Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on July 25, 2012, 12:53:43 PM
-
I've just sanded off my patio table. Bought from a cheap warehouse locally about 15+ years ago and in a hardwood 'teak'. I look after it so it's still going strong. In between regular oilings, every so often I sand off the top. Today it was so dark brown it almost black. After sanding it went very light, and as the oil was applied out jumped a wonderful grain going from redish through light brown to almost yellow streaks in it. Absolutely Gorgeous.
It reminds me of the feeling when someone posts a picture of a new melodeon, it's maker somewhere across the channel, visions of a denuded mountainside and ancient gnarled trees being converted into melodens. I go weak at the knees.
Seeing the beautiful boxes made this year at Yeovil, with stunning grains across their main cases similarly got me going.
( My wife said she totally understood and has similar feelings with fabric. I feel there's a weakness here I can utilise..... 8))
Could this be the first signs of attempting to justifuy early-onset MAD? ::)
....or just too much sun :-\
yours,
a worried woodworm,
Devon.
-
A great way to deal with your love of wood, without buying more melodeons, would be to outfit yourself to plane wood by hand.
You'll need only a simple workbench with 1/4" dogholes drilled into it; a pair of holdfasts (I recommend those sold by Tools for Working Wood/Gramercy Tools -- I'm sure they are sold by some dealer in the UK as well); a second-hand handplane -- pretty much any benchplane to get started but a Record #5 is a good starting point; a few waterstones for sharpening the iron. And of course, some wood, preferably something relatively easy to start out. Pine and poplar are relatively inexpensive; walnut or cherry once you get going.
It is incredibly satisfying to start with a rough-sawn board and plane the first face smooth and flat, to see the beauty of a particular piece of wood emerge, and eventually to break through the frustration and figure out what it takes to turn the rough board into a dimensioned board -- the edges parallel to each other and square to the sides.
This is just a start. Eventually, of course, you'll need more toys... er... tools, and this could become more expensive than MAD...
-
Having stripped back to bare wood two houses - doors, floors and in this house bare old oak beams, I have had time and chance to practise some basic skills, also using old flloring to make ledge and brace doors. Being an old pub built for miners it has a wealth of unusual timber and normal pine too ( 160 year old pine is diffferent to the stuff you get nowadays! )
There's something wonderful about stripping off layers of old paint and getting to the wood below.
I did wonder about trying some turning, but..... too many things to do, too little time...... my concertina playing ground to a halt after having to completely renovate this house. It's done now, time to enjoy myself again in another direction.
Perhaps admiring wood whilst making it vibrate with reeds is another alternative wood loving pastime!
Q
Q
-
I love the grain and colours of teak, too. We used to sand the rubbing strakes of my mate's boat back, then carefully "nib" it with a scouring pad before oiling (Deks Olje) - looked stunning for about a month! Then we tried chemical restoration approach and the results are nearly as good, albeit not as smooth a surface, but had we carried on there'd be little left - but the colour does come back and it oils up well.
The only down side to oiling is if you spill something oily on the finish as it can penetrate. The same mate put the exhaust elbow on the cabin table and the stain is still there years later.
In the spare bedroom I have a set of exceedingly ugly nesting tables made of planks of burmese teak. My Dad brought them home after WWII and they're still varnished and quite a bright yellow. Perhaps one day I'll build a melodeon case from them, unless they get built into my boat in the meantime.
Rob.
-
A great way to deal with your love of wood, without buying more melodeons, would be to outfit yourself to plane wood by hand.
.....
This is just a start. Eventually, of course, you'll need more toys... er... tools, and this could become more expensive than MAD...
You can always make your own planes (http://www.finewoodworking.com/PlansAndProjects/PlansAndProjectsArticle.aspx?id=30181)
-
What Andy said. Anthony Guidice has a good book on basic woodworking and hand tool tuning skills which build good habits. Plus you can impress your friends by flattening and dimensioning a board by hand.
-
Planing can be addictive. I once wasted a nice mahogany guitar back by becoming mesmerised and continuing to plane it, forgetting that I needed to stop and check the thickness.....
No time for that anymore, alas. :(
-
You can always make your own planes (http://www.finewoodworking.com/PlansAndProjects/PlansAndProjectsArticle.aspx?id=30181)
Oh, I have:
(http://i151.photobucket.com/albums/s142/ADHoman/Hornbeam1.jpg)
And I used it to make this:
(http://i151.photobucket.com/albums/s142/ADHoman/table1.jpg)
But I'm pretty sure it made the desire to acquire tools even worse!
-
Thanks Theo, looks like an interesting site.....
and it looks like Andy in V has already been there!
Very nice, both plane and table.
Andy S - yes planing can be addictive, though I've never got that bad!
Q
-
mmmmmmmmmmmmm - i dream of wood :-*
-
I recall that in the '80s Making Music magazine used to run a 'Wood of the month' column. written AFIKR by Adrian Legg. I just Googled this. I was disappointed not to find the affirmation I had hoped for, but I was heartened to find these, rather pleasing, results:
- http://fondellwoodwork.com/wood.php
- http://www.woodnshop.com/wood_of_the_month_club.htm
- http://www.woodworkingnetwork.com/wood/hardwood-softwood-species
-
Wood porn. I buy quite a bit from these guys.
http://www.cookwoods.com/lumber-site/
-
I turned a salad bowl - now THAT's satisfying!
-
Ahhhh.... I see I'm amongst friends here (:)
There are some lovely woods in those clips, I could sit and stroke all day..........but then you have to decide what to make!
decisions decisions.... but like buying melodeons perhaps ;)
Q
-
A good site for cherry harvested in Pennsylvania (http://www.curlymaplewood.com/). He had a telephone number on his website two years ago, now just an email, he was very helpful. Nice pictures, too, if you appreciate a beautiful, erm, figure. :D
-
This is all reminding me of Erika Eiffel.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erika_Eiffel
-
I have a date with twenty cube of lime which is currently in the stick. Same yard has some english walnut, english cherry, sweet chestnut and lots of elm and oak.
Biggest problem now is that demand for fire wood is pushing up the price of wood and there's a lot of really nice wood which is going up in flames.
Steve
-
This is all reminding me of Erika Eiffel.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erika_Eiffel
Interesting... I feel so naive. I have never heard of this...
-
A great way to deal with your love of wood, without buying more melodeons, would be to outfit yourself to plane wood by hand.
You'll need only a simple workbench with 1/4" dogholes drilled into it; a pair of holdfasts (I recommend those sold by Tools for Working Wood/Gramercy Tools -- I'm sure they are sold by some dealer in the UK as well); a second-hand handplane -- pretty much any benchplane to get started but a Record #5 is a good starting point; a few waterstones for sharpening the iron. And of course, some wood, preferably something relatively easy to start out. Pine and poplar are relatively inexpensive; walnut or cherry once you get going.
It is incredibly satisfying to start with a rough-sawn board and plane the first face smooth and flat, to see the beauty of a particular piece of wood emerge, and eventually to break through the frustration and figure out what it takes to turn the rough board into a dimensioned board -- the edges parallel to each other and square to the sides.
This is just a start. Eventually, of course, you'll need more toys... er... tools, and this could become more expensive than MAD...
Disgraceful behaviour, introducing a fledgling grain botherer to full blown wood porn at a single stroke! This may induce treen aversion! :o
-
Tallships: :o
A grain botherer........ wood porn......... :|bl
what have I let myself in for.......
Q
-
.. a few waterstones for sharpening the iron.
Many years ago I went on a four day woodworking course, all we did in four days was sharpen planes, chisels, drill bits, saw blades, anything that cut wood. It was probably the best and most valuable course I've ever been on.
Steve
-
Any wood lovers/butchers in the Oundle Northants area this coming weekend??
fill yer boots ;D MacTimbers (http://www.mactimbers.mfbiz.com/)
(wear your melnet ID or talk to the bloke doing miniatures if he's there)
-
ooh - I have one of Steve Frost's flutes - try his ones with the drones - awesome!
-
Haven't seen Steve there for a while...
anyone thinking of going should check who the demonstrators are this weekend to avoid disappointment.
-
.. a few waterstones for sharpening the iron.
Many years ago I went on a four day woodworking course, all we did in four days was sharpen planes, chisels, drill bits, saw blades, anything that cut wood. It was probably the best and most valuable course I've ever been on.
Steve
Apprentice woodworkers in Japan spend a year sharpening before being allowed to use a tool.
-
I can hear the cry now ..... Cor! Just look at the grain on this one!!
There must be some wood related top shelf magazines -Wood planers monthly? Grain illustrated? Woodworkers wives? >:E
-
Apprentice woodworkers in Japan spend a year sharpening before being allowed to use a tool.
If they are not allowed a tool, how do they sharpen? Really good karate? :D
-
Apprentice woodworkers in Japan spend a year sharpening before being allowed to use a tool.
Where did you hear that?, that smacks of being one of those romantic myths about the mysterious east with little grounding in reality that reverential westerners lap up. I doubt that's actually true but if it is then it's utterly pointless and they're wasting 11 months of that year rehashing the first one when they could be learning new things instead...
I had to attend an introduction to Japanese business etiquette and customs and in the, (off the record), words of the man briefing me, "at least half the stuff you'll have heard about Japan is total bull**** and if you go there believing everything then you'll look like a complete tool".
-
Apprentice woodworkers in Japan spend a year sharpening before being allowed to use a tool.
and if you go there believing everything then you'll look like a complete tool".
At least you'd be a very sharp at the end of it. >:E
-
The whole "tool" thing had genuinely not occurred to me when I posted that... :-\
-
Apprentice woodworkers in Japan spend a year sharpening before being allowed to use a tool.
Where did you hear that?, that smacks of being one of those romantic myths about the mysterious east with little grounding in reality that reverential westerners lap up. I doubt that's actually true but if it is then it's utterly pointless and they're wasting 11 months of that year rehashing the first one when they could be learning new things instead...
It was in the book 'Japanese Woodworking Tools' by Toshio Odate. It may have been only one 'old school' craftsman's approach. I'm sure most people in modern Japan (and the US) would share your assessment of its value.
-
It was in the book 'Japanese Woodworking Tools' by Toshio Odate.
You beat me to it -- I was going to cite Odate, too. The thing that's important to understand is that this is not just so that the tools are really sharp: so much of what you need your hands to "understand" about working wood with handtools will be learned as you learn to properly sharpen. The point isn't that the first-year apprentice isn't working wood, it is that if he cannot make an edge sharp and straight, he actually isn't ready to make furniture with hand tools. But it also is no menial task: a Japanese furniture builders planes and blades are easily worth more money than many people's living room furniture!!!
-
I'd go along with that I earn my living with woodworking tools - sharp tools and being able to sharpen them quickly without honing guides is essential.
-
..being able to sharpen them quickly without honing guides is essential.
Great skill to know, but essential? A Veritas honing guide is my best friend on chisels and plane blades.
When I was just building stuff for the house I used mostly hand tools, for the love of them for one, and because I hate loud tools. The feel and sound of a sharp hand plane on a piece of wood still makes me smile, but I've embraced power tools more and more building accordions. But the one hand tool I will always save room for are scrapers. Does not have the sex appeal of beautiful hand planes, but I haven't found a power tool yet that can completely replace them in my shop.
-
I completely agree with the beauty of a well sharpened scraper. It takes a bit of practice to sharpen a scraper and it's the one instance where I still use an oilstone. I also use the Veritas honing guide with my water stones.
-
And as for spending a year learning to sharpen tools, I fail to see how can learn much on that subject without trying your sharpening efforts on some wood.
-
That's exactly why I think it's a myth, not only is it ludicrously excessive but it makes absolutely no sense from a logical and practical viewpoint either.
Stories and anecdotes that are actually complete cobblers but appeal to some notion of how people want a particular event/culture/profession to be disseminate and eventually end up getting cited in reputable sources all the time.
-
I always wondered if the "master" wasn't just taking advantage of having a rookie to take care of his tedious jobs.
I heard of gunsmith apprentice who had to file a square piece of metal from big to small, and had to keep doing it until he could do it without losing squareness before moving to the next skill. Not only is a very basic skill relevant to the job (maybe for tuning reeds also?), but there is an established benchmark. Surely there would be the same type benchmark for Japanese woodworkers, instead of a time frame.
-
I always wondered if the "master" wasn't just taking advantage of having a rookie to take care of his tedious jobs.
I think you're right...in fact, I think that was the whole point of apprentices for a lot of masters. ;D
My least favourite kind of people when I used to read woodwork and luthiery forums were the "Stradivari didn't have a bandsaw" types. He might not have had a bandsaw but he did have an endless supply of apprentices doing all his donkey work for him!.
-
I always wondered if the "master" wasn't just taking advantage of having a rookie to take care of his tedious jobs.
I think that it is important to distinguish true apprenticeships within a traditional crafts context from some of the assistant work that is called "apprenticeship" these days.
In the traditional context, sure, there is certainly an element of exploitation. It's really a double edge sword where the master does get something in return, but eventually the apprentice can learn enough to become a competitor; the guilds handled this in different ways, but one common rule was that graduated apprentices (journeymen) were required to stay a certain distance away for a period of years. (At least that was the practice in much of Central Europe.) Another thing to think about is that in order to make the relationship really economically worthwhile for the master, there is an incentive to get the apprentice up to speed in non-menial work.
-
That's exactly why I think it's a myth, not only is it ludicrously excessive but it makes absolutely no sense from a logical and practical viewpoint either.
I do not think it is a myth. I think your assessment is a product of the modern culture which is obsessed with multi-tasking and has lost the appreciation for an intense focus on mastering a particular skill. A relatively superficial mastery of many things is viewed more favorably than a deep mastery of few things. Part of the reason is the complexity of the modern world. You have to master quite a few things just to get along in modern society.
-
Tallships: :o
A grain botherer........ wood porn......... :|bl
what have I let myself in for.......
Q
It's very easy to get side tracked you know, I find woodwork deeply satisfying for its own sake and I'm just as happy planing a door to size and chopping out mortices for locks as I am working on anything musical. Developing skills becomes a pastime in itself, beware!
-
[[Moderator notice]]
This thread has been edited to remove a sequence of intemperate comments.
Please be completely polite and respectful of the other persons views.
Now lets get back to wood.
-
Please be completely polite and respectful of the other persons views.
Now lets get back to wood.
For more about Japanese apprenticeships (here mentioning TWO years of sharpening), check out p. 158 of this book (which I also wholeheartedly recommend):
http://books.google.com/books?id=BNGE4D70TyYC&printsec=frontcover&dq=the+workbench+book&source=bl&ots=HWhBzCJSi7&sig=bwdLgCbs4lkuoLcVd38swGQaZr0&hl=en&sa=X&ei=zikUUK2IFYLH6AGPpYHQDw&ved=0CDMQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false (http://books.google.com/books?id=BNGE4D70TyYC&printsec=frontcover&dq=the+workbench+book&source=bl&ots=HWhBzCJSi7&sig=bwdLgCbs4lkuoLcVd38swGQaZr0&hl=en&sa=X&ei=zikUUK2IFYLH6AGPpYHQDw&ved=0CDMQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false)
For more on Toshio Odate, who wasn't making up stories but actually experienced what he wrote about:
http://toshioodate.com/Toshio_Odate_Woodworking/The_official_Toshio_Odate_Page.html (http://toshioodate.com/Toshio_Odate_Woodworking/The_official_Toshio_Odate_Page.html)
Odate's book on tools is an excellent source for understanding the interlocking use of various tools (including the workbench) in a handtool-oriented workshop.
And my personal favorite -- check out the amazing joinery:
http://www.eurus.dti.ne.jp/~k-yazawa/english.html (http://www.eurus.dti.ne.jp/~k-yazawa/english.html)
-
Did someone mention tool p0rn?
http://www.axminster.co.uk/lie-nielsen-lie-nielsen-no-60-1-2-low-angle-block-plane-prod765659/ (http://www.axminster.co.uk/lie-nielsen-lie-nielsen-no-60-1-2-low-angle-block-plane-prod765659/)
-
more of the same... craftsmanship at its best
http://www.billcarterwoodworkingplanemaker.co.uk/
-
I got a copy of the new Dick, ( http://www.mehr-als-werkzeug.de/ ), catalogue in the post the other week. Probably the Playboy Annual of tool porn...
FYI, you must be over the legal age in your jurisdiction to view that website. :Ph
For more about Japanese apprenticeships (here mentioning TWO years of sharpening), check out p. 158 of this book (which I also wholeheartedly recommend):
http://books.google.com/books?id=BNGE4D70TyYC&printsec=frontcover&dq=the+workbench+book&source=bl&ots=HWhBzCJSi7&sig=bwdLgCbs4lkuoLcVd38swGQaZr0&hl=en&sa=X&ei=zikUUK2IFYLH6AGPpYHQDw&ved=0CDMQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false (http://books.google.com/books?id=BNGE4D70TyYC&printsec=frontcover&dq=the+workbench+book&source=bl&ots=HWhBzCJSi7&sig=bwdLgCbs4lkuoLcVd38swGQaZr0&hl=en&sa=X&ei=zikUUK2IFYLH6AGPpYHQDw&ved=0CDMQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false)
For more on Toshio Odate, who wasn't making up stories but actually experienced what he wrote about:
http://toshioodate.com/Toshio_Odate_Woodworking/The_official_Toshio_Odate_Page.html (http://toshioodate.com/Toshio_Odate_Woodworking/The_official_Toshio_Odate_Page.html)
Odate's book on tools is an excellent source for understanding the interlocking use of various tools (including the workbench) in a handtool-oriented workshop.
I am genuinely gobsmacked that they actually do spend all that time learning just to sharpen, I would never have believed that in a million years. :o
I still think it makes no sense from a practical point of view and it's a grossly inefficient use of time but then again, they've always had a longer average life expectancy in Japan... ;D
-
And my personal favorite -- check out the amazing joinery:
http://www.eurus.dti.ne.jp/~k-yazawa/english.html (http://www.eurus.dti.ne.jp/~k-yazawa/english.html)
Almost wish that I had not looked at that - scissor joints- and that red box - enough to give me an inferiority complex :(
Amazing thing (without getting back to the apprenticeship debate) is that he made such a career change and, unless I misunderstood, learnt Japanese techniques himself.
-
Amazing thing (without getting back to the apprenticeship debate) is that he made such a career change and, unless I misunderstood, learnt Japanese techniques himself.
Re: Yazawa -- he actually had some UK connection, perhaps with the Barnsleys? not sure if the info is on his website or if I read it in an article about him...
-
"Great skill to know, but essential? A Veritas honing guide is my best friend on chisels and plane blades. "
Yes I think so - it's part of learning the trade. If you're a self taught woodworker on your own then maybe not except that a honing guide is going to slow you down. But if you are working in a shop with other tradesman you're not going to be respected if you can't sharpen without one.
-
I have been making furniture as a profession for 22 years.
I use a Tormek machine to sharpen tools. I am serious about sharp tools.
In another life I brokered rare and exotic hardwoods to instrument makers, specializing in pernambuco and western big leaf maple as well a Mountain Mahogany and yew.
I still have a sizeable stash of wood; perhaps enough to build 1000 accordeons, that is not an exaggeration.
Some of the wood came off my property, cut, milled, dried, machined...stored.
I have been building instruments since 1964.
-
Now children, withoput using a calculator or those notes you wrote on your ruler, work out exactly how old this gentleman is. You may use a piece of paper, but show your workings. >:E
-
A good site for cherry harvested in Pennsylvania (http://www.curlymaplewood.com/). .... :D
Oh yeah, awesome, beautiful stuff. The UPS shipping cost must be a killer though.
-
A good site for cherry harvested in Pennsylvania (http://www.curlymaplewood.com/). .... :D
Oh yeah, awesome, beautiful stuff. The UPS shipping cost must be a killer though.
He uses the UPS freight rate, which is better (affordable) compared to parcel rates for packages of similar weight and dimensions. Just don't count on the delivery guy leaving the wood anywhere near your front door.
-
A good site for cherry harvested in Pennsylvania (http://www.curlymaplewood.com/). .... :D
Oh yeah, awesome, beautiful stuff. The UPS shipping cost must be a killer though.
It's a killer for the UK, makes it basically unaffordable.
Steve
-
A good site for cherry harvested in Pennsylvania (http://www.curlymaplewood.com/). .... :D
Oh yeah, awesome, beautiful stuff. The UPS shipping cost must be a killer though.
It's a killer for the UK, makes it basically unaffordable.
Steve
Obviously if you are shipping wood across the Atlantic you would need to make other shipping arrangements.
-
A good site for cherry harvested in Pennsylvania (http://www.curlymaplewood.com/). .... :D
Oh yeah, awesome, beautiful stuff. The UPS shipping cost must be a killer though.
It's a killer for the UK, makes it basically unaffordable.
Steve
Obviously if you are shipping wood across the Atlantic you would need to make other shipping arrangements.
I looked into it a couple of years back. Basically you either have to ship very small ammounts for a specific high value job (fiddle backs etc) and take the hit, or quite large amounts to make it worth container charges etc. Unfortunately my needs tend to fall in between the two.
On the plus side I picked up some gorgeous one inch yew last week which is going to make some stunning puzzles.
Steve