Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on July 07, 2012, 12:11:34 PM
-
I'm playing an instrument with a 48 Stradella bass today.
I'm not too bad when I'm doing small jumps e.g. A to G but when it comes to Bb bass note/Bb major chord to A bass note/A minor chord (a fair old leap) I'm really struggling. Is this just a matter of practice/muscle memory or are there any tricks that might help me?
Thanks for any help you can give me! :-\
-
Hi Les - you dont say what key you are playing in so assuming its a direct move from the A diagonal row to the Bb diagonal row its as you say muscle memory or whatever you want to call it. However rather than thinking in terms of going from A to Bb think in terms of down (towaards feet not musically) 6 diagonal rows down( counting the row you are starting from. Start by practicing 'down 3' eg A to G diagonal then down 4 then down 5 then down 6 . The reason for up or down so many diagonals is that it then works for any key.
Another way if you just want say a quick Bb (maj or min) following a Gmaj play the G maj with ist finger and the little finger should just about dangle over the Bbmaj and with a little side movement pot the Bb min. In other words ist to little finger should just about span 6 diagonal rows.
but at the end of the day its all about getting the feel of it & many find playing in frontof a mirror helpful to begin with.
george.
-
Hi George,
I'm playing in F major. The bit I'm struggling on is a fairly standard run down a few bars into the tune as follows:-
|Bb - Am| Gm - F | - I'm playing the typical oom-pah (bass note/chord) for 2 beats on each chord
Your tips are helpful and of course this needs a bit of good old fashioned practice!!
Thanks!
-
Hi
As others have implied there are several ways of getting there.
If I have understood you correctly:-
In your example of playing A minor after Bb
If you are able to play an A minor chord in the treble then you could just play a the A in the counter bass row which is in the F row (one row up from Bb) and play the counter bass A and treble chord in an “oompah†rhythm. (This is “slightly cheating†)
Or
Use the markings on the E bass button, which is either a raised rough surface or has a concave surface.
So you could:-
1) Play your Bb bass & chord
2) Slide up the bass row.
3) Move past the C bass key which is either a raised rough surface or has a concave surface.
4) Move up to the E Bass row
5) Move one row down to A
If I am not going to play the notes with the markings I tend to feel for them with either my middle or index finger and then move up or down a row accordingly.
I use my ring finger for Bass & counter bass notes
Everyone has their own method which they are comfortable with. It’s what works for you
Just my 2p worth
-
Thanks jb and Reedwarbler! (:)
-
I think it's all been said now, but to summarize:
1 - from one bass note to another a semitone away, there's usually a counterbass not far away.
2 - if you really need fundamental basses for both notes, a semitone step is almost the biggest leap you can make and you just have to get good at making the jump accurately by practice.
3 - in some cases you can go in either direction, i.e. the note you are looking for is duplicated. This happens when there are more than 12 rows of basses. In that case the duplicate may be easier to reach in a particular context.
-
As on the melodeon, the 'forked' minor 7th chords mean less jumping and sound nice!
So, in the key of F, your Am7 chord would be substituted for the Am you're looking for. This is an F counter-bass of A with a C chord.
Move this hand position down two rows and you have a Gm7.
This might mean that a sustained LH is more appropriate than the oom-pah... I'm guessing that the chords move quickly, judging by the specifics of the progression, so this might work better anyway. I'd personally try to avoid the leaps you're talking about!
Happy to do a quick youtube vid or similar if I'm not making sense...! What's the tune?
-
PS - the John Spiers 'C over D' forked melodeon chord is also nice on Stradella. In this case, it's on the opposite diagonal from the minor 7th chords described above, i.e. D bass with C chord....
-
(... in F it'd be Bb chord over C bass at the ends of phrases)
It's an addictive chord...
-
As on the melodeon, the 'forked' minor 7th chords mean less jumping and sound nice!
So, in the key of F, your Am7 chord would be substituted for the Am you're looking for. This is an F counter-bass of A with a C chord.
Move this hand position down two rows and you have a Gm7.
This might mean that a sustained LH is more appropriate than the oom-pah... I'm guessing that the chords move quickly, judging by the specifics of the progression, so this might work better anyway. I'd personally try to avoid the leaps you're talking about!
Happy to do a quick youtube vid or similar if I'm not making sense...! What's the tune?
Thanks - yes this is great. Obviously the full minor triad would be preferable but the min7 workaround is perfectly acceptable.
I've attached the tune - it's one of mine.
-
Don't think it's obvious at all. The true 5th in a chord is feeble harmonically - it is basically no more than 3rd harmonic of the bass. It's my first choice note to miss out (in Ab I have to miss the Ab out) if I'm struggling for fingers in a rich chord.
Whereas there's a lot of 'colour' in the 7th. And the third is the ultimate 'colour' note in a chord - difference between major and minor! So don't worry if it sounds OK.
-
Don't think it's obvious at all. The true 5th in a chord is feeble harmonically - it is basically no more than 3rd harmonic of the bass. It's my first choice note to miss out (in Ab I have to miss the Ab out) if I'm struggling for fingers in a rich chord.
Whereas there's a lot of 'colour' in the 7th. And the third is the ultimate 'colour' note in a chord - difference between major and minor! So don't worry if it sounds OK.
Sorry, I should have said that I specifically want the minor chords here rather than the minor 7ths. I agree that minor 7th chords often sound more tasteful/subtle but not for me in this particular case.