Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on June 05, 2012, 09:49:26 AM

Title: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 05, 2012, 09:49:26 AM
On my posts about my very easy video lessons there have been a couple of comments about lining up your four fingers with the  4 x 2 bass buttons on an 8 bass box.

This does make perfect sense of course. I must admit I only use three fingers and I don't think it's hampered me yet but of course I can't say for sure.

I'm being a bit hypocritical here as I am always picking my guitar students up on not using the fourth finger of their fretting hand.

So what do we think?  The fourth finger is notoriously weak so would it put a beginner off if they had to play their very first bass line (G bass G chord) with finger 4 and finger 3 respectively?   I'm not sure so I'd like to know what the consensus is on this.

Thank you.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 05, 2012, 10:00:54 AM
The little pinkie is not only weak, but in some ( my! ) cases it's short too.
I went through the 2 v's 3 vs's 4 finger question. I seem to use 3 for 99% of my playing and sometines use the pinkie on perhaps a G bass. I have small hands so it really can't stretch to the C bass and is weak if it gets there.
Though I have the command of my little finger it simply on't reach so I concluded I'd stick to 3 with the odd use of my little one if it was possible. It seemed a good compromise for me.
As we're all different sizes I suspect each person will have a differing opinion!
cheers
Q
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 05, 2012, 10:01:09 AM
This has been discussed on this forum before, although not recently. As I recall the consensus view is that there is no hard and fast rule about this, but that it is mostly OK to do what is most comfortable for you.

Some players use all four fingers and there is a definite logic about this, but as Les has pointed out, some people have a weak little finger and prefer not to use it. If four fingers work for you, that's fine. You can also train yourself to use the little finger if you haven't already been using it up until now. However, many excellent players use only three fingers and their music is just fine.

Less useful and more restrictive is just using two fingers, and if you are a person who does this, it might really be worth trying to train yourself to use three.

Personally, I use three fingers. I occasionally use four but it's not particularly comfortable for me.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 05, 2012, 10:04:25 AM
I felt that if I was forced to use my little finger it would handicap my playing hence my decision.
As Steve says, it makes perfect sense to use it, except for some it is not possible physically.
Q
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Tom on June 05, 2012, 10:16:01 AM
This has been discussed on this forum before, although not recently. As I recall the consensus view is that there is no hard and fast rule about this, but that it is mostly OK to do what is most comfortable for you.

Some players use all four fingers and there is a definite logic about this, but as Les has pointed out, some people have a weak little finger and prefer not to use it. If four fingers work for you, that's fine. You can also train yourself to use the little finger if you haven't already been using it up until now. However, many excellent players use only three fingers and their music is just fine.

Less useful and more restrictive is just using two fingers, and if you are a person who does this, it might really be worth trying to train yourself to use three.

Personally, I use three fingers. I occasionally use four but it's not particularly comfortable for me.

I'd been wondering about this after seeing the comments on Les' Vid.

So - To be clear: Playing with three fingers would mean that (playing 'um-chas' on an 8 button DG box)
I'd play the g/d and c/c pair with my ring(bass) and middle (chord) fingers
and
the d/a and Em/b pair with my middle(bass) and first (chord) fingers. Right?

and if you buy a 12 bass box do you just do whatever you can to get a pair of fingers in roughly the right place in time?!

PS well done Les!
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: brianread on June 05, 2012, 10:30:17 AM
I switched to 4 fingers on the basses a few years ago, and did a lot of practice using the bottom 2 fingers (in D for me, as I am a Lefty), and feel that it was one of the best things I did.  Sometime I do move the top two down (especially when playing a right handed box - then I use the little finger for the air button  :( )
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lester on June 05, 2012, 11:00:50 AM
For the first 20 years of playing, as far as I know, everyone I saw played with just two fingers so, so did I. I learned (self taught) strict up and down the rows/three chord trick so two fingers are more than enough (IMO).

I have tried 4 fingers and just can't get it. I have tried 3 which I found even harder - my brain is wired (due to 30 years of use) that my first finger plays the chord and the middle finger plays the bass, so when i try 3 fingers where sometimes my middle finger plays chords on the lower pairs of buttons and bass on the upper pair it all just falls to pieces. So two fingers is right in the world of Lester (a strange place) but I defend your right to use as many as you like (as long as you not say your way is RIGHT and the others are wrong)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Theo on June 05, 2012, 11:05:13 AM
Fair points Lester, if you only want to play up and down the rows, but if you want to use a wider variety of RH fingering then the left hand becomes easier and more versatile if you can use at least three, and preferably 4 fingers. I believe beginners should be started off with techniques that will not restrict their later playing.

(Please note careful avoidance of the 'R' and 'W' words ;D)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 05, 2012, 01:22:49 PM
There are clear and undeniable advantages to using all four fingers on the bass end. Some runs which are easy if you are using all 4 can be monstrously difficult with two or even three. In my mind the only real reason not to try using four fingers is if your little finger is too short to reach the C bass satisfactorily. Although I would still recommend trying to use the G bass with the little finger and see whether it makes a difference.

Some little fingers are weak, but this can be changed through practice. People have achieved good results with clothes pegs I recall.

I started off using two fingers and after about three or four years realised that this was stupid and switched to four. It was tricky at first but now I wouldn't do anything else, the benefits are so huge.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 05, 2012, 03:26:15 PM
I was another early 4 finger switcher and would recommend it to anyone as it is the foundation for those nice bass runs we all admire. When you upgrade to 12 bass you'll deninitely need it, but even simple runs like the classic [pull] Em, D, C [push] B are greatly facilitated, and cross chording Em/E .. Em/D .. Em/C = Em .. Em7 .. C maj7 is pretty hard otherwise.

Nowadays I'd even play a 2 bass with indexand little finger  .. it's more comfortable!

I had the same experience on right end, with my pinkie hardly used. This was actually harder to overcome, but greatly assisted by a fractured index finger forcing me to use fingers 3+4+5 for a month.   In this respect (only) flicking grass out of a motor mower exit hole with finger with engine running is a good thing  ;)

I'd encourage any learned to get that last finger going before patterend learning sets in - it does strengthen up to same as the others. That is unless you want to play our instrumant at 75% of what you might accomplish?
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: IanD on June 05, 2012, 03:47:40 PM
It's not so much whether your little finger is weak, it's how much shorter it is than the other fingers, and this varies a lot from person to person.

Mine is a good 2cm shorter than the third finger, so to use it I'd have to push my whole hand forwards and curl up the other three fingers leading to a much less comfortable playing position.

I'd rather play comfortably with three fingers than uncomfortably with four.

People with a longer little finger may have a different opinion...
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 05, 2012, 04:53:20 PM
It's not so much whether your little finger is weak, it's how much shorter it is than the other fingers, and this varies a lot from person to person.
Mine is a good 2cm shorter than the third finger ...
I'd rather play comfortably with three fingers than uncomfortably with four.
People with a longer little finger may have a different opinion...

I'm guessing that there won't be many such people. My LH little finger is 27mm shorter than the 3rd, and I don't think my hand looks all that weird.
Maybe we should have a poll.

Ok this is a very good point. My little finger is 32 mm shorter than my 3rd  - is this abnormal?  My fingers are very long!!!
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 05, 2012, 04:56:46 PM
I think that it is more about the absolute length of the little finger, as opposed to the difference between fingers. My little finger is 27mm shorter than my ring finger, but it is 78mm long.

Try putting your four fingers on the four bass buttons furthest away, i.e. C/C and B/E. If that feels comfortable then give 4 finger bass a go.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: george garside on June 05, 2012, 05:51:03 PM
its not somuch the absolute length of the little finger that matters ( mine is 60cm) but the way the other fingers  are relative to the buttonsand the same principle applies toboth treble and bass.  If fingers 123  are arched in a sort of U shape so the tips  come down on the buttons the business end of  the pinky , positioned diagonally, will  be more or less be in line with the other 3 'arriving' vertically.That is not to say that there arent other advantages ion oth ends of box in having little fingers  that resemble snakes!   Looking at photos & videos of Jimmy Shand  his were long & snakelike and he certainly made very good use ofit on the treble end  using 4 fingers most  if not all of the time on the BCC# keyboard.


george
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: IanD on June 05, 2012, 06:04:19 PM
its not somuch the absolute length of the little finger that matters ( mine is 60cm) but the way the other fingers  are relative to the buttonsand the same principle applies toboth treble and bass.  If fingers 123  are arched in a sort of U shape so the tips  come down on the buttons the business end of  the pinky , positioned diagonally, will  be more or less be in line with the other 3 'arriving' vertically.That is not to say that there arent other advantages ion oth ends of box in having little fingers  that resemble snakes!   Looking at photos & videos of Jimmy Shand  his were long & snakelike and he certainly made very good use ofit on the treble end  using 4 fingers most  if not all of the time on the BCC# keyboard.


george
Which is exactly what I meant about curling your fingers up -- you can do it, but I find it less comfortable than having them straighter, especially if on the bass end it means arching your hand back from the end of the box to allow the little finger to reach.

It's just another ergonomic issue (like mice vs. trackballs), you have to decide between using three fingers in a more natural shape or four with three of them in a less natural one. There are advantages both ways...
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 05, 2012, 06:19:43 PM
I have tried using two, three and four fingers on the basses and I prefer to use two. This decision is partly due to the length of my little finger, which is only 62 mm and is 32 mm shorter than my ring finger. I cannot reach the inner row of basses with my little finger other than by distorting the position of my whole hand to the detriment of comfort and of my ability to use my other fingers. I can use my first and little fingers on my Cajun one-row boxes, but when I need to use my middle two fingers as well on my 2.6 and 3 row boxes, I have to dispense with the little finger. Therefore I don't use it.

So why do I find two fingers easier than three, when my 2.6 row box has 14 bass buttons and my 3 row has 12 bass buttons? It has to do with an instinctive feel for where the buttons are. Using two fingers, it is always my middle finger that is looking for a bass button and my index finger that is looking for a chord button. I found that it didn't take much practice for my fingers to know instinctively how far to travel, even when moving, say, from the G/D basses at one end of the outer row to the F/B flat basses at the other end of the inside row. However, if I use three fingers, I find it more difficult to locate the buttons when moving from one end of the bass array to the other end. I think this is probably because using three fingers upsets the symmetry of always finding a fundamental button with my middle finger and a chord button with my index finger.

Others have clearly found it easier to use three fingers, probably because their brains are wired differently from mine and perhaps because their fingers are different in size and shape to mine.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lester on June 05, 2012, 06:22:31 PM
I have tried using two, three and four fingers on the basses and I prefer to use two. This decision is partly due to the length of my little finger, which is only 62 mm and is 32 mm shorter than my ring finger. I cannot reach the inner row of basses with my little finger other than by distorting the position of my whole hand to the detriment of comfort and of my ability to use my other fingers. I can use my first and little fingers on my Cajun one-row boxes, but when I need to use my middle two fingers as well on my 2.6 and 3 row boxes, I have to dispense with the little finger. Therefore I don't use it.

So why do I find two fingers easier than three, when my 2.6 row box has 14 bass buttons and my 3 row has 12 bass buttons? It has to do with an instinctive feel for where the buttons are. Using two fingers, it is always my middle finger that is looking for a bass button and my index finger that is looking for a chord button. I found that it didn't take much practice for my fingers to know instinctively how far to travel, even when moving, say, from the G/D basses at one end of the outer row to the F/B flat basses at the other end of the inside row. However, if I use three fingers, I find it more difficult to locate the buttons when moving from one end of the bass array to the other end. I think this is probably because using three fingers upsets the symmetry of always finding a fundamental button with my middle finger and a chord button with my index finger.

Others have clearly found it easier to use three fingers, probably because their brains are wired differently from mine and perhaps because their fingers are different in size and shape to mine.

Glad I'm not alone  ;)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: jb on June 05, 2012, 06:40:16 PM
Pretty sure I read somewhere that during the Hundred Years' War the French would cut off the first two fingers on the left hand of any captured melodeonist. Thus the V-sign originated as a gesture of defiance across the lines by the fit English melodeonists.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 05, 2012, 07:31:25 PM
jb: Yes but by all accounts it's a myth.....but a lovely story!

My little finger is about 58mm, from the fold in my skin betwixt little and 3rd, and is ~ 27mm ish shorter. Difficult to be accourate as from which point do you measure from?
The essence being I too have to distort my hand to reach the C bass with it.
cheers
Q

Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: RobinA on June 05, 2012, 07:47:16 PM
I think everyone needs to scroll back up to Chris' post and tell him to never never put ANY of his fingers close to a moving blade again (unless this was already discussed in another post).  I used to do woodworking and build instruments until it occurred to me that I wanted to end up with enough fingers left to play the instruments that I built. I changed hobbies after my second set of stitches, and everyone here needs to be reminded to slow down and be careful with it comes to doing anything potentially dangerous with our fingers. 

As a newbie (who has been playing for about 30 hours now), I'm guessing that if one has a choice like I do, the best option is to start right off using all 4 fingers.  As a youngster taking piano accordion lessons, I resisted using the pinkie, but I'll make a bigger effort to start off using all my fingers on both sides. 
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 05, 2012, 07:49:54 PM
its not somuch the absolute length of the little finger that matters ( mine is 60cm)

george

Blimey - if your little finger is 2ft long, how long is.........no. it doesn't really matter! ;D >:E
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 05, 2012, 08:41:21 PM
Two words:

Django Reinhardt!

I've started with 2 fingers. I realize this is probably not the best idea, but I didn't start on the melodeon with the idea of becoming a virtuoso, only with the idea of playing a few simple tunes reasonably competently. I don't find it that hard to use 3 fingers, so maybe I should make an effort to use the 3rd finger. Th 4th finger seems to involve contortions of the wrist that seem counter-productive to me.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Anahata on June 05, 2012, 09:08:13 PM
I use three fingers for basses most of the time, only bring my little finger in for more tricky runs of notes if it helps.

I also use my little finger a lot on the treble side, but that's another whole can of worms.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: michik on June 05, 2012, 09:59:28 PM
I'm using all 4 fingers (from the very beginning on) and my teacher does.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 05, 2012, 10:06:38 PM
Hmmmmm Anahata's got a point.
I use my right hand little finger quite well, so maybe I need to think again about the left?
Well, am off  :M til next week so my research  will have to wait!
Q
venturing Ooooop North ( i.e. t'other side of Taunton where be dragons ;) )
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bobtheboat on June 05, 2012, 10:25:48 PM
I learnt to use all four from the very beginning (following advice from this forum) and now I can't imagine it being anything but limiting to use less. However I have reasonably big hands so it's quite comfortable. Since I've moved to playing on a 12 bass now I feel using the little finger is advantageous and it didn't take much effort to increase its dexterity. Bob.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: george garside on June 05, 2012, 10:33:40 PM
if 3 fingers are enough for 120 stradella bass buttons surely 2 can cope perfectly well with   8 buttons

george ;)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: IanD on June 05, 2012, 11:50:46 PM
if 3 fingers are enough for 120 stradella bass buttons surely 2 can cope perfectly well with   8 buttons

george ;)
One advantage of using four fingers is that the second and third fingers aren't really independent, I believe they share a tendon.

You can see this by placing your hand flat on a table and trying to lift only one finger at a time -- fingers one, two and four lift very easily, but it's very difficult to lift three on its own (lifting it together with two is easy).

In other words you only really have 3 independent fingers; one, two/three, and four. This makes for some problems playing using the first three fingers only.

But the difficulties with using the fourth finger still apply, especially on the bass end -- the treble end is different because you have a much bigger reach to cover, and the little finger is the easiest one with which to reach the high treble notes.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 06, 2012, 07:03:59 AM
Hmm  :|glug  you learn these little snippets as a student and get to use them 35 years later!  :|glug  Ahem, It's not a whole tendon .. there are usually 'slips' of tendon between the 'extensor digitorum' tendons. Like all anatomy it varies - which might explain some of the variance in advice on the subject. Some pianists are said to have had their slips snipped, I've never actually seen that.

Ian's finger lifting exercise is valid - but note that it is finger 4 that is most constrained. For the purposes of this the thread the pinkie has its own 'extensor digiti minimi' [2] muscle the three other extensors are 'common'). Put there by God to confound all sophistry about left end technique it would seem?  ::)  Furthermore .. it's surely flexing the finger that is the weak movement and we all have 3 muscles for each finger there. So I think it's about practice and usage, that was also my experience.

As I often put the 7th in on right hand chords I couldn't live without that pinkie. Could add that my short index  ;) is involved, but I got away with a 'crush'. To concur with RobinA's H&S advice .. "don't do it at home, children" :o
    (http://img.sparknotes.com/figures/E/eb57ee3c0bbce61d887722fc5931002b/muscles_of_the_hand_dorsal.jpg)

[edit] Hi George, commiserations. I'm no surgeon but AFAIK 'trigger finger' is flexor tendons on the palm side of the hand. Don't think anyone knows "why"
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: george garside on June 06, 2012, 10:21:15 AM
very interesting Chris.  I have had  ops  for release of trigure finger on 1sst finger sof both hands and now the 3rd finger of my right hand is  awaiting the same job.  Is this just sods law or could it be down to fifty odd years of box playing/

george the knackered
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on June 06, 2012, 11:23:56 AM
If I try to use my little finger I have to move my hand forwards and then scrunch my hand up uncomfortably to be able to use the air button. Hence I use three fingers.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Earbrass on June 06, 2012, 12:32:37 PM
I'm reading this at work, with no boxes handy....and I realise I have no idea how many fingers I use. I'm guessing it's four, because I came to the melodeon from a piano-playing background, but I won't be sure till I get home and pick up the pokerwork.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: FlatNote on June 06, 2012, 02:20:55 PM
Pretty sure I read somewhere that during the Hundred Years' War the French would cut off the first two fingers on the left hand of any captured melodeonist. Thus the V-sign originated as a gesture of defiance across the lines by the fit English melodeonists.

They must have been melodeonists with a Tardis in order to show two fingers five centuries before the invention of the melodeon!

I don't think there's as much disagreement over the number of fingers to use as might at first appear.  Surely everyone would agree that the fourth finger is going to be the least used?  The real issue is over which fingers can usefully be employed against which buttons.  The first two fingers are well able to cover all pairs if necessary.  The third will normally be restricted to those in the lower half, and the fourth, when used at all, will certainly be so restricted.  Personally, with small hands, I find the little finger is only useful for the outside bottom button - which sounds rather rude!  Things may change, of course, as one improves since either the first two fingers get better at covering more buttons - so that one can get away with using fewer fingers - or one's general dexterity and confidence improves so that one is able to use more fingers.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: pikey on June 06, 2012, 02:36:19 PM
Lester / Bob - I'm with you!  I THINK I just use two fingers, I won't know for sure until I get home and play a few tunes to see what I do!
I seem to be able to move around the basses with no difficulty, including some of those lovely cross button combinations, so I must be doing something right.

I think Theo's advice is good - if you are learning, learn with four.

Maybe four would be better, I'll have to try it out and see.  ;D

BTW - 4-stop one row players have a similar discussion, whether to use little finger and first finger on the basses, or first and second.

Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Strigulino on June 06, 2012, 02:42:29 PM
Due to the size of my hands and size of my box strap, I have to use my third and fourth fingers to brace between box and strap or I slide about, even with padding; however, I do have quite long fingers so am perfectly able to reach all 8 buttons with just my first and second fingers, and seeing as I work as a typist my fingers are used to dancing about. 

I think that, now I have been playing for some months, I am finding that the main chore of learning to play is not so much what notes are where and when to pull that pesky air button, but it's more learning the jumps from one button to another to get certain useful note intervals, and how to hold the thing so that the right fingers end up in the right places.  As has been mentioned elsewhere by someone watching one of my videos, I have "Essex Girl Nails" and so don't use my fingertips as much as others might, which adds another variable to the equation.

I suppose my point is really that we all have different boxes and hands and fingers, so how one holds and plays the box is very much a personal thing.  It's a folk instrument, therefore the main way of learning to play is just picking it up and having a go.  My first "proper" instrument was a flute at school that no-one else could get middle C out of.  My car has a first gear that everyone but self and husband stall.  We just know its little foibles, and musical instruments are no different.  So I can see that having four fingers on the basses a la typist home keys would be a most useful thing to be able to do, but I doubt I'm going to manage it.

Summary - look at how other people play, and suggestions of improvement.  Have a go at doing that. If it works for you, great.  If it doesn't work, don't do it.  :D
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: pikey on June 06, 2012, 02:53:17 PM
I've just checked one of my videos on Youtube, and I use THREE fingers on the bass!  ;D
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: jb on June 06, 2012, 04:32:02 PM
Pretty sure I read somewhere that during the Hundred Years' War the French would cut off the first two fingers on the left hand of any captured melodeonist. Thus the V-sign originated as a gesture of defiance across the lines by the fit English melodeonists.
They must have been melodeonists with a Tardis in order to show two fingers five centuries before the invention of the melodeon!
I think you'll find that the Tardis is fictional.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lester on June 06, 2012, 04:56:50 PM
I think you'll find that the Tardis is fictional.

Would not let ladydetemps hear you saying that if I were you  ;)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Howard Jones on June 06, 2012, 07:06:48 PM
At a workshop I went to the other week, Andy Cutting advised using four fingers, on the basis that if you want to play one of these 18-bass jobs which are becoming fashionable you need to know exactly where your hand is.

Sound advice, I don't doubt, from someone who unquestionably knows his stuff.  However to bring my little finger into play would involve completely relearning the left hand and changing my hand position, and for no advantage that I can see.  I can comfortably get around all 8 buttons very well with 3.  I'm used to using the little finger for guitar and concertina, so I'm able to bring it in when the need arises, but that isn't very often.

If you're starting out then it's probably a good idea to try using four fingers, but I wouldn't worry if you find it too difficult.  Three fingers work very well, and some people even get by with just two, although I think that is perhaps making things more difficult for yourself.  The important thing is the sound you make, not how you make it.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 06, 2012, 07:15:05 PM
We are not talking "re"learning here. Yes, habits get ingrained. Lester posted his problems about unlearning. At slightly over 50 I tried inverting the D/E plate and stuck it for a season. New tunes - seemed to go OK.  The multitude I'd learned over the years - kept hitting the wrong note - quite disastrously  :|bl

This thread (look back a bit) is about advice to learners. I think that should be to get as many fingers in play as they can. Anything else will hold them back later.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: IanD on June 07, 2012, 01:06:01 PM
We are not talking "re"learning here. Yes, habits get ingrained. Lester posted his problems about unlearning. At slightly over 50 I tried inverting the D/E plate and stuck it for a season. New tunes - seemed to go OK.  The multitude I'd learned over the years - kept hitting the wrong note - quite disastrously  :|bl

This thread (look back a bit) is about advice to learners. I think that should be to get as many fingers in play as they can. Anything else will hold them back later.
Or they should get as many fingers in play as they find comfortable, which isn't quite the same thing :-)

(cramping the left hand/fingers up to get the little finger in doesn't seem like a good idea to me)

Though two fingers only prevents you doing chords with paired basses which need three fingers, and can give a really deep throbby pipe-organ-like sound on sustained notes -- for example, in the long notes in the B music of Black Jack I use (I think):
G+B basses with G chord
C+A basses with C chord
G+D basses with G chord
D+A basses with D chord
which gives you what is heard as 2 simultaneous bass runs (G-C-D-D and B-A-G-A) with the chords (G-C-G-D).
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Earbrass on June 07, 2012, 02:57:49 PM
OK, so I got the box out last night and thought - "now we'll see how many fingers I use": cue 5 minutes of not being able to play anything, as my fingers get stagefright at the prospect of being watched. Settle down after a few minutes of forgetting about fingering and thinking about tunes, and am then able to take a sneaky look (feel?) at my left hand without it noticing. It turns out I use 3 fingers. Having been taught the piano from an early age, I have it ingrained into me that the digits are numbered from 1 (the thumb) to 5 (little finger). Using that system, it seems I use mainly fingers 3&4 for the bottom four basses (G/D & C/C on my D/G box) and fingers 2&3 for the top four (D/A, Em/B). The tip of my fifth finger rests against the case and provides a kind of pivot/anchor for the rest.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bobtheboat on June 07, 2012, 10:27:28 PM
I'm well aware that there are many players, most of them more accomplished than me, who don't use all four fingers on the left hand and perform marvellously. That said, I can't easily believe that had they learnt to use all four from the start they would not be even more accomplished/skillful.
As Chris said the OP was advice for beginners. Given the choice of starting again would the experienced players not choose the path of learning that offers greater scope, economy of movement, efficiency?
I did find it challenging to re-educate my little finger but I'm very glad I did, marvelling in the new found dexterity, and am pleased to have 'brought to life' a previously under-used appendage! ( insert your own Viagra jokes here  ;)) Bob.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: chouston14 on June 07, 2012, 11:17:36 PM
I tend to use 3 fingers on the bass because if I use my pinky finger then my thumb in in the wrong place for the air button.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Cooper on June 08, 2012, 12:10:25 AM
I think we should tell all those other musicians (pianists, fiddlers, guitarist, flute players (!) etc. ) that using their little finger is a strange thing as usually it is shorter and more difficult to control. >:E ;)


If they all can, why shouldnt we be able to? Everyone sees the obvious benefits. But yes, it will take time and practice to get full use out of it. And it will take even more time if you already use another technique.
;-)
W
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 08, 2012, 12:40:33 AM
Sound advice, I don't doubt, from someone who unquestionably knows his stuff.  However to bring my little finger into play would involve completely relearning the left hand and changing my hand position, and for no advantage that I can see.  I can comfortably get around all 8 buttons very well with 3.  I'm used to using the little finger for guitar and concertina, so I'm able to bring it in when the need arises, but that isn't very often.

This is the kind of attitude that I would like to see lessened on this issue (not just picking on you Howard, especially as you do use 3 fingers!). People saying "I am used to using 2/3 fingers and can't see the advantage of using 4". I used to use 2 fingers and switched to four. I now cannot imagine using 2. So much of what I do would be utterly impossible, and you might as well forget 12 bass boxes. I expect I could get used to 3 fingers and this would be better than nothing, but 2 fingers? Far too limiting.

I would summarise my attitude to this as follows: HAVE A GO. If you find that using four fingers is very uncomfortable, then this is a very good reason to give up. You don't want to strain your hand. But if it is comfortable then please do open up your horizons and give it a go, you may well find that it revitalises your playing, as it did mine. If four fingers is uncomfortable then try 3. It isn't impossible, but is a bit more difficult. As Ian says though, there are some things that you can do with three fingers which aren't difficult at all.

But I just cannot understand people sticking to two fingers.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 08, 2012, 04:53:26 AM
Is anyone out there still using ONE finger?  :|glug
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: oggiesnr on June 08, 2012, 07:37:16 AM

But I just cannot understand people sticking to two fingers.


Because for some of us it works for the style and the amount we play  (:)

For a beginner I would say use whatever fingers your arm, wrist and hand are comfortable with.  Try four but if it starts hurting or your fingers aren't all long enough then cut back to what works comfortably for you.  You need your wrists and fingers for a lot more than box playing and screwing them up playing a box would IMHO be plain stupid.

I do wonder if we are seeing a divide between a newer generation with the big Cutting style boxes (18 basses and I suspect more to come) and those of us who learnt on (and mainly play) eight basses.  Just as I suspect there's a difference between those of us happy with the three chord trick and those who are pushing the boundaries of both right and left hand chords.  I admit to being in the camp that accepts the main limitations of a two row box and doesn't feel the need to push the musical boundaries by becoming a handtortionist, if I want to get complicated I  have other instruments more suited to doing that  (:)

How long before we get stradella type layout (but still with the push/pull bass action) and 24 or 36 bass boxes?

Steve
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lester on June 08, 2012, 07:46:21 AM
This is the kind of attitude that I would like to see lessened on this issue (not just picking on you Howard, especially as you do use 3 fingers!). People saying "I am used to using 2/3 fingers and can't see the advantage of using 4". I used to use 2 fingers and switched to four. I now cannot imagine using 2. So much of what I do would be utterly impossible, and you might as well forget 12 bass boxes. I expect I could get used to 3 fingers and this would be better than nothing, but 2 fingers? Far too limiting.

I would summarise my attitude to this as follows: HAVE A GO. If you find that using four fingers is very uncomfortable, then this is a very good reason to give up. You don't want to strain your hand. But if it is comfortable then please do open up your horizons and give it a go, you may well find that it revitalises your playing, as it did mine. If four fingers is uncomfortable then try 3. It isn't impossible, but is a bit more difficult. As Ian says though, there are some things that you can do with three fingers which aren't difficult at all.

But I just cannot understand people sticking to two fingers.

Whilst I admire your zeal and evangelism for 4 fingers Owen I don't really agree with you. You are correct that for your style of playing 4 fingers has many advantages but if, like me and many others, you are a more basic player of tunes mostly up and down the rows with a more basic 3 chord trick basses, two or may be three fingers is more than adequate, including on 12 bass boxes. 

I am happy to be in that place on the ven diagram of melodeon players, after all is said and done I have had a happy career that has seen me travel and play through Europe, play for morris and in ceilidh bands and have be admired for my playing.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 08, 2012, 07:49:59 AM
Blimey, I really opened up the proverbial can of worms with this one didn't I?  I did have a bit of a go with 4 fingers the other day. It was uncomfortable but not impossible and I can definitely see the advantages. It's something I'll discuss in my next bass tutorial. Thanks to everyone for their input on this one. Two fingers, three fingers, four fingers - there's only only one way to settle this, now where's Harry Hill when you need him?!!! (:)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Anahata on June 08, 2012, 08:48:03 AM
I tend to use 3 fingers on the bass because if I use my pinky finger then my thumb in in the wrong place for the air button.
I think I'm the same. I can use pinky on the nearest button only. Maybe the four finger people have less of a difference in length between little finger and others. My little finger only just reaches the outer knuckle joint of the finger next to it, with them all straight.

Is anyone out there still using ONE finger?  :|glug
Er, are we talking about melodeon basses here, or what?  ;)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Howard Jones on June 08, 2012, 09:00:13 AM
This is the kind of attitude that I would like to see lessened on this issue (not just picking on you Howard, especially as you do use 3 fingers!). People saying "I am used to using 2/3 fingers and can't see the advantage of using 4". I used to use 2 fingers and switched to four. .....

I would summarise my attitude to this as follows: HAVE A GO. If you find that using four fingers is very uncomfortable, then this is a very good reason to give up.

That is what I went on to suggest.  However I find that I cannot easily reach the far buttons with my little finger, and to do so would involve a complete change of hand position, which would probably then compromise my use of the air button.  My real point was that I don't believe that doing so would add anything to my playing - I cannot imagine anything it would allow me to do that I cannot do already.  I do sometimes use the fourth finger but only when I have a specific reason to.

Andy Cutting probably has a point when it comes to playing the bigger boxes - I've never done so, so I can't comment.  And for a beginner who may one day want to graduate to an 18-bass then it may be a good idea to get into the habit of using four fingers.  But since almost anything you might want to do with four fingers can be done with just three (how often do you play four-button bass chords?) then I think it's a matter of personal preference rather than one being better than another.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lester on June 08, 2012, 09:04:57 AM
Apart from the physical difficulties of 4 fingers I think it would work better for me, and Bob Ellis, as my brain could then be happy that a finger was either a bass finger or a chord finger. Both Bob and I get confused by the role swapping required for three finger usage.  (:)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: george garside on June 08, 2012, 10:07:54 AM
.

I But I just cannot understand people sticking to two fingers.

Whilst I admire your zeal and evangelism for 4 fingers Owen I don't really agree with you. You are correct that for your style of playing 4 fingers has many advantages but if, like me and many others, you are a more basic player of tunes mostly up and down the rows with a more basic 3 chord trick basses, two or may be three fingers is more than adequate, including on 12 bass boxes. 

I am happy to be in that place on the ven diagram of melodeon players, after all is said and done I have had a happy career that has seen me travel and play through Europe, play for morris and in ceilidh bands and have be admired for my playing.
 

I'm with  Lester on this one!  Whilst I appreciate that some players  want to extract what they see as 'the best' out of the bass I worry about some of the  posts in this thread  making those who get along fine for their type of music with 2 fingers  feel they are not doing things 'properly'.  Most of us have at various times agreed that there is no 'correct' way of playing a melodeon and whatever floats yer boat goes  if it does what an individual wants.  To me four finger bass playhing works well  for those who delight in playing  long heavy and sometimes turgid chords continuosly and with little or no rhythm.   For those who want to play with the bounce that is very much part of English ( or indeed British  & Irish) melodeon playing 2 fingers   are  quite enough .  This is not to say don't use 3 or 4  but just to temper  some of the postings that seem to indicate that those using only wo fingers  are not playing the thing properly.  Lets remain a broad church!

george -   doing a bit of stiring   ;D
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 08, 2012, 12:12:57 PM
I have already stated that I share the views of Lester and George over this, so I will not reiterate my reasons for doing so. However, I do want to take issue with the view expressed by some that if you play a box with more than eight basses, the two-finger method limits what you can do. I spend most of my time playing boxes with twelve or fourteen basses and I do not feel that using two fingers rather than three or four limits my playing in any way.

I have tried using tree and four fingers over an extended period of time and I found that it didn't suit me as well as using two fingers (with the occasional use of a third finger for the kind of complex chords referred to by Anahata). Using two fingers so that the middle finger always plays the fundamental and the index finger always plays the chord has positive advantages, although it does mean that you jump around a bit with the fingers of your left hand. However, you soon come to know instinctively how far to jump. In some ways, this is similar to the jumping around with the right hand that one-row Cajun players undertake as a matter of course.

Some here are advising that new starters should be encouraged to play the bass end with four fingers. I disagree strongly with this. It seems better to me for beginners to be shown (or have explained to them) the advantages and disadvantages of each of these three ways of playing the basses and then to experiment with them and to use whichever seems most appropriate and most comfortable for them.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 08, 2012, 12:17:31 PM

Some here are advising that new starters should be encouraged to play the bass end with four fingers. I disagree strongly with this. It seems better to me for beginners to be shown (or have explained to them) the advantages and disadvantages of each of these three ways of playing the basses and then to experiment with them and to use whichever seems most appropriate and most comfortable for them.

This is exactly what I plan to do in my next tutorial.  Well said Bob!
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 08, 2012, 12:36:59 PM
I would add the following:

Using three chord trick and oom-pah basses, including the "red hot" mentality, is a very powerful technique and I use it myself when the music wants me too. This is perfectly possible with two fingers, but it is also possible with three or four. Plus, using three or four fingers gives you lots more options.

I would also add that in a beginner's context, although I agree that they should be taught the controversy, doing so and concluding that therefore they should do whatever they want I think would be overwhelming and would lead to them doing whatever is easiest, whether or not that is suitable for what they want to play in the future. I would always advocate teaching people to use 4 fingers on the bass if it is comfortable for them, as it is a good deal easier to switch to two or three finger bass from four finger bass than the other way round, and that using multiple fingers gives you everything that you can do with two fingers and more.

EDIT: I own two push pull boxes with unisonoric bass ends. They are great, but not suitable for everything. I will always play an 8 bass box in addition to all the oddities, because it is a wonderful system. But I will always use four fingers.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bobtheboat on June 08, 2012, 12:45:47 PM
I've got a h114 in C coming over from Germany in the next few days so I guess I'll be learning to use 2 fingers on the bass from scratch! Hehehe.
I meant no criticism ,in my posts, of the two and three finger camp and took care to moderate my language and to state that there were many of that camp who are much better players than me (for now >:E). My apologies if my posts ruffled your feathers. Bob.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 08, 2012, 12:59:08 PM
I would also add that in a beginner's context, although I agree that they should be taught the controversy, doing so and concluding that therefore they should do whatever they want I think would be overwhelming and would lead to them doing whatever is easiest, whether or not that is suitable for what they want to play in the future. I would always advocate teaching people to use 4 fingers on the bass if it is comfortable for them, as it is a good deal easier to switch to two or three finger bass from four finger bass than the other way round, and that using multiple fingers gives you everything that you can do with two fingers and more.

You are making the mistake, Owen, of assuming that everyone's mind (and fingers) work as yours do. One of the fundamental concepts of all teaching is to recognise that people's minds work in different ways and that it is important to provide them with alternative ways of learning so that they can adopt the one that suits their way of thinking. Put crudely, some people think visually, some mathematically, others verbally, and so on. Providing alternative methods of using the basses is not an encouragement to adopt the easist approach (some will do that, but they would probably gravitate towards the easiest method even if you didn't mention it!); rather, it is a way of enabling each student to learn in the way that best suits the way his or her mind works.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Howard Jones on June 08, 2012, 01:15:51 PM
We've been talking about how to play without mentioning what is played.  If we think about what is happening musically, for the majority of players what is played on the bass end will usually involve either alternating between two buttons or holding down two buttons.  In other words, for most playing only two fingers at a time are normally required, and what is being debated is which fingers these should be.

Using more than two fingers may help to get around the keyboard more easily (although an 8-bass keyboard is not very large) but is not necessary.  On the other hand it may be difficult for some players to comfortably reach the buttons with their little finger, while others may find they lose their sense of position when using three.

I'm not sure that using three or four buttons gives you more options.  There may be occasions where 3 or even more buttons may be played simultaneously but for most players these can be considered exceptional situations when an extra finger or fingers can be brought into play.   I think what we are talking about here is the 'default' method for normal playing. and for this then any two fingers will do.  For me, this is usually the first  finger and either the middle or the ring finger, but other players may be comfortable with different combinations.  Some combinations of buttons may require a long stretch which may be easier if you have more fingers to choose from, but if you can manage them with just two fingers then it will work.

It appears to me that the only advantage of using four fingers is that each finger 'belongs' to a horizontal pair of buttons, so the hand doesn't have to move and there is less danger of losing one's place.  That's may be useful, but  I don't believe it's a compelling reason to struggle with four fingers if a player finds that difficult.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: ladydetemps on June 08, 2012, 01:24:44 PM
On my posts about my very easy video lessons there have been a couple of comments about lining up your four fingers with the  4 x 2 bass buttons on an 8 bass box.

This does make perfect sense of course. I must admit I only use three fingers and I don't think it's hampered me yet but of course I can't say for sure.

I'm being a bit hypocritical here as I am always picking my guitar students up on not using the fourth finger of their fretting hand.

So what do we think?  The fourth finger is notoriously weak so would it put a beginner off if they had to play their very first bass line (G bass G chord) with finger 4 and finger 3 respectively?   I'm not sure so I'd like to know what the consensus is on this.

Thank you.
I'm a bit of a freak...it depends on the tune (what key etc.) to number of fingers used...
when I play on G row I use 3 fingers it is the fore finger I abandon and the pinkie and two middle fingers that get used. Just coz I struggle to use forefinger and airbutton together.  Just coz I struggle to use forefinger and airbutton together.

when I play on D row I use two fingers.

And I tend not to think about basses (and if possible not use them) as as soon as I think about them the treble end goes wrong.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 08, 2012, 01:53:43 PM
You are making the mistake, Owen, of assuming that everyone's mind (and fingers) work as yours do. One of the fundamental concepts of all teaching is to recognise that people's minds work in different ways and that it is important to provide them with alternative ways of learning so that they can adopt the one that suits their way of thinking. Put crudely, some people think visually, some mathematically, others verbally, and so on. Providing alternative methods of using the basses is not an encouragement to adopt the easist approach (some will do that, but they would probably gravitate towards the easiest method even if you didn't mention it!); rather, it is a way of enabling each student to learn in the way that best suits the way his or her mind works.

I agree with you about teaching - I have spent the last 4 years getting more and more annoyed with my university department for not taking people's learning methods into account.

But I hold that giving people too much choice in their musical development too early is detrimental. I've given a few masterclasses on box and I have always said that there is no "correct" technique, here is what people do, this is why they do it. I think that it is a good idea for people to try out a large range of different techniques and realise how they affect the sound. However, if I were to teach someone, I would try to teach them the technique that would give them greatest scope in the future and would not set them back should they wish to go down a particular path. If you learn two fingers and then want to do Cutting-esque basses, you are going to find it difficult. If you learn four fingers and want to do oom-pah red hot basses then it will be easy.

And aside from the three/four finger debate (matching fingers to chord and basses), I don't really see how learning style comes into this. In my head it is much more about physical movement rather than mental processing. But I might be biased in this from having a piano background, I have no problem with the concept that all four fingers can do different things. But I'm sure that I wasn't born with this - just because someone struggles with something isn't a reason to give up and just because someone finds something difficult doesn't mean that their brain is wired against it.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: oggiesnr on June 08, 2012, 03:07:29 PM
... and the number of people who have been put off playing an instrument because they can't do the "proper" technique is huge.

Essentially the teacher is saying "this is best, anything else is not as good and will limit what you can do". At that point some people (and I've been one) switch off and drop the instrument concerned even though a compromise may in fact allow them to play the instrument perfectly adequately if not to the standard of the best virtuosi.

I have problems with both my thumbs and for double bass it means that my left thumb opposes my first finger not the second and my right hand bow grip is ugly.  However my teacher is great "If it works for you then that's what we go with".  Likewise I don't have a huge reach with my left hand so we work round that when playing at the top end of the fingerboard.  A didactic "first to fourth finger is always a tone"  approach would not work because my hand can't do it.

The physical limitations that people's hand's and bodies (how often have we seen boxes for sale because the seller needs a lighter box) is a crucial part of this debate and for a teacher an important part in deciding the approach and curriculum that should be followed.

Steve
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 08, 2012, 03:35:28 PM
Don't think anyone has gone very far beyond not teaching a 'limited' technique to a beginner. For up and down the rowing 2 (dare I offer, one  >:E) fingers is fine. If they don't want to do the exercise that gets the others going - fine too.    All that I've personally asserted is ..

Quote
I was another early 4 finger switcher and would recommend it to anyone as it is the foundation for those nice bass runs we all admire.  When you upgrade to 12 bass you'll definitely need it,

Reflecting my own journey. (They had me covering Dpull/Abbass on 18-bass for one tune :'( Still hurts to think about it).

Quote
I think that the [objective] should be to get as many fingers in play as they can.

Does anyone really take issue with that?

Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 08, 2012, 04:38:45 PM
As a newcomer to the accordion, I see both sides of this issue: playing the basses with two fingers is unquestionably easier to start with. This makes it easier to progress into more fluent & complex playing without spending months grappling with controlling the third, & (especially) the fourth finger. Progressing more quickly is gratifying & spurs further progress.  On the other hand, I can see that using the third & fourth fingers allows for more efficient & complex bass playing in the long run.

I think I'm going to make an effort to get the third finger working - not sure about the fourth however.  :-\
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 08, 2012, 04:54:54 PM
Quote
I was another early 4 finger switcher and would recommend it to anyone as it is the foundation for those nice bass runs we all admire.  When you upgrade to 12 bass you'll definitely need it,

Quote
I think that the [objective] should be to get as many fingers in play as they can.

Does anyone really take issue with that?

Yes, Chris, I would take issue with two points. Firstly, you don't "definitely need" to use four fingers when you upgrade to 12 basses. As you know, my main squeezes are a Castagnari Benny with 12 basses and an 'Ellis Pariselle' with 14 basses, frequently playing in keys that require the use of at least 12 bass buttons, and I have never found the need to use more than two fingers except in exceptional circumstances. I can play 12 or 14 basses better with two fingers than I can with three or four, so one doesn't necessarily 'need' more than two fingers to play 12 basses. Of course, many people find it easier to play with four fingers. All I am saying is that 'four fingers good, two fingers bad' does not apply to everybody.

It follows from the above that I would also take issue with your claim that the objective should be to get as many fingers in play as possible. I would redefine that objective as being to develop a style of playing that enables one to explore the full range of possibilities with the bass end, and to use however many fingers it takes to develop the bass end of the instrument to its full potential. That number will vary from person to person. For instance, there are bass runs that some people use three or four fingers to achieve, whereas I find them easier with two fingers.

That word 'easier' is important. If you keep struggling on with a system that you find difficult, it will be detrimental to one's playing not only of the bass end, but also of the melody. (I speak from experience of having spent over a year of determined practice to try and play with four fingers - the worst melodeon-related decision I ever made - before reverting to two fingers.) The easier and more natural the bass end is to play, even when executing complex runs, then the less your brain has to concentrate on playing the basses, thus enabling it to focus more fully on expression, ornamentation and so on.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 08, 2012, 05:10:41 PM
Quote
I think that the objective should be to get as many fingers in play as they can.
I can play 12 or 14 basses better with two fingers than I can with three or four

.. and your problem is?  ::)   I'd invite Bob to reconsider on the 12 or 14 as I was talking about 'crossed' chords and that bit was (http://cdn.wikimg.net/strategywiki/images/1/16/Skizzerz_Scissors.png) snipped.

I confess I try to use the pinkie in bass runs too, and it may by time I came out of the closet as a 'South Paw'. From the above I suspect Bob .. isn't?  Do you use all the fingers on the right end?

[apologies to Lester, I was in mid edit] If you're happy, you're happy  8) But  I repeat, we are were talking 'advice to beginners'
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 08, 2012, 05:12:19 PM
... and the number of people who have been put off playing an instrument because they can't do the "proper" technique is huge.

Essentially the teacher is saying "this is best, anything else is not as good and will limit what you can do". At that point some people (and I've been one) switch off and drop the instrument concerned even though a compromise may in fact allow them to play the instrument perfectly adequately if not to the standard of the best virtuosi.

I have problems with both my thumbs and for double bass it means that my left thumb opposes my first finger not the second and my right hand bow grip is ugly.  However my teacher is great "If it works for you then that's what we go with".  Likewise I don't have a huge reach with my left hand so we work round that when playing at the top end of the fingerboard.  A didactic "first to fourth finger is always a tone"  approach would not work because my hand can't do it.

The physical limitations that people's hand's and bodies (how often have we seen boxes for sale because the seller needs a lighter box) is a crucial part of this debate and for a teacher an important part in deciding the approach and curriculum that should be followed.

Steve

I have said several times that physical discomfort is a good reason to abandon this particular technique.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lester on June 08, 2012, 05:16:17 PM
Quote
I think that the objective should be to get as many fingers in play as they can.
I can play 12 or 14 basses better with two fingers than I can with three or four

.. and your problem is?  ::)

Hopefully I can answer this for Bob. His problem is that he (and I) can play 12 bass boxes with two fingers to our safisfaction whereas you clearly state "When you upgrade to 12 bass you'll definitely need it"
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Pete Jackson on June 08, 2012, 05:24:29 PM
I think the 8 - 12 - 14 bass thing may be a bit of a red herring. What is important in this respect is the muscle memory involved in your hand/fingers knowing where they are in relation the keys you are playing and being able to go to the right place for the next keys/buttons without too much concious thought. No guitarist has hands big enough to cover all the frets on the neck and no piano player has hands big enough to cover all the keys on the keyboard (although Art Tatum came close!) without movement. They can, however, go to the right fret/key smoothly and without looking. Equally on the left hand of the melodeon developing this spacial awareness is I think more important than exactly how you achieve it. In any case I could not agree more with Howard - its how it sounds that really matters and we all probably adapt our styles to the requirements of the music being played at the time.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lost Alamos on June 08, 2012, 06:48:56 PM
Okay, the genius of playing is for each their opinion and style. There is nothing wrong with feeling good about ones'self as you may just be "crackers" and celebrated by many. But the point is once you become Gods gift to talent he may still whisper that you encourage others to use the fingers
he gave you. young people who would like to discover the full meaning of the instrument might not
be so put off using the pinkie and their educators can help their progress by thinking outside the
Box of their own Bravado..
Cheers
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 09, 2012, 12:09:15 AM
I'd invite Bob to reconsider on the 12 or 14 as I was talking about 'crossed' chords and that bit was (http://cdn.wikimg.net/strategywiki/images/1/16/Skizzerz_Scissors.png) snipped.

I confess I try to use the pinkie in bass runs too, and it may by time I came out of the closet as a 'South Paw'. From the above I suspect Bob .. isn't?  Do you use all the fingers on the right end?

I wasn't aware, Chris that you were talking about 'crossed chords', by which I assume you mean chords like Am7 (made by playing an A fundamental with a C chord). I do sometimes use a third finger for this type of chord, but not always.

If by a 'South Paw' you mean somebody who is naturally left-handed, but plays the melodeon right-handed, then you would be wrong in your assumption - that is precisely what I am. Therefore, I have greater dexterity with my left hand than with my right. It is just that the shape and size of my hand and the way in which my mind works are not suited to the four-finger method.

In answer to your final question, yes, I do use all four fingers of my right-hand. Why? - because I find it comfortable and helpful to do so and because I can easily reach the buttons with all four fingers without contorting my hand into peculiar positions or losing my sense of where my fingers are in relation to the buttons. So why don't I use four fingers on the left hand? - for closely related reasons. When I do so, it contorts my fingers into uncomfortable positions, which has an adverse effect on the quality of my playing, and I tend to lose my sense of where my fingers are in relation to the buttons.

I would reiterate that I am not suggesting that those who prefer using three or four fingers are wrong, merely that it doesn't suit everyone and that the pros and cons of different methods should be made clear to beginners so that they can find the method that suits them best. A few years ago, I was pressurised by well-meaning players more skilled and experienced than myself into converting to the four-finger method and it did serious damage to my playing because it did not suit me. When I reverted to the two-finger method, my playing immediately began to improve again. By suggesting that the advantages and disadvantages of different methods should be explained to beginners, I am trying to prevent them being badgered as I was into doing something to improve their playing that may have the opposite effect if they happen to be among those people who are not suited manually or mentally to the four-finger approach.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lyra on June 09, 2012, 12:18:02 AM
It has to be asked - how many fingers are you using to type this stuff?

(http://i359.photobucket.com/albums/oo35/veleten/sm_78.gif)

(I'm using all of mine thanks to a sweaty summer at Pitman College)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lester on June 09, 2012, 07:34:20 AM
It has to be asked - how many fingers are you using to type this stuff?

(http://i359.photobucket.com/albums/oo35/veleten/sm_78.gif)

(I'm using all of mine thanks to a sweaty summer at Pitman College)

But do you have your thumb on the edge of the keyboard or behind it and how many straps do you have on your laptop  ;)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 09, 2012, 08:19:23 AM
.. careful there Lester!   ::)

There's a really pithy analogy behind Lyra's innocent little question. Bob's nicely demonstrated disconnect between handedness and how many fingers one can manage to get in play on each side. I actually think my right side knows more tricks too, but that's sort of build into melodeonism?

Confirming I'm left handed too .. here goes:  I use three fingers of each hand typing this, neither pinkie, left thumb (only) on the space bar, and I'll further confess that  my right ring finger only really knows its way to the Delete/End/Page↕ block. But then I'm a complete autodidact in typing technique - medics still use a thing known to ancient Brits as a 'Biro' at work. (I borrowed a pen yesterday that had a 'nib', and 'ink')!

I suspect that .. if as a beginner .. someone had shown me a different way ... rest my case  :|glug
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 09, 2012, 10:52:17 AM
I use three fingers on my right hand and two on my left with the third coming into use occasionally for Caps Lock, Tab and combinations such as Ctrl + S. My little fingers are too short to reach the keyboard withut distorting my hand position....Now where have I heard that before?  >:E
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: diatosoldo on June 09, 2012, 11:14:10 AM
I read all that and tried to understand it completely, though it was sometimes a bit technical for my understanding  ::)

I use four fingers, and I don't find any trouble in doing so, since I place my fingers exactly the same way I do with a glass of wine (picture attached).

But maybe this requires some training ?
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: IanD on June 09, 2012, 11:55:18 AM
... and the number of people who have been put off playing an instrument because they can't do the "proper" technique is huge.

Essentially the teacher is saying "this is best, anything else is not as good and will limit what you can do". At that point some people (and I've been one) switch off and drop the instrument concerned even though a compromise may in fact allow them to play the instrument perfectly adequately if not to the standard of the best virtuosi.

I have problems with both my thumbs and for double bass it means that my left thumb opposes my first finger not the second and my right hand bow grip is ugly.  However my teacher is great "If it works for you then that's what we go with".  Likewise I don't have a huge reach with my left hand so we work round that when playing at the top end of the fingerboard.  A didactic "first to fourth finger is always a tone"  approach would not work because my hand can't do it.

The physical limitations that people's hand's and bodies (how often have we seen boxes for sale because the seller needs a lighter box) is a crucial part of this debate and for a teacher an important part in deciding the approach and curriculum that should be followed.

Steve

I have said several times that physical discomfort is a good reason to abandon this particular technique.
Also what I said. Another thought for the "two-finger" proponents is that even with 8 basses you have to move your hand and fingers around less using three fingers than with two -- I often see people playing with two fingers having to physically move their hand up and down the box between playing the lower four buttons and the upper ones. Or if you don't do this you have to bend the fingers sideways and/or flex the hand to do this. Neither is as comfortable as using three fingers, which seems ergonomically to be optimum. In my opinion ;-)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 09, 2012, 07:32:47 PM
I think the typing analogy is a very good one. Like a lot of people, after years of practice, I type reasonably fast using  two + thumb on each hand, but there's no question that "trained" typists using all fingers are able to type much faster & more accurately.

Although I feel comfortable enough playing with two fingers on the basses, when I look at video of myself playing it's obviously an awkward transition jumping from the top to bottom buttons & it's not hard to imagine that this transition probably effects the ability to "feather" the bass buttons - perhaps less of an issue when playing very rhythmic tunes.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lyra on June 09, 2012, 07:45:37 PM
Personally, I think the glass of wine thing is also very apposite.
As they say, position is everything (http://cdn.astroempires.com/images/smilies/209228.gif)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Roland OBrien on June 09, 2012, 08:42:23 PM
I'm a complete beginner - I started playing a couple of days ago. Having seen earlier debates on this issue, I'd decided to try the 4-finger method, from the start.

I'm not sure I'll stick with it though, so hearing I don't "have" to, is quite reassuring! I can live with some blistering on the pinkie (akin to toughening up your fretting-hand fingertips if you're learning the guitar - unpleasant but temporary). But I am finding I need to put my left hand a long way through the strap in order for the pinkie to reach the further buttons, with the result that my inside forearm is pressed hard against the rear edge of the box, leaving a sore dent in my arm after a few minutes' playing. Also, whist the pinkie is extended to hit the furthest button, my other left-hand fingers have to be curled over, claw-like, to press the buttons.

Is this bad technique on my part, or are these the sort of issues that have led some of you to deliberately only use 2 or 3 fingers?
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 09, 2012, 08:56:48 PM
I've never actually analysed what I do with my left hand, but in the light of this thread I began to observe more closely. It turns out I use 3 fingers 99.9% of the time; the little finger comes into play occasionally for the odd bass run, but generally 3 fingers does it for me.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: george garside on June 09, 2012, 11:15:24 PM
There are two different approachess  to the 'how many fingers for bass' as for as beginners are concerned each with , according to its advocates, different merits.

  For the experienced player it is totally a matter of personal choce taken in the light of type of music played, flexibility and length of digits,  number of bass etc etc. There is also of course the option prefered by many of sometimes using 2, sometims 3 and perhaps occasionally 4 fiingers again depending on whats being played on what.  A point that has not been made is that sometimes no fingers are best  - less is more  - a simple ay of throwing the emphasis on the melody from time to time or perhaps of playing a slow air fiddle style in its entirity.

However  in my opinion the choice between 2 or more fingers for beginners brings in another factor .The single most important thing for most beginners is to get them up and running as quickly as possible i.e. able to ?play ?struggle through a handfulof tunes , maybe even without any bass as soon as possible  so that enthusiasm for the hard and sometimes isolated slog towards 'intermediate'or whatever you want to call it is achieved instead of the not uncommon alternative of shoving the box on top of the wardrobe to gather dust.  This vital initial enthusiasm is  usually attained by keeping things as simple as possible  and 2 finger um pah ing on the bass is as much as many can hope to achieve in their early stages - anything more complicated can result in frustration and a 'wardrobe' melodeon.  Later 'conversion' to 4 finger bass ( and then only if desired) may take a bit of relearning etc  but will  be done then for enjoyment rather than being off putting at a time when  as rapid progress as possible  is the best foundation for future fun!

george :||: :|||: :|glug ;D
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 10, 2012, 08:57:23 AM
Well said, George!
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: waltzman on June 10, 2012, 01:20:16 PM
Very well said, George.  If you are wanting to be a top notch concert violinist then worrying about studying the 'right' technique from the beginning might be appropriate.  If you are learning the melodeon for the pure joy of making music then get those tunes going as quick as possible and worry about fine tuning technique (much) later.  Countless children have been put off making music by well meaning teachers trying to drill the 'right' technique from the get go.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: IanD on June 10, 2012, 03:17:43 PM
Very well said, George.  If you are wanting to be a top notch concert violinist then worrying about studying the 'right' technique from the beginning might be appropriate.  If you are learning the melodeon for the pure joy of making music then get those tunes going as quick as possible and worry about fine tuning technique (much) later.  Countless children have been put off making music by well meaning teachers trying to drill the 'right' technique from the get go.
True -- but once a habit (like using two fingers) is learned it can be very difficult to unlearn once the "second-funger-oom-first-finger-pah" has been hardwired into your brain.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 10, 2012, 03:28:41 PM
Once a habit (like using two fingers) is learned it can be very difficult to unlearn once the "second-funger-oom-first-finger-pah" has been hardwired into your brain.

True, but is it not better to encounter difficulty relearning something once one has made sufficient progress with the instrument to be committed to it than to face daunting difficulties at the outset and just give up?

I wonder how many of those advocating starting with four fingers from the outset actually did that themselves.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: george garside on June 10, 2012, 04:40:42 PM
to which I would add  that   the melodeon is a folk/fun/traditional or whatevr you want to call it instrument , thankfully without the burden of  the exams & grades  that  can put many off whatever instrument they are learning to play.

  Whilst there is absolutely nothing wrong with playing the bass with as many fingers as you like there is also absolutely nothing wrong with getting by nicely using 2 fingers for a lifetimes playing  and by some strange coincidence this is what the majority of  DG players do.   Similarly the majority of  BC players get  by perfectly happily with little or no bass and stalwart one rowers  playi  2 when they sound ok and   none when they don't. 

george
 
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 10, 2012, 06:29:08 PM
Yes. It seems to me that traditional music teaching (piano) emphasizes correct technique above all else. My wife spent years "studying" piano, when she was young younger . She now unable to play at all without sheet music - no improvising, no ability to pick out chords & add a melody.  She very rarely plays. I wonder how many others have gone through the same process?
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: oggiesnr on June 10, 2012, 06:53:47 PM
I'm a complete beginner - I started playing a couple of days ago. Having seen earlier debates on this issue, I'd decided to try the 4-finger method, from the start.

I'm not sure I'll stick with it though, so hearing I don't "have" to, is quite reassuring! I can live with some blistering on the pinkie (akin to toughening up your fretting-hand fingertips if you're learning the guitar - unpleasant but temporary). But I am finding I need to put my left hand a long way through the strap in order for the pinkie to reach the further buttons, with the result that my inside forearm is pressed hard against the rear edge of the box, leaving a sore dent in my arm after a few minutes' playing. Also, whist the pinkie is extended to hit the furthest button, my other left-hand fingers have to be curled over, claw-like, to press the buttons.

Is this bad technique on my part, or are these the sort of issues that have led some of you to deliberately only use 2 or 3 fingers?

It's the sort of issue that led me to being a two (rarely three) fingered player.  You are not alone  (:)

Steve
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lost Alamos on June 10, 2012, 07:20:35 PM
There was a time when I had a one row [melodeon] and I discovered that the pinkie
and index finger were the principle idea for left hand security[base pink- chord index]. that
left the ring and middle finger for holding on. Security was there the instant I used that
combination. I do think that most all here from their beginnings considered the root/5th
principle for playing the bass side..strickly a 2 chord options. Push root/5th pull.
From there the inspired found many options with the 2 row. Each using his instincts to
coordinate his left hand. Often forgetting they may have used their pinkie with great
trust with the one row [left hand]. taking that pink to the 8 basses 2 row was obvious if your
where the cat's meow with the cajan one row. And for all the guitar players that came to the melodeon after the playing of that lovely instrument [the guitar], the big pink is a obvious translation to the diatonic accordeon. Never taught someone to play the guitar without his pink. Never would
teach someone to play the melodeon without his pink unless he said he/she couldn't do it which
really was a lie to themselves. But, do your thing and be happy you think music is easy.
My impression from watching is that those who have fun and are still super instrumentalest
use what they have and learned early on nothing is easy. EAsiest is the first tale of half done.
And your right about piano players. they followed the teachers instructions and many became less
then profound. they often forget to take the additional theory of harmony and yada yada yada.
I realize I am writing to all the pure genius on this site so forgive me as a player who when I was a young man had many questions but found few answers because I was told to do my thing before
I knew what the thing was. Naturally I did everything without my PINKY.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 10, 2012, 07:31:18 PM
Yes. It seems to me that traditional music teaching (piano) emphasizes correct technique above all else. My wife spent years "studying" piano, when she was young younger . She now unable to play at all without sheet music - no improvising, no ability to pick out chords & add a melody.  She very rarely plays. I wonder how many others have gone through the same process?

Equally, I was classically trained, but was trained to play everything from memory and was taught to pick things up by ear before being taught sight reading. I can pick out chords, improvise harmony, etc. Suzuki method people, read it and weep.

I must admit to being surprised at how many people find four finger bass uncomfortable. I think then that the problem is with the instrument...
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: oggiesnr on June 10, 2012, 07:39:19 PM
...Never would  teach someone to play the melodeon without his pink unless he said he/she couldn't do it which
really was a lie to themselves...

Hm, if this means what it seems to mean ...

Steve
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 10, 2012, 10:06:13 PM
I must admit to being surprised at how many people find four finger bass uncomfortable. I think then that the problem is with the instrument...

That is because you are assuming that everyone's left hand has the same size and proportions as yours and that everyone's mind works in the same way that yours does. This is not the case!
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Theo on June 10, 2012, 10:22:20 PM
I must admit to being surprised at how many people find four finger bass uncomfortable. I think then that the problem is with the instrument...

That is because you are assuming that everyone's left hand has the same size and proportions as yours and that everyone's mind works in the same way that yours does. This is not the case!

It's not even as simple as that.  To use four fingers I found I had to adopt a different position for my left hand with the hand further through the strap, and the arm at a different angle.  This requires adjustment to the position of the box relative to the body, and small shifts in your whole posture in order to find a comfortable hold on the box.
So to anyone who started off with fewer fingers but feels the need to try four, don't be put off if it feels awkward to start with, there is quite a lot of adjustment to do.

As an experiment yesterday I tried playing with two fingers on the left hand.   Interesting exercise, the main observation being that I found it impossible to reach the air button while playing the lower four buttons! :'(
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Ollie on June 10, 2012, 10:43:35 PM
I tried one finger bass earlier.

Worked a treat!
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: mory on June 10, 2012, 10:44:31 PM
I found this post took me on a journey through different instruments and left hand finger combinations over a number of years. Guitar 4 no problem or 3, Accordion basses P.A. and British Chromatic 4 automatically for bass runs and counter bass melodies with no problem, concertina 4 a necessity automatic, Tenor banjo 3 as mandolin and 4 like Gerry O', but for some reason I've only ever really found 3 to be practical on melodeon basses I think it probably started with DG with the pinkie leading the charge on the G bass never seemed to manage the same fluidity. AtB mory
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 10, 2012, 11:01:25 PM
That is because you are assuming that everyone's left hand has the same size and proportions as yours and that everyone's mind works in the same way that yours does. This is not the case!

Well this is the point. A good instrument should be adaptable to lots of people's geometries. I am well aware that I am probably in the 95th percentile in terms of hand size, so it is ludicrous if I am one of the few who can use all four fingers. If is the case then it points to a major flaw in the physical ergonomics of the instrument. I am aware that some people will not take to using four fingers due to the way that their brain works, and I am aware that there are some who feel that their little finger is not strong enough (although this can be rectified), but it has shocked me somewhat as to the number of people who find four fingers physically uncomfortable. I think that if the box was to be redesigned, the bass side should not be in that position. Perhaps similar to the Schwyzerorgeli instead in rake.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lyra on June 10, 2012, 11:52:45 PM
I have baby paws and tiny pinkies - but 4 fingers is fine.
I had to sell my D whistle in the end - just couldn't get the stretch. Now have lovely plastic one with siccama key (which I had to get from Canada since I couldn't find a stockist in the UK, leading to the conclusion that all Brits have hands like hams since they apparently don't need them).
Is now the moment for **this?** (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifKKlhYF53w)
I bet at least one of you could fettle something up
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Howard Jones on June 11, 2012, 12:09:22 AM
if I am one of the few who can use all four fingers. If is the case then it points to a major flaw in the physical ergonomics of the instrument.

But that assumes that using four fingers is the ideal.  Since people seem to be able to play it perfectly well with 3 or even 2 fingers, the argument that the design is flawed doesn't stand up.

My experience is similar to Mory's.  I took up melodeon after already playing guitar and anglo, so I was used to using the little finger, but I don't use it much for melodeon (LH that is, I use it a lot on the right).  I was entirely self-taught and so far as I can recall I didn't consciously copy other players when learning the left hand, I just did what came naturally, which was to play with 3 fingers. 

Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 11, 2012, 12:33:57 AM
if I am one of the few who can use all four fingers. If is the case then it points to a major flaw in the physical ergonomics of the instrument.

But that assumes that using four fingers is the ideal.  Since people seem to be able to play it perfectly well with 3 or even 2 fingers, the argument that the design is flawed doesn't stand up.

My experience is similar to Mory's.  I took up melodeon after already playing guitar and anglo, so I was used to using the little finger, but I don't use it much for melodeon (LH that is, I use it a lot on the right).  I was entirely self-taught and so far as I can recall I didn't consciously copy other players when learning the left hand, I just did what came naturally, which was to play with 3 fingers.

No it doesn't, it assumes that using four fingers is a technique which has advantages and is used or would be used by a significant proportion of players. Which I think is the case.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lyra on June 11, 2012, 01:27:00 AM
As an experiment yesterday I tried playing with two fingers on the left hand.   Interesting exercise, the main observation being that I found it impossible to reach the air button while playing the lower four buttons! :'(

Someone selling a box on ebay that's just what you need, then...
(http://i689.photobucket.com/albums/vv252/zpapmusic/Accordions/028-4.jpg)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Howard Jones on June 11, 2012, 08:57:11 AM

No it doesn't, it assumes that using four fingers is a technique which has advantages and is used or would be used by a significant proportion of players. Which I think is the case.

With respect, I think that comes to much the same thing - it suggests that there are significant advantages to using four fingers, which more players would adopt if they could.  However it appears to me from this lengthy and interesting discussion that the case is far from proved.

Logically, as there are four rows of buttons then using four fingers seems to make sense.  Empirically, a great many players seem to find it natural to use three  (including some whose experience of other instruments has developed strength and co-ordination in the little finger, so that's not an excuse), with no loss of playing ability.  Of course, if the keyboard were designed differently then perhaps these people would also have found it natural to use four, but from my own experience I think not.  Any advantages to using four fingers are, I think, fairly small and insignificant insofar as being able to play the basses is concerned.  I defy anyone to tell from listening to the music whether 3 or 4 fingers are being used.

My conclusion is that it doesn't really matter whether you habitually use 3 fingers or 4.  The melodeon isn't such a sophisticated instrument that fine details of technique make much difference.  If you're comfortable playing with 4 fingers that's fine, and if you're comfortable with 3 that's fine too - I really don't believe it will make any difference at all to one's ability to play.  Using only 2 fingers does risk limiting you, imo, but some players seem to be able to overcome that.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: IanD on June 11, 2012, 10:20:27 AM
What Howard said :-)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: george garside on June 11, 2012, 11:39:28 AM
just a thought  but could  the 3- 4 finger advocates also be (mostly) single strap players who are  using the left hand to keep the box  in place relative to the person and are therefore less able to move the whole hand to bring two fingers into play on whatever buttons are required ( plus the occasional 3rd finger if it is desired to depress 3 buttons simultaniarsly)  than are those with the box firmly attached to the person with two straps?

george
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Theo on June 11, 2012, 11:56:42 AM
Not in my case George.  I usually use two straps and four fingers on left hand (and right).
Perhaps the opposite may be true,  I think one or two contributors to this topic have explained that they prefer 3 fingers so that they can brace the pinkie against the LH end to improve stability.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Howard Jones on June 11, 2012, 12:19:09 PM
Me neither.  I usually use two straps now, but for years I was a one-strapper.  Neither do I use the left hand to keep the box in place - that comes from tension in the strap and bracing against the knee or body.  I'm predominantley a 3 finger left/4 finger right player

My reservations about using only 2 fingers are partly the amount of hand movement required and partly the need to stretch for some less obvious chords.  However I acknowledge that some players can manage this.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: oggiesnr on June 11, 2012, 12:29:20 PM
My reservations about using only 2 fingers are partly the amount of hand movement required and partly the need to stretch for some less obvious chords.  However I acknowledge that some players can manage this.

Compared to a double bass the hand movement is negligable  (:)

I wonder whether part of this also stems from a different approach/philosophy to box/bass playing.  I'll be honest, I don't play "less obvious chords" (by which I assume you mean cross chords etc)  because that's never been the way I've approached the music that I play on melodeon.   I tend be very straight ahead in my approach, if I want complex I play my bandoneon (on which I use four fingers).

I accept that I'm not using the box to it's full capabilities but that is my choice and the way I get pleasure out of playing the box just as others get pleasure from be virtuosi and playing the most fiendishly difficult music which I will happily sit back and admire without the burning desire to emulate.

Steve
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 11, 2012, 12:33:55 PM
With respect, I think that comes to much the same thing - it suggests that there are significant advantages to using four fingers, which more players would adopt if they could.  However it appears to me from this lengthy and interesting discussion that the case is far from proved.

I am repeating myself now, so this will probably be my last post on this thread. I believe that there are significant advantages to using four fingers which more players would adopt if they could. And I accept that I am apparently not going to convince people over what I think is a fairly trivial and obvious point.

I think that there is danger of musical snobbery here (not directed at you Howard), with people using I IV V and two fingers looking down on those of us who use the whole of the instrument. I have made pains to never state that using the three chord trick is worse than what I do, indeed for some tunes I could achieve exactly the same effect with only two fingers. But I feel that some posters have bordered on the dismissive when referring to four fingered playing.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: oggiesnr on June 11, 2012, 12:38:22 PM
With respect, I think that comes to much the same thing - it suggests that there are significant advantages to using four fingers, which more players would adopt if they could.  However it appears to me from this lengthy and interesting discussion that the case is far from proved.

I am repeating myself now, so this will probably be my last post on this thread. I believe that there are significant advantages to using four fingers which more players would adopt if they could. And I accept that I am apparently not going to convince people over what I think is a fairly trivial and obvious point.

I think that there is danger of musical snobbery here (not directed at you Howard), with people using I IV V and two fingers looking down on those of us who use the whole of the instrument. I have made pains to never state that using the three chord trick is worse than what I do, indeed for some tunes I could achieve exactly the same effect with only two fingers. But I feel that some posters have bordered on the dismissive when referring to four fingered playing.

Interestingly I thought the snobbery (if it was there) was going in the opposite direction.  (:)

Each to their own.

Steve

PS not all of us who use two fingers exclusively use the three chord trick  8)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 11, 2012, 12:47:02 PM
Having returned from a few days away, I'm stunned this thread has become huge!

I think there is another influence as touched on by recent posts - when the new tune dictates out of the ordinary basses it does bring your playing technique into sharp focus and mean perhaps you might have to move out of your normal comfort zone.
Originally I wanted to 'get on' with playing and felt my little finger was weak yet using 3 I could get on much quicker, as I think I said on page 1 so that's what I did. Recently I've been learing a couple of Andy Cutting tunes and realised his bass technique seems to flow from one chord to another as opposed to um pah's, and there are occasions in the last tune learnt I'm holding down a push D bass/chord using the first 2 fingers, it feels right to simply flex my 3rd/pinkie and move to the G bass/chord.
Some tunes I'm discovering need cross chording so I'm using whatever finger necessary to hold the combination of basses and chords.
I can see there might be occasions in the future when I do try and use my little finger simply because it's easier playing the tune.
Q
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Hello on June 11, 2012, 02:23:47 PM
It's one of those questions to which there is no correct answer. Similar in that respect to the positioning of the right-hand thumb on or behind the fingerboard, or the wearing of 1-∞ straps  ::)

It depends what you want to achieve and how easy it is to achieve it, as to whether you have the motivation to experiment with different finger combinations.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 11, 2012, 04:15:40 PM
It seems that we are going around & around on this one & the only reasonable conclusion is this:
I don't think there's any doubt that using 4 fingers potentially offers the best possibilities for playing. But it is possible to play a lot of tunes equally well using just 2 fingers.  If you're young & committed to a lifetime of playing & improving, taking the trouble to learn to use all 4 fingers definitely seems like a good idea. If you're an old codger with more limited aspirations, 2 or 3 fingers may be fine.

Quote
It depends what you want to achieve and how easy it is to achieve it, as to whether you have the motivation to experiment with different finger combinations.


If it's any comfort to Owen, as a result of this thread, I'm taking a long hard look at getting all 4 fingers working on the basses. I don't know if it will take, but I'm finding I can manage the ergonomics quite easily - it's simply a matter of pushing the hand further through the strap & curling the fingers a bit - the difficulty is in getting the pinkie to co-operate.

Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: george garside on June 11, 2012, 06:54:59 PM
yes we are going round and round   - yes some posters are  becoming increasingly dogmatic in the way they express their opinions - yes  many agree that there is no single best way of fingering the bass - yes  if we carry on  we will all get totally pissed off , board to tears or whatever you want to call it - yes I vote that we  kill it off , at least until it   inevitably resurfaces  in a year or two!

george ::)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 11, 2012, 07:22:22 PM
I would like to thank everyone for their input on this subject. I think my question has been well and truly answered and has probably given us all plenty of food for thought on the subject. Coming from the world of the guitar as I do, there are people like Eric Clapton who rarely uses his 4th finger and this suits his blues-based style admirably whereas Steve Howe (Yes) would never have managed to play what he did without all four.  It's horses for courses as always and I think we all have to agree to differ.  I needed the information for my very easy lessons and I've been able to give an informed and unbiased opinion on the subject. If you're at all interested in what I had to say check out Lesson 5   where I go through the bass part to the tune Bobby Shafto.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Cooper on June 12, 2012, 01:54:25 AM
i would like to add some data to the discussion.

I think in the last 6 or so years i have had probably around 200 students. I teach them that the first thing you need with music is fun. If you have no fun the way you are playing, you need to try playing differently, or quit.
I teach them also to use 4 fingers on both hands. Yes, this requires you to hold your instrument in a different way then if you dont do that. And yes, in the beginning for people without prior training of using those fingers separately this requires training, more training then you would need when playing only with 2 fingers. But you have started to learn something new, why not take that up in the process as well.

Of these 200 people i think about 10? of those have decided that they think the work required for those 2 extra fingers to work properly prohibits them from having enough fun. This can be due to having bodies or brains that dont cooperate for whatever reason possible. They were often good reasons, but even if they werent, it's their decisions. That is ofcourse fine for me. They tried, and decided what is best for them. i am happy to teach them further of they wish me to, and will not fret about it, it's obviously the best choice for them.

All the other players however were able to adjust their way of holding the instrument and train their fingers. Most of them had no trouble at all with using those fingers after the first series of 8 lessons (in 16 weeks). The rest had no trouble after the next series of 8 lessons.

Point is, for most people it is not that hard to learn using those 4 fingers, no need to adjust the instrument in anyway. You have to want to though.

And that last bit is ofcourse the catch. You have to want to...

-Everything you can do with 2 fingers, you can do with 4 fingers as well.

-Some things you can do with 2 fingers just as well as with more.

-A lot of things you can with 4 fingers that you cannot do with 2 fingers.


As a beginner, if you end up liking to play only stuff that you can do equally well with 2 fingers, you have invested some work that wasnt necesary. But i point back to the number of lessons needed to get used to that (and to playing at all on top of that) and point to the fact that it wasnt THAT much investing.

In all the other cases you are better of with 4 fingers. With 4 fingers you have more options. Some people miss those options, some dont.
But for the ones that dont,... it is very often ( not just in music) that if you suddenly were to have the options you would start using them and your joy would increase.

Using only 2 fingers you cannot do anything Legato with your left hand. Not even Oompa-ing the three-chord-mirracle. There will always be a gap between your C-Oompa and your D-push-Oompa (for instance), because you have to jump.

Using only 2 fingers you can never make gapless bass-"walks". E-D-C-B, or C-B-A-G

Using only 2 fingers you can never push some combinations of 2 buttons at the same time. (like Dbass with Em chord, for Em7, or Cbass with Em chord for CM7, or, a more common chord for the three-chord-miracle, Cbass-Dchord for D7). (i hope i have the combinations right, as it is 2.30 am, and i dont play DG)
I will admit that in lots of music you wont need these chords, and you can easily do without those for a musiclifetime. Yet they could make your music (enjoyment) richer. And they could do that for the new beginner as well. And all that for just a small investment.

Very late now,
:-)
W



Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Theo on June 12, 2012, 08:07:04 AM
Moderator message

If you have seen enough of this thread then please simply ignore it.

If you have feel strongly that it is going awry in some way please report your concerns to me by pm or through the message reporting system. Yes there is quite a lot of duplication here and yes it is a long thread, but I don't see either of those as a reason to stop discussion.

Just keep all contributions respectful of the views of others please. (:)

I will remove all the posts which ask for the topic to be closed. :(

Theo  [with stern teacherish face on]
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Howard Jones on June 12, 2012, 09:10:03 AM
I'm inclined to agree with Cooper so far as 2-finger playing is concerned.  I've seen people play some amazing stuff with just two fingers, but I do feel they are making it difficult for themselves.

Where I find it harder to see a distinction is the difference between 4-finger and 3-finger playing.  This is where I respectfully disagree with ukebert - I cannot think of anything which requires all four fingers to achieve (other than a four-finger chord, of course, but surely that is unusual) although I concede it may sometimes be helpful to bring in the little finger I find it is seldom necessary. To be clear, it is its habitual use in normal playing that I am talking about.

It appears to me that the benefits of 4 fingers over 3 are purely mechanical (by which I mean keeping the hand in position relative to the keyboard) rather than giving any musical advantages (by which I mean what can be played).  Nothing I've read so far on this thread has persuaded me otherwise.  However I'd be glad to be enlightened.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 12, 2012, 09:49:48 AM
I cannot think of anything which requires all four fingers to achieve (other than a four-finger chord, of course, but surely that is unusual) although I concede it may sometimes be helpful to bring in the little finger I find it is seldom necessary. To be clear, it is its habitual use in normal playing that I am talking about.

I play right hand 4 finger chords all the time. I admit that the classic 1,3,5,7 chords tend to sound a bit "corner jazz club" in a folk session, but sus chords (as per the new wave guitar stuff in the 80's) are wonderful against our modal music. I'm particularly fond of Bm79  C#,D,F#, B to get a cadence effect against Irish dorian Em. (instead of perpetual Em,D,Em,D, Em ...).  I 'can' play that with 3 fingers, but lets not expand this thread even more into not/covering more than one button.

The latest Pignol/Milleret video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aSQ_KX2u-5I shows some nice 3 finger chords on bass. If the quote above refers to that end - nope I can't think of any either!  But to broaden in another direction .. there are not many other facets of musicality that deliberately restrict harmony to major and minor triads?
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: pikey on June 12, 2012, 12:18:45 PM
I cannot think of anything which requires all four fingers to achieve (other than a four-finger chord, of course, but surely that is unusual) although I concede it may sometimes be helpful to bring in the little finger I find it is seldom necessary. To be clear, it is its habitual use in normal playing that I am talking about.

I play right hand 4 finger chords all the time. I admit that the classic 1,3,5,7 chords tend to sound a bit "corner jazz club" in a folk session, but sus chords (as per the new wave guitar stuff in the 80's) are wonderful against our modal music. I'm particularly fond of Bm79  C#,D,F#, B to get a cadence effect against Irish dorian Em. (instead of perpetual Em,D,Em,D, Em ...).  I 'can' play that with 3 fingers, but lets not expand this thread even more into not/covering more than one button.

The latest Pignol/Milleret video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aSQ_KX2u-5I shows some nice 3 finger chords on bass. If the quote above refers to that end - nope I can't think of any either!  But to broaden in another direction .. there are not many other facets of musicality that deliberately restrict harmony to major and minor triads?

There aren't many other facets of musicality that rely on an instrument that has such limitations!
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Howard Jones on June 12, 2012, 12:28:18 PM
[I play right hand 4 finger chords all the time.

I use the right hand little finger all the time, although I don't often play four finger chords.  However this discussion is about the left hand

Quote

 If the quote above refers to that end - nope I can't think of any either!

It was the bass end I was referring to.

Quote

 there are not many other facets of musicality that deliberately restrict harmony to major and minor triads?

It depends on the type of music you want to play.  For British and Irish folk music there's a strong argument for keeping harmony as simple as possible (even where you're not constrained by the limitations of the instrument). 
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Nick Hudis on June 12, 2012, 12:53:54 PM
After years on the piano and guitar, it never occurred to me not to use four fingers on the box.  Its hard work oom pah-ing between little finger and ring finger but 1) it gets easier with practice 2) I don't do that much oom pah-ing.  On the 18 bass, Using all four fingers opens up some interesting two note combinations.

But as a practice technique to build up coordination, its fun to play the entire bass with one finger or any combination of two fingers.  Four fingers is a doddle after that  (:)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 12, 2012, 01:22:23 PM
I think that Cooper summed up my views admirably.

Howard, I thinki that there are lots of things that would be easier with four fingers rather than three. I'm not sure that there is anything that would be impossible with three that would be possible with four, aside from odd stabs such as CMaj7, a chord that I am using more and more. I have just tried to play with three fingers and found it physically very uncomfortable, just to add that to the mix!
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 12, 2012, 01:45:03 PM
Frankly, it doesn't really MATTER how many fingers you use; do what's comfortable for you, do what works for you and gives you the results you want.  If you find you need more than two fingers, fine; if you don't, then why worry about it?  Django Reinhardt didn't seem to be held back a lot by his deficiency in the digital department.  ;D

Graham
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 12, 2012, 02:01:20 PM
C maj7 = Cbass +Bchord, pull - its a cool chord playing in Em - and a lovely tense chord in G because it implies lydian mode (the G's F# is a #4th against C scale). And you have 6 of the 7 scale notes running on right end to play tune with!  8)  Try it!

G maj7 = Gbass +Echord, push - the ultimate 'relax' chord in G, with all the tension of an Earth lead ;) Can be cool to finish on, but very cliché. Much more fun  when playing in D, where again it's our lydian chord (only 5 scale notes this time)

.. related fingering (and both better with the 3rds out)
   Both complete cripplers using index +middle fingers  :Ph
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Theo on June 12, 2012, 02:18:31 PM
Moderator message

If you have seen enough of this thread then please simply ignore it.

If you have feel strongly that it is going awry in some way please report your concerns to me by pm or through the message reporting system. Yes there is quite a lot of duplication here and yes it is a long thread, but I don't see either of those as a reason to stop discussion.

Just keep all contributions respectful of the views of others please. (:)

I will remove all the posts which ask for the topic to be closed. :(

Theo  [with stern teacherish face on]

I should also add a request:

If you do have more to contribute please do so as long is it is something fresh. 

If you find yourself wanting to repeat something you said before because others have not take your point on board then please restrain yourself.  There are contributors here who clearly are very happy with their own way of playing the bass buttons, however many finger they use, and they are entitled to their views.  Please respect that.

And be nice please!
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: howard mitchell on June 12, 2012, 02:55:53 PM
C maj7 = Cbass +Bchord, pull - its a cool chord playing in Em - and a lovely tense chord in G because it implies lydian mode (the G's F# is a #4th against C scale). And you have 6 of the 7 scale notes running on right end to play tune with!  8)  Try it!

G maj7 = Gbass +Echord, push - the ultimate 'relax' chord in G, with all the tension of an Earth lead ;) Can be cool to finish on, but very cliché. Much more fun  when playing in D, where again it's our lydian chord (only 5 scale notes this time)

.. related fingering (and both better with the 3rds out)
   Both complete cripplers using index +middle fingers  :Ph

Should these perhaps be the other way round -
C maj7 = Cbass +Echord, pull
and
G maj7 = Gbass +Bchord, push

H
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 12, 2012, 03:03:09 PM
And surely G bass with B chord is an augmented major seventh chord, i.e. GMaj7#5?
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: howard mitchell on June 12, 2012, 03:11:04 PM
And surely G bass with B chord is an augmented major seventh chord, i.e. GMaj7#5?
Let's assume that Chris has a Bm.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 12, 2012, 03:51:34 PM
You are right - the G need's the thirds out, the C one tollerates them In the thread's context - sweet and useful chords as per Ukebert - but a crippling stretch if you don't get #4/#5 fingers in play.

whoops - just seen what happens if you copy/paste and then edit wrong row - total bo11ocks pretty poor post all in all  :|bl

 C maj7 = Cbass +Echord, pull
 G maj7 = Gbass +Bchord (thirds out), push 

Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 12, 2012, 04:34:09 PM
Could we have a poll please? I think it would be very interesting to learn how many melnetters use two, three, four fingers. Rather than starting a new thread, could Les add a poll to this thread?

Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 12, 2012, 04:39:12 PM
Could we have a poll please? I think it would be very interesting to learn how many melnetters use two, three, four fingers. Rather than starting a new thread, could Les add a poll to this thread?

Done!!
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 12, 2012, 04:44:52 PM
There's no option for "as many as necessary at the time"..... ;D >:E

Graham
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 12, 2012, 04:47:42 PM
There's no option for "as many as necessary at the time"..... ;D >:E

Graham
Sorted!
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 12, 2012, 05:26:31 PM
Quote
There's no option for "as many as necessary at the time"..... 

I don't think that's a particularly helpful option. We could all come up with a third or fourth finger on a "special occasion"! The real question is, habitually, does your pinkie, the third finger, or the second finger play the lower basses/chords?

 
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 12, 2012, 05:36:23 PM
There's no option for "as many as necessary at the time"..... ;D >:E

Graham
Sorted!

 ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 12, 2012, 05:42:03 PM
Quote
There's no option for "as many as necessary at the time"..... 

I don't think that's a particularly helpful option. We could all come up with a third or fourth finger on a "special occasion"! The real question is, habitually, does your pinkie, the third finger, or the second finger play the lower basses/chords?

Sorry - they do say that humour rarely crosses the Atlantic successfully.  Incidentally, I don't have a "pinkie/y"; I have a thumb, an index finger, a middle finger, a ring finger and a little finger....... >:E

Graham
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 12, 2012, 06:08:34 PM
There's no option for "as many as necessary at the time"..... ;D >:E

Graham
Sorted!
Please may we have a 'vote for more than one option' facility? I mainly use 3 fingers but I will sometimes use 4 depending on the music requirements. So I'd like to vote for both options please.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 12, 2012, 06:54:34 PM
Quote
Sorry - they do say that humour rarely crosses the Atlantic successfully.

I don't know about humour, Graham, but I have crossed the Atlantic. However, this is clearly NOT a laughing matter!   :o

I think the variable finger placement somewhat clouds the issue. I think it's much more informative to indicate what your usual finger placement is.



Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 12, 2012, 06:56:07 PM
Quote
Please may we have a 'vote for more than one option' facility? I mainly use 3 fingers but I will sometimes use 4 depending on the music requirements. So I'd like to vote for both options please.

What I'm trying to establish is what is the most common finger usage, not what you might use occasionally. Posting for a variety of options confuses the question, in my opinion.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 12, 2012, 07:30:27 PM
Quote
Sorry - they do say that humour rarely crosses the Atlantic successfully.

I don't know about humour, Graham, but I have crossed the Atlantic. However, this is clearly NOT a laughing matter!   :o

I think the variable finger placement somewhat clouds the issue. I think it's much more informative to indicate what your usual finger placement is.

Whatever..........
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 12, 2012, 08:47:29 PM
Quote
Please may we have a 'vote for more than one option' facility? I mainly use 3 fingers but I will sometimes use 4 depending on the music requirements. So I'd like to vote for both options please.

What I'm trying to establish is what is the most common finger usage, not what you might use occasionally. Posting for a variety of options confuses the question, in my opinion.
Oh - I think it's more than just occasionally. Quite often really. Three and four fingers. Depending on the music. Sometimes I only use two if I want a drone. I've even been known to use a bit of blue-tack to keep the C chord held down, which leaves me 4 fingers (or 3, or 2 (depending on the music)) free to play the other buttons. But I only do that sometimes.
These polls are just too simplistic to enable detailed responses to be made. And whether any meaningful conclusions can be drawn from them is yet another question...
<sigh>

Epllogue...

Major General: I don’t think we quite understand one another. I ask you, have you ever known what it is to be an orphan, and you say "orphan". As I understand you, you are merely repeating the word "orphan" to show that you understand me.
Pirate King: I didn’t repeat the word often.
Major General: Pardon me, you did indeed.
Pirate King: I only repeated it once.
Major General: True, but you repeated it.
Pirate King: But not often.
Major General: Stop! I think I see where we are getting confused. When you said "orphan", did you mean "orphan" – a person who has lost his parents, or "often", frequently?
Pirate King: Ah! I beg pardon – I see what you mean – frequently.
Major General: Ah! you said "often", frequently.
Pirate King: No, only once.
Major General (irritated): Exactly – you said "often", frequently, only once.

Cue doom music
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Stiamh on June 12, 2012, 09:28:25 PM
Steve, are we supposed to believe that pirates - of all people - would pronounce "orphan" and "often" in the same way? I could believe it of a king of the house of Windsor (r-droppers all), but wouldn't a pirate have a west country accent with pronounced post-vocalic Rs ? Arrr!

All very confusing to North Americans, no doubt. I remember long ago reading an idiot's guide to computer terms which informed me that "baud" was pronounced like "bored". Yes, by a small minority of native speakers of English!

BTW I'm one of those who tried using my l-h fourth/little/pinky finger on my 12-bass box and found it impossible. Possible on an 8-bass, but not a priority for me.

Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 12, 2012, 09:31:57 PM
Steve, are we supposed to believe that pirates - of all people - would pronounce "orphan" and "often" in the same way? I could believe it of a king of the house of Windsor (r-droppers all), but wouldn't a pirate have a west country accent with pronounced post-vocalic Rs ? Arrr!
Yes. Suspend all disbelief. They were 'all noblemen who had gone wrong'.  ;)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lyra on June 13, 2012, 01:02:50 AM
So to sum up (from the beginner's perspective, which I dimly recall being the starting point):
amirite?
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: waltzman on June 13, 2012, 01:42:48 AM
urite! ;)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 13, 2012, 03:41:04 AM
Quote
Major General: I don’t think we quite understand one another. I ask you, have you ever known what it is to be an orphan, and you say "orphan". As I understand you, you are merely repeating the word "orphan" to show that you understand me.
Pirate King: I didn’t repeat the word often.
Major General: Pardon me, you did indeed.
Pirate King: I only repeated it once.
Major General: True, but you repeated it.
Pirate King: But not often.
Major General: Stop! I think I see where we are getting confused. When you said "orphan", did you mean "orphan" – a person who has lost his parents, or "often", frequently?
Pirate King: Ah! I beg pardon – I see what you mean – frequently.
Major General: Ah! you said "often", frequently.
Pirate King: No, only once.
Major General (irritated): Exactly – you said "often", frequently, only once.

Cue doom music

I think misreading intent or "tone" in internet discussions is by far the bigger problem. Graham assumed I misunderstood his tone (jocular/ironic - I didn't) & then misunderstood mine (also jocular/ironic) ... & so it goes! 

Quote
These polls are just too simplistic to enable detailed responses to be made. And whether any meaningful conclusions can be drawn from them is yet another question..

Yes, I'm sure you're right, but I think the reason Les posed the question in the first place is that for newcomers to the melodeon, it IS a pressing question.  It seems to me that with an instrument like the guitar the little finger is a "peripheral" digit - important to complete certain chord structures, but otherwise used less than the other fingers. The same thing would be true for the right hand on the melodeon. By using 4 fingers for the basses, as Owen suggests, the pinky becomes essential - the rhythmic anchor for all playing - so weakness in this finger is more problematic.

Quote
2. If you want to play oom pa only you can get away with two
3. If you want to play fancy stuff, four fingers will probably give you the greatest range

Is DTN playing unfancy, oom pa stuff?   (:)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 13, 2012, 06:47:05 AM
So to sum up (from the beginner's perspective, which I dimly recall being the starting point):
  • It depends on what kind of music you want to play
  • If you want to play oom pa only you can get away with two
  • If you want to play fancy stuff, four fingers will probably give you the greatest range
  • Adapting to four after learning two is potentially hard work
  • Comfort and dexterity will depend on how you hold the instrument, size of hands, relative size of fingers, previous medical history, whether you have chest or tummy, the weather etc
  • in the light of the above, the best choice is whatever works for you in the style you want to play
  • never give up - experiment till you find what works for you
amirite?

esattamente
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Cooper on June 13, 2012, 07:53:46 AM
It's probably superfleous, (or however you write that word) but i would add some words...and i would change the order.

So to sum up (from the beginner's perspective, which I dimly recall being the starting point):
  • The best choice is whatever works for you in the style you want to play
  • never give up - experiment till you find what works for you
  • It depends on what kind of music you want to play, but 4 fingers will allow you all styles
  • If you want to play oom pa only you can get away with two, if you dont want to play legato ever
  • If you want to play fancy stuff, four fingers will probably give you the greatest range
  • Adapting to four after learning two is potentially hard work, whereas if you start with 4 it's not that much trouble
  • Comfort and dexterity will depend on how you hold the instrument, size of hands, relative size of fingers, previous medical history, whether you have chest or tummy, the weather etc, but most people fall within the 90/95% for whom that is not an issue. If indeed you are in those other 5/10% look at the top of the list again

Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Howard Jones on June 13, 2012, 08:54:16 AM
I've voted for three fingers, on the basis that's what I habitually use, but as I've stated previously I will also use the 4th when the occasion demands.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: jb on June 13, 2012, 09:01:00 AM
BUT THAT WASN'T THE ORIGINAL QUESTION!!!!

... about lining up your four fingers with the  4 x 2 bass buttons on an 8 bass box.
...  would it put a beginner off if they had to play their very first bass line (G bass G chord) with finger 4 and finger 3 respectively?   

Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Theo on June 13, 2012, 09:07:34 AM
BUT THAT WASN'T THE ORIGINAL QUESTION!!!!

... about lining up your four fingers with the  4 x 2 bass buttons on an 8 bass box.
...  would it put a beginner off if they had to play their very first bass line (G bass G chord) with finger 4 and finger 3 respectively?   

Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.

Oh yes,  that is really the main point of using 4 fingers.  And yes it does make it hard to begin with.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: jb on June 13, 2012, 09:27:12 AM
Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.
Oh yes,  that is really the main point of using 4 fingers. 

Not in my view. The main point of using 4 fingers is that it self-evidently removes the constraint of using only 3 (or 2). To paraphrase Cooper from a couple of pages back: (i) there is nothing you can do with 3 that you can't also do with 4, and (ii) there are some things you can do with 4 that you can't do with 3.

But if the 4-finger player is going to adopt a new constraint that each finger has to remain on its designated pair of buttons then neither of these propositions is true.   

And how does this technique extend to the 12-bass or more, btw?

I use 3 and occasionally 4 (especially on 12-bass), but I don't see the point or any technical merit in confining any finger to any particular button(s), or vice versa.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 13, 2012, 09:56:49 AM
BUT THAT WASN'T THE ORIGINAL QUESTION!!!!

... about lining up your four fingers with the  4 x 2 bass buttons on an 8 bass box.
...  would it put a beginner off if they had to play their very first bass line (G bass G chord) with finger 4 and finger 3 respectively?   

Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.

Yes. Means that the hand doesn't move around. The one exception for me is playing Amin7, where I use the index finger and middle finger, just because it is more natural than using the middle and ring (due to finger lengths). And even that is only sometimes. For everything else, each finger has it's own column. Makes it much easier.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Theo on June 13, 2012, 10:07:52 AM
I don't feel constrained by assigning one finger to each pair of buttons, it feels easier to me because as Ukebert says, the hand doesn't have to move and there is always a finger available.  But it is very much a personal preference and I'm not trying to say what anyone else might prefer to do. I've recently started to play a 12 bass and of course I still have the original number of fingers  (:) so now I have to move my hand to use the extra 4 buttons, but still (in my head) I have each finger assigned to one pair of buttons, so I now have two hand positions, covering the lower 8 buttons or the upper 8 buttons respectively.  It works for me, but others may find a different approach. 
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: jb on June 13, 2012, 10:09:08 AM
Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.
Yes. Means that the hand doesn't move around.

I'd need persuading that it makes very much difference to hand movement and, even if so, that this is of any technical value.
As to the rest, see my previous reply to Theo.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Theo on June 13, 2012, 10:12:25 AM
Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.
Yes. Means that the hand doesn't move around.

I'd need persuading that it makes very much difference to hand movement and, even if so, that this is of any technical value.
As to the rest, see my previous reply to Theo.

But I don't think we are trying to persuade you, I'm certainly not.   I'm just outlining what works for me. 
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: jb on June 13, 2012, 10:16:23 AM
But I don't think we are trying to persuade you, I'm certainly not.   I'm just outlining what works for me.
I know. Poor choice of words from me. I should say that it isn't obvious to me that this technique can make very much useful difference to hand movement.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 13, 2012, 10:17:06 AM
Well, all I can suggest is that you try it and form your own conclusions.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: jb on June 13, 2012, 10:20:14 AM
Well, all I can suggest is that you try it and form your own conclusions.
I have. I did.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 13, 2012, 10:21:56 AM
Fine. It would be a funny old world if we were all alike.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Howard Jones on June 13, 2012, 10:59:16 AM
[(there are some things you can do with 4 that you can't do with 3.

Could someone please explain to me what these are?  I'm afraid it's not obvious to me.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: jb on June 13, 2012, 11:41:58 AM
[(there are some things you can do with 4 that you can't do with 3.
Could someone please explain to me what these are?  I'm afraid it's not obvious to me.
For me these would arise only occasionally, and only on 12-bass. For example in bass runs that span the whole block, such as Dmin scale on GCF box. And even here "can't" needs some qualifying. It would really be "can't, without compromising something else", e.g. rhythm or dynamics.
Mostly I play with three fingers, but without confining (in principle) any of them to any particular button(s).

[Edit] Another example: on the standard basses for 3-row there's a nice chordal cadence available comprising (e.g. on GCF) Emaj smoothing into Fmaj. Depending on what else is happening down there, 4th finger can be invaluable for this.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 13, 2012, 11:52:56 AM
If your goal isn't 'fluidity' (= more fingers the better) then it's basically 'needed' for any wide stretch crossed chords on a 12 or 18 bass.

I guess most (if not all) can manage Ukebert's Cbass+Em = CΔ chord on an 8 bass with 3 fingers, if not two? I do CΔ both ways .. 'directly' I'd use 4+1, but quite often its a bass run and finger #4 is still on the G/D bass .. then it'll be 3+1. I use this quite a lot incidentally and not for 'freaky' stuff. It turns up naturally in Leafield "Dearest Dickie", and even in the B music of "Speed the Plough".
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 13, 2012, 12:30:13 PM
Ah, see a lot of the time I use it my middle finger is on the B bass, as I like doing G/B so the B leads up to the C.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lester on June 13, 2012, 12:41:26 PM
Dearest Dickie is from the tradition of Field Town not Leafield. They renamed the town not the tradition. 
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Cooper on June 13, 2012, 02:34:57 PM
[(there are some things you can do with 4 that you can't do with 3.

Could someone please explain to me what these are?  I'm afraid it's not obvious to me.

I have tried combining bass-buttons from the knee-side with chord-buttons from the chin-side with three fingers, and got the cramps. I think i have seen others succeed though, but it doesnt work for me. You could ofcourse just use 4 fingers in the instances you want to use those combinations.

But i think for me the biggest advantage from general 4 over 3 finger usage is what Theo and Ukebert said; your hand doesnt need to move. This results in
a) a higher possible speed, and
b) a higher certainty to hit the right button at stressy times (like when you lost track during a tune and need to start improvising. "damn was my indexfinger above button x or button y,..oh the time has passed already".

When playing on a box with more than 8 bttons on your left, you lose profit b, but profit a gets bigger, as with 3 fingers you would have to make even bigger jumps.

And ofcourse, in general, if you have more options to chose from (3 options against 4 options) there is a high possiblity that you can get the best possible outcome (best fingering) when chosing from 4 options.

I do think that using 3 fingers is not halfway between 2 and 4, but a lot closer to using 4 than it is to using 2, i will admit to that.

As an example, on a violin you very often dont need your little finger. And even when you would need it,  have seen people stretching their third finger to get to that 4 position. Everyone can make that distance with their third finger, so that is not the problem. It is a lot harder to keep up to speed when going from 3rd to 4th position (and back) and it is even harder to keep that 4th position in tune (i.e. to aim it just right). I dont play violin, so i am just talking from the position of observer/listener here. Ofcourse all comparisons go awry somewhere, so this might not be very helpful.

W
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Cooper on June 13, 2012, 02:57:01 PM
Does anyone play like this, i.e. assigning each of four fingers strictly to the corresponding pair in the 4x2 block? I would be extremely surprised if so.
Oh yes,  that is really the main point of using 4 fingers. 

Not in my view. The main point of using 4 fingers is that it self-evidently removes the constraint of using only 3 (or 2). To paraphrase Cooper from a couple of pages back: (i) there is nothing you can do with 3 that you can't also do with 4, and (ii) there are some things you can do with 4 that you can't do with 3.

But if the 4-finger player is going to adopt a new constraint that each finger has to remain on its designated pair of buttons then neither of these propositions is true.   

And how does this technique extend to the 12-bass or more, btw?

I use 3 and occasionally 4 (especially on 12-bass), but I don't see the point or any technical merit in confining any finger to any particular button(s), or vice versa.

I think it depends on how rigid you are with the positions. In general i would say i use each finger fo only 2 buttons. But for instance when doing bass-walks like C-B-A-G i do change that and i dont use my middle finger for both the B and the A, but use the indexfinger for the A instead.

When talking about more basses things change more. But still i would say that the chin-basses and chin-chords will not be played by ring- and little finger, and the knee-basses and chords will not be played by middle- and indexfinger.

W
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Cooper on June 13, 2012, 03:05:22 PM
BTW, we are still talking about what we should teach beginners right?

Because i am not advocating that people playing with 2 fingers should change that when they are doing fine without those 2 other fingers. Changing the way you hold your instrument to add those 2 fingers to the mix will be a lot more work when you already have a way of playing. And if you have a good view of what you might win with the extra 2 fingers, the balance of "invested time vs joy won" might be not that favorable. But for beginners the invested time will be a lot less.

W
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: jb on June 13, 2012, 03:06:49 PM
But i think for me the biggest advantage from general 4 over 3 finger usage is what Theo and Ukebert said; your hand doesnt need to move.

Well I said I would be extremely surprised. And so I am.
This technique of playing with four fingers, in a fixed position (or two such positions for 12-bass) whereby each finger is assigned to a specific pair of buttons, seems to me to be signficantly more limiting than playing 'freestyle' with only three fingers, and maybe even two.
For me, hand movement is a non-issue. I don't find that my hand moves excessively in any way which reduces either control or accuracy. Perhaps this is something to do with coming from a PA/stradella background.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Owen Woods on June 13, 2012, 03:19:41 PM
In what way is it more limiting?
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Cooper on June 13, 2012, 03:21:09 PM
stuff

How do you use your fingers in a simple hoompapa on the push from G to D? I was just thinking of something difficult with 3 fingers. And i think this example is already rather difficult. If you use only 3 fingers, you cannot (unless i miss something) make both the transition between you g-chord, and the subsequent D-bass fluent/legato/gapless, as well as the transition D-bass-d-chord?

W
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 13, 2012, 04:10:07 PM
Well, last night I quickly ran through my extensive cache of favourite youtube melodeon clips to see what the players (many of them melnetters,) were doing. The only "fully 4 fingered player" I could find was Ukebert (I have to admit, I'm not entirely sure about Clive, as he tends to favour an atmospheric, soft-focus filter for a lot of his recordings  ;)).  The vast majority of accomplished players seem to use 3 fingers. I notice some occasionally throwing in a 4th finger, for example:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkpA45JtPEs

One of the rare 2 fingered (even 1 fingered at times!) players seems to be DTN:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJR1CNpgjdc&feature=related

If that's "limited" bass playing, I'll take it!  (:)

My conclusion is that although 4 fingers may make sense theoretically, in practice most players don't seem to find it the best way to approach the instrument. My guess is that this is because (for most people) the advantages it offers - less finger movement - are outweighed by the disadvantages - a more awkward wrist position & less dynamic control of the bass buttons.  For myself, I'm going to make the effort to transition to 3 fingers (DTN notwithstanding!).

Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Anahata on June 13, 2012, 04:30:11 PM
Well, last night I quickly ran through my extensive cache of favourite youtube melodeon clips to see what the players (many of them melnetters,) were doing. The only "fully 4 fingered player" I could find was Ukebert

...who has big hands. I think this does makes a difference, even if it is possible to train yourself to use a different hand position so the pinky will reach more/any buttons.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Andy Simpson on June 13, 2012, 04:32:00 PM
Use as few fingers as you like but don't pretend that it's somehow better than not being able to use all of them...
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Pierre B on June 13, 2012, 04:46:40 PM
The principle "be confortable" is not bad.
In the past, I've been teached classical guitar. Later, I tried the keyboard with a method. In all cases, using all fingers is recommanded. Even if the little finger is shorter, it is still usefull.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lester on June 13, 2012, 04:55:36 PM
Use as few fingers as you like but don't pretend that it's somehow better than not being able to use all of them...

Use as few fingers as you like but don't pretend that it's somehow better worse than not being able to use all of them...
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 13, 2012, 05:03:19 PM
Quote
...who has big hands.

Everybody's hands look big playing a Preciosa!  ;)

I think playing the guitar, or the piano, 4 fingers are essential. It's quite clear that it's not essential with the melodeon, but a choice, with (it seems to me) associated pluses & minuses.

I would be interested to see more examples posted of fully 4 fingers melodeon playing, because I don't seem to have come across them.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Theo on June 13, 2012, 05:20:45 PM

I would be interested to see more examples posted of fully 4 fingers melodeon playing, because I don't seem to have come across them.

here are two


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rSx_5WwE8kA (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rSx_5WwE8kA)
http://www.myspace.com/horizontalsunday/videos/ard-haven/108277734http://
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Andy Simpson on June 13, 2012, 05:33:33 PM
Use as few fingers as you like but don't pretend that it's somehow better worse than not being able to use all of them...

Sorry, it is worse. If you can only use 2 or 3 then you can't do everything that you can with 4.

Much like all the arguments about folk musicians being able to understand music theory or "read the dots", not being able to use all 4 fingers on the bass buttons is clearly not a bar to making nice music or enjoying yourself but learning to do it is an additional skill that can only take you further and give you more tools at your disposal. The convoluted excuses, bizarre leaps of logic and plain old stubbornness that some people demonstrate rather than just admitting that they found it too difficult or simply can't be bothered is disheartening but does not to surprise me.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: michik on June 13, 2012, 05:43:37 PM
4-finger bass:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yyPjQmgFv4Q
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Lester on June 13, 2012, 05:45:28 PM
Use as few fingers as you like but don't pretend that it's somehow better worse than not being able to use all of them...

Sorry, it is worse. If you can only use 2 or 3 then you can't do everything that you can with 4

But there are a lot of us that can do everything we want to do with only two. Just because something can be done it does not mean that it needs to be done.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: AirTime on June 13, 2012, 05:52:17 PM
Quote
The convoluted excuses, bizarre leaps of logic and plain old stubbornness that some people demonstrate rather than just admitting that they found it too difficult or simply can't be bothered is disheartening but does not to surprise me.

Hmm ... I'm not sure what the leaps of logic or stubbornness have been. As far as I can see "too difficult" IS an entirely reasonable argument!

I can see the potential advantages of 4 fingered basses, but the fact that so many very accomplished players don't play that way suggests that it's not necessary - more of a choice.

BTW: thanks for the 4-fingered links (although the Andy Cutting one is an odd choice as it's almost impossible to see what he's doing!)
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Andy Simpson on June 13, 2012, 05:54:53 PM
Having 2 fingers you can use may be adequate but having 2 more is undeniably better.

In my instrument making and repairing days there were many times when I wished I had a third hand to help with certain jobs. I had to manage with two but if I had a third one then I damn well wouldn't have just left it hanging there doing nothing.

4 fingers, not necessary but extremely useful and a wasted opportunity if you don't pursue it...
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Theo on June 13, 2012, 07:55:56 PM
I'll say this once more.

Please only contribute to this topic if you have something new to add.

Please keep it positive

Be respectful of the views of others, especially those you disagree with.

If in doubt say nowt!



Edited to add:

Any posts that are not explicitly as above will be removed. No argument.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: mory on June 13, 2012, 08:18:50 PM
Really impressed Theo the world suddenly seems a nicer place, (may even consider a  revisit to  my own doomed thread)

On topic I was playing my 4 bass button Baldoni last night and noticed I was using 3 as usual but also switching to 4 quite regularly both sets of buttons have the same push notes so only 2 variations on the pull and I don't um pa all the time but definitely some of the time. I hadn't really taken a lot of notice before but this thread did make me conscious of my actions. AtB mory
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Howard Jones on June 13, 2012, 09:16:46 PM
stuff

How do you use your fingers in a simple hoompapa on the push from G to D?

I would probably use G3g2 D2d1.  Yes, there's a gap between playing g chord and D bass with the same finger, but it's no more than the gap I would normally leave between the oom and the pah, and which  a four-finger player would also put in.

Quote
If you use only 3 fingers, you cannot (unless i miss something) make both the transition between you g-chord, and the subsequent D-bass fluent/legato/gapless, as well as the transition D-bass-d-chord?

If I wished to go from g chord to D bass without any gap I'd simply roll the finger off one button and onto the other. 

At risk of upsetting Theo by repeating myself, I think that the same musical results can be achieved using either 3 or 4 fingers, and it's simply a matter of personal preference which you use - I really don't think it's important which method you learn.  There may be situations where a 3-finger player may find it helpful to use the fourth finger but by the time they've reached that stage of their playing they should have no problem briniging it in.  The issue is whether not learning to play with all 4 fingers from the start will constrain your playing in the future, and I don't think that is the case.
Title: Re: Left hand - four fingers on four buttons - your views please
Post by: Theo on June 14, 2012, 09:05:50 AM
Just removed several posts because my previous post seems to have made no difference.   All were either off topic, or reworking old points.
Time to end it now.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal