Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on July 22, 2012, 11:03:11 AM
-
Bought a Marine Band G harmonica yesterday. Can anyone recommend some good You Tube tuition videos? Never played before but I'm loving it so far!!
-
just treat it the same as playing on the row on a box and tunes should come out the same. For folk/traditional music a 'solo tuned' mouthie is more useful as it has all the notes which the 10 hole 'blues' ones don't as blues players usually play in 2nd position i.e. like in A on the D row of a box and bend notes by overblowing.
Have you watched the utube clip of Will Atkinson at 91.
george
-
At the risk of self promotion (who, me?), you could try my online lessons at http://www.harmonicaacademy.com (http://www.harmonicaacademy.com)
The lessons are not free, but I think they are around the cheapest online ones going. They cover both 10 hole and tremolo .
-
There's lot of good ideas here, start with part one and keep going (:) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jcSLudnKFPA (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jcSLudnKFPA).
Lovely mix of anecdote and teaching.
Steve
-
Feel free to PM me for free basic instructions about playing folky stuff on 10 hole harps, with suggestions about how to retune a few reeds to make it easier.
Steve
-
You will have noticed that the 10 hole diatonic only has one complete octave - starting on 4 blow.
Either side of this are partial octaves with missing notes. This is why beginer books always have the same tunes in them - they are the ones that can be played without bending notes.
Paddy richterising (raising the 3 blow by one tone) gets back one of the missing notes and increases the number of tunes you can play massively. - The other missing notes seldom cause a problem.
Seydel do off the shelf Paddy richterised harmonicas, however DIY with file/dremel and digital tuner is not hard. - Some may be offended by the Dremel but a measured approach and light touch is possible. The G harmonica is a good one to do, it is the lowest regular tuning so the 3 blow reed should have a good chunk of metal on the end so easy to remove some to raise a tone. I have also done a C harmonica - this was harder as there was not much thickness on the end of the 3 blow reed to start with.
4 -4 5 6
7 -6 6 5 6
4 -4 5 6
6 -6 6 5 -4
4 -4 5 6
7 -6 6 5 6
6 -6 7 5 -4 5 -4 4
7 -7 7 -6
6 -6 6 5 6
7 -7 7 -6
6 -6 6 5 -4
4 -4 5 6
7 -6 6 5 6
6 -6 7 5 -4 5 -4 4
Name that tune - bear in mind it is my attempt at learning by ear and converting to harmonica tab, so may not be note perfect.
"I'm playing all the right notes—but not necessarily in the right order"
-
Paddy richterising (raising the 3 blow by one tone) gets back one of the missing notes and increases the number of tunes you can play massively. - The other missing notes seldom cause a problem.
The Paddy Richter system (a Brendan Power invention) is certainly a good way of solving the problem of the missing low 6th note of the scale (E in key if G) and, as TRAndy says, is easy to make for yourself. For melodeon players, however, it creates the problem that the E is a blow (= push) note, whereas on a 2 row melodeon it would be a pull (= draw). So using your box-playing instincts on mouthorgan gets disrupted. An alternative that avoids this is to tune the DRAW D in hole 2 (still talking G harp) to E. I also tune the Draw A in hole 1 up to C, which gives a nice partial C chord in holes 1 and 2. (For the sale of a label, I call this subdominant tuning.) I use this tuning pretty much all the time for major key tunes and have made harps right up to high F# like this, though not with a Dremel. The 'sanding wands' that model makers use are good for tuning brass mouthorgan reeds.
Steve
-
I prefer solo tuned tremelo mouthies as they have all the notes and more of them! The cheap chinese 24 (x2) holers are solo tuned but only come in C. Hohner and others do betteer ones in a range of keys.
geore
-
I prefer solo tuned tremelo mouthies as they have all the notes and more of them! The cheap chinese 24 (x2) holers are solo tuned but only come in C. Hohner and others do betteer ones in a range of keys.
geore
And indeed tremolos are what most British traditional players (most obviously Will Atkinson) used. They're still the harp of choice for contemporary English folkies such as Martin Brinsford and Katie Howson. But (and this is only a matter of my own taste, not a crit of anyone else) I really don't care for their sound.
-
... the 3 blow reed should have a good chunk of metal on the end so easy to remove some to raise a tone.
You could add some weight e.g solder at the fixed end of the reed instead.
This can in theory raise the pitch, but the only times I've seen it done it reduced the response and volume of the reed so far as to make it virtually useless.
-
Some more thoughts on harmonica retuning.
The idea of raising the 2 draw instead of the 3 blow would give you the same notes as Paddy Richterising (remembering that 2 draw and 3 blow are the same note on a standard 10 hole diatonic) and should feel more like playing the melodeon - particularly if you primarily play on the row. For me, I had already Paddy Richterised my harmonicas before ever picking up a button box so have become used to this layout.
I knew the Dremel would upset some but it is far from my only harmonica retuning tool, for fine tuning I usually scrape with a scalpel. To avoid damaging reeds, regardless of the tool used, it is vital that your grinding/filing/sanding/scraping forces are putting your reeds in tension
- They can withstand direct tension forces but very little in any other direction.
The reason that adding solder near the base of the reed is not effective as a means of raising pitch is that mostly what it adds is mass, what you want to add is stiffness. Solder is heavy but not nearly as stiff as the reed material.
I would always be concerned about adding solder to harmonica reeds (even if it is effective for lowering pitch when added to the free end). My fear is that the lump of solder would become detached during a strong draw note - a lump of solder in your lungs has to be a possibility. With solder you would of course have to be totally certain it was lead free.
I know this thread is diverting slightly from playing to tuning but 10 hole diatonics really should come with some sort of warning that in standard form they are not too great for melody playing.
Do have a go at retuning. If you are concerned about wrecking your harmonica buy a cheapie for practice
-
How to play a mouth organ - blow, suck, blow, suck...... >:E
...except that the first tune I learned on the mouth organ my granny bought me when I was 4 was 'the last post' - all on the blow! :D
Seriously - try and play an easy tune that you already know by ear - Winster Gallop? Start off by playing just the nots in the tune, then experiment by putting more of your mouth around the 'Gob iron', particularly at the side which has the lower notes, and see what souns you can make. Experts like Will Atkinson use their tongue to seperate the melody from a deeper ' vamp', to get the driving rhythm.
Somewhere there's a video of the Jarrow marchers mouth organ band , all vamping away as they march towards London. Sadly vamping skills are dying out - time was when every pub had a bloke with a mouth organ, who would whip it out at any opportunity for a tune. (I was that bloke.....) :D
-
For some seriously good tremelo playing check out Noel Battle on you tube - just be careful to avoid Dj Noel - Battle Mix, you probably won't find that quite so enjoyable.
I prefer solo tuned tremelo mouthies as they have all the notes and more of them! The cheap chinese 24 (x2) holers are solo tuned but only come in C. Hohner and others do betteer ones in a range of keys.
geore
And indeed tremolos are what most British traditional players (most obviously Will Atkinson) used. They're still the harp of choice for contemporary English folkies such as Martin Brinsford and Katie Howson. But (and this is only a matter of my own taste, not a crit of anyone else) I really don't care for their sound.
-
Brendan Power's Paddy Richter tuning is a seriously good idea for those wanting to play traditional tunes on the 10 hole without strugglling with the bending.
I have an alternate tuning called "Major Cross", based on the Lee Oskar Melody Maker tuning. With Major Cross you play in 2nd position, Paddy Richter is for 1st position. The harmonica players out there will know what I mean. More details on Major Cross tuning and what it sounds like are at http://www.harmonicatunes.com/retuned (http://www.harmonicatunes.com/retuned)
For those interested in retuning their harmonicas to Major Cross, Hohner now have an excellent online resource explaining retuning and much else. Located at http://www.hohner-cshop.eu/cms/index.php/en/ (http://www.hohner-cshop.eu/cms/index.php/en/)
Hohner also sell harmonica tools. Another great harmonica tool set is the one by Richard Sleigh, available at http://www.hohner-cshop.eu/cms/index.php/en/ (http://www.hohner-cshop.eu/cms/index.php/en/)
Finally, for those interested in tremolo harmonica, check out my site at http://www.tremoloharmonica.com/ (http://www.tremoloharmonica.com/)
-
The cheap 24 (x2) Chinese tremolos are available in several keys nowadays and are really very cheap. Ihave one in C (Swan) and another in B (Howlin' Harp). You get the full 3 diatonic octaves, which is more than can be said for the Hohner Echo two-sided tremolo. costing more than £80. It's worth having a go on the tremolo, even though you have to get used to a funny note lay-out. With the ten-holers you only get one full octave in the middle, but you can get the full three diatonic octaves by learning to bend the draw notes at the lower end and the blow notes at the top end. >oads ot fun.
Eric
-
With the ten-holers you only get one full octave in the middle, but you can get the full three diatonic octaves by learning to bend the draw notes at the lower end and the blow notes at the top end. >oads ot fun.
Eric
As noted earlier in this thread, there are numerous possibilities for re-tuning 10 holers to cope with this problem.
Steve