Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Andy on June 12, 2012, 11:37:32 PM
-
Hi
Have a B/C accordion but thinking of getting a C#/D (Think I am aware of most of the the B/C v C#/D arguments - infact I have them with myself all the time)
But my question relates to buttons.
I can see that, particularly for playing in D on a C#/D box, the additional low notes on a 23 button box (compared to 21) could be useful but insisting on 23 buttons (which I presume will have fourth button start) cuts down choice, limits choice to more expensive models and (less of a concern) will generally up the size and weight a bit.
So how important do you rate the extra notes? - handy or essential?
If you have a 21 button C#/D how often do you wish you had the extra notes?
Might be slightly answering my own question here but any tunes that span a range which makes it possible to play in a higher or lower octave I prefer to play in the lower octave (May not be totally authentic but much as I love the accordion and harmonica I have not yet learned to love the sound of the really high high reeds)
Any thoughts welcome.
-
If you play Irish music then low G is very useful, essential almost. I hate being without one.
On a 21-button C#/D box, if you want low G, you have a few options.
- Put low D/G on the bottom button of the C# row. Then you lose low Bb. Which may not be a problem for you but I wouldn't want to be without it.
- Choose a 4th button start. You lose top c# on the D row, but you have this note (on the push) on the C# row. I chose this layout on a Gaillard Turquoise and regretted it. You need the pull c# for gracing top B - and playing tunes in B/C fingering. The box feels scalped without it!
- Put the low G on the press on the bottom button (B/G). Awkward, I would think (never tried it).
- Have the 21 buttons arranged 10-11, so that your D row has 11 buttons. This is the only acceptable solution for me, makers won't want to make one for you. After asking lots of them, the only one who was game was Peter Hyde. But... recently the ingenious Mike Rowbotham made me a Black Dot with 22 buttons, squeezing an extra button onto the bottom of the D row and and extending the reedblocks. Brilliant solution - you might consider it too.
Cheers!
Edited to answer your question simply: I rate 23 buttons (or 11 buttons on the D row) as very important.
-
I know the OP was referring to a B/C box and Steve also discusses the C#/D box, but 23 buttons on a two-row quad-tuned box D/G, C/F, G/C, etc. is also worth a mention.
Many Saltarelle boxes have 23 buttons with a 4th button start when tuned D/G. This is potentially useful because it allows you to have both low notes and chin-end accidentals without losing the very highest notes at the knee end (which you would normally find on a 21 button, 3rd button start box). I know that some people find those very highest notes useful, so 23 buttons are a good option for them.
Personally, I hardly have any use for the highest notes on a D/G box, so 21 buttons with a 4th button start with low notes and accidentals at the chin end is a very good option for me. I would imagine that one could argue a similar case for a C/F box.
However, a G/C box is a different animal with most of the playing being done in the upper, knee-end octave. Losing the highest notes would therefore be quite serious. So as far as I know, most 21-button G/C boxes are 3rd button start, and as the G/C box is so low-pitched anyway, there is little advantage in having a 4th button start as the chin end is quite growly already. A 23 button G/C box with normal 3rd button start would give you extra notes at the knee end which I suppose could be useful for some players, but I don't really play the G/C box enough to form an advanced opinion. I find my 21 button 3rd button start G/C box perfectly adequate for my needs.
-
Personally, I hardly have any use for the highest notes on a D/G box, so 21 buttons with a 4th button start with low notes and accidentals at the chin end is a very good option for me. I would imagine that one could argue a similar case for a C/F box.
Absolutely. My D/G is 4th button start with low notes (though admittedly it's a 21+4, so there's no question of missing accidentals) and my C/F is 3rd button start with accidentals, and I often begin happily playing a tune on the C/F that I normally do on the D/G, only to discover (usually too late!) that the low note I instinctively reach for is an extremely unwelcome accidental an octave up! Like you, I do use the dogs-and-dolphins end from time to time, but not very often.
Graham
-
Whatever system and tuning you use, I'm increasingly of the opinion that 23 buttons is the perfect number for a diatonic box.
-
So how important do you rate the extra notes? - handy or essential? If you have a 21 button C#/D how often do you wish you had the extra notes?
To add to my earlier post and address the above points: on a standard 21-button C#/D, for Irish music, the only really important note missing is low G (G below middle C). How often would I miss it? Often. In most sessions at least one or two tunes will go by where you need this note, especially if you are playing with fiddlers. And I'd be less willing to learn tunes that use that note, because fudges are a good deal more awkward on the box than on, say, flute.
The button-mate of that low G is low D. This is a nice note to have, for chords and other effects, but doesn't occur in tunes. (Except in one case that I know of - Joe Cooley's Em setting of Sean Ryan's jig, The Castle - and there it's not essential, but a nice tip of the hat to Joe C for those in the know.)
The extra notes you get on the outer row are low C#/F# (press/draw). I wouldn't miss these at all. Their only real use (unless you're in a C# session!) is to grace their counterparts on the inner row (with a fake slide). Unless you make a habit of this possibility, they really are superfluous. Strengthening the case for a 10/11 21-button layout.
You mention playing in the lower octave... if you mean playing tunes, or sections of tunes, an octave lower than standard, as good fiddlers often do to add depth to an ensemble performance, then your ability to do this on a C#/D box, even with an 11-button D row, is limited. For one thing you are stymied by the lack of a low E. The other thing is that fluency in that low octave, with B and G being shifted to buttons nearer the knee than A and F#, requires a good deal of practice. (If you had low E, on a 25-button box for example, the brain-fry factor would only increase.) :|glug
-
Hi Steve and all, I have low E bottom button on the outside row and high E top button outside row on the draw on 23 button C#D (my brain was fried years ago) All the Best mory
-
I think 23 buttons is much preferable to 21 whatever the system and cannot see any possible advantage exept perhaps a little extra cost and a miniscule increase in weight. Can't understand why Hobgobs posher ? scarlatti with italian reeds is 21 button for DG and 23 for BC it could even be more economical with such mass produced boxes to just tool up for 23 buttons.
Are there any real advantages in having 'only 21. rather tahn 23
george
-
It seems to me that that there is somewhat limited assumption that extended range = more low notes. The 34 button Hohner Xtreme, in common with the new Anecleto and firmly established Gabannelli models has the extra notes in the upper octave. This gives significant advatages in playing in thirds, sixths and octaves.
-
All the layouts for big 33 button G/C/Acc. layouts like Heim and Le Tron are 3rd button start with the extra notes at the top and, IIRC, 30 button versions lose the lowest notes rather than the highest.
But I don't think that anyone would dispute that being able to go down to low G when playing material from the British Isles has so many advantages and it makes perfect sense to go lower on B/C, C#D and D/G boxes.
My own approach to a 23 button box is a little unconventional, I'm using it to get a full range of accidentals over 2 octaves.
-
Quite! All I was saying is that 2 extra notes per row, be they at the bottom or top (to choice of player & taking into acocunt the tuning of a particular box) must be better than not having them! For me personally I would go for extra low notes on both DG & BC i.e 4th button 'do'. Its a pity the major UK melodeo sellers ( and the smaller ones as well) don't get together & negotiate 23 button (4th button Do) with the maajor manufacturers as the standard issue DG box for the uk market
george
-
But I don't think that anyone would dispute that being able to go down to low G when playing material from the British Isles has so many advantages and it makes perfect sense to go lower on B/C, C#D and D/G boxes.
In fact B/C boxes have low G on a 21-button layout.
To my mind, it would be more logical for 23-button B/C boxes to keep the 3rd button start and get an extra button at the top, giving them high d, but that isn't what happens.
-
I agree with Steve. High D on the B/C would be a good idea. I miss it in quite a few tunes on my 21 button.
-
You could always tune up the top C# on the B row but I guess loosing the C# might be more important.On the C#D its the Eb you loose to get the top E and on the low E its the F# (on 23) you loose but you have the inner row F# still. these guys who have turned round the rows on 19 button Paolos and Baldonis DC# to C#D always seem to extend their D row into the C# row so the loses aren't fatal. AtB mory
-
my 23 button BC box has the high D on the C row as that ( the C row) has 12 buttons and the B row 11 which works very well. I don't know why BC boxes dont all haave the long row on the inside. (perhps its because mine also has another 11 button row betweeen the C row and the grille!)
george ;)
-
Does anyone know how the folks who have converted the O'Byrne-Dewitt 19 button D/C# Paolo's to C#/D are dealing with 9 buttons in the "D" row? I got to play one once, but not long enough to figure that out. it sure was light, tight and mighty!
-
The bottom button on the outside D row stays put You then move the 2nd button note out side row to the first button inside following this up for the rest of moving the D row across, you then scrap the origanal first button note G# of the C# row and move the second button notes to the first on the outside row and follow this up . you are then left with an empty top button outside row, your choice so you get on the push
a d f#a d f#a d f#
f#c#f g#c#f g#c#f ?
I think that's right, that's what I was thinking of doing on mine and had heard of others, but I decided it would be a shame not to give it more of a go as is, I'd be equally interested to hear what others may have done though. All the Best mory
-
thanks, mory
-
Thanks for all the informative and useful responses.