Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Graham Spencer on June 07, 2012, 01:34:04 PM

Title: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 07, 2012, 01:34:04 PM
 A propos of nothing in particular, I was trawling round YouTube looking at (sometimes very!) assorted morris videos, and I was somewhat taken aback to see a side - to spare their blushes, I will reveal neither the name, gender nor nationality of said side - whose musician spent the entire dance with his/her back to the dancers, looking at the floor.  Needless to say, s/he was a little surprised when the dancers finished and s/he didn't!  How on earth can anyone play for any kind of dancing without watching the dancers - or at least giving them a glance from time to time?  Mind, you, I fear that musician is not alone........

Incidentally, I will say that the side in question is quite long-established, so someone ought to know better.

Graham
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Stiamh on June 07, 2012, 02:59:57 PM
Well, sometimes people just start dancing when you're just playing for yourself, doing a sound check, or running through a piece before a gig has started, or at a session or party. Was this one of those occasions?

Usually it's a nice surprise when you look up to find a dance is happening - but then you have to keep on playing, sometimes for longer than you wanted to!
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 07, 2012, 04:08:15 PM
Well, sometimes people just start dancing when you're just playing for yourself, doing a sound check, or running through a piece before a gig has started, or at a session or party. Was this one of those occasions?


No - it was a public show on a formal dance-out in full kit with a decent-sized audience; which was precisely why I was so taken aback to see it.
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on June 07, 2012, 08:20:14 PM
Very occasionally I turn my back on our side when a certain man is dncing because I can't play and giggle at the same time. This never occurs when I play melodeon though - does melodeon face have practical benefits?
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 07, 2012, 08:26:26 PM
Very occasionally I turn my back on our side when a certain man is dncing because I can't play and giggle at the same time.
Been there, done that!  ;D

Graham
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: pikey on June 08, 2012, 12:21:32 PM
I won't mention Gareth's name...... ;D

Maybe the musician just couldn't stand watching the dancers??  Mind you, they could have closed their eyes instead - no-one would have noticed!!
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Ollie on June 08, 2012, 01:37:08 PM
I know that quite a few of the 'old guard' play with their eyes closed.... can't understand it.
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Tom on June 08, 2012, 03:01:18 PM
I know that quite a few of the 'old guard' play with their eyes closed.... can't understand it.

Praying.
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: ladydetemps on June 08, 2012, 03:04:13 PM
I know that quite a few of the 'old guard' play with their eyes closed.... can't understand it.
If you close your eyes you can't see them so they aren't there....  :P
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: pikey on June 08, 2012, 03:12:44 PM
Dreaming of playing in a band with Andy Cutting....
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Keithypete. on June 08, 2012, 07:49:32 PM
 If it's already on you-tube it's already in the public domain, surely it's fair game to tell?
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 08, 2012, 09:13:07 PM
You may think that.....I couldn't possibly comment  ;)
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: IanD on June 09, 2012, 12:04:42 PM
Sometimes I've wished that I hadn't been watching...

-- but mostly I watch like a hawk -- after all, who else will take the piss out of Smiffs when they cock it up in public?
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 09, 2012, 10:50:59 PM
Yes, our NW side had a dancer nicknamed "the Pregnant Duck" by the band.  To keep in tempo we all had to take great care not to watch him or the bellows went into the rythm of the guffaws.  Doesn't every side have one - with the possible exception of the invitation only sides and some of them make me laugh 'cause their so up themselves! Present company excepted, I'm sure...

Rob.
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: pikey on June 10, 2012, 07:50:05 AM
a good musician always watches the dancers, whether it's morris, sword, playford, english country, american square, etc etc.

You need to check that the dancers are ok with the tempo tha you selected, and, if required, subtly change it.

For barn dances, without watching you can't tell if the dancers are tired/bored//entranced/.   I hate the '5 times through' EFDSS embarassment - you should play through as many times as the dancers like . Hence the need to watch both their feet and their faces.  we once did 'Buttered Peas' for 40 minutes, because the dancers were lapping it up - and when we finished it, they called for an encore!!
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 10, 2012, 08:08:38 AM
a good musician always watches the dancers, whether it's morris, sword, playford, english country, american square, etc etc.

You need to check that the dancers are ok with the tempo tha you selected, and, if required, subtly change it.

For barn dances, without watching you can't tell if the dancers are tired/bored//entranced/.   I hate the '5 times through' EFDSS embarassment - you should play through as many times as the dancers like . Hence the need to watch both their feet and their faces.  we once did 'Buttered Peas' for 40 minutes, because the dancers were lapping it up - and when we finished it, they called for an encore!!

My feelings exactly.
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: ACE on June 10, 2012, 09:05:52 AM
a good musician always watches the dancers, whether it's morris, sword, playford, english country, american square, etc etc.

You need to check that the dancers are ok with the tempo tha you selected, and, if required, subtly change it.

For barn dances, without watching you can't tell if the dancers are tired/bored//entranced/.   I hate the '5 times through' EFDSS embarassment - you should play through as many times as the dancers like . Hence the need to watch both their feet and their faces.  we once did 'Buttered Peas' for 40 minutes, because the dancers were lapping it up - and when we finished it, they called for an encore!!

I would have thought that is the callers job. But watching the dancers is part of being the lead musician and being a dancer themselves goes a long way to making sure the dance is progressing properly, an extra A might be needed to get inexperienced dancers through to the end of the set, tempo might need to be adjusted, a lift inserted into the tune if they are flagging or a complete civilised stop if the caller needs an early restart due to dancers misunderstanding the call.
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 10, 2012, 09:14:02 AM
a good musician always watches the dancers, whether it's morris, sword, playford, english country, american square, etc etc.

You need to check that the dancers are ok with the tempo tha you selected, and, if required, subtly change it.

I would amend this to say that a good musician watches a dancer. Dancers tend to dance at slightly different tempos: some are spot on the beat; some are slightly before it; others slightly behind it. I find that if I transfer my attention between dancers then the tempo changes slightly, so I choose one good dancer (often, but not always, the person dancing in the number 1 position) and follow that person throughout. My only exceptions to that are in corner dances, when I transfer my attention to the better of the two dancers for each corner, and double jigs, where I adjust the tempo to the needs of each dancer.

Unfortunately, we have other musicians who take little or no notice of the dancers or of the musicians with whom they are playing. Jenny and I can often be seen bobbing up and down vigorously or heard muttering 'steady!' when these musicians go racing ahead in a word of their own.  ::)
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Anahata on June 10, 2012, 11:21:03 AM
an extra A might be needed to get inexperienced dancers through to the end of the set

Yes, that's one VERY good reason why you should be watching the dancers.

I would amend this to say that a good musician watches a dancer.

Wasn't it Scan Tester who said something like "I look for the best dancers in the room and play for them"
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 10, 2012, 11:26:04 AM

You need to check that the dancers are ok with the tempo tha you selected, and, if required, subtly change it.


I was at a club evening in the week, in this case with recorded music. During the walkthrough/introduction, the experienced  caller announced "We need to go through that bit again, because the music wasn't playing at the speed that you were dancing".
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on June 10, 2012, 12:17:49 PM
You can't shout at CDs as you can at real musicians!  :Ph
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: strad on June 10, 2012, 01:21:40 PM
You can shout at cd's but they don't respond!

I find, when playing for dancers I keep my eyes open and watch what they're doing. But in a session I frequently close my eyes, especially if I'm not too sure of playing via buttons instead of strings. Perhaps by cutting out the visuals I'm reverting to single tasking instead of multitasking!

Nigel
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: pikey on June 10, 2012, 02:55:27 PM
is that the melodeon players equivalent of putting your fingers in your ears, Carthyesque style?
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: pikey on June 10, 2012, 02:58:44 PM
a good musician always watches the dancers, whether it's morris, sword, playford, english country, american square, etc etc.

You need to check that the dancers are ok with the tempo tha you selected, and, if required, subtly change it.

For barn dances, without watching you can't tell if the dancers are tired/bored//entranced/.   I hate the '5 times through' EFDSS embarassment - you should play through as many times as the dancers like . Hence the need to watch both their feet and their faces.  we once did 'Buttered Peas' for 40 minutes, because the dancers were lapping it up - and when we finished it, they called for an encore!!

you're right, of course - I was the caller and the second melodeon player!

I would have thought that is the callers job. But watching the dancers is part of being the lead musician and being a dancer themselves goes a long way to making sure the dance is progressing properly, an extra A might be needed to get inexperienced dancers through to the end of the set, tempo might need to be adjusted, a lift inserted into the tune if they are flagging or a complete civilised stop if the caller needs an early restart due to dancers misunderstanding the call.
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: pikey on June 10, 2012, 03:05:07 PM
a good musician always watches the dancers, whether it's morris, sword, playford, english country, american square, etc etc.

You need to check that the dancers are ok with the tempo tha you selected, and, if required, subtly change it.


the problem with watching the best dancer is that you are looking at the one who can cope with tempos that arent quite right, and the one that will be ale to keep dancing when everyone else is struggling! for morris, i focus on number 1 - he is leading the dance. For barn dances, I focus on one of the middle ability dancers, but keep an eye on every set. The aim is to get as may sets comfy as possible, noting that there is nearly always one that will strugle a bit, no matter what you do!

Btw - that's why callers should also be capable musicians, and why they should play with the band. It's also why the band lead should be a capable dancer! Qv Bob Cann.   

I would amend this to say that a good musician watches a dancer. Dancers tend to dance at slightly different tempos: some are spot on the beat; some are slightly before it; others slightly behind it. I find that if I transfer my attention between dancers then the tempo changes slightly, so I choose one good dancer (often, but not always, the person dancing in the number 1 position) and follow that person throughout. My only exceptions to that are in corner dances, when I transfer my attention to the better of the two dancers for each corner, and double jigs, where I adjust the tempo to the needs of each dancer.

Unfortunately, we have other musicians who take little or no notice of the dancers or of the musicians with whom they are playing. Jenny and I can often be seen bobbing up and down vigorously or heard muttering 'steady!' when these musicians go racing ahead in a word of their own.  ::)
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: IanD on June 10, 2012, 03:10:56 PM
a good musician always watches the dancers, whether it's morris, sword, playford, english country, american square, etc etc.

You need to check that the dancers are ok with the tempo tha you selected, and, if required, subtly change it.

I would amend this to say that a good musician watches a dancer. Dancers tend to dance at slightly different tempos: some are spot on the beat; some are slightly before it; others slightly behind it. I find that if I transfer my attention between dancers then the tempo changes slightly, so I choose one good dancer (often, but not always, the person dancing in the number 1 position) and follow that person throughout. My only exceptions to that are in corner dances, when I transfer my attention to the better of the two dancers for each corner, and double jigs, where I adjust the tempo to the needs of each dancer.

Unfortunately, we have other musicians who take little or no notice of the dancers or of the musicians with whom they are playing. Jenny and I can often be seen bobbing up and down vigorously or heard muttering 'steady!' when these musicians go racing ahead in a word of their own.  ::)
I tend to watch the set as a whole and play what seems right for the set overall. If you have a good dancer ("the best" one?) who is more energetic (or less tired) than the rest and follow them then the others in the set can't keep up (usually because the music is too slow for them) and the dance as a whole looks less good. It's better overall to play what works bet for everyone -- the "best" dancer may think the music is a bit too fast, the "worst" one the opposite, but on the whole the result will look better than playing to one extreme.

Of course you should always play to encourage the dancers to put as much into the dance as possible...
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Ollie on June 10, 2012, 03:33:11 PM
is that the melodeon players equivalent of putting your fingers in your ears, Carthyesque style?

But it's not finger-in-the-ear... you actually form a cup with your hand around your ear, and it's a very effective way of hearing yourself.
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 10, 2012, 03:42:23 PM
Perhaps I should have defined what I mean by a 'good' dancer and I should have made it explicit that I was referring to Morris only. The dancer I choose to follow is not necessarily the fittest dancer or the best technically, but an experienced dancer who understands the tempo at which the dance should be performed and can be performed by the less experienced dancers in the set. While this is usually number 1, it isn't always! We have somebody in our side who likes to dance at number 1 who is always slightly ahead of the beat. If I followed him, the music would speed up as the dance progressed, so I choose another experienced dancer who dances on the beat and I follow that person.

Of course, one has to be aware of the weaker dancers in the set, but it would be folly to set the tempo to suit the weakest dancer.

Another relevant factor is the tradition. For instance, I always pitch the tempo for Ascot-under-Wychwood on the slow side, otherwise some of the dancers would get hopelessly out of time when performing the cross-backs.
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 10, 2012, 04:14:02 PM
is that the melodeon players equivalent of putting your fingers in your ears, Carthyesque style?

But it's not finger-in-the-ear... you actually form a cup with your hand around your ear, and it's a very effective way of hearing yourself.

Yes, it always amuses me that the great unwashed poke fun at folk singers for doing that, but nobody ever mentions it when opera singers, jazz singers, and even pop and rock singers do it - usually when recording. It is indeed an extraordinarily effective way of blocking out a good deal of ambient noise and actually hearing what you're singing.

Graham
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 10, 2012, 04:18:02 PM
Yes, but you really need the knitted jumper to get the full effect. And not just any old beard will do...
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 10, 2012, 04:46:52 PM
Yes, but you really need the knitted jumper to get the full effect. And not just any old beard will do...

Just checking - it IS 2012, isn't it? ;D ??? :|glug
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 10, 2012, 05:07:17 PM
Yes, but you really need the knitted jumper to get the full effect. And not just any old beard will do...

Just checking - it IS 2012, isn't it? ;D ??? :|glug

Ssshhh - there's a lot of people don't know that. That bloke who organises the Ship Band, apparently, an MP or two, ....
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 10, 2012, 05:10:27 PM
Yes, but you really need the knitted jumper to get the full effect. And not just any old beard will do...

Just checking - it IS 2012, isn't it? ;D ??? :|glug

Ssshhh - there's a lot of people don't know that. That bloke who organises the Ship Band, apparently, an MP or two, ....

 ;D
Title: Re: Keeping your eye on the job....
Post by: Marje on June 10, 2012, 05:36:16 PM
is that the melodeon players equivalent of putting your fingers in your ears, Carthyesque style?

But it's not finger-in-the-ear... you actually form a cup with your hand around your ear, and it's a very effective way of hearing yourself.

Yes, it always amuses me that the great unwashed poke fun at folk singers for doing that, but nobody ever mentions it when opera singers, jazz singers, and even pop and rock singers do it - usually when recording. It is indeed an extraordinarily effective way of blocking out a good deal of ambient noise and actually hearing what you're singing.

Graham

It is, but if you're performing live, it has the unfortunate effect of making your singing less audible (and your mouth less visible) to anyone sitting towards the side on which the elbow is raised - this can apply to people who are attempting to sing or play along with you, or to audience members.

It is (perhaps fortunately) impossible to do when playing melodeon. I do admit to the trick of closing eyes when learning a tune that someone else is playing or singing, but I generally open them when I'm ready to start joining in. At a session, I think I use visual clues to help me keep in time with whoever's leading the tune. Someone once asked me if the reason I was attentively watching a fiddler playing was to follow the melody, but it was only to keep the rhythm.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal