Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Nick Hudis on October 08, 2008, 12:00:32 PM
-
A few weeks back on the Melodeon !st or 2nd class Citizen thread, I expressed my reservations, as a new player about going to sessions. Ptarmigan replied as follows:
So go for it Nick, you won't regret it ... & do come back & tell us how you got on.
So here's my report. Encouraged by Theo, I took my self off to the Cumberland Arms "anything but Irish" session. First time I took my wife rather than my box, she's quieter for a start, and a very discerning classical musician. She was impressed!
It was a very friendly affair and I was delighted to find an old aquaintance who I hadn't seen in five years or so. Little bamboozled by the tunes though. With my patchy repetoire of southern english country dance tunes and few Playfords and hebredian tunes, I didn't recognize a single tune among the ?northumbrian and Swedish tunes being played. Couldn't even work out the keys half of the time.
Anyway, I brought a box to the next session, began to make a few friends and even managed to play a couple of tunes when someone thought it would be a joke to play Davey Nick Nack. Getting better on the keys too. Tip for beginners: if the fiddles are really singing and you can't work out the key- its probably A major. A nice young man with a table full of harmonicas played my box for me most of the evening (one talented guy!) and I just enjoyed listening.
Two things did strike me. Firstly the amazing standard of playing. I don't remember anything like this from my youth when I was more into the folk scene. I was driven away from the folk scene in the early eighties by the inexorable encroachment of gormless folk rolk and angst ridden contempory songs on the traditional music that I loved. I only came back to folk music a few years ago, and there seem to have a been a bit of a revolution in playing standards in the last 20 years. (particularly fiddles) Great!!!!
The other thing was that it gladdens my heart to see so many younger people playing. When I was a teenager in the late 70s I was considered a total weirdo for being into trad music. all my friends listened to Genesis, Yes and Pink Floydd while I was hitching out to Suffolk pubs to try to hear a traditional singer or two.
I am still not sure that the double bass, guitar, cittern, piano and several melodeons were all playing the same chords! But I can see myself bcoming a regular at the Cumberland. Its a great pub too with good beer.
Nick
-
I am still not sure that the double bass, guitar, cittern, piano and several melodeons were all playing the same chords!
They weren't ;D
-
Sound like a great session last night, I'm only sorry that some virus has me in its clutches and I was unable to be there.
The ABI session at the Cumberland is often as you describe, but it is a pretty exceptional session. There are some astoundingly good young players who are regulars there who are also remarkably tolerant of my very ordinary playing ability. Partly it is the result of the people who have been drawn to Tyneside for the folk degree course, but its not all students.
-
I'm on the folk degree and usually go to the ABI session. Missed it last night as I was booked at Stanley folk club. Sounds lik Will was there playing harmonicas then!
Being a Sussex boy myself, I've had to adapt to the tunes they play, but I always get a few well known southern tunes in that everyone knows too. So next time we're there I'll play some tunes like Davy Nick nack.
And no.... we never all play the same chords in there!
-
Being a Sussex boy myself, I've had to adapt to the tunes they play, but I always get a few well known southern tunes in that everyone knows too. So next time we're there I'll play some tunes like Davy Nick nack.
Pip, I'll introduce myself next time. I'm the scrawny looking middleaged guy with a ponytail and a nice looking (and sounding) Verde box that he can't play. I'd enjoy the odd well known tune.
-
I always thought of Davy Nick Nack as a Scottish tune.
That may start another thread drift
-
It can't be Scottish - it's crap!
-
It's in:
Rev.R.Harrison's MS,c1815,Cumbria,
George Spencer m/s, Leeds,1831,
CarlisleMS,Anon.c1812.
Which makes it English, probably ;)
-
I always thought of Davy Nick Nack as a Scottish tune.
That may start another thread drift
I wasn't suggesting it was a sussex tune, so much as a well known one! IT's just the last time I was in the Cumberland many sussex tunes got played, which was nice. But I know them (I started them!) so all the other stuff needs to be played too, so I can learn it!
-
The reason so many Sussex tunes got played may have been due to the fact that i was there as well (me also being from Sussex and hence the old phrase (that i made up just now) 2 Sussex musicians in the north are braver than one).
I have only been to the Cumberland twice now, but i have found it to be a really nice friendly session and will gladly go again.
MQ
-
It can't be Scottish - it's crap!
I've always thought Davy Davy Nick Nack was as Scottish as Oor Wullie's bucket (http://bp2.blogger.com/_XsVALQtGIZM/RwUz9z6A9SI/AAAAAAAACDM/djUp4Idaj2Y/s1600-h/Oor+Wullie.jpg).
It's hackneyed to death for sure, but it ain't crap. It just depends what you do with a tune - e.g. what Blowzabella do with it - kicks in at 1:24 on this video... (http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=xcPBS-Jfb_E)
Ed J
-
To paraphrase Johnson, when a man is tired of Davy Davy Knick Knack he is tired of music. Any fool can learn hard tunes with lots of notes in, but when you can play DDKK ten times through and make people want to dance all the way through then you're a real musician.
-
It's hackneyed to death for sure, but it ain't crap. It just depends what you do with a tune - e.g. what Blowzabella do with it - kicks in at 1:24 on this video... (http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=xcPBS-Jfb_E)
Ah - but that tune is known as 'New Road to Alston', but I hadn't realised before now that it is Davy Davy Knick Knack in a minor key.
And I do agree with Ed that DDKK is most certainly not crap. Even the best tunes (what ever they are?) can be made to sound dull and boring if the musicians play them that way.
-
Well if it's no crap it must be Scottish! ;)
-
Looking for common ground here, Waltham... Is someone a real musician if they can play DDKK 10 times and make people want to dance all the way through - and still think it's, er, a less than stellar tune?
-
I was only able to listen to 30 seconds of DDKK(never heard of it before).Maybe I had to be there,dancing and enjoying that barrage of noise.
Chris
-
... but that tune is known as 'New Road to Alston', but I hadn't realised before now that it is Davy Davy Knick Knack in a minor key.
Thanks Steve, bought the album this is on at Sidmouth and couldn't work out why it sounded so familiar.
-
I was only able to listen to 30 seconds of DDKK(never heard of it before).
Sorry Chris - the sound balance on the YouTube clip is fairly dire. 'Tis a bit of a bloomin racket...
I just used it as a rough and ready example... DDKK isn't on the clip, it's New Road to Alston. DDKK is in a major key - see here... (http://www.thesession.org/tunes/display/3697#comments)
...and still think it's, er, a less than stellar tune?
Going from the comments on thesession.org... if it affronts the cool of the trad-polizei, then it's a solid 24 carat tune IMHO. 8) As is the Bluebell Polka, or any other hoary hackneyed old pot-boiler... love 'em all! ;D
Ed J
-
The Session.org is usually good for tunes (though I did have a job trying to find the abc's for such a very well-known session tune as "The Wrong Trousers"); it's only the Discussions which attract people who take themselves ever so seriously - and even then it's mostly (no insult intended to anyone here :-[ ) Americans who like to think of themselves as Irish, rather than Irishpersons, who take things this far, bless them.
Chris-the-not-really-anonymous-at-all.
::)
PS. I really enjoy playing pot-boilers - there's less chance of me hitting bum notes.
C.
-
No apologies necessary Ejay.Maybe I have to hear the tune properly to appreciate it.I do love the Bluebell polka though.
Chris
-
hoary hackneyed old pot-boiler...
Hackneyed is just a state of mind, Tunes are usually played to death because they are good/popular.
Just every now and then I drag out The Streets of London (note for note McTell version on guitar). The audience groan noticeably, join the first chorus reluctantly, but are singing their hearts out by the end of the song. Why would that be then? Probably because it's a good, well scripted song with a rock solid simple tune and a great hook that anyone can sing because the range isn't too great.
The Bluebell Polka is a flashy sounding piece with a fairly moderate level of difficulty; played well it's a pretty, jolly little tune that deserves playing well and often imho. Tunes like this only become tiresome when played too often by musicians who are not yet capable of making them come alive. That'll be why I never play it then ... :-[
-
A well run, ordinary open session should always include some of the better known tunes to give the newer and less experienced players a chance to join in. It's really up to whoever is running the session to see that nobody is excluded from being able to make some input at some point. Unfortunately there are always those who never miss out on the chance to try to steal the show with something that they know nobody else can play so they can bask in solo glory. Sad really. At one time the skill was to pick what to play so everyone would join in playing or singing or whatever. Nowadays it sometimes seems to be more of a case of picking something that everybody else can't play....
Mike
-
At one time the skill was to pick what to play so everyone would join in playing or singing or whatever. Nowadays it sometimes seems to be more of a case of picking something that everybody else can't play....
Again though if the whole session is tunes that everyone knows & joins in, it can sound a bit samey and therefore drab to other people. Again its getting the balance right!
-
. At one time the skill was to pick what to play so everyone would join in playing or singing or whatever. Nowadays it sometimes seems to be more of a case of picking something that everybody else can't play....
Mike
Quite agree Mike. those who seem to prefer to play with themselves would be better placed in a singaround/playaround format of event where everybody gets a few minutes to do their party piece if they so desire. A session is almost by definition a gathering of musicians playing together & whilst not everybody will know every tune several , probably different, participants will be able to join in each tune. In the session I lead I actively discourage the playing of tunes by anybody wanting to show off thier sunday best that nobody else can play. I try to run only tunes that at least 30% of those present are willing and able(ish) to have a go at.
george
-
There's a regular and popular weekly session near where I live that does give a bit of room for "soloists" to try something out that they might feel stands a chance of becoming a tune that may become accepted by the rest. However, we also have a once a month "mobile English session" that is in a different location each month but always out in the bar with the locals (having thoroughly sussed the pub out and being sure that the landlord thinks it would go down Ok with his regulars) - and that's been doing well too. At that one we stick to tunes that most of us can join in with as part of the fun is putting on a bit of a show. It's great when the non-folkie people in the pub clap, join in and generally tell you that they've enjoyed it. For me, that's what it's about (or certainly where it's come from) and I would much rather do that than be in one of the closed door sessions. But then we're all different.
Mike
-
Thanks fo rememberig the non-virtuoso, George!
:-*
Chris.