Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: rees on July 25, 2012, 11:17:43 PM
-
This year I have had the honour of being appointed dep musician for the inimitable Lisa McDermott, as melodeon player for the incomparable All Blacked Up english ceilidh folk rock, etc. band, etc.
I am a happy bunny. Some belting gigs so far and the whole summer to go.
Anyway, back to dem microphones.
De boss of de band (him Alistair) he give me AKG C1000s, cos that's what Lisa used.
Sounded great for me too until we plugged in the Shure SM58.
Nice.
Ok granted, Lisa plays close in to the mic while I tend to leave some space so perhaps that's the whole answer.
I suspect there's more.
-
Instrumentation would be as follows:
Lisa:
Castagnari TOMMY D/G. light swing tuning.
Castagnari MAX D. light swing tuning.
Hohner POKERWORK C/F. Tremolo tuning.
Rees:
Hohner POKERWORK D/G tremolo.
Paolo Soprani JUBILEE III. D/G. swing mosso.
Hohner CLUB Modell 1. C/F. tremolo americano.
Hohner POKERWORK G/C tremolo.
Wesson WINDJAMMER C. tremolo.
Wessson CLIPPER D. swing.
So, a fair cross section I reckon.
-
Rees,
my own choice has aways been c1000, with SM58 as a close second. I have used SM57, but I've nver felt that the have the b*llx I want, or expect.
I prefer playing into a mic, rather than using internals, gooseneck, or Cajun style on body SM58 adaptations. I like to play with the dynamics, moving around over the mic. Only problem I have is that as the night goes on I find myself drifting ever further from the sweet spot. :|glug
-
SM57 is not a bad all-round instrument mic, as well as being reasonably cheap and very robust.
SM58 is a bizarre choice for instruments, as it has an intentionally distorted frequency response and built in pop shield to make it perform well on close-mic vocals. I always assume if a soundman puts up 58s for instruments it's because that's all he has and/or doesn't know any better.
The two mics use the same capsule, by the way. The difference is entirely due to the foam-stuffed wire mesh ball on the end of the 58, which acoustically creates a massive "presence peak" and then almost nothing above about 10kHz. I suppose the presence boost would be useful if you need to give a mellow-sounding box a bit more bite.
Condenser mics like the C1000 are OK if you don't put them too close.
If you want cheap condensers though, the Behringer C2 is a steal and well up to the job for live sound. It also has a useful switchable hi-pass (rumble) filter. At £50 a pair you can't go wrong. It does need phantom power though.
-
Instrumentation would be as follows:
Lisa:
Castagnari TOMMY D/G. light swing tuning.
Castagnari MAX D. light swing tuning.
Hohner POKERWORK C/F. Tremolo tunin
So, a fair cross section I reckon.
[/quote
Lisa's Max is in C...that's probably where you're going wrong...
The other melodeon player...
-
Instrumentation would be as follows:
Lisa:
Castagnari TOMMY D/G. light swing tuning.
Castagnari MAX D. light swing tuning.
Hohner POKERWORK C/F. Tremolo tunin
So, a fair cross section I reckon.
[/quote
Lisa's Max is in C...that's probably where you're going wrong...
The other melodeon player...
Yes and I ought to know, I put the reeds in it! ::)
-
I find a pair of Shure PG81 condensers very effective for a range of boxes from the very wet corona II though the dry sander and the concertina.
-
I had some time on my hands so I arranged a group of 8 microphones and played some tunes on my Saltarelle Pastourelle III into them and recorded the individual outputs. You can hear the result at http://soundcloud.com/howard-mitchell/sets/mics-and-melodeon (http://soundcloud.com/howard-mitchell/sets/mics-and-melodeon)
I chose tunes which use a wide range of notes and also varied the reeds using M, MM, ML and MML.
Attached to this post are pictures of the microphones, the microphones and the melodeon and the desk to which they were connected and the screen behind showing 8 parallel tracks. For the technically inclined the mics were connected directly to the Audient desk, no inserts, no EQ and the recording outputs went to a Digidesign 192 A/D and then into a Mac, recorded using Pro-Tools 9 at 88.2, 24bit, saved as wavs at 44.1, 16 bit for uploading to soundcloud.
The mics are (in order of the recordings) -
1 Behringer ECM 8000 Measurement Condenser
2 "no-name" small diaphragm condenser (http://www.bluearan.co.uk/index.php?id=SKT173844 (http://www.bluearan.co.uk/index.php?id=SKT173844))
3 Behringer C2 - condenser
4 Neumann KM184 - condenser
5 Shure SM57 - dynamic
6 Shure SM58 - dynamic
7 AKG C1000s - condenser
8 Senheisser MD421 - dynamic
I know this isn't a rigorous test but it does give some indication of the characteristis of the mics.
Although often used as drum overheads, I often use the no-name mics or C2s as instrument mics, they're small, cheap, rugged and unobtrusive.
Howard
-
Can't access page - private and requires login?
Thanks for setting up a mic shoot-out anyway, looking forward to hearing the results.
I did one on my cello recently.
Behringer C-2, AKG Blueline cardioid, KM184, Schoeps MK41.
Possibly also Röde NT2A, SM57, Beyer M201, ATM25 and Sennheiser MD421, I can't remember.
It was for studio recording purposes, not live sound.
Mostly they just sounded different, difficult to rank as good/bad.
The C-2 came out sounding very thin, but I only noticed later that I had the rumble filter switch engaged, so the experiment should really be repeated. I did discover, however, that the C-2 is inverted w.r.t. all the others - if you place one side by side with any other mic I tested and mix the signals, most of the sound vanishes; inverting one channel restores the sound to what you'd expect from two mics in-phase.
-
Can't access page - private and requires login?
Oops, somehow the link had a line break in the middle of it. Correct now.
I did similar recently for my double bass for recording and ended up with an Electrovoice RE20 as the choice.
-
I did similar recently for my double bass for recording and ended up with an Electrovoice RE20 as the choice.
I'd forgotten I had one of those. That was in my test too, and I have used it previously on the cello.
-
7 Shure C1000s - condenser
Are you sure the Shure C1000s isn't an AKG C1000s?
-
7 Shure C1000s - condenser
Are you sure the Shure C1000s isn't an AKG C1000s?
I was wondering who would be first to spot that! I've changed the original post.
-
That's fine for recording in a studio, but doesn't cover pattern control which is at least -- if not more -- important for on-stage use.
Response errors (if not too bad) can always be equalised out. A mic with too wide a pattern (or an omni) picks up all sorts of rubbish from monitors and/or the room and this can't be fixed at the desk or afterwards.
Usually on-stage it's impossible to position mic and monitors so the monitor is directly behind the mic, which is where the null is for a cardioid. However it is often possible to get the monitor to the rear of the mic but off-axis, so a hypercardioid is much better for rejecting feedback from monitors, as well as picking up less unwanted sound from the stage and the room.
I do this and have never had any problems with feedback, even with melodeon loud enough to hear over Mr. Gifford's drum kit a few feet to my left.
Speaking with my sound man hat on, even if you don't actually get feedback the sound is coloured by mic pickup, it's much easier to get a clean sound with a hypercardioid.
-
...
Speaking with my sound man hat on, even if you don't actually get feedback the sound is coloured by mic pickup, it's much easier to get a clean sound with a hypercardioid.
Agreed. I did actually consider a Beta 58 and a Beta 57 to start with but decided to stick to response rather than pattern this time round. It occured to me that what I'm hearing on all these microphones could easily be smoothed out by a noise boy with the right equipment and the right ears.
-
That's a very useful test, Howard! - interesting how different they sound, isn't it, (echoing your comment about the importance of the sound man's input?) Except, surprisingly, I couldn't tell apart the SM57 and SM58 - could that have something to do with positioning, do you think?
However I support IanD's comments, and am somehow reminded of the old adage; 'Never mind the quality, feel the width!'
-
Except, surprisingly, I couldn't tell apart the SM57 and SM58 - could that have something to do with positioning, do you think?
I jotted down notes before checking which was which, and I had "brighter" for the 57 and "brighter still" for the 58.
The C1000S and MD421 both seemed very thin and distant. The MD421 is designed for close miking and loud instruments - brass, bass drum etc. so may be needed to be positioned closer.
I was surprised to hear how dull the KM184 sounded next to the others, but that's probably a fairly flat responses compared with a high-mid peak on the others.
The ECM8000 is sold as a measurement mic. It's omnidirectional so fairly useless for live sound, and limited in the studio as it's quite noisy, but omnis tend to have quite good flat response and no proximity effect so can be placed close to sound source.
-
How odd!
I started this thread after being surprised that, in my particular band situation, the 58 sounded better than the AKG C1000s.
After listening to Howards' test, the 58 still came out on top.
Perhaps I've just got weird ears. (quiet now, Lester!)
-
Re directional response:
Ian's right of course, a hypercardioid will generally give you higher and more reliable gain-before-feedback, which is useful if you're playing in a band with drums or other loud instruments, requiring high monitor levels which make feedback a possible problem.
If you're looking for a dynamic mic with good hypercardioid response, the Beyer M201 does everything the SM57 does but better - smoother response, hypercardiod pattern and being a dynamic like the 57 you won't overload it (it's often used on snare drums!), it doesn't need phantom power and it's robust. Costs a bit more than a 57, but I got a S/H one for £80 over ten years ago and it's still going strong, though I don't use it often.
-
which is useful if you're playing in a band with drums or other loud instruments, requiring high monitor levels which make feedback a possible problem.
Absolutely, and I would add to your list, 'or in halls with awful acoustics and noisy audiences', where the monitors just have to cut through the mush if anyone in the band is going to hear what's going on.
Off-topic, possibly, but sparing a thought for the poor caller in such unforgiving surroundings, would anyone like to recommend a close radio mike system for callers that sounds reasonable, doesn't suffer from feedback or interference problems, and allows them to keep both their hands and feet free?
-
Re directional response:
Ian's right of course, a hypercardioid will generally give you higher and more reliable gain-before-feedback, which is useful if you're playing in a band with drums or other loud instruments, requiring high monitor levels which make feedback a possible problem.
If you're looking for a dynamic mic with good hypercardioid response, the Beyer M201 does everything the SM57 does but better - smoother response, hypercardiod pattern and being a dynamic like the 57 you won't overload it (it's often used on snare drums!), it doesn't need phantom power and it's robust. Costs a bit more than a 57, but I got a S/H one for £80 over ten years ago and it's still going strong, though I don't use it often.
I use AKG D3900 for exactly the same reason -- great on melodeon and sax, and also on voice where the switchable bass rolloff avoids the need to use a lot of bass cut on the desk. Unfortunately also not available any more, though I guess plenty of similar mics are...
Worrying about small differences between the frequency balance of mics pales into insignificance compared to the EQ often needed to compensate for placing a mic close to an instrument that's designed to be listened to from much further away :-)
-
Re directional response:
Ian's right of course, a hypercardioid will generally give you higher and more reliable gain-before-feedback, which is useful if you're playing in a band with drums or other loud instruments, requiring high monitor levels which make feedback a possible problem.
If you're looking for a dynamic mic with good hypercardioid response, the Beyer M201 does everything the SM57 does but better - smoother response, hypercardiod pattern and being a dynamic like the 57 you won't overload it (it's often used on snare drums!), it doesn't need phantom power and it's robust. Costs a bit more than a 57, but I got a S/H one for £80 over ten years ago and it's still going strong, though I don't use it often.
I use AKG D3900 for exactly the same reason -- great on melodeon and sax, and also on voice where the switchable bass rolloff avoids the need to use a lot of bass cut on the desk. Unfortunately also not available any more, though I guess plenty of similar mics are...
Worrying about small differences between the frequency balance of mics pales into insignificance compared to the EQ often needed to compensate for placing a mic close to an instrument that's designed to be listened to from much further away and/or from a different direction :-)
-
(AKG D3900) Unfortunately also not available any more
For the avoidance of confusion, the Beyerdynamic M201 which I recommended is available new.
I only bought mine second hand because it was half the price of a new one!