And avoid the temptation to take the metronome back to the shop because it slows down while you're playing :P
I also often imagine a friend dancing
I also often imagine a friend dancing
Actually, playing for real dancers should be a good discipline for learning accurate rhythm. It works best if you're playing solo, so you aren't relying on someone else to keep you in time.
Actually, playing for real dancers should be a good discipline for learning accurate rhythm. It works best if you're playing solo, so you aren't relying on someone else to keep you in time
But he is tapping his foot - see the original post.
I agree that you're on the way to controlling it because you've recognised the problem.
The worst offenders are those who speed up time after time and then say it was all due to other people, or to some vague force within the tune itself.
I certainly used to, and probably still do, speed up at tricky bits, ornamentations, bits with "clever" harmony/etc. Be aware of your speed at those points in particular, and you may be able to counter the effect...
I think the answer is twofold - first, you have to tap your foot somehow, and second, you already have to be able to play the tune unconsciously, so that your conscious mind is engaged 'in the groove', i.e the timing, rhythm and phrasing. Only then will your fingers trust your foot!
If you don;t have control of the speed with your playing you probably don't have the control with foot tapping either.
I'm actually quite surprised to find that there's so clearly such a divide between foot-tappers and non-foot tappers, here.
As a bass player I find many live situations - such as no foldback, poor balance, or noisy audience, where if we didn't have the lead singer's foot to rely on to set the intended speed, it would almost certainly fall apart!
Toe tapping is fine so long as your internal metronome keeps your toe tapping at a constant pace. One of the worst "speeder uppers "I know keeps in perfect time with his feet, it's just that his feet speed up!
(http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41FoUuMJJfL._AA160_.jpg) £13.99 | (http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41OSVt2QafL._AA160_.jpg) £8.99 |
or www.metronomeonline.com | (there are many others) |
There were even people who sang along to J'ai fait un gros erreur.