Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Larus on July 17, 2012, 01:06:45 PM
-
Hello all,
I'm still dabbling with a Hohner 114, lightening springs, re-felting, etc., but long term I'll be looking to change to "better" pallets.
My questions are:
1.......would the Hohner Ariette pallet arm and spring mechanism slot into a Hohner 114 without modification or is it a different size/design (is it any better?)
2...... are better quality pallet mechanisms available to fit a 114 (without modification) by another manufacturer.
I've asked these questions on the back of other threads (with no replies) but hopefully somebody out there can help.
Thanks in advance.
-
Purely curious, since I've never had or looked inside one of these:
What is it about the pallets that you don't like? I've seen a range of wooden ones, and fancy metal ones, but thought the differences mainly for looks.
When you talk of the pallet mechanism, presumably you are talking about the treble (and bass?) mechanisms? So again, what are you hoping to gain (or what's wrong with the original)?
And is the Ariette mechanism particulary good then?
I've been on here a little while now, and don't recall hearing these questions asked before, so I'm curious.
Malcolm
PS LOL post crossed with Theo's
-
Why do you think the Arriette pallet and arm would be an improvement? After all the Ariette is a cheaper box.
-
Why do you think the Arriette pallet and arm would be an improvement? After all the Ariette is a cheaper box.
I suppose that's why I'm asking for advice.
I've lightened the springs and plan to put thicker felt on the pallets in the hope I can lighten the springs further.
The Ariette idea was based on pictures only (never held one) -where they seem to be more adjustable than the 114 pallet arms.
The idea is more than cosmetic, I'm not really bothered how it looks-it's how it functions.
I've never played around with the mechanics of a melodeon, so it's very much a "seeking advice" post and any suggestions would be warmly received.
I purchased this 114 to play around with and learn a bit more about melodeons generally-it adds another dimension.
-
Purely curious, since I've never had or looked inside one of these:
What is it about the pallets that you don't like? I've seen a range of wooden ones, and fancy metal ones, but thought the differences mainly for looks.
When you talk of the pallet mechanism, presumably you are talking about the treble (and bass?) mechanisms? So again, what are you hoping to gain (or what's wrong with the original)?
And is the Ariette mechanism particulary good then?
I've been on here a little while now, and don't recall hearing these questions asked before, so I'm curious.
Malcolm
PS LOL post crossed with Theo's
Hope the reply to Theo answers your questions Malcolm.
Basically I'm experimenting and hoping to tap into the wealth of expertise on here.
-
As far as I can see the only thing preventing the use of much thicker felt on the pallets is that this raises the pallet and upsets the geometry of the lever. A simple workaround is to put the same thickness of packing under the area where the fingerboard and the action are mounted. A strip of wood of the appropriate thickness is all you need. You might need longer screws to hold the fingerboard, but these are standard M3 so should be easy to obtain. If you don't glue in the wood packing then the whole project is reversible if it doesn't work out.
-
As far as I can see the only thing preventing the use of much thicker felt on the pallets is that this raises the pallet and upsets the geometry of the lever. A simple workaround is to put the same thickness of packing under the area where the fingerboard and the action are mounted. A strip of wood of the appropriate thickness is all you need. You might need longer screws to hold the fingerboard, but these are standard M3 so should be easy to obtain. If you don't glue in the wood packing then the whole project is reversible if it doesn't work out.
Thanks Theo,
this seems a simple solution to the problem, more importantly it's a solution within my skill level.
When the felt arrives, I give it a go and post as to it's effectiveness. (:) Thanks again.
-
I've done this on a two and a half row Hohner before. You will also need to shim the fingerboard with the same thickness of wood. It works quite well and, as Theo mentioned, is completely reversable if you don't like the result.
-
I've done this on a two and a half row Hohner before. You will also need to shim the fingerboard with the same thickness of wood. It works quite well and, as Theo mentioned, is completely reversable if you don't like the result.
Sounds hopeful. It'll be an interesting exercise regardless ;D
-
I hope I do a better job on the treble mechanism than the subject box spelling-I'd hate to miss out the "A" there!!! ;D ;D
-
As far as I can see the only thing preventing the use of much thicker felt on the pallets is that this raises the pallet and upsets the geometry of the lever. A simple workaround is to put the same thickness of packing under the area where the fingerboard and the action are mounted. A strip of wood of the appropriate thickness is all you need. You might need longer screws to hold the fingerboard, but these are standard M3 so should be easy to obtain. If you don't glue in the wood packing then the whole project is reversible if it doesn't work out.
Thanks Theo,
this seems a simple solution to the problem, more importantly it's a solution within my skill level.
When the felt arrives, I give it a go and post as to it's effectiveness. (:) Thanks again.
I've finished the job.
The pallets now have 5.5mm felt on and are mounted on a raised fingerboard and the button travel limited.
As you thought I had to use larger M3 screws and had minor problems with the small screws that keep the mechanism in place.
In the end I used Panel pins with rubber cement applied on the inside (to stop them lifting). The fingerboard packer and shims were old wooden blinds glued to the correct thickness, as was the backing to limit button travel (soft enough to indent the wood, making adjustment easier).
Incidentally I sanded down the pallets, removed all vast amounts of rubber cement present, painted and reset them.
Probably looks odd to the purists ???, but the button resistance is so light, it plays a lot better! ;D
-
Pictures?
-
(http://)
Here a a close up of "the business end" Note the spring angle, very light resistance.
Obviously this was during construction, its a bit more polished now!
-
I like the red pallets! Also noticed hat this is the "Cajun" model, they're supposed to have more strongly built bellows. The only two I know of spent some time being abused to soften the bellows a bit. I believe about two months gigging with a Welsh Cajun band did the trick.
-
I like the red pallets! Also noticed hat this is the "Cajun" model, they're supposed to have more strongly built bellows. The only two I know of spent some time being abused to soften the bellows a bit. I believe about two months gigging with a Welsh Cajun band did the trick.
Thanks. The pallets are grey with red tape to the top to ensure no arm movement within the pallet (due to removing lots of rubber gunk).
A temporary thing, but it looks nice enough.
I've heard this said before about these bellows-they are much stiffer than my other 114 (less use though).
Incidentally I've had the other bellows on this box, a noticeable difference in playing speed.
All in all, a good start, but I have a few more ideas and things I want to try on this box. >:E >:E
-
Looks great!
-
Looks great!
That's very kind of you to say so. (:)
-
I know this comes somewhat after the fact, but looking at my Ariette (of which I really have to post that review that I promised :|bl) the spring mechanism is significantly different from the pictured 114, and the pallets... well, they function perfectly well but they appear to be made of chromed plastic. Older Ariettes may be different, of course; I gather that they were redesigned relatively recently.
-
Looks great!
Great job...
-
I know this comes somewhat after the fact, but looking at my Ariette (of which I really have to post that review that I promised :|bl) the spring mechanism is significantly different from the pictured 114, and the pallets... well, they function perfectly well but they appear to be made of chromed plastic. Older Ariettes may be different, of course; I gather that they were redesigned relatively recently.
I'd still be interested in seeing the mechanising of the Ariette and how it differs from a 114, and whether it would fit into the fingerboard of a 114.
-
Looks great!
Great job...
Thanks Syale-it was your post where you mentioned lessening spring resistance that started it all off.