Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on May 08, 2012, 07:57:00 AM

Title: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 08, 2012, 07:57:00 AM
Ok I've been playing for nearly a year now.  As well as time spent on here I've also spent many a happy hour listening to various boxes and box players on You Tube. I started, like most people, with a DG Erica, quickly picked up a lower pitched GC Erica and after 6 months also bought a Saltarelle Connemara 3. All lovely boxes in their way but it strikes me that the sound I really like is the Andy Cutting Mory or Anahata's Dino/Oakwood Super. These seem to have what I would describe (in my ignorance) as an almost soft, harmonica-ish sound which sounds great played quietly but also cuts through when needed with superb clarity. Also really like the Saltarelle L'Elfique which seems to have a similar quality.  I know this is completely subjective and there will be loads of you who have different boxes that you swear by (at?) but it would very interesting to hear what other people aspire to owning.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Theo on May 08, 2012, 08:11:13 AM
A couple of things:

The Castagnari Mory "sound"  is actually very varied.  In about 1999 I had exactly the same thought and ordered a new Mory, it was disappointing from the moment it arrived, and other players I know who bought new Morys at that time had a similar experience.  There was something about the way they were made at that time that produced thin sounding boxes that are hard work to play.   I've since been fortunate enough to be able to buy a Mory that would have been built in the late 80s and it is a complete delight to play.  So there can be big differences between individual examples, even with Castagnari.

These seem to have what I would describe (in my ignorance) as an almost soft, harmonica-ish sound which sounds great played quietly but also cuts through when needed with superb clarity.
In the case of the Mory that quality comes from two additional factors (1) superbly accurate and crisp playing, and in (2)the case of Mr C, playing an LMM box in the top octave.
And in the case of the Mory it is a very much bigger and heavier box (which is a lot to do with how it sounds) but also requires a different playing technique if you don't want to get stress related problems in your arms and wrists.
Quote
Also really like the Saltarelle L'Elfique which seems to have a similar quality.  I know this is completely subjective and there will be loads of you who have different boxes that you swear by (at?) but it would very interesting to hear what other people aspire to owning.

To my ear the Elfique has a completely different sound, and much more typical of a Saltarelle, brighter and more brassy than a Castagnari.


Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 08, 2012, 08:28:15 AM
A couple of things:

The Castagnari Mory "sound"  is actually very varied.  In about 1999 I had exactly the same thought and ordered a new Mory, it was disappointing from the moment it arrived, and other players I know who bought new Morys at that time had a similar experience.  There was something about the way they were made at that time that produced thin sounding boxes that are hard work to play.   I've since been fortunate enough to be able to buy a Mory that would have been built in the late 80s and it is a complete delight to play.  So there can be big differences between individual examples, even with Castagnari.

These seem to have what I would describe (in my ignorance) as an almost soft, harmonica-ish sound which sounds great played quietly but also cuts through when needed with superb clarity.
In the case of the Mory that quality comes from two additional factors (1) superbly accurate and crisp playing, and in (2)the case of Mr C, playing an LMM box in the top octave.
And in the case of the Mory it is a very much bigger and heavier box (which is a lot to do with how it sounds) but also requires a different playing technique if you don't want to get stress related problems in your arms and wrists.
Quote
Also really like the Saltarelle L'Elfique which seems to have a similar quality.  I know this is completely subjective and there will be loads of you who have different boxes that you swear by (at?) but it would very interesting to hear what other people aspire to owning.

To my ear the Elfique has a completely different sound, and much more typical of a Saltarelle, brighter and more brassy than a Castagnari.

Thanks Theo. Just had another listen to the Elfique and yes, I see what you mean.  Lester had a similar experience with a Mory I believe.  It's so weird, this time last year I couldn't have even told you what a melodeon was.  I then stumbled upon Jimmy Shand's video of The Bluebell Polka and I was hooked. First of all I was really into that wet Morino sound and I guess over time my taste has got drier!
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Lester on May 08, 2012, 08:29:23 AM
Really just backing up what Theo said. The Mory is a very heavy box which is the main reason I sold mine, mind you it was a Friday afternoon box and the build quality was not that good, fortunately Hobgoblin were able to improve it but not what you expect from what was a v expensive box..

And the L'Elfique has a very different sound to a Castagnari. I am a big fan of the Saltarelle raspy almost hurdy gurdy sound but not to everyone's taste.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 08, 2012, 09:50:10 AM
These seem to have what I would describe (in my ignorance) as an almost soft, harmonica-ish sound which sounds great played quietly but also cuts through when needed with superb clarity.
Have you ever listened to a 3-voice (LMM) Giustozzi with Binci hand-made reeds?

No but could you point me to a video/audio file please?  Sounds interesting!
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 08, 2012, 10:11:44 AM
I've got a simple "swing" M+M tuning on the Oakwood - had yet another complement on it's tone this weekend  (:). 

When I bought a Gaillard, he offered the same, but I purposefully had it in L+M bandoneon tuning "to have a different sound". I'm still glad I did that.

As I suffer from "MAD" a 3 voicer has been commissioned from Frans v.d Aa. It will have both combos available on a session friendly D/G. I've already been offered a completely stupid sum for the Oakwood!

Theo - you've just tuned up the Oakwood (thanks) - why is it's sound so agreeable?
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 08, 2012, 10:14:17 AM
I've got a simple "swing" M+M tuning on the Oakwood - had yet another complement on it's tone this weekend  (:). 

When I bought a Gaillard, he offered the same, but I purposefully had it in L+M bandoneon tuning "to have a different sound". I'm still glad I did that.

As I suffer from "MAD" a 3 voicer has been commissioned from Frans v.d Aa. It will have both combos available on a session friendly D/G. I've already been offered a completely stupid sum for the Oakwood!
It would be nice to hear your Oakwood.  Do you have anything that you could post for us?
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Mcgrooger on May 08, 2012, 10:21:50 AM
I think that one of the main factors in which box sounds best is what type of music you're playing on it. The Mory's an awfully big beast and is very versatile but I wouldn't want to play one all night at a gig. Fine for sensitive playing especially music with complex harmonies but hard to get the bounce for a jaunty English polka or morris tune. On the Saltarelle/Castagnari front, I have a bit of a feeling that it's a bit like Windows vs Apple or Fender vs Gibson. In the end, you sort of feel you belong in one camp as opposed to the other.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Mcgrooger on May 08, 2012, 10:23:29 AM
Yay - I've just become a 'respected sage'.;D 8)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Theo on May 08, 2012, 10:32:18 AM
I've got a simple "swing" M+M tuning on the Oakwood - had yet another complement on it's tone this weekend  (:). 

<snip>
Theo - you've just tuned up the Oakwood (thanks) - why is it's sound so agreeable?

Swing tuning (in the sense of a very slow beat 1.5bps or less) is I think the hardest tuning to get right. It requires a combination of pitching the reeds within a very close tolerance and also listening very carefully and training the ear to focus on the fundamental beat, then making very tiny changes to get the sound consistent across the range. I find it impossible to get right by just setting each reed of a a pair to the theoretically correct pitches. Because of the way the pitch changes with playing pressure the only way I can get it to sound right is by paying close attention to the sound of the two reeds playing together and inside the box.  There also has to be some fudges to the tuning of the lower pitches or they sound too wet, and the whole thing is sensitive to things like the tightness of the reedblock clamping.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Pete Jackson on May 08, 2012, 11:41:33 AM
I have a Mory which I am very pleased with and which gets compliments for tone etc.. When I first got it though I did wonder how I was ever going to manage the size and weight but it is surprising how quickly you do get used to it. Mind I always (or nearly) play sitting which makes a difference. One of the beauties of the instrument is the 1/2 row containing accidentals and reversals which are so much easier placed than on the end of the rows - I think this makes a big difference to how the instruments can be played, giving choices between bounce and and fluidity and therefore on the sound and style. In other words think about layout and what you want to play as well as the tone of the box - in my opinion it matters and doesn't take too much to get used to using the 1/2 row.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 08, 2012, 12:20:09 PM
Yay - I've just become a 'respected sage'.;D 8)

Steve I've always respected you!!! ;) ;) ;)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: IanD on May 08, 2012, 01:28:42 PM
I have a Mory which I am very pleased with and which gets compliments for tone etc.. When I first got it though I did wonder how I was ever going to manage the size and weight but it is surprising how quickly you do get used to it. Mind I always (or nearly) play sitting which makes a difference. One of the beauties of the instrument is the 1/2 row containing accidentals and reversals which are so much easier placed than on the end of the rows - I think this makes a big difference to how the instruments can be played, giving choices between bounce and and fluidity and therefore on the sound and style. In other words think about layout and what you want to play as well as the tone of the box - in my opinion it matters and doesn't take too much to get used to using the 1/2 row.
The 1/2 row isn't the issue (there are plently of smaller lighter 2 1/2 row boxes), the size and weight are. Yes you can "get used to" it, if by that you mean adapting your playing style to deal with it -- of course if you play across the rows to start off with this might not be needed. But no amount of right-hand dexterity can make up for the sheer mass of a Mory if you want to keep that bouncy English style with lots of up-and-down-the-rows and little or no row-crossing, and I do ;-)

I guess it's a difference in attitude towards how to play -- the more "English" style (what I do) stays mostly on one row and uses row-crossing only when necessary because either the notes aren't there or the basses don't fit otherwise, and positively prefers the punchy sound reduslting from all the bellows direction changes. The more "continental" style crosses rows much more often to avoid bellows reversals and get a more fluid sound with continuo chords, and uses push-pull only where necessary because note runs aren't possible in one direction -- the preference is to use cross-fingering instead of bellows reversals.

Of course there's a continuum of styles between the two extremes, but the essential difference is whether to avoid row-crossing where possible or prefer it.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Ollie on May 08, 2012, 05:29:18 PM

And the L'Elfique has a very different sound to a Castagnari. I am a big fan of the Saltarelle raspy almost hurdy gurdy sound but not to everyone's taste.

It's funny how things sound different to different people... I'd definitely say the Saltarelle sound was more rounded than a Castagnari, but I find raspy and almost gurdy-like.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Lester on May 08, 2012, 05:36:40 PM
On mature reflection I don't understand why you are still looking for the perfect sound when you already own two Hohners?    (:)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Chris Brimley on May 08, 2012, 05:48:31 PM
The button accordion particularly (and music generally) is at heart diverse.  Perfection is chimera, and no attempt to find it will ever succeed, IMO.  All you can do is to follow what you like, from time to time.  (Crosses fingers!)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: waldoB on May 08, 2012, 06:02:01 PM
That's why there's a Buy & Sell section
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 08, 2012, 06:03:58 PM
On mature reflection I don't understand why you are still looking for the perfect sound when you already own two Hohners?    (:)

Lester - you know that I'm the most immature 59 year old on here!!  Some people never grow up.  I'm still like a small child waiting for his next toy!!
Maybe our long suffering wives/husbands/partners should have their own forum.  Melodeon Widows.Net?  Any other suggestions for a name? ;) ;) ;) ;D
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Spikey on May 08, 2012, 08:09:00 PM
Maybe our long suffering wives/husbands/partners should have their own forum.  Melodeon Widows.Net?  Any other suggestions for a name? ;) ;) ;) ;D
For mine it would be AreYouStillPracticisingThatSameBl**dyTune.net ::)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 08, 2012, 08:12:13 PM
Maybe our long suffering wives/husbands/partners should have their own forum.  Melodeon Widows.Net?  Any other suggestions for a name? ;) ;) ;) ;D
For mine it would be AreYouStillPracticisingThatSameBl**dyTune.net ::)

Well said Spikey.  Mine would actually be ILoveItWhenYouPlayTheGuitar.net
 ;) ;) ;)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Spikey on May 08, 2012, 10:31:48 PM
And to go back to your original question (:)...I think I have been travelling in the opposite direction to you, Les, starting off at the slightly melancholic Andy C sound (my Morgane was the closest I could stretch to!), and now finding myself drawn to the more traditional morris sound - so today I would aspire to owning a really nice D/G Pokerwork...though if you asked me tomorrow I might have changed my mind again ::).
Have promised myself (and my better half) I will try and fix up my Pressed Wood first before I am allowed to buy another too - better get on with it!
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: oggiesnr on May 08, 2012, 11:00:37 PM
The problem I have is that the perfect sound changes depending what I'm playing.  For French music, blues and off the wall I've found it with my Loffet. However if I play for dancing then I want the grunt of the Black Pearl and for noodling a really wet Hohner seems to fit the bill.

There are time when I hanker after a really full cajun style sound but I keep sitting on my wallet  (:)

I've found the flip of side of searching for the perfect sound is that expensive boxes also tend to be lightning fast and show up every flaw in my technique (as well as being too loud to hide in the background).  For the moment I'll stick.

Steve
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 09, 2012, 07:01:07 AM
I'm afraid that's the case for anyone with eclectic tastes in music, and underpinned my own decision to have two boxes that voice very differently. The Gaillard incidentally "loves da Blues" as in solo L mode the low notes are like chocolate, and the mid/upper ones will bend.  8)

That was part of the plan, but it ain't a cheap journey. I'd love a Cajun sound too, but it only seems to come with single row and 4 voices.  Just don't play Cajun that much ..
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Howard Jones on May 09, 2012, 09:00:09 AM
The problem I have is that the perfect sound changes depending what I'm playing.  For French music, blues and off the wall I've found it with my Loffet. However if I play for dancing then I want the grunt of the Black Pearl and for noodling a really wet Hohner seems to fit the bill.

One of the things I like about my Salterelle Nuage is the degree of control it gives me over the sound.  It has LMM reeds with individual stops so I can have any combination.  On the left hand it has stops to take out the thirds and low notes.  Different tunes seem to call for different combinations.  I find it a bit surprising that so few other models seem to offer this level of choice.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: oggiesnr on May 09, 2012, 10:02:53 AM
The problem I have is that the perfect sound changes depending what I'm playing.  For French music, blues and off the wall I've found it with my Loffet. However if I play for dancing then I want the grunt of the Black Pearl and for noodling a really wet Hohner seems to fit the bill.

One of the things I like about my Salterelle Nuage is the degree of control it gives me over the sound.  It has LMM reeds with individual stops so I can have any combination.  On the left hand it has stops to take out the thirds and low notes.  Different tunes seem to call for different combinations.  I find it a bit surprising that so few other models seem to offer this level of choice.

My Loffet has all the same options but is tuned very dry (which I really like for the music I play on it).  Even with those choices I still can't get the sound palettes that my other melodeons offer.

Steve
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Peter Savage on May 09, 2012, 12:11:40 PM
Very interesting thread. 

I started on an Erica (B/C) but just couldn't stand the sound of the thing, even after I had it re-tuned dry.  I quickly switched to a Castagnari Ilary (B/C) and suddenly I was in love with playing.  I was producing a sound that was like the players I listened to and respected (Andy Cutting, Julian Sutton etc.). Unfortunately I then realised that the music I was playing worked so much better on a D/G, so I sold my Ilary and borrowed a Castagnari Studio (D/G) which I am still playing today.  The studio is a reasonable sounding instrument for the price but not a patch on sound of the Ilary.

Like Daddy Long Les, I'm still looking for that perfect sound and this quest is the main reason I still have not purchased a D/G of my own.  I want a D/G that essentially sounds and feels like my old Ilary, smooth and responsive.  I generally play cross-rowed as much as possible to limit bellow changes; so very much not in the morris style.  I'd also therefore definitely use the accidentals and the additional basses offered by a larger box.

I think the sound I am looking for is the same as Daddy Long Les so I'm very interested to hear the suggestions coming in regarding that. 
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: sticky fingers on May 09, 2012, 05:34:28 PM
Just ordered a bespoke layout Giustozzi Mod 118/A, LMM with hand made Binci's, should be ready by late Sept, tuned dry,dry,dry, o'h and a bit dryer still!, good luck sf.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Theo on May 09, 2012, 05:49:26 PM
Just ordered a bespoke layout Giustozzi Mod 118/A, LMM with hand made Binci's, should be ready by late Sept, tuned dry,dry,dry, o'h and a bit dryer still!, good luck sf.

[pedant warning]
you can't have degrees of dryness, if its dry the reeds are in unison, anything else is not dry,
[end pedant warning]
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: waltzman on May 09, 2012, 06:17:31 PM
only a single reed can be perfectly dry.  >:E
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Lester on May 09, 2012, 06:22:56 PM
Just ordered a bespoke layout Giustozzi Mod 118/A, LMM with hand made Binci's, should be ready by late Sept, tuned dry,dry,dry, o'h and a bit dryer still!, good luck sf.

[pedant warning]
you can't have degrees of dryness, if its dry the reeds are in unison, anything else is not dry,
[end pedant warning]

If something is wet and you leave it in the sun it will become dryer, therefore there must be degrees of dryness between wet and dry.   And therefore degrees of wetness between dry and Hohner. >:E
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Tom on May 09, 2012, 07:01:09 PM

Quote

If something is wet and you leave it in the sun it will become dryer, therefore there must be degrees of dryness between wet and dry.   And therefore degrees of wetness between dry and Hohner. >:E

So..... Are you suggesting I should dunk the Pokerwork in a water butt? Or suggesting that's already happened???  :|glug
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: AirTime on May 09, 2012, 07:32:28 PM
Not having access to a wide variety of boxes, I'm forced to judge sound quality through the resource offered by Youtube. However, it's hard to draw meaningful conclusions when there are so many different factors involved: the box itself, the tuning of the box, the tune, the player, the set-up of the recording. Any & all of these can make a big difference to how the sound quality of the box is perceived.

It would be really interesting if there was a thread that attempted to illustrate, as clearly as possible, the different sounds of a variety of boxes

Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Lester on May 09, 2012, 07:36:02 PM

Quote

If something is wet and you leave it in the sun it will become dryer, therefore there must be degrees of dryness between wet and dry.   And therefore degrees of wetness between dry and Hohner. >:E

So..... Are you suggesting I should dunk the Pokerwork in a water butt? Or suggesting that's already happened???  :|glug

That is the best way to test for air leaks  (:)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: MartinW on May 09, 2012, 10:34:51 PM


[pedant warning]
you can't have degrees of dryness, if its dry the reeds are in unison, anything else is not dry,
[end pedant warning]
[/quote]

Theo, as I said to you Yeovil it is quite possible to have degrees of dryness - just think of sherry or white wine rather than water. Actually thinking of wine istead of water probably comes naturally to many of us.

Martin
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Theo on May 09, 2012, 10:48:28 PM
Well we will have to agree to differ.  I have to try and use consistent terminology when I'm discussing with clients what kind of tuning they want. Dry has a specific meaning, and is a very specific sound that you actually hear quite rarely.  Once there is a measurable difference between two reeds then there is a variation in the sound over time eg swing, tremolo etc which is something different from dry which is a sound that has no audible chage over time.
So if you like dry is zero on a scale which goes through several varieties of swing, American and toward the other extreme is a very wet tremolo. There is no fixed end to the scale at the wet end, but eventually I think there will be a point where most people would agree that it just sounds bad.
I'm happy to use comparitive terms like 'drier' to indicate getting closer to dry, but what you can't have is drier than dry!
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Lester on May 09, 2012, 11:01:01 PM
What is the advantage of having more than one reed if you want dry? Surely having two or more reeds just makes you a hostage to the minor variance in tuning that will occur over time? A difference of say 2 cents is hard to distinguish on the fly in a tune played on standard Hohner tuning but I would guess it is easier to hear if the box is tuned dry.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Theo on May 09, 2012, 11:14:06 PM
Lester,  I think that is why truly dry tuning is not often used.  It does have a distinctive sound though which is not the same as a single reed. I don't understand why it is different, but it is. 
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: waltzman on May 09, 2012, 11:46:08 PM
It does have a distinctive sound though which is not the same as a single reed. I don't understand why it is different, but it is.

Surely it's because there are always small differences between two reeds no matter how precisely you tune them. Don't you think?
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Theo on May 09, 2012, 11:51:24 PM
It does have a distinctive sound though which is not the same as a single reed. I don't understand why it is different, but it is.

Surely it's because there are always small differences between two reeds no matter how precisely you tune them. Don't you think?

Well that seems one plausible speculation. Another is that because the reeds are separated by a finite difference there are interferences between between the wave forms from the two sources, there could be any number of other reasons.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Andy Simpson on May 09, 2012, 11:54:58 PM
I've become quite drawn to the idea of a totally dry sound and asked for my new box to be tuned that way. I'm prepared to have to dampen it slightly if it proves necessary to mask the ET tuning discrepancies...


but what you can't have is drier than dry!

...says a man who's obviously never had the Taittinger '96... *haw haw haw*

We need a top hat and monocle emote.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: AirTime on May 10, 2012, 04:45:58 AM
Quote
What is the advantage of having more than one reed if you want dry? Surely having two or more reeds just makes you a hostage to the minor variance in tuning that will occur over time?

This is my question. Why pay for the extra weight, bulk, cost & tuning issues of a 2 voice if there is no discernible result?

Could somebody post some examples of a dry tuned 2 voice compared to a 1 voice for comparison?
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Peter Savage on May 10, 2012, 06:39:42 AM
Just ordered a bespoke layout Giustozzi Mod 118/A, LMM with hand made Binci's, should be ready by late Sept, tuned dry,dry,dry, o'h and a bit dryer still!, good luck sf.
I'd be interested to hear about how you came to the conclusion to go with this box?  Did you try one first?
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 10, 2012, 07:19:22 AM
Quote
What is the advantage of having more than one reed if you want dry? Surely having two or more reeds just makes you a hostage to the minor variance in tuning that will occur over time?

This is my question. Why pay for the extra weight, bulk, cost & tuning issues of a 2 voice if there is no discernible result?

Could somebody post some examples of a dry tuned 2 voice compared to a 1 voice for comparison?

Good point though 2 reeds adds to the volume, 1 can be lost in the bass end pretty easily if you linger on the chords..   
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Lester on May 10, 2012, 12:35:00 PM
Good point though 2 reeds adds to the volume, 1 can be lost in the bass end pretty easily if you linger on the chords..

Not sure I agree with this, I have heard many a Morris band with massed Pokerworks and clearly heard above them all, the single Lilly player.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 10, 2012, 12:43:47 PM
Quote
Not sure I agree with this, I have heard many a Morris band with massed Pokerworks and clearly heard above them all, the single Lilly player.

the only boxes I`ve had with stops (registers) on have been PAs and none of them on 1 voice have the volume of a Lily, that 1 voice can get lost in the bass easily if you`re not careful - imagine a Lily with TWO reeds tuned dry though  >:E  ...... It`s all relative ..

I love your MAD page Btw Lester. I`ve got to get some stuff sold so I can get a 4 stop 1 Row in G and everytime I see that Mignon ....... hmmmmmmm , Love that Pariselle 2 and a bit row too .. I`m waiting on that Club-IIIB S to arrive
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 10, 2012, 02:46:56 PM
Quote
Not sure I agree with this, I have heard many a Morris band with massed Pokerworks and clearly heard above them all, the single Lilly player.
imagine a Lily with TWO reeds tuned dry though  >:E  ...... It`s all relative ..
It almost certainly wouldn't live up to your expectations. The reasons the Lily is so powerful are:
1. It has high-quality reeds (Voci Armoniche TAM).
2. The reeds are mounted flat on the inside surface of the soundfondoboardplatethingy.
3. Because of its small size, the bellows have a relatively small cross-sectional area. This enables a relatively high air pressure to be passed through the reeds, compared with a larger instrument. I suspect also that the reeds are probably set with a slightly wider gap to make use of the high air pressure, which will also increase the volume of sound.

To get two sets of reeds inside a Lily would necessitate upright reed blocks and/or a larger bellows cross-section area to allow for flat mounting, both of which would reduce the the potential power of the instrument. You would end up with something like a Tommy but with only two voices. Still good, but you will have lost the essence of the Lily.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Owen Woods on May 10, 2012, 03:18:11 PM
Or you buy a Preciosa :P

(discalimer: which has a completely different (and far better sound), because of lots of reasons)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 10, 2012, 03:24:47 PM
Thanks for "Inside the Lily" explanation Steve - The Hohner 1 Row 1040 "pokerwork" in C has flat mounted reed pans and it`s lovely and raucous , the only thing I find is that the basses can Modulate the treble end on the push (induce growl), the "real" pokerwork (DG) with its vertical reedblocks doesn`t suffer such modulations.. I think it adds to the sound of the box but it`s not desirable all the time . I`ve never heard a lily do this but I`ve only seen them played, not played one myself.

As for Quest for the perfect sound - I`ll probably get Turboted for this but I love the sound of the big Hohner Alpina Helicons with the brassy chambers on the bass end . Wide loud and rude at one end and the other parping away like a rutting Moose ! - Not a box for general use but for sheer indulegance  ..
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Peter Savage on May 10, 2012, 04:25:00 PM
I love the sound of the big Hohner Alpina Helicons with the brassy chambers on the bass end . Wide loud and rude at one end and the other parping away like a rutting Moose ! - Not a box for general use but for sheer indulegance  ..
I live down in deepest darkest Bavaria and the machines they play in the beer gardens down here often have that big "brassy" bass end.  They make an amazing sound; with the bass end passing for a tuba after a couple of pints.  Not that I'd want to play one...but they are something to behold.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 10, 2012, 05:11:48 PM
Yeah, Fantastic those things, a 3 row with a Unisonoric button in the middle like a club . there seem to be quite a few Makers of them too. if I was ever to experiment in another kind of button box, I`d grab one long before a CBA or B/C/C# ..... though Price  ?  :-[
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Theo on May 10, 2012, 05:31:26 PM
Just goes to show that the perfect sound is a very individual thing. No one sound will be perfect for all.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Anahata on May 10, 2012, 08:03:16 PM
Yeah, Fantastic those things, a 3 row with a Unisonoric button in the middle like a club . there seem to be quite a few Makers of them too. if I was ever to experiment in another kind of button box, I`d grab one long before a CBA or B/C/C# ..... though Price  ?  :-[


Steirische Harmonikas. And the proper ones are four rows - three row boxes are the student models.
As for prices: http://www.thomann.de/gb/diatonic_accordions.html (http://www.thomann.de/gb/diatonic_accordions.html)  ;)


The unisonoric button is on all rows except the outer.

Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: sticky fingers on May 10, 2012, 08:36:53 PM
Reply to ScannAr, It is a long story, yawn, yawn, yawn, but yes I did alot of research both on this site and on the internet to find an accordion company who could make, or should I say assemble! a melodeon to my exact specification and tuning, With price also a consideration. Bertrand Gailard was my first choice, but with a 42 month wait I could not be sure if both I or he would snuff it! half way through the order time leaving me stranded. so I took one of the other options. Giampiero Giustozzi could deliver a 3 voice 21 button flat keyboard, with a stop to remove the thirds and a stop for the third voice, totaly bespoke ie D/G 21 button, top 6 buttons, 12 notes, where the dogs howl gone!, entire scale shifted upwards making a 6th button start and adding extra low notes and most of the accidentals across 2 octaves, in walnut with hand made Binci pro reeds for an incredible price. With exceptional testimonies from users on this forum with almost the exact box apart from spec! made it a no brainer. next question?
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 10, 2012, 08:46:13 PM
[Steirische Harmonikas. And the proper ones are four rows - three row boxes are the student models.
As for prices: http://www.thomann.de/gb/diatonic_accordions.html (http://www.thomann.de/gb/diatonic_accordions.html)  ;)
The unisonoric button is on all rows except the outer.

I didn`t think they were cheap ! .. Shame they don`t do them in regular A/D/G  :|||: . I`ll file these under "an extravagance for when I`m well off"
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Anahata on May 10, 2012, 09:15:42 PM
Shame they don`t do them in regular A/D/G  :|||:


http://www.peter-ganther.de/ie/beschrsteir.html (http://www.peter-ganther.de/ie/beschrsteir.html)


A/D/G, E/A/D/G or A/D/G/C !
(You could probably get one of those tunings via Thomann if you asked - they are quite friendly and helpful, and have fluent English speakers)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 10, 2012, 09:40:19 PM
A/D/G/C !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  ;D  ;D ;D ;D

WOW . you get an A Row, a D/G and a C 1 Row all in one massive, Dirndl spinningly wet, Lederhosen Splittingly Parpy  - SuperBox ..

There`s a Model called "Alpine" in the Roland FR3S but it`s nothing like the real thing, sounds way too PA (they could have meant Hohner Alpina PA which is a totally different thing)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: AirTime on May 10, 2012, 09:59:24 PM
A few months ago there were a whole series of nice looking steirische boxes coming up on US Ebay. Several of them sold in the $600 - $800 US range. It's certainly a lot of box for your money, & I was tempted, but had to face up to the reality that I'm really rather adverse to polka music! Plus, you'd have to factor in the extra cost of the accompanying outfit ...
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 10, 2012, 11:53:50 PM
I love the sound of the Steirische Harmonika.

Here's one of my favourite Youtube performers:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E2aEwwmk_kM

She really enjoys her music  (:)
And look at those splendid RH finger pattern shifts....  :|||:
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Owen Woods on May 11, 2012, 12:33:54 AM
I love Helikon bass, but the size and weight puts me off. Surprised that no "mainstream" maker has tried putting them in a conventional Italian box though. Imagine a pokerwork Heligonka!
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 11, 2012, 06:44:53 AM
I love the sound of the Steirische Harmonika.

Here's one of my favourite Youtube performers:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E2aEwwmk_kM

She really enjoys her music  (:)
And look at those splendid RH finger pattern shifts....  :|||:

That's great Steve. Beautiful sound and feel. That's a big b****r isn't it?
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 11, 2012, 07:21:58 AM
Lovely Expressive example Steve !!..

Alessandra Mignacca, totally Rocks , Italian too (not German or Austrian 8) ), the only British player I heard of was Suzanne ?  (dunno her surname) and that was a long time ago .

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yy6Af0vGM4I

One advantage from coming from the PA camp is that boxes like the 'Steirische Harmonika' are relatively light and compact ;-)  .... I`ll get practicing on the Club-IIIBS when it lands (closest i`m going to get to one) which is at least in the same key used ones will show up in.  I`ve loved the sound of these things for decades but didn`t know they had an official Title (Steirische Harmonika), seeing that one at the Music room website has sparked it off again

I`ve got pretty eclectic tastes in squeezebox music and yes, Polkas are amongst that.

Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Peter Savage on May 11, 2012, 08:09:09 AM
I love the sound of the Steirische Harmonika.

Here's one of my favourite Youtube performers:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E2aEwwmk_kM


Great clip. That is exactly the style of playing/instrument that I see in the beer gardens down here in southern Bavaria.  The only thing I would say is that watching on YouTube doesn't quite do justice to just how big those basses sound outdoors, they are incredible.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: IanD on May 11, 2012, 08:24:53 AM
A/D/G/C !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  ;D  ;D ;D ;D

WOW . you get an A Row, a D/G and a C 1 Row all in one massive, Dirndl spinningly wet, Lederhosen Splittingly Parpy  - SuperBox ..

There`s a Model called "Alpine" in the Roland FR3S but it`s nothing like the real thing, sounds way too PA (they could have meant Hohner Alpina PA which is a totally different thing)
I've got such an ADGC mit ze parpy basses, but it's a bit like trying to play a wardrobe :-(
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: IanD on May 11, 2012, 08:30:28 AM
I love Helikon bass, but the size and weight puts me off. Surprised that no "mainstream" maker has tried putting them in a conventional Italian box though. Imagine a pokerwork Heligonka!

We thought about it but they just use too much air for conventional size bellows :-(

So we're trying bigger reed blocks with bass end pitch a fifth below "normal" D/G to see if that works instead :-)

Ian

P.S. My ADGC can only play jolly tunes since all 14 basses are major!
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Anahata on May 11, 2012, 08:36:19 AM
Heavy to carry around, but the playing style is almost totally cross-row, so it's almost PA-style 1 bar in, one bar out on the bellows, which means weight of the bass end doesn't matter quite so much. (OK, IanD's x-post suggests it's not that easy....)


Steve's link is to Karin Seyringer, who is definitely one of my favourites too. She hasn't posted anything new for a while, not solo anyway; recent videos are of her band Xelchten.


Also look for the  Herbert Pixner Project on YouTube.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QhE_Qjss6OI (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QhE_Qjss6OI) walzting Pixner-style.


And playing the blues: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-V5Qm4Lcw-E (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-V5Qm4Lcw-E)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 11, 2012, 08:38:21 AM
Quote
I've got such an ADGC mit ze parpy basses, but it's a bit like trying to play a wardrobe :-(

Nahhhh They`re Tiny light little things (after a big PA anyway)  ;D . teenage girls play them on rollerblades

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GwfaqqrH5vw&feature=related

Suzanne I heard live was built like Olive Oyl and had no problems, Alessandra is hardly a Russian mud Wrestler either

I take all your points, I knew I`d be pretty much alone with regard to these things, I guess it`s the direction we`re coming from, I`m used to big heavy Unisonoric boxes (I know these are Diatonic but are played cross row so less belows changes) .
I respect the playing of the Herbert Pixner Project examples but IMO this is PA material and isn`t what these Jolly parpy boxes are all about, to me that`s the equivalent of playing Mahler on a Pokerwork
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: IanD on May 11, 2012, 08:38:25 AM
Heavy to carry around, but the playing style is almost totally cross-row, so it's almost PA-style 1 bar in, one bar out on the bellows, which means weight of the bass end doesn't matter quite so much. (OK, IanD's x-post suggests it's not that easy....)


Steve's link is to Karin Seyringer, who is definitely one of my favourites too. She hasn't posted anything new for a while, not solo anyway; recent videos are of her band Xelchten.


Also look for the  Herbert Pixner Project on YouTube.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QhE_Qjss6OI (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QhE_Qjss6OI) walzting Pixner-style.
And playing the blues: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-V5Qm4Lcw-E (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-V5Qm4Lcw-E)

My playing style isn't at all like that which is why I find the damn thing so difficult...
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 11, 2012, 08:42:25 AM
Deeply tempted by Mike's Bb mixo organetto - but then who plays in Bb/Eb/F ?
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Mike Hirst on May 11, 2012, 09:03:56 AM
playing Mahler on a Pokerwork

ThOTM ?
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Anahata on May 11, 2012, 11:15:20 AM
Deeply tempted by Mike's Bb mixo organetto - but then who plays in Bb/Eb/F ?

The Bavarians and Austrians, who play along with brass instruments that are naturally in Bâ™­ and Eâ™­.
Hence some Steirische Harmonikas are in F/ Bâ™­/ Eâ™­/ Aâ™­ or even Bâ™­/ Eâ™­/ Aâ™­ /Dâ™­
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Owen Woods on May 11, 2012, 11:42:08 AM

We thought about it but they just use too much air for conventional size bellows :-(

So we're trying bigger reed blocks with bass end pitch a fifth below "normal" D/G to see if that works instead :-)

Ian

P.S. My ADGC can only play jolly tunes since all 14 basses are major!

Aye, doesn't surprise me. Probably the minimum bellows size is way bigger than I would wish to cart around :(

A fifth below normal D/G? What do you mean by that? Surely the bass would be a fifth out? Unless you mean having long reeds without weights on the end (which respond a lot quicker and are generally lovely, I have them in my Liliput).
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 11, 2012, 12:37:23 PM
The reeds in steirische harmonikas for the bass end are very long indeed , no weights I could see in this video :)

shows here in a how we make them ( by Novak )

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-xhPnjoF9c&feature=related
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: IanD on May 11, 2012, 10:30:24 PM

We thought about it but they just use too much air for conventional size bellows :-(

So we're trying bigger reed blocks with bass end pitch a fifth below "normal" D/G to see if that works instead :-)

Ian

P.S. My ADGC can only play jolly tunes since all 14 basses are major!

Aye, doesn't surprise me. Probably the minimum bellows size is way bigger than I would wish to cart around :(

A fifth below normal D/G? What do you mean by that? Surely the bass would be a fifth out? Unless you mean having long reeds without weights on the end (which respond a lot quicker and are generally lovely, I have them in my Liliput).

Bass reeds in a normal D/G club go (in order of pitch) CDEFGAB, we're going to try FGABCDE -- low basses using the biggest Harmonikas#1 reeds http://www.harmonikas.cz/sortiment-hlasue.htm (http://www.harmonikas.cz/sortiment-hlasue.htm) on much bigger than normal reed blocks -- no treble blocks to take up space inside the bellows.

If the lowest reeds are a bit slow to start the octave and second octave should help to hide this.

Also inverted chords with the fifth lowest, then tonic, then third/fifth switchable above it.

The idea is to get more pitch separation between the bass end and the treble as well as nice low basses -- I play a lot of continuo bass chords and runs (like a bass guitar) rather than staccato, and this sometimes gets mixed up with the treble end sound.

Ian
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Owen Woods on May 12, 2012, 12:07:10 AM
Bass reeds in a normal D/G club go (in order of pitch) CDEFGAB, we're going to try FGABCDE -- low basses using the biggest Harmonikas#1 reeds http://www.harmonikas.cz/sortiment-hlasue.htm (http://www.harmonikas.cz/sortiment-hlasue.htm) on much bigger than normal reed blocks -- no treble blocks to take up space inside the bellows.

If the lowest reeds are a bit slow to start the octave and second octave should help to hide this.

Also inverted chords with the fifth lowest, then tonic, then third/fifth switchable above it.

The idea is to get more pitch separation between the bass end and the treble as well as nice low basses -- I play a lot of continuo bass chords and runs (like a bass guitar) rather than staccato, and this sometimes gets mixed up with the treble end sound.

Ian

Ah, I see, that makes sense! Be interesting to see. And a worthy ambition. With a staccato way of playing makes a high bass and chord really effective, but I've never played like that either. The Estonian players have boxes with really high chords, but they stab at it and it sounds great.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Andy Simpson on May 12, 2012, 02:03:05 PM
My own quest for the perfect sound is definitely going in the direction of lower pitches and more unusual keys. I've got an F/Bb on the way fairly soon and I've just contacted another maker about my next box, which will probably be an E/A.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: AirTime on May 15, 2012, 09:21:20 PM
Here's an unusual (?) small, two row Steirische Harmonika on US Ebay. I'm not sure why it's been bid up so high as it appears to be unrestored.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/360458024335?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649#ht_733wt_884

There's a link to this wonderful Youtube clip:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0VRAC3MDBpI&feature=related



Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 15, 2012, 09:26:20 PM
Ahh, the Castagnari Lily of Steirische Harmonikas :) Cute
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Owen Woods on May 16, 2012, 01:53:03 AM
The more I think, the more I would love to have a play with a gonka...

And obviously, any thread featuring helikon reeds must at some point have this posted:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpmDAu_47OE&feature=fvwp
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: diatonix on May 16, 2012, 06:59:19 AM
I get a bit nervous when watching that video, Ukebert: one slight choreographic misjudgement and quite a few people + 2 Steyrische will find themselves lying in a mixture of blood and beer.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Anahata on May 16, 2012, 08:04:15 AM
There's a video of die Twinnies (maybe not that one) where one of them does fall over. She picks herself up and carries on with remarkable rapidity and no apparent ill effects.
What it is (was) to be young!  :'(
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 16, 2012, 08:27:16 AM
The more I think, the more I would love to have a play with a gonka...

And obviously, any thread featuring helikon reeds must at some point have this posted:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpmDAu_47OE&feature=fvwp

Yeah, I posted that higher up the thread -  and big hefty guys were moaning about the weight of a Saltarelle Tara !  ;D
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Owen Woods on May 16, 2012, 10:58:58 AM
Did you? Oops! :P
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 16, 2012, 11:11:44 AM
There's a video of die Twinnies (maybe not that one) where one of them does fall over. She picks herself up and carries on with remarkable rapidity and no apparent ill effects.
What it is (was) to be young!  :'(

I`d like to see that one ! . Don`t try it with a full size PA folks, you may not get up (and the locals will think the Cybermen have invaded)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Anahata on May 16, 2012, 01:32:35 PM
I`d like to see that one !

It's on YouTube somewhere. Enjoy your quest  ;)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Andy Simpson on May 17, 2012, 12:00:21 AM
I've just contacted another maker about my next box, which will probably be an E/A.

....and I've just committed to an order. Someone's getting a Bergflodt next year. 8)
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Owen Woods on May 17, 2012, 12:35:22 AM
You lucky thing! I would love one of Olav's boxes.
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Adam-T on May 17, 2012, 07:20:04 AM
Quote
....and I've just committed to an order. Someone's getting a Bergflodt next year. 8)

Stunning - am I mistaken in thinking they have Helicon bass, or are the two top vents just normal vents ?
Title: Re: The quest for the perfect sound
Post by: Andy Simpson on May 17, 2012, 11:33:15 AM
I've been quoted 1 year for delivery. It's only going to take him a couple of weeks to make it, the Norwegian postal service is just really slow. ;D

1 year isn't bad at all IMO. If I'd ordered a Gaillard instead I'd have to wait, I think, 2 or 3 years...and I could only have a box that was made to suit M. Gaillard, not to suit me...

I've wanted one for years, I can't wait!.

..and nope, no helikon basses.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal