Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: oggiesnr on May 15, 2012, 07:40:40 AM
-
Or between those in bandonions and harmoniums?
I've seen lots of references to this (and to the difference types/prices of reeds) so what are the differences please?
Steve
-
Proper concertina reeds are a different construction to melodeon/accordion reeds. They have removable tongues and the frames are designed to push into the reed pan
http://www.suttnerconcertinas.com/images/concertina_reeds.jpg
-
Last time I was at Colin Dipper's he mentioned "making a reed" - "can't you buy them?" - "no, all made upstairs, I make brass holder, I cut the slots and file the steel down, all m'self". He even cuts own screws on bolts though!
I think this may be true of nearly all concertina makers. Whereas every accordion/melodeon maker I know buys in Italian reeds of a quality to suit his market. Loffet "finishes" and tunes them himself. Gaillard contracts out the whole process to a lady friend. Similarly Oakwoods were reeded and tuned externally. Castagnari order reed sets in, and fit/tune themselves on the top floor.
-
Proper concertina reeds are a different construction to melodeon/accordion reeds. They have removable tongues and the frames are designed to push into the reed pan
http://www.suttnerconcertinas.com/images/concertina_reeds.jpg
Concertina reed tongues are not really removable! Woe betide you if you ever try to move/adjust or otherwise mess with the bolts which clamp the reed tongues to a concertina reed frame! If the reed tongue moves out of position, you will be in serious trouble, as it will be virtually impossible to get it back to where it should be, and indeed you may have to go and grovel in person at the feet of a concertina maker and plead with them to undo (if possible) the mess you have made. :(
When concertina reeds are made, the reed tongues are made from a longer strip of steel, the 'tail' of which protrudes beyond the clamp whilst the exact alignment and adjustments are made, and only after that is the tail cut off flush with the clamp.
-
Proper concertina reeds are a different construction to melodeon/accordion reeds. They have removable tongues and the frames are designed to push into the reed pan
http://www.suttnerconcertinas.com/images/concertina_reeds.jpg
Concertina reed tongues are not really removable! Woe betide you if you ever try to move/adjust or otherwise mess with the bolts which clamp the reed tongues to a concertina reed frame! If the reed tongue moves out of position, you will be in serious trouble, as it will be virtually impossible to get it back to where it should be, and indeed you may have to go and grovel in person at the feet of a concertina maker and plead with them to undo (if possible) the mess you have made. :(
When concertina reeds are made, the reed tongues are made from a longer strip of steel, the 'tail' of which protrudes beyond the clamp whilst the exact alignment and adjustments are made, and only after that is the tail cut off flush with the clamp.
Concertina reeds are removable, I agree it is not a good idea but it can be done.
-
Proper concertina reeds are a different construction to melodeon/accordion reeds. They have removable tongues and the frames are designed to push into the reed pan
http://www.suttnerconcertinas.com/images/concertina_reeds.jpg
Concertina reed tongues are not really removable! Woe betide you if you ever try to move/adjust or otherwise mess with the bolts which clamp the reed tongues to a concertina reed frame! If the reed tongue moves out of position, you will be in serious trouble, as it will be virtually impossible to get it back to where it should be, and indeed you may have to go and grovel in person at the feet of a concertina maker and plead with them to undo (if possible) the mess you have made. :(
When concertina reeds are made, the reed tongues are made from a longer strip of steel, the 'tail' of which protrudes beyond the clamp whilst the exact alignment and adjustments are made, and only after that is the tail cut off flush with the clamp.
Concertina reeds are removable, I agree it is not a good idea but it can be done.
So are accordion/melodeon reed tongues, just remove the rivet. Takes a bit longer than removing two screws, but can be quicker to replace!
Better to say that the reeds use different methods for holding the reeds in place. Rivet in accordion reeds and a screwed clamp in concertina reeds (except for the ones that use a rivet). ;D
-
So are accordion/melodeon reed tongues, just remove the rivet. Takes a bit longer than removing two screws, but can be quicker to replace!
:-)
-
Last time I was at Colin Dipper's he mentioned "making a reed" - "can't you buy them?" - "no, all made upstairs, I make brass holder, I cut the slots and file the steel down, all m'self". He even cuts own screws on bolts though!
I think this may be true of nearly all concertina makers.
True of all concertina makers who use concertina reeds, but none of those who use accordion reeds. ;)
See recent post about concertinas good, bad and ugly.
-
A reed is a reed is a reed - they all have a tongue that vibrates in a slot. The difference is how they are manufactured, what the tongues are made out of, what the reeds are made out of, how they are fitted to the instrument, and finally how they are tuned.
Different instruments have historically used reeds manufactured in different ways and out of different materials, but now you often see, for example, reeds made for accordions fitted into concertinas.
Reed tongues can be made from steel, brass, german silver, or even bamboo! (As fitted to the Chinese Sheng, the first 'free reed' instrument).
Reed plates can be made from brass, zinc, aluminium, or alloy.
Reed plates can house one reed, or multiple (look inside a mouth organ to see what a multiple one looks like).
In cheap instruments, the reed plate and the reeds are cut from one single piece of brass (qv cheap mouth organs).
Bandonions (and harmoniums) typically have steel tongues in zinc plates.
Concertinas typically have tongues of brass, steel, or german silver fitted in individual brass or aluminium plates.
Melodeons typically have steel tongues in individual aluminium/alloy plates.
Note use of the wod' typically'! There are many exceptions ;D
I'll let someone else describe the tuning options!
-
New THESE are Italian Reeds !! ..
Believe it or not, this reed bank is from an Italian accordion, made in Italy 100% .. PLASTIC Reeds - they were also used in the same companies reed organs, yes it`s a Bontempi from the 70s and the bellows are 100% Cardboard, no cloth gussets or bellows tape, the treble end has one massive combined reeds, reedplate and soundboard all moulded from the one piece of plastic, the amazing thing is that it`s pretty much bang on in tune ! .. the Chinese £10 melodeon is a castagnari compared to this
-
New THESE are Italian Reeds !! ..
Believe it or not, this reed bank is from an Italian accordion, made in Italy 100% .. PLASTIC Reeds - they were also used in the same companies reed organs, yes it`s a Bontempi from the 70s and the bellows are 100% Cardboard, no cloth gussets or bellows tape, the treble end has one massive combined reeds, reedplate and soundboard all moulded from the one piece of plastic, the amazing thing is that it`s pretty much bang on in tune ! .. the Chinese £10 melodeon is a castagnari compared to this
Fabulous (:)
-
Are they proper A Plastica reeds or just Tipo A Plastica?....or even Super Polistirolo?.
-
Are they proper A Plastica reeds or just Tipo A Plastica?....or even Super Polistirolo?.
They`re just Tipo A Plastica, top of the range A Plasticas don`t have the soundboard moulded in and are generally only found in higher end instruments like pictured below, cost is prohibitive in lower end instruments, this awesome Classic B14 could sting you for as much as £15 in mint condition at a particularily posh car boot sale. I`ve seen them go for a wallet stinging £20 at a high street dealer (Junk shop) .. Super Polistirolos were never used by Bontempi, they cost way too much, you`re looking spending out on a magnus to get reeds of that quality, they`re individual mouldings and on the high end organs, held in with Genuine Evostik
-
Did they use plastric effect wood? ;D
-
Not on the B14 which is the top of the range one, it`ll be REAL plastic ..
BTW 2 more posts and I`ll get the title of "Respected Sage" . personally I think "Pointless GasBag" would be more appropriate in my case
-
I fancy the idea of a low carbon bamboo reeded melodeon. I'm sure it could be done!
-
...now you often see, for example, reeds made for accordions fitted into concertinas.
I'd like to see "reeds made for accordions fitted into concertinas" but I reckon they'd stick out the sides... >:E
-
the first pic shows typical concertina reeds in the reed pan (as described by previous posts)
the second shows a 30 button Italian tina with melodeon reeds
the third pic shows the difference between accordion and melodeon reeds
the accordion reeds (left in pic) are the same note on the press or draw of the bellows, ie same slot size, same reed dimensions
the melodeon reeds (right in pic) are different notes on the press and draw of the bellows, ie different slot size and different reed dimensions
-
That could be arranged ;D
-
So far most of the responses (for which many thanks) hinge around the fact that the reeds are held in a different way which I confess I already knew having taken all five of the types of reed instrument apart at various times.
My question is really about the actual composition of the reed itself, is there a material difference in the vibrating part of the reeds which makes a sonic difference? Does it all come down to how they're held in the instrument and the other charateristics (bellows size etc) of the individual instrument.
Steve
-
All of the above!
-
Whether it's due to differences in the shape of the reeds or the way they are mounted, "hybrid" concertinas using accordion reeds have a distinctively different sound from those using traditional concertina reeds.
-
There is a distinct difference in the slot between concertina reeds and accordion/melodeon reeds, and also reed organ reeds. It all affects the way that air is vented when the tongue enters the slot hence the distinct sounds.
In a concertina reed the slot sides taper in an up down direction and the tongue is parallel along it length.
In a melodeon/accordion the slot is parallel in the up down direction and the tongue and slot are tapered along the length.
In reed organ reeds the slot is parallel up down and along the length but the tip of the frame is milled out on the underside. This undercut milling some times extends along the reed frame.
-
... "hybrid" concertinas using accordion reeds have a distinctively different sound from those using traditional concertina reeds.
You might also be able to tell the difference, without hearing a note being played, by observing the attitude of some towards the mere existence of so-called "hybrid" concertinas. As well as various melodeons, I aslo play anglo concertina, owning "traditional" as well as "accordion" (sic) reeded instruments. They are different but I enjoy both, and would be happy to endorse either; regardless of playing ability. From wide personal experience (in the UK, Ireland, Germany, Sweden, the USA and Canada), I've witnessed palpable derision towards "hybrids" from some "traditional" quarters. Not neccesarliy directed towards me (at least not to my face!) but more generally and it's not that un-common. You occasionally detect it on a well-known concertina forum which many here will also frequent. Thankfully I don't get that sort on vibe on mel.net (and hope I haven't started it!) In fact, the less expensive boxes seem to have a healthier following here and long may it continue. Maybe the ability, or necessity, to spend a lot of dosh on a "real" (sic again) concertina instils a degree of snobbery?
Just don't get your moothie out in a harmonica group! ;)
-
What Old Leaky says is true, although I think the situation is rather complex. If it's snobbery, I don't think it's do with price but with the character of the instrument.
The difference between a cheap melodeon and an expensive one is simply one of quality. Often the biggest difference is in the construction of the case and action rather than the reeds. There is considerable variation in the sound across all types of melodeons (and which you prefer isn't necessarily dependent on cost) but they all sound like melodeons.
With hybrid concertinas, it's almost a different instrument - they not only sound different from more expensive concertinas, they sound different from cheaper concertina-reeded ones too. The fact is they don't sound entirely like concertinas (or like melodeons for that matter), although many people find the sound perfectly acceptable. However a hybrid is probably a much better choice for most players than a vintage concertina of a similar value, which may sound more concertina-like but won't play as well. Hybrids play extremely well and sound very good - just a bit different. Using reeds with a different tone is a necessary compromise to achieve the desired quality within a certain price bracket.
Hybrid concertinas fill a gap which doesn't exist in the melodeon world, where there is a continuum between cheap and cheerful up to the top of the range, and you can find an instrument to suit your budget. Until the hybrids came along, the choice was between affordable but not very good and high-quality but very expensive instruments. Most people would say that a small (sometimes barely detectable) difference in timbre is a price worth paying.
-
I have heard a high quality accordion reeded concertina. It sounded absolutely stunning and I preferred the sound to a conventionally reeded one. There are good examples and bad examples of everything - but as Howard says, they are different instruments and deserve to be treated as such, taking them as they are.
-
.. and let us not forget that Colin Dipper makes a "Franglo" concertina reeded, hex boxed, button matrix both ended, melodeon!
The concept came from Emanuel Pariselle - who has at least two of these chimeras. Ordered mine .. hmmm .. nearly 10 years now ;) but I'll see 'em all at Ch.d'Ars and maybe ginger things along :|glug
:|glug :|glug .. :|glug
-
I have heard a high quality accordion reeded concertina. It sounded absolutely stunning and I preferred the sound to a conventionally reeded one.
All the hybrids I've seen are superb instruments, and sound great. Not quite like a traditional concertina, but that's a matter of taste. To obtain equivalent quality from a traditionally-made 'tina you'd probably have to pay at least double, and to justify that you've got to be a reasonably good player (or seriously aspire to be one) and be fairly well off. For a serious player who isn't fortunate enough to have a spare few thousand quid, a hybrid is the obvious choice. They fill a much-need gap in the market, and I think they're great. I'm fortunate enough to have traditional 'tinas, but I would certainly consider one of these if I was buying now.
The prices of Jeffries simply spiralled out of control, due entirely to brand snobbery among the worldwide Irish Tradition Music crowd. It's possible to obtain 'tinas of similar quality by other makers for less, including Crabbs, which is ironic as Jeffries were supplied by Crabb with parts and even entire instruments.
It's also worth noting that this applies almost entirely to Anglos (again, driven by ITM demand) and that other systems are relatively cheaper - duets in particular.
-
I reckon the key difference is the material used for the shoes. Concertina reeds are usually set in brass shoes which is heavier than zinc/aluminium etc. Tone is good, but the trade-off is extra weight. Hybrids use melodeon reeds, so they are light, fast and bright but lack a certain depth of tone. Horses for courses really.
-
I don't know about the heaviness of the shoe, but Brass has a lower loss coefficient than Zinc, according to a graph in my notes. Copper Alloys also do well on the E.eta line. That might have an influence? Not sure how and I seem to remember diatonix saying that the difference between brass and steel plates was fairly negligible.
-
I'm afraid my knowledge of thermodynamics isn't all it should be, but basically: More mass = lower absorbtion of energy = longer, stronger vibration, ie better sustain and more volume. Hence the difference in sound between mahogany and rosewood backed guitars, and by extension, brass and zinc/aluminium shoed reeds.
-
I'm afraid my knowledge of thermodynamics isn't all it should be, but basically: More mass = lower absorbtion of energy = longer, stronger vibration, ie better sustain and more volume. Hence the difference in sound between mahogany and rosewood backed guitars, and by extension, brass and zinc/aluminium shoed reeds.
Density:
Aluminium 2.7
Zinc 7.1
Brass 8.4
So as far as mass is concerned both brass and zinc are more than 2.5 times as dense as Aluminium. So we should expect that the benefits of tone should apply to brass and zinc.
-
Interesting - Never realised zinc was as dense as that. It certainly explains the difference in sound with the old hohner zinc plate reeds though. Only trouble here would be the problem of oxidisation (although it could help prevent alzheimers) - I've never seen a concertina with zinc shoes. Were they ever made?
-
On a visit to Colin Dipper, I suggested that the vent holes in the reed pan, at the back of the reeds looked very small, and could they be enlarged. His response was that if you did, it would sound like an accordion.
Graham
-
I'm afraid my knowledge of thermodynamics isn't all it should be, but basically: More mass = lower absorbtion of energy = longer, stronger vibration, ie better sustain and more volume. Hence the difference in sound between mahogany and rosewood backed guitars, and by extension, brass and zinc/aluminium shoed reeds.
It's actually quite complex in every sense of the term. Basically the energy reflected at an accoustic couple is proportional to the difference of the squares of accoustic impedance, and contrary to intuition, heavy things have low impedance (think "railway lines singing"). Impedence here means the opposite of ability to transmit.
In ultrasound this means that both as dense stone or a buble of air in a kidney give the same 99.99% reflecivity and look the same until the patient moves. But against a dense steel reed/rivet a heavy metal might actually hit the accoustic "sweet spot" and transmit energy!
I suspect this wouldn't matter as there would then be poor transmission at the metal/wood interface. But it's pretty complicated as the thin layer of wax would make this a double interface! AFAIR Colin still used brass. I "think" he once experimented with aluminium pan .. or was that ends?
-
Crabb used aluminium reed frames. My concertina has them and still sounds like a concertina.
-
Hybrid concertinas may not sound exactly like the real thing but they definitely serve a useful purpose; especially the Rochelle. I had picked up a Hohner 20-button on a lark, and was doing OK with it, then I got a Rochelle for Christmas a couple years ago and it was like night and day; the purists may not think it's a "real concertina" but it's a very decent instrument as far as I'm concerned. I am normally a Hohner loyalist, being a blues harp player from way back and the proud owner of a '50s German-made Pokerwork; but I've come to think Hohner should be forcibly prevented from manufacturing and selling the leaky, unresponsive monstrosities which they claim are "concertinas." I live in a country where concertinas are mostly unheard of and I tend not to have a lot of money these days, so a proper concertina is generally out of reach both financially and availability-wise; but I'm slowly saving for a better hybrid.
On a slightly more reed-related tack, I've always wondered if a manufacturer of Indian harmonium reeds might not take too much retooling to be able to produce lower-cost proper concertina reeds; in the first place harmonium reeds are individual rather than paired, and on brass plates. Even if that would be unworkable they'd quite likely still be able to make relatively inexpensive reeds that, while not *exactly* concertina reeds, would be more conducive to traditional concertina reed pan construction (and hence quite likely traditional concertina sound) than melodeon reeds are.
-
I have a Hybrid...can't understand the snobbery about hybrid V antique concertinas. If I'm paying a lot of -for me - money I'd rather have something new. Plus I like the sound of a melodeon so a concertina with the same sound wouldn't bother me. ;)
I just wondered would having wood V metal ends affect the sound as well?
ps. I don't usually contribute to these technical threads (goes right over my head density, hertz etc.)...but i've always wondered the difference between concertina reeds etc was myself but was afraid to ask.
-
Just thinking aloud here as I'm really out of my depth (but thank you all for your replies), if you put high quality melodeon reeds in a hybrid would anyone really know the difference between them and concertina reeds unless they took it apart? When I play my Loffet in single voice it sounds a hell of a lot like my old C/G Lachenal.
Steve
-
Just thinking aloud here as I'm really out of my depth (but thank you all for your replies), if you put high quality melodeon reeds in a hybrid would anyone really know the difference between them and concertina reeds unless they took it apart? When I play my Loffet in single voice it sounds a hell of a lot like my old C/G Lachenal.
Steve
People will tell you it is easy to tell but they may well be the same people who pay vast amounts of money for oxygen enriched, atomically aligned speaker cables because it makes their hi-fi higher-fi ;)
-
Just thinking aloud here as I'm really out of my depth (but thank you all for your replies), if you put high quality melodeon reeds in a hybrid would anyone really know the difference between them and concertina reeds unless they took it apart? When I play my Loffet in single voice it sounds a hell of a lot like my old C/G Lachenal.
Steve
Most of the respected hybrid concertina makers do routinely use high quality accordion-type reeds. Marcus, A.C Norman, Tedrow, Edgley, Herrington, Morse, etc., all produce fine concertinas which play (and sound) very well indeed. As far as I'm aware the reed quality is tipo a mano as a minimum, and more often a mano. I've owned a Marcus myself and have had a good play on some of the others. In my opinion, Morse instruments are particularly good.
The sound of a good quality hybrid is slightly different from that of a traditionally reeded concertina, but it is still nevertheless a concertina sound, and not a melodeon or accordion sound.
Like Howard says in an earlier post:
They [hybrids] fill a much-need gap in the market, and I think they're great. I'm fortunate enough to have traditional concertinas, but I would certainly consider one of these if I was buying now.
I completely agree with this.
-
I have a Hybrid...can't understand the snobbery about hybrid V antique concertinas. If I'm paying a lot of -for me - money I'd rather have something new. Plus I like the sound of a melodeon so a concertina with the same sound wouldn't bother me. ;)
I just wondered would having wood V metal ends affect the sound as well?
What's the point in having a concertina then? ??? A concertina should sound like a concertina and a melodeon should sound like a melodeon.
-
What's the point in having a concertina then? ??? A concertina should sound like a concertina and a melodeon should sound like a melodeon.
They play differently for a start, Concertinas are far less bulky too - ideal for the Tina player who prefers the powerful sound of a melodeon .....
This is why I went out of my way to search out an original 1st revision Hohner Student-1 PA - it`s a basically a Pokerwork with unisonoric reed tongues and a mini keyboard jammed in where the fingerboard goes and it SOUNDS like a Pokerwork with that loud rude raucous sound unlike any other PA (including later REVs of the Student-1) , so why not get a real pokerwork ? - well I have one and it`ll be a long time til I can play it as well .
-
[I have heard a high quality accordion reeded concertina. It sounded absolutely stunning and I preferred the sound to a conventionally reeded one]
in fact, someone on the concertina.net site did a blind "taste test" asking folks who had no clue as to "concertina reeds" or "accordion reeds" and no clue was "supposed" to be better, which one's sound they liked better, and i believe the vote was unanimous or nearly so, in favor of the accordion-reeded one. i love both. and i admit that my love of the "concertina reed" sound was acquired. acquired by the emotional version of pavlovian conditioning. i came to associate it with county clare and the clare music and players i love. but "objectively," i like the accordion-reeded sound as much if not better....
i believe wim wakker has stated that concertina reeds are more responsive in the sense of giving a more nuanced spectrum of expressive dynamics....or dynamic expression.
whether or not the hybrids all use premium or "hand-type" reeds i don't know. but they don't all use the same make or label reeds. and their reed response and/or speed is not identical. same with the button-mechanism speed/response. they vary. i like the sound of all of them. but they have different strengths and weaknesses and these will appear differently depending on subjective taste and playing emphasis....
-
The first time I heard Jackie Daly I thought he was playing a concertina! That was back in the days when all you heard was wet tuned Hohners.....
-
The first time I heard Jackie Daly I thought he was playing a concertina!
Are you sure he wasn't? He does, you know, or at least he used to.
-
It is my understanding that the "Morse" concertinas are fitted with a "dural" quality reed.
I,too, enjoy the accordeon reeded sound in a concertina.
-
It is my understanding that the "Morse" concertinas are fitted with a "dural" quality reed.
I,too, enjoy the accordeon reeded sound in a concertina.
Yes, I did some work on a Morse English last week that was fitted with Dural reeds.
-
The first time I heard Jackie Daly I thought he was playing a concertina!
Are you sure he wasn't? He does, you know, or at least he used to.
Yep - still does as far as I am aware.
-
It is my understanding that the "Morse" concertinas are fitted with a "dural" quality reed.
I,too, enjoy the accordeon reeded sound in a concertina.
Yes, I did some work on a Morse English last week that was fitted with Dural reeds.
Ah - that's interesting. I thought they were TAM (see my earlier post). Perhaps I've been misinformed. I will query my source of information.
-
What's the point in having a concertina then? ??? A concertina should sound like a concertina and a melodeon should sound like a melodeon.
Well firstly a hybrid sounds like just that. Not one thing nor t'other. But also, there are substantial advantages to having a concertina that sounds like a melodeon. A duet concertina anyway, the others are a bit strange.
-
A hybrid concertina plays like a concertina.
-
They may use different grades of reed in different models, and may have changed over time too.
-
The first time I heard Jackie Daly I thought he was playing a concertina!
Are you sure he wasn't? He does, you know, or at least he used to.
I knew he did (and still does!) - but it was a track when he wasn't playing his 'tina!
-
What's the point in having a concertina then? ??? A concertina should sound like a concertina and a melodeon should sound like a melodeon.
You can't play four parts on a melodeon. You can't play inversions in the bass end. OK the Gods amongst us may be able to, but most can't, yet I can do so on an anglo. You would struggle to play a classical violin part on a melodeon but an English was designed to that.
In all honesty once I get out of the cheap and cheerful end I struggle to tell the difference between a traditional concertina and a hybrid.
IMHO there's a lot of snobbery around amongst those who can afford classic instruments who don't like the idea that maybe a modern hybrid instrument might be as good..
Steve
-
I owned a Jeffries. I had another on loan to me. Both 38 button models.
I have played 4 of the Morse instruments.
I can afford another Jeffries, even at the current prices. Would I buy one? No.
I find I prefer to play the Morse.
-
The label "ITM" is that adopted by the players themselves, on concertina.net, The Session and elsewhere. I don't see why you should feel touchy about it. There are other informal groupings covering other musical genres, including in the UK English, Welsh and Scottish, French and Scandinavian, but they don't have the same global reach which Irish music has achieved.
There is no doubt that many Jeffries are very fine instruments, and they have a particular quality of sound which many prize, not just in ITM. However is also true that there are many other high-quality instruments out there (and many ITM professionals play other makes). Before the global recession burst the bubble, it was very apparent that there was a very strong demand from ITM players in particular who insisted on buying Jeffries. As well as driving up prices disproportionately, it led to a very high proportion the ebay scams , including some fakes.
Of course players will want the very best instruments and rightly so (especially professionals, although it seems the market was by no means driven by professionals), however this did appear to smack of 'brand snobbery'. It was the brand name which mattered, and Jeffries instruments were attracting premiums of thousands of pounds or dollars which seemed disproportionate to their supposed better quality (and by no means all the instruments achieving high prices were good quality). There was far less interest in other high-quality brands, including Crabb (who supplied Jeffries) and their prices were considerably lower. In fairness, not all this demand came from ITM, but the majority did and there can be little doubt that the global revival of interest in concertinas is driven by the spread of ITM.
There are anecdotal reports on concertina.net that to be taken seriously in some ITM circles, and particularly competitions, only a Jeffries would do, and that parents of children who showed promise as players felt pressured to obtain one.
Demanding the best is one thing, and the best may well be a Jeffries. However, even if you think they're better than anything else, the premium which was being obtained was disproportionate - they're not that much better. Basing buying decisions on brand name rather than actual quality is another thing entirely, and it seems to be this which was driving the market.
As for 'begrudgery', I admire Jeffries instruments but I play a Crabb and a Dipper, both high-quality instruments which cost me far less than a Jeffries would, so I have no need to feel hard done by.
-
About 15 years ago (ie before the internet) a dealer drove almost the length of the country to see my 30 key C Jeffries which was not far off a basket case. I didn't think much of the tone either - that's not true I actively disliked it.
He was happy to pay £2200 knowing it would be a complete rebuild and told me he would still make a profit on the Irish market. He explained that on the competition circuit many parents felt a Jeffries was a must for their child and would pay big money to get one.
I also had an octagonal 40key Crabb Anglo made for me in about 1972. It was a wonder to hear and left the Jeffries standing for tone.
At the time I knew a man called Eric Holland whose Wheatstone (mid 20thC) had an even more beautiful tone. I love melodeons but have yet to hear one that matched those 2 instruments and had always supposed it was down to the reeds.
Just an anecdote - I make no claim to be an expert.
-
I don't think XYZ "crowd" is derogatory in British English, it merely implies people of common interest ("ITM" is a new one on me!) "Fraternity" would also be pretty neutral, even neutral wrt gender in the right context.
XYZ "clique" would imply a measure of exclusivity. XYZ "cronies" or "mafia" - now that would be derogatory! I read Howard's post as entirely friendly.
-
I was going to suggest 'circle', but notice Howard beat me to it (and it seems to be acceptable... )
-
I certainly hadn't intended "crowd" to be derogatory, and as Chris has said I don't think that's not how it would usually be interpreted on this side of the water. However if it caused offence I will gladly apologise.
-
… as Chris has said I don't think that's not how it would usually be interpreted on this side …
Grrr, is he suggesting I've gone native Liverpudlian? >:E
No, a real Scouser would use a triple negative ;)