Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on May 18, 2012, 08:06:38 AM

Title: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 18, 2012, 08:06:38 AM
When I practice - which I do a lot - I get this pain in the back of my head/neck. It's a sort of stiffness in the hard bony part of the head just about level with my ears and spreading downwards.  This means that I don't tend to play for more than about fifteen minutes at a stretch because it becomes too uncomfortable which is a real nuisance as I want to keep going. It soon wears off when I stop.

It's not the weight of the box as I get this even when I'm playing my Ericas.  I use two very comfortable straps and I get the pain sitting or standing.

Is this a common thing with box players and is there a remedy?

Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Lester on May 18, 2012, 08:11:01 AM
I find if I am learning a tune (practising) I get various sorts of pains and put it down to being tense due to the "stress" of having to read music/follow a recording/keep getting it wrong etc. Once the tunes are embedded and I relax I can play with little pain other than in my damaged left shoulder.
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Lester on May 18, 2012, 08:21:35 AM
I have just viewed you latest blog and would opine that you set up for the Erica is a bit awkward looking, too high and a bit too far to your right and the keyboard tilted on the vertical thus forcing your right arm into an odd shape. You look much more at ease with the Saltarelle, which is set lower and further left plus your use of the thumb behind also moves your right hand to a better position.

Now I am a single strap and player and I believe (hopefully George is not listening) that it give a better, more natural position for you right arm

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvqibo1cbbg (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvqibo1cbbg)

YMMV  :-)
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 18, 2012, 08:35:53 AM
Yes I know what you mean. My straps are at the maximum length on my Ericas so maybe I'll use one of my Saltarelle straps as a single on the Hohner and give your method a go. Just dont tell George!  Like you, I get tense when I'm working on a piece and I'm sure that's a lot of it.  I'll let you know how I get on.
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Theo on May 18, 2012, 08:44:11 AM
I get tense when I'm working on a piece

Try learning by listening to a recording over and over, preferably while doing something else.  I often learn new tunes by putting a single CD track on repeat play and letting it play for maybe an hour a day over several days.   By then I've memorised the tune without conscious effort and the final process of working it out on the box is very much more relaxed.
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Lester on May 18, 2012, 08:55:46 AM
Yes I know what you mean. My straps are at the maximum length on my Ericas so maybe I'll use one of my Saltarelle straps as a single on the Hohner and give your method a go. Just dont tell George!  Like you, I get tense when I'm working on a piece and I'm sure that's a lot of it.  I'll let you know how I get on.

Being of more generous proportions than your good self I find a standard strap to be too short for single strap work and I recommend a Mally Strap (http://www.mally.com/details.asp?id=468)

Or for a quick fix pop to Pets-R-Us (other pet shops are available), get a suitable dog collar to make a strap extender
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: george garside on May 18, 2012, 09:51:46 AM
sometimes the (TWO!) straps need slight lengthening  for the taller person.  This can easily & cheaply be done by adding a pair of those 'dog lead' type clips ( they have a specal name?) that are readily available from camping  & outdoor shops.  I use one of these on the top right hand strap connection on my 3 row box so I can unclip it and leave the back strap on, I first  came accross this idea on a Shand Morino  owned by morris man Andy Banks  of ? Birmingham  -ish about 30 years ago

george  - who will now be away for a few days so the onestrapists can have an uninterupted field day! ;)
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Hello on May 18, 2012, 09:57:20 AM
Oooooh Matron!
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Lyra on May 18, 2012, 10:04:28 AM
"onestrapists" - melodeon players who don't say much? Or who make great beer?
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: malcolmbebb on May 18, 2012, 11:21:21 AM

Try learning by listening to a recording over and over, preferably while doing something else.  I often learn new tunes by putting a single CD track on repeat play and letting it play for maybe an hour a day over several days.   By then I've memorised the tune without conscious effort and the final process of working it out on the box is very much more relaxed.

By which time everyone else within earshot is climbing the walls and gibbering...  :o

PS am I right in thinking that Mally's straps are a bit longer than most?
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 18, 2012, 11:24:19 AM
Yes I know what you mean. My straps are at the maximum length on my Ericas so maybe I'll use one of my Saltarelle straps as a single on the Hohner and give your method a go. Just dont tell George!  Like you, I get tense when I'm working on a piece and I'm sure that's a lot of it.  I'll let you know how I get on.

Being of more generous proportions than your good self I find a standard strap to be too short for single strap work and I recommend a Mally Strap (http://www.mally.com/details.asp?id=468)

Or for a quick fix pop to Pets-R-Us (other pet shops are available), get a suitable dog collar to make a strap extender

Ok - just tried my Saltarelle straps on my Erica.  Using only one didn't work for me - too much wobble so I went for two.  Much better!  I can now can put the thumb round the back of the treble board and can control the whole thing much better.  Still a bit painful but not as bad.  I'll have a drive down to our local pet store and see what I can find to lengthen my two sets of Hohner straps as I now have an undressed Saltarelle shivering in the corner!! ;)
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Rob2Hook on May 18, 2012, 11:26:05 AM
Or for a quick fix pop to Pets-R-Us (other pet shops are available), get a suitable dog collar to make a strap extender

Probably not quite as embarassing - offering collars up to your box - as it is trying them for fit around your calves for mounting bells...

Rob.
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: malcolmbebb on May 18, 2012, 11:32:37 AM
Or for a quick fix pop to Pets-R-Us (other pet shops are available), get a suitable dog collar to make a strap extender

Probably not quite as embarassing - offering collars up to your box - as it is trying them for fit around your calves for mounting bells...

Rob.

LOL -  ;D you get used to it after you've made a few - I still have to live down the trawling through the charity shops looking for an old leather skirt.
For the bell pads - for the bell pads!!

Although my wife no longer looks askance at me bringing home iems of female (outer) clothing from charity shops, as long as they're leather :M
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 18, 2012, 11:46:09 AM
"onestrapists" - melodeon players who don't say much? Or who make great beer?

Brilliant!! (:)
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Mcgrooger on May 18, 2012, 11:49:51 AM
The pain does sound like a combination of tension which is easy to get when concentrating hard on a tune and strap positions and I also think yours look a bit high. For me, the most secure and comfortable sitting position is one strap, legs crossed, RH end of the box jammed agains right leg as here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v-I8qYG4jGM
The only time I tend to use two straps is to play standing up when I use my own (un)patented method where my left strap starts too long which allows me to lift it over my head to come over my right shoulder as shown at the very beginning of this vid here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoIQFhLlyjU
Recently when I stood in for our box player at a gig playing stood up for a whole evening, although I used my 2 strap method, I spent most the time with my foot raised on my box so that I could have used a single strap. This is because I don't use the double strap method much at all these days so didn't feel like I had enough control.
I also tend to have the straps on my main boxes lengthened using shortish climbing slings and I'm not as tall as you.
Completely separate from straps, I'd suggest you take regular breaks and walk around do some shoulder rolls, neck turns etc. and loosen up that whole area. Good luck - neck pain's 'orrible.

Editied - to unjumble my legs when sitting!
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Quebecois on May 18, 2012, 12:07:10 PM
See how you keep your shoulders while you play. Sometimes the arms posture or the weight of the accordion lead to some "shrugging" and this can generate pain. If possible have someone else check and/or massage the base of your neck to see if there is some tension there. When you pick up your melodeon and set the straps in place, just before playing, try relaxing your shoulders muscles and let the straps take the weight without shrugging.
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 18, 2012, 12:30:44 PM
See how you keep your shoulders while you play. Sometimes the arms posture or the weight of the accordion lead to some "shrugging" and this can generate pain. If possible have someone else check and/or massage the base of your neck to see if there is some tension there. When you pick up your melodeon and set the straps in place, just before playing, try relaxing your shoulders muscles and let the straps take the weight without shrugging.

Thanks for this.  Just checked and I've definitely been shrugging without realising it.  Think this might really help!
Title: Re: Pain in the neck!
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 18, 2012, 04:14:01 PM
The pain does sound like a combination of tension which is easy to get when concentrating hard on a tune and strap positions and I also think yours look a bit high. For me, the most secure and comfortable sitting position is one strap, legs crossed, RH end of the box jammed agains right leg as here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v-I8qYG4jGM
The only time I tend to use two straps is to play standing up when I use my own (un)patented method where my left strap starts too long which allows me to lift it over my head to come over my right shoulder as shown at the very beginning of this vid here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoIQFhLlyjU
Recently when I stood in for our box player at a gig playing stood up for a whole evening, although I used my 2 strap method, I spent most the time with my foot raised on my box so that I could have used a single strap. This is because I don't use the double strap method much at all these days so didn't feel like I had enough control.
I also tend to have the straps on my main boxes lengthened using shortish climbing slings and I'm not as tall as you.
Completely separate from straps, I'd suggest you take regular breaks and walk around do some shoulder rolls, neck turns etc. and loosen up that whole area. Good luck - neck pain's 'orrible.

Editied - to unjumble my legs when sitting!

Thanks Steve - definitely going to try your suggestions. ;)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal