Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: syale on June 17, 2012, 12:59:05 AM
-
Purchased an old Hohner single row diatonic 4 stop on ebay recently (HA-114). Excellent sound from the box but it has some wear problems at the bass end of the box that the prior owner has stuck a sticker on the gold paint. I want to restore it back to how it was.
1. What type of paint is used on them?
2. Is there a standard color for the antique gold color
Stephen
Been playing for 6 weeks now and loving it!
-
Don't know what it was...
Try PACTRA or HUMBREL.
-
I may be entirely wrong, but I have a feeling the Hohner Goldbrand finish was silkscreened rather than painted, in which case touching in will be quite a challenge. I'm sure a resident restoration expert will be along soon with advice!
Graham
-
Yours looks relatively unplayed, the bass end on these is usually more black than silver around the spoons due to paint wear .. the only way to successfully tidy up the spoon box (Growlbox) is to remove the spoons & Handstrap and make it all one colour (Paint, rubbing compound on the gold etc) ..
This is what the they usually look like
-
I'm sure we'd all be interested to hear of any success in matching the finish! Can't be certain, but I believe that the finish is hot rolled onto the parts before assembly - I've never heard of anyone yet refurbishing it! Wear is considered by most to be part of the patina of an old box, until it becomes so tatty that you strip it off and chose your own new finish. A friend rubbed down a very tired Pokerwork and painted it wedgewood blue with whitewood trims - classic!
If you don't like the sticker maybe you shuld choose your own replacement to personalise it? During a get-together, several friends spent some time passing the four-stops around to identify their own purely by the wear patterns. Mine has a piece of tortoiseshell glued above the bases where a previous owner's fingernails had wornthe surface away.
Rob.
-
I think you're right, Rob. The hot-rolling process is, I guess, an industrial development of the screen-printing method I referred to as "silkscreen" - industrial screens are of course fine metal mesh. Either that, or it's a heavyweight version of lino-printing. Either way up, it's not paint, and I wouldn't fancy trying to patch it.
Graham
-
A friend rubbed down a very tired Pokerwork and painted it wedgewood blue with whitewood trims - classic!
I've seen a photo of this box, it does look very good indeed.
-
Mine has a piece of tortoiseshell glued above the bases where a previous owner's fingernails had worn the surface away.
What a good idea, (:) guitars have scratchplates, why not melodeons?
-
Perhaps I should get an Epiphone sticker to go on the scratchplpate...?
I appreciate a new owner wanting to touch up the minor defects in the finish, but like so many cars, it wasn't designed with maintenance and repair in mind! The up-side is that every small change you make personalises the box. At any morris gathering it can take quite a while to sort out which Pokerwork is whose...
Rob.
-
Unless you are insanely good at this sort of thing, (ie, you have years of training and experience and museums regularly commission you to restore priceless art treasures), don't even think about trying to touch up the paint on goldbrand Hohners.
Even decent attempts to remedy cosmetic faults almost always end up making things look worse than before. I'd take a couple of wrinkles over a frozen botox face or a permanently surprised looking facelift any day...
-
OK, so I'll see if I can retrieve the assorted lot of pokerworks I have touched up ; all with reasonable success.
Another possibility is gold ink.
As an aside, for 22 years I have been making and faking historic painted furniture.
I personally prefer the worn look of a well played Pokerwork. Grant Peterson of Rivendell Bicycles coined a word some years back that relates to a well ridden, well loved bicycle.... "beausage" pronounced byousahzh not bo sage..
A combination of beautiful and usage. I apply this to cars as well. Mechanically sound with some cosmetic attention but no slavish attemps at a rolling councours garage queen... examples would be my 1974 Merecedes Benz 450 SL or my 1972 International 1010 Custom pickup... both with around 64K original miles. Both a joy to own and operate with no fear of scratching or dinging to deflate value.
The pokerworks I have touched up all had minor "damage" not normal wear.
I believe the original pokerworks had pieces fed through a roller press in long strips then cut to length. Not sure of the technique used by the Chinese.. I'll assume similar.
I espouse anything that is reversible.
-
you can actually buy both ends of a pokerwork (as in 2 row) from Charlie Marshall for about £35 per end but haven`t seen ends for the 4 stop - a shame but probably because the reedblocks are Glued down and DIY transplants could result in disaster, it`d be a way to tidy the box up and guarantee a flat soundboard with no leaks all in one go .
Saying that though, other parts such as the button action, Bellows, front and back soundboard papers and even the webbing bass strap aren`t available for the 4 stop either whereas everything is for the pokerwork (you can build one entirely from Charlie`s Stock from parts !! ) ..
-
I definitely think the best advice is "live with it". Wear is part of the charm of an old Hohner, and stickers - or the remains where they have been - are part of a box's history. As long as it's mechanically sound and plays well I wouldn't worry overmuch about the casework. My 1-rows are certainly, shall we say, lived-in! I've just had a closer look at the photo of yours and it's in far better cosmetic nick than any of mine.
Graham
-
Try a gold Crayola crayon. It worked to touch up my black Hohner with the gold inlay.
I rubbed the crayon into the spots that were missing the gold and then used a rag to clean off the high spots. It looks pretty good and the price was right.
-
I've just had a closer look at the photo of yours and it's in far better cosmetic nick than any of mine.
It`s mint compared to mine as you can see ... as you say Graham, Who cares.
I`ve just done the Wax on the bass end and sealed some typical Manufacturing Guffers as well (the big bass reed Pallet had a gap at one end!, the chord reeds had no wax at all between them, did that carefully ), it`s still tatty but is sounding good
-
Try a gold Crayola crayon. It worked to touch up my black Hohner with the gold inlay.
I rubbed the crayon into the spots that were missing the gold and then used a rag to clean off the high spots. It looks pretty good and the price was right.
Now THAT could work if the wear is slight (yes, I know it depends on your definition of "slight"!)
Graham
-
I'll throw in my vote to refinish, or leave as-is, not touch up. I'm a big fan of the well worn look. But the stripped/sanded/polished look is very nice, too. You could even stain it or be surprised if there happens to be a figure, however incidental, lurking beneath the paint. Just my two cents. Good luck!
-
I refer you to the
<------------- Penguin of Death Pokerwork
-
Thanks all for all the good advice. I have never been a member of a forum that has so many people providing support, help and encouragement.
I took into account all the advice and I do concur with the wear and tear look. I do have some wear marks on the patterned sides from someone playing the accordion and did not want to restore this. In the attached photos you can see the area where the sticker was. The initial acrylic paint I bought was so far off but it did well as a primer as the paper and plywood were visible after I pulled the sticker off. I ended up buying Classic Gold and a Bronze acrylic (both metallic) and mixed 4 parts Classic Gold with one part Bronze. I painted the whole end so that you can't see the join. I have another accordion to compare with as shown in the images. The one on the left is a newer one and the gold is slightly yellower. The one on the right, I restored, matches the goldbrand pattern colour. I am happy with the job and have enough acrylic left to probably paint a hundred of them :-)
I am English but living in the USA in Texas and trying to learn Newfie tunes! Figure that out (I married a Newfie...) and bought the acylics at Hobby Lobby and Michaels but I expect that if you wanted to fo this you could find similar colours where you are to mix and match.
Thanks again guys for all the suggestions and help, what a fabulous forum!
Stephen
-
One last image!
Stephen
-
Ah - I think we may all have been somewhat at cross-purposes; I think we thought you were looking to touch in the actual Goldbrand pattern on the front/back/top/bottom of the box. At least, I did......
Graham
-
I have found that many paper stickers can be removed with kerosene applied to the sticker with a cotton swab, this soaks through the paper, and dissolves the adhesive underneath. This USUALLY does not react with the paint, but I would check first on a inconspicuous spot.
I have found that auto paint polish will remove surface discoloration and even things out, but if the paint is thin it may just wear through.
-
Yes, the refurb of the solid coloured panel is rather impressive! Good idea to patch in and then paint over the whole panel.
I have three HA11* variants. One has a "gold" panel and the other two are "silver". Actually it's more like no-lead pewter, just as the "gold" is more like freshly polished copper.
Rob.
-
I`ve thought about "re-wallpapering" the ends of mine (it's a silver one) , the screws holding the growlbox on are at least partly under the reedpans though .
-
I have found that many paper stickers can be removed with kerosene applied to the sticker with a cotton swab, this soaks through the paper, and dissolves the adhesive underneath. This USUALLY does not react with the paint, but I would check first on a inconspicuous spot.
I have found that auto paint polish will remove surface discoloration and even things out, but if the paint is thin it may just wear through.
Yes, this does work, but I've found to my cost, that kerosene, or paraffin is quite a good solvent, and will attack certain finishes. WD40 does the job for me, spray or wipe on to the back of a sticker, and it will pull of without damage or residue after 30 mins or so.
-
I've found the best thing to remove sticky labels is Sticky Label Remover(!). You can get it at any office suppliers - the can I have at the moment is Digitex Office, but there are several other brands.
Graham
(I just realised this is my 1000th post.... I hope some of them have been useful!)
-
I've found the best thing to remove sticky labels is Sticky Label Remover(!). You can get it at any office suppliers - the can I have at the moment is Digitex Office, but there are several other brands.
Graham
(I just realised this is my 1000th post.... I hope some of them have been useful!)
Goo Gone is a good solvent for grime and other sticky goop, available in the US. It just stinks to high heaven of oranges. Works fine on wood or celluloid. And yes, your posts have certainly been helpful!
-
I use WD40 for removing labels/goo etc
-
WD40 was sent from the Gods to aid us, like nectar and ambrosia. That and gaffer tape.
I'm never without a can in the house and in the car, although my car can did rust and leak a bit. Did polish up the boot plastic to a lovely finish though.
It's a lovely smell too, that always reminds me of my Dad.
-
WD40 was sent from the Gods to aid us, like nectar and ambrosia. That and gaffer tape.
I'm never without a can in the house and in the car, although my car can did rust and leak a bit. Did polish up the boot plastic to a lovely finish though.
It's a lovely smell too, that always reminds me of my Dad.
I love your post especially the last line ;D
-
Is it possible or can a reasonable job be done to touch up the gold paint on a box with this much wear?
john
-
I don`t think so and I did look into it once and it`d look tacky however it was done.. it`s better to leave as is or do a plain wood / Retro sand down like I did with a black painted 2915 double-ray or sand down and paint in a funky colour, black etc
-
I have found that many paper stickers can be removed with kerosene applied to the sticker with a cotton swab, this soaks through the paper, and dissolves the adhesive underneath. This USUALLY does not react with the paint, but I would check first on a inconspicuous spot.
I have found that auto paint polish will remove surface discoloration and even things out, but if the paint is thin it may just wear through.
Yes, this does work, but I've found to my cost, that kerosene, or paraffin is quite a good solvent, and will attack certain finishes. WD40 does the job for me, spray or wipe on to the back of a sticker, and it will pull of without damage or residue after 30 mins or so.
Still trying to fathom out how to spray the back of the sticker without getting it off first ???
-
For sticker removal, lighter fuel is preferable to paraffin it is not as greasy
-
Are there any other ideas on touching up gold paint, I'd rather repair than take it all off as an alternative? (:)
-
Are there any other ideas on touching up gold paint, I'd rather repair than take it all off as an alternative? (:)
Why change it? It is honest wear, shows it has enjoyed making music. A good patina like that is something you can't reproduce, and should be cherished IMHO.
-
Are there any other ideas on touching up gold paint, I'd rather repair than take it all off as an alternative? (:)
Why change it? It is honest wear, shows it has enjoyed making music. A good patina like that is something you can't reproduce, and should be cherished IMHO.
100% agreement; it's actually in pretty good nick for its age, and personally I really like that lived-in look. Realistically, I don't think you'd stand a cat in hell's chance of matching that lovely old finish with modern materials or anything less than a lifetime's experience as an antique restorer. I'd definitely keep it the way it is. Just my opinion.......
Graham
-
Thanks guys, you've sold me on this and I will leave it as it is. (:)
John