtains as high as possible.  In between tunes though he had to stand up and whisper the titles into the curtains!

Rob.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 29, 2012, 02:49:37 PM
Hmmm.... I think I need to go read up on these devices and decide exactly what I want or need, especially if the recording quality allows for other things.

LdT: yep, mine does but lugging a SLR around isn't very subtle, plus the 'oh dear I've knocked my beer over your camera' option isn't nice to think about!

Rob: Yep, even had that problem on my old trusty cassette!
Half way through a good tune and someone knocks the table, which on playback resembles thunder, or leans over for a chat cos they don't know the tune either!
Real life recording can be irritating  :D

As for Ed, well, we all have out little secrets  ;D
Q
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: ladydetemps on April 29, 2012, 03:12:27 PM
Mine isn't a SLR its a cheap(in comparison) casio camera. It takes pretty good vids too. Although I wish it had better zoom.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 29, 2012, 04:40:44 PM
LdT: I must admit, I think one of my girls might have a compact not being used as opposed to lumping my gurt thing around.
Tis a reasonable thought that!
I haven't really got my head around recording with such things as cameras, I rely on a webcam for those odd moments when I think i can play and record something for TOTM, but perhaps I'll have another look. Being somewhat neolithic, I tend to use cameras for taking stills, forgetting they are far more versatile nowadays than my original pin holed Box Brownie.
Thanks for the thought.
Q
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Marje on April 29, 2012, 06:26:44 PM
I have an MP3 player with voice record function and have used this sometimes to record at sessions. One advantage is that it's very small and discreet and people don't get distracted by it (as long as I conceal the little flashing light on one end of it). I can upload the tracks to my computer if I want to, and if I were not such a techno-numpty I could probably edit them to remove the woffle, chatter and general crack (which takes up a surprising amount of session time when you play it back).
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Chris Brimley on April 29, 2012, 06:43:13 PM
Marje, if you haven't tried anything like Goldwave, have a go, it really is a doddle.  You can download it here: http://www.goldwave.com/release.php.

Then plug the recorder into the computer with a USB lead, and move the file into your computer, or maybe leave it on the recorder.  Open the file up in Goldwave, and it displays each channel.  If you move the start and stop points about, and then 'delete' or 'trim', it will cut out the bits you don't want.  You can add reverb effects if you want (there's easy presets), and then it's a good idea to 'maximise' the level, and save it somewhere.  There's lots of more complicated stuff, but that will allow you to do the basics you'll usually want to do.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on April 29, 2012, 06:47:50 PM
Audacity does the same thing and it's free software (as in freedom of speech) and gratis.

http://audacity.sourceforge.net/
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Chris Brimley on April 29, 2012, 06:57:06 PM
That's strange, Andrew, my version of Goldwave was also free, but I notice from that link that they do seem to be charging people now.  I've no idea how I managed to get mine accepted as free!  Anyway, I agree with you that there's no need to pay anything - I think Audacity does much the same things. 
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 29, 2012, 07:28:48 PM
I have Audacity but am reluctant to use it.
I had a part share in a usb turntable, when it was my turn to convert lp's to mp3's it killed my video card  >:(
Sort of puts you off...... but I'll have to bite the bullet and have another go sometime. Chris's  described abilites to chop and edit are worth having.

I tend to sit in front of my pc and web cam me playing on rare occasions. Having a simpler thing might mean I'm more self aware and critical if I record and playback tunes.
Q
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on April 29, 2012, 11:08:38 PM
I have Audacity but am reluctant to use it.
I had a part share in a usb turntable, when it was my turn to convert lp's to mp3's it killed my video card  >:(
Sort of puts you off...... but I'll have to bite the bullet and have another go sometime. Chris's  described abilites to chop and edit are worth having.

I tend to sit in front of my pc and web cam me playing on rare occasions. Having a simpler thing might mean I'm more self aware and critical if I record and playback tunes.
Q

How could it possibly "kill your video card"??

Audacity does not directly interact with your video or audio card. This is done by your operating system kernel with drivers. Same as every other programme on your computer.

It's just a sad coincidence.

-
edited to add: Sorry, didn't mean to seem censorious, but people do get some odd notions sometimes.

edited again: Yes, i know that some Windows programmes muck around with drivers and stuff ... however, Audacity is not one of them. Full stop.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Anahata on April 29, 2012, 11:23:19 PM
I have an MP3 player with voice record function and have used this sometimes to record at sessions. One advantage is that it's very small and discreet and people don't get distracted by it (as long as I conceal the little flashing light on one end of it). I can upload the tracks to my computer if I want to, and if I were not such a techno-numpty I could probably edit them to remove the woffle, chatter and general crack (which takes up a surprising amount of session time when you play it back).

If I take my Edirol to a session, I leave it on the table somewhere in the middle, not too close to me, and leave it recording the whole session. It has an option to make the bright red recording light  go off a few seconds after recording has started, and this combined with the fact that I don't touch it during the session makes it less distracting and easy to ignore.

It's actually easier to find the separate tunes in one big file with Audacity and save each as an appropriately named file than to record each tunes as a separate file in the first place, which then still have to be played back and renamed.

And Andrew's right - Audacity is harmless. It has some limitations as a sound editor, but what it can do, it does very well.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Malcolm on April 30, 2012, 06:32:55 AM
I have one of these http://www.amazon.co.uk/Portable-Handheld-Audio-Recorder-format/dp/B004OA6JW0/ref=sr_1_sc_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1335763803&sr=8-1-spell (http://www.amazon.co.uk/Portable-Handheld-Audio-Recorder-format/dp/B004OA6JW0/ref=sr_1_sc_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1335763803&sr=8-1-spell) that might be worth a look.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 30, 2012, 06:53:34 AM
I had a Zoom for a month or so. The build was very plasticky and it took a seeming age both to boot up, and post process or whatever it does when you press stop.

Chap next to me showed my his Olympus, which had cost about 50% more, but was twice as good. Boots in seconds, and start/record/stop is instant.  So I took the plunge. Guess I could have sent the mail order Zoom back,  but instead gave it to Dolly May who records choirs and isn't a 'tune grabber'.  It's fine in that mode and we are both happy.

Anahata's tip to record the whole session and sort it later sounds good too, an would possibly have kept me with the original kit, but the Olympus also "feels" so good, don't regret it.  :|glug
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Eoin Mac on April 30, 2012, 07:31:50 AM
I use a Yamaha Pocketrack C24 and been pleased with the results. Its very compact and easy to use and there are a number of reviews on Youtube. (:)
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Chris Brimley on April 30, 2012, 10:50:18 AM
Quote
and it took a seeming age both to boot up, and post process or whatever it does when you press stop.

When you first turn on the power the Zoom H2 seems to take 9 seconds to be ready to start recording, but once it's on, it's virtually instantaneous to start recording.  When you press stop it seems to take 4 seconds to return to the state where you can start to record again, and as far as I can tell that doesn't seem to relate to the length of the recording.

I have to say I've heard this criticism of the Zoom before, but have never found it to be a practical limitation.  Also it is pretty robust.  You get a protective cover with it, but I've never bothered using it.  The little plastic tripod is great, you just plonk it on a table pointing in whatever direction you want, and it doesn't fall over easily.  And the microphones and recording quality in microphone mode are exceptionally good.

The only minor niggles I've got with it are these:  The screen has a back light which comes on to help you in a dark environment when you put it in recording standby.  Unfortunately it goes off after a few seconds to save battery, so if I wanted to start the actual recording later, I can't check that it's done so without putting on my glasses and peering at the LED screen in the gloom.  And second, if I haven't recharged the batteries recently (which actually I now always do), and I try to record a long session, and the batteries run out, I will lose the whole of that recording (though not any previous ones).  Hence for me Anahata's advice would be good with knowingly recharged batteries only.

The more important issue is that there seems to be a problem with direct 'line in' recording.  I can't get the levels to match without doistortion - possibly it needs some sort of attenuator.  But I never use it this way anyway.

Just a point with the 'record the whole session' advice, which would apply to any recorder.  I do that too, but if you've got a long recording at high quality, say using four channels, that's quite lot of data.  When you come to edit out specific songs, it's best to 'cut and paste' or 'copy and paste' into a new file.  If instead you copy the whole lot several times into different files, and then trim down each one to preserve the bit you want, you'll still have kept all the deleted data, because the software doesn't know whether you will want to undo your command.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Anahata on April 30, 2012, 11:24:20 AM
The screen has a back light which comes on to help you in a dark environment when you put it in recording standby.  Unfortunately it goes off after a few seconds to save battery, so if I wanted to start the actual recording later, I can't check that it's done so without putting on my glasses and peering at the LED screen in the gloom.
The Edirol R-09 dims the backlight but doesn't turn it off, which is a reasonable compromise.

Quote
And second, if I haven't recharged the batteries recently (which actually I now always do), and I try to record a long session, and the batteries run out, I will lose the whole of that recording
I've mentioned this before, but it is well worth the slight extra expense to get "low self discharge" NiMH rechargeables. Typically marketed as "supplied ready charged" they are spectacularly better at holding their charge, with a claimed 80% of full charge retained if left on the shelf for a year - in practice, it means I can charge them up after use, pick up the Edirol a month later and it's ready to go.

Quote
The more important issue is that there seems to be a problem with direct 'line in' recording.
No problem here. I have a potential live recording setup using a DAV mic preamp and I had to make an attenuator for the Edirol's line in, but that's because the DAV puts out frighteningly high levels (15 volts peak) and I wouldn't expect the Edirol to take that. I've hooked it to the "tape out" on a consumer amp without any problems.

Quote
When you come to edit out specific songs, it's best to 'cut and paste' or 'copy and paste' into a new file.  If instead you copy the whole lot several times into different files, and then trim down each one to preserve the bit you want, you'll still have kept all the deleted data
With Audacity, that is the obvious way anyway. Load the whole session, mark a section with the mouse, then select File->export selection, choose a file and it's done! Repeat select+export per tune.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Chris Brimley on April 30, 2012, 12:05:42 PM
Quote
Quote
And second, if I haven't recharged the batteries recently (which actually I now always do), and I try to record a long session, and the batteries run out, I will lose the whole of that recording

I've mentioned this before, but it is well worth the slight extra expense to get "low self discharge" NiMH rechargeables. Typically marketed as "supplied ready charged" they are spectacularly better at holding their charge, with a claimed 80% of full charge retained if left on the shelf for a year - in practice, it means I can charge them up after use, pick up the Edirol a month later and it's ready to go.

Ah yes, Anahata, me too - I wasn't referring to self-discharge issues, which I don't find either with my NiMH, just previous use!
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 30, 2012, 05:50:05 PM
Andrew: As you say, my linking Audacity with likking my video card makes no sense, excpet that it happend at the same time. Coincidence I'm sure, it just wrankled!

Having a bit of a busy time, but checking in here, and finding it a quite interesting discussion. I hadn't realised it had gone on so far from me and my cassette!
Q

Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Lyn on May 03, 2012, 10:43:29 AM
I'm pretty well on the back foot with anything technical, even reading the instruction books sometimes leaves me totally at sea. However, the ZOOM is very easy to use - even by me! And as Chris says, while it might take a while to boot up once it's on in recording mode, you just click and it records, click and it stops. Easy peasy . Why I like it is the quality (in purely layman's terms) is very good in comaprison with all the other gadgets I've tried to use in the past.

That's my view for what its worth....not very much from the techie point of view, but to show even the technologically-impaired can cope with it!
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 07, 2012, 05:02:37 PM
Hi,
After an unusually busy week, I'm finally catching up and trying to think about what's been said here, and thanks for to those who've chipped in.
I think for a simple 'tune grab' something like Lester's Olympus sounds about right, and at a good price too.
I've also looked at the Zoom, Edirol and more music based recorders in the Olympus range. At the same time trying to work out  what having a better quality recorder would mean. The technical stuff is unknown to me, but I take Anahat's point that you need higher quality recording for music than for voice.
I don't need to send tunes around a band for rehursal, but could be interested in recording me as a learning tool, monitoring progress and those 'what do I really sound like' moments.

Thinking aloud - Presumably, a music recorder would allow you to record your tunes onto the sound only things like onmvoice, soundcloud or whatever giving a good recording quality?
....but to simply record me playing, or grabbing a tune at a session, a voice recorder would do the same except just not at a high level of quality?
Q in thought mode.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Mcgrooger on May 07, 2012, 05:10:33 PM
Thinking aloud - Presumably, a music recorder would allow you to record your tunes onto the sound only things like onmvoice, soundcloud or whatever giving a good recording quality?
....but to simply record me playing, or grabbing a tune at a session, a voice recorder would do the same except just not at a high level of quality?
Q in thought mode.

It would indeed allow you record tunes giving a good quality to use in whatever way you like.  I use my Olympus LS10 for my TOTMs to create a 'soundtrack' for YouTube vids, practising tunes, recording our band etc.etc.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 07, 2012, 06:32:30 PM
Hmmmm .... so how do you put the 'soundtrack' and video together?
( being vastly experienced, after 2 ToTM efforts  ;)  I've just used my webcam and transferred that onto Youtube. )Not sure how you'd mate the two......

off to  :M now but will read later with interest!
Q
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Mcgrooger on May 07, 2012, 07:17:18 PM
I use Windows Live Movie Maker. Sandy Flett and I had a brief chat about this on Recordings and Videos in this recent thread: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9382.0.html
The first time I put together a video for YouTube and mixed in the sound it took me most of a day. After a bit of trial and error it now takes a few minutes to get a piece together using WLMM.
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Howard Jones on May 08, 2012, 09:00:33 AM
Quote
Just a point with the 'record the whole session' advice, which would apply to any recorder.  I do that too, but if you've got a long recording at high quality, say using four channels, that's quite lot of data. 

When I record sessions it's usually for the purpose of capturing new tunes, which otherwise are immediately driven out of my mind as soon as the next set starts up.  I'm usually quite happy to record at low quality (which is still quite good) in return for being able to record for a longer period.  I find it's better to record everything and cut out the chatter afterwards, otherwise it's easy to miss the first few bars when a new tune starts up.

If you want to record the session for it's own sake at high quality then you are going to have memory problems.  However, to justify using high quality and all the channels you should probably also be using separate mics suitably positioned, and perhaps a separate mixer.  If you're recording it for a specific purpose eg for a CD then it's perhaps even more important not to miss the start of tunes, so perhaps it's worth investing in an extra memory card.  If it's just for your own pleasure, do you really need CD quality?
Title: Re: Recording tunes at sessions?
Post by: Chris Brimley on May 08, 2012, 10:04:39 AM
Yes, I've not found any practical problem with lack of memory with the Zoom, even at high quality settings (indeed it works well as a portable data storage device for photos, say) - my point was that it's quite a good idea for various reasons to split long recordings of sessions into sections, because this makes it quicker and easier when you come to edit later, and it means you won't lose the whole lot in the unlikely event of a battery failure or dropping it on the floor and dislodging the batteries.  It takes less than 10 seconds to pick up the recorder, stop the recording, start another, and plonk it (quietly) back on the table.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal