Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ButtonBoy on June 25, 2012, 04:59:30 AM

Title: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: ButtonBoy on June 25, 2012, 04:59:30 AM
Hello,

I'm new here and have been messing around with a Scarlatti Rosso B/C two row melodeon.  I purchased the Hanrahan book and CD entitled "The Box" which has provided some good beginner information.  What has me confused, however, is the fact that the music book and CD illustrate songs in the keys of D and G primarily.  This makes for pretty tricky playing for a beginner and I'm wondering if it's "fair" to simply transpose the songs into C or B.  Why have a B/C box if the bulk of the music is in D or G?  Is there a short history as to why the B/C is used more for Irish folk music?

Thanks!....It sure is fun to mess around with, and quite more difficult technically than our Soprani piano accordion.

ButtonBoy
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Bill Young on June 25, 2012, 08:51:08 AM
The standard history of the BC box in Irish music is in Stephen Chambers' article, here. (http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=2347&mode=threaded&pid=22950)

You need to be able to play in G and D (and A and C) because those are the main keys for folk music, presumably to suit fiddles.
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: george garside on June 25, 2012, 10:10:48 AM
Hi & welcome to melnet.  playing in dg (and a and maybe F) are as Bill says ore or less essential if you are going to play with others.   If you have any previous experience on a piano type keyboard  it may help to visualise the C row as containing the white notes  and the  B row the black notes.  Then just as on a piano keyboard the bulk of the business will be done on the white notes  with just one black note for G, 2 for D and 3 for A.  It can help to practice  the scale in C on the C row over both octaves to begin with as this will  familierise you with the push/pull sequence aalong the whole of the C row.  For G its just a question of starting on G ,following the push pull seqence and nipping over to the B row for the F#.  Then practice scales in G until reasonably proficient ( and a few tunes as well!) before moving on to D. same goes then on to A.

george
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: TomB on June 25, 2012, 12:52:08 PM
Why have a B/C box if the bulk of the music is in D or G?  Is there a short history as to why the B/C is used more for Irish folk music

ButtonBoy

Welcome to the forum, use the forum search to find past discussions on different key systems ( DG BC C#D etc.). The idea of playing BC (semi tone tuned) as opposed to DG (quint tuned) is that BC, or in fact any semitone tuned accordion, has all twelve notes available (whites and blacks). Not all players favour BC as not all players favour GD. I've seen plenty of good players making irish music sound great on a GD box. I'm a BC player but only because that's the first box I obtained many years ago so that's what I learnt on, now I can't see any reason to change. I have tried different systems and different keys but still come back to BC.
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Strigulino on June 25, 2012, 01:14:06 PM
My understanding is that most UK folk music is in D or G, as has been said, because those are keys easily played in our traditional instruments - Morris for example is only recently played on melodeon - before about 150 years ago it would have been things like fiddles, wind instruments and drums, as I understand it.

The point of a box tuned to keys only a semitone apart is that it is therefore a bit more like a piano keyboard, in that you have more half notes available, so can play all the "diddly diddly" Irish bits. 

So yes, my D/G box is perhaps more intuitive to play, but there are a few tunes (Bluebell Polka is my standout example) where I literally CANNOT play the fourth part.  It jumps in key from G to D to G again, and then goes into C just for a laugh at the end and I can't play an F natural. I have a Hohner Morgane with low notes and no accidentals.  All the tunings have their advantages and disadvantages. 

I think a lot of it depends where you live.  If you are in Scotland or Ireland, say, you will be well off with a B/C box as a lot of the people you meet will play that system.  D/G you're going to see a lot in England.  C/F in Germany.  I'm generalising of course, but there is a pattern.  I think you have to get stuck in with a box and play before you find out what you do and don't like, and then perhaps keep B/C or change to something else when you know what you want. 
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Lester on June 25, 2012, 02:09:21 PM
My understanding is that most UK folk music is PLAYED in D or G,


I've corrected that for you  >:E

If you look at the original manuscripts many other keys abound (C in East Anglia for instance) and many tunes sound better in their collected keys.

But you are correct mostly we play in G and D and E Minor
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Strigulino on June 25, 2012, 04:12:25 PM
I stand corrected.  Presumably the keys that things were written in changed as fashions in folk instruments changed?
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Theo on June 25, 2012, 04:37:31 PM
And from place to place.   The fiddle players round here love to play in a wide range of keys,  us melodeon players just have to fit in as best we can.
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: ButtonBoy on June 26, 2012, 12:44:14 AM
Hope I'm doing this follow-up correctly.

Thanks for all responses.  I suspected this was the case.....that I should learn the scales for D and G using both button rows.  One last concern:  It seems this would also imply that the bass/chord left-hand tunings are useless when playing in D or G....probably pretty obvious, but just checking to see if I'm missing something.

Sure is fun to play, I must admit.  Can't say the dogs like it too much, but it's summer and they like to be in the basement anyway.....  :P
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Anahata on June 26, 2012, 08:06:08 AM
One last concern:  It seems this would also imply that the bass/chord left-hand tunings are useless when playing in D or G

Many B/C boxes have basses/chords set up for playing in G and D, but the arrangement isn't optimal because you don't have all the chords you need in both directions. You'll have to find out exactly which chords you have and how they fit with the right hand notes.

So maybe not useless, but perhaps restricted.
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Bill Young on June 26, 2012, 08:35:23 AM
  One last concern:  It seems this would also imply that the bass/chord left-hand tunings are useless when playing in D or G
You should have some bass and major chords usable when playing in D and G. Your left hand arrangement is probably one shown on the keyboard layouts on the main website (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,keyboard_2_row.html) - either this one (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/BC21tradbass.gif) or this one. (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/BC21modernbass.gif)
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: george garside on June 26, 2012, 09:11:09 AM
Bill is right , you should have some major chords thatwill go with D & G keys , However  unlike those on a aDG the BC chordss, other than when playing in C can't be used to drive a rhythm or play an um pa accompanyment throughout the proceedings.  Instead theytend to be used to highlight a particular treble note from time to time where everything is going in theright direction.  Many BC plaayers of Irish music  just don't use the bass atall. I would recommend that you  get the hang of the treble scales and a few tunes and then experiment with 'dotting' a bit of bass in  here & there and keep in mind that its OK not to use the bass  atall  or to not use it a great deal.

george
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: ButtonBoy on June 27, 2012, 08:34:40 PM
Thanks everyone! 

When I bought the thing I thought "Two rows of buttons?....how hard can that be??!"  Looks like I've got some practicing to do.  I think the "Talent Contest" at the local county fair will have to wait until next year.....unless they want to hear me practicing scales....

Best wishes!

Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Gromit on July 12, 2012, 07:31:43 PM
I started with the Hanrahan book (with a tape) - it was all that was available but there's enough info there to explain all you need to get going and with stuff about basses
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: deltasalmon on July 20, 2012, 08:09:14 PM
Not a question about the basses on a B/C box but a question about the treble side...

I noticed the only duplicate notes on a B/C box are the B and E. How do most people approach this? Play the B and E on the C-row unless you really need one in the reverse bellows direction? Do you pick one key for B and E and just stick to that? or does it pretty much just vary tune to tune?
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: deltasalmon on July 20, 2012, 08:10:22 PM
I'll add that I have the Hanrahan book but didn't notice any mention of playing those notes with a certain key / bellows direction
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Gromit on July 21, 2012, 08:12:42 AM
Play the B and E on the C-row unless you really need one in the reverse bellows direction? - generally yes for me
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: george garside on July 21, 2012, 01:21:52 PM
The push B & E ( or sometimes just one of them) are very useful when playing in A as they  help prevent undue bellows opening.  Egstart tunes like Athol Highlanders, Cock of the North etc  use the push e  .  In D the push B can be very handy egin The Rowan Tree.

It all depends very much on the particular bit of the particular tune   It also helps to know where you are coming from and where you aregoing!.  The easiest way to get the hang of it  isa to experiment  by trying both eg in dawning of the day (  in Hanahans book)  play as far as the B and play it on the C row.Then start again and try it on the B row.  Do this on all your tunes with both E's & B's  and this will help to develop an intuitive 'feel' for which alternative to go for in any particular situation as making the right choice  can both help bellows control and /or ease a partiacular bit of fingering. 
Yopu've got 2 alternative sso it makes sense to explore their use fully and then make your own cinformed choice of what to do.

george
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: deltasalmon on July 21, 2012, 01:38:21 PM
Thanks for the advice! That's interesting what you said about playing in A because so far I've been trying to play certain tunes that I know on my tenor banjo and I noticed that two of the tunes that I tried and had trouble with (the foxhunter's reel and atholl highlanders) are in A and my big issue was the bellows opening up too much which made me ask.

I'll experiment with the E's and B's and see how that helps :)
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: george garside on July 21, 2012, 02:33:20 PM
just to give you an idea of what to aim for I have just played athol highlanders in A on a cheap chinese box  mostly with bellows zero to 4 inches going briefly out  to about 8 inches in third part of tune.  This was using push B and push E throughout.

george
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: boxer on August 07, 2012, 12:19:07 AM
There's just one really useful piece of advice in Hanrahan's book which, as I lost my copy, I must paraphrase: "only use the first three fingers on the treble keyboard"

If I were to be asked to edit the book, I would make the following amendment: "only use the first two fingers, the third if you have to, and never the fourth"

The fact is, you don't play the B/C in the way you play D/G.  The right hand must be very mobile and (in my experience) too many fingers just get in the way.   
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Keithypete. on August 07, 2012, 12:51:54 AM

If I were to be asked to edit the book, I would make the following amendment: "only use the first two fingers, the third if you have to, and never the fourth"


This is not sound advice. It is not helpful to beginner to be told to just use two fingers. IMHO.
I use three, & sometimes four, depending on the tunes.
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Gromit on August 07, 2012, 01:52:50 PM
"use three, & sometimes four, depending on the tunes."

Same here - three and sometimes four.

I did a B/C workshop with Luke Daniels (a respected box player over here) where he recomended using the fourth finger in certain situations - it opens up more options and Damien Connolly uses the fourth in his tutor.
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: nfldbox on August 07, 2012, 02:22:17 PM
Oh, no. Not the number of fingers again. Many great box players never use the pinky and many do. I was talking to an excellent player who said, "It is ridiculous not to use the fingers you have. Would Heifitz not have used his pinky?" I just took a workshop from a superb player who said stick to three as "too many fingers get in the way." I use my pinky and shall continue to use it until I become absolutely amazing. I shall die before that time but that is a whole other problem.
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Keithypete. on August 07, 2012, 02:33:32 PM
My post wasn't meant to start this debate off again. But I don't think advising a new-ish box-player to just use two fingers is good at all.  3 or 4 - whatever, but 2 seems a bit limited, and likely to make it more difficult than it needs to be. Use both thumbs if you like, I don't think it is against the rules.
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Stiamh on August 07, 2012, 02:47:39 PM
I noticed the only duplicate notes on a B/C box are the B and E. How do most people approach this? Play the B and E on the C-row unless you really need one in the reverse bellows direction? Do you pick one key for B and E and just stick to that? or does it pretty much just vary tune to tune?

There are two reasons for using (or not using) the "magic notes" on a semitone box.

The first is phrasing & bellows direction. You can use the reversal in the outer row to save a bellows direction change, or to make the tune flow in a particular passage if that's what you want. From my limited experience of playing B/C I would say that you will use the outer row E a little more frequently for this purpose than the outer row B.

Conversely you may want to add a bellows change, or at least not avail yourself of the possibility of saving one, either because that's how you want the tune [not] to flow, or as George points out, to keep the bellows on a tight rein in certain keys. Chances are you'll be using the air button as you sound these notes on the main row.

The second reason you may choose one E or B or the other has to do with chords. As I pointed out in a recent thread in the Tunes section (Apples in Winter), on most B/Cs your E chord (Em or thirdless E) is on the push, meaning that if you want to use basses in an Em tune you'll often use  the push B on the outer row and the push E on the inner row.

A useful exercise is to take a Em tune that pivots around B and E and experiment with the phrasing effects you get by using the various alternatives. The first few bars of Drowsy Maggie should be very instructive. Having found something that sounds good and is workable, throw the chord consideration into the mix!

As for numbers of fingers, I feel boxer has somewhat overstated the case - but exaggeration can be useful in getting a point across. I have come across a number of tricky passages that have become easy using two fingers instead of three.

(Edited to correct typing errors. )
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: george garside on August 07, 2012, 03:57:45 PM
Sir Jimmy Shand used all 4 fingers and if its good enough for him its good enough for me!     What we seem to all agree on is that there are no hard & fast rules  as to how best to play semitone button boxes .  It is therefore a bit strange that some very stongly advocate using a particular number of fingers and thereby perhaps losing the flexibility that can advantageosly be had from using whatever nuber fingers work best in a particular situation (particular part of particular tune). I think in terms of 4 as the starting point but depending on where I am going on the keyboard use 3 or even2 for some passages.  Some things like playing 'in octaves' need 4 fingers  as do some right hand chords.  The converse of course being that it can sometimes be useful to play 2 buttons together using one finger.

george 

george
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: nfldbox on August 07, 2012, 05:06:13 PM
George's typo "nuber fingers" I first read as "rubber fingers." I immediately realized that my problem is not number of fingers but rather the inflexibility of the ones I have!
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: boxer on August 12, 2012, 07:09:48 PM
to pick up on Steve Jones's thoughtful comments

The phrasing chosen for a tune should dictate the (fingering/magic note selection/anything else) used to play it.  This should be obvious, but it's not always the case.  For me, progress toward developing a playing technique that could cope with quick Irish tunes only began when that basic truth had dawned. 

Good luck, all beginners, and keep an open mind.  There's always a better way of doing it (on B/C anyway)



 
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: Old Leaky on August 13, 2012, 11:35:19 PM
I purchased the Hanrahan book and CD entitled "The Box"...

How are you getting on with the CD? Many years ago, I started with the cassette tape then bought the CD only to find it was out of concert pitch! I never worked out whether it was sharp or flat, fast or slow, but it was definitely "out"! ::)

There's just one really useful piece of advice in Hanrahan's book which, as I lost my copy, I must paraphrase: "only use the first three fingers on the treble keyboard"

The book says, and I quote: "Use three fingers..." but this has to be read in the context of the preceding text in the section ("So How Do I Play it?") in which it appears i.e. "Now try to play the notes of the scale using the diagram on previous page." I doubt it's intended to be prescriptive in terms of playing (the tunes that follow).
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: deltasalmon on August 14, 2012, 12:26:37 PM
Quote
Many years ago, I started with the cassette tape then bought the CD only to find it was out of concert pitch!

I was disappointed with this myself. Just starting with the melodeon I learned a tune or two from the book that I was familiar with and when I tried to play along with the CD I first thought "I just purchased this accordion and it's already out of tune!?"

My digital tuner soon assured me that the CD was out of tune and not my melodeon.
Title: Re: Newbie with B/C box...
Post by: boxer on August 14, 2012, 06:49:23 PM
tutors are only guides, not holy writ.  I was fortunate to find the needle in Hanrahan's haystack nine years ago and, whether my interpretation was correct or not, its application certainly improved my playing beyond measure (in all truth, it was pretty bad before I picked the book up).

you could apply Edward Elgar's philosophy to box playing (once again I paraphrase):  "...try everything once, except incest and morris dancing....."

 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal