Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: melodyman on October 06, 2008, 02:29:25 PM

Title: Recording Devices
Post by: melodyman on October 06, 2008, 02:29:25 PM
Dear all

What I want is a portable recording device that ticks the following boxes:-

1) Can play back without the need to connect to P.C or other.
2) Is not so small that with my old eyes and lack of comprehensive I.T skill I can operate it easily.
3) Is battery powered.

Thats all - I have a Zen which I find to fiddly and long winded to set up and no internal speakers
               Also have a small dictation MP3 but the quality is poor and no internal speakers.

Your Thoughts Please

Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Falseknight on October 06, 2008, 03:01:31 PM
Zoom H2.

My wife (secondary music teacher) uses one for capturing exam performances and classroom progress checks.  Dead easy - and you can play with the files on PC afterwards if you need to.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: melodyman on October 06, 2008, 03:47:23 PM
Zoom H2.

This looks the ticket

Has it got internal Speakers

Thanks
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Falseknight on October 06, 2008, 03:57:30 PM
No - headphone socket.  Internal speakers aren't usually a good idea when field recording - feedback!
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Lester on October 06, 2008, 05:28:01 PM
Zoom H2 is definitely the bees knees. Also use it as a USB mic directly into my PC using Audacity.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Quebecois on October 06, 2008, 05:47:06 PM
I vote for the H2 as well! Unbeatable for features/price ratio. Looks cool too.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Bill Young on October 06, 2008, 05:54:43 PM
I too absolutely endorse the Zoom H2. In addition to its normal uses, I have used it as a personal monitor so that I can hear myself playing in loud groups: internal accordion mic -> external mic socket on H2 (3 levels of sensitivity) -> recording standby mode -> single earpiece in headphone socket (volume control). Voila, I can hear myself in one ear and the group with the other, instead of the group with both and myself with neither.

If you really want an internal speaker, there are many office voice recorders on the market which might suit you.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: C age ing on October 06, 2008, 06:37:08 PM
Agree with all of them, H2 is the way to go. Have minus 7.5 prescription and cataracts but find that I can read and operate it. It has two forms of stereo recording and a useful 'surround' sound system so you can plonk it down in the middle of the group and get 'em in all their horror.
Old Bill.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Stiamh on October 06, 2008, 09:18:18 PM
Must admit the H2 looks good and from what I can read it has a few advantages over what I have, the Edirol R-09. Particularly:

1) the fact that you can split files, and thus trim or edit tracks, on the machine itself (which you could do on a minidisc but not on the R-09, although a recent firmware upgrade does allow you to start a new track in the middle of a recording).

2) the fact that it can use USB power while connected to a computer, and act as a microphone

3) it also looks a little more compact

4) is a bit cheaper.

Another annoying feature of the R-09 is the two-stage hinged door that allows access to the SD card and batteries. Every time I use it I expect the thing to break.

The R-09 It does its recording job very well, at least. Has anybody used both and have any comments to make?

Steve:

Edited to add: some comparisons here: http://www.wingfieldaudio.com/portable-recorder-reviews.html

A couple of the models shown have speaker monitors. The Marantz looks very good, if a bit pricier than the H2 and R-09.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Quebecois on October 06, 2008, 09:34:17 PM
I have a friend who has the R-09 and tried a H2, he says the R-09 is a bit more convenient to use in a session because the screen and buttons are larger and easier to see in the dark, but it seems that the recording has a little less noise on the H2. The H2 has nice microphone modeling features. But the price is the big decision point, it's about 40% cheaper than the Roland.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Bryson on October 06, 2008, 09:48:06 PM
I can only endorse the above sentiments on the Zoom H2.
I have used it for about 6 months now and in contexts as varied as sessions, ceilidh nights, my own internet development (an English language learning site) and practice sessions it has has proved to be first rate in all respects.
Buy a larger flash card eg at least 4GB (they take up to 16GB cards). This allows six hours of high grade stereo recording or something like 36+ hours at a decent MP3 quality.

One tiny drawback is that utilising a direct USB link from the H2 uses only USB 1. When I bought mine the two 4GB flash cards that I ordered came with a free USB adaptor which uses USB 2+ standards. If you are moving large files the differences is substantial.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Steve Fox on October 06, 2008, 10:47:12 PM
Zoom H2 is definitely the bees knees. Also use it as a USB mic directly into my PC using Audacity.

Does anyone know if it can be used as an input source with Garage Band on a Mac?
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Bryson on October 07, 2008, 06:35:05 AM
The H2 records as wav files 44.1kHz/16bit up tp 96kHz/24bit or as mp3 48k to 320k or mp3 VBR - variable bit rate - this means it samples at bit rates depending on the information in the input source.
So you could use it with any software that can import wav or mp3 files. The wav files are Windows PCM format.
Hope that helps
cheers
Bryson
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Pushpull on October 07, 2008, 09:17:06 AM
Zoom H2 is definitely the bees knees. Also use it as a USB mic directly into my PC using Audacity.

Does anyone know if it can be used as an input source with Garage Band on a Mac?

Another endorsement for the the H2 from me. Yes it can be used as a USB stereo mic on a mac, though I tend to record onto the H2 and transfer WAV files (I agree with the dismally slow file transfer, though you can stick the SD card in a USB 2 card reader for the transfer). Though if you are multi-tracking going straight into Garageband would be more convenient.

The only issue I have with it is that it seems to get through rechargeble batteries much quicker than I would have thought - though that might be down to the batteries I'm using or the charger.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Bill Young on October 07, 2008, 09:38:43 AM
The only issue I have with it is that it seems to get through rechargeble batteries much quicker than I would have thought - though that might be down to the batteries I'm using or the charger.

I haven't logged the time from a set of batteries, but I'm happy with the duration of a pair of 2800mAh NiMh batteries from 7DayShop.com (http://www.7dayshop.com/catalog/default.php?cat=3&type=3060&man=0&filterwords=AA&go=SEARCH&comp=). I use their V6500 charger. A fellow Roland FR3 owner has recently reported slightly better results from the Panasonic rechargeables from the same source.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Geoffleft on October 07, 2008, 01:16:40 PM
Yup. The H2 is definitely the current machine. Especially for the price.

 I find a couple of issues a bit wanting though...batteries don't go far.......flashing red recording led's are a definite no no in the hallowed environs of the session table........ and these days I'm so blind that I can't read the display to check my recording status without making an obvious point of it. One sometimes likes to be unobtrusive in session recording, and if your'e stuffing around with your reading glasses, well everybody knows you aren't about to read a book. Not at our session anyway as I think reading is banned there.

Great machine. I love the way it downloads on to the computer. And how long did we have to wait for it to appear on the market? Too long! I'm glad it finally got here though.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Ian Powis on October 08, 2008, 10:16:33 PM
I have a Boss Micro BR unit which is very easy to use for quick recordings and is about the same price as the H2 I think.  I did do a direct recording comparison with a friends H4 unit recently and the H4 was definitely better, and that's comparing the H4's internal mics with the Boss Micro plus external Sony ECM MS907, so would be interesting to see how it compares with the H2.  Anyway it's fine for what I use it for - quick recordings of new tunes to then try and learn back at home!  The Boss is more aimed at guitarists I think.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: melodyman on October 12, 2008, 11:30:36 PM
Dear All

Just to say thanks for all your help and advice

Decided on the H4-coulndn't resist the four track recording capability.

Had it a couple of days now and yes the navigation through the menu's
is somewhat tricky but it will get quicker.

Overall really pleased with it.

Ta
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 11, 2009, 09:48:19 AM
Yes, I've just encountered the same problem with the H2 battery life - in my case less than two hours with what I thought were newly recharged batteries.  And the worst of it is that if you don't notice that the battereies are about to run out, it seems to corrupt the file, and you can't get at the bit that was recorded OK.

Is there a way around this, does anyone know?

Chris
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Theo on January 11, 2009, 01:02:00 PM
The Edirol R09 seems to die gracefully when the batteries run out,  I've not lost any recordings as s result.  My old MD recorder was even worse than the H2.  If the batteries died while it was recording then the whole contents of the disc was corrupted.
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Glassguy on January 11, 2009, 04:49:42 PM
Hello all,

New man here. Must tell you how much I am enjoying exploring this site. I am finding tons of great info.

If I may join this discussion with a vote for the Tascam DR1. I have had one for about six months. Very intuitive to operate. Records to wave and MP3 files onto a removable SD card. It also has a built in tuner and metronome. It will slow down a selection by 50% while retaining pitch, and has the ability to save a slice of a tune and loop it. Downloads to computer by usb and I bought a separate plug in transformer to save battery life when using it in place

Hope this helps
Best regards

Bob
Title: Re: Recording Devices
Post by: Quebecois on January 11, 2009, 06:01:40 PM
The Edirol R09 seems to die gracefully when the batteries run out <snip>
As the old adage says, you get what you pay for!  I am a fan of the H2 but it has its drawbacks.

The Edirol R09 was designed with the professional in mind, so it is better put together with a better user interface and safeguard features. The H2 is an "entry-level" recording device, they had to cut corners to offer it at that price!

 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal