Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Tunes => Topic started by: ladydetemps on July 18, 2012, 10:33:03 AM

Title: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 18, 2012, 10:33:03 AM
I'm a little confused in bluebell polka in the bit in D...
should I play it on the G row and crossover to the D row for the sharps or just swap to D row? (haven't even attempted the 'C' bit). Or should I play it on the D row and crossover to the G just for flats?

I'm not even attempting basses at this point.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on July 18, 2012, 10:46:28 AM
I swap to the D row for the 'b' part. I'm on hols at the mo, but when I get back I'll put it up on Youtube for you.

Cheers,
Pikey
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Lester on July 18, 2012, 10:48:29 AM
Deleted 'cus I was talking about the primrose Polka which is close, florally, to the Bluebell Polka but a mile away musically  :-\
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on July 18, 2012, 10:49:40 AM
I echo pikey. :||:
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 18, 2012, 10:51:32 AM
I swap to the D row for the 'b' part. I'm on hols at the mo, but when I get back I'll put it up on Youtube for you.

Cheers,
Pikey
That's kind of you.
I play various bits on either the G or D row dependant on where it fits best to the basses. As Im in Costas at the mo not sure what I actually play where. Have a look when I get home.
I really struggle playing tunes from the dots when there are changes of key. Coz my brain is like 'stuck' in in translating one key. I'm wondering if I would do better trying to pick up this one by ear? But picking up the accidentals by ear scare me.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: TomB on July 18, 2012, 11:14:13 AM
If a tune is in G and you play it on the G row, another is in D and you play it on the G row, it's surely just a case of playing up and down the row, so I don't understand where the 'accidentals' appear? Once you have the tunes playable that way you can then experiment with the [reversals], if that's the right word, to maybe get the basses to fit a bit better.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Ollie on July 18, 2012, 11:18:40 AM
Play it on the D row. If you look at the dots, the vast majority of the B part is just a broken D chord. It will be a lot more fluid, and easier to play, on the D row.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 18, 2012, 11:21:44 AM
If a tune is in G and you play it on the G row, another is in D and you play it on the G row, it's surely just a case of playing up and down the row, so I don't understand where the 'accidentals' appear? Once you have the tunes playable that way you can then experiment with the [reversals], if that's the right word, to maybe get the basses to fit a bit better.
Well according to this abc is goes sharp, then flat
http://www.thesession.org/tunes/display/3352
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Lester on July 18, 2012, 11:29:15 AM
If a tune is in G and you play it on the G row, another is in D and you play it on the G row, it's surely just a case of playing up and down the row, so I don't understand where the 'accidentals' appear? Once you have the tunes playable that way you can then experiment with the [reversals], if that's the right word, to maybe get the basses to fit a bit better.
Well according to this abc is goes sharp, then flat
http://www.thesession.org/tunes/display/3352
So the A is in the key of G, the B is in the key of D and the C in the key of C. All playable on a D/G but hard.

What is played around my way is this:

X:49
T:Bluebell Polka
M:4/4
L:1/8
K:G
(3Bdg|b2b2gfge|d2d2B2G2|FGAB c2e2|ed^cd B2 (3Bdg|
b2b2gfge|d2d2B2G2|FGAB cdef|g2g2g2:|
K:D
e2|d2d2Bdgb|d'2d'2b2b2|d'2c'2=c'2a2|e'2d'2c'2d'2|
d2d2Bdgb|d'2d'2b3b|d'2c'2=c'2a2|g2b2g2:|
K:G
A2|B2B2Bc d2|B2B2Bc d2|c2cd cB A2|c2cd cB A2|
B2B2Bc d2|B2B2Bc d2|c2cd cB A2|G2B2G2:|

Not for the purists but easier  ;)

Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 18, 2012, 11:32:25 AM
If a tune is in G and you play it on the G row, another is in D and you play it on the G row, it's surely just a case of playing up and down the row, so I don't understand where the 'accidentals' appear? Once you have the tunes playable that way you can then experiment with the [reversals], if that's the right word, to maybe get the basses to fit a bit better.
Well according to this abc is goes sharp, then flat
http://www.thesession.org/tunes/display/3352
So the A is in the key of G, the B is in the key of D and the C in the key of C. All playable on a D/G but hard.

What is played around my way is this:

X:49
T:Bluebell Polka
M:4/4
L:1/8
K:G
(3Bdg|b2b2gfge|d2d2B2G2|FGAB c2e2|ed^cd B2 (3Bdg|
b2b2gfge|d2d2B2G2|FGAB cdef|g2g2g2:|
K:D
e2|d2d2Bdgb|d'2d'2b2b2|d'2c'2=c'2a2|e'2d'2c'2d'2|
d2d2Bdgb|d'2d'2b3b|d'2c'2=c'2a2|g2b2g2:|
K:G
A2|B2B2Bc d2|B2B2Bc d2|c2cd cB A2|c2cd cB A2|
B2B2Bc d2|B2B2Bc d2|c2cd cB A2|G2B2G2:|

Not for the purists but easier  ;)

so it strays into the dusty end of the melodeon?
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Lester on July 18, 2012, 11:44:22 AM
so it strays into the dusty end of the melodeon?

You paid for them all so should use them to get value for money  ;)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Anahata on July 18, 2012, 11:56:57 AM
I have already put it on YouTube, if it helps: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lyHB6n9Nwv4

I play the D bit on the D row...
The key change to D implies a C# in the key signature, but as it happens the tune doesn't actually use a C#. However it's easier to play on the D row anyway.
There are some G# notes, correctly shows as accidentals and unfortunately not available on a two row D/G melodeon. It has a G#, but an octave lower that the one you really need. I think I faked it by playing the lower pitched G# anyway.

The C music (in C) is tricky if you're not used to playing in C, but if you have standard accidentals you can get the required F natural.

It's also possible to play the whole thing on a D/G box in the keys of D, A and G, which actually works very well as you can get the D# in the B music. I first learnt the tune that way, from Colin Cater who played it on an A/D/G three row box.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Daddy Long Les on July 18, 2012, 12:05:06 PM
I feature this tune in my Blogs 8 and 9.  Look at the latter part of both blogs.  I had Martyn White re-tune one of my squeaky G row buttons especially for this tune - watch the video to find out more.

The playing is pretty poor as I had only been learning for 2.5 months but I'm sure you'll get the idea.  George Garside gave me the idea of using my RH thumb in the C major section.

Hope this helps

Les
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Graham Spencer on July 18, 2012, 12:13:03 PM
I must confess I usually play the C music in G as well; I don't know why - I must have learned it that way from someone sometime in the dim and distant.

Graham
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 18, 2012, 12:18:40 PM
I have already put it on YouTube, if it helps: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lyHB6n9Nwv4

Wow! You must have long fingers...no way I could reach the accidentals while playing at the dusty end. lol!

Quote
I play the D bit on the D row...
The key change to D implies a C# in the key signature, but as it happens the tune doesn't actually use a C#. However it's easier to play on the D row anyway.
There are some G# notes, correctly shows as accidentals and unfortunately not available on a two row D/G melodeon. It has a G#, but an octave lower that the one you really need. I think I faked it by playing the lower pitched G# anyway.

The C music (in C) is tricky if you're not used to playing in C, but if you have standard accidentals you can get the required F natural.

Or just swap to the C box for the C part? ;)

I must confess I usually play the C music in G as well; I don't know why - I must have learned it that way from someone sometime in the dim and distant.

Graham
What keys do people usually play it in?
I feature this tune in my Blogs 8 and 9.  Look at the latter part of both blogs.  I had Martyn White re-tune one of my squeaky G row buttons especially for this tune - watch the video to find out more.

The playing is pretty poor as I had only been learning for 2.5 months but I'm sure you'll get the idea.  George Garside gave me the idea of using my RH thumb in the C major section.

Hope this helps

Les
Have you got direct links?


Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Lester on July 18, 2012, 12:27:16 PM
Have you got direct links?

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9415.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9415.0.html)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 18, 2012, 12:36:07 PM
I think I know why now every time I think about trying this tune I give up. There's no simple idiots version. :-\ :-[
Why do I like all the really *hard* tunes?  ::)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 18, 2012, 12:45:50 PM
By utter coincidence, I bumped into Anahata's version on Youtube last night and was wondering about getting the dots......and they appear here!
Brilliant.
I keep twiddling a version I've learnt from goodness knows where but perhaps is a less accurate version. I quite like the F naturals. It's about time I learnt it properly.
As Lester says, I've bought them, better use them!
Q
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on July 18, 2012, 03:20:46 PM
I must confess I usually play the C music in G as well; I don't know why - I must have learned it that way from someone sometime in the dim and distant.

Graham

so do I, and so do most people I know.
Does anyone else apart from me play a 4th part in E minor?
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: TomB on July 18, 2012, 03:43:15 PM
If a tune is in G and you play it on the G row, another is in D and you play it on the G row, it's surely just a case of playing up and down the row, so I don't understand where the 'accidentals' appear? Once you have the tunes playable that way you can then experiment with the [reversals], if that's the right word, to maybe get the basses to fit a bit better.
Well according to this abc is goes sharp, then flat
http://www.thesession.org/tunes/display/3352

What I meant was if you only had a one row melodeon, you would only have the basic scale to play with, so you would ignore anything in the music that strayed from what you have available, instead modifying the tune to 'get close enough'. With the Bluebell Polka, you essentially have two tunes to learn, one in D and one in G (save the C tune until later). The accidentals form only a tiny amount of the whole tune and they can be corrected later when you have a firm grip of the basics of the tune(s).
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Strigulino on July 19, 2012, 02:34:41 PM
This tune is on my "to do" list when I get some accidentals on my forthcoming Liliput.  Pesky F natural!  Or whatever it would be on a C/F box...
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Graham Spencer on July 19, 2012, 07:28:36 PM
This tune is on my "to do" list when I get some accidentals on my forthcoming Liliput.  Pesky F natural!  Or whatever it would be on a C/F box...

Eb........

Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Strigulino on July 19, 2012, 07:35:08 PM
*checks Lester's diagram*

Yes!  I will have Eb.  On pull and push.  My cup runneth over.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on July 19, 2012, 09:09:20 PM
There seems a reasonable concensus that the A part (in G) is played on the G row & the B part (in D) is played on the D row. The only 'problem'   then is the lack of a high G# which would   , if you had one, be sndwiched between 2 A's.  As there are 5 notes in the bars in question none of them are going to be   audible  for  more than a fraction of a second so a bit of faking   will take care of the situation.  I   substitute a quick i.e. 'short' G i.e. AGA instead of AG#A  which can simply be done by a quick little 'back flip' on the bellows - nobody has ever noticed or complained whether solo or in a band.  Another fake would be simply to play 3  short A's instead of AG#A whilst of course Anahatas using the low G# at chin end works fine provided you can reach it.

The C part  (in C) is a different kettle of fish as it is ,to me anyway, impossible to 'fake' the F natural as 12 out of 41 notes in the C part are F naturels!  To make life a bit more difficult  6 of the F naturels come in very prominent groups of 3.  Fortunately most DG boxes have an F naturel  at the chin end of the G row  but not only is it awkward to reach  ( I use thumb for chin end accidentals) but is very awkward to play in the right sequence due to its propensity in the C part of the bluebell polka although it can be done with practice.  To facilitate this on both pokerwork & lilly I have arranged a   simple linkage (extremely simple on pokerwork) to an extra button adjacent to the F# on the G row  , easy to do on some boxes, and this makes it dead easy.

Personally I don't think it sounds quite right playing the C part in G  but its better than now't.

george
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: TomB on July 19, 2012, 10:00:55 PM
George, I've heard the 'C' part played on the D row a few times and that doesn't sound too bad. I think all DiGi boxes should be fitted with a C row (and a B row would help even more)   >:E
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on July 19, 2012, 10:05:10 PM
what F natural? i've played Bluebell in sessions for nearly 30 years, and have never heard anyone play the third part in C.

Is it me??????
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Bill Young on July 19, 2012, 10:21:20 PM
what F natural? i've played Bluebell in sessions for nearly 30 years, and have never heard anyone play the third part in C.

Is it me??????
Never heard a Jimmy Shand recording of the Bluebell Polka?
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on July 19, 2012, 10:28:56 PM
Yes, but he didnt play in our sessions :-)

Mind you, we never had anyone trying to show off by playing in C on a D/G box :-)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on July 19, 2012, 10:54:59 PM
what F natural? i've played Bluebell in sessions for nearly 30 years, and have never heard anyone play the third part in C.

Is it me??????
Never heard a Jimmy Shand recording of the Bluebell Polka?

Indeed  Bill.   To me its not the bluebell polka without the C part in C!

george
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Theo on July 19, 2012, 11:31:36 PM
Spot on George, and i think the G#s in the B part are pretty important too.  Leaving them out is like eating chips without salt.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on July 20, 2012, 01:16:23 AM
@ pikey: I very much doubt it!
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 20, 2012, 10:03:04 AM
I too like Pikey have always played it without F naturals, and thinking about it play the C music down a touch on my English concertina.
Usually around B,C,D and allowing me to use Bb's if I want ( difficult as the EC isn't to hand )
Perhaps this is the ruse to get away from the F nat's?
Is that what you do Pikey?
Q
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on July 20, 2012, 10:04:33 AM
Spot on George, and i think the G#s in the B part are pretty important too.  Leaving them out is like eating chips without salt.

Totally agree Theo  and wouldn't dream of not  playing the high G#   on boxes  so equiped. I do however think its better to fake  it  if you havn't got it rather than transposing the C part into G or D or leaving it out completely. 

 I see faking as very much part of the art of playing simple 1 or 2 row boxes without or with only limited accidentals   as  it provides scope for playing tunes that perhaps could not otherwise be played.   As a generalisation I find that those bereft of classical training  take to faking much more readily, probably because they do not have the same concience about doing it 'correctly' or should it be not doing it incorrectly.

george
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 20, 2012, 10:18:26 AM
Theo: too much salt is bad for you  ;)
....but I take the point.

When I first started playing EC I just learnt what everyone else was playing, so if they played the tune without G#'s or the C music down a little to use B/C/D runs, I had no idea, I just learnt what was being played. I think I might have been vaguely aware of a version in Kerr's but thought if I played it like that I would have learnt it 'wrong' cos no one I knew played it as written.
Essentially it's the perpetuated 'myth' version that I learnt.
I think there are many tunes like this, perhaps the eternal question about the C music in the Redowa Polka where people use an A chord wrongly springs to mind.....

I want to learn it 'properly' on a melodeon just to use the accidentals and get my hand stretching.
When later in a local session I succumb to the old ways, I have no idea!
Q
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Graham Spencer on July 20, 2012, 12:50:14 PM
I think I've probably always known that the "C" music should be in C (actually the sheet music I've seen says it should be played AABBAACC to make 64 bars, but that's another matter) but I've always played it in G (on a D/G box) because that's the way I learned it by communal osmosis, and that's the way everyone else round my way played it.  Maybe it's time I got down to learning it the "proper" way.........be an interesting experiment to see if I can make myself forget the way I currently play it.

Graham
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Anahata on July 20, 2012, 01:37:15 PM
the sheet music I've seen says it should be played AABBAACC
Like many three-part tunes of its era, and again this can be confirmed by viewing any of the YouTube recordings of Jimmy Shand. Also if you went from B music in D to C music in C it would be a rather remote change.

Quote
I've always played it in G (on a D/G box) because that's the way I learned it by communal osmosis, and that's the way everyone else round my way played it.

Yes, but only because it's been adapted by melodeon players without the imagination or skill (or in some cases without the F natural accidental, to be fair) to try doing the C part in C.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on July 20, 2012, 03:31:30 PM
 ;)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Graham Spencer on July 20, 2012, 04:06:59 PM

Quote
I've always played it in G (on a D/G box) because that's the way I learned it by communal osmosis, and that's the way everyone else round my way played it.

Yes, but only because it's been adapted by melodeon players without the imagination or skill (or in some cases without the F natural accidental, to be fair) to try doing the C part in C.

Which is precisely why I think I should learn it "proper"; I may make a start this evening........ ;)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: YorkieKen on July 20, 2012, 04:40:47 PM
Don't bother...It's one of those tunes like 'captain pugwash (Trumpet Hornpipe)', Dingle Regatta, Drowsy Maggie, etc. that's been "hacked to death" over the years. it makes me cringe when somebody starts up! Good chance to go to the bar for a pint, or the loo for a pee...lol.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on July 20, 2012, 04:48:09 PM
everybody to there own but I like it  provided it is played as the maker intended and not raced!

george
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 20, 2012, 04:54:37 PM
I've not heard it played in a local session before...ever. So don't know how it can be as cliched as you say. ;)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Anahata on July 20, 2012, 04:56:17 PM
Of course the trouble with playing it "right" in a session is everyone else will ignore your C music in C and carry on playing it the way they usually do.

I've not heard it played in a local session before...ever. So don't know how it can be as cliched as you say. ;)
Maybe in some circles it's deliberately avoided now because it used to be done to death.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: YorkieKen on July 20, 2012, 05:58:09 PM
Of course the trouble with playing it "right" in a session is everyone else will ignore your C music in C and carry on playing it the way they usually do.

I've not heard it played in a local session before...ever. So don't know how it can be as cliched as you say. ;)
Maybe in some circles it's deliberately avoided now because it used to be done to death.

That's just what I mean, but you will probably find that some of the tunes played at our sessions, (in York) are equally thoroughly boring elsewhere....!
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Daddy Long Les on July 21, 2012, 09:01:40 AM
I think it's a great tune and it's the reason I started learning the melodeon in the first place.   Though there's some who would say that's not necessarily a good thing!!! ;)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Pete Dunk on July 21, 2012, 11:06:04 PM
Of course the trouble with playing it "right" in a session is everyone else will ignore your C music in C and carry on playing it the way they usually do.

Yep, I play alongside someone who rides roughshod over the F natural in the opening bars of the B music of Lilibullero and plays F# because it 'sounds better' Sheesh!!!
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on July 23, 2012, 10:22:36 AM
2 of the nhs's finest hearing aids  can be very useful in such situations.  You can turn the tuneless bugger on either side on  and  off or up & down at will!!

george >:E ;)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on July 23, 2012, 11:58:39 AM
Don't bother...It's one of those tunes like 'captain pugwash (Trumpet Hornpipe)', Dingle Regatta, Drowsy Maggie, etc. that's been "hacked to death" over the years. it makes me cringe when somebody starts up! Good chance to go to the bar for a pint, or the loo for a pee...lol.

;D

No wonder you cringe when I turn up at a session, you have to buy lots of beer!
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on July 23, 2012, 12:12:17 PM
 There could be a danger of getting where  you go for a pint and where you go for a pee mixed up whilst in the process of  having a severe 'cringe'!

george  ;)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Anahata on July 23, 2012, 01:35:04 PM
... everyone else will ignore your C music in C and carry on playing it the way they usually do.

Yep, I play alongside someone who rides roughshod over the F natural in the opening bars of the B music of Lilibullero

Yes, but I mean playing the whole section in the wrong key!
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: malcolmbebb on July 23, 2012, 02:05:15 PM

Yep, I play alongside someone who rides roughshod over the F natural in the opening bars of the B music of Lilibullero

Yes, but I mean playing the whole section in the wrong key!
@tallship - what key(s) do you normally play Lilliburlero?
@anahata - were you referring to the polka or Lilliberlero?

Confused of Dorset.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Anahata on July 23, 2012, 03:05:06 PM
@tallship - what key(s) do you normally play Lilliburlero?
I assume he meant in G, which means there is (should be) an F natural in the B music.

If you have no accidentals, you can play Lillibullero in D, using the G row for the C naturals.

Quote
@anahata - were you referring to the polka or Lilliberlero?
Blue Bell Polka, C music being played in G when it should be in C.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Graham Spencer on July 23, 2012, 03:55:48 PM
OK, I've got the melody of the C part down in C now - actually it didn't turn out to be too much of a challenge. Problem now is the left hand - my F natural is on the pull, and I don't have a G bass on the pull........

Graham
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Strigulino on July 23, 2012, 04:03:09 PM
I usually just leave out the bass end for a bar if it doesn't fit, especially if it's the last bar of a phrase.  Make it look like you meant to do it for emphasis.  :)  There's a bit of Trumpet Hornpipe where I've got a couple of triplets at the end of a line and the breakthrough was when I just stopped playing the bass end for that part. 

If it's the bit I think you mean, the sheet music I've just looked at has that as a G7 chord, so you could play a B or a D instead of a G bass.  Presume you don't have an F bass.  If you've got the same basses as I have you should have B and D on the pull.  Can't play the chord though - perhaps alternating the B and D bass notes might be fun?
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on July 23, 2012, 04:38:42 PM
There could be a danger of getting where  you go for a pint and where you go for a pee mixed up whilst in the process of  having a severe 'cringe'!

george  ;)

Especially when you get to YorkieKens age.....
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: YorkieKen on July 25, 2012, 09:35:13 AM

Especially when you get to YorkieKens age.....

Pikey....You should have been at last nights session, guess what, a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'...but we totally foxed her by playing that 4th part in Em. Priceless you would have loved it.

Plus you could have bought me a pint!!
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on July 25, 2012, 09:37:34 AM
LOL   ;D
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Steve Fox on July 25, 2012, 09:44:22 AM

Pikey....You should have been at last nights session, guess what, a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'...but we totally foxed her by playing that 4th part in Em. Priceless you would have loved it.


And that is why sessions terrify me!  ;)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Lester on July 25, 2012, 10:15:29 AM
Pikey....You should have been at last nights session, guess what, a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'...but we totally foxed her by playing that 4th part in Em. Priceless you would have loved it.

Is it not a bit antisocial that when "a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'" you ride roughshod over her/his tune by changing the key. Not good etiquette in my world
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: malcolmbebb on July 25, 2012, 11:01:29 AM

... a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'...but we totally foxed her by playing that 4th part in Em. Priceless you would have loved it.
Sound like a friendly session where other players are made welcome.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Larus on July 25, 2012, 11:08:55 AM
Pikey....You should have been at last nights session, guess what, a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'...but we totally foxed her by playing that 4th part in Em. Priceless you would have loved it.

Is it not a bit antisocial that when "a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'" you ride roughshod over her/his tune by changing the key. Not good etiquette in my world
Totally agree Lester. Down our way you'd be poked in the chest for that. >:(
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on July 25, 2012, 11:26:26 AM
We all had fun - including the lady fluter!  :||:
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Theo on July 25, 2012, 11:46:01 AM
Pikey....You should have been at last nights session, guess what, a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'...but we totally foxed her by playing that 4th part in Em. Priceless you would have loved it.

Is it not a bit antisocial that when "a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'" you ride roughshod over her/his tune by changing the key. Not good etiquette in my world
Totally agree Lester. Down our way you'd be poked in the chest for that. >:(

Is that all!  Round here you'd have got a hacky look and that is the end socially.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Larus on July 25, 2012, 12:02:12 PM
Pikey....You should have been at last nights session, guess what, a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'...but we totally foxed her by playing that 4th part in Em. Priceless you would have loved it.

Is it not a bit antisocial that when "a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'" you ride roughshod over her/his tune by changing the key. Not good etiquette in my world
Totally agree Lester. Down our way you'd be poked in the chest for that. >:(

Is that all!  Round here you'd have got a hacky look and that is the end socially.
:o :o :o
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on July 25, 2012, 12:20:38 PM
totally agree with Lester, Larus ,Theo and no dooubt many others who feel the same way.  Apart from being plain bad manners hijacking or otherwise arsing about with  a tune somebody has taken the trouble to/plucked up the courage to start is enough to put them off ever again attempting to start a tune in a session

george ::)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Steve Fox on July 25, 2012, 03:58:53 PM
totally agree with Lester, Larus ,Theo and no dooubt many others who feel the same way.  Apart from being plain bad manners hijacking or otherwise arsing about with  a tune somebody has taken the trouble to/plucked up the courage to start is enough to put them off ever again attempting to start a tune in a session

george ::)

Which was exactly the point of my post, George.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: YorkieKen on July 25, 2012, 07:14:30 PM
I think you guys are taking our 'Yorkshire Humour' a little too seriously! the lady flautist is a regular and much loved member of our session. she was really very surprised,... yet impressed with the Em 4th part of the tune, and quickly picked it up as we played it several times thro' . I just found it uncanny that the tune ( Blue Bell Polka )was so relevant' it being discussed on this thread.   :|glug

Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on July 26, 2012, 02:56:52 PM

... a flute player started up with 'Blue bell Polka'...but we totally foxed her by playing that 4th part in Em. Priceless you would have loved it.
Sound like a friendly session where other players are made welcome.

It's precisely that , as are all sessions in God's chosen county  ;D (apart from the quoted one at Whitby festival, which is probably folks from outside Boycottshire....)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on July 26, 2012, 02:59:44 PM
I think you guys are taking our 'Yorkshire Humour' a little too seriously! the lady flautist is a regular and much loved member of our session. she was really very surprised,... yet impressed with the Em 4th part of the tune, and quickly picked it up as we played it several times thro' . I just found it uncanny that the tune ( Blue Bell Polka )was so relevant' it being discussed on this thread.   :|glug

Touche Ken.

I'll run a test at Whitby , and play the version of the 'Oscar Woods' jig that I learned from Oscar himself, and then see how many regular melnetters try to change it back to the Old Sawn Band version......   >:E

Only joking!!!
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on July 26, 2012, 10:50:42 PM
Does anyone have the dots for the Em bit? I tried it on Tuesday, but take rather longer than most to pick up tunes.
  :||: :|bl :|glug :Ph
Pretty please with sugar on.

Chris.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on July 27, 2012, 10:15:41 AM
nope.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: TomB on July 27, 2012, 11:16:23 AM
Does anyone have the dots for the Em bit? I tried it on Tuesday, but take rather longer than most to pick up tunes.
  :||: :|bl :|glug :Ph
Pretty please with sugar on.

Chris.

If you can play it. I can transcribe it to dots or ABC, but I don't know how it goes?  :|||:
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on July 27, 2012, 01:24:33 PM
To the same tempo as the C part:

E,E ,E, F#, G   (all to an Em chord)
E,E, E, F#, G  (Em chord)
F#, F#, F#, D, B  (D then B chord)
F#, F#, F#, D, B,  (D then B chord)
E,E ,E, F#, G  (Em)
E,E, E, F#, G (Em)
F#, F#, F#, D, B, E, D, and back to the A part......  (D, then B chord, then chords for last 2 notes are Em then D)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on July 27, 2012, 06:30:08 PM
Thanks Pikey. Are you out tonight?  :||:  :|glug
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Strigulino on July 27, 2012, 07:02:26 PM
Quote
Like many three-part tunes of its era, and again this can be confirmed by viewing any of the YouTube recordings of Jimmy Shand.

I've just had a listen to my copy of Jimmy Shand playing this; it goes, rather complicatedly: AABB ACCA BACA.

As has been said, each of these three parts is in a different key, and he seems to have been playing them in whatever order he thought sounded nicest... so I think the conclusion is, play them however you like but make sure you reach a consensus before starting! 

If you are attempting to play a la Shand, either play it on your own and busk it, or perhaps write the order down somewhere and make sure you remember where you are...
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Graham Spencer on July 28, 2012, 10:04:26 AM
Quote
Like many three-part tunes of its era, and again this can be confirmed by viewing any of the YouTube recordings of Jimmy Shand.

I've just had a listen to my copy of Jimmy Shand playing this; it goes, rather complicatedly: AABB ACCA BACA.

As has been said, each of these three parts is in a different key, and he seems to have been playing them in whatever order he thought sounded nicest... so I think the conclusion is, play them however you like but make sure you reach a consensus before starting! 

If you are attempting to play a la Shand, either play it on your own and busk it, or perhaps write the order down somewhere and make sure you remember where you are...

You will notice, though, that the C part always follows the A, making (to my ears anyway!) a more satisfactory key change.

Graham
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on July 28, 2012, 10:17:08 AM
Not sure as to whether Sir Jimmy always played it to that length i.e finishing with  single BACA & this may have been done to suite the  requierd length of a partiular recording. I have several recorded at different times & will have agood listen in due course.  HOwever I feel it is best to follow his example and finish by following the two C's with a single A

george
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on August 02, 2012, 01:53:26 PM
Maybe we should all play ABACAB - it worked for Genesis  ;D
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on August 03, 2012, 11:28:15 PM
Shall we try it at The Elsinore Meet?  :||:

PS: Did we arrange a Sidmouth Meet at all by the way, or have I missed the details somehow? :||: I'm out of town in Exmouth this week, so I've probably missed a lot. 

Chris.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Strigulino on February 19, 2013, 11:42:41 AM
Excuse the threadomancy but I have a further question about this - am now attempting this, and have found where the relevant accidentals are on my box.  A and B parts are going well, but apart from C major I haven't the faintest idea what I'm supposed to be doing for the C part for the bass end.  Any consensus?  I tried looking at Anahata's video but his fingers dance so lightly I can't make it out.  :D
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Anahata on February 19, 2013, 11:55:08 AM
Well, you're in C at that point. C and G are the only chords you can use.
(I'm assuming your new 2.5 row box is D/G with 8 basses)

1st two bars you can just use C bass and chord
Next two bars:
- simple version G bass and chord
- posh version  ( D bass G chord G bass G chord ) x 2

Repeat for next 4 bars, except the very last note is back to C bass & chord.

Does that make any sense?

I'm also assuming your F natural is a push note. I've reversed mine to a pull note, but I can't remember if I did that before or after making the YouTube video  :|bl
If it's a pull note, things don't work so well (there are advantages in other tunes...)

-- Anahata the light-fingered
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on February 19, 2013, 12:01:19 PM
 on a 2 row DG I play the Cpart in CC  using  C bass & chord for the first 2 bars, the DG bass & chord for bars 3 and 4, back to Cbass for bars 5 & 6 and DG bass for 7&8

george
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on February 19, 2013, 12:12:11 PM
on my Lilly and pkerwork I have  put a  made a linkage to bring a duplicate F nat  between the inside row and the grill and between the D & F# buttons.  This greatly facilitates playing the C part of the Bluebell Polka.   The method of arranaging the link is different on both boxes and is dead easy to do on the pokerwork/erica and presumably many other boxes with a flat closed keyboard.

If anybody is interested as to how its done i can try to post some photos  on here

george
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Strigulino on February 19, 2013, 12:50:28 PM
Thanks all - many options to try there.

My Liliput is actually a declubbed C/F - I think the pesky F natural is therefore an Eb, and I have those on push and pull on the half row, so should be fine.  It's going to be a finger-twister, but should be possible.  I tried to play the C part by ear last night and failed miserably so I think I have to actually sit down and work out which buttons to press. 
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Anahata on February 19, 2013, 01:24:29 PM
work out which buttons to press.

That's always a good start  :P
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on February 19, 2013, 02:25:30 PM
Thanks all - many options to try there.

My Liliput is actually a declubbed C/F - I think the pesky F natural is therefore an Eb, and I have those on push and pull on the half row, so should be fine.  It's going to be a finger-twister, but should be possible.  I tried to play the C part by ear last night and failed miserably so I think I have to actually sit down and work out which buttons to press.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on February 19, 2013, 03:29:39 PM
meant to say this in the above post but for some reason it vanished into thin air! 

 The C p art of the Bluebell Polka is just played entirely on the C row of a CF box!

I think Owens BC and half C# Lillyput conversion is probably much easier to manage in a veriety of keys     as it follows a logical pattern  working out from the C row - but then you wouldnt expect me to say otherwise!

george ;D
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Strigulino on February 19, 2013, 03:39:33 PM
You misunderstand me I think - to play the entire thing on a C/F 2.5 row box, I believe I have to transpose the entire thing into F/C/B.  So the C part would be in B major.  I'm going to have to do it that way to get the chords to work, I think.
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: KLR on February 19, 2013, 04:29:12 PM
You mean Bb.  The key of the third part of this tune is a fourth above the key of the first part, i.e., Bb.  Modulating into B would get you burnt at the stake in Renaissance Christendom, among other problems.   ;D  What you have available on your basses is beside the point.

The structure ABABC was quite common in genteel late 19th century dance compositions, whose forms trickled down to folk musicians - polkas, schottisches, waltzes, etc.   Reg Hall did a bangup job writing about this phenomenon in the world of Irish music for the liner notes to the CD Round the House and Mind the Dresser.

Think I'll learn the B part of Flop Eared Mule for a D part for this tune, which is ancestral to it, or vice versa?  The Bluebell was first printed in the 1880s.  I learned it from an old recording of an Irish fiddler, James Morrison, who dispensed with the third part for some reason - maybe it hadn't been composed yet?
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Strigulino on February 19, 2013, 04:54:22 PM
Bb, you are quite right.  :)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 19, 2013, 05:26:35 PM
You mean Bb.  The key of the third part of this tune is a fourth above the key of the first part, i.e., Bb.  Modulating into B would get you burnt at the stake in Renaissance Christendom, among other problems.   ;D  What you have available on your basses is beside the point.

I digress a bit, but the notes of Bâ™­ and Dâ™­  (relative to a C tonic) were banned by the Russian Establishment in the 1920's as bourgeois, and reactionary. The Soviet had interdicted any 'religious' musical reference (reverence?) a few years previously, and now turned against the influence of the American negros whom they perceived as essentially capitalist lick-spittles. I can't find reference to this on the Web, but BBC's programme (approx 2009) on Stravinsky had establishment musical teachers going through student's work systematically deleting or replacing any note considered 'blue'  ::)

I'm not sure what the role of 'colour' was in this, be that black/white or blue/red ;)  They certainly had no shortage of basses!  :|glug
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: KLR on February 19, 2013, 06:43:51 PM
You mean Bb.  The key of the third part of this tune is a fourth above the key of the first part, i.e., Bb.  Modulating into B would get you burnt at the stake in Renaissance Christendom, among other problems.   ;D  What you have available on your basses is beside the point.

I digress a bit, but the notes of Bâ™­ and Dâ™­  (relative to a C tonic) were banned by the Russian Establishment in the 1920's as bourgeois, and reactionary. The Soviet had interdicted any 'religious' musical reference (reverence?) a few years previously, and now turned against the influence of the American negros whom they perceived as essentially capitalist lick-spittles. I can't find reference to this on the Web, but BBC's programme (approx 2009) on Stravinsky had establishment musical teachers going through student's work systematically deleting or replacing any note considered 'blue'  ::)

I'm not sure what the role of 'colour' was in this, be that black/white or blue/red ;)  They certainly had no shortage of basses!  :|glug

In Soviet Russia painting colors you!

Have to run and can't find the link for you but came across a very amusing roundup of assorted famous composers' stripes of synesthesia.  They all wholly cancelled each other out, of course. 
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on February 21, 2013, 12:35:53 PM
on my Lilly and pkerwork I have  put a  made a linkage to bring a duplicate F nat  between the inside row and the grill and between the D & F# buttons.  This greatly facilitates playing the C part of the Bluebell Polka.   The method of arranaging the link is different on both boxes and is dead easy to do on the pokerwork/erica and presumably many other boxes with a flat closed keyboard.

If anybody is interested as to how its done i can try to post some photos  on here

george

yes please George, photos of the linkage would be great!
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: george garside on February 22, 2013, 08:20:52 PM
Will  take some photos and put them on instrument repairs etc so as not to occur the wrath of 'im in Gateshead!

george ;)
Title: Re: Bluebell polka - help?
Post by: pikey on February 22, 2013, 10:51:56 PM
Will  take some photos and put them on instrument repairs etc so as not to occur the wrath of 'im in Gateshead!

george ;)

Ta !
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal