Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Sandy Flett on June 28, 2012, 04:30:26 PM
-
If I were to endeavour to make reed blocks for use with Hohner reeds and to give the characteristic Hohner sound what type of wood would I use and where would I be able to buy it. I am aware Hohner use plywood for their lower cost melodeons, but what about the likes of the Morino Club or Oeuverture?
-
Some of my old Hohners have spruce blocks, but most have a lightweight, almost grain-free hardwood. My best guess is it's lime (known also as linden; its American cousin is basswood, which is softer and lighter). That would certainly be my choice if I were making Hohner-style blocks. It's the timber of choice for wood-carvers, so if your local specialist timber-merchant can't supply it, try craft suppliers such as Alan Holtham or Craft Supplies - a Google search should throw someone up. Most of them will supply by mail. I guess you're in Scotland - this may be of help http://www.scottishwood.co.uk/index.htm (http://www.scottishwood.co.uk/index.htm)
Graham
-
That's really helpful, Graham, thank you. I live in the south of England, but can google for equivalent in my area.
-
I've just looked through a number of Hohner diatonic and pa blocks, must common timber for the sides of the chambers seems to be some sort of pine or spruce, there is also something that looks more like a soft hardwood, possibly alder, the sole plate is often beech, occasionally sycamore or maple. The mid rib is usually a soft greenish coloured hardwood. Modern Hohner diatonic boxes blocks are made of a cream coloured even grained tropical hardwood possibly Ramon or obeche.
I think Hohner just used whatever was available and reasonably easy to work, with a harder material foe the sole. I don't think there is much magic in the species used.
-
And lafleur of this parish and Stormy Hyde have shown that reed block material doesn't make a huge amount of difference to the sound. Whether there is varnish or not makes a bit more of a difference, but the degree to which this occurs depends on the reed geometry.
-
I've just been working on an old Hohner HA113 with the roughest reedblocks imaginable.
Rough sawn with big chunks missing.
I've seen better looking orange boxes.
Sounds fine, though. (:)
-
And lafleur of this parish and Stormy Hyde have shown that reed block material doesn't make a huge amount of difference to the sound. Whether there is varnish or not makes a bit more of a difference, but the degree to which this occurs depends on the reed geometry.
Does the material of the sole plate matter more than the material of the chambers and rib? For instance you could probably build the block structure from any timber but wouldn't want to have a softwood sole? Sorry to bring this up again. I understand the rigidity arguments for varnish, gluing down blocks, etc. I'm just trying to get this all straight in my head.
-
And lafleur of this parish and Stormy Hyde have shown that reed block material doesn't make a huge amount of difference to the sound. Whether there is varnish or not makes a bit more of a difference, but the degree to which this occurs depends on the reed geometry.
Does the material of the sole plate matter more than the material of the chambers and rib? For instance you could probably build the block structure from any timber but wouldn't want to have a softwood sole? Sorry to bring this up again. I understand the rigidity arguments for varnish, gluing down blocks, etc. I'm just trying to get this all straight in my head.
Hmm, interesting. There are two aspects to this, as you know. Firstly there is the airflow, i.e. the geometry of the block. Forcing the air to travel in different ways leads to unusual effects. In particular, allowing an airflow to impact a boundary will cause some of the energy to be dissipated. How much and over what frequency range is dictated primarily by the air-block interface (citation needed). This means either the material or the finish (if any).
Secondly there is the structural element. Having a material with a low impedance means that the entire block may vibrate. If the material has a low damping ratio then these vibrations will continue. And if the natural frequency of the block coincides with the operating range of the instrument then bad things happen. So the material is important from that aspect too.
So in answer to your question, yes, I believe that the sole plate does matter more than any other part. Partly because the airflow will impact that plate, so it is more critical in terms of the energy lost than any other part (I have no idea how significant this effect is mind) and partly because the flexing of the sole plate is critical to the vibration of the entire block. So yes, I would say that either the sole plate needs to be rigid with a low impedance or the block needs to be glued to the soundboard, and it should (possibly) be varnished.
Make sense? I'm basically making this up as you know, so if anyone disagrees then please do speak up.
-
Sole plates, Beech, Maple, Sycamore
Divider... poplar (linden)
The rest: Spruce or pine
-
Many thanks, all, for the responses and interesting discussion.
Are wood suppliers able to provide small quantities of such woods and in sizes suitable for reedblock making?
-
My guess is that for the quantities required for a few reed blocks they may well refer you to a box of offcuts. Timber merchants are a very varied breed, from those selling construction timber by the truckload, to dealers in exotic woods who sell pre-cut blanks for making small objects such as pen barrels. You want one of the latter type, who probably also sell to instrument makers, and are geared up for supplying small quantities.
-
I think I'd probably look for some nicely seasoned reclaimable timber from some car-boot sale furniture; pre-WW2 drawers are often made with solid timber sides and bases, frequently of decent hardwoods. I have some nice straight fine-grained mahogany about 3/16 in thick that I liberated from the drawer-sides of an old sideboard that was well past saving, and for which I paid absolutely nothing as it was waiting to go into a skip. Much of the carcase was knackered old veneered ply, but the top, doors & drawer fronts were oak and the drawer sides and backs mahogany.
Incidentally, Sandy, I apologise for jumping to a conclusion about your whereabouts - must have been the combination of a Scottish sounding name and a Shand Morino!
Cheers
Graham
-
I think I'd probably look for some nicely seasoned reclaimable timber from some car-boot sale furniture; pre-WW2 drawers are often made with solid timber sides and bases, frequently of decent hardwoods. I have some nice straight fine-grained mahogany about 3/16 in thick that I liberated from the drawer-sides of an old sideboard that was well past saving, and for which I paid absolutely nothing as it was waiting to go into a skip. Much of the carcase was knackered old veneered ply, but the top, doors & drawer fronts were oak and the drawer sides and backs mahogany.
Incidentally, Sandy, I apologise for jumping to a conclusion about your whereabouts - must have been the combination of a Scottish sounding name and a Shand Morino!
Cheers
Graham
Sounds like it could be part of the fun to go looking for nice bits of seasoned wood in old furniture pieces. I assume I could learn from books/internet how to recognise the different woods.
Your assumption was half right, Graham, as I am from Scotland, but I am intrigued to know where you got the Shand Morino connection.
-
My only excuse is that it's currently 34 deg at 75% humidity here at the moment, and my brain isn't working properly....I could have SWORN there was a Shand Morino in your signature line. Must have been someone else I'd been looking at. More apologies - if we ever meet I'll owe you a barful of drinks by the time I'm finished! Speaking of which....... :|glug
;D
Cheers
Graham
-
Ah, your secret is out; you must lurk occasionally on Al's accordionforum.com where my "accordion" signature line refers to a "Shand-era Hohner Morino CBA", which is the nearest I can get to a Shand Morino without being able to play BCC#. So no need to apologise, and anyway, your tip to look out for what might be salvageable from old furniture is worth me buying you a drink - wonder what we would talk about ::).
-
- wonder what we would talk about ::).
Everything and anything box related! I seem to remember that when I bumped into Sandy, we covered an incredible number of subjects in a few minutes (between dances). I also have odd lumps of timber saved from the skip, but nearly all mahogany and teak. Now a case made in teak could really look something, eh?
Rob.
-
My experience is still pretty limited, but it doesn't seem to make a huge difference what type of wood. Any wood I've tried has made good blocks, main thing is stability, I would think. I can hear a difference from the hardest wood I've used (hickory), to the softest (balsa), but both sound good. What makes a bigger difference is the configuration of the block chamber, depth and taper.
I've used balsa twice, both with seemingly the same results, a softer tone that is very rich. I like the tone a lot, but the sound doesn't seem to project as much as the harder woods. The harder woods seem not quite as rich but project more. As I've done with reeds, I also tried mixing woods, as in half the blocks all balsa, and the other half all maple, hoping to get a little of both. Results are positive but not earth shattering.
Main drawback to using softer woods, especially something like spruce or balsa, is repair woods needs to be done by someone who is aware of the wood type, and a very gentle hand. One slip can totally destroy a balsa block.
-
Have you tried just varying the wood of the sole plate Bryan? Say using a harder wood for that and the rest out of Balsa. It would be interesting to see to what extent that would be different, but by the sounds of it it wouldn't be much.
-
If by sole plate, you mean the part at the bottom of the reed, I don't use it. I glue my blocks directly to the faceplate/fondo/palletsoundboard.
On the one I did half and half, I actually used mahogany for the top of the balsa blocks, mainly to lessen chance of block damage when removing reeds.
-
If by sole plate, you mean the part at the bottom of the reed, I don't use it. I glue my blocks directly to the faceplate/fondo/palletsoundboard.
On the one I did half and half, I actually used mahogany for the top of the balsa blocks, mainly to lessen chance of block damage when removing reeds.
Ah, that would explain that one then!
What I'd really like to know is whether the effect of using different woods is audible to people other than luthiers and players...
-
The problem with glueing them in is there is no way to compare. Even building 2 identical accordions doesn't take care of all the little variables. I think there is a difference, it's just a matter of how noticeable..
-
The problem with glueing them in is there is no way to compare. Even building 2 identical accordions doesn't take care of all the little variables. I think there is a difference, it's just a matter of how noticeable..
Quite!
-
I favor walnut for the bass plate, for its workability if for no other reason.
Kimric