Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: NormanB on July 23, 2012, 08:54:46 PM

Title: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: NormanB on July 23, 2012, 08:54:46 PM
I see from earlier posts that Hohner Double Rays are now made in China. When was production transferred and is there any noticeable difference in sound and/ or quality of build between the older German and new Chinese models.  Thanks
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: FlatNote on July 24, 2012, 11:30:58 AM
Here's an interesting page about the history of the Double Ray:

http://gumshoearcana.blogspot.ie/2011/02/many-faces-of-hohner-double-ray.html (http://gumshoearcana.blogspot.ie/2011/02/many-faces-of-hohner-double-ray.html)

I can't comment on the difference between German and Chinese Double Rays generally but I do have one of each.  My father bought the German model before I was born in 1965 but I don't know the actual year.  I bought the Chinese model about 12 years ago.  In terms of sound, the Chinese model seems more shrill at the treble end but deeper at the bass end.  I don't know how much of that is due merely to the age discrepancy.  A real musician - not a melodeon player but very skilled on orchestral instruments - once commented on the 'lovely' tone of the German model, but she never got to hear the Chinese version.  The Chinese model does seem to have more 'oomph' for want of a better word and feels very robust.  I hit the buttons quite hard - lack of skill - and don't treat it with kid gloves and it has never given me a problem.  The differences between the peripheral components - bellows, straps, pins etc. - are exactly what one would expect from the age discrepancy;  I can't see that the country of origin makes any odds there.  I can't comment on the insides since I've never had occasion to open them up and would only break something through ignorance if I did!
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: Adam-T on July 24, 2012, 12:21:22 PM
My chinese Pokerwork about 2 years old has less clatter than the German ones (better felt/leather on the Pallets) otherwise the components are no worse than the german ones, some are reputed to leaving the factory out of tune (along with Ericas and D-Rays) but then I`ve heard even worse of Saltarelle who are well respected purveyers of expensive Boutique Melodeons .

I`d not hesitate in getting another Chinese made Hohner, a better option than a rusty clapped out, leaky, clattery wreck with saggy valves and crumbly wax ------ unless you`re buying the wreck to fix up like I often do  ;D.

New boxes tend to be quiet and stiff - bellows and reeds need playing in - my GERMAN Corona-II Classic which had been played twice before I got it makes my thumb ache due to this so if you get a new DoubleRay and find it hard work, it`s not because its Chinese - it`s because its NEW . Just a point to remember
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: Andy on September 03, 2012, 07:28:51 PM
Only 2 replies but intrestingly neither goes along with the common perception that the Chinese made Hohners are massively inferior to the German ones.

So is the superiority of the German made models a myth? or if you do belive them to be superior, what is it that makes them better? If it is 'build quality' please try to be more specific as this can be a bit of a vague cover all statement.

I have limited experience of either and my own accordion is a modern Crucianelli 2 row B/C. I do find the long travel buttons dissapearing under the keyboard on modern Hohners pretty horrible, the Crucianelli being much better in this respect. Did however have a shot of an old Hohner Gaelic IV  B/C/C# and the short, snappy, precise action on its buttons was a revelation.
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: FlatNote on September 03, 2012, 08:22:35 PM
Let me revise my earlier statement somewhat.  Just the other day a spring broke in the keyboard of my Chinese DoubleRay.  Pulled off the grill to have a look and replacing it would seem to be a time-consuming and fiddly pain, so am considering whether to cannibalise it for parts for my old German model, which could certainly do with them.  The last time I messed with a keyboard was when I managed to press the gleichton button on a Hohner Lilliput a bit far.  It went right down through the hole.  When I opened up the keyboard the keys just fell all over the place.  It took me two hours and a lot of luck to get them back into the right holes and I nearly took a hammer to it.  Can't bring myself to touch it since.  So while Chinese build quality may not be that great, perhaps old German engineering is not always what it's cracked up to be either.  Having had a couple of Fiats for the last 8 years, however, I'm not sure that I'm ready to make the move to Italian engineering yet though!
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: Adam-T on September 03, 2012, 08:39:47 PM
The liliput and Preciosa were totally unique in their button lever design - the Normal sized 2 row Hohners had the same mechanism which the chinese used in your Double-Ray - have a look at my thread about the renovation of a 1930s model, all the mechanics & internals are the same as yours only 80 years older and rusty (It`s pokerwork shaped of course)
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: boxer on September 04, 2012, 12:09:29 AM
I bought my first Pokerwork in 1973 - German built - and it was a bit of a disaster.  Springs broke, reeds failed, within a week of buying it.

Chinese made Hohners are better than that.

I've heard people say that the Swwedish steel used in pre-war Hohner reeds was better than whatever was used in post war production, but that's water under the bridge.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal