Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Peter Savage on May 15, 2012, 07:23:07 AM
-
I have a Castagnari box on loan at the moment and was interested in knowing what model it was. I attach a picture. It is a D/G, LMM, 21 treble, 8 bass with a stop to remove the thirds on the basses and another stop to add/remove the lower treble reeds. Inside it says that it's from 2004, has typo mano reeds and is a "Sander". BUT - the fretwork on the box doesn't look at all like other Sanders I have seen (e.g. http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=8567.0). Did Castagnari change the design of the Sander box sometime in the past? Thanks in advance for your assistance.
-
Yes. The design of the Sander changed sometime around 2009. A shame IMO because I thought it was Castagnari's most tasteful and nicely understated design, neither overdone nor too plain, prior to that.
-
Thanks for the info Andy; much appreciated.
-
I like the new Sander design. As you can see from the photos of mine in the link which ScannAr has provided, there are cut-outs in the front faces of the treble and bass ends. I think it helps give a more balanced sound, and it certainly looks nice - not overdone at all.
-
Yes, the cutouts on the bass end especially should improve the sound but on a purely visual level I personally find the current design a little over-egged and think that the new additions mar the looks of what was previously a very handsome instrument.
Your Sander there was originally ordered by me. I bailed on it after they went way over the quoted delivery time, (quoted 6-8 months, I walked away at 14, it eventually turned up at 18 or 19 and I'm still very grateful to Rees for his absolute zero pressure sales approach), and I must admit that the change of design was a factor in my doing so. At the time I ordered it the catalogue showed the old design, which is easily my favourite post-"window logo" Castagnari design of all and if I'd known that it was going to change then I'd probably have committed to spending more on a Hascy instead, entirely because the looks of the new Sander irk me so much.