Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: malcolmbebb on June 27, 2012, 12:02:38 PM
-
I'm sure that there is a much better thread in which to place this, but I couldn't find it. Moderators feel free to move it.
I apologise for the image quality, taken on a phone, late evening in a crowded pub, when I didn't want to use flash.
But I found it amusing.
Malcolm
-
I've got a Larson book at home and I'm pretty sure that one is in it. I'll scan that one if I can find it.
-
What you do privately as an individual is up to you and your conscience. But I don't think anyone should be posting copyright images (or video/audio clips) on this website and forum unless permission to do so has been obtained from the copyright holder. Sorry, but that's the law and in the worst case scenario Theo could be prosecuted and this website removed.
-
I always thought it was allowed as long as you said who it was.
-
I always thought it was allowed as long as you said who it was.
I suspect you are thinking of 'Fair Dealing' which allows, for instance, the use of copyright material for private educational and study purposes. It would be scarcely conceivable that making unauthorised scanned copies of Gary Larson's cartoons and placing them on this website (which, as anyone can access it, effectively is a public area, just like a display board in the street) could be considered a valid 'private educational and study purpose'.
UK copyright law is complex, although the basic tenets are simple enough: to protect the creators of literary, musical and visual work from unauthorised use of their work and to give them control over how their work is used. Copyright law varies from country to country but generally the basic principles are similar. Since this website is based in the UK, it will be covered and governed by the current valid UK legislation which is the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
In my work as a university lecturer, I have always had to be especially careful when preparing materials for lectures and students' assignments, worksheets, etc. as the penalties for copyright infringement can be very severe - fines of tens of thousands of pounds in some instances.
I refer you (and everyone) to the website of the UK Copyright Service, which provides very clear guidelines about what can and cannot be done. A good starting point is the Copyright Law Fact Sheet No.1 which is available here:
http://www.copyrightservice.co.uk/copyright/p01_uk_copyright_law
In particular, paragraph 7 'Restricted Acts' states unequivocally:
It is an offence to perform any of the following acts without the consent of the owner:
Copy the work.
Rent, lend or issue copies of the work to the public.
Perform, broadcast or show the work in public.
Adapt the work.
Paragraph 8 following outlines what is allowed under 'fair dealing' and, as mentioned earlier, posting copyright material (in this case Gary Larson cartoons) on this forum without the copyright owner's permission is unlikely to be covered in this way. So in effect an offence has already been committed by the original poster.
Many people seem to have a 'couldn't give a toss' attitude to the copyright and intellectual property rights of others, thinking it is a trivial matter and that the law is an ass. But deliberate flouting of the rights of the creators is stealing, just as much as if you were to break into their house and make off with their cash, television, or the contents of their freezer.
-
Steve does this extend to the copying and publishing of Copyright Law Fact Sheets or parts thereof one wonders ;) AtB mory
great cartoon though
-
While Steve is of course correct, I rather feel that the tone of his first post has a rather heavy-handed feel to it.
I doubt Gary Larson's lawyers are queuing up to be first to sue the users of this site for the loss of sales incurred from a non-commercial post to a narrow-interest forum, particularly when the source is attributed.
So it's something to be mindful of. We don't want to do people out of their livelihoods, (some might except a few lawyers from that) but let's maintain perspective.
I'm sure we have all confirmed the origin of those tunes we play in sessions and and checked for any permissions before playing the tune or printed the pdf and stuffed it in the gig bag, haven't we? >:E
-
Steve does this extend to the copying and publishing of Copyright Law Fact Sheets or parts thereof one wonders ;)
In this case I am quoting (not copying) and, at the same time, acknowledging the source so I cannot be accused of plagiarism. There is no infringement of copyright here.
-
Feel the need to be supportive to Steve on this now, as Content manager I'm sure he only has the sites best interest at heart, malcom perspective is always worth keeping indeed (:) AtB mory
great cartoon though
-
I doubt Gary Larson's lawyers are queuing up to be first to sue the users of this site for the loss of sales incurred from a non-commercial post to a narrow-interest forum, particularly when the source is attributed.
I understand Gary Larson or his lawyers to be particularly hot on unauthorised reproduction of his work. Some years ago I was looking on cartoon sites for a particular one of his, to discover that all his works had been removed for that very reason. Whether suing was involved, I do not know; but removal certainly was.
-
[[[ Admin hat, yes, I believe Steve's spot on with this one. Image removed. -- Clive ]]]
-
As a side point for discussion, how does that affect all these sessions we play in and YouTube videos we make, if public performance is illegal?
-
As a side point for discussion, how does that affect all these sessions we play in and YouTube videos we make, if public performance is illegal?
Illegal without permission...
In general public performance in the UK is covered by PRS*. If you join PRS as a composer or songwriter, you have effectively given permission for public performances of your works in return for a royalty payment, and handed over the administration of that process to PRS. Of course many folk performances at sessions and clubs are under the radar, but not at a festival or arts centre venue, on in a radio broadcast. So because Genevieve Tudor played a track of two of my tunes from our new album on her BBC Radio Shropshire folk programme recently, I'm hoping for a PRS payment some time next year. (haven't had one yet, but Mary had had lots for her "trad arranged by..." rights over the last few years). And we fill in a PRS return at folk festivals.
YouTube does flag performances of works where the copyright owner is identifiable. I've had a couple (e.g. The Bluebell Polka) but it hasn't resulted in a take-down. It might result in some kind of royalty payments being made to the rights owner, which would explain why YouTube have said they might place adverts next to the video "in some cases". In practice I doubt they'll do much unless viewing figures hit the hundreds of thousands. (2810 so far on Bluebell...)
If the rights owner flatly refused to allow any performance, then YT would have to take it down.
*Performing Right Society
-
Many people seem to have a 'couldn't give a toss' attitude to the copyright and intellectual property rights of others, thinking it is a trivial matter and that the law is an ass. But deliberate flouting of the rights of the creators is stealing, just as much as if you were to break into their house and make off with their cash, television, or the contents of their freezer.
There are two separate questions here. First, was this unauthorised copying illegal? Second, was it wrong? It does not follow from the fact that something is illegal that it is wrong unless either all legal requirements are moral requirements or there is an overriding moral requirement to obey the law as such. Nobody who thinks that there can be unjust laws and unjust regimes of law is likely to subscribe to either of these positions. So, given that Steve makes a reasonable case that this copying was illegal, it nevertheless remains an open question whether it was wrong. Equating copyright violations to taking the food out of someone's freezer is certainly an oversimplification! Everyone is entitled to make a just or 'living' wage which enables them to provide for the necessities of themselves and their dependants. Any acts which violate that are clearly wrong. In olden times it used to be thought that failing to reward workers in proportion to the efforts and resources they employed in undertaking their work constituted a clear violation of their right to a just wage. Current copyright and intellectual property laws, however, are intended to reward workers not on the basis of what they put into their work but on the basis of the value which is derived from it. In an age when certain resources are capable of being replicated endlessly for virtually no effort this would entitle some workers to be endlessly rewarded for a distinctly limited effort. A few months of effort by a writer may legally entitle them to rewards which a cleaner could not gain after hundreds of years of scrubbing! Is this the law? Yes. Is it right? It is very debatable. Certainly it is usually imprudent to disobey the law, but the demands of prudence have to be weighed against those of the other virtues. In this case I can't seem that there is any great value to be gained which would justify the site administrators in ignoring the demands of prudence, but in other cases the answer might not be so straightforward.
-
You must mean...
Certainly it is usually imprudent to [dis]obey the law...
-
YouTube does flag performances of works where the copyright owner is identifiable. I've had a couple (e.g. The Bluebell Polka) but it hasn't resulted in a take-down. It might result in some kind of royalty payments being made to the rights owner, which would explain why YouTube have said they might place adverts next to the video "in some cases". In practice I doubt they'll do much unless viewing figures hit the hundreds of thousands. (2810 so far on Bluebell...)
If the rights owner flatly refused to allow any performance, then YT would have to take it down.
*Performing Right Society
Apparently, youtube actually have a licence with the PRS and similar organisations to play copyright music on their videos; so if you see a '50 great airports' (e.g.) video of photos with chart music playing on the top, you'll often see it has the name and artist of the track displaying underneath the video. It's not illegal in this case - its licensed by youtube on its users behalf. The legality of playing music where the author is unhappy with it being used is another issue, as is that of doing unauthorised covers which the author disapproves of. I'm not convinced, if they've signed up to the PRS/MCPS, and youtube has a PRS licence, they actually have any legal right to stop it being used, but I believe that as a matter of respect for the artist, TOTM in particular always needs to trace the composer of the month's tune where possible and respect their wishes.
If youtube 'flags' a video, it is *not* a notice of infringement of copyright. It's merely their automatic content spotting engine saying "I think this track was composed by (e.g.) Paul McCartney, so I'm going to give him a little money in his PRS pot - if you think I've got that wrong (which it inevitably has), please click here."
Clive
-
you'd think one random cartoon which might potentially bring new people to his oeuvre (thus calendars, books, mugs, bog roll et al) would be seen as free marketing, rather than theft of intellectual birthright.
But hey ... as said by one more literate than I, sometimes "the law is a ass"
-
The "free marketing" argument is often put forward, especially by those who put bootleg copies of other people's CDs on line. However shouldn't it be up to the person who created it in the first place to decide whether they want free publicity or whether they'd prefer to get paid?
It's easy to think "what's the big deal?", especially when it's just something posted on a small community website such as this for the amusement of a small circle. However this website is visible to the whole world.
-
You must mean...
Certainly it is usually imprudent to [dis]obey the law...
Certainly it is usually imprudent to obey the law without question ;)
-
There's a massive difference between one small cartoon and a whole CDs. Not to mention most CDs don't end up on mugs and bogroll, although perhaps some should. And it clearly is up to the author - some go with it, some keep the legal community in work ... entirely their choice.
And I trust you are not implying, however, that I would put bootleg CDs online - cos it looks awful like you are .... yanow?
Anyway - thread seems without point now.
-
I wasn't implying anything, simply saying that it's a common excuse. But I don't really see the difference between a cartoon and a music track. These things have commercial value and the person who created them is entitled to say how they can be used.
-
YouTube does flag performances of works where the copyright owner is identifiable. I've had a couple (e.g. The Bluebell Polka) but it hasn't resulted in a take-down.
That's interesting. Who do they think is the copyright holder for the Bluebell Polka?
-
my undersanding is that it was composed by F stanley ? in the 1890's or thereabouts so may be out of copyright.. Shand recorded two distinct versions one pre war and his well knownversionin the 50's. Presumably his arrangement is also copyrighted.
george
-
Bluebell Polka is attributed to F. Stanley in the first edition of Kerrs Merry Melodies, which matches the approximate date in George's post.
A few years back I spent some time giong sp going through Kerr's, Kohler, and other 19thC sources matching composers with known compositions. There appear to be three dominant centres for 19thC composers working in what we would now consider the traditional style. Thus far evidence indicates Aberdeen, Newcastle and Boston as being important, with rapid interchange between these places. There is of course much work yet to be done.
-
my undersanding is that it was composed by F stanley ? in the 1890's or thereabouts so may be out of copyright.. Shand recorded two distinct versions one pre war and his well knownversionin the 50's. Presumably his arrangement is also copyrighted.
Bluebell Polka is attributed to F. Stanley in the first edition of Kerrs Merry Melodies, which matches the approximate date in George's post.
I wondered about this because the music I use (seems identical to the Shand recording) from "The Rutherglen Collection of 40 Scottish Polkas" has for the Bluebell Polka "Arr F Stanley? Very early copies of the tune were entitled 'The Little Toddlekins Polka'. Dating back so far it seems unlikely that Fred Stanley was the composer - although possibly he may have been the arranger of the present setting?" Unfortunately no date indicated for Little Toddlekins.
-
my undersanding is that it was composed by F stanley ? in the 1890's or thereabouts so may be out of copyright.. Shand recorded two distinct versions one pre war and his well knownversionin the 50's. Presumably his arrangement is also copyrighted.
Bluebell Polka is attributed to F. Stanley in the first edition of Kerrs Merry Melodies, which matches the approximate date in George's post.
I wondered about this because the music I use (seems identical to the Shand recording) from "The Rutherglen Collection of 40 Scottish Polkas" has for the Bluebell Polka "Arr F Stanley? Very early copies of the tune were entitled 'The Little Toddlekins Polka'. Dating back so far it seems unlikely that Fred Stanley was the composer - although possibly he may have been the arranger of the present setting?" Unfortunately no date indicated for Little Toddlekins.
Hmm. definitely worthy of further investigation
-
You must mean...
Certainly it is usually imprudent to [dis]obey the law...
Correction made. Must have been a Freudian slip caused by barely repressed criminal tendencies! >:E
-
[
Bluebell Polka is attributed to F. Stanley in the first edition of Kerrs Merry Melodies, which matches the approximate date in George's post.
I wondered about this because the music I use (seems identical to the Shand recording) from "The Rutherglen Collection of 40 Scottish Polkas" has for the Bluebell Polka "Arr F Stanley? Very early copies of the tune were entitled 'The Little Toddlekins Polka'. Dating back so far it seems unlikely that Fred Stanley was the composer - although possibly he may have been the arranger of the present setting?" Unfortunately no date indicated for Little Toddlekins.
Hmm. definitely worthy of further investigation
[/quote]
Shands pre war version of the bluebell polka ,on the CD 'a night at the jiggin' is entitled 'The Bluebell Pollka (Little Pet Polka) (Trad.arr. J Shand). no mention of F Stanley who is credited on Shands post war version ( or is it Stanleys version!) The plit thockens!
george