Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Pete Jackson on June 17, 2012, 04:21:24 PM

Title: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Pete Jackson on June 17, 2012, 04:21:24 PM
I have been to a couple of workshops with John Kirkpatrick and he always recommends taking one tune and playing it for an hour. He says the same thing in the introduction to his English Choice tunebook. To quote: "I beseech you, at least once, to sit and play the same tune for one hour.You'll go through the threshold of pain and boredom and reach somewhere you've never been before. It could transform your life". I buy into the reasons, including finding ornamentation and variations you would not otherwise discover, but he also says it induces a "different state of being".
I am curious to know how many of the hundreds of us that have listened to JK, been to workshops, read his musings and heard him say this have actually been able to follow the advice. I am not talking about playing one tune for dancers for ages but playing alone, for practise, for an hour solid on one tune. I have tried a couple of times but have to confess I got nowhere near the hour level. Have others found some sort of nirvana on the other side or, like myself, come closer to the Cobain solution instead whilst attempting the feat?
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 17, 2012, 04:34:39 PM
Pete, an interesting question.
I've always thought I would one day but somehow never got there.....
I await other answers with interest!
Q
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: rees on June 17, 2012, 04:42:40 PM
I have to admit I do it all the time. I find it one of the best ways to relax. After a while the tune takes over and plays itself leaving the mind a perfect blank. It's a good way to learn a new tune but is also a good way to expand tunes that you know really well.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 17, 2012, 04:55:13 PM
LOL I would love to but I am always practising within earshot of people who would, I think, go insane long before I finished.

Might get a chance next weekend but I doubt it - might upset the Shropshire cows!
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Pete Jackson on June 17, 2012, 05:07:06 PM
Ho ho, yes I live an old Victorian house with pretty substantial walls giving a fair degree of soundproofing - but even so I have to be a bit careful not to get the yells of "oh  no, not that one again - surely you know it by now" (but less polite) and the threats to turn the box into firewood. Then again that might be a commentary on my playing rather than the tune!
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Owen Woods on June 17, 2012, 05:16:56 PM
I've played tunes for half an hour or so before. Don't think I've ever tried playing for an hour... could be interesting.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Gary P Chapin on June 17, 2012, 05:51:08 PM
I completely agree with him and have been doing this for years.  When I've got a serious gig coming up, I get even more focused.  I find it to be very ... spiritual ... honestly ... I feel like I'm really immersed in the music.  I have the same feeling when I'm practicing lines for a theater performance, or working on a classical recorder piece.  It really connects you with something larger than yourself and even your own performance.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on June 17, 2012, 06:14:07 PM
I think it's the only way to learn a tune properly - for me anyway with my personal baggage. Others no doubt can pick up tunes immediately and be teaching them in the hour allowed!  :Ph
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: TomB on June 17, 2012, 06:29:42 PM
Interesting concept, saturation for 'brain training', but the letters RSI immediately spring to mind. I do use repetitive practice for 'training' my fingers to go to the right place, sometimes practicing a couple of awkward bars in a tune over several weeks or in some cases months, but never more than a few minutes at a time, a few minutes break playing something else, then back to the awkward bits. Once I feel confident I can play the awkward bits, I then leave them out of my practice for a while so that my brain can work on them in its 'downtime'. That's just the way I do it of course but if JK's system works for you, then go for it.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Pete Jackson on June 17, 2012, 07:06:50 PM
Interesting stuff from all - thanks.
One of the fascinating things for me in the concept from JK (assuming I have understood him properly - but I think I have) is that he is not necessarily talking about tunes that you don't know at the beginning of the process, in other words it is not (or not just) a method of learning a tune - although by the end of it you would have learned the tune pretty thoroughly.
I absolutely agree with TomB about the way to learn fiddly, difficult or awkward bits that won't "go in" without the repetition of structured practise and I do this often. However, JK seemed to me to be talking about the spiritual aspect of the process like Gary Chapin above and it is this that I have so far failed to access.
Perhaps what I need to do is to set aside a suitable period of time and try to empty my mind whilst playing to get into a sort of meditative state similar to that you can find yourself during an intense period of physical exercise ie running and perhaps that would be best attempted with a tune I already know so I am not actually trying to learn it at the same time.
(To anyone who knows me, yes I do know there may not be that much to empty from that space I laughingly call my mind/brain! And I don't want to get too precious about the whole thing.)
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Ray on June 17, 2012, 07:56:35 PM
I think trying to force yourself to do it could be a bad idea, if you have to force yourself to play one tune for an extended period of time you probably don't like it. There are some tunes I can't stand to play for longer than 10 minutes in one go (E.g. Lots of tunes I should learn for my morris side), but there are just so good that I can't play them for any less that half an hour.
If you want to find new ways of doing a tune/adding bits, I'd just put the tune to one side for a bit, forget it a little, then pick it up again and you'd be amazed what comes out by accident. But at the end of the day I guess it works differently with everyone (:)
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: AirTime on June 17, 2012, 08:27:48 PM
Oh dear. One tune for an hour? I do it all the time! 

I posed this question in the "beginners showcase" thread. How do you get to the point where you can pick up a box & play a tune - any tune - through without making any mistakes? I have discovered the that, for me, it takes A LOT of practicing! And that means playing the same tune over & over again until it really sinks in & then I can concentrate on the timing & the feeling of the piece & not just "playing it right".

After a little less than a year playing, I have a repertoire of about 25 to 30 tunes that I can play - sort of - but only 5 or 6 that I can play through confidently without screwing up somewhere along the way. The way I "mastered" those is by playing them for an hour - lots of times.  :||:   :||:    :||:  :||:   :||: 

I'm hoping that this time requirement will diminish somewhat as I gain experience ....  :-\
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Lester on June 17, 2012, 08:32:47 PM
<snip>
 How do you get to the point where you can pick up a box & play a tune - any tune - through without making any mistakes?
<snip>

Dont think you ever get there, I have seen the great and good play tunes and make mistakes (John Kirkpatrick makes a big song and dance to cover up his mistakes  (:) ). What you need to get to is the ability to make mistakes but not to grind to a halt because of them.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 17, 2012, 08:35:42 PM
Lester's hit the nail on the head.
Getting to the point where you can keep going despite a stumble is a big step forward.
Q
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: TomB on June 17, 2012, 10:31:02 PM
Beginners make.. mistakes
Experienced players make.. variations to the tune  >:E
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Pete Jackson on June 17, 2012, 10:34:22 PM
I thought it was that:
amateurs practise until they can get it right,
professionals practise until they can't get it wrong.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Steve C. on June 18, 2012, 06:15:18 PM
I don't know if I have ever gone an hour, but certainly 30-45 minutes, quite often.
It seems the best way to get past "oom pa pa" bass playing, as the melody side soon becomes second nature and you can noodle around the basses and chords without losing the tune.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Strigulino on June 19, 2012, 01:08:57 PM
I doubt I go on for an hour, but I have found myself stubbornly focusing on one tune, trying to nail a tricky bit.  Princess Royal it was for me.  I SO wanted to be able to play it but the quick bits were quite fiddly.  So while I wasn't playing one tune for an hour, I was playing certain bars of it over and over and over again at varying speeds. 

I think there is worth in this approach, but I think you'd have to let that song lie fallow for a while afterwards to let the memory bed in.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Hello on June 21, 2012, 12:11:14 PM
[quote/]
What you need to get to is the ability to make mistakes but not to grind to a halt because of them.

So, we need to get better at making mistakes.

Do you think it would help to deliberately try to make mistakes or otherwise expose oneself to a situation likely to cause them, in order to be able to handle them better?
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Lester on June 21, 2012, 12:26:20 PM
What you need to get to is the ability to make mistakes but not to grind to a halt because of them.

So, we need to get better at making mistakes.

Do you think it would help to deliberately try to make mistakes or otherwise expose oneself to a situation likely to cause them, in order to be able to handle them better?

If you deliberately make a mistake it is no longer a mistake   >:E
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: IanD on June 21, 2012, 12:49:11 PM
What you need to get to is the ability to make mistakes but not to grind to a halt because of them.

So, we need to get better at making mistakes.

Do you think it would help to deliberately try to make mistakes or otherwise expose oneself to a situation likely to cause them, in order to be able to handle them better?

If you deliberately make a mistake it is no longer a mistake   >:E

Otherwise known as the Ralph Jordan principle of ornamentation ;-)
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Endolf on June 21, 2012, 12:52:54 PM
If you deliberately make a mistake it is no longer a mistake   >:E

I joined a morris side (or 2) deliberately, I'm fairly certain that was still a mistake :)

Endolf
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 21, 2012, 12:54:02 PM
Do you think it would help to deliberately try to make mistakes or otherwise expose oneself to a situation likely to cause them, in order to be able to handle them better?

Speaking for myself, I don't need help getting into this situation.

If you deliberately make a mistake it is no longer a mistake   >:E
Well it's true - and since you made some preparation for the "mistake", you have also de facto made some preparation for correcting it.
I find correcting a mistake quite easy if I'm working from the dots, but if I'm going from memory a simple mistake can stop me in my tracks.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Anahata on June 21, 2012, 01:09:41 PM
What you need to get to is the ability to make mistakes but not to grind to a halt because of them.

So, we need to get better at making mistakes.

Pig Dyke Molly actually "practice going wrong" sometimes.
Not so much going wrong deliberately, but making sure dancers have a sensible strategy if they make a mistake or forget where they should be - there are good and bad ways to recover from a mistake. If it's done well, the average audience can't tell anything went wrong.

Quote
Do you think it would help to deliberately try to make mistakes or otherwise expose oneself to a situation likely to cause them, in order to be able to handle them better?

When practising, I've seen it recommended to play in unfamiliar surroundings - i.e. if you have a music room where you usually play, sitting in one place, facing a particular direction, go and play in a different part of the house, sitting on a different chair (if you play sitting down), with a diferent view in front of you and a different acoustic. Changes in surroundings can be distracting and thus cause mistakes, so getting used to that will overcome one cause of trouble when playing in front of an audience.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 21, 2012, 01:15:22 PM
Changes in surroundings can be distracting and thus cause mistakes, so getting used to that will overcome one cause of trouble when playing in front of an audience.
Very true - the first time I played a concertina in a hall, instead of the small room I use for practice (no, not that small room) I was completely unnerved by the difference in sound.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: RobinA on June 23, 2012, 04:15:11 AM
A musician once told me that you have to play something 10,000 times to burn it into muscle memory.  But I'd probably get kicked out of the house long before that!!!
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Owen Woods on June 23, 2012, 07:47:11 AM
Another tip is to wander around the house whilst playing. You have to know the tune quite well to successfully navigate both that tricky bass run and the pile of dirty washing at the top of the stairs, or in my case, the delicate bits of delicate melodeons strewn all over the floor...
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: deltasalmon on February 01, 2013, 03:34:08 PM
An interesting idea. I made a "boxolution" to increase my repertoire by learning 3 new tunes each month. I'll give this method a try one day when my significant other is out of the house.

I've never timed myself to see how long I have spent playing a single tune. I'll try timing myself and see what I think after an hour.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: boxer on February 01, 2013, 07:05:10 PM
endless repetition - playing a tune for and hour, for example - will help to "burn in" the mechanicals of fingering etc.  Once that's achieved the tune almost plays itself and your mind is free to mess about with the nuances of stress and phrasing and you can turn even a simple tune into a minor work of art.

 
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Steve C. on February 02, 2013, 01:39:43 PM
Agreeing with Ukebert:  walking around the house or yard while playing seems to improve the muscle memory while your brain memory is doing something else.

Also helps in that it makes fingering and bellows control just a little bit harder as everything is moving around.

So when you stay put again, all seems much easier.

And while seems silly, marching around in a circle or back and forth helps keep time, especially when practicing dance tunes, helps one get grounded into playing at the right speed, not too fast, especially.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: MandoC on February 02, 2013, 06:49:52 PM
I recently read Arnold Schwarzenegger's autobiography Total Recall, which I found to be surprisingly interesting.  One of his rules for life in the last chapter of the book is called reps, reps, reps. He shows a photo of a speech he gave to the U.N. which has over 60 tick marks at the top of the page. the text below it says "Each tick at the top of the page represents one time I rehearsed delivering the speech.  Whether you're doing a bicep curl in a chilly gym or talking to world leaders, there are no shortcuts-everything is reps, reps, reps." Repetition is the single most important thing that works for me to get better at playing (although the progress on accordion is agonizingly slow). Charlie
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: rileycat on February 10, 2013, 03:56:57 PM
I remember being at the original JK workshop in Sidmouth decades ago, when he first publically practiced what he preached, and got us all to play (as I remember) Winster Gallop for almost the entire hour! It made an impression to say the least and quite a few souls, once they had recovered from the experience, complained long and loud - poor John, he was making a valid point, but perhaps the world wasn't ready! Was anyone else here at that event? ;)
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Anahata on February 10, 2013, 04:13:12 PM
I remember being at the original JK workshop in Sidmouth decades ago, when he first publically practiced what he preached, and got us all to play (as I remember) Winster Gallop for almost the entire hour! It made an impression to say the least and quite a few souls, once they had recovered from the experience, complained long and loud - poor John, he was making a valid point, but perhaps the world wasn't ready! Was anyone else here at that event? ;)

I thought I was there, but at the one I attended we played Davy Davy Knick-Knack. Was that the same one, or did he do it more than once?
Most memorable reaction was from an old boy with a PA who complained (after hearing the tune played non-stop for nearly an hour) that (a) he didn't know the tune and (b) no music was provided...

The background was that previously JK had given a workshop on variations, but felt that hadn't worked as well as it should because the participants hadn't really got the tune under their skin before starting to improvise around it.

It's all in his famous Medley Mania (http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.asp) piece on his web site.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: michik on February 11, 2013, 10:32:40 AM
I think the goal of that is "getting into the music" as Joe Derrane says at 26:40 on http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0fOlTjpzAw
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: pikey on February 11, 2013, 11:49:14 AM
Never done the full hour, but our dance band regularly played Buttered Peas and Officers Polka as a set (twice through each tune then change) for 40 minutes - the tunes got more and more mesmerising !

I also recall Reg Reeder leading Heel and Toe polka on his hammer dulcimer in a session at the second ECMW for 20 minutes. That was just plain boring.  :(
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: jackson10 on February 11, 2013, 12:08:43 PM
I just tried this for the first time and while timing it found that I had previously been quitting probably around the 20-minute mark, where my concentration seemed to be breaking down.  But I think there was some progress this time. I'll try it some more and see how it works going forward.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: EastAnglianTed on February 11, 2013, 12:11:56 PM
Jeez I wouldn't put my housemates through an hour of one song, they'd literally kill me
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: pikey on February 11, 2013, 02:49:52 PM
I DARE YOU !!   ;)
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Gary P Chapin on February 11, 2013, 03:17:46 PM
I had previously been quitting probably around the 20-minute mark, where my concentration seemed to be breaking down.
They claim -- they being those who claim such a thing -- that if you can persist through that Flagging Wall, you will emerge on the other side greatly improved.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Tamba on February 11, 2013, 05:11:28 PM
I think there will be a window of opportunity open for me to have a go at this tomorrow. All I have to do now is decide which tune I want to play for an hour  :-\ although I don't think it really matters!  :||:
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Howard Jones on February 11, 2013, 08:21:57 PM
The point of the exercise, as I recall from one of Mr K's workshops, is not to learn a tune, but to deconstruct it so that you can start to take it into some interesting places.  His theory is that after an hour you'll be so bored with the basic tune that you'll start exploring variations.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: mory on February 12, 2013, 09:06:29 AM
I think in his original suggestion it related more to things coming out and developing of their own accord rather than anything to do with boredom, at least that was how he expressed it to me. All the Best mory
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Anahata on February 12, 2013, 10:19:13 AM
That's how I heard it - whether you call it boredom or spontaneous variations, I think the point it that you get into a mental zone where you really don't have to think about the tune at all, and variations will become effortless.

"not thinking" is, of course, a way of describing meditation. I don't know if JK has explored altered mental states though meditation, but he certainly has all the right jargon to describe it in Medley mania. He apologetically suggests it might be "cosmic claptrap" but I suspect he knows from experience what he's talking about.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Tamba on February 12, 2013, 12:42:17 PM
Having just done this I can really recommend it. It wasn't as mentally/physically tough as I anticipated and greatly helped me to get inside the tune. I played 'Le bout du monde' (inspired by DTN http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XnVJVV-adK4 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XnVJVV-adK4)and his blue Saltarelle) as I have been playing it for a few months now and thought I knew it well enough to have a play around with it but was fresh enough to it not to get bored with playing it.
So, if you haven't done this then give it a try, it is worth it.

 :||:  :Ph Tim
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Tamba on February 12, 2013, 03:58:17 PM
I must add that I didn't reach Nirvana at any point (bit disappointed about that) :(, but I will do this again from time to time in further pursuit of melodeonlightenment.  ::)
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Anahata on February 13, 2013, 11:19:06 AM
melodeonlightenment
;D ;D
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Lester on February 13, 2013, 11:23:49 AM
further pursuit of melodeonlightenment.  ::)

Petrol and matches work well for melodeonlightenment   ;)
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: pikey on February 13, 2013, 01:11:36 PM
I must add that I didn't reach Nirvana at any point (bit disappointed about that) :(, but I will do this again from time to time in further pursuit of melodeonlightenment.  ::)

Smells like teen spirit?   >:E
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 13, 2013, 05:53:18 PM
Lester - never realised Hendrix played the box.........
Perhaps he was copying that other well known box player recently mentioned - Leadbelly.
Might be a trend?
Q
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 13, 2013, 08:07:10 PM
Quote from: tamba link=topic=9715.msg144188#msg144188
I will do this again from time to time in further pursuit of melodeonlightenment.  ::)

:D We may have another new word here.    OED, are you tuned in?
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: jackson10 on March 04, 2013, 01:54:01 PM
I had previously been quitting probably around the 20-minute mark, where my concentration seemed to be breaking down.
They claim -- they being those who claim such a thing -- that if you can persist through that Flagging Wall, you will emerge on the other side greatly improved.
Are there any tips to help in persisting through the wall - brute force?  take a 3 minute break and come back to it?  take a deep breath and relax? switch briefly to another tune and then come back?   
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 04, 2013, 03:23:44 PM
I'd give it a rest and come back another day, if that is how you feel.  Basically the "concentration" word is a red herring in this.  What you are aiming for is to play the tunes and your favourite twiddles automatically and without conscious thought. Level 2 being to play in those twiddles "at will". Level 3 being able to go from one variation to another fluently in the course of play.  We do this all the time in speech; good singers do the same. The mechanical nature of a playing an instrument takes (a lot) more work but you are still aiming for automaticity

You must unlearn what you have learned;
           Do, or do not.     There is no "try"
(http://i294.photobucket.com/albums/mm107/gnerph/yoda.gif)
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Bob Ellis on March 04, 2013, 04:00:44 PM
Jk's recommendation of an hour is no more than a guide. If you are having to force it, you will do more harm than good and you may fall out of love with playing anything!

My advice would be to play the tune for as long as you are happy to do so and when the urge to stop or to change to another tune becomes too strong, don't fight it. Come back to the first tune later, or on another day, when you feel in the right frame of mind to do so.  
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on March 04, 2013, 04:24:37 PM
Quote from: tamba link=topic=9715.msg144188#msg144188
I will do this again from time to time in further pursuit of melodeonlightenment.  ::)

:D We may have another new word here.    OED, are you tuned in?

Melodeonenlightenment..... The art of having an instrument maker construct a box made of Balsa wood with Crepe bellows and filled with Helium when not being played and including  a G- Lighten button.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: LDbosca on March 04, 2013, 06:44:13 PM
Jk's recommendation of an hour is no more than a guide. If you are having to force it, you will do more harm than good and you may fall out of love with playing anything! 

Call me old-fashioned but I reckon the odd bit of forcing never does any harm!
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 04, 2013, 07:25:51 PM
Hmmm.... until last week I think I would have agreed that 'a bit of forcing does no harm...'
I'd made a deal with myself to enter ToTM as I wanted to learn the tune. After getting it reasonable close for a first attempt I spent the last two afternoons trying to get a reasonable recording so kept plugging away..... and just got worse and worse.
In essence I was trying to force a good recording when I was possibly not quite ready.
I left it for a couple of days and played it decidedly better.
I think to get to the bottom of JK's motives you need to be competant at the tune, so you can play it automatically and then let it find itself in some Zen like meditation, as opposed to practising a tune that's not quite there where you might just consolidate mistakes.
Q
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: LDbosca on March 04, 2013, 09:26:17 PM
Hmmm.... until last week I think I would have agreed that 'a bit of forcing does no harm...'
I'd made a deal with myself to enter ToTM as I wanted to learn the tune. After getting it reasonable close for a first attempt I spent the last two afternoons trying to get a reasonable recording so kept plugging away..... and just got worse and worse.
In essence I was trying to force a good recording when I was possibly not quite ready.
I left it for a couple of days and played it decidedly better.
I think to get to the bottom of JK's motives you need to be competant at the tune, so you can play it automatically and then let it find itself in some Zen like meditation, as opposed to practising a tune that's not quite there where you might just consolidate mistakes.
Q

Ah yes, you can't force a recording, you're dead right. You can definitely psych yourself out and mess it up even more, I've done it.

I don't reckon there's any need to be at a certain standard to practice a tune for an hour though; just slow it down until there's no mistakes and bring it up as appropriate.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 04, 2013, 10:27:52 PM
Glad to know it's not just me that can mess up recording!
and I think once you get through the 'no mistakes' barrier, you're on your way.
Q
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Anahata on March 05, 2013, 08:29:59 AM
I spent the last two afternoons trying to get a reasonable recording so kept plugging away..... and just got worse and worse.
...
I left it for a couple of days and played it decidedly better.

That always happens, but the improvement doesn't just come from doing nothing for a couple of days. The intensive practice may or may not show an immediate improvement while you are doing it, but it seems to start a process of brain re-wiring which continues in the background for a day or two, after which the effect becomes much more noticeable.

Make a plan: intensive practice now, record in a couple of days' time. It'll work.
(you'll still find you can play the same thing much better a week or a month later: c'est la vie)
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: daveyaaa on March 05, 2013, 01:06:30 PM
Lester - never realised Hendrix played the box.........
Perhaps he was copying that other well known box player recently mentioned - Leadbelly.
Might be a trend?
Q
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 05, 2013, 02:16:57 PM
.. the improvement doesn't just come from doing nothing for a couple of days. The intensive practice may or may not show an immediate improvement while you are doing it, but it seems to start a process of brain re-wiring which continues in the background for a day or two, after which the effect becomes much more noticeable.

Brain rewiring is probably pretty close to what is physically happening, and probably in cerebellum ("little" brain, at the back) which ain't well understood. In our  Stroke Unit we sometimes see massive damage there with little consequence  ??? other than clumsiness and a wide gait. But it seem to govern fine movements, and has quite fast "learning" centred on plump "Purkinje" cells believed to have "plasticity" in their connections.   In electronic terms I tend to think of this as an uncommitted logic array, but I'm no neurophysiologist, and of course they don't agree on what's going on  ;)

But who else has practiced until their brain ached, still not "automatic" and then slept on it? Next day you have a new "skill for life". Well, it worked for me, though rather less as I get older.
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on March 05, 2013, 04:06:31 PM
Lester - never realised Hendrix played the box.........
Perhaps he was copying that other well known box player recently mentioned - Leadbelly.
Might be a trend?
Q

Ha ha.

You do realise that's clearly a doctored photograph ... don't you?
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: 911377brian on March 05, 2013, 04:47:33 PM
I have to admit that learning tunes has never really been a problem for me, but playing the tunes I've learned without any mistakes is beyond me...however, I have noticed that after passing my 75th birthday RECALLING the learnt tunes has become more difficult, I know the tune I want to play but often can't remember what it sounds like. I've had to fall back on adding the first four or five notes after the tune title in my little book. That works.I played Lesters 'Mr an Mrs Micky Mouse for forty minutes yesterday, because it would'nt stay in my mind. Now I'm stuck with it as a background tune. Is that what is called an 'ear worm'? :||: :||: :||: ???
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 05, 2013, 08:06:07 PM
Anahata and Chris: Yes I think I knew this but perhaps in a moment of lunacy decided to prove it to myself!
In my defence, I wouldn't have normally pushed so hard but a week in bed with flu doesn't improve your playing i've discovered,  >:( and I really had committed myself to posting the tune. I should have known better.

Brian: Yep sounds like an Earworm!
You know it's happening when you find yourself humming it, waking at silly-o'clock and....it's there :||:
They drive you nuts, but it is a good way to inadvertantly get it into the brain.
Q
Title: Re: Playing one tune for an hour as practise - as per JK recommendation
Post by: Dave F on March 31, 2013, 11:04:59 PM
I think there's a lot to be said for repetitive practice. When I was at school I played the bassoon in our school orchestra. Our music teacher was passionate about music and didn't take any prisoners when it came to what we played. Some of the music we played was simplified for school orchestra's, but we also used full professional scores. His technique was to make us practice the same piece, movement or even a few bars over and over, rehearsal after rehearsal. It worked, not only could we play well, we loved the music we played and it stuck. I've not picked up a bassoon in anger for 36 years and I can still visualise some of the pieces we played, even down to seeing the notes on the page, hearing my parts and being able to make the right shapes with my hands to reach the notes. I've never had the luxury of having enough time to play so intensely again, but it must have worked.

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal