<snip>
How do you get to the point where you can pick up a box & play a tune - any tune - through without making any mistakes?
<snip>
[quote/]
What you need to get to is the ability to make mistakes but not to grind to a halt because of them.
What you need to get to is the ability to make mistakes but not to grind to a halt because of them.
So, we need to get better at making mistakes.
Do you think it would help to deliberately try to make mistakes or otherwise expose oneself to a situation likely to cause them, in order to be able to handle them better?
What you need to get to is the ability to make mistakes but not to grind to a halt because of them.
So, we need to get better at making mistakes.
Do you think it would help to deliberately try to make mistakes or otherwise expose oneself to a situation likely to cause them, in order to be able to handle them better?
If you deliberately make a mistake it is no longer a mistake >:E
If you deliberately make a mistake it is no longer a mistake >:E
Do you think it would help to deliberately try to make mistakes or otherwise expose oneself to a situation likely to cause them, in order to be able to handle them better?
If you deliberately make a mistake it is no longer a mistake >:EWell it's true - and since you made some preparation for the "mistake", you have also de facto made some preparation for correcting it.
What you need to get to is the ability to make mistakes but not to grind to a halt because of them.
So, we need to get better at making mistakes.
Do you think it would help to deliberately try to make mistakes or otherwise expose oneself to a situation likely to cause them, in order to be able to handle them better?
Changes in surroundings can be distracting and thus cause mistakes, so getting used to that will overcome one cause of trouble when playing in front of an audience.Very true - the first time I played a concertina in a hall, instead of the small room I use for practice (no, not that small room) I was completely unnerved by the difference in sound.
I remember being at the original JK workshop in Sidmouth decades ago, when he first publically practiced what he preached, and got us all to play (as I remember) Winster Gallop for almost the entire hour! It made an impression to say the least and quite a few souls, once they had recovered from the experience, complained long and loud - poor John, he was making a valid point, but perhaps the world wasn't ready! Was anyone else here at that event? ;)
I had previously been quitting probably around the 20-minute mark, where my concentration seemed to be breaking down.They claim -- they being those who claim such a thing -- that if you can persist through that Flagging Wall, you will emerge on the other side greatly improved.
melodeonlightenment;D ;D
further pursuit of melodeonlightenment. ::)
I must add that I didn't reach Nirvana at any point (bit disappointed about that) :(, but I will do this again from time to time in further pursuit of melodeonlightenment. ::)
I will do this again from time to time in further pursuit of melodeonlightenment. ::)
Are there any tips to help in persisting through the wall - brute force? take a 3 minute break and come back to it? take a deep breath and relax? switch briefly to another tune and then come back?I had previously been quitting probably around the 20-minute mark, where my concentration seemed to be breaking down.They claim -- they being those who claim such a thing -- that if you can persist through that Flagging Wall, you will emerge on the other side greatly improved.
| You must unlearn what you have learned; Do, or do not. There is no "try" | (http://i294.photobucket.com/albums/mm107/gnerph/yoda.gif) |
Quote from: tamba link=topic=9715.msg144188#msg144188I will do this again from time to time in further pursuit of melodeonlightenment. ::)
:D We may have another new word here. OED, are you tuned in?
Jk's recommendation of an hour is no more than a guide. If you are having to force it, you will do more harm than good and you may fall out of love with playing anything!
Hmmm.... until last week I think I would have agreed that 'a bit of forcing does no harm...'
I'd made a deal with myself to enter ToTM as I wanted to learn the tune. After getting it reasonable close for a first attempt I spent the last two afternoons trying to get a reasonable recording so kept plugging away..... and just got worse and worse.
In essence I was trying to force a good recording when I was possibly not quite ready.
I left it for a couple of days and played it decidedly better.
I think to get to the bottom of JK's motives you need to be competant at the tune, so you can play it automatically and then let it find itself in some Zen like meditation, as opposed to practising a tune that's not quite there where you might just consolidate mistakes.
Q
I spent the last two afternoons trying to get a reasonable recording so kept plugging away..... and just got worse and worse.
...
I left it for a couple of days and played it decidedly better.
Lester - never realised Hendrix played the box.........
Perhaps he was copying that other well known box player recently mentioned - Leadbelly.
Might be a trend?
Q
.. the improvement doesn't just come from doing nothing for a couple of days. The intensive practice may or may not show an immediate improvement while you are doing it, but it seems to start a process of brain re-wiring which continues in the background for a day or two, after which the effect becomes much more noticeable.
Lester - never realised Hendrix played the box.........
Perhaps he was copying that other well known box player recently mentioned - Leadbelly.
Might be a trend?
Q