Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Andy Simpson on May 24, 2012, 11:02:37 PM

Title: Pignol-Milleret Layout?
Post by: Andy Simpson on May 24, 2012, 11:02:37 PM
Is there actually such a thing?, each diagram I've seen is different.

I haven't seen any of the Mustradem books but La Maison De L'Accordéon give the option of two different MP layouts for a new Castagnari and there's a third different one on Marc Serafini's site. What's up with that?. :o
Title: Re: Pignol-Milleret Layout?
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 25, 2012, 06:57:18 AM
quick graphics Google  ...  Here's the system, but not the precise layout as they play Gaillards on an 11/12/11 matrix

Push    F#    Eb     F     F#      G#      F       F#     Eb     F       F#       
     Bb     A      C      E      A       C        E        A       C       E       A   
Db    D     G        B       D     G       B      D      G        B        D        G


Pull      Db    Eb     G     Bb      Db      Eb      G      Bb     Db     Eb       
     Ab     B      D       F      Ab      B       D        F      Ab       B      D   
E     F#      A       C      E       F#      A      C       E       F#        A      C

Pignol describes this as Sol + La mineur harmonique + accidenteaux and his aim is full chromaticity on pull - where 80%+ of his playing, and all his impro happens. G row (black) is normal, his Am row relates to C diatonic but a different push/pull run, and importantly a sharpened "G"=Ab note. The rest is accidentals, including a (bizarrely) displaced G note!

I've played this game myself and (essentially mathematically) a melodeon is one button short of 2 diatonic scales+all accidentals on pull unless you side  slip the accs row and lose symmetry in the process. By getting that Ab onto a diatonic row Pignol/Milleret  achieved their goal

(http://chrisryall.net/img/pignmilchrom.png)

Ahah you say, his main (middle row) C scale has now become an obscure mode of the Harmonic minor?  True - but there are workarounds, and  I don't think I've ever seen this fella play "up and down the rows"  ;)
Title: Re: Pignol-Milleret Layout?
Post by: waltzman on May 28, 2012, 09:08:25 PM
The ten button helper row club system, I believe, is fully chromatic on the draw for more than two octaves.  I wonder what advantage the Pignol-milleret system has over the older club system.  Weltmiester makes a G/C club system tuning.
Title: Re: Pignol-Milleret Layout?
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 29, 2012, 08:10:15 AM
It actually only lacks Ab on push, so right hand chord sequences can be played fluently. On stage one of them will generally be chording, while the other runs tune or improvises. eg this suite plinn (in Cm, so there's and Ab in half the chords) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XibgD1YQy8s

I think for impro purposes the 'linear' nature of the chromatic (and thus any) scale on pull is a positive. My own kit has a note "you have to go back to" making you use brain when you should be using the Force  ;) In this respect I found X/Y with 2 accidental buttons really awkward when trying to play off piste.  But then it wasn't designed for that, was it?

I clubbed mine for a summer but it drove me mad - too old to relearn - but yes that has great logic.  Francois Heim's accordion is essentially club plus helpers. Actually any system works and you get used to what you have. But if you want complete chord voicings you need all notes in at least one direction.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal