Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Adam-T on July 13, 2012, 09:53:26 PM

Title: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Adam-T on July 13, 2012, 09:53:26 PM
Hmm, Probably taken a bit of a risk here but I do like interesting boxes at interesting prices .. Scandalli make fantastic PAs, they were one of the old top names (never owned one as I hate those damn bin-lids and never saw the later lid-free ones at a sensible price) , I knew they made decent CBAs too  but this is the first time I`ve seen a Scandalli Melodeon .

It`s a typical Paolo shaped B/C 8 bass italian box, by my reckoning likely not made by Scandalli (as this is the first time I`ve seen one) though I can`t see them putting their name on rubbish .. its a very plain looking box even by Paolo-wannabe standards , anyone seen one before ? Pics removed for actual ones by me


Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: pgroff on July 15, 2012, 06:12:30 PM
Hi Adam,

I don't have much time for writing this month;  just a note here that I have had a few Scandalli boxes in C/C#, G/C, etc.  They often seem cheaply made but are lightweight and resonant, can have good reeds in them,  and they can be very nice sounding and fun to play.  The actions sometimes need tweaking.  I know I've posted pics and discussion of them here (including very recently in the context of a Scandalli PA constructed much like some Scandalli 2-row diatonic boxes).  If you use the search function of this forum you should find more info. 

PG
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Adam-T on July 15, 2012, 07:24:02 PM
Cheaply made and Scandalli doesn`t mix usually but I`ve seen a few Italian button boxes of sub-Par construction where their PA counterparts are made to the highest standard (think Orfeo for one - Sounded superb though) . this box doesn`t scream Scandalli at me from the photos but I can`t imagine them putting their name on Rubbish, especially Then, when it really was Scandalli (rather than Menghini, Excelsior, whoever) .. I`ve not seen a poorly made Scandalli PA but then I`ve not seen the smaller ones.
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: pgroff on July 16, 2012, 03:52:32 AM
Hi Adam,

Here are a few of the discussions I remembered:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9193.msg117742.html#msg117742

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,823.msg7977.html#msg7977

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2706.msg31065.html#msg31065



And here's the Scandalli PA I mentioned, built quite similarly to some of those diatonic boxes.  I suspect this 32 bass is tuned MM tremolo on the melody side.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/14-Scandalli-Accordion-w-Original-Case-Made-in-Italy-/271013639762


PG
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Adam-T on July 16, 2012, 08:08:29 AM
Thanks Paul .. that PA does look like it came from the same factory as the Orfeo button box I had  which had poor wood / rough wood finishing but superb reeds & sound, the mechanics were pretty damn good too (its keys, pallets and 36 bass Stradella mechanism better than Weltmiester / Galotta for instance)

I mentioned my experience of the build of the PAs because even the humble lightweight 2 voice 120 bass Calvi I have is built to very high standards internally, shames my Hohner Atlantic (and all the hohner Melodeons short of a morino) and is at least Morino if not Gola level in Hohner terms regarding wood & internal finish, key and button action and I`ve seen this to be pretty much the norm of large Italian PAs of that period (50s to 70s) though as I mentioned, I`ve not opened anything up less than 120 bass italian PA wise.

It`ll be interesting to see how this Scandalli B/C box fares when it lands, hopefully the wood is better than the Orfeo, the mechanics as good and hopefully is a 3 voice, being a Paolo wannabe probably won`t be 2 voice.

Thanks for the links, I remember the three red scandallis now, they look different to this one (which is all cellulolid) though like the Orfeo, Celluloid can be stuck over aluminium on grilles and fingerboards and looks best removed :)
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on July 16, 2012, 01:36:09 PM
Here's a nice one....

Crocodile skin finish; very tasteful  :-*  (not)
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on July 16, 2012, 01:39:08 PM
I was working on this one a while back.
Might even finish it one day.....
The intention was to strip it back and refinish with a natural wood finish, but the quality of the casework leaves much to be desired and I'll probably end up painting it, though not in "croc".
As a visitor to my workshop remarked, the wooden casework "has more bog than a toilet cleaners' convention"   >:E >:E >:E
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Adam-T on July 16, 2012, 02:21:38 PM
Both look like the same box as the one I`m getting . like that the grille / fingerbaord cover are alloy covered in celluloid like the Orfeo`s F/Board so can be stripped for the Paolo look :) . the top one looks like it has been painted (hence the Croc skin alike crazing) ..

how is the build quality, sound ? , how many voices ? . thanks ..
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Mike Hirst on July 16, 2012, 02:30:32 PM
Scandalli club box

Milonga para as Missões-Renato Borghetti e Arthur Bonilla (http://youtu.be/xfsaGLesNHE)

(note dot on button in middle of second row - presumably gleichton.)
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Theo on July 16, 2012, 02:35:55 PM
Scandalli club box

Milonga para as Missões-Renato Borghetti e Arthur Bonilla (http://youtu.be/xfsaGLesNHE)

(note dot on button in middle of second row - presumably gleichton.)

And great playing.
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: pgroff on July 16, 2012, 03:45:40 PM
Great link Mike!

I see the auction link for the Scandalli Rosalba (supposedly C/F and maybe 3 voice), discussed in one of the earlier melnet threads, is now dead.  I think that accordion eventually sold after multiple listings on ebay and other auction sites.  But before the owner listed it, it was featured in this discussion:

http://www.reyesforo.com/post/The-SENSATIONAL-Wurzer-collection-1852833

and I seem to have a photo of it.  Looks somewhat similar to some Casali and Busilacchio 3 voice boxes, and in fact has the same celluloid and some design details as a very nice 1940s Baldoni-Bartoli 6 voice 15-key box I once owned.

PG
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Adam-T on July 16, 2012, 04:07:02 PM
Nice box and excellent playing  in that link Mike !! ........

The brown one looks very related to the Orfeo Paul (it`s that brown cel finish again and the grille design). the one i`m getting looks more like the ones in Malcolm's post ..... I wonder who made these? , I doubt Scandalli had much to do with them.
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Adam-T on July 21, 2012, 09:25:00 PM
Malcolm -- yours is the same version ....... I`ve put all the bass reeds in the right places, revalved and waxed them and it`s a very fine box indeed for its cheapness, sounds and plays very well indeed, the bellows are the most supple I`ve played in a melodeon of anywhere near this vintage - the shockers are the treble and bass mechs, both of which shame Hohner by a large degree, also it appears to have hand assembled reeds (Peened with a Hammer) - the ends are held on with brass woodscrews where Bellows pins would usually be (from original too as all the screws are the same and the same as the ones holding the rear panel on)  ..

here`s the pics.. I`m still in two minds to Nitromors the grille/button panel to give it that Paolo look (it looks like a teletype machine at the moment)  . I`ve replaced the bellows straps, the strap brackets are next . this one is black celluloid, not painted like yours was.. It appears that poor woodwork was the norm for Italian button boxes of this period though this IS a lot better than the Orfeo woodwise.

Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on July 22, 2012, 03:36:40 AM
Adam, yes, the action, brass wood screws instead of bellows pins and the glued-in red blocks are identical to my stripped (ex-croc) one. As you say, the bellows are very nice on these, and ones I've had before have, imho, sounded better than the later (?) flat grilled Scandallis.

To get the treble action better, you may find that you need to replace the small coil spring on the axle, which is usually rusted out, missing  or not sufficiently strong to keep the arms and spacers in position. Try a good old retractable Bic biro spring....worked for me!   :o
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Adam-T on July 22, 2012, 07:29:44 AM
I`l have a look at that but the action on this thing is making my Corona Classic Jealous and the pokerwork go into hiding :( .. the reeds are shorter than Pokerwork ones but the bass is fuller and sounds better than the typical hohner 2915 boxy honk . it`s funny that yours was painted and this one Celluloid. I need to get new strap brackets and put two discs of Celluloid behind them, the junk originals have bent, rotated and scratched the box in a circle badly.
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Mike Hirst on July 29, 2012, 04:48:51 PM
Re the above, this ebay book offer may be of interest:

THE STORY OF SCANDALLI ACCORDIONS - INTERESTING HARD TO FIND BOOK (http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/THE-STORY-OF-SCANDALLI-ACCORDIONS-INTERESTING-HARD-TO-FIND-BOOK-/280927227765?pt=UK_MusicalInstr_Keyboard_RL&hash=item4168914f75)

This internet article gives some interesting historical detail, much of which is quoted from Sandro Strologo, author of the above:

http://www.incamerano.net/ecastle2.html (http://www.incamerano.net/ecastle2.html)
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Adam-T on July 29, 2012, 05:18:28 PM
Amazing what books have been written !! . I`m not into scandalli enough to buy the book but it`s a good find all the same !

I wish someone would write a Hohner one, including model designations, dates of boxes, reasoning behind design and naming changes and of course history ....... unlikely to happen, I bet even hohner themselves haven`t a clue -LOL
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 09, 2012, 12:30:35 PM
....and the glued-in red blocks are identical to my stripped (ex-croc) one.

Project progressing, but slowly.

A bit of useful useless information:
The treble reed block spacings are exactly the same as the "unshared" reedblocks of a Hohner Corso.
So rather than replacing the (no longer) glued in reed blocks, I intend to mount Corso blocks which I just happen to have obtained from a scrapper.

Will hopefully make future reedwork a whole lot easier....

Now to decide whether to use the original C/F reeds, change them to a different tuning (D/G???), buy a set of new Cagnos or perhaps re-reed with Hohner reeds.

Decisions, decisions! Will have to consider this over a  :|glug or several.
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Adam-T on November 09, 2012, 01:38:35 PM
The little scandalli is poorly made wood wise but the mechanics I found to be excellent, the bellows are to die for so a Corso retrofit would be a good move ! the grille would need replacing with somethig which lets sound out too
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 15, 2012, 07:30:06 AM
....and the glued-in red blocks are identical to my stripped (ex-croc) one.

Now to decide whether to use the original C/F reeds, change them to a different tuning (D/G???), buy a set of new Cagnos or perhaps re-reed with Hohner reeds.


Decided upon D/G Hohner T reeds in aluminium frames and mylar valves for the treble, partially in light of Adam's concerns about lack of sound through the limited grill fretting. I find these are generally a bit louder than Italian factory reeds or earlier Hohner ones.

The result was ample volume on the (outside) D row, but a little muted on the G row.  But still fairly useable as it is.

I've checked the obvious: pallet heights, reedblock gaskets, etc. So I think the grill is to blame. So next job (sometime) will probably be to cut a few more holes in the grill (or extend the existing ones) nearer to the finger-board. Might allow a bit more air from the G row pallets to reach the outside world.

Used the original left hand reeds with a bit of tuning and swapping around. Seems quite a good balance.

Not sure I'd describe the bellows as "to die for", but the air release certainly is.... Wish I could mount it on my CastaTommy, but the lack of space prevents much improvement.


Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 15, 2012, 07:38:01 AM
Before and after shots...

Looks a bit different now, for better or worse....

(Yeah, I know the Scandalli badge is downside up; I'm allowed one deliberate mistake, surely.... >:E  )
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Adam-T on November 15, 2012, 07:44:10 AM
looks great Malcolm !!. the next challenge is to replace the grille with something which actually lets sound out - one thing I really noticed was how much better it sounded with the grille OFF especially the inner row (which isn`t anywhere near the fingerboard) .
Title: Re: Scandalli Melodeon ?
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 15, 2012, 08:29:23 AM
looks great Malcolm !!. the next challenge is to replace the grille with something which actually lets sound out - one thing I really noticed was how much better it sounded with the grille OFF especially the inner row (which isn`t anywhere near the fingerboard) .

No problem with the D row sound getting out. Plenty of "apparent" volume imho (tuned to quite a wide tremolo). Certainly within a whisker of the volume of my pokerwork.

It is the G row, i.e. the inside row, the row nearest the finger board, which is lacking. So extending the fretwork holes (fretwork implies something a little more artistic!!!) further towards the inner row pallets would certainly be worth a try surely.

Can't see the value in making a totally new grill without first modifying the existing one to see if it helps!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal