Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: SamWise on October 03, 2008, 02:22:06 PM

Title: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 03, 2008, 02:22:06 PM
I'm not, as yet, as melodeonista. I do, however, have a best friend who is an out-and-proud folkie, and I'm helping her work on an EP. I need to assemble some musicians to add various parts - no problem, I have good contacts. Trouble is, for a folkie, she has odd taste in keys. She's used to playing on her own, guitar and vocals, and using the dreaded capo to find a key that works for her. This means that of the three songs we have so far, she's doing two in Bb, and one in Eb. Hmmmm.

I play whistle and flute, but clearly those aren't happening in those keys. My Dad is a folkie, and he plays concert flute, so I can draft him in there. I was also hoping to rope in melodeon for at least one song, but I'm not aware of any way of playing a button box in either of these keys. Is there something I don't know? At the moment, it's looking like I need to find a highly competent piano accordionist instead!
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Dazbo on October 03, 2008, 02:32:25 PM
Whilst I don't know anyone to play a box in these keys there are quite a few Eb/Bb boxes around - mainly old hohners etc- It wouldn't surprise me if a D/G (or C/F, G/C, A/D etc) box player near you has one knocking about for "private parties" shall we say ;D
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: TomB-R on October 03, 2008, 02:35:45 PM
...and the inner row of a D/D# is also in Eb!  ;D
(And on one of those, a B/C player playing in "G" would be sounding in Bb!)
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 03, 2008, 02:41:20 PM
Hmmm. I've been wanting to take up melodeon myself. Presumably Bb/Eb boxes would tend to be (relatively) cheap compared to a more popular D/G, so perhaps it would be ideal for me to try to snap one up and become her personal melodeonist? Where would one go looking for an inexpensive used Bb/Eb?
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: george garside on October 03, 2008, 05:06:15 PM
[quote 
 At the moment, it's looking like I need to find a highly competent piano accordionist instead!
[/quote]



or a BCCsharpist!

george
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Matthew B on October 03, 2008, 05:19:40 PM
 . . . Or a club box player, a C/F club will get you Bb on both ends, and Eb on the right hand.  And then of course there's the Bb/Eb club.  Several people here play at least one of these tunings, and as I've yet to meet a melodeon player who turned down work I'm sure you could convince one of them to contribute to your project.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Theo on October 03, 2008, 05:19:48 PM
Hmmm. I've been wanting to take up melodeon myself. Presumably Bb/Eb boxes would tend to be (relatively) cheap compared to a more popular D/G, so perhaps it would be ideal for me to try to snap one up and become her personal melodeonist? Where would one go looking for an inexpensive used Bb/Eb?

There is one on ebay (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&item=270279382309) due to end soon.

It looks in good condition, but boxes of this age (from 1930s)  will always need a reed overhausl to get them playing properly.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: C age ing on October 03, 2008, 05:30:49 PM
Sam,
Your local music shop will sell you a Generation whistle in Bb or Eb for under four quid, keyless flutes are available in the same keys at considerably more and simple system keyed flutes or the Böhm like your dad's will easily cope.
If you're really stuck, have tenor saxophone and will travel. :)

Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Doug Anderson on October 03, 2008, 06:00:30 PM
Bb and Eb are just a semitone above A and D, respectively, and both A and D are playable on a D/G melodeon. I'd see if the singer could deal with the slightly lower keys before spending money on instruments that are otherwise unlikely to see much use.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: george garside on October 03, 2008, 06:06:12 PM
Bb and Eb are just a semitone above A and D, respectively, and both A and D are playable on a D/G melodeon. I'd see if the singer could deal with the slightly lower keys before spending money on instruments that are otherwise unlikely to see much use.

 It would be nice if someone could invent a sort of capo to be fitted to singers - that way you could move them up or down a bit to the  nearest recognisable key  ;)
george ;)
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Matthew B on October 03, 2008, 07:02:33 PM
It would be nice if someone could invent a sort of capo to be fitted to singers - that way you could move them up or down a bit to the  nearest recognisable key  ;) george ;)

I'm wincing at the thought . . .
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: HallelujahAl on October 03, 2008, 08:02:29 PM
Get a concertina (English or Duet) is my suggestion. I use it to lead singing with most weeks in my church (The Sally Army) and most of the hymns we sing are in Bb, F or Eb (and a few more in Ab). It's simply a fantastic instrument for all that kind of stuff. Which is the reason why the SA equipped most of its officers with them back in the early 1900s. Sadly I'm the only serving (i.e. not retired yet) officer I know of in the UK still using one - I guess you can say I'm hoping for a revival!

As to the issue of capos for singers...can't a special corset be made that would do the job?
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 03, 2008, 08:06:06 PM
Sam,
Your local music shop will sell you a Generation whistle in Bb or Eb for under four quid, keyless flutes are available in the same keys at considerably more and simple system keyed flutes or the Böhm like your dad's will easily cope.
If you're really stuck, have tenor saxophone and will travel. :)



Yeah, I have Generation whistles in all sorts of keys, but they're not really playable. I've got nice whistles in D and G and C, and a really nice handmade wooden keyless flute, also in D. My Dad is a flute fanatic, and will probably have something in Bb - at the last count he had around 40 flutes), but it's a shame not to play my nice instruments.

I agree that trying to get Kate into a different key is the best approach, and that's what I've got in mind. She's a truly outstanding singer, but needs a confidence boost, and I'm sure a bit of diaphragm work will help with her range. In a way, I think I'm looking for an excuse to buy a melodeon - I've wanted one for ages. Not much money floating around though - even the £200 chinese jobs look expensive. Likewise, that means that whether melodeonists never turn down work or not neither of us can pay them! It'll all be strictly on the friendship system.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Doug Anderson on October 03, 2008, 09:35:11 PM
It would be nice if someone could invent a sort of capo to be fitted to singers - that way you could move them up or down a bit to the  nearest recognisable key  ;)
My guitar player friend and I are usually able to sing with key-challenged instrumentalists by switching which of us sings lead and which sings harmony. He uses a capo as needed, and I play my English concertina if the piece is not in the G or C home keys of my melodeon.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Falseknight on October 04, 2008, 01:20:11 AM
If a singer is tied to  semi-tone of key, I'd  question whether they are worth recording anyway.

There should be enough latitude.

Best way to manage this, incidentally, is not to TELL the singer you've moved the key.  Nine times out of ten they won't notice.  (Alternatively tune the guitar a semitone sharp or flat - same game!)
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 04, 2008, 07:31:01 AM
Oh, she's worth recording, believe me. She just needs confidence and experience. With the Bb song, for example, I could probably take it UP to C without too much trouble, but the bottom note in Bb is near the bottom of her range. I think she can hit it in A though.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 04, 2008, 08:07:16 AM
Actually, I've been thinking about this some more, and I still think buying a Bb/Eb box is not a bad idea. I've wanted a melodeon for ages, evidence suggests I'd get a decent one a good bit cheaper than a D/G, and the more I think about the "It'll never get played" comment, the more it's a fallacy. The singer I'm most likely to play with transposes most tunes into these keys, so it'll see use there. I'm not really a folkie - I like folk music, but I find sessions bizarre - you need to know 8 million different tunes just to get along, and whilst I like folk, I'm nowhere near committed enough to it to invest the sort of time involved - I have too much other music to play. I'm interested in learning songs to perform, and for my purposes, why not Bb/Eb?
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Skipy on October 04, 2008, 10:22:10 AM
I like folk music, but I find sessions bizarre - you need to know 8 million different tunes just to get along,

I had to smile when I read this and you're spot on of course, although I feel 8 million may be slight exaggeration, one way or the other!  ;)

However, I love my local one, it's a great place be, a great place to meet new musicians and a great way to learn lots and lots and lots and lots of new tunes.

Skipy
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: C age ing on October 04, 2008, 10:49:11 AM
Yeah, I have Generation whistles in all sorts of keys, but they're not really playable. I've got nice whistles in D and G and C, and a really nice handmade wooden keyless flute, also in D. My Dad is a flute fanatic, and will probably have something in Bb - at the last count he had around 40 flutes), but it's a shame not to play my nice instruments.
Sam,
Have you tried the old trick of taking the head off of Gennies, filling the underside up to the window with Blutak and cleaning off the moulding flash? Makes a difference and you will only need to treat the Bb and then use one of the on line fingering charts to find out the cross fingering for the Ab for the Eb tunes. Remember that some of those excellent professional Irish whistle players play bog standard whistles rather than Morpanes or similar..
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 04, 2008, 11:01:56 AM
I've not heard of that, but I'll give it a try. I need to go through and see what keys I have. I know I've got Bb, but I might have Eb too....

I don't have top notch whistles, just a Shaw G and a Howard Low D, but they're a clear cut above the Generations I have. My Dad has a wooden High D with a silver mouthpiece that cost around the £150 mark though, and it's by a distance the best thing I've ever played. My flute is a Kything, handmade in Oz by a guy called Michael Hoza, and I find it easier to play than any of the Rudell and Rose or Rudell Carte items I've tried. It's gorgeous.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 04, 2008, 11:03:48 AM
Hmmm. I have a Bb Generation. I can cross-finger into Eb just fine - Ab might be more of a challenge. I'll try Blu-tack
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Falseknight on October 05, 2008, 01:00:17 PM
I like folk music, but I find sessions bizarre - you need to know 8 million different tunes just to get along, and whilst I like folk, I'm nowhere near committed enough to it to invest the sort of time involved - I have too much other music to play. I'm interested in learning songs to perform, and for my purposes, why not Bb/Eb?

It's fairly easy to argue that sessions are neither folk nor music - especially with two banjo players trying to boss every tune at 95 miles an hour.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 05, 2008, 04:16:24 PM
They certainly don't work well for me. The first one I attended was in Northumberland, and I assumed that as an able musician who can improvise well, I'd do fine. In the event, I barely played a note. Everyone in the room knew all these tunes, and I knew nothing, yet it wasn't very pleasant to listen to.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Stiamh on October 05, 2008, 08:18:43 PM
They certainly don't work well for me. The first one I attended was in Northumberland, and I assumed that as an able musician who can improvise well, I'd do fine. In the event, I barely played a note. Everyone in the room knew all these tunes, and I knew nothing, yet it wasn't very pleasant to listen to.

I can sympathise if the music wasn't very pleasant to listen to Sam, but as far as joining in goes, maybe you need to see things from the other side.

It's not unusual for people to turn up at the kinds of sessions I go to (mostly Irish music) and expect to be able to join in without knowing the tunes. Perhaps because they assume that a "session" must be a "jam session" where all you need is to be able to improvise.

When such a person shows up with their instrument, someone has to explain to them that no, it isn't a jam session, and that most of us have been learning the music we are playing for many years. Anybody is welcome to join in, but only if their contribution doesn't spoil things for the other participants. Yes, there is scope for a certain amount of improvisation - but only if you know the musical language well, which isn't going to be the case unless you have been playing it for some time. If you want to join in, you have to learn some of the tunes that are likely to be played, at least.

Trying to get this across is not always easy. Ideally it will be done in a friendly manner, making it clear to the "postulant" that they are welcome to join the circle, ask questions, get pointers, and so on. And ideally the newcomer will understand. It doesn't always work out that way, though, and as a result the session may get wrecked and/or people's feelings hurt.

Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 05, 2008, 09:40:54 PM
Well, you'll be pleased to know that I was extremely well behaved. I brought my mandolin, my whistles, and my guitar, but I sat and listened before trying to get involved. It became evident that everyone in the room knew all the tunes, and that my whistles and mandolin should stay where they were. I got my guitar out, and it wasn't difficult to listen through the tune the first time, and comp chords the next time through; it just wasn't any fun. Don't get me wrong, it doesn't upset me that other people want to do it, but I don't really get what the appeal is of sitting in as 30-40 people batter a tune which could be quite lovely if just 4 or 5 of them played and the rest listened. There were no dynamics, little feeling; I just didn't get it. So I comped along for a bit, then made my excuses and left. It would've been nice if someone had said hello, or told me a bit about what was going on, but it wouldn't have made any difference really.

Anyway, the point was not to slag off sessions; I only mentioned them to make the point that for me, it doesn't specially matter is a box is D/G or Bb/Eb in terms of whether it'll get played, because I don't need to fit in with lots of other tune-players. Indeed, it's quite likely for the moment that a box which plays in the keys the singer I'm working with wants to sing in will get a lot MORE use than a D/G, and if that means I can pick one up for £100 instead of £2-300 because they're less use to others, then hurrah! If I take to it as I imagine I might, more boxes could follow, but for now? Well, Eb and Bb are very singable keys for me as well........

For those who do love sessions, more power to your elbow. I'm quite interested, actually, to know what it is you get out of them - can someone enlighten me?
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Stiamh on October 06, 2008, 12:23:00 AM
... I don't really get what the appeal is of sitting in as 30-40 people batter a tune...

Ah. I see what you mean. The sessions I go to regularly usually have no more than 6 players. 10 is getting big. When the mix is right, what I get out of it is a lot of fun from the social interaction (hesitate to use the overworked word "crack") and the pleasure of making music that sounds good. Both aspects have to be there. If socially it isn't happening and the music doesn't sound good then you're right - no fun at all.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 06, 2008, 07:13:52 AM
Ah. Once you have 6 players, especially if they're generally the same ones, you're getting to something more like a band rehearsal, and then I get the appeal. This was merciless, it really was.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 06, 2008, 08:00:52 AM
...... but I don't really get what the appeal is of sitting in as 30-40 people batter a tune which could be quite lovely if just 4 or 5 of them played and the rest listened. There were no dynamics, little feeling; I just didn't get it. So I comped along for a bit, then made my excuses and left. It would've been nice if someone had said hello, or told me a bit about what was going on, but it wouldn't have made any difference really......

.... For those who do love sessions, more power to your elbow. I'm quite interested, actually, to know what it is you get out of them - can someone enlighten me?
SamWise,
I've played in many sessions, some were good, some indifferent and some downright bad. Yours sounds like one of the latter type (30-40 people?? Crumbs, normally that's just too many). The things which annoy me most in sessions are (a) people not listening to the person who started a tune and race away with it or otherwise take it over and (b) if someone starts a tune which some of the others don't know, the others just start talking loudly amongst themselves, instead of taking an opportunity to be quiet and learn something new.

Fortunately they're not all like that, and it is worth trying a few more before you give up on them altogether.
A session I go to fairly often out in the wilds of the Peak District is normally very friendly indeed. Numbers vary from about 8 to 15.  Many of the people there are long-standing friends and play together elsewhere in various bands, so inevitably there is a good selection of core tunes that rattle along quite nicely with no need for anyone to call any changes because we all know what tunes will happen next. This could be quite intimidating for a new visitor or beginner, but we all make a real effort to welcome newcomers and learn their names - and importantly, make sure they have as many opportunities to start or join in tunes as they wish.

Having said all that, there is one very busy session which I do enjoy greatly - the Friday night session at the beginning of Melodeons at Witney. It can be loud and continuous melodeon music for 3 hours or so. No sooner does one tune finish than another starts. There might be 40+ melodeon players in the room - can you imagine it!!?? Many of the people who go there do so purely to let their hair down and catch up with friends whom they haven't seen for 12 months since the last time. The session sometimes lacks finesse, but it is a fantastic feeling to be part of such a wall of sound, just once in a while. I do warn beginners what to expect here and reassure them that the sometimes wild and woolly atmosphere is definitely not an indication of what will be happening in the formal tuition sessions of the rest of the weekend.

What do I get out of sessions? I've already mentioned the buzz from the 'wall of sound' experience; great - but I wouldn't want it to happen too often. Mostly I just love playing tunes - it's my 'drug' and I like to get my 'fix' in the company of others doing the same. For me, sessions are not usually the place where refined music happens. For that, a small group, 3 or 4 of us meet in each others houses and learn new stuff, try out different tunes and work out arrangements, etc.

Otherwise for me the session is the place where you can meet with others to have a stonking good set of tunes, let your hair down, enjoy the rhythm and melody and not worry too much about the fine details.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: george garside on October 06, 2008, 09:56:27 AM
I agree with Steve's comments about people not listening and also  not trying to ppick up a tune played by a newcomer to the session.  Unfortunately some (but by no means all) sessions seem to be run as a private party even when in the bar of a pub and the players seem to make a serious attempt to discourage  anybody joining in .  Sadly the same applies to some 'lead' festival sessions where the leader(s) play flat out throughout the session on the basis that anybody is welcome to join in provided they can but nobody is actively encouraged to participate - which to me is the key componant of a lead session i.e. getting as many people playing as possible at any given time  & keeping the pace steady i.e. at the tunes natural speed  which every tune has & when everything comes nicely together.  I am not keen on the term 'slow session' which can easily become a 'workshop'. Both session & workshop have their place but not at the same time!  For what its worth I think a tune plyed at 200 miles an hour sounds just as  crappy as one played at half speed- neither was what the maker intended!

As to really big sessions they are great to take part in , or indeed to lead  & as Steve has saiad there is a buzz about playing en masse.  I once recorded a session I was running at Sidmouth festival with 156 players taking part.  It sounded  great on the night but bloody awful when played back, probably because the tape could not convey the 'atmosphere' of  everybody enjoying themselves - warts & all.

If there are no sessions in your area (or only 'fast' sessions) why not get together 5 or 6 like minded individuals and start your own - hopefully going on to provide a real welcome to all who subsequently come along.

george
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Falseknight on October 06, 2008, 10:33:31 AM
Since most tunes are for dancing (OK, not slow airs) the rule should be, if it is too fast to reasonably dance to, then it is too fast.

With the slow airs, there somethines seems to be a competition as to how slow you can actually play the thing without actually stopping.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 06, 2008, 10:54:02 AM

If there are no sessions in your area (or only 'fast' sessions) why not get together 5 or 6 like minded individuals and start your own - hopefully going on to provide a real welcome to all who subsequently come along.

george

I'm sure there are plenty of sessions in my area, I just have no desire to go! Even though some of what you all describe in these smaller sessions sounds like fun, it's still not really what I enjoy about music. A 5 or 6 person session might be fun to listen to, but I can't imagine learning repertoire just to play at a session. On the other hand, my missus is working on opening a tea shop which will be open til midnight and provide entertainment, and there might be room for a weekly or bi-weekly folk session amongst the open mic and comedy nights. Perhaps a folk club though. I dunno.

Anyway, I really don't think session playing is for me, it's just not directional enough - too much of an "end in itself". I have such little spare time that I want to invest it in music that can take me somewhere new, just at the moment.
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: SamWise on October 09, 2008, 09:56:33 PM
For those who were following the original point of this thread, an update. I went into the loft to inspect an old piano accordion I bought 10 years or so ago for £30 at a flea market. I remembered it being a wreck, but it's not. All the (120!) basses seem to work fine, the lowest two keys on the keyboard only play in one direction, and there are a couple of quieter keys, but all in all, it's servicable. It'll sound a little wheezy, I expect, but for sea shanties that'll be perfect. Therefore, unless I get a great offer of a Bb/Eb, it'll probably take the flat key duties for now, leaving me back to considering a D/G or a one row cajun as my first button-box.......
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: smiley on October 12, 2008, 01:14:22 AM
I've been jamming with some jazz musos for a while (on bass) and have begun playing some of the songs in 'flat' keys on my old C/F hohner box, which has the standard accidentals. For some tunes with a few Eb or Ab chords I can improvise ok behind the melody by playing other notes in the relevant chord - or just slur a few quick passing notes to fake it until we get to a 'safer' key ;-)

But if you've got a piano box available it would probably be more sensible to just concentrate on playing that. [jeez I think I've just expressed heretical views on this forum ....]
Title: Re: Playing with singers who need an odd key
Post by: Pete of Ebor on October 15, 2008, 08:26:16 PM
There's always a Streb ! - can't that be retuned to odd keys ?
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal