Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Adam-T on June 27, 2012, 10:10:58 PM
-
I`ve never seen a Preciosa and a Liliput side by side and always thought they were the same size, but given that the Preciosa has flat reed pans in an ingenius setup and the Liliput has regular reedblocks there must be some size difference,.. I always wondered why both models too .......
Can the tiny reeds be tuned up to D/G or do these conversions mean reed swapping (and more obtaining), is it possible to get the pink celluloid thesedays? thanks
-
I am beginning to wonder if you are writing a book...
There is a slight size difference, but they are both small.
I think the Liliput came first, the Preciosa overlapped and continued for a couple of years after. The Preciosa may have been more economical in materials, given that this was wartime.
But I expect Theo will have the details, if not others will.
Intended market allegedly gentlemen hikers, but apparently popular with soldiers. I have yet to teach Lili Marleen to my Liliput.
-
Bout time someone wrote the hitchikers guide to Hohners . I thought a database was taking place here at one stage - Thanks to Linz, I`ve got a Project Liliput coming (needs work) and like to investigate, I`ve done a search but it didn`t mention size diff and how far you can push the reeds .... MAD is a real Problem
Ahh, one followed the other, I`d have guessed the Preccy was the older model due to the oddball internal design, just shows . thanks :)
-
Theo and Mike Rowbotham both offer D/G conversions. Mine is D/G (was C/F). I don't know to what extent reeds are swapped around/retuned, I guess one could work it out.
Lilliput was 1935-1940 nominally, I think Preciosa continued to 1942, but don't quote me.
The most common Liliput colour seems to have been purple, but other colours inc red (mine is brown with red trim) were made. There were two models, the later one more rounded. Mine is the earlier.
-
This is an older one with the squared off fingerboard, it`s the pinky purple coloured one. T reeds on Zinc treble end, the bass end look like Aluminium plates from the pics
-
Conversion to DG can't be done by just tuning up a tone IMHO. I have worked out a method that uses all the original reeds, but swapping reeds around to minimise tuning, and a 4th button start.
-
Hmm, I thought it would be too much to try and tune those tiny tongues that much .. 4th button start is not a bad thing on a D/G box anyway !
-
If you wait a few weeks I'll do an inside and out on my Liliput :P
The Liliput is a bit bigger and has reeds mounted on blocks rather than pans. They do however have the same shorter scale reeds (iirc they are the same width but shorter and thicker? There is a comparison floating around somewhere I think). The Liliput also doesn't have the bellows lock. Other than that they are similar instruments. Both models started out with sharp corners and both models then went to rounded ones. The later model Preciosas are nice instruments, but aren't quite as pretty as the original and they don't have the lock. The later model Liliputs are some of the prettiest boxes ever produced, with a gorgeous interlocking circle grille. Most Preccys are early models, the later model is a lot rarer. Whereas later model Liliputs do crop up from time to time. In terms of colour, most Preccys appear to be grey, with green, orange and purple also available. The most desirable colour is cream with red trimmings. Later models tend to be cream or red/brown as far as I can tell. Early Liliputs are generally purple or grey, but the later ones are the most beautiful ruby red or blue. There are probably other colours, I don't pretend to be an expert on this!
In terms of sound they are utterly different and utterly beguiling. I feel privileged to have one of both.
-
Thanks Owen .. I`m glad the Liliput hasn`t the bellows lock, IMO anything which can leak air in old Hohners is best avoided (Stop rods, old register levers, bellows locks etc) unless totally necessary like stop rods in the HA series...
I`ve come to love Hohners old and new, All my boxes (which aren`t for sale) PA or button are now Hohner (bar one chinese "toy" of each Mel and PA), an affordable fettleable Liliput has been very high on my list for ages and this one is very welcome - the only non-Hohners I really want are a Castagnari Lilly and a Steirische Harmonika (Hohner ones aren`t common and vastly overpriced compared to a superior Strasser, Novak, Rutar, Zupan etc)
-
Bout time someone wrote the hitchikers guide to Hohners . I thought a database was taking place here at one stage - Thanks to Linz, I`ve got a Project Liliput coming (needs work) and like to investigate, I`ve done a search but it didn`t mention size diff and how far you can push the reeds .... MAD is a real Problem
Ahh, one followed the other, I`d have guessed the Preccy was the older model due to the oddball internal design, just shows . thanks :)
The apparent lack of a reliable source of information to date these boxes precisely is infuriating, especially as they carry serial numbers.
I first ran across Preciosas and Liliputs many years ago (pre-Ebay), when they were viewed as "novelty instruments" that sometimes turned up in UK junk shops (usually as WW2 "souvenirs" a.k.a. "spoils of war"), rather than the ingenious and fine boxes they are. I liked them so much that I now have two of each model, in different versions and in various tunings, including a Rowbotham DG Liliput. In fact, they made my old Casta Lilly, that I had for many years, so redundant that I passed it on last year.
-
Im Zelt und auch im Paddelboot darf die Hohner-Harmonika nicht fehlen
-
Nice picture - Preciosa from the colour scheme?
Non literal modern version might be:
"Camping or (lit. also) canoeing, a Hohner melodeon won't let you down. "
-
Great pic find Mike !! ..
Threre always seems to be times when certain instruments are "worthless" and can be had for nothing, then suddenly become valuable - it happened with Analog synths . the art is to guess what will be wanted , grab whatever at the worthless stage and keep it .
Think of really good, not hugely expensive on the used market now but discontinued (or not common) boxes which may become sought after in 10 years . Merlin?, Panther ? , Corso ?, Casta Mignon ?, Baffetti Piccolo ?
Anyway regarding this Li`l Lilli, not sure whether to get Theo to do the D/G mod or just fettle it as a C/F, I like both Keys - depends on cost really
-
I have yet to teach Lili Marleen to my Liliput.
My Lilliput plays "Lili Marleen" automagically when I pick it up!
-
Im Zelt und auch im Paddelboot darf die Hohner-Harmonika nicht fehlen
Brilliant. This is sooo apposite - I must show that photo to my douce moitié. She has always objected to my plans to bring a box on our annual canoe camping trip, contending that an accordion-free holiday is somehow important for her mental health. (Whistles are permissible - perhaps on the grounds that I have succeeded in engaging loons in duets at sunset.)
So far I have always capitulated, unable to justify the size and weight of a normal box. But the Liliput is so tiny it will slip into a dry bag along with T-shirts and knickers. And wifey will have to recognise that I am helping the instrument fulfil the purpose intended by its admirable German designers - as well as expanding the musical horizons of the northern fauna.
-
I think it may be safer to take a Harmonica than a "Harmonika" in the "Paddleboot" ::) LOL . I`d rather see a £25 blues harp sink than a £600+ Liliput
-
I think it may be safer to take a Harmonica than a "Harmonika" in the "Paddleboot" ::) LOL . I`d rather see a £25 blues harp sink than a £600+ Liliput
Have no fear. "Dry bags" are totally waterproof - and they float. So when you capsize in the rapids, you can fetch all your luggage downstream.
-
l'accordéon en vacances
-
I have decided I want a Liliput for my next box - decided that a few weeks ago. Portability, vintage pretty but not overly expensive, and I just love those Hohner basses!
It would complement my Morgane nicely. I'm tempted with a C/F and then I have a few more keys available to me. Something with accidentals would be a plus also (Bluebell Polka eludes me at present, no F natural). Would probably declub, if not done already, and have the basses changed to the more D/G style layout so my fingers don't get confused.
It'd have to be the "right" box though, so it may be next year, it may be years down the line.
-
The odd thing about liliputs is that I`ve seen more "Right" boxes than "Wrong" ones, most that have been on offer, even unfettled have been in remarkably decent condition, even those two wrecked Preccies in Germany look pretty good. C/F would appear to be the most common key , perfect for Polkas, especially with the Gleichton note in the middle of the F row
-
The odd thing about liliputs is that I`ve seen more "Right" boxes than "Wrong" ones,
Yes they do seem to survive pretty well as far as case work goes, but you should assume that they will need a full reed overhaul. Because of the limited space round the reeds the amount of wax that can be used to secure them is a fraction of what is used in a conventionally sized box. So even with the nails used to help the wax it is very common to find reed plates have broken loose, or if still in place are able to vibrate and sound terrible. Pallets are made of quite thin wood and are prone to slight distortion leading to slight leaks, so its safe to assume pallet re-facing will be needed too.
-
Conversion to DG can't be done by just tuning up a tone IMHO. I have worked out a method that uses all the original reeds, but swapping reeds around to minimise tuning, and a 4th button start.
Theo converted a Liliput for me last year, 4th button start, and a layout very similar to my Connemara 3. He did a great job, everything I expected and more, very easy to play and doesn't use much air. I have to say it's fantastic, and utterly beguiling! If you are thinking about getting one, go for it, you won't regret it!
Trevor
-
The odd thing about liliputs is that I`ve seen more "Right" boxes than "Wrong" ones, most that have been on offer, even unfettled have been in remarkably decent condition, even those two wrecked Preccies in Germany look pretty good. C/F would appear to be the most common key , perfect for Polkas, especially with the Gleichton note in the middle of the F row
I think by "right" I mean silly things like the right colour and shape. :) Girl stuff.
I think what I'd probably do with a clubbed C/F if I got my hands on such a thing would be to have a go and see if I can get the trick of the gleichton and the non-gleichton inner lower bass/chord, and if not, get it declubbed.
-
Here's photos of my two; the black Preciosa was tuned to DG (from Eb/Bb I think) by Theo. The red Liliput was "tickled" by Theo, but left in CF Club.
The Preciosa is much louder than the Liliput, but the latter is more mellow and I think, easier to play.
I don't prefer one to the other - they are both as different to one another as they are to my concertina.
Peter
-
My Lillput looks like this.
Chas
-
Mmm..... the red one..... shiny thing. I like.
-
Here's photos of my two I don't prefer one to the other - they are both as different to one another as they are to my concertina.
Peter
Thanks Peter - The Preccy`s grille has the common Hohner pattern whereas the Lilli`s is different - the size difference seems to be more down to width ..
Strig - I`m also amazed at how many different colours there are - mine when it comes is the pinkish colour one like Fidjit`s (I like the red one too, not seen one before), I guess you could change the celluloid to any colour you`d like but you`d not get the name transfers.. also it`s hard enough to get common boxes (which come in a choice of colours) in the col you want let alone one which stopped production during WW2
-
The Preciosa is much louder than the Liliput, but the latter is more mellow and I think, easier to play.
Peter
I would add that the Liliput would not necessarily be an ideal session box - sat next to two Ericas I was completely drowned out. Admittedly I wasn't playing hard, but neither were they :D
-
Theo rebuilt my Preciosa and converted it to D/G. I like to hear others playing it, but when playing it myself I seem to hear too many harmonics, making it sound much harsher than it really is. The only other non-standard mod I would go for if doing it again would be to have a couple more folds in the new bellows! The small bellows are quickly exhausted and even with my small build I could cope with the longer length.
Rob.
-
I know I'll just have to take what I'm given as far as colour goes, really. I suppose it's like kittens. You think you'll get a tabby one or a black and white one or whatever, but then one looks up at you in the shelter and mews and that's the one for you...
The volume isn't a problem really. I'm thinking of this as a "travelling light" holiday box as well as being for when I really want to play a tune in a different key or one with tricky accidentals. I imagine I will still be using the Morgane for sessions and group playing.
Now I just have to be patient and wait for one to come along.... when I have the money. :(
-
I think what I'd probably do with a clubbed C/F if I got my hands on such a thing would be to have a go and see if I can get the trick of the gleichton and the non-gleichton inner lower bass/chord, and if not, get it declubbed.
Good plan. The Gleichton has a lot going for it, and the only reason I haven't "clubbed" all my non-gleichton boxes is because I'm a dyed-in-the-wool old git and can't be bothered to change the habits of half a lifetime.
-
The odd thing about liliputs is that I`ve seen more "Right" boxes than "Wrong" ones, most that have been on offer, even unfettled have been in remarkably decent condition, even those two wrecked Preccies in Germany look pretty good. C/F would appear to be the most common key , perfect for Polkas, especially with the Gleichton note in the middle of the F row
As you say, they are often in quite good order, at least outwardly. One thing which seems to be a fairly common problem is small bits of the edge banding strips having been knocked off. This isn't too hard to solve on Liliputs (where it seems less frequent anyway), where the banding is usually solid black cellulose and easy to scarf in a bit. However, on the Preciosas (at least the ones I've encountered) the black celluloid banding has a minute strip of white on the inner edge.
The last time I saw this type of material was in the instrument panel of my vintage 1973 Norwegian Sabb marine engine! I did manage to make some in the end, but it's not easy.
The other thing which I still haven't found a satisfactory source for is a replacement for the old-gold Preciosa bellows tape, which has a sort of watered silk or moire pattern in it and looks rather handsome against the pale lavender papers. If anyone knows of one, please tell.
-
I would add that the Liliput would not necessarily be an ideal session box - sat next to two Ericas I was completely drowned out. Admittedly I wasn't playing hard, but neither were they :D
Perhaps it's the Ericas that aren't the best instrument for a session. The kind of session where everyone listens to everyone else. (That is the only kind we all go to, isn't it? ;) )
-
Love the "camping" photo ... & l'accordéon en vacances pic! It's so .... French! An older guy with a sexy young babe wearing high heels & hot pants! Yeah, that's the ticket!
I did have the Vespa once, many years ago, & it was a guitar not an accordéon, but, sadly, no blonde babe. :'(
Could those who have both the Preciosa & the Lilliput offer more insight as to the difference in the quality of sound (a hard thing to quantify, I know) & any other distinctions?
-
I would add that the Liliput would not necessarily be an ideal session box - sat next to two Ericas I was completely drowned out. Admittedly I wasn't playing hard, but neither were they :D
Perhaps it's the Ericas that aren't the best instrument for a session. The kind of session where everyone listens to everyone else. (That is the only kind we all go to, isn't it? ;) )
Dunno about that. I was thinking myself lucky they weren't Pokerworks.
-
I love playing in F on my B/C Liliput. C/F would be a good choice.
-
I can't speak to the Preciosa's abilities, never having played one. However I play two Liliputs, and I recommend the instrument without reservation. One, in the original C/F club tuning, was "Theorized" into modern pitch several years ago. The other was "Rowbothamized" into D/G earlier this year. I use the club box for singing and noodling around outside the fiddle keys. The D/G serves the need for all the other stuff. Liliputs are great travel instruments. In the case they'll still fit into a back-pack, dry-bag, carry-on, courier bag or carrier bag. They have the Hohner ringing shout, enough of the Hohner percussion section to maintain some credibility, and they'll hold their end up in a session. I recently sat in with two Industrial Accordions (PAs), two concertinas, assorted fiddles, frets, and a sax, and still managed to hear myself. They're pretty robust, and robustly pretty. They're small enough for kids to play, and lots of people want to come over and chat about them. Because they're light and a bit short on air, they force one to think about technique a bit. And they have a few extra buttons.
All in all, a good option.
-
The great thing with Liliputs is that you can leave them about the house without getting too much aggro. Also they just want to be picked up for a quick play whenever you see them. the sound is brilliant. I have two, bothe early purple models. An original in Bb/Eb modern tuned by Theo, and a D/G converted by Theo, Excellent value, even with conversion costs compared to the Lilly I think.
-
Hobgob have a nice condition working one in standard form for £600 - which seems steep to me but it`s a commission sale and these high street Box dealers take a whopping 33% Commission which bumps the price up massively (camera, Hifi, Studio and other things generally are between 10 and 20% Commission) , dunno if it`s been fettled wax and valves wise let alone if its been tuned to 440 but they`re happy with the playabilty of it .
that`s a lot less than a Lily as it stands (IF its been waxed, valved and tuned) so depends on how much it`d cost for the D/G mod to compare ... used Lilys tend to be around the £900 mark for a decent one, The Saltarelle Epsilon (Lily-esque) is around a grand new. all these things have to be taken into account.
-
The grille on my Lilliput is nothing like the ones on the earlier photos - it is good quality chrome, with no cloth behind it.
See here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hteXJX4jkIw
I thought I'd have fun with the smalelr buttons, but no such thing - I took to it like a duck to water! It is a joy to play.
-
Hobgob have a nice condition working one in standard form for £600 - which seems steep to me but it`s a commission sale and these high street Box dealers take a whopping 33% Commission which bumps the price up massively (camera, Hifi, Studio and other things generally are between 10 and 20% Commission) , dunno if it`s been fettled wax and valves wise let alone if its been tuned to 440 but they`re happy with the playabilty of it .
that`s a lot less than a Lily as it stands (IF its been waxed, valved and tuned) so depends on how much it`d cost for the D/G mod to compare ... used Lilys tend to be around the £900 mark for a decent one, The Saltarelle Epsilon (Lily-esque) is around a grand new. all these things have to be taken into account.
By coincidence, If this is the one in their Bristol shop I played it today, it's a nice box (C/F), plays well and sounds good. As to whether it had been re-waxed, etc. the questions weren't asked as I didn't really think it was for me.
-
Aye pikey, that's the later (and some say better) model (:)
-
The grille on my Lilliput is nothing like the ones on the earlier photos - it is good quality chrome, with no cloth behind it.
It would have started life with cloth behind the grille, identical to the stuff covering the bass holes.
-
The grille on my Lilliput is nothing like the ones on the earlier photos - it is good quality chrome, with no cloth behind it.
It would have started life with cloth behind the grille, identical to the stuff covering the bass holes.
Anyone have any ideas on:
How to clean a grille cloth without it falling off, or
the best way to stick one back on?
-
I use Bostik clear to stick grille cloths on but its ther messiest stuff out there - leaves big long stringy bogeys all over the place if not careful ..
-
I've used a light spray of 3M 77 spray adhesive on the inside of the grill and then lay the cloth on it. Quick, simple and invisible and sticks the cloth evenly. The adhesive is not too strong so as to be a problem with removal later either.
-
I can show a Size comparison myself now, maybe handy for future reference .
Liliput size compared to first the ubiquitous Pokerwork and secondly how it Dwarfs the £10 two voice 1 Row Toy Melodeon .
-
But I know which one I'd rather have! ;D
-
What would be the rough cost of professionally re-waxing, tuning and de-clubbing such a box (but keeping it in the original keys).
Just idle curiosity really, but I'd be interested to know. Thanks
-
I don`t know - more for a Preciosa than a liliput due to the obscure reed pan setup Vs the Liliput`s standard "Miniaturized Pokerwork" reedblock setup .
Re-Pikey
But I know which one I'd rather have!
I`d hate to guess that one ::)
BTW the grille has very nice chrome indeed, I`ve not seen it to this standard on a Hohner before
-
What would be the rough cost of professionally re-waxing, tuning and de-clubbing such a box (but keeping it in the original keys).
Just idle curiosity really, but I'd be interested to know. Thanks
I had a quote of just over £300 to rewax, revalve, tune, declub, and replace half a dozen broken reeds in a Hohner Club II, so I'd guess about the same for a Lilliput. The quote to change to D/G at the same time was just over £400.
-
That sounds in the right sort of area.
Martyn
-
What would be the rough cost of professionally re-waxing, tuning and de-clubbing such a box (but keeping it in the original keys).
Just idle curiosity really, but I'd be interested to know. Thanks
I had a quote of just over £300 to rewax, revalve, tune, declub, and replace half a dozen broken reeds in a Hohner Club II, so I'd guess about the same for a Lilliput. The quote to change to D/G at the same time was just over £400.
Thanks for the reply.
It's good information to have if one's (like me) toying with the idea of purchasing one (worst case scenario and all that!)
-
given a price, it allows you to budget in the restoration when buying - if you bought that Hobgoblin one for £600 , it`d not need fettling (from what I can tell) but the De-Clubbing would cost as they`d have to replace a tiny unisonoric reed with a standard one - hopefully they won`t use a cheap chinese concertina reed which are about the same size..
Dunno about the rear end, I`d want to de-club that, it drives you nuts - but the treble end is another matter - Personally I`d be tempted to stick another Gleichton on the C row on mine and turn the top row of accidentals into a small Bb row making it even better for the German Polkas ..
Another Point
I`m amazed at how far the bellows stretch ! , I`ve got long arms and the liliput i`m sure would stretch quite a bit further !. even the Club-3-BS didn`t stretch that far .. also this is the first box of any kind I`ve played where you`ve got to be even remotely careful guiding the bass end back on the push at long stretch , probably because of the length to diameter of the bellows ..
I guess they had to get air into these things somehow, loadsa deep folds is the only way . how does a castagnari Lily fare on air - apart from the benefit only having 1 voice ? .
The Preciosa must be worse as it`s not quite as wide as the Liliput and has an extra reed in the bass (though the Liliput isn`t lacking in that area to begin with) ..
I can see why people get hooked on these boxes - I take back the comment I made months ago about a fully fettled D/G converted one being seriously steep at £750 . a used Casty Lily maybe only about £150 more and it IS a superb sounding tool (I`ve yet to play one) but it`s not a 2 voice Hohner and will never be one..
Hohner re-issued the wooden fingerboard Coronas, the Atlantic name (if not the actual accordion) and continued Pokerwork & HA114 production -- so why not a Liliput revival ? , casagnari aren`t short of buyers for their little box ! .
-
Personally I`d be tempted to stick another Gleichton on the C row on mine and turn the top row of accidentals into a small Bb row making it even better for the German Polkas ..
That would be unconventional to say the least. Even real Steirische boxes don't have a gleichton on the outer row and if you want a G on pull (on a C/F box) you've already got one readily accessible on the F row.
As for half a row of Bâ™, that does makes some sense for that sort of music.
-
That would be unconventional to say the least. Even real Steirische boxes don't have a gleichton on the outer row and if you want a G on pull (on a C/F box) you've already got one readily accessible on the F row.
As for half a row of Bâ™, that does makes some sense for that sort of music.
I was getting my rows mixed up - thinking of the C row as the second to outer one the 4 Rowers rather than the out .. The smallest proper Steirsche I know of with proper Helicon bass is an Oberhorner and is the size of a Pokerwork , there are Heligonkas of that size but not the same. anyway, it`s amazing what can be done with a Liliput , Owen Ukebert had his turned into a kind of "baby Shand" (B/C with a bit of C#) , mine will be a "Strasserette" :o
-
What would be the rough cost of professionally re-waxing, tuning and de-clubbing such a box (but keeping it in the original keys).
Just idle curiosity really, but I'd be interested to know. Thanks
I had a quote of just over £300 to rewax, revalve, tune, declub, and replace half a dozen broken reeds in a Hohner Club II, so I'd guess about the same for a Lilliput. The quote to change to D/G at the same time was just over £400.
Thanks for the reply.
It's good information to have if one's (like me) toying with the idea of purchasing one (worst case scenario and all that!)
My Preciosa cost a little over £200 from ebay.de, though it might be difficult to get one as cheaply nowadays since demand has gone up in the last couple of years.
Restoring and converting it to D/G (an excellent job from Theo) cost me about double that, but this will vary depending on condition and how much work has to be done.
But there's no modern equivalent, and less than £700 for a lovely little box like this is a bargain in my view :-)
Cheers
Ian
-
£600 fully fettled and DG'd is a great buy as you got the box at a good price to start with but £600 (the Hobgob Box) + the £400 DG fee is pushing it IMO .
-
Well, while we're all 'fessing up, my Liliput cost around £550 after getting it for a good price on Ebay. Includes purchase, D/G conversion and overhaul, and carriage.
I would guess that prices quoted often don't include carriage to and from the repairer, which adds a chunk more.
-
Good for me to see all of this price comparison too. I have a feeling a few of us will be fighting over Liliputs in future. :D
-
Again .......... Hohner seriously need to re-issue it . all the current mini-boxes are single voice, only one full row (inc tiny extra buttons) or both .. all they`d have to do is copy the old LP design but with no need complicated preccy reedpans, they could knock out natural wood ones which look like Mini Merlins
-
Yes, but reckon on the price being the equivalent of a modern full size 2.5 row, it generally costs more to make a smaller version, more accurate building, special sized reeds, small size action parts, etc etc. guess it would be at least £2k to £3k, unless you could sell half a million units.
-
I do wonder if it was a wartime rationing thing. My understanding is the Liliput was made pretty much exclusively during WW2. (I mentioned it once; I think I got away with it). Lots of men going off to war, not much wood and metal available for fripperies like musical instruments?
-
The Liliput's official dates are, I think, 1935 to 1940 with the Preciosa hanging on a couple of years longer. I have heard that they were aimed at middle class hikers. Outdoor occupations were, I believe, encouraged around this time although I think hiking was a well established leisure activity.
Hence a lightweight, small box that didn't need to be loud. Subsequently popular with soldiers - possibly even the real market - as Germany's army was building up over this period.
This might tend to support the general good condition - they weren't hammered in pubs and music halls.
Accordions (inc melodeons) were more popular then, but I imagine these boxes were expensive even then due to low volumes.
-
Yes, but reckon on the price being the equivalent of a modern full size 2.5 row, it generally costs more to make a smaller version, more accurate building, special sized reeds, small size action parts, etc etc. guess it would be at least £2k to £3k, unless you could sell half a million units.
Hmmm, I don`t think the minimal miniaturization of the liliput parts should push the cost up, it`s not as if they`ve got to squeeze it into a Castagnari Mignon size, there`s nothing complex or difficult in there to make such as weird reedpans or a tiny 36 bass stradella etc.
The reed plates are no smaller than those in a £99 chinese concertina or the £10 toy melodeon and Quality reed tongues are a lot smaller again in mouth organs. It doesn`t need to be 2.5 row either as the Club system is dead, this means the buttons can be bigger and a smaller version of the pokerwork mech can be used.
The only cost-upper is that they can`t build it from the parts bin in typical hohner fashion but other makers (even chinese ones) face that all the time - for once, Hohner will have to actually make a box using newly designed parts ! (shock Horror!) . Again , the chinese are good at this, they tool up to mass produce all sorts of new products all the time. they could do Chromatic versions and re-use the Preciosa name if they feel like adding their usual confusion to the mix.
Very Doable IMO - the only real problem is if Hohner have the guts to stick their neck out and try something new..
-
The Liliput's official dates are, I think, 1935 to 1940 with the Preciosa hanging on a couple of years longer.
I was researching and listening to melodeons for years before actually getting one (which was actually pretty recently) and was always confused about the two models, as I mentioned in another post, I thought they ran side by side, were the same size and that the Liliput was 1 voice and the Preccy 2 voice, the preccy being the more expensive version - Theo later corrected me on the voice business and it was then suggested by someone elsethat the preccy was later
so it would seem that the two overlapped and the cheaper build of the liliput meant it carried on for a while rather like the Corona-II Classic and Corona-II Extreme (there is no Classic model now, I don`t even think the Base model of Corona II exists either, it`s plastic Compadre or Full Xpense Xtreme thesedays, I bet that upset quite a few) ...
-
there is no Classic model now, I don`t even think the Base model of Corona II exists either, it`s plastic Compadre or Full Xpense Xtreme thesedays
Not sure where you've been looking, but the current Hohner Musikinstrumente GmbH website lists the following 3 Row Diatonics:
Corona II Flaco Jimenez
Corona II
Corona II Classic
Corona II Xtreme
Corona III
Corona III V Xtreme
Corona III N Xtreme
Compadre
El Rey del Vallenato
It is also important to consider the new Italian built Hohner Anceleto models:
Rey Del Norte II
Rey Del Norte II S
Rey Del Norte II L
Rey Del Norte III S
Rey Del Norte III L
Rey Del Norte TT S
Rey Del Norte TT L
Rey Del Norte IV
Rey Del Norte II 4
Rey Del Norte III 4
http://anacletoaccordions.com/
-
there is no Classic model now, I don`t even think the Base model of Corona II exists either, it`s plastic Compadre or Full Xpense Xtreme thesedays
Not sure where you've been looking,
Shops mainly, I couldn`t find them when I was looking . Re-checked at Eagle and Hohners site and yeah, the base model does seem to still exist - the rest are expensive special editions or extremes (we`re talking Corona-IIs of course) .. the Corona-II Base is a bargain at eagle music compared to the new Inflated price of the Pokerwork
http://www.hohner.eu/index.php5?1985
Hohner were clever in introducing the Italian range, Gabbanelli seem to have a firm foothold in the south american music scene and these boxes are very Gabbanelli alike.
-
so it would seem that the two overlapped and the cheaper build of the liliput meant it carried on for a while
I've not seen inside a Preciosa but I think you may have meant Preciosa not Liliput.
I have also heard that the Hohner factory was used later in the war to manufacture items required by the war effort, although I don't recall what. This happened in the UK also, of course. I have no idea whether instrument production was suspended.
Somebody posted a pdf, or a link to one, showing dates of manufacture for the different boxes. I don't have a copy to hand. I think it may have been on the Hohner USA site.
I think we should be charging Hohner for all the business advice here. Could run the site for years on the fees. >:E
-
Somebody posted a pdf, or a link to one, showing dates of manufacture for the different boxes. I don't have a copy to hand. I think it may have been on the Hohner USA site.
http://hohnerusa.com/upload/links/l_00000779_Hohner_Accordion_Models_06.pdf
-
so it would seem that the two overlapped and the cheaper build of the liliput meant it carried on for a while
I've not seen inside a Preciosa but I think you may have meant Preciosa not Liliput.
No, I meant that production of the Liliput overlapped with the introduction of the Preciosa and carried on for a while into the timeline of the Preciosa so at a time there were both (or how it would appear to have turned out)
thanks Mike, I have that list, it`s very incomplete (no doublerays mentioned for a start) . it says they started at the same time but the preccy went on longer - that would indicate that the Preccy was the hi-end model and the Liliput the cheaper one (less features and cheaper fittings agree with this) but someone stated here the liliput came first .. Ahh well, whatever ::)...