Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: syale on July 09, 2012, 02:06:58 PM

Title: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: syale on July 09, 2012, 02:06:58 PM
I am keen to learn about tuning reeds as part of a long term plan for when I finish work, hopefully in about 10 years! I plan on buying an old box to practice tuning on. What other purchases would I need to make to enable me?

What recommendations can the forum give on how to start learning. I see tons of info online about the theory and text orientated sites about what to do but not much visual stuff. Is there a course I can take in reed tuning or would I be better placed to ask the guy who is tuning one of my boxes now about apprenticing under him (that is, of course, if he would let me!). I am reading the text based sites to get a better appreciation of the principles but I know from experience hands on brings so much more.

Do Hohner have any maintenence courses available. I see some info on tuning harmonicas. Are the principles the same?

I also see software to help with tuning. Is digital software better or does an old fashioned strobe give better results?
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Jon Loomes on July 09, 2012, 03:09:34 PM
get an old Piano box to start with - loads of reeds. Take the whole thing up a semitone (file the reed tips). Then take it back down to pitch (file the stem of the reed about a third of the way up fom the rivet).  This will ruin the box, but at the end of this you'll know two important things:  how to do it and whether or not you want to.  Software strobe tuners work fine.

Good luck!

Cheers,
J
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: waltzman on July 09, 2012, 05:18:04 PM
I taught myself to tune with the help of this forum, mainly.  It really is not complicated or difficult and reeds are tough.  I think it would be difficult to ruin a reed.  I have not ruined one so far.  PA reeds are certainly the cheapest source of reeds but Hohner diatonics are available pretty cheaply on Ebay too so if that is your interest I would get yourself a Hohner diatonic in a key that you want and just go for it.  There is a DVD available from Marc Savoy that has a  section on tuning an accordion that is very down to earth.  I think it is called the Gospel Accordion to Marc vol 2.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: blafleur on July 09, 2012, 06:00:23 PM
Syale, just curious, who is tuning for you now?  Is he tuning for Cajun music or other? 

I also thought Savoy's dvd had a useful section on tuning, especially if you're wanting to tune for Cajun music.  The actual mechanics of tuning is the same for anything, but there are some nuances to each type of music, in addition to taste, that come in to play.

A lot of people use rotary power tools, like a Dremel. I started out with a Dremel, but have switched to files.  I bought some good Swiss files from a gunsmith supply and have since moth balled my Dremel. I feel I get more control with files, they can be faster, a lot less forgiving of slips, and provide a better finish (not sure how much finish matters but it makes me feel better).  This does not apply to cheap local hardware store needle files.

You also need to learn about reed gaps.  No one told me about that when I began, and my first couple seemed to use a lot of air, then I learned that when tuning, you can change the reed gap, making it take a lot more air to start, or, not start at all.  There is a sweet spot with each reed regarding the gap that allows it to start quick and not choke.  I rule of thumb is the thickness of the reed, but that is only a rule of thumb.

You also need to learn about the valves. Valves and reed gaps seem to account for a lot of sound issues.

The whole thing is definitely not rocket science, but there is much more to it than I had first anticipated, but if you don't mind tedious work, it's fun learning.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Lester on July 09, 2012, 06:21:29 PM
The whole thing is definitely not rocket science, but there is much more to it than I had first anticipated, but if you don't mind tedious work, it's fun learning.

It may well not be rocket science but there is a whole lot of Black Magic, 100% agree about gaps, valves etc in addition I use a scraper to flatten reeds rather than a file but each to their own.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: syale on July 09, 2012, 06:38:51 PM
Tuning for a box I have in at the moment is with a guy called Wienart Grohmann here in Houston. He is tuning for Newfoundland/Quebecois wet tuning. He had another accordion there, which I really enjoyed the sound from, with +6flat -7sharp if I recall correctly. Wienart has been tuning for 45 years and comes recommended from someone local. There is a store in Pasadena but I prefer a recommend from someone else any day. Wienart has told me he isn't fast but I have time! He uses a strobe to get there and ear the rest of the way. Really nice guy as well!
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: blafleur on July 09, 2012, 07:32:10 PM
Tuning for a box I have in at the moment is with a guy called Wienart Grohmann here in Houston. He is tuning for Newfoundland/Quebecois wet tuning. He had another accordion there, which I really enjoyed the sound from, with +6flat -7sharp if I recall correctly. Wienart has been tuning for 45 years and comes recommended from someone local. There is a store in Pasadena but I prefer a recommend from someone else any day. Wienart has told me he isn't fast but I have time! He uses a strobe to get there and ear the rest of the way. Really nice guy as well!

Interesting, didn't know there was a guy in Texas that tuned for other than Cajun or Tejano.  Man if he'd be willing to do a tuning apprenticeship that would be a golden opportunity.  Seems like a decent Polish community around you who may be able to use that guy as well.

I also use a strobe to get a baseline then finish by ear.  I also keep a cheap guitar tuner handy for getting in the ballpark if I don't know the note, or if it's way off.  Got it after I tuned an ancient Hohner for Cory where he handed me a box of reeds to sort out.  Also handy after dropping a set on the ground. 
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Graham W on July 09, 2012, 08:00:29 PM
IIs there a course I can take in reed tuning

http://www.itemm.fr/  run accordeon tuning courses, among many other things . . . but all taught in French :(
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: syale on July 16, 2012, 04:11:28 AM
Anybody have any experience of DaTuner (http://www.applaudapps.net/ (http://www.applaudapps.net/)) on an android device for tuning a melodeon  ?
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Quebecois on July 16, 2012, 08:53:01 PM
I use gStrings on Android, available from the Google store. Very nice tuner for its price!
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Keithypete. on July 17, 2012, 12:14:51 AM
 I intend to try some reed tuning, as part of a project that will include replacing valves as necessary, and therefore re-waxing too. Once a reed-plate has been removed, obviously it will be easier to tune the inner reed, but how does it seal to whatever sort of tuning table being used?
   
 Secondly, once each reed-plate has been tuned, is it then replaced straightaway, or is a whole set put back on together?
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Martyn on July 17, 2012, 12:25:06 AM
I intend to try some reed tuning, as part of a project that will include replacing valves as necessary, and therefore re-waxing too. Once a reed-plate has been removed, obviously it will be easier to tune the inner reed, but how does it seal to whatever sort of tuning table being used?
   
 Secondly, once each reed-plate has been tuned, is it then replaced straightaway, or is a whole set put back on together?

The best way to do it is to remove all the reeds from the blocks, re-valve and re-wax them back in, then tune them in the blocks. If you try to tune the reeds out of the blocks the tuning will be different when you put them back in.

Martyn
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Keithypete. on July 17, 2012, 01:02:21 AM
I intend to try some reed tuning, as part of a project that will include replacing valves as necessary, and therefore re-waxing too. Once a reed-plate has been removed, obviously it will be easier to tune the inner reed, but how does it seal to whatever sort of tuning table being used?
   
 Secondly, once each reed-plate has been tuned, is it then replaced straightaway, or is a whole set put back on together?

The best way to do it is to remove all the reeds from the blocks, re-valve and re-wax them back in, then tune them in the blocks. If you try to tune the reeds out of the blocks the tuning will be different when you put them back in.

Martyn


 So tuning of the inner reed is done through the reed-plate? Tricky, I should think. I imagine its easy to exert too much pressure and make a mess of things, as the reed is unsupported.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Lester on July 17, 2012, 07:37:44 AM
I intend to try some reed tuning, as part of a project that will include replacing valves as necessary, and therefore re-waxing too. Once a reed-plate has been removed, obviously it will be easier to tune the inner reed, but how does it seal to whatever sort of tuning table being used?
   
 Secondly, once each reed-plate has been tuned, is it then replaced straightaway, or is a whole set put back on together?

The best way to do it is to remove all the reeds from the blocks, re-valve and re-wax them back in, then tune them in the blocks. If you try to tune the reeds out of the blocks the tuning will be different when you put them back in.

Martyn


 So tuning of the inner reed is done through the reed-plate? Tricky, I should think. I imagine its easy to exert too much pressure and make a mess of things, as the reed is unsupported.

I will be doing some tuning today, I will try and take some photos that may help.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Keithypete. on July 17, 2012, 11:43:13 AM
Thanks Lester.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 17, 2012, 01:23:33 PM
Thanks Lester.
Not wishing to forestall Lester's offer at all, but a couple of years or so ago Theo also posted a link to a set of his photos (http://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.110159238166.95032.709188166&l=5be6150682) dealing with this very topic. Click on each photo in turn to see a caption with more information about what is going on.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Keithypete. on July 17, 2012, 01:41:30 PM
Thanks Steve. It would still be interesting to see Lester handiwork.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Lester on July 17, 2012, 05:05:33 PM
Thanks Steve. It would still be interesting to see Lester handiwork.

Not sure there is much I can add to Theo's photos. I use the Italian style lifter and my own version which I use when tuning on my tuning table which is just a straitened Italian lifter which I up through through the air hole in the bottom of the block to lift the  reed.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Telemorris on July 17, 2012, 05:56:15 PM

 So tuning of the inner reed is done through the reed-plate? Tricky, I should think. I imagine its easy to exert too much pressure and make a mess of things, as the reed is unsupported.

Support of the reed tongue is fairly easy to do. Take a look at the drawing here showing the use of a "reed pinger." (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5955.msg75732.html#msg75732) it's a simple tool that I use almost exclusively for lifting the tongue of the inside reed. I have several different thicknesses of "pinger" to take care of differences in the gap between the end of the tongue and the chamber.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Keithypete. on July 17, 2012, 08:52:11 PM
Magic, our Morris!! :-D
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Adam-T on July 17, 2012, 09:18:40 PM
Magic, our Morris!! :-D

Is it, Great where are you dancing next , may come and see .......... (Sorry, couldn`t resist)
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: syale on July 17, 2012, 09:50:30 PM
Hohner have a set of videos on youtube about harmonica tuning which shows the process quite well for tuning inner reeds.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: HansW on July 28, 2012, 11:49:25 PM
Hi
I found this video helpful: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ee1VSeALd6g
cheers, hans
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Lester on July 29, 2012, 07:05:06 AM
Hi
I found this video helpful: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ee1VSeALd6g
cheers, hans

Interesting video but gives the impression that you can tune reeds off the block, wax them on and then install the blocks and all will be well. This is, in my experience, far from true. The tuning will be altered both by fixing the reeds to the blocks and, to a lesser extent, by fitting the blocks in the box.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Anahata on July 29, 2012, 08:38:53 AM
One way to deal with this is after reassembly to make a list of all the reed pitch errors in cents, then strip the box down again and adjust each reed in the equal and opposite direction.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: HansW on July 29, 2012, 11:00:27 AM
Hi
I will ask Martin about that, -- see him next week anyway.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Prestidigitator on July 29, 2012, 01:42:55 PM

 So tuning of the inner reed is done through the reed-plate? Tricky, I should think. I imagine its easy to exert too much pressure and make a mess of things, as the reed is unsupported.

Support of the reed tongue is fairly easy to do. Take a look at the drawing here showing the use of a "reed pinger." (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5955.msg75732.html#msg75732) it's a simple tool that I use almost exclusively for lifting the tongue of the inside reed. I have several different thicknesses of "pinger" to take care of differences in the gap between the end of the tongue and the chamber.

I've found that a very small (6mm x 4mm x 2mm) but powerful neodymium magnet, glued to a wooden handle, is very useful for lifting the reed end to insert a pinger, especially when the reed is depressed some way into the recess. It will also lift an inside reed up enough to put the pinger in without too much twisting and turning; although this gets more difficult to do as you go up the block and the reed tongues are shorter and stiffer, and therefore harder to lift.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: HansW on August 04, 2012, 04:25:57 PM
Hi
I asked Martin and this was his answer: Yes, the reeds go out of tune when being put into the accordion.  It could be up to +4 cent in Paolo's and +2 cent in Hohners.  He takes a reading with the reeds still in the instrument and then another reading when the reeds are removed from the blocks.  Comparing both readings gives him an idea how much he has to correct the tuning suit the instrument. (clever idea!)
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: diatonix on August 06, 2012, 06:32:02 AM
The final tuning must be done with the reed blocks in situ, using either a tuning bellows or the instrument itself. Not only in order to compensate for inevitable misreadings but also for practical reasons. An experienced tuner never concentrates on 1 reed alone and continuously cross checks with its surroundings. Do the octaves and other intervals sound right? In the case of tremolo tuning, this gets even more important: does the beating of two or more particular reeds make sense compared with all the others? You need a keyboard to be able to do that. You will also more easily find out how the reeds actually behave when they are being played and deal much more quickly with eventual issues. If one is making a living repairing and tuning, not only quality but also time is of the essence.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: syale on September 30, 2012, 01:39:28 AM
I am starting to gather all the pieces for my tuning table and get things rocking and rolling. I looked in my one row boxes (one is G the other C) and it looks like the reed blocks are glued in, maybe because of the slides with the stops. Is it the case that the reed blocks are glued in in the HA114 series and if so what is the best method of removal so that I can tune and what glue is used to put them back in. It certainly does not look like wax.

See images for details (2nd post for G box)


Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: syale on September 30, 2012, 01:40:46 AM
2nd post for HA114G
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: tirpous on September 30, 2012, 06:01:32 AM
I'm no expert but I think if the blocks are glued in, it is simpler to leave them in place and tune the reeds 'in situ'.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Lester on September 30, 2012, 07:37:21 AM
Ah!  tuning melodeons with fixed reed blocks needs a different method, I use this one learned from Rees who says he got it from my favourite Frenchman Emmanuel Pariselle.

You need to construct a small frame that fits inside the folds of the bellows then you can use the melodeon itself to be its own tuning bench:

(https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-P3vcH9RlfKc/UGfnLt7bRHI/AAAAAAAAJE4/EtGoCDXUmJQ/s1280/P1020251.JPG) (https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-P3vcH9RlfKc/UGfnLt7bRHI/AAAAAAAAJE4/EtGoCDXUmJQ/s1280/P1020251.JPG)       (https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-QtdexpxevQs/UGfnMsm1v3I/AAAAAAAAJFA/jWDN8hDLTnE/s1280/P1020252.JPG2.JPG) (https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-QtdexpxevQs/UGfnMsm1v3I/AAAAAAAAJFA/jWDN8hDLTnE/s1280/P1020252.JPG2.JPG)

You then just pop the treble end on, sound the reed, pop it off and tune, rinse and repeat.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: malcolmbebb on September 30, 2012, 09:45:39 AM
Inspired by Carolan - a couple of planks and his Irwin bench clamps.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Theo on September 30, 2012, 10:02:33 AM
Is it the case that the reed blocks are glued in in the HA114 series and if so what is the best method of removal so that I can tune and what glue is used to put them back in.

Yes they are glued in but you should tune them in situ. If you try to remove the blocks you are likely to damage the wood, especially the thin sections that house the slides.

Access to the two banks of reeds between the blocks is tricky but not impossible.   

If it is your first tuning I would recommend starting on a box with removable blocks.  As diatonix says you should do final tuning with the blocks in situ, but with the blocks removed you have better access to the reeds and can more readily build up your skill at manipulating reeds and getting a feel for where to remove metal and how much to remove.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: syale on September 30, 2012, 03:50:20 PM
Excellent, thanks for the tips!
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: blafleur on September 30, 2012, 05:41:58 PM
I use the existing bellows to tune mine. I just hold the bellows with my knees and hold the frame against the bellows frame with the fingers of both my hands on each side of the frame, and my thumb on the button.  I have a tuning bellows that I can pretune individual reeds if they are way off, or if I'm trying to determine the note of a bunch of loose reeds.....like if you drop a set on the shop floor, for instance... >:(
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: rees on September 30, 2012, 07:25:52 PM
a bunch of loose reeds.....like if you drop a set on the shop floor, for instance... >:(

........ been there, bought the tee shirt  ;)
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Theo on September 30, 2012, 08:50:10 PM
I Once received a parcel of new reeds through the post with several different sets all loose in a heap on the bottom of the package.  What fun that was.
Title: Re: Reed tuning - where to start
Post by: Lester on September 30, 2012, 09:06:17 PM
a bunch of loose reeds.....like if you drop a set on the shop floor, for instance... >:(

........ been there, bought the tee shirt  ;)

Only yesterday  :'(
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal