Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on July 12, 2012, 10:05:17 AM

Title: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 12, 2012, 10:05:17 AM
I'm struggling on how to play oranges in bloom as a waltz.

This is my attempt
http://soundcloud.com/ladydetemps/orange-in-bloom

Any tips, advice etc?
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: Lester on July 12, 2012, 10:14:06 AM
Seems fine to me, bit slower than I would do it but that is personal preference. What do you think the problem(s) is?
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 12, 2012, 10:16:17 AM
Seems fine to me, bit slower than I would do it but that is personal preference. What do you think the problem(s) is?
Its the B part. It just feels a bit awkward...wants to go back to being a jig every time.
Its fairly slow so I can practice clog dance to it.
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: Lester on July 12, 2012, 10:18:20 AM
Seems fine to me, bit slower than I would do it but that is personal preference. What do you think the problem(s) is?
Its the B part. It just feels a bit awkward...wants to go back to being a jig every time.
Its fairly slow so I can practice clog dance to it.

Like I said you stayed in 3/4 all the time, I agree that the first bar or so of the B is tricky but all it needs is perseverance  ;)
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 12, 2012, 10:21:07 AM
Seems fine to me, bit slower than I would do it but that is personal preference. What do you think the problem(s) is?
Its the B part. It just feels a bit awkward...wants to go back to being a jig every time.
Its fairly slow so I can practice clog dance to it.

Like I said you stayed in 3/4 all the time, I agree that the first bar or so of the B is tricky but all it needs is perseverance  ;)
What do I do with the bases? Umpapah-ing them just doesn't seem to fit...
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: Lester on July 12, 2012, 11:01:54 AM
What do I do with the bases? Umpapah-ing them just doesn't seem to fit...

You need Up Pah Pah, but you already knew that.

http://soundcloud.com/alison-10/orange-in-bloom-waltz (http://soundcloud.com/alison-10/orange-in-bloom-waltz)
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 12, 2012, 11:41:53 AM
What do I do with the bases? Umpapah-ing them just doesn't seem to fit...

You need Up Pah Pah, but you already knew that.

http://soundcloud.com/alison-10/orange-in-bloom-waltz (http://soundcloud.com/alison-10/orange-in-bloom-waltz)
How do you make it so light...my basses sound like an elephant in treacle
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: Theo on July 12, 2012, 12:07:04 PM
Seems fine to me, bit slower than I would do it but that is personal preference. What do you think the problem(s) is?
Its the B part. It just feels a bit awkward...wants to go back to being a jig every time.

The way I hear it you are playing a slow jig from the very start, the significant difference between this an a waltz (eg Lester and Alisons version) is where you place the second of the three main beats. In the jig the second beat comes late. Try playing a more even one - two - three and it should feel more like a waltz, and then the bass and chords should fit in more naturally.
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: Marje on July 12, 2012, 05:25:12 PM
I think once you start adding the basses you will be able to make it more waltz-like, and stop hearing a jig in your head. You can hear from Alison's lovely playing that a strong first beat and a light touch on the pah-pah for 2 and 3 can help to give it that swaying rhythm you want for a waltz. A jig, even slowed down, would be different, as there's no "pah" on the 2nd beat, giving it the bumpy rhythm that jigs have but waltzes don't.

I will add, though, that when it's played as slowly as you're playing it, it's almost certain to sound a bit heavy. If you could up the tempo a little, it would be easier to lighten it. Otherwise, just keep the bass really light and staccato - nothing makes a waltz sound droopy and soupy more than sustained, heavy basses.
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: Lester on July 12, 2012, 05:31:15 PM
You can hear from Alison's lovely playing that a strong first beat and a light touch on the pah-pah for 2 and 3 can help to give it that swaying rhythm you want for a waltz. A jig, even slowed down, would be different, as there's no "pah" on the 2nd beat, giving it the bumpy rhythm that jigs have but waltzes don't.

Hating to be thought of as immodest but it is me playing it, the Soundcloud account is used by The Sainted Mrs Bailey (Alison) and me. Thank you.
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: Graham Spencer on July 12, 2012, 06:00:48 PM
I find it very difficult to think of Orange in Bloom as either a waltz or a jig - in my mind it's neither; it's a beautiful compound-time tune that is what it is. Waltzes are very much "one to the bar", with no strong offbeat, while jigs are "two to the bar" with a very pronounced offbeat. To my mind OiB is neither of those - it's a fluid, sinuous and haunting melody which I would probably notate in 12/8 if pressed, with a "largo" marking.  Feel free to disagree - but it's how I see this lovely tune.  FWIW, I think of waltzes as ooom-pa, while jigs are um-pa um-pa. Then there are twosteps - but let's not go there......

Graham
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: Anahata on July 12, 2012, 07:34:20 PM
Soundcloud is almost totally unresponsive right now. (7.30pm Thursday) is anyone else having better luck?
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: Jinkers1 on July 12, 2012, 07:40:38 PM
Worked fine for me just now.
Title: Re: Oranges in bloom as a waltz?
Post by: Marje on July 13, 2012, 10:08:57 AM
You can hear from Alison's lovely playing that a strong first beat and a light touch on the pah-pah for 2 and 3 can help to give it that swaying rhythm you want for a waltz. A jig, even slowed down, would be different, as there's no "pah" on the 2nd beat, giving it the bumpy rhythm that jigs have but waltzes don't.

Hating to be thought of as immodest but it is me playing it, the Soundcloud account is used by The Sainted Mrs Bailey (Alison) and me. Thank you.

Sorry for that, Lester, happy to give you the credit!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal