I'm nearly finished doing a full repair/restoration of an old red pre-Pokerwork instrument. I'm enjoying the process, but it is not a simple task. Things like bellows repair are straightforward and simple, replacing reed valves is simple, but tweaking reeds to get them to sound properly is iffy and time consuming, not to mention tuning. I gravitated to the melodeon after a fascination with concertinas. The melodeon is much more "my" instrument, and I'm glad I found it. While in the concertina universe I built a couple of digital instruments for the fun of it (YouTube video linked below). By the time I finished it up I concluded that, although it was a fun project, I wanted to work on good old acoustic instruments. I'm rethinking that now, and here's why:
There are some beautiful old boxes out there, as anyone who shops the usual sources -- particularly Ebay -- can attest. These are often lovely bits of work and -- I once thought -- might be good candidates for refurbishing and selling at a reasonable cost to folks new to the instrument who wanted something to play. I'm retired with time on my hands, so making a fortune at this is not a requirement. However, now that I've dealt with two Ebay boxes, I can see that this may well be a fool's errand. There is no way of pre--determining how much work a box will require, and even something in moderately good condition is likely to consume a fair amount of bench time. Doing one for myself (my current project) is one thing, but making a habit of it is something else entirely.
Then there is the problem of "what key is it?". It seems that 90% of online listings have no indication of the key(s) the melodion was built to, and the sellers are not likely to figure it out even if asked to. Depending on the focus of one's musical interested, a nice box, even if working well, may be unsuitable.
Having gone through the extensive work of building a digital concertina I've solved most of the problems associated with that, and that knowledge/practice directly translates to the melodion. So I'm rethinking things. Theres a lot more room in a melodeon box, so the idea of having not only a MIDI based synthesizer inside but also a couple of quality speakers and amps is entirely doable. That, along with a rechargeable internal battery, creates an instrument that is entirely freestanding, plays like a melodeon, sounds like a melodeon and -- best of all -- looks like a lovely vintage box because it is one. Add to that the ability to select any combination of keys you like, how wet or dry you want the sound to be, specifically assign any button or combination of buttons, turn off the speakers and plug in a headset to practice/play silently, etc. You get a very flexible system that can be changed on the fly. The system I've designed uses an air pressure sensor to detect bellows pressure, so the feedback you get from the bellows can be tuned to match what you're already used to. The buttons use Hall-effect sensors and are nearly entirely trouble and maintenance free, not to mention nearly silent.
So, what do you think? Would you play such an instrument? Here's the YouTube video. This shows a fully built concertina from parts I 3D printed. For a melodeon I am proposing retrofitting a nice looking vintage box:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wICkse5D8Gc&t=1196s