Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on June 19, 2012, 03:47:12 PM

Title: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 19, 2012, 03:47:12 PM
Just thought I'd share this as it might help someone else out there.

Like every beginner when I first started I struggled with using the air button properly until one day it just clicked.

Today I was playing my Dino Baffetti and found I was really struggling with this technique on a piece that I could play really well on my Erica.  Anyway, to cut a long story short, I shortened the left shoulder strap to bring the bass side up and bingo!

So I've now done this on all my boxes i.e. right shoulder strap longer than left and it instantly feels like I've got more control.  Obviously the Dino is a very different box to the Erica - on one hand it's far more responsive etc. but I guess I've got used to my nice worn-in sloppy Hohner.  I guess this is the downside of owning several melodeons!!

Any thoughts?
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on June 19, 2012, 04:06:53 PM
Oh, the strap debate again :-D

Yes, it would seem that most two-strappers seem to tighten the left strap more than the right ...

then again (just to keep the correct tone of the debate), if god had meant us to play with two straps then I would have put two straps on my melodeons :-P

Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: george garside on June 19, 2012, 04:10:12 PM
Oh, the strap debate again :-D

Yes, it would seem that most two-strappers seem to tighten the left strap more than the right ...

then again (just to keep the correct tone of the debate), if god had meant us to play with two straps then I would have put two straps on my melodeons :-P

He must have cos I 've  always put two staps on mine!

george ;D
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: MartinW on June 19, 2012, 10:21:37 PM
Until recently I had always found 2 straps to be 1 too many. I'd tried it on various melodeons over the years, but it never felt right and I always went back to 1 strap.

However in the last few weeks I have tried using 2 straps on the melodeon I made on the course in Yeovil, courtesy of Emmanuel. On this box 2 straps feels right. I think this is because it is heavier than others I have owned - and I still don't like 2 straps on my other melodeons.

So, as far as this theological debate goes, after years as a devout follower of the single strap creed I have suddenly found myself straddling the divide. Oh, and to return to the original point, the left strap has to be shorter for it to work for me.
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Lester on June 19, 2012, 10:31:39 PM
Something I discovered on my Emmanuel 1 row course was that sets of melodeon straps from Italian suppliers have two different length straps. Always worth checking when adjusting your straps that they are the right way round.
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: ladydetemps on June 19, 2012, 10:37:03 PM
Ah, the number of straps debate. I started off with two but now use one. Why? I'll give you two reasons and they are below my chin.
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on June 20, 2012, 11:05:25 PM
Have you the wrong number of arms then?
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Sandy on June 20, 2012, 11:49:35 PM
Even with just one strap there are different ways of 'wearing' your melodeon  ::)

I fidget a lot with the melodeon position as I just don't have something that feels totally right...yet !

Cheers,

Sandy
 (:)
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: AnnC on June 21, 2012, 08:39:14 AM

I fidget a lot with the melodeon position as I just don't have something that feels totally right...yet !
(:)

   .... visions of the Fast Show tailors Ken and Kenneth turning up at Folk festivals offering a bespoke melodeon strap fitting service ....   Suits you Sir  .. or Madam  ;D 
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Lester on June 21, 2012, 08:41:55 AM
  Suits you Sir   

<pedantry alert>

That will be Suit you Sir

</pedantry alert>
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: AnnC on June 21, 2012, 08:54:34 AM
That will be Suit you Sir

    mea culpa  ;D
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 21, 2012, 01:20:51 PM
That will be Suit you Sir

    mea culpa  ;D

This must be the poshest forum in the whole world!! ;)
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 21, 2012, 01:34:01 PM
This must be the poshest forum in the whole world!!
not quite (http://www.theposhforum.co.uk/)

Ah, I see what you did there!! ;D ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: pikey on June 21, 2012, 09:23:09 PM
this season I'll be mostly wearing.......

A melodeon with 1 or 2 straps!.
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: AnnC on June 21, 2012, 10:04:09 PM
 ;D  not sure but the Melodeon player for  Bob Flemming's A**e  Morris Dancers (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ksSwGyXkASs&feature=g-hist)  might be using two  :||: ;D
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: pikey on June 22, 2012, 04:07:46 PM
LOL !

I've just got my new Lilliput to play with, and tried to play it standing up.

I'v been a single strapper for the last 36 years, so I tried a single strap - the d*amn thing is so light and tiny, that the box kept drooping at a funny angle!  So I remembered this thread, and for the first time in my life used two straps - the left being shorter.

Hey presto! I can now play the Lilliput standing up!  I think I'll revert to single straps for sitting down though, it looks better..... ;D
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Anahata on June 23, 2012, 08:22:36 AM
Two straps standing and one sitting is what I do too. I even use a backstrap, though the Oakwood is tiny and light. My shoulders are very slopey and straps tend to slip off given half a chance.
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Adam-T on June 23, 2012, 08:34:59 AM
Single for button boxes as I always sit playing them,  two for ALL PAs even tiny ones as I always stand playing them (don`t ask why, Habit I guess from the Gigs I`ve done)

The only exception is that Orfeo (wide B/C Box) which I find easier with two straps regardless as it has stradella . I have played the Pokerwork and 1 row 1040 standing and still use 1 strap though I`d not want to try it with a bigger box like the club3 - the Corso has only a single strap loop system from the factory for some reason, but then the 1040 and 114 of the same era had NONE

I hate backstraps, if you set the main ones right you shouldn`t need one on even the bulkiest of PAs - unless you`ve got overly sloping shoulders of course as Anahata has mentioned.
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: george garside on June 23, 2012, 10:07:39 AM
strps slipping of shoulder can also caused or at least contributed to be the type of strap and the type of shirt or whatever upper garment is being worn.  I use 60cm wide straps on serenellini 2 row. 4 inch on 3 row and 45/50 cm on Lilly (what it omes with)  All are padded andcloth faced on the inner side so have a reasonable coeficient of friction.  A shirt of a slightly course texture rather than dead smooth also can make a difference. IT might also be influenced more by  an upright or a drooping stance rather than sloping shoulders. Head up & shoulders back works well for me.  However if all else fails a back strap  can save the day.

  And for what its worth  I personaly can't see the point in  using only one strap whilst sitting having gone to the trouble of carefully setting up 2 straps  to provide maaximum comfort.

george
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 23, 2012, 10:28:01 AM
going back to Sandy's point up there ^ ^ I seem to go through stages of leaving straps alone, then having a day of playing with them to see if I can improve the position. It never ceases to amaze me what a difference one hole adjustment on a strap can mean to the position of the melodeon.

My left hand bass strap has a wheel adjuster and I'm still playing with that too. Though easy to use and infinitely adjustable, I wonder if over the course of time it self adjusts and perhaps slackens slightly. I do keep it fairly tight to prevent the whole bass end from slipping down mid-tune.
Any thoughts?
Q
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: george garside on June 23, 2012, 10:59:28 AM
all the wheel adjusters that I have had hve gradually readjusted themselves! The amount of slack of the bass strap is very much down to personal choice. I adjust it so that the strap is lightly but definately pressing on the wrist i.e. I can feel its presence.  Similer with velcro type adjuster , just pull it through until it is touching the wrist and velcro it.  On non adjustablepones its a questionn of getting it as near as possible ( if it isn't ok the way the makeer did it) bymaking a couple of new holes in the strap for the screws but it only needs a little difference in screw position to make a big diference in the feel of it so new holes not more than about half an inch from originals as a starting point. Alternatively just arch the wrist to take up the slack.

george
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: IanD on June 23, 2012, 12:06:23 PM
strps slipping of shoulder can also caused or at least contributed to be the type of strap and the type of shirt or whatever upper garment is being worn.  I use 60cm wide straps on serenellini 2 row. 4 inch on 3 row and 45/50 cm on Lilly (what it omes with)  All are padded andcloth faced on the inner side so have a reasonable coeficient of friction.  A shirt of a slightly course texture rather than dead smooth also can make a difference. IT might also be influenced more by  an upright or a drooping stance rather than sloping shoulders. Head up & shoulders back works well for me.  However if all else fails a back strap  can save the day.

  And for what its worth  I personaly can't see the point in  using only one strap whilst sitting having gone to the trouble of carefully setting up 2 straps  to provide maaximum comfort.

george
I never have a problem with one strap slipping off either standing or sitting, but then I have it set long so the box is well over to the left and braced against the strap by the heel of my hand (standing) or my right thumb and right thigh (crossed over left leg) when sitting. This also brings the right arm/hand around more to your front and the left arm straighter and lower which I find more comfortable and less tiring (stronger arm muscles are used for pushing/pulling bellows).

Personally I can't see why you'd want to use two straps when sitting having gone to the trouble of carefully setting up one strap to provide maximum comfort ;-)

Ian
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Mike Hirst on June 23, 2012, 12:26:10 PM

From the evidence above it would appear that it is standard practice for Swiss (Orgeli?) players to use a single strap looped over the upper arm just above the elbow.
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: oggiesnr on June 23, 2012, 12:46:52 PM
  • http://youtu.be/_joDidn6F-4
  • http://youtu.be/DcJqV8JJTv8
  • http://youtu.be/SNvrOCw_tXE

From the evidence above it would appear that it is standard practice for Swiss (Orgeli?) players to use a single strap looped over the upper arm just above the elbow.

Ignoring the strap position for a moment, is it my imagination or are the bass buttons flat on the bass end rather than being at 90 degrees to the end as on a melodeon?

Steve
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: george garside on June 23, 2012, 12:47:19 PM
strps slipping of shoulder can also caused or at least contributed to be the type of strap and the type of shirt or whatever upper garment is being worn.  I use 60cm wide straps on serenellini 2 row. 4 inch on 3 row and 45/50 cm on Lilly (what it omes with)  All are padded andcloth faced on the inner side so have a reasonable coeficient of friction.  A shirt of a slightly course texture rather than dead smooth also can make a difference. IT might also be influenced more by  an upright or a drooping stance rather than sloping shoulders. Head up & shoulders back works well for me.  However if all else fails a back strap  can save the day.

  And for what its worth  I personaly can't see the point in  using only one strap whilst sitting having gone to the trouble of carefully setting up 2 straps  to provide maaximum comfort.

george
I never have a problem with one strap slipping off either standing or sitting, but then I have it set long so the box is well over to the left and braced against the strap by the heel of my hand (standing) or my right thumb and right thigh (crossed over left leg) when sitting. This also brings the right arm/hand around more to your front and the left arm straighter and lower which I find more comfortable and less tiring (stronger arm muscles are used for pushing/pulling bellows).

Personally I can't see why you'd want to use two straps when sitting having gone to the trouble of carefully setting up one strap to provide maximum comfort ;-)

Ian



Indeed - what I was meaning was  that I can't see the point of doing standing and sitting with a different strap arrangement   

george ;)
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Mike Hirst on June 23, 2012, 01:08:23 PM
  • http://youtu.be/_joDidn6F-4
  • http://youtu.be/DcJqV8JJTv8
  • http://youtu.be/SNvrOCw_tXE

From the evidence above it would appear that it is standard practice for Swiss (Orgeli?) players to use a single strap looped over the upper arm just above the elbow.

Ignoring the strap position for a moment, is it my imagination or are the bass buttons flat on the bass end rather than being at 90 degrees to the end as on a melodeon?

Steve

Yes
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 24, 2012, 10:00:34 AM
Back to the strap adjusting thing:
I confess to twiddling my straps on occasions in an effort to improve, or sometimes adjust then go back to the previous adjustment. I wonder if it's something that goes away in time?
i.e. as you become more comfortable playing and maybe used to playing other boxes as opposed to just the one you learnt on, you don't need to get it 'absolutely right' you can tolerate differences in straps much more so it all settles down.
Just an idle thought..............
Q
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Ellisteph on June 24, 2012, 10:58:56 AM
Two straps with a backstrap when standing gives me a feeling of security. Doing up the backstrap is another matter - probably easier for the more practiced female of the species.
Incidentally, does anyone know where I could get a new pair of Salterelle straps? The stuffing is coming out of mine and I wouds like to replace them with matching ones if possible. On-line searches have only brought up leather 'Mally' straps or piano accordion straps.
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Lester on June 24, 2012, 11:13:18 AM
Two straps with a backstrap when standing gives me a feeling of security. Doing up the backstrap is another matter - probably easier for the more practiced female of the species.
Incidentally, does anyone know where I could get a new pair of Salterelle straps? The stuffing is coming out of mine and I wouds like to replace them with matching ones if possible. On-line searches have only brought up leather 'Mally' straps or piano accordion straps.

Charlie Marshall can probably sort you out

http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Shoulder_Straps.html (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Shoulder_Straps.html)
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Ellisteph on June 24, 2012, 11:19:58 AM
Two straps with a backstrap when standing gives me a feeling of security. Doing up the backstrap is another matter - probably easier for the more practiced female of the species.
Incidentally, does anyone know where I could get a new pair of Salterelle straps? The stuffing is coming out of mine and I wouds like to replace them with matching ones if possible. On-line searches have only brought up leather 'Mally' straps or piano accordion straps.

Charlie Marshall can probably sort you out


Thanks Lester. An astonishing choice there  - Ill take time to browse.

http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Shoulder_Straps.html (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Shoulder_Straps.html)
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: pikey on June 24, 2012, 04:38:12 PM
I've used the same straps on my pokerwork for the last 36 years - two straps, both same length, both go over my right shoulder.

One is a 1.5 inch wide white cloth belt, which came off my dad's tennis shorts.
The other is 3/4 inch wide blue Troll climbing tape, strong enough to take ,y weight, just in case the tennis belt breaks (which it still hasn't done after 36 years of frequent abuse and neglect).

Both are tied to metal pipe clips, which are screwed to the box.

All because my pokerwork didnt come with straps, or brackets, it was xmas eve when I got it and I wanted to play it at new year, the shops were shut, and I was a tight fisted young b*ggar anyway!

Tee hee.........
 

Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on June 24, 2012, 09:18:12 PM
A friend of mine has two perfectly good straps, but always puts both over the same shoulder, standing or sitting! She says she learned it when a beginner (You know who
I mean pikey?).  ???
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: pikey on June 24, 2012, 11:40:41 PM
is that why Wendy sits like she does, with both bra straps over the same shoulder? ........
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Owen Woods on June 25, 2012, 12:51:38 PM
Ignoring the strap position for a moment, is it my imagination or are the bass buttons flat on the bass end rather than being at 90 degrees to the end as on a melodeon?

Steve

Yep. See here for more details:

http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/05/30/inside-and-out-part-3-schwyzerorgeli/
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: oggiesnr on June 25, 2012, 03:44:49 PM
Ignoring the strap position for a moment, is it my imagination or are the bass buttons flat on the bass end rather than being at 90 degrees to the end as on a melodeon?

Steve

Yep. See here for more details:

http://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/05/30/inside-and-out-part-3-schwyzerorgeli/

Thank you, I'd missed that edition of your blog  :|bl

Good stuff.

Steve
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: dave t on July 06, 2012, 08:17:12 PM
Something I discovered on my Emmanuel 1 row course was that sets of melodeon straps from Italian suppliers have two different length straps. Always worth checking when adjusting your straps that they are the right way round.

I'd never noticed this. I checked on my Saltarelle and they were indeed the wrong way round. I've swapped them now and it's made a big difference.

Cheers, Dave
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 13, 2012, 08:32:50 PM
Thought I'd re-awaken this thread after I had something of a revelation last night.
After  :M we  :|||: and I was sat beside a good friend joining in, starting a few tunes and listening/picking out snatches when I didn't know them.
I often end up bent over with my head in the grille trying to find the notes. Then realised if I pushed the end of the keyboard firmly so the grille was under my nose, as opposed to the right hand side of my chest I could hear myself much easier without some very odd looking contortions (:)
I slackend  off my right hand strap and tightened the left had one to bring the grille more central. Just tweaked it tonight and it feels so much better. Normally, sat at home I hear the sound I'm making, but in amongst a session it matters so much more, and so the position of the place where the sound comes out of is more critical to hear yourself.
Basic thought but......I've only just twigged it!
Q.
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: george garside on July 13, 2012, 08:54:03 PM
the longer right strap & shorter left so as to bring the kyboard approx under the chin is standard  practice for larger accordions and works just as well for even a lilly.  A big benefit is that the right arm & elbow can be (more or less) down  ones right hand side rather than   flapping around as if attempting to take off. this in turn puts the right haand in a nice relaxed position  with either the thumb ( on button boxes) or thepal of the hand on piano & continentals resting gently on the edge of teh keybord  and able to move up & down with minimum  efort & without any contortions!.  On larger boxes  (probably 60 bass upwarrds it eenables the body of the instrument to rest on the left knee so taking some of the weight if playing seated without sacrificing the loctional benefit of 2 straps. 

Getting the setting just right for  personal anatomy  takes  a bit of fine tuning .

george
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 13, 2012, 10:02:25 PM
indeed George.....and I had a fine tune up last night in both respects!
Q
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Sandy on July 14, 2012, 10:56:27 PM
As a sat down one strap player I find it interesting that, as time goes by, the strap needs to be longer. The box is moving further away from me gradually as time goes by.

Sandy
 (:)
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 15, 2012, 09:14:27 AM
Perhaps over time you're tuning in more and more to your particular reeds so don't need to be quite so up close and personal with it.
Also maybe the more you play the more you'll unconsciously know where your fingers are going so don't require as much feedback from listening to what you're playing....... but it's only a guess!
Looking at my friend who was sat beside me on monday night, he took up melodeon in about '76, so by now he just knows where he's going and what his fingers are playing. He's also annoyingly good!
I keep reminding myself something I think Theo said after I'd been playing for a month or two - it takes time.
Never a truer word said.........
Q
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: arty on July 15, 2012, 09:43:41 AM
As a sat down one strap player I find it interesting that, as time goes by, the strap needs to be longer. The box is moving further away from me gradually as time goes by.

Sandy
 (:)

I am having the same problem too....only, in my case it's too much chocolate!
Title: Re: The importance of getting your straps right
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 15, 2012, 09:51:22 AM
 ;D
hale fellow choc-a-holic!
Q
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal