Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Mike Hirst on May 31, 2012, 10:16:46 AM

Title: Old Pitch
Post by: Mike Hirst on May 31, 2012, 10:16:46 AM
As long as I have been playing I have heard people talk about old pitch. Usually in the context of retuning older instruments. Although I am familiar with the term the exact definition has remained obscure. As a seeker of arcane knowledge I have found these two concertina.net (http://www.concertina.net/) posts invaluable:


The table below shows values extracted from the concertina.net posting. Values are stated in relation to the currently accepted standard of A=440Hz.

Old Pitch434.91
New Philharmonic438.95
Modern440
Society of Arts445.68
Old Philharmonic454.08

I am curious to know how these values relate to older melodeons and button accordions. Are there regional variations? Were different pitch standards used by makers in Klingenthal from thoise used in Stradella? Is there a date after which old piches cease to be used, or is there period through which many different tunings were used?
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Graham Spencer on May 31, 2012, 10:32:26 AM
The only old pitch instruments I have any direct experience of have been German, and all have been within a gnat's crotchet of A=435.

Graham
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Theo on May 31, 2012, 12:25:43 PM
Yes, lots of pre WW2 German instruments are in A=435, in the case of Hohners it is sometimes marked on the instrument but expresses as 870.
It is still common for recent instruments to be tuned to 441, 442 or even occasionally 443, especially piano accordions.  I've come across many modern Italian diatonics that are at 442.
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Lyra on May 31, 2012, 01:52:40 PM
Shedloads of symphony orchestras tune to 442 (and Germans even 443 and up) - although melodeon concertos are thin on the ground. Mayhap a gap in the market  ;)
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Anahata on May 31, 2012, 03:36:58 PM
We have at home an old Lachenal EC with brass reeds which is considerably sharper than 440.
I have long been aware that there's no such (single) thing as 'old pitch' and it depends of how old and evidently where.

I might measure the EC when I get home tonight and see if it's actually Soc. of Arts, Old Philharmonic or neither. I suspect it's close to the 456 of Old Philharmonic because it's at least a quarter tone sharp, and at A=440, Bflat would be 466, putting 456 a little higher than halfway between.
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 31, 2012, 05:47:17 PM
I used to have A Bbgpipe in that pitch  ;D
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: forrest on May 31, 2012, 08:28:35 PM
I have an old Jones concertina, Circa 1882, in Philharmonic pitch...Its a bit hard to pin down because it is tuned in an unequal temperament. But A=about 450Hz though. Of course the older German instruments were quite flat from this, probably leading to inability to play nicely together in sessions and ultimately resulting in conflict.  :||: >:( :P :||:
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: pgroff on May 31, 2012, 08:40:03 PM
True enough, most of the London-made concertinas in high pitch are based around A 446 - 453 and don't play well with low-pitch german instruments.  But I do have one semi-miniature C/G anglo concertina with some Jones and some Jeffries features that is in such a high pitch (around 458 - 460) that its key of D works pretty well together with low-pitch (A 435)  Hohner Preciosas played in the key of Eb.

Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Adam-T on May 31, 2012, 09:22:58 PM
Shedloads of symphony orchestras tune to 442 (and Germans even 443 and up) - although melodeon concertos are thin on the ground. Mayhap a gap in the market  ;)

Priceless - LOL ...... "Das Pokerwerk" - a Melodeon Symphony in D/G , no need to buy tickets, you`ll hear it for miles
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Mike Hirst on July 17, 2012, 11:45:29 PM
I spent some time trawling through old forum postings this afternoon. I came across these two items, which match very closely with the original thrust of this thread.

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5211.msg65867.html#msg65867

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4436.msg56101.html#msg56101

In my original post I was looking for information and ideas that might help in determining the instruments (and playing position) used in recording the source cylinder and disc recordings for the (1978?) Topic release Melodeon Greats. I have in my own collection copies of several of the later discs included on this collection, as well as many others from the same era. Despite spending time carefully digitising the archive sources, using pro quality transcription equipment, I have found it difficult to determine the key (or keys) of the instruments played.

I have recently taken delivery of an International Chromatic in G/G#. Although this is not in perfect condition the tuning remains close enough to original for it to match very closely with the disc and cylinder recordings. There is much to be learned here. I intend spending some time with the tuner to document the exact pitches. I would be keen to share this with others whose mindset is of a similar ilk.

With ref to Paul's postings re determining the intended tuning, my instrument has a very clear letter G impressed on the rear of the fingerboard. As with the instruments described in past postings it is difficult to tell whether this is a high G/G# or low Ab/A. Indeed, prior to noticing the imprinted marking I had assumed it to be in the higher key.

It is my intention to restore the instrument to playing condition (I find the action and the weight of the instrument very favourable). With this in mind it will probably be the case that the instrument will be brought up to current concert pitch (A=440Hz), so, documenting the pitches of the reeds as I find them will be important. I will be keen to look into any possible quirks which are evident in the tuning and may decide to perpetuate these through the pitch adjustment.
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Christopher K. on July 19, 2012, 06:01:05 PM
Quote
In my original post I was looking for information and ideas that might help in determining the instruments (and playing position) used in recording the source cylinder and disc recordings for the (1978?) Topic release Melodeon Greats. I have in my own collection copies of several of the later discs included on this collection, as well as many others from the same era. Despite spending time carefully digitising the archive sources, using pro quality transcription equipment, I have found it difficult to determine the key (or keys) of the instruments played.

Is there a speed controversy (using the word 'controversy' lightly) with these recordings? I recall the debate regarding the correct speed for Robert Johnson's records, and I have some hillbilly instrumentals on 78 which were presumably sped up to make them livelier or to fit on the disc. I'd think the former is more likely with up-tempo recordings.
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Strigulino on July 19, 2012, 06:42:00 PM
Priceless - LOL ...... "Das Pokerwerk" - a Melodeon Symphony in D/G , no need to buy tickets, you`ll hear it for miles

Don't knock it.  It worked for the ukelele.  I've seen the Ukelele Orchestra of Great Britain on the main stage at Guilfest. 

You'd have to play something out of genre though.  People love a genre-bending cover, myself included.  Presumably you've all seen this Shand/50 Cent mashup?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MnxO9XnZq_Y
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Theo on July 19, 2012, 06:48:25 PM

You'd have to play something out of genre though.  People love a genre-bending cover, myself included. 

Have you heard Simon Ritchie's Squeezebox Schizophrenia (http://www.x-tradition.com/)? Definitely genre-bending.
(http://www.melodeonmania.demon.co.uk/images/CD-new-2-TRANSreflec-.jpg)
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Anahata on July 19, 2012, 08:40:31 PM
Have you heard Simon Ritchie's Squeezebox Schizophrenia (http://www.x-tradition.com/)? Definitely genre-bending.

Got that. Totally amazing and wonderful.
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: mory on July 19, 2012, 09:20:34 PM
Thanks for that Strig, brilliant, it really comes together towards the end, hysterical  ;D AtB mory
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: oggiesnr on July 21, 2012, 07:33:39 AM
Tango bandoneons are still tuned to 442.

Steve
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Simon on August 02, 2012, 06:38:50 AM
Society of Arts445.68

Can they really tune that accurate? Btw I've read somewhere that they intended to use 444 but the tuning fork ended up a bit sharp. And even the 444 should have been 440, but something went wrong with conversion from C-frequency to A-frequency (using perfect intervals from A to C and equal temperament to get back to A again).[/td][/tr][/table]
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Peadar on November 19, 2020, 11:41:55 PM
I spent some time trawling through old forum postings this afternoon. I came across these two items, which match very closely with the original thrust of this thread.

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5211.msg65867.html#msg65867

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4436.msg56101.html#msg56101

In my original post I was looking for information and ideas that might help in determining the instruments (and playing position) used in recording the source cylinder and disc recordings for the (1978?) Topic release Melodeon Greats. I have in my own collection copies of several of the later discs included on this collection, as well as many others from the same era. Despite spending time carefully digitising the archive sources, using pro quality transcription equipment, I have found it difficult to determine the key (or keys) of the instruments played.

I have recently taken delivery of an International Chromatic in G/G#. Although this is not in perfect condition the tuning remains close enough to original for it to match very closely with the disc and cylinder recordings. There is much to be learned here. I intend spending some time with the tuner to document the exact pitches. I would be keen to share this with others whose mindset is of a similar ilk.

With ref to Paul's postings re determining the intended tuning, my instrument has a very clear letter G impressed on the rear of the fingerboard. As with the instruments described in past postings it is difficult to tell whether this is a high G/G# or low Ab/A. Indeed, prior to noticing the imprinted marking I had assumed it to be in the higher key.

It is my intention to restore the instrument to playing condition (I find the action and the weight of the instrument very favourable). With this in mind it will probably be the case that the instrument will be brought up to current concert pitch (A=440Hz), so, documenting the pitches of the reeds as I find them will be important. I will be keen to look into any possible quirks which are evident in the tuning and may decide to perpetuate these through the pitch adjustment.
Thread revival.
Turning over my still unrestored International (Wyper Patent) B/C I notice it has  both a "B" Label on the top and B stamped on the back of the keyboard. It's also in high pitch but I still haven't got a tuner fit to get the actual frequencies (in Hz) measured.
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: Theo on November 20, 2020, 08:05:37 AM
This is a useful tool for documenting all the pitches of an instrument:

http://www.mcgee-flutes.com/RTTA.htm

Available for iPhone and Android.

You have to do one row at a time because it doesn’t cope with repeated notes.
Title: Re: Old Pitch
Post by: CAB on November 20, 2020, 09:10:12 AM
I see Terry refers to Flutini, which I used to find helpful for checking the tuning of wooden flutes.  But wouldn't it be confused by a melodeon with a lot of tremolo?
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal