Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: penn on June 26, 2012, 06:24:23 PM
-
Does anyone have any comments, information or history on this model?
I've just acquired one for what (at the moment) feels like a very reasonable price via an auction site. It's grey, celluloid finish, pearly buttons, orange bellows paper, gold tapes, and looks very much like the one on Jacques Delaguerre's Club system site.
http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/club/index.html (http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/club/index.html)
It feels a lot higher build quality than my D/G Erica and is in really excellent cosmetic condition, but...... it's not in tune and so I'm probably going to need to get someone to give it an overhaul.
There are many of these on ebay and I've seen suggestions on this forum that they're not very popular for some reason. It feels a little heavy, but sounds very smooth compared to the Erica, and being C/F & 4th start is a bit deeper, with strong basses too. I can appreciate the club system is quite different to D/G but I'm quite keen to give it a try and expand my horizons a little.
Do you think it's worth the possible expense of having it tuned (+ etc.) or would I be better off hanging it on the wall to warn me off further auction site MADness?
thanks, Steve
-
Just play it -
I have its older big brother, the square shaped Club-IIIB-S 3 voice and yes it`s smooth with a capital smoo (doesn`t scream like a Corso though It`s LMM not MMM like Corsos are) but as you say the build is in a different universe to the Corona, Erica, Corso, Doubleray series, the bass end is to die for, deep and powerful, the bellows massive and supple, the air button moves a massive pallet which sucks in air like a beluga whale.
I`ve grown to like the Uni-Button (Gleichton) on the F Row and wish the C row had one too, but then I`m playing German Polkas on the thing (which I guess is what it was designed for) .. I`m looking out for a proper Steirische box now
as I said, just play it, enjoy it, don`t hang it on the wall unless its making you long for a D/G box of the same quality
-
It feels a little heavy, but sounds very smooth compared to the Erica, and being C/F & 4th start is a bit deeper, with strong basses too. I can appreciate the club system is quite different to D/G but I'm quite keen to give it a try and expand my horizons a little.
Do you think it's worth the possible expense of having it tuned (+ etc.)
Could well be worth fettling if you like the sound and the note layout, and you are happy to explore a more cross-row style of playing.
-
I think of my Club IIB as being an acquired taste that needs time to be appreciated. It has a 1950s 'retro' look and feel, and people like the sound of it when I occasionally play some old standards with jazz bands. Doing a big glissando run on the outside rows gives the punters that authentic french feel ;) Just get me a beret and call me a
dilettante wanker.
-
Thanks for the encouragement chaps. Yes I think I'll need to do some budgetary manoeuvres and get it tidied. It really does need a tune - It's not that easy to tell if the gleichton's going to work for me as it's nearly a quarter tone flat on the pull.
Steve
-
After weeks of prevaricating, I've had the big Club IIB box back from its fettling for a week now and I can confirm:-
Martyn White is indeed a Wizard.
When I picked up the box on ebay it had probably been in someone's attic for half a century, it was in a decent condition and playable, but the reeds were rusty and so horribly out of tune that it wasn't really playable in company. Martyn popped them all out, bathed them in some delicious unction, popped them back in with honey and beeswax and tickled them all into tune.
It's quite a different instrument now – responsive, smooth, big big bass, and although its a heavy box doesn't seem to need such as much pumping as my Erica (I'm having to learn a lighter touch).
I kept the C/F and Club bass and gleichton in order to explore its possibilities. Martyn tuned it Viennese - I can't say whether that makes a difference, but it sounds great, and I guess that has to be a contributing factor.
It's not a very fashionable box, and probably the least suitable for this months TuneOTM, but I've had a lot of fun with it and haven't been able to put it down all week. The results are here
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v3R65MjN_DU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v3R65MjN_DU)
apologies to Martyn for my playing not having really done it justice.
Steve
-
Glad you like it Steve.
For the very short time you've been playing you are doing really well.
Looking forward to hearing your next contribution to ToTM :||:
Martyn