Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: george garside on September 11, 2019, 12:10:42 AM
-
The Dg box is a great rhythm box and here are my thoughts on adding layers of rhythm to which hopefully others will add to, agree with, disagree with or whatever!
To me there are in essence 4 ways of creating rhythm which can be used singly or in any combination depending on the tune being played and the desired effect.
1. Playing the melody line rhythmically. The basic rhythm should be inherent in the way the melody is played in just the same way as happens on melody only instruments such as fiddles, whistles etc. Every tune has or should have an inherent rhythm including slow airs and it is that basic rhythm that is essential in transforming playing the right notes ion the right order into music!
2. Using spare fingers to beat a rhythm additional to the inherent rhythm of the treble, The extra rhythm can be extra single notes or right hand chords or a combination of the two. This is quite easy to do as on the push any combination of notes will harmonise and on the pull there is only one combination that won't
3. Intermitant GENTLE pulsing of the bellows to add a fairly unobtrusive extra layer of rhythm here and there in a tune particularly bits where the bellows are going in one direction for a few bars of music. This is not to be confused with bellows shaking that some piano box players indulge in.
4. The bass , preferably played lightly and crisply and not necessarily consisting of um pa ing throughout the proceedings. Sometimes less is more and leaving the bass off for a bar or two here and there can add to rather than detract from the overall effect. With some tunes at opposite ends of the speed spectrum leaving the bass rhythm ( but maybe or maybe not keeping sustained chords) can help eg in haunting slow aires or very fast jigs and reels.
please feel free to disagree or otherwise criticise this list or preferably to chuck in some more 'layers' of bass???
george
-
I think you are spot on. Rhythm has been a strong focus of mine for most of this year as I needed improvement. I think points 1-3 best illustrate what I have spent most of my time working on. #4 has been become a focus more recently, and can be a very powerful tool as you said for both fast and slow tunes.
-
Similar to (2), you can also try holding a sustained bass note and tapping a rhythm on a chord button - or vice versa.
-
Thanks very much for this breakdown!
-
One extra thing I've seen used is what I call the "palm slap", where you accentuate the rhythm by pulsing the right hand against the treble keyboard. This technique is probably best seen in DTN's playing - watch his right hand:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6FjuOzZFjw
I suppose an extension of George's point 3 but amplified.
-
I think your #3 (bellows pulse) gets at something that is almost unique to squeezeboxes: the ability to easily swell the volume, especially of chords. I can't easily think of another acoustic instrument that allows a single player to swell up a chord the way an accordion or concertina can. It allows us to really emphasize the downbeat by starting the sound early and swelling up to the actual beat, so we get a rrrrrrrUP sort of sound. I love this technique for morris dance tunes where it really gives a feeling of falling into the downbeat (and then hopping or leaping up on the upbeat).
(If someone else can think of another instrument that can do this, let me know! Bowed string instruments can swell the volume, but not easily with chords on a single instrument. Same with woodwinds and brass; you really need an ensemble of players to swell up a whole chord.)
-
Worked REALLY hard on this when I moved back from tunes to singing 8-10 years back
I was after "the English guitar style" but hitting a melodeon doesn't butter the right parsnips
The key to success was … silence! The more you play well silences, ideally abruptly started or ended in your music, the more rhyhmic it sounds.
And don't forget that the end of a note is as much a rhythm event as its start 🤔 beyond that … experiment and listen to others 😀