Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: robinbid on July 08, 2012, 03:27:58 PM

Title: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: robinbid on July 08, 2012, 03:27:58 PM
Dear all - I need help
I've found that I tend to speed up through a tune and, especially when playing in public, I actually start off at 100mph and then race myself to the end - much to the consternation of the fiddle players. I tap my foot, but have found that I just tap quicker! Has anyone got any advice, tips, limericks that I can put into practice to have a less frantic musical experience?
Many thanks
robin
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: arty on July 08, 2012, 03:41:12 PM
Forgive me, as I am a beginner on the melodeon but I have experience on other instruments. The way to stop the tendency of slowing/speeding up during the course of a piece of music, is to practice A LOT with a metronome. And when you've done that, practice some more, with a metronome!
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Anahata on July 08, 2012, 03:44:11 PM
And avoid the temptation to take the metronome back to the shop because it slows down while you're playing  :P
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: arty on July 08, 2012, 04:00:35 PM
And avoid the temptation to take the metronome back to the shop because it slows down while you're playing  :P

HaHa! I've known that....don't forget to wind it up!
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 08, 2012, 04:24:12 PM
If you're ever going to achieve it, you need to calm down!  The racing start is the norm at first, as you're nervous, excited and your pulse is racing.  The adrenalin just keeps pumping as you go along until your fingers just can't keep up.  Been there - done that....

After a decade of playing, I'm still inclined to introduce a decoration in the first phrase which I can't manage comfortably if the pace is to fast.  I also often imagine a friend dancing - elegant and precise, it helps as I know she just wouldn't look as great if I force the pace.  It's all about achieving a level of detachment from the event and just being in the tune.

Rob.
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Anahata on July 08, 2012, 04:28:02 PM
I also often imagine a friend dancing

Actually, playing for real dancers should be a good discipline for learning accurate rhythm. It works best if you're playing solo, so you aren't relying on someone else to keep you in time.
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Lester on July 08, 2012, 04:32:55 PM
I also often imagine a friend dancing

Actually, playing for real dancers should be a good discipline for learning accurate rhythm. It works best if you're playing solo, so you aren't relying on someone else to keep you in time.

100% agree with this. Nothing focuses the mind than 6 sweaty bloke telling you you are speeding up  :D
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: george garside on July 08, 2012, 04:37:33 PM
and if you havn't ot any real dancers  shut your eyes and imagine some!  It helps to know ehy you are playing a tune as the same basic tune can be used for different purposes and at different speeds . Not haaving that sense of purpose can result in the tune coming out as neither one thing nor t'other. Eg The Athol Highlanders is by rights a pipe march and  if so played must be at a speed that would enable a sqad of men to march many miles to its rhythm (about 90)  ON the other hand it makes a cracking tune for rapper  for which it is played as a fast jig so the iage of whas required will be quite different.  Somewhere in between it can be plyed for  the Gay Gordons  and again a mental image of people dancing the gay gordons helps a lot.

Many 3/4 tunes can be played as aires, ballad accompaniment  vienese \( fairly brisk ) waltzes or slow 'smoochy ' waltzes  - same tune, different speed , phrasing and dynamics.

etc etc etc

george
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Theo on July 08, 2012, 06:14:10 PM
Playing with another musician who you know is able to keep a steady pace can also help, as is playing along with a recording.
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 08, 2012, 06:58:02 PM
Actually, playing for real dancers should be a good discipline for learning accurate rhythm. It works best if you're playing solo, so you aren't relying on someone else to keep you in time

Very, very, true, Doesn't matter that much what dancers either. I posted this video (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9853.0.html) yesterday afternoon and it's a nice example as these two are the most 'on beat' I've come across.  They are playing for a dance (here a mazurka) and play for dance more often than not. (I can confirm that they practice to metronomes). In their courses you have to clap rhythms, stamp even beats, sometime they make you do three.

    Try the video and click the control bar to flick between start and end of a 10 minute tune (with loads going on..) - absolutely solid rhythm.  :P

... whereas your mainland Britain English or Irish pub session - ne'er a dancer in sight  - and all over the place.  I rest my case (and thank Anahata for making it for me)  ;)
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 09, 2012, 10:08:18 AM
I think you're on the way simply because you recognise you are speeding up or starting too fast.
Sadly the world of sessions is littered with speed merchants who have no idea, or don't care. You are aware and do care!
I'm prone to this too, so I try and take a deep breath, think about the tune in my mind possibly a touch slower than optimum, then try and play the first few bars like that.
Then relax into it.
Q
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Chris Brimley on July 09, 2012, 11:48:53 AM
I think the answer is twofold - first, you have to tap your foot somehow, and second, you already have to be able to play the tune unconsciously, so that your conscious mind is engaged 'in the groove', i.e the timing, rhythm and phrasing.  Only then will your fingers trust your foot!
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: george garside on July 09, 2012, 12:16:35 PM
providing you know why you are playing a tune  keeping steady solo is not that difficult using a bit of mental imagery  of  dancers, marchers or whatever or in the case of a song singing it in ones head so to speak.  I find  it far more difficult in a session where some bugger devoid of phrasing, dynamics etc hijacks your tune  & goes loudly & relentlessly ever onwards at  a speed that is just that bit faster than it should be.  IN such sistuations I usually concede defeat  anad go for a pee, to the bar or whatever!

george
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 09, 2012, 02:23:01 PM
I think if I'm really trying I might well hum along as jb suggests - never analysed itr that closely!
Interesting thought that singing/humming is more resiliant to pressure.
Q
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Strigulino on July 09, 2012, 02:53:14 PM
Must admit I always visualised things like elephants walking.  I blame Fantasia.  Something plodding steadily.  Think of the feet plodding and the hips swaying at the speed I want to play at, then join in. 
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: oggiesnr on July 09, 2012, 03:12:34 PM
May I refer you to this thread? http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9365.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9365.0.html)

Steve
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Chris Brimley on July 09, 2012, 03:16:55 PM
Quote
But he is tapping his foot - see the original post.

jb, I realise that, and entirely agree with you.  I said it because I agree it is necessary to do so, but not sufficient, you also have to relax into the rhythm, as you say.  The best foot-tappers, (of which I am not one!), seem to do it quietly, I've noticed - I've wondered whether that's a subtle but good way of making the other musicians concentrate - by giving the deliberate appearance of calm!
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: ladydetemps on July 09, 2012, 03:30:20 PM
I have imaginary dancers in my head...if they can't dance to it I'm going too fast. Also take up dancing. ;)

I also find if I record myself playing....then try to play along with myself, it shows up problems with speed.
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Clive Williams on July 09, 2012, 03:45:14 PM
A few thoughts:

To start at a decent pace, think the tune through in your head at the pace you'd like, tap your foot to that, and keep it tapping at that pace and start playing against it.

As a variation on that, if playing for ceilidh dances, take your pace from the dancers during the walkthrough - almost inevitably there is a 'gallop down to the bottom bit' or something similar in the dance where the dancers find themselves stamping round the hall/clapping etc during the walkthrough. Set your pace against that (they'll all naturally fall into sync with each other), tap your foot to it, and keep going at that pace until ready to start. Then start the tune to that rhythm/speed.

To guard against speed up, if tapping your foot, try tapping with your heel rather than your toe as most people would.

I certainly used to, and probably still do, speed up at tricky bits, ornamentations, bits with "clever" harmony/etc. Be aware of your speed at those points in particular, and you may be able to counter the effect...

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Marje on July 09, 2012, 05:12:26 PM
I agree that you're on the way to controlling it because you've recognised the problem. The worst offenders are those who speed up time after time and then say it was all due to other people, or to some vague force within the tune itself.

I do the "imaginary dancers" thing too sometimes, or imagine dancing to it myself. Playing to real dancers might help, but if it didn't, you'd have an irritated and breathless group of dancers to contend with by the end.

Sometimes people speed up by inadvertently shortening the long notes, or the gaps between notes or at the end of lines/sections. "Play" the rests and the silences just as methodically as you play the notes.

And yes, a metronome is he way to test yourself, and find out where you tend to speed up and why. I find 6/8 tunes are more susceptible to acceleration - not just by me but by musicians generally. You may have your own weak spots and a metronome will help you identify them.
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: george garside on July 09, 2012, 06:02:03 PM
for what its worth the late Will Atkinson, mouthie player supreme  ( and pretty good on a shand morino as well) once said  to someone  who was speeeding up in a workshop he was running " every tune has a natural speed - and you would find it a lot easier to play at its natural speed.  And that was to then secretary of the British Harmonica Society no less!

george ;D
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Stiamh on July 09, 2012, 06:30:10 PM
I agree that you're on the way to controlling it because you've recognised the problem.

Agreed.Speaking as a former regular offender, propensity to recidivism much reduced in latter years but not entirely eliminated, depending greatly on the circumstances.

Quote
The worst offenders are those who speed up time after time and then say it was all due to other people, or to some vague force within the tune itself.

Agreed, also, but I do believe that weird things can happen between different players, all to do with those nebulous notions of playing on, behind, or ahead of the beat, or people's internal rhythm when playing tunes - internal meaning what they do in between strong beats.

There are a couple of people that I find it very difficult to play with because of this. Left to their own devices they may play at a steady enough tempo, but when I play with them they often seem to be anticipating the beat by the tiniest fraction, or at any rate that's what it feels like to me. (The people involved have a certain stiffness to the way they play, also.) This creates a very uncomfortable feeling, and my natural response is to advance to land on the beat at the same time as they do, and before you know it they are "ahead" again, and a vicious cycle of speeding up can quickly ensue.

The only way I can avoid speeding up in this situation is to grit my teeth, concentrate very hard on my own foot, and suffer the uncomfortable tension that results. Or stop playing, of course, but you can't do that all the time. Especially if you're playing a gig with them - which you won't do by choice of course.

I hasten to add that this happens with only a very small minority of people I play with so I feel safe in saying I'm not the source of the problem, even if I am vulnerable to its effects and don't deal with it very successfully much of the time.
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Theo on July 09, 2012, 06:46:00 PM
And with tapping the foot on reels polkas rants and other common time tunes only tap two beats in the bar. Tapping four beats in the bar in these tunes leads to speed because it means too many beats are being emphasised.
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: waltzman on July 09, 2012, 10:24:41 PM
I certainly used to, and probably still do, speed up at tricky bits, ornamentations, bits with "clever" harmony/etc. Be aware of your speed at those points in particular, and you may be able to counter the effect...

This is where I find working with a metronome to be most useful.  It will show you where in the tune you have a tendency to speed up (or slow down for that matter).
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Larry Stout on July 09, 2012, 10:33:26 PM
I think the answer is twofold - first, you have to tap your foot somehow, and second, you already have to be able to play the tune unconsciously, so that your conscious mind is engaged 'in the groove', i.e the timing, rhythm and phrasing.  Only then will your fingers trust your foot!


If you don;t have control of the speed with your playing you probably don't have the control with foot tapping either.  Concentrate on the music, not on foot stomping.

Sorry, it's one of my betes noir.
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Mike Hirst on July 10, 2012, 12:36:38 AM
It has previously been mentioned in this thread that playing for dancers is a useful method for achieving steady tempo. In addition to this I have a Scottish Pipe Tutor which suggests marching on the spot as good way to set tune speed. Can I suggest a third technique of dancing to your own music, as is ably demonstrated by these two girls:

http://youtu.be/HSIbpjsbH40
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: robinbid on July 10, 2012, 12:54:17 AM
Thanks for all the helpful replies, though I am still awaiting the limerick.... I have to make an admission that I am trying to play Cajun and the number of dancers available to test my abilities on are limited. I've played other instruments (trombone) for morris clog, but I seem unable to get the wonderful laid back feel of the likes of Chris Miller (http://www.youtube.com/user/cpm6miller), though perhaps I should have started learning 25 years earlier.....
Still, I'll see how my new view of the world of rhythm works on wednesday at Norrie's cafe in Leominster when Clungumbo makes a strike outside of South Shropshire.....wish me luck!
cheers
robin
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Anahata on July 10, 2012, 07:52:09 AM
If you don;t have control of the speed with your playing you probably don't have the control with foot tapping either.

Yes. I don't know why I didn't pick up on that before - I've never been sure that it works.
Foot tapping isn't a good habit to get into anyway. (It's fine if your audience does it!)
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 10, 2012, 08:11:57 AM
I got thoroughly bo11ocked for foot-tapping at the Siska Huyghe's Impro weekend in Gent last November  :|bl
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Chris Brimley on July 10, 2012, 11:57:10 AM
I'm actually quite surprised to find that there's so clearly such a divide between foot-tappers and non-foot tappers, here.

In defence of the foot-tappers:

It's using a kind of natural pendulum.

It shows others in the band what speed is underlying your playing, and vice versa.  (As a bass player I find many live situations - such as no foldback, poor balance, or noisy audience, where if we didn't have the lead singer's foot to rely on to set the intended speed, it would almost certainly fall apart!)

You don't have to make any noise with your foot to get the benefits, though many do, with good effect.

Like a metronome, it provides a sharp 'transient', as opposed to the less attacking transients inherent in most boxes.

It's a 'groove' thing - it doesn't only set the tempo, it somehow allows you to stress the internal rhythm of the music more easily.

So many (most?) musicians do it automatically, so they must clearly find it helps them.

It makes the playing more enjoyable, and audiences pick up on that!

Now I'm not saying foot-tapping is the only way, but it's surely a good way of helping you keep time?  Sometimes a tune does not actually need a constant rhythm, or change in rhythm is part of the music.  Some people perhaps have a very good internal sense of rhythm, and don't need the metronome effect.   It is of course essential to match the time of other musicians, but even then that may be best achieved by everyone making sure they keep their feet in time, rather than by trying to follow each other's playing.  And I've noticed that sometimes I don't need to do it - I play in a dance band where I tend to set the initial speed of the tune on the box, and the band's rhythm section (bass and keyboard) immediately take over that speed, and are then rock solid.  From then on, I can just play, the right notes seem to come out from nowhere, and I can tell you it just makes me laugh!  In the words of the great Ginger Baker, 'Sometimes you're not playing the drums, they're playing you.'


Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: waltzman on July 10, 2012, 01:26:40 PM
I'm actually quite surprised to find that there's so clearly such a divide between foot-tappers and non-foot tappers, here.

I find that very surprising too.  I really can't understand why anyone would think it was detrimental unless it's producing an undesirable noise.  I agree with Chris... tapping the foot is a very simple movement to help ground the rhythm and tempo whereas playing an instrument involves very complex movements that may be much more difficult to keep steady.  It's a simple way of getting the rhythm and tempo 'in the body' and feeling it when you are playing an instrument and not dancing yourself.
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: melodyman on July 10, 2012, 01:45:51 PM
 "though perhaps I should have started learning 25 years earlier.."

Couldn't agree more !

Although a little off thread I can remember that before I was morris savvy, and whilst watching a morris group on the South Bank (Thames),  I must of been tapping my foot.
One of the dancers politely asked me not too.
It was not till I started to play the melodeon ( at age 53 ) and started to play for a morris side that it is not always a regular beat.

So now I am 60 and have a good sense of time/rhythm (thanks for saying so) and I tap my foot when leading a dance/session but am very wary when not leading.

enough said

davied
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Stiamh on July 10, 2012, 03:53:27 PM
As a bass player I find many live situations - such as no foldback, poor balance, or noisy audience, where if we didn't have the lead singer's foot to rely on to set the intended speed, it would almost certainly fall apart!

At about 3:40 in this very nice compilation of clips (http://youtu.be/qeYFA-1KfjY) of the brilliant John James, he tells the story of Elvis' backing musicians having to rely on the twitch of Presley's bum! 

Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: george garside on July 10, 2012, 05:04:37 PM
to me foot tapping is an integral   part of  the spontanaity of folk/traditional music.  Frowning on it is an affectation loved by some of those of a classical disposition

george >:E
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Chris Brimley on July 10, 2012, 05:52:12 PM
But George, don't those classical types have someone at the front waving a little stick about for the same reason? ;)
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Sandy on July 10, 2012, 06:01:36 PM
I'm a foot tapper...I think it helps me find that inner metronome that is in harmony with the music rather than running along side it. Just need to be careful on what footwear is involved and keep it all under control. I think Andy Cutting is a master of the foot and heel tap. I have been comparing foot and heel tapping (hope that doesn't sound weird :D). Julian Sutton's tap is very cool  8)

I do think it helps me keep a steady tempo overall.

Cheers,

Sandy
 (:)
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: oggiesnr on July 10, 2012, 06:16:42 PM
Toe tapping is fine so long as your internal metronome keeps your toe tapping at a constant pace.  One of the worst "speeder uppers "I know keeps in perfect time with his feet, it's just that his feet speed up!

The issue comes down to how you make your internal metronome accurate enough to control either your instrument directly or your feet and then your instrument.

Steve
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Anahata on July 10, 2012, 07:07:52 PM
Toe tapping is fine so long as your internal metronome keeps your toe tapping at a constant pace.  One of the worst "speeder uppers "I know keeps in perfect time with his feet, it's just that his feet speed up!

This is exactly what happens if I know I am speeding up while practicing and I try foot tapping to keep time!
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 11, 2012, 08:19:18 AM
(http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41FoUuMJJfL._AA160_.jpg)

£13.99
(http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41OSVt2QafL._AA160_.jpg)

£8.99
or www.metronomeonline.com
(there are many others)
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: oggiesnr on July 11, 2012, 11:50:11 AM
Or there are free apps for smart phones.  I use Mobile Metronome which I've found the most fexible so far, allows a wide range of time signatures, emphasis on first beat or not and you ca tap in the time you want in real time (I've used this for "timing" dancers so I can then practice at their preferred pace).

Steve
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: robinbid on July 12, 2012, 09:09:37 AM
Dear all
happy to say that our session went well last night. Having been working hard on my internal metronome, our first tune was a bit too fast, but then after getting a grip and concentrating things went a lot better. Unfortunately, there was no space for people to dance, but the audience help by tapping their feet(!) to help us a long. There were even people who sang along to J'ai fait un gros erreur. Thanks to Mark and Jill of the Rhythm Thieves who hosted the evening and were very encouraging and thanks for all the helpful advice from Melnetters which got me thinking about what I'm doing.
cheers
robin
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Stiamh on July 12, 2012, 12:00:53 PM
That's great to hear, Robin. Obviously people were right when they said that being aware of the problem is the most important first step in fixing it!

There were even people who sang along to J'ai fait un gros erreur.

Ça, par contre, c'est une petite erreur... on dit une grosse erreur. Excuse the pedantry, can't help it... what the French call a déformation professionnelle.  ;)
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: robinbid on July 12, 2012, 01:52:26 PM
I know - I had to check it myself, but that's how it's spelt on one of Marc Savoy's albums and that's good enough for me. Cajun French doesn't always follow the conventions, it appears.
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Stiamh on July 12, 2012, 02:40:52 PM
Thanks Robin. There must be a name for that kind of statement - one that unintentionally demonstrates what you're saying.
Title: Re: Speeding up - how do I slow down??
Post by: Anahata on July 12, 2012, 04:24:09 PM
A self-referential sentence. There isn't a single word for it, but there is a word autological for a word that describes itself, like "polysyllabic"

There is also a relevant internet proverb Skitt's Law (http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/skitts-law) that says whenever you correct someone else's spelling or grammar you will make a mistake in your correction.

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal