Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: risto on November 18, 2007, 09:46:17 PM
-
I would be interested to hear what kinds of workouts the advanced melodeon players do to improve their technical skills. What did your teacher tell you to do?
-
I would be interested to hear what kinds of workouts the advanced melodeon players do to improve their technical skills. What did your teacher tell you to do?
One thing I was told many years ago was to play scales... sounds easy? Try making the scale go over two full octaves (no cheating and splitting it into 2 separate octaves), on the same row, up and down continuously, at speed. You'd be surprised how many people will struggle with the top octave, yet a decent mastery is quite important for being able to play a tune in the upper register easily.
Cheers,
Clive
-
One thing I was told many years ago was to play scales
Agreed. And:
- scales in octaves
- scales played with one finger
- scales played across the rows
- scale in the bass buttons
-
Very good points, thanks. Playing two octaves back and forth really isn't so easy as one might expect.
Slowing down tunes is a very good trick to hear what ppl are doing. For instance, when I recently transcribed the Silver Spire from Shannon's playing I now really paid attention to how lightning fast is her triplet. Instead of the normal three notes with equal note lengths, her triplet consists of two consecutive short notes after which comes a longer note. You can notate it with 1/16 + 1/16 + 1/8 notes in a midi file and make it sound almost the same but in reality her two fast notes are much faster.
I know she started as very young so it is impossible to get anywhere near to her standard starting now at old age, but any ideas what kinds of (muscle) practising methods are used for the triplet? Naturally it is repeat after repeat but I'm trying to figure out what to repeat:-) By repetition wrong things will get stuck in your brains as easily as the right things, or perhaps even easier. I'm using two fingers for the triplet (and always play with four fingers) which seems a must to me at this point. This is because with a triplet played with three fingers you easily get stuck in an impossible fingering situation for the notes coming after the triplet.
My question above is mess but I hope you can figure out what I'm actually asking:-)
Theo, what is the purpose of the one finger scale practise?
EDIT: So I guess I'm actually asking if there are any certaing drills to get the muscles work to play the triplets....
-
Theo, what is the purpose of the one finger scale practise?
Its a first step to playing in octaves. This is something I'm working on, but I've not got very far. To play in octaves I use my index finger finger for the low note, little finger for the high one, so the first finger goes up the scale at the same time as the little finger. The added complication is that the fingers do not move at the same time! so for a G scale:
Note Finger Button Finger Button Push/draw
G 1 3 4 6 Push
A 1 3 4 7 Draw
B 1 4 4 7 Push
C 1 4 4 8 Draw
D 1 5 4 8 Push
E 1 5 4 9 Draw
F# 1 6 4 10 Draw
G 1 6 4 9 Push
Ties your brain in knots to start with ;D
-
Ties your brain in knots to start with ;D
Heh, yes indeed:-) So did I get this right, you are 'climbing' the scale up with the index and pinky with the other finger changing button while the other is held down?
-
Exactly!
-
Exactly!
Ok! This is a good parctise to learn the keyboard as well. It makes quite clear how the 2-4-6-7 notes shift away from the 1-3-5 pattern (from how they are layed out in the middle part of the KB )when you go upwards (or downwards) .
-
I agree with "scales and octaves". There's another thing that I like, that "triangles"; because they develop fingering skills and you often use them in tunes. By that, I mean play GABG, then ABCA, then BCDB, etc. up the scale and then back down. Then, GBAG, ACBA, etc. You'll find lots of variations and all are useful. Play them up and down the scale, and try to work up speed and fluency. Also, I like to play "missing notes" in the D-G area -- i.e. DFg, DEg, gED, gFD, etc. (on the 5-6 button, I mean) -- this is another place where you'll run into patterns in ordinary use that can be tricky if you don't have fluency with them.
Charlie Pilzer says that these tunes are mostly scales and arpeggios anyway. True, but it's the exceptions that often catch me out!
BH, NC USA
-
... when I recently transcribed the Silver Spire from Shannon's playing I now really paid attention to how lightning fast is her triplet. Instead of the normal three notes with equal note lengths, her triplet consists of two consecutive short notes after which comes a longer note. You can notate it with 1/16 + 1/16 + 1/8 notes in a midi file and make it sound almost the same but in reality her two fast notes are much faster....
So I guess I'm actually asking if there are any certain drills to get the muscles work to play the triplets....
Ah, the famous Sharon Shannon "raspberry"... Much as I admire her mastery of the keyboard in general, and her execution of this device in particular, I've no desire to emulate it (the raspberry, that is). To me, it's definitely a young dude(ss) thing - all the young hotshots are doing it and I reckon that if I ever mastered it (not sure I could) it would be the equivalent of an octogenarian sporting a platinum wig and a miniskirt :)
I prefer my one-note "trebles" to stay closer to the true 1/16th + 1/16th + 1/8th rhythm you described - using 3-2-1, I can get these very fast, even if I haven't found a way to get that farting quality, and am quite happy with them. The only situation where I've found 3-2-1 doesn't work is when you approach the treble from below and then have to follow with another note below. In that case I use fingers 1 & 2 e.g. Be e/e/e B could be fingered 13 2/1/2 1.
As for drills, it seems to me that to really get a raspberry you need to hit the buttons very fast and very hard. A possible exercise would be drumming your fingers on the tabletop until you can really get the required rhythm.
Tongue in cheek, since you're a four-finger devotee, I'd also suggest you practise them using fingers 3&4. Nice demonstration of why many Irish players recommend either eschewing, or not relying heavily on, the little finger. ;)
Cheers
Steve
-
I prefer my one-note "trebles" to stay closer to the true 1/16th + 1/16th + 1/8th rhythm]
You know what, I believe that if you practise enough the "true" rhythm on the melodeon, it will by itself gradually go towards the raspberry sound. I had this happen when practising triplets on the mandolin.
Tongue in cheek, since you're a four-finger devotee, I'd also suggest you practise them using fingers 3&4. Nice demonstration of why many Irish players recommend either eschewing, or not relying heavily on, the little finger
I'm in the lucky position that I have practised classical guitar drills for years and therefore find it very easy to play the melodeons treble side with four fingers (lefty guitar). Though the muscles are used in somewhat different manner I think I have some advantage from the previous practising.
Many use the little finger quite a lot (in the Keanebox thread in the old forum James used too if I remember correct), so I don't understand why someone would want to eschew it. From another perspective, cosider that you have to play N notes in a certain time interval, having 4 fingers do the job they can be quite lazy compared to the only 3 fellas who must do the four mans job in the same time:-)
EDIT: So yes, I will take your advice and practise the 3&4, but I still quite don't know for sure what to practise for the triplets and how.
-
Many use the little finger quite a lot (in the Keanebox thread in the old forum James used too if I remember correct), so I don't understand why someone would want to eschew it. From another perspective, cosider that you have to play N notes in a certain time interval, having 4 fingers do the job they can be quite lazy compared to the only 3 fellas who must do the four mans job in the same time:-)
Well, it's whatever works for you. I can understand your point of view because it's the view I started with based on my experience as a fiddler, where the fourth finger (of the left hand) is invaluable. If you can really make the little finger contribute on the box, go for it. But watch a wide cross-section of good Irish-style players carefully - I think you'll be surprised at what you see.
I can only say that when I tried out the advice of a very good player to deprecate the little fella (advice I was initially reluctant to take, it seemed illogical and absurd), my playing really began to take off.
I reworked all my playing to avoid using the little finger wherever possible and have worked at the patterns I have developed for over two years now. I'd never consider going back to the way I used to play before "taking the challenge". I now allow myself to use the little finger, but only when no higher notes are needed in the phrase. Which usually works out to on high b only, and then only when there is a good reason not to use finger 2 or 3 instead.
I think it was Clive who was talking about practising scales. I do this a lot - every day in fact. And - for a straight up and down on the row scale - I have found that two fingers (1 & 2) can beat the pants off any other combination for speed and accuracy. But, whatever works for you.
-
By repetition wrong things will get stuck in your brains as easily as the right things, or perhaps even easier.
Practice makes permanent--not perfect.
-
... I reworked all my playing to avoid using the little finger wherever possible...
But isn't this how you do it with your fiddle too, use stronger fingers whenever possible and reasonable?
My thought of this is that the little finger is like a crutch which you use whenever it gives you some advantage over the 'not using it'. Now, to be able to use it (when you need it) you must train it.
In CBA accordion playing using the little finger is a norm, same goes with the piano, (with both they even use the thumb). Is there some particular reason why the melodeon would be so much different?
EDIT: Or could it be that our views are actually closer than what we think and we are 'arguing' about nothing.
Well, it's whatever works for you.
Yes, two fingers worked for Django Reinhardt
-
I may be going a bit off topic here, but I had no idea that people would choose not to use their little finger for playing the treble side of the melodeon! I did play the piano (badly) as a child so perhaps that's why I did it 'naturally'.
I don't quite follow Theo's scales exercise, I haven't had time to try it on my box yet, sure it'll become clear when I do! (though my brain is addled enough already... ::))
-
I think the answer is that the piano keyboard and the diatonic button box keyboard are really quite different. The length of the piano keys makes it much easier to use all the fingers. And your thumb isn't tied up in a strap or glued to the edge of the fingerboard. So why assume that all piano technique is bound to be transferable to the button box?
It might depend on what style of music you play too. The Quebec players around here use all four fingers to great effect on their one-rows, but they are playing chords and little mini-chord fills all the time. I play Irish music on the C#/D and to play reels and jigs at speed - say the speed that set dancers like, or that you find in many sessions - your hand really has to fly around keyboard, esp. as many of the tunes have a big range. This is where I have not bothering with the little finger makes a big difference. But even in passages where you hand stays within a range of 4 buttons, it makes a difference in terms of confidence and accuracy.
Also in Irish-style playing you are doing a lot of ornaments involving several fingers on adjacent and sometimes the same buttons, and for this, having your big three right over the centre of the action is vital.
There may be a difference between the C#/D and B/C styles, too, depending on the key you're playing in. I'd use three rather than two fingers for a D scale on the B/C, because of the row crossing and I suppose the little finger might come in handy a little more often. But risto, have you seen Peter Browne's video? Watched him do his pyrotechnics on the B/C? He never uses the pinky - not that I could see, anyway.
I've heard the Django Reinhardt analogy before and actually it's a bit of a red herring. He had no choice. Mairtin O Connor, Peter Browne and all the other Irish-box virtuosos who don't use their little finger could if they wanted to. All I can say is, try it and see...
-
I've taken up the idea of playing scales but I have a question about the fingers being used.
I understand Theo's idea of just using one (index) and four (pinky) or even one finger scales, as recommended by John Kirkpatrick.
If I'm using all four fingers is there a recommended sequence? I notice that in Dave Mallinson's book D/G Melodeon Absolute Beginners he suggests that there are 4 main ways to move fingers up or down -
change - when a single note is played twice - obviously doesn't appertain to scales
cross - when finger one crosses finger two to move up the scale or vice versa i.e. 2 crosses 1
stretch - a finger reaches further than the button it is hovering over
miss - miss out the hovering finger and use next finger up or down
As I have little chance to visit workshops I was wondering if there was a standard way when practicing scales?
Or should I use a mixture of Dave Mallinson's movements?
-
Theo said:
"To play in octaves I use my index finger finger for the low note, little finger for the high one, so the first finger goes up the scale at the same time as the little finger. The added complication is that the fingers do not move at the same time! so for a G scale:"
I think this is what Tony Hall calls the "crab walk".
May I suggest the "crab limp": Do the same but play the octave notes separately (i.e. play low G, then higher G, lower A, higher A etc). It's great for popping in octave ornamentation on runs.
Martin
-
Ok, so there are different schools, and that's fine. I can't argue with you because I have just started the learning, but here's what some of the masters think of this:
- John Williams uses pinky on the John Doyle DVD and on his tutor DVD he teaches scales with the pinky.
- Watch Danny O’Mahoney in this Comhaltas video, some shots of his right hand here and there: http://comhaltas.ie/music/detail/comhaltaslive_227_4_micheal_o_raghallaigh_and_danny_omahoney/
I think the answer is that the piano keyboard and the diatonic button box keyboard are really quite different. The length of the piano keys makes it much easier to use all the fingers. And your thumb isn't tied up in a strap or glued to the edge of the fingerboard. So why assume that all piano technique is bound to be transferable to the button box?
That was a nice try Steve, do you have a similar explanation for the CBA playing? ;)
-
That was a nice try Steve, do you have a similar explanation for the CBA playing? ;)
Well the layout of notes on CBAs is very different from our straight rows, and from what I've seen players hold their right hand at a very different angle. So there may be even less of a case for assuming that the fingering techniques for CBAs apply to diatonics.... ;D
Yes there are different schools and I have the John Williams DVD. Apart from the scale demos the place I noticed him using the 4th finger consistently was to play the def# pull triangle using 343. Works for him obviously!
I heard a quote from another prominent B/C player, Paddy O Brien: something to the effect you use your first three fingers in the lower part of the keyboard and the last three in the upper reaches - which I can see the sense of.
But the player who convinced me to go cold turkey on the little finger for a while put it this way - during a five minute lesson that I begged after a concert. He asked me to play and after about four bars he stopped me and said, in these exact words: "You have to stop using your little finger." I was gobsmacked...
I don't want to set myself up as some sort of authority or anything - nor paint myself into a corner: just today I was analyzing a passage and decided using that the fourth finger was the best way of tackling it - part of The Wheels of the World: ABce gece d3.... (on B/C transpose down a tone into C mix: GA_Bd fd_Bd c3) - it made sense to hit that g with the pinky rather than move the whole hand - for once ;)
So I wouldn't try to propound a hard and fast rule against using the 4th finger - but I would say, based on my experience, that you can improve your playing a lot by learning to work without it. Making a conscious effort not to use it for a while will force you to get your hand moving much more, and the benefits of that are huge.
-
I've taken up the idea of playing scales but I have a question about the fingers being used.
I understand Theo's idea of just using one (index) and four (pinky) or even one finger scales, as recommended by John Kirkpatrick.
If I'm using all four fingers is there a recommended sequence? I notice that in Dave Mallinson's book D/G Melodeon Absolute Beginners he suggests that there are 4 main ways to move fingers up or down -
change - when a single note is played twice - obviously doesn't appertain to scales
cross - when finger one crosses finger two to move up the scale or vice versa i.e. 2 crosses 1
stretch - a finger reaches further than the button it is hovering over
miss - miss out the hovering finger and use next finger up or down
As I have little chance to visit workshops I was wondering if there was a standard way when practicing scales?
Or should I use a mixture of Dave Mallinson's movements?
I don't have Mally's book and I don't play D/G but maybe these tips will help:
Try playing scales using a variety of strategies, they will all help to develop your mobility and command of the keyboard. You will have gathered if you've been following my previous posts in this thread that I'm not big on using the 4th finger and in scales, esp. on one row, I think it just gets in the way.
The "change" strategy does apply to scales, btw, and indeed is very useful, because most of the time you'll be playing two notes on one button.
Here's one method I was showing to some beginning students recently, for a first-octave scale of D on the D row, using two fingers only:
On every button (except the first) you change fingers in between the press and draw. Your hand will climb up the keyboard like a monkey, hand under hand - or finger under finger. The button numbers are for a 4th-button doh.
Button Press/Draw Finger
D 4 P 1
E 4 D 1
F# 5 P 2
G 5 D 1
A 6 P 2
B 6 D 1
c# 7 D 2
d 7 P 1
You lead with your second finger.
Then come down again. This time you lead with the first finger. Again, the last button is the only one you don't change fingers on.
Button Press/Draw Finger
c# 7 D 2
B 6 D 1
A 6 P 2
G 5 D 1
F# 5 P 2
E 4 D 1
D 4 P 1
See what you think of that! You can continue into the second octave the same way, using the 3rd finger just once, to play top C#.
Then practice the same thing, but using fingers 2 and 3 instead of 1 and 2. (Risto can try with 3 and 4 ;) )
Then try a one-octave scale using three fingers, changing over from 3 to 2 between A and B. Then changing from 3 to 1 and going up further. And lots of permutations like that. Then look into how you can play the same scale with cross-rowing. Possibilities are endless, but no effort you spend on this will be wasted, in my view!
Steve
-
Hi Steve
Thanks for that. Looks like I've got my winter activities sorted out.
And as you rightly point out the "change" does apply to scales. Just shows how long it takes for the logical part of the brain to come to terms with the fact the 1 can equal 2. :)
-
Yes there are different schools ....
Thanks Steve, this has been a very enlightening discussion. I checked my fingerings in the Dmaj version of the Silver Spire based on the "three strong ones" and using more jumping up and down. I found some spots where it makes a difference. However, where the tune plays in the second octave I'm going to keep the pinky playing in the couple of places which work just fine.
Last night I spent a couple of hours to find videos from Youtube which would show how Sharon Shannon uses pinky but couldn't find one.
-
I may be going a bit off topic here, but I had no idea that people would choose not to use their little finger for playing the treble side of the melodeon! I did play the piano (badly) as a child so perhaps that's why I did it 'naturally'.
I don't quite follow Theo's scales exercise, I haven't had time to try it on my box yet, sure it'll become clear when I do! (though my brain is addled enough already... ::))
I agree totally with Fee about using the little finger. Most little fingers are a bit on the week side so need to be put in training ( playing scales is one way - playing whole tunes with just little finger is anothr & drimming it on the table, steering wheel or whatever is handy also helps) Not using the little fingr deprives you of a massive 25% of your prodding power which is a bit of a waste! The thumb can also be useful in some circumstances giving a potential 20% increase in prodding power.
With regard to Theo's exercise the thing to remember is that with a standard undoctored DG layout notes on the push repeat every 4 buttons all the way up and notes on the pull repeat every 5 buttons. You therefore walk up the box in a crab fashion starting with fingr 1 on 3rd button & 4 on 7- push bellows. next move finger 4 on to button 8 keeping 1 on button 3 -pull bellows.keeping finger4 on button 8 move finger1 onto button 4 - push bellows ----- That crablike motion can then be continued right up the box as it always puts you 4 buttons apart on push and 5 apart on pull.
It is also the key to playing in octaves i.e. prodding 2 of the same an octave apart i.e. alays 4 buttons apart on push and 5 apart on pull.
This is another reason getting the little finger into trim is important. The same technique cn be used on BC etc when playing accross rows to considerable effect and was much used by Jimmy Shand.
george
-
Welcome aboard, George - good to have you back!
-
** Warning, I'm going to be an awkward bugger and probably overstate my case :P **
Hmmm, scales. In all my years of playing I have never been requested to give a public recital of scales.
Is there some rule that the more esoteric or boring the practise is, the more "worthy" it is?
Surely, the technique that you need to play tunes on the melodeon is that which you use to play tunes on the melodeon. If any tune required me to play a continuous scale over two octaves, then I'd practise that. Since I've never come across a tune that requires that, I've never seriously practised it.
I well remember, as a young child at junior school, going along to recorder lessons where we were not allowed to play any tunes, just stultifying exercises to recorded "plinky plonk" piano music accompaniment. I soon jacked it in and luckily for me was given a tin whistle by my father. What a release!
Of course I'm not saying that *technique* should not be practised. Triplets, runs (as you find them in tunes), getting the bass end going and all that. That is, stuff that you will actually find in tunes. Do I want to practise sterile nonsense that has no link to folk music? No.
-
.... Do I want to practise sterile nonsense that has no link to folk music? No.
IMO two things are important in practises:
A. To learn to know the instrument.
B. Finger/muscle training.
Scales taste like work, practising triplets tastes like fun ;)
-
I play a D/G and have started playing every new tune I learn in both D and G. I play across rows a lot so one key is often easier than the other for a particular tune. For example, Mally's version of Sweet Jenny Jones is easy for me to play in D and not so easy in G. Working on the "difficult" key for every new tune is making me more comfortable with the instrument in general.
-
*and have started playing every new tune I learn in both D and G*
Sometimes this is not possible. i.e when you need to play a low E
*Sweet Jenny Jones is easy for me to play in D*
It sound nicer in D too i think.
Also, having learnt 5 instruments, in 3 of them my teachers made me do scales. I hated them and could see no logical reason for doing them.
I was still forced to do them and in my grade 7 trombone i scored a pitiful 9 out of 21 for them. Yuk!!
How do you create quotes?
-
*and have started playing every new tune I learn in both D and G*
Sometimes this is not possible. i.e when you need to play a low E
The pull E on the third button of the D row works fine for me in both keys.
How do you create quotes?
When I read the articles there is a "QUOTE" button in the upper right corner of the frame. It quotes the whole article. I just delete the stuff I don't want to include in the quote.
-
*and have started playing every new tune I learn in both D and G*
Sometimes this is not possible. i.e when you need to play a low E
The pull E on the third button of the D row works fine for me in both keys.
I meant the tunes in G that need a low E, when transposed into D they need a B instead. Thus, unless you have a low notes instrument instead of accidentals you can't play it, since there isn't a low B.
-
I meant the tunes in G that need a low E, when transposed into D they need a B instead. Thus, unless you have a low notes instrument instead of accidentals you can't play it, since there isn't a low B.
Those tunes can be played in the upper octave. That's what I do, and I'll be the first to admit that it sounds pretty squeeky. But the point of this exercise isn't to sound good, it's to become comfortable with the whole keyboard. The really bad ones are those I play in the upper octave of the G row, but that work will pay off when the G/C Lorelei gets here.
-
I had no idea that people would choose not to use their little finger for playing the treble side of the melodeon!
A bit late coming in here - blame Christmas! I quite agree, Fee; it came as a surprise to me too that anyone would deliberately choose not to use the 4th finger. Surely the melodeon presents you with enough problems without handicapping yourself by depriving yourself of an entire digit? I know I couldn't play without using mine. Still, if it suits some, then whatever floats your boat - I wouldn't dream of saying it's wrong, just that it's not a route I'd choose.
Incidentally, my teacher never told me anything - I didn't have one! I just bought my first melodeon and got on with it, and whatever techniques or characteristics my playing may have acquired have either developed subconsciously or been stolen from someone else's playing.
Cheers
Graham
-
I also use my little finger all the time, as a left handed player, perhaps that might be more expected?
I also use all 4 fingers on the right (chord) hand. I have the advantage (I think!) of having the G chord buttons on the first two fingers, and as G predominates I am not tempted to cross over the rows (on the chord end that is). Whereas I can see that a right handed player might be tempted to use the stronger fingers on the lower rows.
-
Octaves are actually rather simple: two keys between first and forth finger on push, three keys between fingers on the pull. To go up and down the scale, you only move one finger per note. You just "crab-walk" up and down the scale.
I play Cajun mainly and octaves are the absolute core of cajun accordion playing. The rythmic high/low octave bounce, back and forth with timed bellows push/pulls are a signature sound as well. It is what hooked me on the music. In fact, I find playing in octaves to be much easier than playing single notes. Octaves also leave you the two middle fingers for grace notes, triplets, four note squeezes and other ornaments. Don't get me wrong, Cajun music also is done in single notes, especially that bouncing sound. Bellows techniques are very important to rythmn etc., but octaves are just plain fun.
-
I had no idea that people would choose not to use their little finger for playing the treble side of the melodeon!
A bit late coming in here - blame Christmas! I quite agree, Fee; it came as a surprise to me too that anyone would deliberately choose not to use the 4th finger. Surely the melodeon presents you with enough problems without handicapping yourself by depriving yourself of an entire digit? I know I couldn't play without using mine. Still, if it suits some, then whatever floats your boat - I wouldn't dream of saying it's wrong, just that it's not a route I'd choose.
Incidentally, my teacher never told me anything - I didn't have one! I just bought my first melodeon and got on with it, and whatever techniques or characteristics my playing may have acquired have either developed subconsciously or been stolen from someone else's playing.
Cheers
Graham
It's an interesting question (the little finger thing I mean). I've often looked at videos of Mairtin O'Connor and Jackie Daly, noticing the lack of little finger work. I've also seen it live in other musicians.
Mairtin O'Connor, for example, can play at such a speed and accuracy that I can't see that being an inherent problem. What I think it does do, however, is start to impose a certain style of playing.
I've been trying this out this three fingered approach on some slides that I've learnt from recordings of Jackie Daly and Eoghan O'Sullivan. Impact has been very interesting. You can hear the style of playing change, and the ornamentation (or lack of it) becomes more distinctive of their particular Irish style.
-
Mairtin O'Connor, for example, can play at such a speed and accuracy that I can't see that being an inherent problem.
Well I would contend that the speed and accuracy exhibited by O Connor et al. is actually a direct result of using three fingers. This is based on my own experience.
Are you suggesting that using three fingers imposes a style involving less ornamentation? If so, I can't agree with you there. There's an interesting DVD tutorial by Peter Browne consisting mainly of demonstrations of r/h ornamentation techniques on a B/C. Some serious finger pyrothechnics at serious velocity - he never uses the fourth finger.
-
Mairtin O'Connor, for example, can play at such a speed and accuracy that I can't see that being an inherent problem.
Well I would contend that the speed and accuracy exhibited by O Connor et al. is actually a direct result of using three fingers. This is based on my own experience.
I'm pretty sure that argument couldn't be sustained, it can easily be refuted by people who can go just as fast with four fingers. Speed isn't everything and I suspect that it's effect upon style is much more important.
Are you suggesting that using three fingers imposes a style involving less ornamentation? If so, I can't agree with you there. There's an interesting DVD tutorial by Peter Browne consisting mainly of demonstrations of r/h ornamentation techniques on a B/C. Some serious finger pyrothechnics at serious velocity - he never uses the fourth finger.
Nope, just that it encourages a different style and ornamentation.
-
I'm pretty sure that argument couldn't be sustained, it can easily be refuted by people who can go just as fast with four fingers. Speed isn't everything and I suspect that it's effect upon style is much more important.
You're probably right Andrew. It struck me in between the time of my last post and your reply that it could be that the reason the 3-finger technique makes such sense to me is that my aim is to play in the style of those Irish players - for all I know it could be a hindrance for playing in other styles!
If you find you can put into words what the tangible effect on style is, I'd be interested to hear your take on it.
-
** Warning, I'm going to be an awkward bugger and probably overstate my case :P **
Hmmm, scales. In all my years of playing I have never been requested to give a public recital of scales.
Is there some rule that the more esoteric or boring the practise is, the more "worthy" it is?
Surely, the technique that you need to play tunes on the melodeon is that which you use to play tunes on the melodeon. If any tune required me to play a continuous scale over two octaves, then I'd practise that. Since I've never come across a tune that requires that, I've never seriously practised it.
I well remember, as a young child at junior school, going along to recorder lessons where we were not allowed to play any tunes, just stultifying exercises to recorded "plinky plonk" piano music accompaniment. I soon jacked it in and luckily for me was given a tin whistle by my father. What a release!
Of course I'm not saying that *technique* should not be practised. Triplets, runs (as you find them in tunes), getting the bass end going and all that. That is, stuff that you will actually find in tunes. Do I want to practise sterile nonsense that has no link to folk music? No.
I like your way of thinking! I agree too, as I couldn't hack just sitting and playing scales I suppose I'd be a much better player if I could actually force myself to play scales and techniques, but I just like having fun with it and playing tunes that I like and that make me smile. I think life is too short to spend it doing anything we don't like. It's bad enough I have to work a day job, and then if I got home in the evening and thought I'd have to play scales, I wouldn't even be able to pick up my box and play. I took 14 years of piano lessons from Catholic nuns, even though I was not Catholic, and the one teacher I remember best told me to not practice if I wasn't in the 'mood'. She also told me to only practice the songs I loved the best. I always thought she was the one of the most wise people I ever knew. It was delightful to take lessons from her. Over the years I've pretty much forgotten those teachers who forced me to practice scales and songs I didn't love, but I've always remembered her with a special fondness.
-
got some really useful info here.......I still struggle with the upper octave.............as with all instruments scales.that iI often neglect.are really good practice..must fo more of it. I also like the idea of playing in octaves...had a go when I borrowed a cajun single row in C...............but I also used it to discipline myself to playing on one row more......I cross rows far too often and my sound comes out too smooth rather than lumpy.........so I try to play everything at the moment on single rows where possible..Les.
-
got some really useful info here.......I still struggle with the upper octave.............as with all instruments scales.that iI often neglect.are really good practice..must fo more of it. I also like the idea of playing in octaves...had a go when I borrowed a cajun single row in C...............but I also used it to discipline myself to playing on one row more......I cross rows far too often and my sound comes out too smooth rather than lumpy.........so I try to play everything at the moment on single rows where possible..Les.
One of the bits of advice I was given early on is to learn tunes in the upper and lower octaves (the same tune that is). It really helps in learning your way around the instrument.
-
I'm pretty sure that argument couldn't be sustained, it can easily be refuted by people who can go just as fast with four fingers. Speed isn't everything and I suspect that it's effect upon style is much more important.
You're probably right Andrew. It struck me in between the time of my last post and your reply that it could be that the reason the 3-finger technique makes such sense to me is that my aim is to play in the style of those Irish players - for all I know it could be a hindrance for playing in other styles!
If you find you can put into words what the tangible effect on style is, I'd be interested to hear your take on it.
There are a couple of things that stuck me immediately twiddling around with it all:
English players seem to do a lot of octave/chordal work with the right hand. For instance, you could be playing a note with the little finger whilst playing the note an octave below, or parts of a chord. The full spread of four fingers is pretty much needed for this.
I'd think that there are quite a few tunes which seem to make the use of four fingers necessary. I'd be interested to see how someone would get around "La Bastrinque" or "Dark girl dresses in blue" with three fingers on a D/G box. Then again, I could stand corrected :-)
The three fingered style means more moving of the hand up and down the keyboard. This constant repositioning of the hand means that you more often have to play the same note with different fingers consecutively to get the hand in position or play short runs with a single finger.
As I mentioned above, all of this is on a D/G melodeon, though with tunes learnt from C#/D players on the D row, so I think there will be some similarity in experience.
-
Self correction:
Actually "Dark girl dressed in blue" is perfectly possible. Good fun this, it's making me think more about how I'm playing tunes.
-
Last few posts moved to new topic "Dark Girl Dresses in Blue/Modes" in Tunes
-
I'd be interested to see how someone would get around "La Bastrinque" or "Dark girl dresses in blue" with three fingers on a D/G box. Then again, I could stand corrected :-)
I indeed make use of all available fingers when playing québécois tunes! That includes some cross-row work and notes played with the index and pinky especially during part B of "La Bastringue", and tunes such as "Reel de Sherbrooke" or "Money Musk" for which you need all the fingers you can get if you want to keep up with the speed.
-
One important thing missing from this site is the fingerings for all scales. It would be a big job considering all the tunings used (and the three or four finger preferences) but a very useful thing for all us beginners. Besides, does there exist a common way of presenting accordion fingerings, what I recall seems as if each uses ones own style...?
-
I think I have seen as many "fingerings" as I have seen melodeon players!
I read good fingering tips on this site (http://pagesperso-orange.fr/diato-amateurs/apprendre_techniques.htm) but it is all en français.
One tip says to study each phrase of a tune, figure out the corresponding button numbers (starting at 1 from the lowest note); the lowest number is where the index finger should land and the highest number is where the pinky should be. Works often since 4 buttons (usually) cover 8 notes and typical phrases rarely extend beyond an octave.
-
I think I have seen as many "fingerings" as I have seen melodeon players!
quite agree - there is no definitive right way to finger any button box, be it a one row (obviously played on the row) or optional accross rowing on 4th apart boxes or compulsory cross rowing on semitone boxes. To me it seems sensible to practice scales in whatever keys you want to play & do so up to a fair speed whilst retaining accuracy. This helps to develop finger movement and navigation of buttons involved in particular scale as well as complimentary bellows reversals. The most important bit is to try to always have a finger ready over the next button BEFORE the note is required - this makes for quick & accurate playing. In order to do so a system of either 'walking' up & down the keybord or sliding up & down (or combination of both ) is required. Quite how this is done depends on both personal preference, levels of skill & of course the needs of a particular tune but a VERY ROUGH guide is to play 2 or 3 buttons then move up or down as appropriate. I find it also helps to play the keynote with the saem finger whichever octave you are in , so if in G start on G with ist finger & next higher G again with first finger unless the higher G is the highest note in a tune , in which case I may settle for little finger as going no higher.
Another thought is that if the fingering & bellows movements are extremely difficult there may well be an easier way of doing it that you hav't found as yet! - so experiment with that part of the tune to find an easier way of approaching it. Keeping bellows tight also helps as it gives much more accurate control of fast ins & outs by using the wrist muscles rather than arm or shoulder.
this is probably as confusing as it is hopefully enlightening ! Has anybody developed a method of fingering applicable to all keys and tunes i.e. a basic 'universal' way of doing it.
george
-
Another thought is that if the fingering & bellows movements are extremely difficult there may well be an easier way of doing it that you hav't found as yet! - so experiment with that part of the tune to find an easier way of approaching it.
Absolutely. Each phrase of a tune that appears difficult to render deserves developing a "strategy" on how to play it. When learning a new tune I usually print the dots and make notes on the difficult passages with colour markers as a reminder of bellows movement and buttons to use. Once muscle memory has set everything sounds so much better.
-
One tip says to study each phrase of a tune, figure out the corresponding button numbers (starting at 1 from the lowest note); the lowest number is where the index finger should land and the highest number is where the pinky should be. Works often since 4 buttons (usually) cover 8 notes and typical phrases rarely extend beyond an octave.
Well, this wouldn't work so well in Irish music, where there are lots of phrases going well over one octave and quite often two complete octaves. Incidentally phrases of this type are where I have found using 3 fingers to bring the biggest benefits. I do "study the phrase", but in terms of how I can move through it most efficiently, not where fingers should be statically placed.
OTOH, picking up on what George said about using the first finger on the tonic: I have developed a similar strategy mainly playing on the D row (C#/D box) - when I have to zoom up the keyboard quickly I like to make sure I land on second octave D with my first finger, which gives me a familiar vantage point from which to tackle whatever comes next in the higher reaches. Works well in many tunes, especially those in D and G. I suspect everyone works out tricks like this to suit their style of music and style of playing.
-
typical phrases rarely extend beyond an octave.[/b]
[/quot e]
trouble is that whilst many phrsesneed only 8 notes this doesn't necessarily mean that they are on 4 buttons on a semitone box. Also some 4 phrases sit accross octaves being part in one & part in a higher or lower one. hence the 1st finger moving up to keynote so as has been mentioned it acts as a navigational aid & you are following a paattern rather than diving obout randomly for a particular tune. Perhaps this is less important on a 21 button semitone box as the scope upwards is limited however becomes more important on 25 key 2 row or 37 key 3 row.
george
-
Certainly good pieces of advice but I was thinking of just scale practises.
It is very typical for a beginner practising on his own to use fingerings which work (or seem to work) with the undeveloped playing hand but will eventually not bring the best of results. This is very common with guitar players (if you allow the parallelism), and not many beginners can intuitively reinvent the fingering systems which have been found to be the best during the history of guitar playing. The same must apply to accordion playing. Much time can be lost and persistent bad habbits can develop when practising things the "wrong way". "Each to their own" is therefore not a good answer IMO.
With the new C#/D reeds I will have to relearn all my tunes and while doing that I perhaps should post proposals for fingerings of the related scales as initial starting points which you can then chop down as you please. :)
-
Certainly good pieces of advice but I was thinking of just scale practises.
It is very typical for a beginner practising on his own to use fingerings which work (or seem to work) with the undeveloped playing hand but will eventually not bring the best of results.
With the new C#/D reeds I will have to relearn all my tunes and while doing that I perhaps should post proposals for fingerings of the related scales as initial starting points which you can then chop down as you please. :)
one of the reasons for 'fingering' to not work well is because to some people playing a 'scale' only entails doing so for the middle octave - then when the tune goes higher you are buggered! - so scales need to be at least the middle octave plus whatevr you have on your box above it. (and for that matter below it!) and this is where the problem of a standardised way of playing comes in. The push pull set up can never be equated to a linear piano keybord as the bellows movements are crucial and on both semitone & 4th aprt boxes there are 'alternative' notes available.
eg a scale (mid octave only ) in G on BC (or same fingering gives A on C#D) can easily be fingered as follows
note G A B C D E F# G G A B C D E F# G
finger 1 1 2 2 3 3 1 1 but it can also be done just as well 1 1 2 2 3 4 4 3 (using E on outside row)
and these are not the only ways of doing it. However with both of these you finish on high G with 4th or 3rf finger which is not very handy for proceeding furthur.
Therefore another way would be --
note G A B C D E F# G G A B C D E
finger 1 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 which then puts you in line for 1 2 3 2 4 3
now in the real world a tune such as jimmy allen cn be played using the first fingring as it doesnt go beyond the high G note , another is the hullican jig. - another tune in G may require a start with eg 1st finger on D followed by a swift slide up to ist finger on G (eg Molly Malone)
it is therefore important to practice DIFFERENT ways of playing each scale rather than seeking a standard/universal /best set of fingering (as is possible on piano keybord) There just isn't one.
at the end of the day it is essental to know where every note is (including bellows direction) & tis applies just as much to non readers as they still need to know the route to higher & lower notes in a given tune or to put it another way from one note to the next. The ideal situation is to try to develop playing to the stage where you can play any note with any handy finger rather than thinking in terms of this finger should be playing that particular note. You then have a direct connection between brain and box and the fingering will often sort itself out in the same way os the brain/gob connection of a singer (they don't think in terms of 'open wider' 'purse lips' 'breath more air out' or whatever - they think of the tune and the gob does the right things (mine never does!)
to sum up its back to as many ways of playing as there are players. I heard very good friend of Jimmy Shands (& a fellow shand morino player) say that Jimmy played the 3 row box in a way that was subtly different to anybody else - and this was a bloke who had been tought by JS.
bottom line - don't worry about formal ways of doing it - just experiment and get on with it - but always be prepared to do more experimenting - button box playing is a lifelong learning curve.
george (just trying to confuse the issue even more!)
-
bottom line - don't worry about formal ways of doing it - just experiment and get on with it - but always be prepared to do more experimenting - button box playing is a lifelong learning curve.
george (just trying to confuse the issue even more!)
Right on, George!
One thing most people do (including myself) when confronted to learning a new kind of instrument is try to make sure they "get it right" from the beginning. We all wish there is a "best way" to do things that will make it "easy" and speed up the learning process.
I guess the "path of least resistance" concept can apply here too, meaning that, when learning a tune, find the most effective finger/bellows/hand setup according to your style and current abilities.
-
First whisk 5 raw eggs and hold in mouth for 15 seconds before swallowing.
Next snort 0.5 grams of chilli powder in each nostril.
Third insert asparagus into nostrils and bury face in chopped onions.
After this anything to do with melodeons is easy.
Seriously though, Playing in 6ths is useful (2 button gap pull, one button gap push) and John Kirpatricks advice of playing slowly and staccato really does work.
-
... John Kirpatricks advice of playing slowly and staccato really does work.
This shows how different a playingstyle you have with a CBA as they practise LEGATO.
-
I guess we are talking B/C here?
-
I guess we are talking B/C here?
Not particularly. If you check the initial post it was about practices.
-
I guess we are talking B/C here?
Not particularly. If you check the initial post it was about practices.
Practising scales
I seem to remember someone saying that scales can be interesting "in a context"; and they mentioned some pieces which could need some scale practise to get up to speed to play the piece (bumblebee flights apart).
Could one try playing just sections of the pieces to get the scale practice? Although range might pose a few problems depending on how many buttons you have.
Here's a slow one, often used it seems for beginners, which has a little bit of scale work; and is that a grey Paolo S?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uvH_-G61NY0
A lot of buttons in this one, plus stretches of scales;
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PAox6myQ9UQ&feature=related
or on straight accordion keyboard with some bass scale work
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hmTG9wTfrzk
Another at around 2'51", alas on the piano, and at around 6.20 and 8.20
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEH17GCig34
Perhaps there are others out there. ???
sorry forgot these scales at around 1"26 but there seem to be some fingering problems from the very start
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aajtw30-YG0
-
On the subject of 3 vs. 4 fingers, is there a certain number of tunes that are 'impossible' to play with only 3 fingers? Is this a long list? I'm thinking of one that's giving me some grief at the moment: The Primrose Lass played as a reel on a C#D box.
-
If you 'play in chords' you tend you use all the fingers automatically. For example I've got a reversed D mid box. When the tune wants a set of notes from the Em group {E,G,B} I'll often either trill into the D, or even hold it down with #4 finger as a descant - while I play tune with the other three. All I'm doing is adding a minor 7th to the chord to make Em7 so there is never tension there. (It does beg the question as to whether such embellishment improves the tune)!
You can similarly dot in major 7th to extend major chords (eg add C# when the notes run Dmaj {D,F#,A}, without affecting music flow. However if you end on a major7 chord it sounds very 'jazz' - which might not be the effect you want. But again it brings all 4 fingers into play.
While I don't do dedicated workouts for my little finger, I never duck a chance to use it, hoping it might learn some of the musical tricks the others have mastered. Another example is my favourite from last summer Grind Hans Jässpodspolska (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2475.msg27270.html) which has an (unusual for me) quadruplet in its B music played in the top half of the box. OK - go for it. Took me a couple of weeks - but pinkie now has bulging quads 8)
Basically - anything that extends your dexterity - Do it. The effort will pay you back - sometimes many tunes later. Chris
-
Chris, I wouldn't quibble with any of that as far as playing r-h chords is concerned. But to answer Ted's question, I haven't yet come across a tune - melody - that I can't manage without the little finger on C#/D box.
Not to say that I haven't come across tunes or passages in which the little finger is a judicious choice, even for the rabid 3-finger merchant that I am. But so far in my exploration of (mainly Irish) music they are very few, and the little finger is still a useful option, never (yet) a necessity.
Edited to add: Ted, just had a look at Primrose Lass - this setting in G ( http://www.folktunefinder.com/tunes/223947/ ), which sounds close to recorded versions I've heard. Is it the start of the B part that seems to call for the little finger?
My strategy for phrases like that is to consistently play the d with the first finger. The trick I use for coping with the triplet is to play Bc#d with fingers 1-2-1, i.e. changing from 2 to 1 between the c# and the d, bringing me back to my vantage point and leaving fingers 2 and 3 free for the e and g.
But I see there are many settings out there so maybe that isn't where the problem lay.
Cheers
Steve
-
I very nearly put in "don't try extending to 7th chord in an Irish session" when I wrote that this morning. Their music seems to be based on triads. But I assure you it is very useful, nice even, other contexts. And for any note chord that little pinkie is very useful.
-
3/4 Finger debate aside, I used to swear by practicing all major scales at the start of practice, as well as doing all major scales in one note triplets with three fingers (CCC, DDD, EEE etc.) but now all I do is two octaves on C, G, D, A and F and occasionally Bb or Eb if I'm playing something in those keys. If I've a very difficult passage then I take it out on its own and play it dead slow loads of times and start speeding it up. Nothing fancy at all really, just playing things as slow as they need to go to be 100 percent right and then bringing them up to speed. My playing hasn't suffered by spending less time on this stuff.
I'm not convinced that scales are the most useful thing in the world to Irish musicians, even when there are scale passages in tunes it's often nice to ornament a few notes of them which means a different fingering is necessary. That said, it never hurts to know ones way around the keyboard.
-
Lots of wonderful discussion going on here though only a couple of brief comments on practising triplets. I'm a relative newbie playing a BC, any suggestions?
-
Lots of wonderful discussion going on here though only a couple of brief comments on practising triplets. I'm a relative newbie playing a BC, any suggestions?
Try this thread from a while back (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=2207).
-
Waiting for a delivery again, Chris?
-
I've taken up the idea of playing scales but I have a question about the fingers being used.
I understand Theo's idea of just using one (index) and four (pinky) or even one finger scales, as recommended by John Kirkpatrick.
If I'm using all four fingers is there a recommended sequence? I notice that in Dave Mallinson's book D/G Melodeon Absolute Beginners he suggests that there are 4 main ways to move fingers up or down -
change - when a single note is played twice - obviously doesn't appertain to scales
cross - when finger one crosses finger two to move up the scale or vice versa i.e. 2 crosses 1
stretch - a finger reaches further than the button it is hovering over
miss - miss out the hovering finger and use next finger up or down
As I have little chance to visit workshops I was wondering if there was a standard way when practicing scales?
Or should I use a mixture of Dave Mallinson's movements?
Hiya Bryson!
just to add confusion to the whole thing....I would recomend being able to do things in as many different ways as possible. Adaptability is a really valuable part of technique. Usually there is no "set way" that things should be done..so try to find as many ways of doing things as possible. If I find a different way of doing things, I'll usually try to use the new way as much as possible to get used to it, but then often either revert or use a mixture....variation and adaptability are really useful! :-)
-
oh and just to throw something completely beyond reason. I used to practice all scales major and minor on a two row DG with accidentals....starting with the home keys and then working every key chromatically...playing a scale up and down. G, G#, A, Bb, C etc This involves jumping around octaves and thinking where all notes are plus utilising lots of accidentals. After learning this, I decided I had possibly wasted far too much time on something which was impractical for melodeons BUT it did give me great discipline and a greater knowledge of my instrument. If you really have tiem on your hands give it a try...... ;-)
-
Scales have their uses (all the more so if you want to changes nore in impro). I'd not advise 'alphabetical' practice although that does prepare you for the unexpected! And I' not go to far into this without at least 1/2 row of 'accidentals'.
Scales in circle of 5ths is perhaps easier, more natural, and emphasises the relationships and differences. Eg that simple C>C# change that distinguishes D from G, (and via their Greek modes, Em dorian from Em aolian). Start with the 'flattest' you might ever use .. C G D A might suit most in GB.
Practice that little run, or altered II chord that moveds the muic into the other key. eg C .. .. Dm chord ... C .. D7 chord => G key change
If you want to play Blues, find the G, D A and E minor blues scales and get them solid. For solo blues I'd add F#.
Don't just play scales lineraly as "1234456787654321". Learning 123 234 456 567 678 876 765 654 543 432 321 will pay off later. (Jazzers would also do this in groups of 4). This form of practice naturally takes you through the modes of the scales. Try to tap a bass drone in to emphasis that. Move to doing same extending into 8 note runs - now you're doing modes. Some will be better on pull, some on push.
-
Great advice!!!! :-)
-
This may be a little off subject, but...
Our morris side is giong through a phase of doing warm ups and stretches. I find that joining in helps lift me out of the lethargy of waiting to be asked to play!
Rob.
-
oh and just to throw something completely beyond reason. I used to practice all scales major and minor on a two row DG with accidentals....starting with the home keys and then working every key chromatically...playing a scale up and down. G, G#, A, Bb, C etc This involves jumping around octaves and thinking where all notes are plus utilising lots of accidentals. After learning this, I decided I had possibly wasted far too much time on something which was impractical for melodeons BUT it did give me great discipline and a greater knowledge of my instrument. If you really have tiem on your hands give it a try...... ;-)
It's surprising how many keys you can play on a 2-row DG, albeit jumping octaves sometimes. As Liam says, not very practical but it certainly gets you thinking.
-
oh and just to throw something completely beyond reason. I used to practice all scales major and minor on a two row DG with accidentals....starting with the home keys and then working every key chromatically...playing a scale up and down. G, G#, A, Bb, C etc This involves jumping around octaves and thinking where all notes are plus utilising lots of accidentals. After learning this, I decided I had possibly wasted far too much time on something which was impractical for melodeons BUT it did give me great discipline and a greater knowledge of my instrument. If you really have tiem on your hands give it a try...... ;-)
It's surprising how many keys you can play on a 2-row DG, albeit jumping octaves sometimes. As Liam says, not very practical but it certainly gets you thinking.
Indeed. G minor, F# minor, Bb major and Ab major are all surprisingly possible on a D/G box with standard accidentals.
-
Indeed. G minor, F# minor, Bb major and Ab major are all surprisingly possible on a D/G box with standard accidentals.
.. but you really do run out of basses
-
Indeed. G minor, F# minor, Bb major and Ab major are all surprisingly possible on a D/G box with standard accidentals.
.. but you really do run out of basses
This is true :P G minor is possible if you can take the thirds out, even if you tend to play the dominant more than you would otherwise do, due to the pull Bb.