This has been discussed on this forum before, although not recently. As I recall the consensus view is that there is no hard and fast rule about this, but that it is mostly OK to do what is most comfortable for you.
Some players use all four fingers and there is a definite logic about this, but as Les has pointed out, some people have a weak little finger and prefer not to use it. If four fingers work for you, that's fine. You can also train yourself to use the little finger if you haven't already been using it up until now. However, many excellent players use only three fingers and their music is just fine.
Less useful and more restrictive is just using two fingers, and if you are a person who does this, it might really be worth trying to train yourself to use three.
Personally, I use three fingers. I occasionally use four but it's not particularly comfortable for me.
It's not so much whether your little finger is weak, it's how much shorter it is than the other fingers, and this varies a lot from person to person.
Mine is a good 2cm shorter than the third finger ...
I'd rather play comfortably with three fingers than uncomfortably with four.
People with a longer little finger may have a different opinion...
I'm guessing that there won't be many such people. My LH little finger is 27mm shorter than the 3rd, and I don't think my hand looks all that weird.
Maybe we should have a poll.
its not somuch the absolute length of the little finger that matters ( mine is 60cm) but the way the other fingers are relative to the buttonsand the same principle applies toboth treble and bass. If fingers 123 are arched in a sort of U shape so the tips come down on the buttons the business end of the pinky , positioned diagonally, will be more or less be in line with the other 3 'arriving' vertically.That is not to say that there arent other advantages ion oth ends of box in having little fingers that resemble snakes! Looking at photos & videos of Jimmy Shand his were long & snakelike and he certainly made very good use ofit on the treble end using 4 fingers most if not all of the time on the BCC# keyboard.Which is exactly what I meant about curling your fingers up -- you can do it, but I find it less comfortable than having them straighter, especially if on the bass end it means arching your hand back from the end of the box to allow the little finger to reach.
george
I have tried using two, three and four fingers on the basses and I prefer to use two. This decision is partly due to the length of my little finger, which is only 62 mm and is 32 mm shorter than my ring finger. I cannot reach the inner row of basses with my little finger other than by distorting the position of my whole hand to the detriment of comfort and of my ability to use my other fingers. I can use my first and little fingers on my Cajun one-row boxes, but when I need to use my middle two fingers as well on my 2.6 and 3 row boxes, I have to dispense with the little finger. Therefore I don't use it.
So why do I find two fingers easier than three, when my 2.6 row box has 14 bass buttons and my 3 row has 12 bass buttons? It has to do with an instinctive feel for where the buttons are. Using two fingers, it is always my middle finger that is looking for a bass button and my index finger that is looking for a chord button. I found that it didn't take much practice for my fingers to know instinctively how far to travel, even when moving, say, from the G/D basses at one end of the outer row to the F/B flat basses at the other end of the inside row. However, if I use three fingers, I find it more difficult to locate the buttons when moving from one end of the bass array to the other end. I think this is probably because using three fingers upsets the symmetry of always finding a fundamental button with my middle finger and a chord button with my index finger.
Others have clearly found it easier to use three fingers, probably because their brains are wired differently from mine and perhaps because their fingers are different in size and shape to mine.
its not somuch the absolute length of the little finger that matters ( mine is 60cm)
george
if 3 fingers are enough for 120 stradella bass buttons surely 2 can cope perfectly well with 8 buttonsOne advantage of using four fingers is that the second and third fingers aren't really independent, I believe they share a tendon.
george ;)
| Hmm :|glug you learn these little snippets as a student and get to use them 35 years later! :|glug Ahem, It's not a whole tendon .. there are usually 'slips' of tendon between the 'extensor digitorum' tendons. Like all anatomy it varies - which might explain some of the variance in advice on the subject. Some pianists are said to have had their slips snipped, I've never actually seen that. Ian's finger lifting exercise is valid - but note that it is finger 4 that is most constrained. For the purposes of this the thread the pinkie has its own 'extensor digiti minimi' [2] muscle the three other extensors are 'common'). Put there by God to confound all sophistry about left end technique it would seem? ::) Furthermore .. it's surely flexing the finger that is the weak movement and we all have 3 muscles for each finger there. So I think it's about practice and usage, that was also my experience. As I often put the 7th in on right hand chords I couldn't live without that pinkie. Could add that my short index ;) is involved, but I got away with a 'crush'. To concur with RobinA's H&S advice .. "don't do it at home, children" :o | (http://img.sparknotes.com/figures/E/eb57ee3c0bbce61d887722fc5931002b/muscles_of_the_hand_dorsal.jpg) |
Pretty sure I read somewhere that during the Hundred Years' War the French would cut off the first two fingers on the left hand of any captured melodeonist. Thus the V-sign originated as a gesture of defiance across the lines by the fit English melodeonists.
I think you'll find that the Tardis is fictional.Pretty sure I read somewhere that during the Hundred Years' War the French would cut off the first two fingers on the left hand of any captured melodeonist. Thus the V-sign originated as a gesture of defiance across the lines by the fit English melodeonists.They must have been melodeonists with a Tardis in order to show two fingers five centuries before the invention of the melodeon!
I think you'll find that the Tardis is fictional.
We are not talking "re"learning here. Yes, habits get ingrained. Lester posted his problems about unlearning. At slightly over 50 I tried inverting the D/E plate and stuck it for a season. New tunes - seemed to go OK. The multitude I'd learned over the years - kept hitting the wrong note - quite disastrously :|blOr they should get as many fingers in play as they find comfortable, which isn't quite the same thing :-)
This thread (look back a bit) is about advice to learners. I think that should be to get as many fingers in play as they can. Anything else will hold them back later.
Sound advice, I don't doubt, from someone who unquestionably knows his stuff. However to bring my little finger into play would involve completely relearning the left hand and changing my hand position, and for no advantage that I can see. I can comfortably get around all 8 buttons very well with 3. I'm used to using the little finger for guitar and concertina, so I'm able to bring it in when the need arises, but that isn't very often.
But I just cannot understand people sticking to two fingers.
This is the kind of attitude that I would like to see lessened on this issue (not just picking on you Howard, especially as you do use 3 fingers!). People saying "I am used to using 2/3 fingers and can't see the advantage of using 4". I used to use 2 fingers and switched to four. I now cannot imagine using 2. So much of what I do would be utterly impossible, and you might as well forget 12 bass boxes. I expect I could get used to 3 fingers and this would be better than nothing, but 2 fingers? Far too limiting.
I would summarise my attitude to this as follows: HAVE A GO. If you find that using four fingers is very uncomfortable, then this is a very good reason to give up. You don't want to strain your hand. But if it is comfortable then please do open up your horizons and give it a go, you may well find that it revitalises your playing, as it did mine. If four fingers is uncomfortable then try 3. It isn't impossible, but is a bit more difficult. As Ian says though, there are some things that you can do with three fingers which aren't difficult at all.
But I just cannot understand people sticking to two fingers.
I tend to use 3 fingers on the bass because if I use my pinky finger then my thumb in in the wrong place for the air button.I think I'm the same. I can use pinky on the nearest button only. Maybe the four finger people have less of a difference in length between little finger and others. My little finger only just reaches the outer knuckle joint of the finger next to it, with them all straight.
Is anyone out there still using ONE finger? :|glugEr, are we talking about melodeon basses here, or what? ;)
This is the kind of attitude that I would like to see lessened on this issue (not just picking on you Howard, especially as you do use 3 fingers!). People saying "I am used to using 2/3 fingers and can't see the advantage of using 4". I used to use 2 fingers and switched to four. .....
I would summarise my attitude to this as follows: HAVE A GO. If you find that using four fingers is very uncomfortable, then this is a very good reason to give up.
.
I But I just cannot understand people sticking to two fingers.
Whilst I admire your zeal and evangelism for 4 fingers Owen I don't really agree with you. You are correct that for your style of playing 4 fingers has many advantages but if, like me and many others, you are a more basic player of tunes mostly up and down the rows with a more basic 3 chord trick basses, two or may be three fingers is more than adequate, including on 12 bass boxes.
I am happy to be in that place on the ven diagram of melodeon players, after all is said and done I have had a happy career that has seen me travel and play through Europe, play for morris and in ceilidh bands and have be admired for my playing.
Some here are advising that new starters should be encouraged to play the bass end with four fingers. I disagree strongly with this. It seems better to me for beginners to be shown (or have explained to them) the advantages and disadvantages of each of these three ways of playing the basses and then to experiment with them and to use whichever seems most appropriate and most comfortable for them.
I would also add that in a beginner's context, although I agree that they should be taught the controversy, doing so and concluding that therefore they should do whatever they want I think would be overwhelming and would lead to them doing whatever is easiest, whether or not that is suitable for what they want to play in the future. I would always advocate teaching people to use 4 fingers on the bass if it is comfortable for them, as it is a good deal easier to switch to two or three finger bass from four finger bass than the other way round, and that using multiple fingers gives you everything that you can do with two fingers and more.
On my posts about my very easy video lessons there have been a couple of comments about lining up your four fingers with the 4 x 2 bass buttons on an 8 bass box.I'm a bit of a freak...it depends on the tune (what key etc.) to number of fingers used...
This does make perfect sense of course. I must admit I only use three fingers and I don't think it's hampered me yet but of course I can't say for sure.
I'm being a bit hypocritical here as I am always picking my guitar students up on not using the fourth finger of their fretting hand.
So what do we think? The fourth finger is notoriously weak so would it put a beginner off if they had to play their very first bass line (G bass G chord) with finger 4 and finger 3 respectively? I'm not sure so I'd like to know what the consensus is on this.
Thank you.
You are making the mistake, Owen, of assuming that everyone's mind (and fingers) work as yours do. One of the fundamental concepts of all teaching is to recognise that people's minds work in different ways and that it is important to provide them with alternative ways of learning so that they can adopt the one that suits their way of thinking. Put crudely, some people think visually, some mathematically, others verbally, and so on. Providing alternative methods of using the basses is not an encouragement to adopt the easist approach (some will do that, but they would probably gravitate towards the easiest method even if you didn't mention it!); rather, it is a way of enabling each student to learn in the way that best suits the way his or her mind works.
I was another early 4 finger switcher and would recommend it to anyone as it is the foundation for those nice bass runs we all admire. When you upgrade to 12 bass you'll definitely need it,
I think that the [objective] should be to get as many fingers in play as they can.
QuoteI was another early 4 finger switcher and would recommend it to anyone as it is the foundation for those nice bass runs we all admire. When you upgrade to 12 bass you'll definitely need it,QuoteI think that the [objective] should be to get as many fingers in play as they can.
Does anyone really take issue with that?
QuoteI think that the objective should be to get as many fingers in play as they can.I can play 12 or 14 basses better with two fingers than I can with three or four
... and the number of people who have been put off playing an instrument because they can't do the "proper" technique is huge.
Essentially the teacher is saying "this is best, anything else is not as good and will limit what you can do". At that point some people (and I've been one) switch off and drop the instrument concerned even though a compromise may in fact allow them to play the instrument perfectly adequately if not to the standard of the best virtuosi.
I have problems with both my thumbs and for double bass it means that my left thumb opposes my first finger not the second and my right hand bow grip is ugly. However my teacher is great "If it works for you then that's what we go with". Likewise I don't have a huge reach with my left hand so we work round that when playing at the top end of the fingerboard. A didactic "first to fourth finger is always a tone" approach would not work because my hand can't do it.
The physical limitations that people's hand's and bodies (how often have we seen boxes for sale because the seller needs a lighter box) is a crucial part of this debate and for a teacher an important part in deciding the approach and curriculum that should be followed.
Steve
QuoteI think that the objective should be to get as many fingers in play as they can.I can play 12 or 14 basses better with two fingers than I can with three or four
.. and your problem is? ::)
I'd invite Bob to reconsider on the 12 or 14 as I was talking about 'crossed' chords and that bit was (http://cdn.wikimg.net/strategywiki/images/1/16/Skizzerz_Scissors.png) snipped.
I confess I try to use the pinkie in bass runs too, and it may by time I came out of the closet as a 'South Paw'. From the above I suspect Bob .. isn't? Do you use all the fingers on the right end?
It has to be asked - how many fingers are you using to type this stuff?
(http://i359.photobucket.com/albums/oo35/veleten/sm_78.gif)
(I'm using all of mine thanks to a sweaty summer at Pitman College)
Also what I said. Another thought for the "two-finger" proponents is that even with 8 basses you have to move your hand and fingers around less using three fingers than with two -- I often see people playing with two fingers having to physically move their hand up and down the box between playing the lower four buttons and the upper ones. Or if you don't do this you have to bend the fingers sideways and/or flex the hand to do this. Neither is as comfortable as using three fingers, which seems ergonomically to be optimum. In my opinion ;-)... and the number of people who have been put off playing an instrument because they can't do the "proper" technique is huge.
Essentially the teacher is saying "this is best, anything else is not as good and will limit what you can do". At that point some people (and I've been one) switch off and drop the instrument concerned even though a compromise may in fact allow them to play the instrument perfectly adequately if not to the standard of the best virtuosi.
I have problems with both my thumbs and for double bass it means that my left thumb opposes my first finger not the second and my right hand bow grip is ugly. However my teacher is great "If it works for you then that's what we go with". Likewise I don't have a huge reach with my left hand so we work round that when playing at the top end of the fingerboard. A didactic "first to fourth finger is always a tone" approach would not work because my hand can't do it.
The physical limitations that people's hand's and bodies (how often have we seen boxes for sale because the seller needs a lighter box) is a crucial part of this debate and for a teacher an important part in deciding the approach and curriculum that should be followed.
Steve
I have said several times that physical discomfort is a good reason to abandon this particular technique.
Very well said, George. If you are wanting to be a top notch concert violinist then worrying about studying the 'right' technique from the beginning might be appropriate. If you are learning the melodeon for the pure joy of making music then get those tunes going as quick as possible and worry about fine tuning technique (much) later. Countless children have been put off making music by well meaning teachers trying to drill the 'right' technique from the get go.True -- but once a habit (like using two fingers) is learned it can be very difficult to unlearn once the "second-funger-oom-first-finger-pah" has been hardwired into your brain.
Once a habit (like using two fingers) is learned it can be very difficult to unlearn once the "second-funger-oom-first-finger-pah" has been hardwired into your brain.
I'm a complete beginner - I started playing a couple of days ago. Having seen earlier debates on this issue, I'd decided to try the 4-finger method, from the start.
I'm not sure I'll stick with it though, so hearing I don't "have" to, is quite reassuring! I can live with some blistering on the pinkie (akin to toughening up your fretting-hand fingertips if you're learning the guitar - unpleasant but temporary). But I am finding I need to put my left hand a long way through the strap in order for the pinkie to reach the further buttons, with the result that my inside forearm is pressed hard against the rear edge of the box, leaving a sore dent in my arm after a few minutes' playing. Also, whist the pinkie is extended to hit the furthest button, my other left-hand fingers have to be curled over, claw-like, to press the buttons.
Is this bad technique on my part, or are these the sort of issues that have led some of you to deliberately only use 2 or 3 fingers?
Yes. It seems to me that traditional music teaching (piano) emphasizes correct technique above all else. My wife spent years "studying" piano, when she wasyoungyounger . She now unable to play at all without sheet music - no improvising, no ability to pick out chords & add a melody. She very rarely plays. I wonder how many others have gone through the same process?
...Never would teach someone to play the melodeon without his pink unless he said he/she couldn't do it which
really was a lie to themselves...
I must admit to being surprised at how many people find four finger bass uncomfortable. I think then that the problem is with the instrument...
I must admit to being surprised at how many people find four finger bass uncomfortable. I think then that the problem is with the instrument...
That is because you are assuming that everyone's left hand has the same size and proportions as yours and that everyone's mind works in the same way that yours does. This is not the case!
That is because you are assuming that everyone's left hand has the same size and proportions as yours and that everyone's mind works in the same way that yours does. This is not the case!
if I am one of the few who can use all four fingers. If is the case then it points to a major flaw in the physical ergonomics of the instrument.
if I am one of the few who can use all four fingers. If is the case then it points to a major flaw in the physical ergonomics of the instrument.
But that assumes that using four fingers is the ideal. Since people seem to be able to play it perfectly well with 3 or even 2 fingers, the argument that the design is flawed doesn't stand up.
My experience is similar to Mory's. I took up melodeon after already playing guitar and anglo, so I was used to using the little finger, but I don't use it much for melodeon (LH that is, I use it a lot on the right). I was entirely self-taught and so far as I can recall I didn't consciously copy other players when learning the left hand, I just did what came naturally, which was to play with 3 fingers.
As an experiment yesterday I tried playing with two fingers on the left hand. Interesting exercise, the main observation being that I found it impossible to reach the air button while playing the lower four buttons! :'(
No it doesn't, it assumes that using four fingers is a technique which has advantages and is used or would be used by a significant proportion of players. Which I think is the case.
My reservations about using only 2 fingers are partly the amount of hand movement required and partly the need to stretch for some less obvious chords. However I acknowledge that some players can manage this.
With respect, I think that comes to much the same thing - it suggests that there are significant advantages to using four fingers, which more players would adopt if they could. However it appears to me from this lengthy and interesting discussion that the case is far from proved.
With respect, I think that comes to much the same thing - it suggests that there are significant advantages to using four fingers, which more players would adopt if they could. However it appears to me from this lengthy and interesting discussion that the case is far from proved.
I am repeating myself now, so this will probably be my last post on this thread. I believe that there are significant advantages to using four fingers which more players would adopt if they could. And I accept that I am apparently not going to convince people over what I think is a fairly trivial and obvious point.
I think that there is danger of musical snobbery here (not directed at you Howard), with people using I IV V and two fingers looking down on those of us who use the whole of the instrument. I have made pains to never state that using the three chord trick is worse than what I do, indeed for some tunes I could achieve exactly the same effect with only two fingers. But I feel that some posters have bordered on the dismissive when referring to four fingered playing.
It depends what you want to achieve and how easy it is to achieve it, as to whether you have the motivation to experiment with different finger combinations.
I cannot think of anything which requires all four fingers to achieve (other than a four-finger chord, of course, but surely that is unusual) although I concede it may sometimes be helpful to bring in the little finger I find it is seldom necessary. To be clear, it is its habitual use in normal playing that I am talking about.
I cannot think of anything which requires all four fingers to achieve (other than a four-finger chord, of course, but surely that is unusual) although I concede it may sometimes be helpful to bring in the little finger I find it is seldom necessary. To be clear, it is its habitual use in normal playing that I am talking about.
I play right hand 4 finger chords all the time. I admit that the classic 1,3,5,7 chords tend to sound a bit "corner jazz club" in a folk session, but sus chords (as per the new wave guitar stuff in the 80's) are wonderful against our modal music. I'm particularly fond of Bm79 C#,D,F#, B to get a cadence effect against Irish dorian Em. (instead of perpetual Em,D,Em,D, Em ...). I 'can' play that with 3 fingers, but lets not expand this thread even more into not/covering more than one button.
The latest Pignol/Milleret video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aSQ_KX2u-5I shows some nice 3 finger chords on bass. If the quote above refers to that end - nope I can't think of any either! But to broaden in another direction .. there are not many other facets of musicality that deliberately restrict harmony to major and minor triads?
[I play right hand 4 finger chords all the time.
If the quote above refers to that end - nope I can't think of any either!
there are not many other facets of musicality that deliberately restrict harmony to major and minor triads?
Moderator message
If you have seen enough of this thread then please simply ignore it.
If you have feel strongly that it is going awry in some way please report your concerns to me by pm or through the message reporting system. Yes there is quite a lot of duplication here and yes it is a long thread, but I don't see either of those as a reason to stop discussion.
Just keep all contributions respectful of the views of others please. (:)
I will remove all the posts which ask for the topic to be closed. :(
Theo [with stern teacherish face on]
C maj7 = Cbass +Bchord, pull - its a cool chord playing in Em - and a lovely tense chord in G because it implies lydian mode (the G's F# is a #4th against C scale). And you have 6 of the 7 scale notes running on right end to play tune with! 8) Try it!
G maj7 = Gbass +Echord, push - the ultimate 'relax' chord in G, with all the tension of an Earth lead ;) Can be cool to finish on, but very cliché. Much more fun when playing in D, where again it's our lydian chord (only 5 scale notes this time)
.. related fingering (and both better with the 3rds out)
Both complete cripplers using index +middle fingers :Ph
And surely G bass with B chord is an augmented major seventh chord, i.e. GMaj7#5?Let's assume that Chris has a Bm.
Could we have a poll please? I think it would be very interesting to learn how many melnetters use two, three, four fingers. Rather than starting a new thread, could Les add a poll to this thread?
There's no option for "as many as necessary at the time"..... ;D >:ESorted!
Graham
There's no option for "as many as necessary at the time".....
There's no option for "as many as necessary at the time"..... ;D >:ESorted!
Graham
QuoteThere's no option for "as many as necessary at the time".....
I don't think that's a particularly helpful option. We could all come up with a third or fourth finger on a "special occasion"! The real question is, habitually, does your pinkie, the third finger, or the second finger play the lower basses/chords?
Please may we have a 'vote for more than one option' facility? I mainly use 3 fingers but I will sometimes use 4 depending on the music requirements. So I'd like to vote for both options please.There's no option for "as many as necessary at the time"..... ;D >:ESorted!
Graham
Sorry - they do say that humour rarely crosses the Atlantic successfully.
Please may we have a 'vote for more than one option' facility? I mainly use 3 fingers but I will sometimes use 4 depending on the music requirements. So I'd like to vote for both options please.
QuoteSorry - they do say that humour rarely crosses the Atlantic successfully.
I don't know about humour, Graham, but I have crossed the Atlantic. However, this is clearly NOT a laughing matter! :o
I think the variable finger placement somewhat clouds the issue. I think it's much more informative to indicate what your usual finger placement is.
Oh - I think it's more than just occasionally. Quite often really. Three and four fingers. Depending on the music. Sometimes I only use two if I want a drone. I've even been known to use a bit of blue-tack to keep the C chord held down, which leaves me 4 fingers (or 3, or 2 (depending on the music)) free to play the other buttons. But I only do that sometimes.QuotePlease may we have a 'vote for more than one option' facility? I mainly use 3 fingers but I will sometimes use 4 depending on the music requirements. So I'd like to vote for both options please.
What I'm trying to establish is what is the most common finger usage, not what you might use occasionally. Posting for a variety of options confuses the question, in my opinion.
Steve, are we supposed to believe that pirates - of all people - would pronounce "orphan" and "often" in the same way? I could believe it of a king of the house of Windsor (r-droppers all), but wouldn't a pirate have a west country accent with pronounced post-vocalic Rs ? Arrr!Yes. Suspend all disbelief. They were 'all noblemen who had gone wrong'. ;)
Major General: I don’t think we quite understand one another. I ask you, have you ever known what it is to be an orphan, and you say "orphan". As I understand you, you are merely repeating the word "orphan" to show that you understand me.
Pirate King: I didn’t repeat the word often.
Major General: Pardon me, you did indeed.
Pirate King: I only repeated it once.
Major General: True, but you repeated it.
Pirate King: But not often.
Major General: Stop! I think I see where we are getting confused. When you said "orphan", did you mean "orphan" – a person who has lost his parents, or "often", frequently?
Pirate King: Ah! I beg pardon – I see what you mean – frequently.
Major General: Ah! you said "often", frequently.
Pirate King: No, only once.
Major General (irritated): Exactly – you said "often", frequently, only once.
Cue doom music
These polls are just too simplistic to enable detailed responses to be made. And whether any meaningful conclusions can be drawn from them is yet another question..
2. If you want to play oom pa only you can get away with two
3. If you want to play fancy stuff, four fingers will probably give you the greatest range
So to sum up (from the beginner's perspective, which I dimly recall being the starting point):amirite?
- It depends on what kind of music you want to play
- If you want to play oom pa only you can get away with two
- If you want to play fancy stuff, four fingers will probably give you the greatest range
- Adapting to four after learning two is potentially hard work
- Comfort and dexterity will depend on how you hold the instrument, size of hands, relative size of fingers, previous medical history, whether you have chest or tummy, the weather etc
- in the light of the above, the best choice is whatever works for you in the style you want to play
- never give up - experiment till you find what works for you
So to sum up (from the beginner's perspective, which I dimly recall being the starting point):
- The best choice is whatever works for you in the style you want to play
- never give up - experiment till you find what works for you
- It depends on what kind of music you want to play, but 4 fingers will allow you all styles
- If you want to play oom pa only you can get away with two, if you dont want to play legato ever
- If you want to play fancy stuff, four fingers will probably give you the greatest range
- Adapting to four after learning two is potentially hard work, whereas if you start with 4 it's not that much trouble
- Comfort and dexterity will depend on how you hold the instrument, size of hands, relative size of fingers, previous medical history, whether you have chest or tummy, the weather etc, but most people fall within the 90/95% for whom that is not an issue. If indeed you are in those other 5/10% look at the top of the list again
... about lining up your four fingers with the 4 x 2 bass buttons on an 8 bass box.
... would it put a beginner off if they had to play their very first bass line (G bass G chord) with finger 4 and finger 3 respectively?
BUT THAT WASN'T THE ORIGINAL QUESTION!!!!... about lining up your four fingers with the 4 x 2 bass buttons on an 8 bass box.
... would it put a beginner off if they had to play their very first bass line (G bass G chord) with finger 4 and finger 3 respectively?
Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.
Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.Oh yes, that is really the main point of using 4 fingers.
BUT THAT WASN'T THE ORIGINAL QUESTION!!!!... about lining up your four fingers with the 4 x 2 bass buttons on an 8 bass box.
... would it put a beginner off if they had to play their very first bass line (G bass G chord) with finger 4 and finger 3 respectively?
Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.
Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.Yes. Means that the hand doesn't move around.
Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.Yes. Means that the hand doesn't move around.
I'd need persuading that it makes very much difference to hand movement and, even if so, that this is of any technical value.
As to the rest, see my previous reply to Theo.
But I don't think we are trying to persuade you, I'm certainly not. I'm just outlining what works for me.I know. Poor choice of words from me. I should say that it isn't obvious to me that this technique can make very much useful difference to hand movement.
Well, all I can suggest is that you try it and form your own conclusions.I have. I did.
[(there are some things you can do with 4 that you can't do with 3.
For me these would arise only occasionally, and only on 12-bass. For example in bass runs that span the whole block, such as Dmin scale on GCF box. And even here "can't" needs some qualifying. It would really be "can't, without compromising something else", e.g. rhythm or dynamics.[(there are some things you can do with 4 that you can't do with 3.Could someone please explain to me what these are? I'm afraid it's not obvious to me.
[(there are some things you can do with 4 that you can't do with 3.
Could someone please explain to me what these are? I'm afraid it's not obvious to me.
Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.Oh yes, that is really the main point of using 4 fingers.
Not in my view. The main point of using 4 fingers is that it self-evidently removes the constraint of using only 3 (or 2). To paraphrase Cooper from a couple of pages back: (i) there is nothing you can do with 3 that you can't also do with 4, and (ii) there are some things you can do with 4 that you can't do with 3.
But if the 4-finger player is going to adopt a new constraint that each finger has to remain on its designated pair of buttons then neither of these propositions is true.
And how does this technique extend to the 12-bass or more, btw?
I use 3 and occasionally 4 (especially on 12-bass), but I don't see the point or any technical merit in confining any finger to any particular button(s), or vice versa.
But i think for me the biggest advantage from general 4 over 3 finger usage is what Theo and Ukebert said; your hand doesnt need to move.
stuff
Well, last night I quickly ran through my extensive cache of favourite youtube melodeon clips to see what the players (many of them melnetters,) were doing. The only "fully 4 fingered player" I could find was Ukebert
Use as few fingers as you like but don't pretend that it's somehow better than not being able to use all of them...
...who has big hands.
I would be interested to see more examples posted of fully 4 fingers melodeon playing, because I don't seem to have come across them.
Use as few fingers as you like but don't pretend that it's somehowbetterworse than not being able to use all of them...
Use as few fingers as you like but don't pretend that it's somehowbetterworse than not being able to use all of them...
Sorry, it is worse. If you can only use 2 or 3 then you can't do everything that you can with 4
The convoluted excuses, bizarre leaps of logic and plain old stubbornness that some people demonstrate rather than just admitting that they found it too difficult or simply can't be bothered is disheartening but does not to surprise me.
stuff
How do you use your fingers in a simple hoompapa on the push from G to D?
If you use only 3 fingers, you cannot (unless i miss something) make both the transition between you g-chord, and the subsequent D-bass fluent/legato/gapless, as well as the transition D-bass-d-chord?