Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Adam-T on May 26, 2012, 05:32:24 PM

Title: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Adam-T on May 26, 2012, 05:32:24 PM
Hokay folks just HAD to ask, someone Must have before and I`m sure everyone knows this except me - so here goes ..

Whats the whole "Black Dot" thing about with the Double Ray ? . normally a funny feeling (or looking) button on button boxes denotes a Unisonoric button or "Gleichton" but the curvy shaped pearloid Double Ray is just semitone tuned Erica, Right? (I`m sure I`ve seen semitone tuned actual Ericas but not in B/C) so why the confusing black button? , it's not even the Start button, in fact it`s exactly where the "Gleichton" would be if Hohner were to put one on the outer Row.....

BTW don`t lose the "Gleichton" off your Club-3 , it could be mistaken for a lemon flavoured Rowntrees Fruit gum..
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Bill Young on May 26, 2012, 06:21:43 PM
It's the start button of the B row. Cf the Hohner Trichord, which has black buttons on the B,C and C# buttons on the respective rows. Better than the colour is the cross hatching - it just lets you know where you are. Possibly the brainchild of Charles Forbes, Dundee, who commissioned the Double Ray from Hohner in the 1930s.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: strad on May 26, 2012, 08:30:39 PM
Have found the cross-hatched buttons useful locators, no matter what state I'm in!!

Nigel
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Adam-T on May 26, 2012, 08:41:16 PM
I didn`t realise that the B row was button SIX Start, but then I never got on with the B-Row when I had a B/C hence the D/G pokerwork and a 1 row in C ..

Funny how they used the black dot for the start of the B row and not the C row and the Erica doesn`t have anything .... Clubs of course have cross hatching on the "Gleichton". it`d be more use on the Start buttons given the extra accidentals on the 30 button Club models but it`s useful wherever it is.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: mory on May 26, 2012, 09:06:11 PM
It is the second octave B on the B row and nicely placed as the centre button visually ( which it couldn't be on the 10 button C row), you get the same on the double ray deluxe AtB mory
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Adam-T on May 26, 2012, 09:51:14 PM
It is the second octave B on the B row and nicely placed as the centre button visually ( which it couldn't be on the 10 button C row), you get the same on the double ray deluxe AtB mory

Double ray deluxe being a Corso .. still odd why the different naming and the black button - why aren`t they all just Ericas and Corsos and all have (or not) a black button ? .
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Bill Young on May 26, 2012, 10:12:45 PM
The Double Ray Black Dot was introduced in the 1930s; the Erica in 1955,  so what's your point here? Have you tried addressing your question to Hohner?
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: FlatNote on May 26, 2012, 10:44:02 PM
An indication of the central key button on a row with an odd number of buttons is a good idea, particularly if it is tactile as well as visual.  So making the 6th button on the outside row of a 21 button Erica in some way distinct might, indeed, not be a bad thing from a player's point of view.  Perhaps Hohner don't do it precisely so that an Erica will look different from a BlackDot. Although very similar in all other respects they typically do have quite different types of tuning system and a visual indication of which class the box falls into is not a bad idea from the marketing point of view.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Adam-T on May 27, 2012, 07:49:55 AM
The Double Ray Black Dot was introduced in the 1930s; the Erica in 1955,  so what's your point here? Have you tried addressing your question to Hohner?

The Erika was "Erica" of the square original Double ray period so the two lines have run side by side from early days. my point is merely one of curiosity .. I guess the answer really is that no one really knows why the difference between the respective models, I just thought there`d be some history to it or something especially as you can buy other Hohner boxes in a host of different keys without visible difference . I have Emailed Hohner in the past and got no reply..

I know that Hohner do all sorts of things, there are numerous PAs from their past which are the same model but a different name and they mix and match parts wherever too (for instance my Atlantic has Morino reeds in but not all did) but the Black dot business always intrigued me ..
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: mory on May 27, 2012, 09:59:50 AM
It is the second octave B on the B row and nicely placed as the centre button visually ( which it couldn't be on the 10 button C row), you get the same on the double ray deluxe AtB mory

Double ray deluxe being a Corso .. still odd why the different naming and the black button - why aren`t they all just Ericas and Corsos and all have (or not) a black button ? .
double ray deluxe being a double ray deluxe, if it was a corso it would be a corso  ;)
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Theo on May 27, 2012, 10:17:38 AM

The Erika was "Erica" of the square original Double ray period
Not really, they are different models with almost every component being a different size. True there is a family resemblance, buy probably the only interchangeable part between Erika and Erica is the buttons, and the strap brackets. :o

Hohner's naming scheme is a complete shambles with isolated areas of logic, but trying to learn anything useful from similar names is a waste of time.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 27, 2012, 10:45:37 AM
We humans eh?
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Adam-T on May 27, 2012, 12:06:48 PM
Hohner's naming scheme is a complete shambles with isolated areas of logic

LOL - great explanation . PA models are a total mixup. and Yeah, Ebor, I`m as human as it gets ;) to my disadvantage sometimes.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: rees on May 27, 2012, 09:29:48 PM
There was a tutor book (probably by Forbes of Dundee) for the B/C Double Ray.
It was called "The Black Dot System" - so there you have it  (:)
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Mutt on May 29, 2012, 07:23:39 PM
. . . in fact it`s exactly where the "Gleichton" would be if Hohner were to put one on the outer Row.....

I read, years ago, that originally it WAS a Gleichtone. I wish I could remember my source.  :(
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Stiamh on May 29, 2012, 07:37:13 PM
It's worse than a useless ornament in my opinion: ugly for starters and I hate the feel of the cross-hatching under my fingers. Do they come off easily?

Mike R is doing a spot of after-sales tweaking on my Rowbotham special D-R at the moment, and I've asked him to move the black button to the highest note of the outside row. (Get it out of the way _and_, since it will be invisible there, make the rows look symmetrical with the extra low button Mike retrofitted to the inside row.)    8)
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Adam-T on May 29, 2012, 08:33:21 PM
You should be able to get a normal button from Charlie Marshall, Theo may even have a few yellowed old ones about to match the others (depending on how old your box is of course) ..

I didn`t know the later ones (the ones without the swastika) had a cross-hatched button, I thought they were just like the rest but black.

The comical thing is that Club boxes which actually have a button which behaves different to the rest make do with a same colour button ! (Cross hatched of course but the same colour)
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Christopher K. on May 29, 2012, 10:47:04 PM
That's a nice looking keyboard. Those might be real MOP buttons and so the gleichton is only cross-hatched, not dyed. I have an old 30s Club with MOP buttons of uniform color and no hatching on the gleichton at all.

Personally, I like the Double-Ray's single black key. There's something pleasingly deliberate about its placement and I enjoy its visual effect, the way it is set off by black keyboard cover, gold tape and paint, red celluloid and white buttons. A black DR Deluxe with black pearl keys and a red dot would be cool, too. I've seen photographs of a few accordions, I want to say they were Jorginas, that had darker buttons for the accidentals at the end of the keyboard. Those looked cool, too.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Adam-T on May 30, 2012, 07:05:45 AM
That's a nice looking keyboard. Those might be real MOP buttons and so the gleichton is only cross-hatched, not dyed.

I honestly don`t know what they`re made of, whatever it is, it seems to go all the way through the button . Regarding the Black Dot, I guess there`s one really good excuse for it - you can tell which box is B/C and which is D/G in a dark pub after a few pints when writing is a blur so you don`t grab the Erica by mistake  ;D
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: malcolmbebb on May 30, 2012, 08:32:46 AM
I have an old 30s Club with MOP buttons of uniform color and no hatching on the gleichton at all.

What (in this context!) is MOP?
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Theo on May 30, 2012, 08:36:08 AM
Mother of pearl, ie shell.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Lester on May 30, 2012, 08:39:12 AM
I have an old 30s Club with MOP buttons of uniform color and no hatching on the gleichton at all.

What (in this context!) is MOP?

Mother of Pearl at a guess, but more likely to be Mother of Toiletseat  ;)
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: malcolmbebb on May 30, 2012, 08:49:25 AM
Thanks guys - Theo for the explanation, and Lester for giving me something to ponder for the rest of the morning.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: Lester on May 30, 2012, 09:01:37 AM
Nacre aka Mother of Pearl (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nacre)

Perloid aka Mother of Toiletseat (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pearloid)
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: malcolmbebb on May 30, 2012, 09:15:12 AM
I wondered what they did with the big oval bit they cut out the middle. Now I know.

Postscript:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pearloid
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: triskel on September 06, 2013, 09:28:21 PM
Whats the whole "Black Dot" thing about with the Double Ray ?

We had a thread about this on the old Forum: http://forum1.aimoo.com/melodeon/melodeon-net/Latest-News-From-Scotland-Ref--1-608268.html (http://forum1.aimoo.com/melodeon/melodeon-net/Latest-News-From-Scotland-Ref--1-608268.html), but basically it was all down to Forbes of Dundee and their instruction method.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: rees on September 06, 2013, 10:28:27 PM
Whats the whole "Black Dot" thing about with the Double Ray ?

We had a thread about this on the old Forum: http://forum1.aimoo.com/melodeon/melodeon-net/Latest-News-From-Scotland-Ref--1-608268.html (http://forum1.aimoo.com/melodeon/melodeon-net/Latest-News-From-Scotland-Ref--1-608268.html), but basically it was all down to Forbes of Dundee and their instruction method.

I heard that too.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: george garside on September 06, 2013, 11:03:04 PM
the black dots simply provide a reference point  as on the push they play the keynote of each row. Same goes on the three rows of a trichord.  Its quite useful as a guide to initial positioning of the fingers in much the same way as the indented bass notes  as navigational aids on stradella bass

george
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: triskel on September 07, 2013, 06:30:10 PM
the black dots simply provide a reference point

It does, but the Black Dot was designed specifically to be used in conjunction with The Forbes Easy Graphic Method book, a copy of which was originally supplied with them, and the way the music is written out (in tablature) in the Forbes method (on "a piano stave of 2 x five lines, with an additional line added in between. The notes on the outside row being represented by the 11 lines, those on the inside by the 10 spaces in between them. Notes written with the stem upwards are on the press, stem downwards on the draw") the black button is a navigational aid denoting the two notes on the added middle line:

Quote
"The sixth (or middle) line is more distinct than the others, and in the DOUBLE-RAY Accordeon the sixth, or middle, key is black." (from The Forbes Easy Graphic Method.)

Mind you, it was a time when Hohner were doing great business promoting the setting-up of piano accordion, Club Model and harmonica bands, and perhaps it was felt that the hatched button might somehow make potential players associate these new "Double-Ray" button accordions with the Club Models that were so fashionable and successful at the time. After all, we know from the Method that it was hoped that people would form B/C "Accordeon Clubs TODAY!" across the UK...  :||: :|||: :||:
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: pikey on September 07, 2013, 06:48:56 PM
. . . in fact it`s exactly where the "Gleichton" would be if Hohner were to put one on the outer Row.....

I read, years ago, that originally it WAS a Gleichtone. I wish I could remember my source.  :(

It was on the early black dots that I borrowed back in the late 1970s.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: rees on September 07, 2013, 08:18:24 PM
. . . in fact it`s exactly where the "Gleichton" would be if Hohner were to put one on the outer Row.....

I read, years ago, that originally it WAS a Gleichtone. I wish I could remember my source.  :(

It was on the early black dots that I borrowed back in the late 1970s.

Unusual. I must have handled hundreds of these and never seen one with a gleichton.
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: george garside on September 07, 2013, 08:58:43 PM
neither haave I.  My first box was a double rahy about 1956 when me and a mate bought a pair of them - we new nowt about music and played on the row in B & C although we didn't even no what keys we were in but at least we could play together.  It was some years later that I suddenly found myself playing the bluebell polka in 3 different keys  but again hadn't a clue which they were! Much  later it transpired that I had got it right and was playing in G,D & C   -- but definitely without any club type jiggery pokery or gleishy thingies!

george
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: KLR on September 08, 2013, 05:25:15 AM
Hey Stephen, great to see you post here again, have learned an awful lot from your writings here and elsewhere.  It's great fun informing people that the original idea for a 2 row accordion with the rows a semitone apart came from "George Jones."  No, not the recently deceased country and western singer.  ;D  That, and how they came up with the same idea in Irish America as a way to play tangos, foxtrots, 2 steps...

Speaking of button color coding, found this exceedingly garish CBA on a nearby Craiglist:

(http://images.craigslist.org/00q0q_4JZxX4l1cQ0_600x450.jpg)

Item description:  "Chromatic Accordion, M&M system, just kidding. in fair condition, Swiss Model, Wilhelm Tell"  Yum! 
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: martin p on September 09, 2013, 03:51:52 PM
Fascinating thread this as I recently acquired an old Double-Ray B/C box in need of tlc. Any idea why Hohner called these boxes  "Double Ray" in the first place?
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: triskel on September 10, 2013, 09:48:47 PM
Any idea why Hohner called these boxes  "Double-Ray" in the first place?

Hohner probably didn't, it was more likely Forbes who came up with the name - perhaps a bit of Scots dialect for "double-row" (= "two-row"), as opposed to "single-ray" (= "one-row")  ?

Though maybe that should be twa-raw... :-\
Title: Re: Hokay, whats the "Black Dot" about ?
Post by: an bosca ceoil on September 10, 2013, 09:58:39 PM
Possibly the way a German misheard it?
Was it not a similar misunderstanding that resulted in accordions getting badged up as Sutherlands?
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal