Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: butimba on June 18, 2012, 09:40:44 PM
-
Hi,
I’m another newcomer to the forum (which has already proved to be very helpful!) and wanted to ask for advice on the best d/g melodeon to buy for a beginner. Although I’ve never picked up a melodeon before and am not completely sure it’s the instrument for me, I want to buy one that I’ll enjoy the sound of and find easy to play, so get the impression I should stay clear of the really cheap makes and go for one around £700–£900. Is this a good idea?
I’m a bit of a weedy girl with small hands so want to find a melodeon that is reasonably lightweight and compact. Ideally I’d like an instrument that can be played quietly and has a nice mellow tone. Can anyone recommend something in the price range above?
My one concern over buying a melodeon is that I’ll quickly get frustrated with the limited keys – really I just want to play a bit of everything (English, Irish, French, Balkan...) and I’m worried that I’ll find the d/g melodeon quite restricting. Has anyone else had this problem?
And apologies for all the questions but I just have one more: can anyone recommend tutors/beginner groups/sessions etc. in London?
-
Hi,
Good questions. I came to this forum about 6 months ago and asked the exact same questions.
The response I got was to go for either a second hand pokerwork or a delicia popular. Both are great instruments and can be found at relatively cheap prices £300-500.
In the end though I found a G/C pre-pokerwork from American ebay and a C/F Erika from German ebay both cumulatively costing less than £200. Bearing in mind that I will spend a fair amount of time and money learning how to restore these beauties.
I don't think you will find the melodeon limiting at all, as most songs can be transposed into the key you are playing in and when moving to a different box or row the patterns generally stay the same.
I really love learning this instrument, it is a unique challenge.
Good luck on your quest!
Chappie
-
Another piece of advice if you have never ever played is try a cheap £10 toy melodeon. It can give you the basic concepts and no great expense spared. However, it will be a very creaky and leaky instrument!
Chappie
-
I'm aware this won't apply to everyone but when I hear beginners say "I want to play a bit of everything" and reel off a list of diverse genres, more often than not in my experience, that really means that they're unfocused and haven't decided what they really like and want to play. I also think that a lot of beginners are wrongly turned off by the idea of a limited range of keys and not having each and every note on tap, in practice that is not a problem for most people once they start playing and realise that they're not running forwards and backwards through the circle of 5ths and needing to hop between 4 sharps and 3 flats at the drop of a hat!.
A D/G is the standard box for English and you can play French stuff as well but in different keys and without the lovely richness of a G/C. Irish tunes can be played easily enough but the style and playing technique,and consequently the resulting overall sound and feel, between a D/G and a B/C or C#D is vastly different. Most people would generally agree that a standard D/G 2 row can't really cut it for more exotic stuff like Balkan or Klezmer.
For instruments themselves, the upper limit of your price range would get you a Sandpiper or Hohner Morgane, which would both be very good starter boxes. However, you could get a Made in Germany Hohner from a restorer for a lot less that will be guaranteed to be in tune and in proper working/playing order and will hold it's value if you decide the melodeon isn't for you and want to sell it. I would not recommend buying a Hohner from eBay, unless it's been restored properly and explicitly says so in the listing, you will need to spend a lot of money to get it playable.
-
In the D/G world the price limit you set should buy a decent second hand box. On this site there's been a Lilliput and a Dino Baffetti Black Pearl sold in the last week for well under your limit either of which would be great boxes.
As far as playing lots of genres is concerned then the bass end will limit you to a large extent even if you can play the melody on the right hand. Also a lot of Balkan music (for example) isn't suited to any squeeze box, it's insanely fast (lots of notes) and omptimised for whistles or pipes (been there and done that (:))
My approach was to decide what I really wanted to play and bought a box that most suited that style (at the time a D/G). Since then I've moved on and as I play more french and klezmer I now have a G/C with accidentals which also allows me to play english etc although I've had to alter the fingerings.
There's lots of good secondhand boxes out there in your price range (in fact you could probably pick up a D/G and a C/F and have change from £900)
Steve
-
A friend of mine is selling his mint condition delicia popular , in D/G, an ideal beginners instrument and much better made than the black Chinese ones sold by a well known music shop.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9652.msg119485.html#msg119485
Please send me a message me if you're interested.
Cheers!
Pikey
-
Welcome to the forum.
Taking into account your small hands, wish to play quietly and light weight, you might want to consider a Hohner Liliput.
These are pre-war German boxes, much smaller than most with small buttons and reduced spacing. A restored and retuned one should be in your price range. They were designed for hikers, sound sweet, can be played quietly but also loud enough to annoy the neighbours >:E
The oft recommended Pokerwork, wonderful box though it is, is not normally classified as quiet or mellow - rather the opposite. I have a Liliput and a "full-sized" Erica and can move between the two with only a short adjustment period.
You won't get one in Hobgoblin, though, but there are a couple of likely sources on this forum.
You might like to reverse the question. First find a tutor group - or indeed a local English music session in a pub. You are most likely to find DG boxes being played and their owners are most likely to be helpful.
Any decent box will be re-sellable.
Malcolm
-
If you don't know whether melodeon is right for you, I'd recommend not splashing out too much cash, try get a nice german D/G pokerwork, as far as I've been able to tell they don't really lose much in the way of value unless you break them! They're nice and light and a joy to play, and if you want to upgrade to something else you can just sell it!
-
If your hands are small you may find the pokerwork awkward, the Erica has the same reeds etc but in a more rounded and comfortable case. You would not go wrong with a used Erica but get the button travel restricted, if it has not already been sorted. Try to find one of the old black Ericas from the 80s. Lilliputs are fine but a bit specialised for a first box.
-
If you are interested, I do have a mellow D/G Pokerwork for sale, fitted with Binci reeds, that is. It's in great shape, very responsive with excellent compression. £460 + shipping to your neck of the woods.
Best,
Andre
-
I`d definately recommend a D/G Box for two reasons, 1:- it`s easier to play known english folk tunes on one in the right key 2:- if you don`t get on with the instrument it`s far far easier to sell a D/G here than any other key .
A used Delicia (cheapest value option) or Hohner Pokerwork or Erica (or earlier variant if its been fettled) would be my suggestion, the Hohners mentioned are keepers even if you want something with more Rows, voices or class after you`ve learned as they have a unique sound - many owners of multi-thousand £££ Italian Costalottis still have a Pokerwork in their arsenal and wouldn`t part with it ..
BTW the recent Chinese made Pokerworks are just as good as the older German ones bar the bellows tape (which doesn`t affect the playing) , in fact better in one respect, the pallets have proper felt damping so they don`t clatter when playing .
Liliputs are lovely but you`re paying a heavy premium for the size, cuteness factor and that it would have had a lot of work done to tune it to D/G and bring it up to full fettle (they`re something like around 70 years old)
-
Small hands should not be a particular problem with a melodeon, after all you have a range of an octave under 4 treble buttons, so the stretches are much smaller than on a piano keyboard. If you do find the treble button spacing a bit wide then it would be worth looking at any of the Italian makes which have a very slightly closer button spacing than Hohners. It is a very small difference though and I suspect most players don't notice it. In your price range a secondhand Saltarelle Bouebe would fit the bill.
As for choice of key and the restrictions that follow from that, the whole point of a melodeon is that it is a limited instrument, it is a joy to play within its limitations, and you can play in some other keys than the home keys. Taking DG as an example you can play in D and G obviously, also a lot a trad tunes in A major, and then the related minor keys and modes eg Am, Em, Bm are all reasonably straightforward, though once you leave the home keys the possibilities for playing a full bass part do fall away.
But it is a limited instrument, there are some things it can't do well, or even at all. I suspect Balkan music may be inaccessible though I've not tried, so may be wrong.
Choice of key depends on what you plan to play, but more importantly it depends on who you will play with or be taught by and what keys you need to play with them.
-
I have stumpy fingers and struggle with most melodeons(and had similar budget when I started). I find the tommy perfect fit but its out of your current price range.
If you want something small that can play in a range of keys have you considered an anglo concertina?*
Or else get something in D/G and as you learn you will find what you like/dislike while you learn the basics. Then you'll know if you *really* want to play all those genres.
*ducks for cover
-
There's a good English session in Walthamstow where the first half of the night is aimed at beginners- details are on the events board.
I've only been once as it is a bit out of the way for me, but I think it would be perfect for someone starting out who wanted to play some tunes in a supportive atmosphere.
-
I was very fortunate in that when I started playing someone lent me a Pokerwork. I already had a cheap East German concertina, but after a very short time I knew I wanted a melodeon. Being able to borrow one was fantastic. D/G Pokerwork led to a Dino Baffetti BP II.
My opinion is buy the best you can! It will serve you well while you learn & should retain some resale value. A Saltarelle Le Bouebe is a cracking box, possibly a bit pricey but good value in the long term.
I'd have another Dino Baffetti without question - I loved mine, it was so very playable.
Good luck whichever way you go!
-
there is a 12 month old as new castagnari lilly on ebay for a buy now proice of £950 . Top end of your price range but top class very small box. (sound clip on ebay). I have no connection whatsoever with seller etc etc.
george
-
"small hands" made me think Castagnari Lilly straight away, but then the OP's requirement for quiet and mellow made me think again.
But they are nice boxes, as long as you you don't want deep basses.
-
Much as I love my Morgane, I have found that I needed to pad the bass strap and brace my fingers against it to play it, so if your hands are particularly slim then you may find it a difficult box to play; otherwise it is a lovely box within your price range. I've been playing it about 8 months now.
From my own experience, you tend to just fall in love with a sound. I, like you, had a shortlist of boxes that had been recommended, narrowed that down by price, then went on YouTube and listened to people playing them. I found the Morgane had the sound that I wanted, and a look that I liked. It may sound a little mercenary and "girly" to pick a box by sound and looks at the finish, but if you are going to be needing to practice a lot, something that you are happy to be seen and heard with is a big plus.
I'm sure most (if not all) of the people you are likely to get hold of a melodeon from are more than happy for you to have a go at playing it.
I'm not far from London and I do come in from time to time to go to shows etc. Unlike some of the people here with advanced MAD (Melodeon Aquisition Disease) I have only the one box but you are welcome to have a go of it. I'm sure the nice chaps at Hobgoblin near Tottenham Court will let you try some of theirs too. They certainly did with me. :) I got my box from there and they were very helpful to a newbie. If you do decide to go down the second-hand route, I'd ask some of the stalwarts here to help you with it. Don't want a dog of a box, after all.
As an afterthought, in a few years when I am thinking of getting a second box, a Lilliput or Preciosa would be what I'm looking for. Hohner but more portable. :) I had a squeeze of what I think was a Lilliput at Melodeons and More.
-
At the top of your price range, it might be possible to pick up a second hand lilly or an excelsior mini, raucous little buggers, but played gently can be quite mellow.
-
Hi Snaffletaffle, welcome!
I too have small hands and was asking this same question just under 2 years ago. I ended up as LdT has with a Tommy, but the Black Pearl II ran it close and second hand should be within grasp.
One thing I do recommend is - go and try stuff, ask for a quick squeeze!
I was lucky enough to have Sidmouth festival within a 40 minute drive and went around *every* stall with my daughter and we tried everything in sight. When I say try, I mean pick up, put on and see if i could reach all the keys, then press a few and see how responsive it was.
i.e. did I press hard and not much happen, or press gently and it played?
Did it feel comfortable?
Were all the keys easily reachable?
I was unable to play a tune, but just doing as above gave me a good feel for what I bought, and I also discovered they all feel slightly different.
Generally people are only too pleased to talk, offer advice and a quick go on their box, so don't be shy.
Good luck :D
Q
-
If I was on your side of the pond, I would PM Rees or Lester or one of the other folks in the business and say: please send me the next decent, priced right, D/G you get.
These guys go out of their way to stay "uncommercial" on the forum, but these guys are the "go to".
-
Thank you all so much for your replies! It is really reassuring to get your advice when thinking about spending so much money on an instrument I know very little about.
Once I've got more time at the weekend I'll look into all of the boxes recommended here and try to narrow things down a bit. It turns out that I work very close to Hobgoblin so will pop round one lunchtime, although will feel a bit daft asking to try instruments that I don't even know how to play :D Oh well.
It's reassuring to know that it should be quite easy to sell on a D/G melodeon if it turns out not to be the instrument for me (although similar to MAD I think I have general instrument acquisition disease, so probably won't!)
-
Oh dear, I think I've just found exactly the sound I want and it comes out of a Dino Baffetti (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEckk_tAcHM&feature=related). :( Back to the drawing board I think...!
-
I’m a bit of a weedy girl with small hands so want to find a melodeon that is reasonably lightweight and compact. Ideally I’d like an instrument that can be played quietly and has a nice mellow tone.
Oh dear, I think I've just found exactly the sound I want and it comes out of a Dino Baffetti (Binci)
You must have changed your mind about "can be played quietly... nice mellow tone" and replaced it with "power to strip paint off a wall at 50 yards" >:E
The Baffetti Binci is a really lovely box if you want loud and bright.
-
You must have changed your mind about "can be played quietly... nice mellow tone" and replaced it with "power to strip paint off a wall at 50 yards"
I think we`re back to the Pokerwork ideal again ;D .. This is why I`d like a Lily, ability to burst eardrums in a tiny size and loads of control too .
-
I’m a bit of a weedy girl with small hands so want to find a melodeon that is reasonably lightweight and compact. Ideally I’d like an instrument that can be played quietly and has a nice mellow tone.
Oh dear, I think I've just found exactly the sound I want and it comes out of a Dino Baffetti (Binci)
You must have changed your mind about "can be played quietly... nice mellow tone" and replaced it with "power to strip paint off a wall at 50 yards" >:E
The Baffetti Binci is a really lovely box if you want loud and bright.
They are rather loud....in a piano accordion kinda way. *dives for cover*
-
I've been playing for about a year. I started on a Hohner Erica DG and just recently acquired a Dino Baffetti Binci II.
Yes, the Dino is loud but only if you let it be. It's very possible to play it quietly and sensitively. Having said that, I still regularly play my Erica and in fact there are certain tunes that I prefer on it. It's a very easy box to play and I would definitely recommend that you start with something like this before you start spending a lot of money. Like others have said, don't go the eBay route but rather, buy from someone like Lester Bailey or Martyn White. I've had dealings with both and you're in safe hands there. Not only that, they're both within reach of where you live so you can try before you buy.
Lots of luck on your "journey".
Les
-
They are rather loud....in a piano accordion kinda way. *dives for cover*
PAs are generally loud in a big and mushy kinda way, far from Raucous (unless its an oddball like the Hohner atlantic series which were designed to be Bright) , from Anahata`s description the Binci is loud in a Casti Lilly kinda way - the only PA I`ve encountered which Strips Paint is the original Rev-1 of the Hohner Student-1 which is basically a pre-Pokerwork with a makeshift keyboard jammed on anyway and sounds like the most hooligan of Hohner Melodeons
-
I, too, have quite small hands - I can't play a full-size double bass, for instance, because I just can't stretch far enoughm and even a 3/4 can sometimes be challenging - but my first box was an Erica and I had no problem with it whatever. I really don't think I could have picked a better box to start on.
Graham
-
You must have changed your mind about "can be played quietly... nice mellow tone" and replaced it with "power to strip paint off a wall at 50 yards" >:E
Perhaps 'mellow' wasn't the right word to use then - I think what I like about the Dino's sound is that it's quite pure and clean (does that make sense?) - but I suppose it's a moot point because I can't buy one anyway. Although perhaps if I'm very good at practising on whatever I do end up buying, I'll then be able to justify the upgrade!
-
Perhaps 'mellow' wasn't the right word to use then - I think what I like about the Dino's sound is that it's quite pure and clean (does that make sense?)
People are now going to start talking about voices and wet and dry tuning and musette, and your brain will shut down. Mine does. :D
I suppose you could always do the old "I want my haircut like this picture" and bring a recording of a sound that you like along with you and say "I want something that sounds like this!".
-
Perhaps 'mellow' wasn't the right word to use then - I think what I like about the Dino's sound is that it's quite pure and clean (
To a large extent the sound you are liking is to do with the way the instrument is tuned, with only a very slight tremolo (swing tuning) or no tremolo at all (dry tuning).
Hohners. eg Erica or pokerwork, famously come with a very strong tremolo, but this is something that can be changed for a small fraction of the difference in price between a Hohner and a Dino/Binci. (:)
For example here is Josephine Marsh playing a dry tuned Hohner (http://www.juzp.net/-OTczeDeJoYu-)
I sincerely hope I've not caused your brain to shut down! :-[
-
At the risk of going too far off topic, I admit I always thought my Hohner was on the dry side. I am either totally wrong about wet/dry, therefore, or Morganes are somewhat drier than most other Hohners.
My understanding (to share with those not as far down the path as I):
Voices - the number of reeds there are. So single voice = only one reed = only one note.
More than that are the number of different reeds playing at once.
Dry tuning - reeds tuned to the same note. The "wetter" the tuning, the further apart the reeds are tuned, so the more "wobble" or tremolo you get, so the note sounds like it's oscillating.
Correct?
-
Morganes are somewhat drier than most other Hohners.
Yes, that was why I mentioned Erica and pokerwork only. ;)
-
Dry tuning - reeds tuned to the same note. The "wetter" the tuning, the further apart the reeds are tuned, so the more "wobble" or tremolo you get, so the note sounds like it's oscillating.
Correct?
Correct.
Strictly speaking as the reeds are tuned further apart the wobble becomes faster, but that's perceived as "more".
-
Lilly defense:
True, the "stripping paint off the wall" accessory is built in. Comes in handy. Nothing raises hell like a Lilly!
What is nice, though, is that if you use the "Anahata" layout, you can transpose way down in G to where the Lilly becomes (almost) mellow.
Only drawback, you are down in the range of the basses.
-
Dragging this back to where we started. I run the session that was mentioned in Walthamstow -- on the second Tuesday. Details on posts here or at the Walthamstow folk club website -- http://www.walthamstowfolk.co.uk (http://www.walthamstowfolk.co.uk). You could come along and have a go on several melodeons there -- and if we know you're coming I could bring my Liliput and Steven's Pokerwork for you to play with as well.
I also have small stubby hands, which seriously limited my development as a pianist (almost as much as never practising!) and I struggle with even average sized boxes. So I now mostly play a (2-voice) Dino Baffetti Binci, which is probably not a helpful answer. I do love it though, for its combination of loudness and quietness, portability and ease of play. The new ones are far more than any beginner should be spending on a box; a second-hand one would probably hold its value reasonably well but will still be very pricey.
In terms of playing all sorts of different music for a reasonable outlay, the Liliput is unbeatable, because as retuned by eg Theo it's got two full chromatic octaves and can in theory play anything on the treble side. The buttons are very tiny though and take some getting used to. It should also be well within your budget fully restored. Having said that, just because it *can* play anything doesn't mean you'd want to, especially as a beginner. If you're interested in that approach, then an old-style wood Erika can have the same sort of scope with normal-sized buttons.
I still don't think I've remotely exhausted the scope of what is possible with an ordinary 21 key 8 bass D/G, and unless you're seriously into Eastern European music (in which case D/G melodeon is probably not the instrument for you) I wouldn't worry about shortage of things to play. Dave Mallinson has published I think 500 tunes (4 'mostly English' books and an Irish book), including a huge range of standard session tunes, that use only 14 notes between them; that's the reality of the folk music of these islands.
-
OMG also I have just realised that the youtube you linked to is the one of my box, from when I bought it! Pip really did do a wonderful job advertising it. I guess that means I've had it four years. Probably time I (a) had it tuned, and (b) deconstruct that video note for note to learn the arrangement.
-
To emphasise Theo's point, I've had two identical Dino Baffetti Black Pearl llls, (great boxes - still my most used amongst a fair collection) and they both sounded very different from one another, one having been re-tuned a bit 'wetter' than as-bought. But another point about tuning is that the 'wetter', the greater the 'cutting ability' of the box. Volume isn't simply a matter of construction or make.
Also, if you can, get a box with the thirds removed - or removeable with a button - from the bass chords. This makes the chords neutral - neither major nor minor - and opens up a huge cavern of possibilities. One of the great melodeon mysteries, to me, is why boxes are built with thirds in the chords if they can't be removed at will. It must add to the production cost, while achieving a disastrous limitation on the usefulness of the box! My interest in playing the box was almost at an end until I came by a box with no thirds. Now I'm an addict, and have permanently removed the thirds from all my boxes. There's a small reduction in bass volume, but it's a small price to pay for such a huge increase in the musical versatility of the instrument. It's still possible to play a big range of music with thirds in the chords, but without them you can add all manner of colourings to your melody.
-
Dave Mallinson has published I think 500 tunes (4 'mostly English' books and an Irish book), including a huge range of standard session tunes, that use only 14 notes between them; that's the reality of the folk music of these islands.
I think 14 notes is an exaggeration... there are only 12 in the chromatic scale! In fact a D/G without accidentals has only 8 notes, as far as I can see. Which adds weight to what you are saying.
OTOH it should be said that the folk music of these islands does get played in keys other than those having one or two sharps - just not by yer average D/G box player. (:)
-
Dave Mallinson has published I think 500 tunes (4 'mostly English' books and an Irish book), including a huge range of standard session tunes, that use only 14 notes between them; that's the reality of the folk music of these islands.
I think 14 notes is an exaggeration... there are only 12 in the chromatic scale! In fact a D/G without accidentals has only 8 notes, as far as I can see.
I think Mally and Alison were counting notes in different octaves, not just note names.
Keeping the whole range (lowest to highest) restricted makes the selection of tunes accessible to the maximum number of players.
And though I'm an advocate of boxes going down to the G below middle C, I'm well aware that you have have a perfectly good tune book with nothing going below middle D.
-
I think Mally and Alison were counting notes in different octaves, not just note names.
Ah, thanks, I was assuming they meant 2 diatonic rows each having 7 notes. (I had to use three hands to check that in D & Gmaj, D --> b' does indeed make 14 notes.) ;D
-
The fourteen notes are indeed D to high B in a G scale plus C#, and of *course* that leaves you with notes you can't play and a desire to go lower (though possibly not often higher on the box at least. But isn't it great to be able to play so many things? Having watched my son enjoy playing saxophone hugely until the inevitable point in the teaching where they started pressing him to extend his range into notes that are difficult to play, at which point he lost all heart, I do wonder whether a lot of music teaching sort of misses the point here.
-
To a large extent the sound you are liking is to do with the way the instrument is tuned, with only a very slight tremolo (swing tuning) or no tremolo at all (dry tuning).
Hohners. eg Erica or pokerwork, famously come with a very strong tremolo, but this is something that can be changed for a small fraction of the difference in price between a Hohner and a Dino/Binci. (:)
Also, if you can, get a box with the thirds removed - or removeable with a button - from the bass chords. This makes the chords neutral - neither major nor minor - and opens up a huge cavern of possibilities.
This is particularly useful - thanks! It's good to know that the sound I'm after doesn't necessarily come down to the make (and price) of the box. I had heard people talking about removing the thirds on YouTube and didn't realise what they meant, so it's good to work one more thing out...
-
Must admit I'm tempted for my second melodeon (in a while, I admit!) to get one with accidentals and the thirds removed. It's true to say that you don't know what you want until you've been playing for a while, though. Will still be keeping my old one though, for when I want to play in D/G, with thirds and low notes. :D
-
Must admit I'm tempted for my second melodeon (in a while, I admit!) to get one with accidentals and the thirds removed. It's true to say that you don't know what you want until you've been playing for a while, though. Will still be keeping my old one though, for when I want to play in D/G, with thirds and low notes. :D
My D/G has a stop to remove the thirds from the basses, and while I do use it from time to time (usually in minor modal tunes) I have to admit that most of my playing is done with all reeds firing. I do agree that "neutral" chords open many more harmonic avenues, but I find something inherently unsatisfactory in their unresolved nature. Incidentally, it's a 21+4 with 4th button start and extra low notes (a full 3 octaves), which I think gives me the best of several worlds.
Graham
-
I was never too sure about a thirds stop, never used one, couldn't imagine the sound etc etc.
I now have a box with such a stop. Like Graham I seem to leave it down so that the thirds are in, but haven't had it that long so am still experimenting. As a total beginner I'd not worry too much about this yet, there's plenty other things to think about.
My only modification is to get my original box moved to a 4th button start, enabling me to have an octave below the normal G on the treble clef ( that is normally the 3rd button ) As a lot of written tunes were collected and originally fiddle tunes they often go down to low G but as the standard melodeon may not have this, get played up an octave.
To get this modification you tend to loose the top 2 buttons at the knee end ( really high notes ), famously useful, according to John Kirkpatrick for nothing more than calling in the dog!
Low notes are a useful thing to have given the option.
Q
-
I`m thinking of removing the thirds on the Pokerwork and Definately the comedy Popeye whistles where the low notes should be (I`ve come to hate high accidentals down there) , if they`re going to put accidentals on D/G boxes why don`t they replace the useless ultrasonics at the top end with them ?
-
if they`re going to put accidentals on D/G boxes why don`t they replace the useless ultrasonics at the top end with them ?
Adrian Murfitt (Wide Glide Band) has accidentals at both ends of the rows which is a brilliant idea I might try sometime. It means on a D/G box that the accidentals go from a low Eâ™ to a high Bâ™, and all the accidentals are physically closer to the buttons nearest them in pitch. Plus, of course, there's a low F natural for playing D minor tunes, and a high G♯ for playing in A.
-
I like the idea of that very much, except I think I'd find reaching down with my little finger to play the high accidentals a bit hard to adjust to so both the boxes I've ordered are going to have the high accidentals on 2 buttons next to the main rows, (mini half row?, quarter row?), and will also have each pair flipped over to the opposite button.
That's for an F/Bb and an E/A. I wouldn't do it on a D/G because I'm not, in the words of JK, a dog-hating lunatic so I have no use for the top octave of a D/G. ;D
*edit* Is this starting to drift?, maybe worth forking...
-
Lilly defense:
True, the "stripping paint off the wall" accessory is built in. Comes in handy. Nothing raises hell like a Lilly!
What is nice, though, is that if you use the "Anahata" layout, you can transpose way down in G to where the Lilly becomes (almost) mellow.
Only drawback, you are down in the range of the basses.
The lilly is very easy to make more civilised/mellow. Just tape over the 4 holes in the centre of the reedblock .
george
-
A box worthy of consideration is the GABBANELLI 'POCKET'. Superior to a Pokerwork IMHO.
http://www.londonaccordion.com/index.php/new-accordions/gabbanelli-pocket-dg.htm
Listed as B/C, but I have seen this exact model in D/G.
-
A box worthy of consideration is the GABBANELLI 'POCKET'. Superior to a Pokerwork IMHO.
No disrespect, but for around twice as much I rather hope it would be.
-
A box worthy of consideration is the GABBANELLI 'POCKET'. Superior to a Pokerwork IMHO.
Listed as B/C, but I have seen this exact model in D/G.
Is it better than other "Granders" such as the Salty Bouebe or the £800 Sandpiper though ?