Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Clive Williams on June 27, 2012, 12:40:32 AM

Title: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Clive Williams on June 27, 2012, 12:40:32 AM
I came across this today, idly browsing Bandcamp for melodeon CDs as you do.

http://richardsanderson.bandcamp.com/album/improvisations-for-melodeon

I can honestly say I haven't heard a melodeon played like this before.

:o
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Andy Simpson on June 27, 2012, 12:58:33 AM
He's either taking the piss or taking himself way too seriously....I honestly can't tell....
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Ollie on June 27, 2012, 01:03:54 AM
If John Cage had discovered the melodeon...


Sonatas and Interludes for Prepared Melodeon, anyone? :P
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: TomB on June 27, 2012, 01:11:05 AM
My dog found it subliminally disturbing.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Lester on June 27, 2012, 07:17:15 AM
Judging by the pages art work it is played on a Chinese Pokerwork, would have been infinitely better on an older German or, even better still, Swiss made one  ;)
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Peter Savage on June 27, 2012, 07:43:28 AM
It's sounds like he accidentally switched on the recorder whilst he was setting up!
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: OldJack on June 27, 2012, 07:45:17 AM
Dog gone it, that's what I heard just before I woke up in a cold sweat. Then, it came to me. Some body phoned home from my garden shed.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 27, 2012, 08:41:18 AM
Buy Pignol's "Fictions" CD - there's a lot of this sort of thing on there. It's very current and avant garde - technically "free improvisation" - as opposed to something built on a tune or chord sequence.   If you go to stage impro in SE France they make you do free impro as an exercise, but obviously not with the sampled sound. So yes, I've experienced this and he's not at all bad. I've not personally come across Richard Sanderson but I've initiated an enquiry amongst the London improvising community and will report back .. C
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 27, 2012, 05:52:23 PM
Sorry, I know I'm a reactionary traditionalist - but what a winker!  Random creaks and groans just bore me to f'ing tears.

Rob.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Mike Hirst on June 27, 2012, 05:57:11 PM
Sorry, I know I'm a reactionary traditionalist - but what a winker!  Random creaks and groans just bore me to f'ing tears.

Rob.

It's so sad that the internet is full of bigotry, ill considered knee jerk reactions and misdirected vitriol. Why can't we live in a happy land where everyone thinks the same as me.  :'(
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Adam-T on June 27, 2012, 06:06:24 PM
5 small stones sounds like reed tuning , and filing whilst squeezing the tuning bellows
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 27, 2012, 06:08:07 PM
No bigotry, well considered (I listened to it) and no vitriol - just stating my opinion.  It lacked everything that a melodeon does well - music!

Rob.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Boxster on June 28, 2012, 10:34:37 AM
I'm a bit confused?
I liked it.
It sounds like one of my tunes, but didn't end end with "that's enough now John-put it back in the case and get the beers in!". >:E
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Mike Carney on June 28, 2012, 10:50:53 AM
I came across this today, idly browsing Bandcamp for melodeon CDs as you do.

http://richardsanderson.bandcamp.com/album/improvisations-for-melodeon

I can honestly say I haven't heard a melodeon played like this before.

:o
The test might be to find out how many discs he has sold...
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Peter Savage on June 28, 2012, 11:13:03 AM
The test might be to find out how many discs he has sold...

According to the Bandcamp link the CDs (n=50) are sold out.  So he has sold at least 50.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Lost Alamos on June 28, 2012, 04:25:08 PM
Okay, hands up to me means a criminal has been apprehended..This is a criminal alright.  Like John Cage who fooled the people on most occassions because they said he was different, but truly wasn't.
People of some breed or other are always running interference with the reality of logic. Doesn't mean
that they are Goofers but it does mean they haven't learned to be honest with themselves. Chris Ryall is on top of this when he mentions Nobert Pignol. Pignol is an Artist. He know's the meanings and is free to improvise. It can be exciting to hear his one person's expressions. He is honest in a
not so honest world. ICEBreaker Music is a term for experiment but the hinge is that years of sacrifice go with the final achievement.  There are still rules to follow as you explore and this introduction to breaking the ice is a absolute Lie from the said player. This music is criminal for
anyone and for sure anyone who is looking to reach beyond the reality of his or her music as
professed by the main stream. I encouraged everyone to experiment but you must know the rules before the journey. Almost every player on this forum has the experience to step out and discover.
Not so with whatever this guy's name is.  Maybe he has 50 family members or than again the public
is just waiting for another chance to be foolish.
experiment come's after the rules. All the best in the modern world which began 150 years ago.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Mike Hirst on June 28, 2012, 05:35:03 PM
Okay, the genius of playing is for each their opinion and style. There is nothing wrong with feeling good about ones'self as you may just be "crackers" and celebrated by many.

Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Theo on June 28, 2012, 06:26:31 PM
A long time ago I made up my mind very firmly about what kind of music I like.  Now I classify music as either (a) the music I like, or (b) the music I've not yet learned to like.  There is quit a wide range in each category. 
I commend this classification to all.:)
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Christopher K. on June 28, 2012, 08:42:30 PM
Duke Ellington said there's two types of music: good and bad. I wouldn't call what the Bandcamp bloke does "music," same for much of John Cage's work. I'm a big supporter of the musically strange and unusual, but that was pretty boring. I can't say it's terribly original, either. It reminds me heavily of what Peter Browne was doing a few years ago.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Anahata on June 28, 2012, 09:30:47 PM
Whatever you may think about John Cage's music, you can't ignore that fact that many respectable 20th century composers were hugely influenced by Cage's ideas about sound, music and how we listen.

However, I can't say I was able to listen to Sanderson's melodeon improvisation for very long, whether that's saying something about me or him.

An interesting test, though, is to try that sort of thing yourself and see if you could do any better. Whatever "better" means, of course - difficult to judge when the usual criteria don't work.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Christopher K. on June 28, 2012, 09:36:46 PM
Quote
Whatever you may think about John Cage's music, you can't ignore that fact that many respectable 20th century composers were hugely influenced by Cage's ideas about sound, music and how we listen.

Absolutely, that's completely correct, he influenced music like a partial influences timbre -- even if it can't be detected directly, his influence is there, conceptually and otherwise. But Cage's work often bores me to smithereens.  (:)
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: GuyWyatt on June 28, 2012, 10:20:39 PM
Well whatever else you might say about this chap's "music", you cannot dance to it, and it doesn't make you want to sing.  For me, that is all that I need to know.

With slightly more seriousness, I really disliked it.  Nicely done website though.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Mike Hirst on June 28, 2012, 11:25:15 PM
There is a false logic at play here. The success or failiure of this or any other creative endevour does not rely upon external opinion. The fact that I do not like opera does not mean that any given operatic performance is a failure. This is rather like the child who looks out of the window on a windy day and notices that the trees are bending, thus concluding that when the trees bend it causes the wind to blow.

Context and intent are important here. In the context of a morris performance the musical intent is to support the dance. There are many musicians who manage this with success. I doubt that I would wish to listen to that music without the dancers. Similarly the intent here is to put the melodeon into the context of free improvisation.  The fact that I like or dislike the results has no bearing on the merit of the endevour.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 29, 2012, 05:05:15 AM
More false logic is to regard this as music. There is no rule that says all one can do with a melodeon is play tunes.  In February Boris Trouplin had us paired each with a dancer. Both had to improvise from scratch. In this there was no lead person and you have to watch your partner like a hawk and respond. In my case the dancer(s) tended to set the rhythm, and that varied somewhat. There were challenges from both sides. Often these were in the 'noise' rather than music genre. Or you might simply 'huff' the bellows, or do other percussions. Or pick up on the dancer's response and let some notes flow.

Final evening we were split into 2 teams and were given simple themes to improvise to. Much humour involved with often wacky application of instruments. Bass clarinette bell became elephant noses (not bad elephant trumpet either!). Melodeons became cash registers, a typewriter ...

Here's something similar to Richard's stuff - from Pignol's album "Fictions" http://boutique.mustradem.com/player/accueil/mp3/orrorine2.mp3 Orrorine 2*  All done on melodeon (according to Stéph) - with sampled sounds and some digital jiggery-pokery too.

*with permission = 4th sample track on boutique.mustradem.com (http://boutique.mustradem.com)
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Mike Hirst on June 29, 2012, 07:25:53 AM
Here's something similar to Richard's stuff - from Pignol's album "Fictions" http://boutique.mustradem.com/player/accueil/mp3/orrorine2.mp3 Orrorine 2*  All done on melodeon (according to Stéph) - with sampled sounds and some digital jiggery-pokery too.

Great link. Thanks Chris.

(I was gonna say that it reminds me of Hermeto Pascoal's blown bottles, but I realise that may be too challenging for some of the more vociferous and less open contributers to this forum.)
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Keithypete. on June 29, 2012, 11:12:04 AM
I hadn't heard this until it was brought to my attention by Clive Williams. I won't be listening to it again because I don't like it. I prefer jigs & reels, etc.
 If it is truly improvisation - as in not practiced beforehand - then it's probably better than people are giving credit for. But he surely couldn't play that in a live set as he's already played it, practiced it - by definition.

 If I couldn't sleep one night I might play his entire back catalogue.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 29, 2012, 05:32:36 PM
Got feedback from Dolly May who is another London improvisor - never heard of the chap  :-\

BTW here's last years post http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Dl0fplnmRk of her improvising with Mano the Gallesian Gaita Galega player at last year's Bagsoc blowout. I'd watched this collaboration suggested an hour before over lunch- so they'd definitely not practiced it - or even met before ::)
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: oggiesnr on June 30, 2012, 11:18:41 AM
It's very reminiscent of some of the music that appears on the Tadzik label in New York and in the byways of the European impro scene.  Not everyones cup of tea and I prefer a bit more depth/collaboration in impro.  For that reason I prefer "For PM 61-87" with Paulo Chagas and Jerome Poirier. http://threelegsduck.bandcamp.com/album/for-pm-61-87 (http://threelegsduck.bandcamp.com/album/for-pm-61-87)

As far as performing impro is concerned that's always a grey area, most improvisors I know have a repertoire of sounds and effects that they use which will come out differently each time even when starting from the same theme.

Steve

PS in his other incarnation he's a perfectly respectable morris melodeon player.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Mike Hirst on June 30, 2012, 07:06:27 PM
If you don't like this, you probably wont like these either.

Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: bagrec on July 28, 2012, 10:40:59 PM
Hello - I am Richard Sanderson, and I recorded "Improvisations for Melodeon" about a year and half ago. Thank you all for listening to it, even if some of you evidently didn't like it (or, it would seem, me) very much. I enjoyed very much all your comments, not least as there are some names I intend to check out in the near future.

I'd like to thank Steve for describing me as a "perfectly respectable morris melodeon player" - this is really too kind, as I am really just an enthusiastic joiner-in of sessions - I've only once played for the morris, and this proved to be a challenge too far, and won't be repeated any time soon.

I'm really not a criminal - just a bloke making music, just like all of you. :||:



Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Clive Williams on July 28, 2012, 11:02:07 PM
 (:)

Hello, and welcome! Funny thing really; after Steve's comment, my perception changed quite a bit - knowing that you know how to play the thing 'normally', but have made an active choice to make music in different ways on it makes me a lot more open about it if that makes any sense. Glad you dropped by to visit - please hang around!

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 29, 2012, 03:36:46 AM
Most of us  started life as a tune players. I would actively seek out and practice up melodies of players/groups I admired. If a medley was involved,  I'd strive to learn up those same tunes, and play the in the same order, as if God given.

Contact with the wider European scene change my own perceptions - I recall asking an accordéoniste the name of a 5/8 waltz we'd just enjoyed .. "improvisée".  The actual lesson I needed to learn was that there was "nothing wrong with that".

May I welcome Richard to this group. I loved some of his musical ideas, I didn't relish everything, but delighted that he'd a go. I can recommend this place for thought stimulating discussion of both (indeed all) approaches to music. Should Richard ever seek to cross Morris off his own 'too hard list' it's a great place for help and support in that too. Confess that I went to watch some dancers last Monday - they've asked me to do it!
               (http://chrisryall.net/img/ides.png)
[edit] Anahata's trojan horse suggestion below .. acknowledged!
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Anahata on July 29, 2012, 08:48:30 AM
Possible theme of the month? Richard-style impro. Normal notes optional, in fact to be discouraged. The variety of contributions would be huge, and one might learn that it's harder than expected to do well.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: bagrec on July 30, 2012, 09:39:59 AM

To paraphrase Captain Willard (in discussion with Colonel Kurtz in "Apocalypse Now"): "I don't hear any music at all, sir." ;)

Or perhaps it's more Kurtz's: "The horror! The horror!" ;) ;)
[/quote]

Aw c'mon!

Still at least you're not calling me "a criminal".
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: bagrec on August 01, 2012, 11:33:44 PM
Bless you all.
I will be back - if only to find out how I can do an easy drone on any other note than bass C on a D/G....or create a cluster effect without using the accidentals...
I'm holiday at the moment, ave a nice summer!
 8)
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Theo on August 02, 2012, 01:50:27 PM
how I can do an easy drone on any other note than bass C on a D/G....

D of course, just need to switch buttons between push and pull, which can be done just as smoothly as for C if you use different fingers for the two D bass buttons.
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: pikey on August 03, 2012, 11:56:59 AM
A long time ago I made up my mind very firmly about what kind of music I like.  Now I classify music as either (a) the music I like, or (b) the music I've not yet learned to like.  There is quit a wide range in each category. 
I commend this classification to all.:)

You forgot the classical music option:
(c) the music I don't like but I pretend to like

qv John Cages silent work and plenty more!
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Lyra on August 03, 2012, 12:36:27 PM
d) music I don't like (might be very good, but I still don't like it - sorry, Mr Hindemith), and will frankly never like but that's not the end of the world for me or the late Mr H.
e) music I don't understand, into which a lot of stuff. I don't mean I don't know why it was written, but that I really don't understand the maths and mechanics behind it so I am unable to fully appreciate it. I may or may not like  it, regardless.
I do not confuse "like" with "has merit" - a shuffle through my ipod would confirm this  :|bl
Title: Re: OK, hands up who's heard this before?
Post by: Pilgrim on August 03, 2012, 01:40:23 PM
i haven't heard this 'tune' before - I should have left it that way!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal