Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: RobinA on May 24, 2012, 04:59:57 PM
-
Hi. I'm yet another newbie, with a melodeon on order that I will receive next week. I am in Florida - I take it many of the people here are from the UK - is there a US-based group I should be posting in instead?
I have to say first that it was the Anahata Bear Dance video on YouTube that I stumbled upon by accident that inspired me to want to learn the melodeon. At the advice of some of the forum members, I'm starting with a D/G Pokerwork and will see what happens from there. I have long been a sufferer (beneficiary?) of I(nstrument)AD, having 20-some instruments at my house, including 3 piano accordions. So if I love this as much as I think, the Pokerwork may have company in time.
In looking at the button layout, I have to wonder why there is a B-Major in the bass, as B-minor would seem to be a more logical choice. I play a lot of the session tunes from the Dave Mallinson books, and b-minor seems to be a more useful chord. But I imagine it will all make sense at some point.
My Pokerwork arrives next week, but we're at the beginning of a 6-week work/family related road trip, so it will be a little later in the summer before I can spend any serious time with it.
-
Welcome to the forum. As the music theory nerd of the group ..
1. Our D/G is a 'transposed' French G/C designed in the early 60's
The corresponding chord is Em on that machine
2. A lot of continental music is in harmonic minor (French: generally Amharmonic)
3. The V or "dominant" chord for this scale is E7, in D/G terms that would be B7
4. But melodeon basses don't do 4 note chords - we get only B,D#,F# = B major - it works!
5. That's the correct tonal/harmonic chord for E harmonic minor
.. but most of our anglo/american folk tradition is modal, and on our kit E aeolian (G row notes with a C natural) or E dorian (derived from D row notes, C#) .. run very nicely. You are right. B minor is the chord for these. The usual solutions are to tape out the D# reed, or get Theo to re-tune it to Bm, or buy a box with a stop to "take out thirds".
.. loads more chat on this perenial issue if you use the search facility. Chris
-
The B major functions as the V chord for E minor. You can get a Bm7 by using the B base with the DMaj chord button. Some people do re-tune the B maj to min. Another way around it is to have the thirds taken out. One of the fun things about the 8 bass is figuring out all the possible unusual chords you can get out of the available standard buttons. There is a thread on here somewhere about that.
-
I have to say first that it was the Anahata Bear Dance video on YouTube that I stumbled upon by accident that inspired me to want to learn the melodeon.
I deny all responsibility for corrupting innocent young minds!
(no, really I'm hugely flattered - thank you)
In looking at the button layout, I have to wonder why there is a B-Major in the bass, as B-minor would seem to be a more logical choice.
As has been said, some D/G boxes are made with B minor chord (My Oakwood D/G box, for example) and it does have many uses. But the Bear Dance in the video you mentioned makes good use of a B major. That box has also had the F natural/D# accidentals switched so the D# is on push, which means it actually fits with the B major chord.
There's quite a few melnetters your side of the ocean, but I think you'll find they are typically separated by hundred of miles from each other. Your local melodeon-playing community is HERE!.
Anyway, welcome to melnet and I hope you enjoy your Pokerwork when it arrives. Melodeons are strange animals, hugely rewarding and frustrating at the same time. Good luck with it. If you already play other instruments you'll be fine.
-
Thank you everyone! I've actually watched that Bear Dance video at least 25 times, plus everyone else's renditions as well. It's all really good PR to spread the word about the instrument. I was just surfing around listening to Celtic accordion music when I happened across it.
I won't go taping the third on my b-major just yet, but will see how I do with it for a while before making any changes.
I really appreciate all the good information here. It's already been very helpful.
thanks!!
-
Welcome to the forum, Robin!
Just adding to what the others have written here...
In my opinion, keeping the B major chord is the best option. Why? If you have a B major chord, you can
- play B major when you need it
- play Bm7* when you need a minor chord. It also sounds great ;)
On the other hand, if you have a B minor chord, you don't have an option to play B major. You're stuck irrevocably with B minor.
I once had an instrument which had been customised so it had a B minor chord. It was great at first, but after a few months I began to really miss the B major option, which seemed to be needed in a surprising number of tunes. :(
In the end I sold the box for various reasons, but I would not now buy another one with a B minor chord.
* Bm7 = push B bass note with a push D chord
-
Isn't it interesting how different players have different opinions on this? My box (a Salterelle Nuage) has Bm, and I've been playing it for so long that I'd forgotten that the 'normal' arrangement is B Maj. Bm is the relative minor scale to D, so it seems to go naturally with having a D major scale.
Unlike Steve, I am very happy with Bm and have no wish to change. Perhaps this is because I am an entirely "seat-of-the-pants" harmoniser, unconstrained by any thoughts or knowledge of what should be the "right" chord ;)
I don't think there is a right or wrong answer to this - it depends on the type of music you want to play, and how you want to play it.
-
I don't think there is a right or wrong answer to this - it depends on the type of music you want to play, and how you want to play it.
Exactly, and it is part of general limitedness of the diatonic box. You can't have everything, you just have to use the limitations to find creative ways round the things that you can't do.
-
I don't think there is a right or wrong answer to this - it depends on the type of music you want to play, and how you want to play it.
Exactly, and it is part of general limitedness of the diatonic box. You can't have everything, you just have to use the limitations to find creative ways round the things that you can't do.
seconded!
george
-
I think that the B Major chord is very useful, and I partially agree with Steve in saying that that the Bm7 option sounds just as good- I think it does in tunes where the Bm is a passing chord like in "Sweeps hornpipe" or "All in a garden green", but for tunes mainly in Bm- eg "If you will not have me you may let me go", "Jack Lintell's Hornpipe" the Bm7 doesn't have quite the mournful quality needed IMO.
I guess it comes down to personal preference, and as others have said, the repetoir you play, so if you keep wishing you had a Bminor, get the chord retuned! My preference is strongly for having a stop to take out 3rds and I wouldn't ever want to have a main box without this option, partly beacuse I think the sparser chords can be usefull for backings that are more droney and chord based rather than very rhythmic.
-
I partially agree with Steve in saying that that the Bm7 option sounds just as good- I think it does in tunes where the Bm is a passing chord like in "Sweeps hornpipe" or "All in a garden green", but for tunes mainly in Bm- eg "If you will not have me you may let me go", "Jack Lintell's Hornpipe" the Bm7 doesn't have quite the mournful quality needed IMO.
Funnily enough , I'm now playing "If you will not have me you may let me go" on my new(ish) Dino Baffetti Pro prototype which does have a B major, but I play it with the thirds cut out. In theory it should go well on my Oakwood with the B minor chord, but for some reason the box doesn't sound quite right for that tune.
I guess it comes down to personal preference, and as others have said, the repetoire you play
That's it exactly. As Theo says, any melodeon has its limitations, and there are certain tunes that work well with some tunings, and others that work well with others. You can't play them all with out faking something, and there's lots of of music you can't play on any melodeon.
I'm currently learning Kreuzgriffiger (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JVdtcUberVw), which is really a Steirische Harmonika tune. It turns out to be an excellent fit on a C/F Club, if I start in C, (that video is in B flat but she's playing a F/Bâ™/Eâ™/Aâ™ box!) but I have to skip some basses and chords especially where it goes into G. A real G/C/F Steirische would get it all, and a standard "Vienna" two row without the Gleichton (in other words a typical English melodeon) would be so seriously limited I'm not even going to try to play it on one.
-
I deny all responsibility for corrupting innocent young minds!
I think, for that, you would need the Bare dance ;)
-
I think, for that, you would need the Bare dance ;)
There are other sites than YouTube for that sort of thing.
Er, allegedly. ;)