Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: rileycat on July 12, 2012, 07:55:43 PM
-
More than 30 years ago a friend (now sadly deceased) played a red BC Paolo Soprani with vigour (shall we say!) and would send it off periodically to a tuner, who's little plastic label read "tuned by Nielsen". The box was a 4 voice and used to come back truly "singing" in a way I've never heard another button box match (IMHO) - it was magical.
My query is whether Nielsen's skill/gift/knowledge was passed on and if one of the current crop of Italian 3 voicers could be encouraged to sing with similar joy - can anyone out there recommend a tuner in UK for this task or is it an old Paolo thing or a forgotton secret!? I'd love to know if I might ever get a box of mine to sound that great - or am I missing a reed!? ;)
-
I'm guessing that would be Nils Nielson (I'm never sure how to spell his surname!), an absolute genius with accordion repairs and tuning. Thanks to a recommendation by John Kirkpatrick I always had my tuning done by him, and you're right - my boxes always sounded so sweet and full and played so easily when I got them back. I think - though I could be wrong - that he is still with us, though no longer doing any tuning or repairs; the last time I rang him (some years ago now) to book a tune I spoke to his wife, who said that he was not well and not accepting any work at that time. Since then I've moved away from UK so I have no idea of the current situation. I have very fond memories of the hours I spent chatting to him in his workshop, listening to his recollections and admiring his Daimler Dart sports car.
Graham
-
It would indeed have been Nils. I kind of guess that being Hohner trained and having 60+ years of tuning behind him made him great or, more thyan likely, he was just a genius. I use "was" as I believe he is no longer working after a poor recovery from a very serious fall from a ladder.
Apart from his tuning work he was a professional CBA player and Hawaiian guitar player/designer.
I like GPS used him to do my tuning especially useful for me as he only lived 15 minutes down the road. Any visit required at least 30 minutes of chat planned in to it, I loved his stories of the Music Hall and how he knew one of the Bettys from Wilson, Kepple and Betty "very well" :D
-
I never used Nils, but in my old days I used to take the box into Coldharbour Lane HQ, and go and see Willie Daneker in his long garret, which I recall was upstairs and on the left hand side of the Hohner warehouse. He too was a genius . People still comment on how different my Pokerwork sounds - bright and mellow, but never strident.
-
I spoke to him about 9 months ago and he was still tuning then.
-
I have a Nielsen tuned 1920s Hohner Bb/Eb box tuned by him in 1982 which sounds wonderful. I have used this as a template for all my tuning work. I think the secret is he always seemed to use Viennese, or Dedic tuning as we now know it.
Martyn
-
I like GPS used him to do my tuning especially useful for me as he only lived 15 minutes down the road. Any visit required at least 30 minutes of chat planned in to it, I loved his stories of the Music Hall and how he knew one of the Bettys from Wilson, Kepple and Betty "very well" :D
Only 30 minutes? I think the "Betty" he knew was probably Jeannie McKinnon, whom I also knew - in the 70s/early 80s, having retired from the stage, she used to run a basement pub next door to Birmingham Hippodrome.
I'm very glad to learn from Gromit that not only is he still with us, but still tuning.
Graham
-
Martyn, have you worked out what methods he used to tune? i.e. sandpaper, scratchers, file, dremel and so on?
-
Martyn, have you worked out what methods he used to tune? i.e. sandpaper, scratchers, file, dremel and so on?
Files and scratchers he would die rather than use a Dremel ;)
-
I vaguely remember reading that some of the 'secret sauce' is in not just tuning the main note of each reed, but the harmonics too. Of course, change the harmonic, and you change the main note too, so it's a bit like herding cats. Theo/Martyn/Lester - is that right, or urban legend?
-
I vaguely remember reading that some of the 'secret sauce' is in not just tuning the main note of each reed, but the harmonics too. Of course, change the harmonic, and you change the main note too, so it's a bit like herding cats. Theo/Martyn/Lester - is that right, or urban legend?
You don't know how happy I am to be thought of as part of "Theo/Martyn/Lester" :D
Not sure about Nils' secret tuning sauce but he certainly had a secret wax recipe, you can spot his waxing at 100 yards due to the bright green colour of the wax.
-
Of course, change the harmonic, and you change the main note too,
- is that right, or urban legend?
I think you have answered your own question Clive!
Free reed harmonicas are exact multiples of the fundamental, unlike strings, so there is no equivalent of the stretch tuning used in pianos to get a better agreement between the harmonics.
If you really want a sweet tuning (esp. for playing chords) then IMO you have to ditch equal temperament and go to some sort of meantone tuning. I've recently worked on some old anglo concertinas that seem to be in their original non-equal temperament tuning, and chords sound so sweet and smooth compared to ET tuned instruments
-
Martyn, have you worked out what methods he used to tune? i.e. sandpaper, scratchers, file, dremel and so on?
Looking at the one I have most of the tuning seems to be done with a file, with a few scratcher marks but this could have been from a previous tuning.
His green wax seems to be of a softer and less sticky consistency than usual waxes, which suggests to me it probably contains a percentage of paraffin wax.
Martyn
-
If you really want a sweet tuning (esp. for playing chords) then IMO you have to ditch equal temperament and go to some sort of meantone tuning.
I think Nils does his tuning mostly by ear, and it could well be that he doesn't tune to equal temperament, which would make his tunings sound different as described.
I don't know if he's still doing it now, but I took my Oakwood to him a few years a go and he tuned it much wetter than it had been before, which I wasn't expecting. He also left it with the treble side end systematically out of pitch with the basses and I had to take it back and get it fixed. I heard other rumours that he wasn't entirely reliable anymore and haven't used him since. Also it's true about the amount he likes to talk - and you can ask him questions but don't expect a straight answer!
I've recently worked on some old anglo concertinas that seem to be in their original non-equal temperament tuning, and chords sound so sweet and smooth compared to ET tuned instruments
Yes my first Anglo (a 20 key two row) was like that.
-
I took my Oakwood to him a few years a go and he tuned it much wetter than it had been before, which I wasn't expecting. He also left it with the treble side end systematically out of pitch with the basses and I had to take it back and get it fixed. I heard other rumours that he wasn't entirely reliable anymore and haven't used him since. Also it's true about the amount he likes to talk - and you can ask him questions but don't expect a straight answer!
This was exactly my experience of him tuning my Rik a few years ago.
When I spent my happy afternoon at la Maison de L'Accordeon recently, which included the workshop, the only tuning tools in evidence were long thin triangular file and scratcher. No sandpaper, Dremel etc anywhere to be seen. They do have the most amazing tuning bench with a keyboard along the front edge and slots with little spring fixing arms in which it looks as though all the treble reeds can be fixed at once to enable much more of the tuning to be done 'on the bench' before reeds are fitted to the blocks, leaving only the finest of final tuning to do 'in the box'.
They were very insistent that it took two years of training and tuning accordeons every day for someone to reach a standard where they could work unsupervised on customers instruments!
-
I've recently worked on some old anglo concertinas that seem to be in their original non-equal temperament tuning, and chords sound so sweet and smooth compared to ET tuned instruments
Yes my first Anglo (a 20 key two row) was like that.
I recently acquired an 1880's vintage Jones 20 button anglo in old Philharmonic pitch (about A450+), which I measured. Although it needed a bit of touching up, the measured tuning was quite close to 1/4 comma meantone, which I used as a template to sweeten it up. It certainly provides sweet intervals throughout. (:)
-
I am not sure how applicable, but here in the States one has to specifically ask a piano tuner "do you tune by ear" as so many now use the machines.
Even the most pedestrian piano, like our old Gulbransen, sounds 1/2 decent when properly tuned.
Part of it is that stretch, I guess.
When tuned by machine, it sounds, well, like an old pedestrian Gulbransen.
-
Nils' tuning set up was a tuning bench with a set of reference reeds against which he tuned your reeds, he also had a tuning meter.
As to tuning by ear even I, a relative new comer, don't rely entirely on electronics, yes they are good to get to about the right place but then you need to listen to what you have and tinker (technical term (:) )
-
They were very insistent that it took two years of training and tuning accordeons every day for someone to reach a standard where they could work unsupervised on customers instruments!
I've only been tuning reeds for about 10 years, and I reckon I'm beginning to get the hang of it. (:)
-
I suppose an underlying part of my query was the fundamental question "can a modern box ever sound as good as one of the old ones?" A moments reflection then throws up the obvious reply "depends what the listener/player calls 'good'" and round I go again :-\ Oh dear!
I somehow felt, though, that there might be a common agreement among box orientated listeners when hearing a particular instrument, that "it sounds fantastic" and that its not the element which the player puts in (massive tho' that is), but the actual sound of the reeds/the tuning that interested me. I thought that Nielsen achieved this with the Paolo I knew, hence the query. Many thanks for all the thoughts so far expressed - they are helpful. I'm not hoping to tune anything myself - zero skill and no time to learn - but I'd love to have a box with 'that sound'. Regards to all and thanks (:)
-
Nielsen witchcraft is the best explanation I currently have for why Ian Dedic's Oakwood sounds the way it does. A truly remarkable machine, we took it apart, leaving no stone unturned, and I've been thinking about it ever since but there was nothing I could see that I can attribute the almost magical way it plays to...
-
Nielsen witchcraft is the best explanation I currently have for ...... the almost magical way it plays...
I know - when Nils became (temporarily, as it turns out) unavailable I took my boxes to another reputable tuner. I have no complaints about his work and they came back in tune, but never sounded the way Nils got them to.
Graham
-
Nielsen witchcraft is the best explanation I currently have for why Ian Dedic's Oakwood sounds the way it does. A truly remarkable machine, we took it apart, leaving no stone unturned, and I've been thinking about it ever since but there was nothing I could see that I can attribute the almost magical way it plays to...
I always used to get Nils to retune it before we did a CD -- and even though it didn't sound bad before, it always sounded much better afterwards...
But I haven't used him since the last time I went a few years back to try and get him to fix a broken bass end lever. He not only suggested taking the complete bass mechanism out and sending it to Castelfidardo -- an unusual suggestion seeing as how it was put together in Leeds from Italian bits -- but didn't remember having worked on it before, which was strange given the number of times he'd retuned it, replaced reeds on it, and even hand-made new straps for both ends :-(
-
Does anyone have a Nielson tuned instrument handy? I'm very curious about how the different intervals are tuned. Did he, for instance, use a 1/4 comma meantone tuning or some other type of temperament? I'm especially interested in the way he tuned the treble end.
I realize that tuning is an art and still have much to learn, however the more information I have about temperaments and what "sounds sweet," the better. Learning from a master tuner is not possible where I live. There is no Theo, Martyn, Lester or other professional to chat up and learn from. This forum is a real tutor for me.
Another avenue of tuning that I've recently run into is the concept of the sequence of steps, the process by which the tuner tackles tuning, say, a two row melodeon. I'll start another thread about that soon.
Ed
-
There's a nice demo of meantone vs. ET here:
meantone (http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/44/Cabezon_Caballero_Beginning_Meantone.ogg)
Equal (http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d4/Cabezon_Caballero_Beginning_Equal.ogg)
(not on free reeds!)
-
Tuning in other temperaments has advantages, but it has disadvantages too, apart from the obvious ones of not being able to play on all keys. For a start fifths are less pure than in ET, and the further round the circle of fifths you go the sharper or flatter the whole thing becomes, whic would take some getting used to if say you played with a fiddle player who cared about intonation. There is no simple answer, it's just a question of choosing which set of compromises you prefer. I don't think there is any magic bullet of tuning, it's more a matter of constant attention to minute detail, and always looking for better ways of doing things.
-
Does anyone have a Nielson tuned instrument handy? I'm very curious about how the different intervals are tuned. Did he, for instance, use a 1/4 comma meantone tuning or some other type of temperament? I'm especially interested in the way he tuned the treble end.
I realize that tuning is an art and still have much to learn, however the more information I have about temperaments and what "sounds sweet," the better. Learning from a master tuner is not possible where I live. There is no Theo, Martyn, Lester or other professional to chat up and learn from. This forum is a real tutor for me.
Another avenue of tuning that I've recently run into is the concept of the sequence of steps, the process by which the tuner tackles tuning, say, a two row melodeon. I'll start another thread about that soon.
Ed
Nielsen definitely tuned in ET -- but *very* well...
-
Sadly, my box hasn't been in Nils's hands for a long time now. But like Ian, I always had him run his magic hands over it before a recording session; this http://www.rannygazoo.eu/page7.html (http://www.rannygazoo.eu/page7.html) is from, I think, the last studio session I did with the box freshly tuned by Nils.
Graham
-
Coincidentally I've just had a previously Neilsen tuned Castagnari Benny arrive at the workshop for tuning. To me the tuning was a little bit variable. The tremolo didn't really follow a pattern. I'm not sure how long since it was last tuned but I would have thought within the last 5 years, so it shouldn't really have drifted much in that time.
Martyn
-
There's a nice demo of meantone vs. ET here:
meantone (http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/44/Cabezon_Caballero_Beginning_Meantone.ogg)
Equal (http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d4/Cabezon_Caballero_Beginning_Equal.ogg)
(not on free reeds!)
Thank you Anahata, very nice demonstration and I love the music to boot. I started out in my 20s as a luthier making in instruments for the Early Music crowd. That's the best demo I've ever heard.
Cheers,
Ed
-
He was so highly recommended that I sent my Casti Hascy to him from the US to the UK by Internation Mail at some expense. It was some of the best money I ever spent.
-
Martyn, have you worked out what methods he used to tune? i.e. sandpaper, scratchers, file, dremel and so on?
His green wax seems to be of a softer and less sticky consistency than usual waxes, which suggests to me it probably contains a percentage of paraffin wax.
Just reviving this thread to see if anyone has any pictures of the Green Wax that the fabled Nils Nielsen used? I'd love to see some photos of his work. Thanks.
-
If you really want a sweet tuning (esp. for playing chords) then IMO you have to ditch equal temperament and go to some sort of meantone tuning. I've recently worked on some old anglo concertinas that seem to be in their original non-equal temperament tuning, and chords sound so sweet and smooth compared to ET tuned instruments
Good demonstration by Adrian Brown on Anglo concertina - ¼ comma meantone vs equal temperament tuning. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HT9fStxlbBQ&list=PL4_kwj7PfO8mEpS0TGnFQe6jeQ0L-QiQ3&index=49&t=3s)
-
I have an originally B C C# that has had the C# row replaced using green wax. Ivor Hyde told me many years that it Neilsons work. I've been able to succesfully post a photograph here, no problem to send by email.
-
I've been able to succesfully post a photograph here, no problem to send by email.
I hope you can post a picture here so we can all benefit ! (:)
-
I got permission to post these pictures of Noel Kennedy's Casali 3V in DD# that was tuned by Nils some time ago. He reckons the box wasn't played in 30 years. Pictures in several posts due to size:
-
more pics...
-
No sign of green wax....could anyone verify if this would be typical of Nils valves/wax etc. thanks
-
Nope. Nils' green wax was very green, if he had revalved he would have rewaxed and, trust me, his green wax was really green. I would also opine his wax was tidier than that in the images
-
Here's an example of Nielson's green wax on the bass end of my Dallape which he fettled in the 1990s.
-
Here's an example of Nielson's green wax on the bass end of my Dallape which he fettled in the 1990s.
interesting, I wonder what makes it green? Dye? And it looks like a darker material beneath it.
Ps I could be wrong and you may already know if so, it looks like one of your reeds has come loose on the side facing the large bass reeds.
-
interesting, I wonder what makes it green?
Some type of olive oil, maybe ?
-
interesting, I wonder what makes it green?
Some type of olive oil, maybe ?
Olive oil isn’t really green, though. I’ve also used plenty of reedwax made with olive oil and it was never anything like that colour. I wonder if he added a dye simply to be able to identify it as his wax.
-
Olive oil isn’t really green, though.
Depends, that's why I said 'some type'. See https://www.spanish-oil.com/blog/olive-oil-color/ (https://www.spanish-oil.com/blog/olive-oil-color/), for example.
-
Olive oil isn’t really green, though.
Depends, that's why I said 'some type'. See https://www.spanish-oil.com/blog/olive-oil-color/ (https://www.spanish-oil.com/blog/olive-oil-color/), for example.
Oh, wow!
-
Thanks for the additional picture and information. Always good to document the work of a master craftsman. It looks like a glossy green - perhaps food colouring or candle wax-specific dye.
-
One one of my rare visits to Nils, he started talking about his wax. He said he had done some research into industrial waxes, which are used for a huge range of engineering purposes and sometimes synthetically made to precise specifications. He wasn't about to give too much away of course, but hinted that this had given him some ideas about wax design that some others might not have thought of.
-
One one of my rare visits to Nils, he started talking about his wax. He said he had done some research into industrial waxes, which are used for a huge range of engineering purposes and sometimes synthetically made to precise specifications. He wasn't about to give too much away of course, but hinted that this had given him some ideas about wax design that some others might not have thought of.
He told me it was a mix of waxes to get the right mix of softness/strength/adhesion, including carnauba wax IIRC. The green colour was dye so he could always spot his work/repairs... ;-)